A place were I can write...
My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.
December 30, 2019
Cassini Spacecraft Crosses Saturn's Ring Plane
If this is Saturn, where are the rings? When Saturn's "appendages" disappeared in 1612, Galileo did not understand why. Later that century, it became understood that Saturn's unusual protrusions were rings and that when the Earth crosses the ring plane, the edge-on rings will appear to disappear. This is because Saturn's rings are confined to a plane many times thinner, in proportion, than a razor blade. In modern times, the robot Cassini spacecraft orbiting Saturn frequently crossed Saturn's ring plane during its mission to Saturn, from 2004 to 2017. A series of plane crossing images from 2005 February was dug out of the vast online Cassini raw image archive by interested Spanish amateur Fernando Garcia Navarro. Pictured here, digitally cropped and set in representative colors, is the striking result. Saturn's thin ring plane appears in blue, bands and clouds in Saturn's upper atmosphere appear in gold. Details of Saturn's rings can be seen in the high dark shadows across the top of this image, taken back in 2005. The moons Dione and Enceladus appear as bumps in the rings.
Messier 20
The beautiful Trifid Nebula, also known as Messier 20, is easy to find with a small telescope in the nebula rich constellation Sagittarius. About 5,000 light-years away, the colorful study in cosmic contrasts shares this well-composed, nearly 1 degree wide field with open star cluster Messier 21 (top left). Trisected by dust lanes the Trifid itself is about 40 light-years across and a mere 300,000 years old. That makes it one of the youngest star forming regions in our sky, with newborn and embryonic stars embedded in its natal dust and gas clouds. Estimates of the distance to open star cluster M21 are similar to M20's, but though they share this gorgeous telescopic skyscape there is no apparent connection between the two. In fact, M21's stars are much older, about 8 million years old.
Make History Again
Astronaut Christina Koch Poised to Make History Again
NASA astronaut Christina Koch makes observations from the International space Station's cupola. Koch has already made history once in her stay aboard the orbital laboratory. In October 2019 she was part of the first all-female spacewalk and now she is poised to make history again. On Dec. 28, 2019, she will break the record for the longest single spaceflight by a woman, when she surpasses former Station Commander Peggy Whitson's record. When she arrives back on Earth in February 2020, she will have spent more than 300 days in space.
NASA astronaut Christina Koch makes observations from the International space Station's cupola. Koch has already made history once in her stay aboard the orbital laboratory. In October 2019 she was part of the first all-female spacewalk and now she is poised to make history again. On Dec. 28, 2019, she will break the record for the longest single spaceflight by a woman, when she surpasses former Station Commander Peggy Whitson's record. When she arrives back on Earth in February 2020, she will have spent more than 300 days in space.
Handling of war crimes case
National security adviser defends Trump’s handling of war crimes case
“Ultimately the president as commander-in-chief has said that he's got the back of our men and women in uniform."
By RISHIKA DUGYALA
National security adviser Robert O’Brien said Sunday that President Donald Trump is standing behind retired Navy SEAL Eddie Gallagher, despite footage obtained by The New York Times of Gallagher’s platoon describing him as “evil” and “toxic.”
“Ultimately, the president, as commander in chief, has said that he's got the back of our men and women in uniform. He has the power to pardon and to grant clemency. He exercised that power here,” O’Brien told Jonathan Karl on ABC’s “This Week.“
He added, “This is a case that deserved clemency.”
Gallagher was acquitted in July of murdering a wounded teenage prisoner of war in Iraq but was convicted of posing with the corpse, and he was subsequently demoted. In November, Trump undercut military leadership to ensure Gallagher maintained his rank and his SEAL status, tweeting that he “was not pleased with the way that Navy Seal Eddie Gallagher’s trial was handled by the Navy.” Earlier this month, Gallagher and his wife visited Mar-a-Lago to present Trump with an unspecified thank you gift.
The New York Times obtained video interviews — part of Navy investigative materials pertaining to Gallagher’s prosecution — of members of SEAL Team 7 Alpha Platoon portraying their former leader in a troubling manner: “The guy is freaking evil.” “The guy was toxic.” “You could tell he was perfectly OK with killing anybody that was moving.”
Platoon members also accused Gallagher of shooting a 12-year-old and discussed rumors of him attacking civilians.
O’Brien on Sunday said the videotaped platoon members were part of “a selective group of SEALs” and there were many others who supported Gallagher and appealed to the president on his behalf.
There was an investigation, O’Brien said, and the president decided “we’re going to stand behind our warriors.”
“We put these men and women in very tough situations. And I think the president took that into account.”
“Ultimately the president as commander-in-chief has said that he's got the back of our men and women in uniform."
By RISHIKA DUGYALA
National security adviser Robert O’Brien said Sunday that President Donald Trump is standing behind retired Navy SEAL Eddie Gallagher, despite footage obtained by The New York Times of Gallagher’s platoon describing him as “evil” and “toxic.”
“Ultimately, the president, as commander in chief, has said that he's got the back of our men and women in uniform. He has the power to pardon and to grant clemency. He exercised that power here,” O’Brien told Jonathan Karl on ABC’s “This Week.“
He added, “This is a case that deserved clemency.”
Gallagher was acquitted in July of murdering a wounded teenage prisoner of war in Iraq but was convicted of posing with the corpse, and he was subsequently demoted. In November, Trump undercut military leadership to ensure Gallagher maintained his rank and his SEAL status, tweeting that he “was not pleased with the way that Navy Seal Eddie Gallagher’s trial was handled by the Navy.” Earlier this month, Gallagher and his wife visited Mar-a-Lago to present Trump with an unspecified thank you gift.
The New York Times obtained video interviews — part of Navy investigative materials pertaining to Gallagher’s prosecution — of members of SEAL Team 7 Alpha Platoon portraying their former leader in a troubling manner: “The guy is freaking evil.” “The guy was toxic.” “You could tell he was perfectly OK with killing anybody that was moving.”
Platoon members also accused Gallagher of shooting a 12-year-old and discussed rumors of him attacking civilians.
O’Brien on Sunday said the videotaped platoon members were part of “a selective group of SEALs” and there were many others who supported Gallagher and appealed to the president on his behalf.
There was an investigation, O’Brien said, and the president decided “we’re going to stand behind our warriors.”
“We put these men and women in very tough situations. And I think the president took that into account.”
Flor-I-Daaaaa.....
‘Florida is too important to blow off’: Late primary won’t dim state’s primary status
By MAYA KING and MATT DIXON
Florida Democrats are used to being wooed by presidential candidates hungry for endorsements and local fundraising early in primary season.
This year, the love is late in coming.
The state and its 219 party delegates have long enjoyed a front-row seat to electoral brawls. The 2020 election calendar, however, has dimmed the spotlight on the state’s celebrity after the Legislature, under pressure from national leaders of both parties, adopted a March 17 primary. By the time that date rolls around, 25 states and four U.S. territories already will have voted and nearly half the Democratic Party’s 4,051 delegates will be spoken for.
But a crowded Democratic field and an expected split in early voting states could inject some adrenaline into Florida after its sleepy start in the presidential election. Democratic front-runners Elizabeth Warren and Joe Biden — and deep-pocketed, not-so-front-runners Michael Bloomberg and Tom Steyer — slowly have begun making their presence felt in the state.
“Florida has become the familiar stomping grounds for candidate’s third cousins, spouses, and siblings,” political strategist Screven Watson joked about this year’s election cycle so far. But he predicts that candidates will be forced to eat their political vegetables and spend more time in the Sunshine State in coming months.
“When it becomes showtime, Florida is too important to blow off,” said Watson, an unaffiliated Democrat. “Like the annual trip to the dentist, they will begrudgingly show up.”
It’s a truism that Florida is the nation’s biggest swing state—Democrats are aiming to block President Donald Trump’s path to a second term here.
But the primary this cycle will come two weeks after Super Tuesday, thanks to a dispute years in the making.
In 2008, the Democratic National Committee stripped Florida of its party delegates after the Republican-controlled Florida Legislature jumped the gun by scheduling a January primary. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama pledged not to campaign in the state during their battle that year. In 2012, Florida again scheduled its primary at the end of January.
But in 2013, the state bowed to party wishes, passing legislation that moved its primary to mid-March on Super Tuesday II, avoiding further ire from both parties’ national committees while preserving the state’s must-win reputation.
Outside of the first Democratic debate in Miami in June, Democratic candidates so far have made few campaign stops in the state. In October, not a single contender attended the party’s annual Leadership Blue event.
And the surrogates who did attend were underwhelming. California Sen. Kamala Harris, who has since dropped out of the race, sent her husband, Douglas. South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg also dispatched his husband, Chasten, who ended up addressing state party heavyweights via FaceTime from an Alabama airport after he had difficulty getting to Orlando.
But even as candidates focus on do-or-die early states such as Iowa and New Hampshire, Florida’s trove of delegates could be enough to solidify a frontrunner or shift the odds in a closely contested race after Super Tuesday.
That’s why Warren is building a staff infrastructure across Florida’s 67 counties. Biden has hustled for legislative endorsements and held South Florida fundraisers while his wife Jill has stumped in the Panhandle. Bloomberg has spent $10.5 million in television ads in Florida since he entered the race four weeks ago. Steyer is advertising, too.
“It’s so difficult to even play in Florida unless you have the resources,” said state Sen. Annette Taddeo (D-Miami). “With so many states ahead of Florida and with Biden having such a huge advantage when it comes to recognition, I think that that’s part of the reason why.”
Bloomberg on Dec. 20 hired 170 staffers in March primary states including Florida, where he tapped Brandon Miller to be state director. Miller is a former chief of staff to the Democratic National Committee and managed the campaign of Andrew Gillum, who lost his 2018 run for Florida governor.
“Florida will have a big role to play because it’s a very crowded Democratic field. You have some [campaigns] only competing in states outside of the first four,” said Ashley Walker, state director of For Our Future Florida, a progressive nonprofit that organizes Democratic grassroots efforts.
“That is shaking up the calendar and the more traditional way of thinking,” Walker said.
Florida Democrats interviewed by POLITICO said the characteristics of this year’s primary could make the state a kingmaker.
One reason: The four early states could fail to deliver a front runner headed into Super Tuesday. Based on Real Clear Politics’ average of polls, Buttigieg holds a 2-point lead in Iowa, Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders has 1.3-point lead in New Hampshire and Biden is up by 18 points in South Carolina and 8 points in Nevada.
“This year, the way it is shaping up, it is going to make Florida very much in play,” said Eric Johnson, a longtime South Florida Democratic operative. “It looks like we could come out of Super Tuesday without clarity. Right now, there quite possibly could be different winners in each of the early states.”
Juan Peñalosa, executive director of the Florida Democratic Party, pointed to the strong grassroots presence Warren, Buttigieg and other candidates have in the state as evidence of Florida’s importance. It’s also a good place for courting swing voters, a constituency key to winning in the state and setting up a roadblock to a Trump victory in November.
“I would argue that the late nature of Florida’s primary actually makes it even better for our state,” Peñalosa said. “We are growing. And a March primary comes at exactly the right time for our field operation in terms of kicking it up a notch right before the election.”
By MAYA KING and MATT DIXON
Florida Democrats are used to being wooed by presidential candidates hungry for endorsements and local fundraising early in primary season.
This year, the love is late in coming.
The state and its 219 party delegates have long enjoyed a front-row seat to electoral brawls. The 2020 election calendar, however, has dimmed the spotlight on the state’s celebrity after the Legislature, under pressure from national leaders of both parties, adopted a March 17 primary. By the time that date rolls around, 25 states and four U.S. territories already will have voted and nearly half the Democratic Party’s 4,051 delegates will be spoken for.
But a crowded Democratic field and an expected split in early voting states could inject some adrenaline into Florida after its sleepy start in the presidential election. Democratic front-runners Elizabeth Warren and Joe Biden — and deep-pocketed, not-so-front-runners Michael Bloomberg and Tom Steyer — slowly have begun making their presence felt in the state.
“Florida has become the familiar stomping grounds for candidate’s third cousins, spouses, and siblings,” political strategist Screven Watson joked about this year’s election cycle so far. But he predicts that candidates will be forced to eat their political vegetables and spend more time in the Sunshine State in coming months.
“When it becomes showtime, Florida is too important to blow off,” said Watson, an unaffiliated Democrat. “Like the annual trip to the dentist, they will begrudgingly show up.”
It’s a truism that Florida is the nation’s biggest swing state—Democrats are aiming to block President Donald Trump’s path to a second term here.
But the primary this cycle will come two weeks after Super Tuesday, thanks to a dispute years in the making.
In 2008, the Democratic National Committee stripped Florida of its party delegates after the Republican-controlled Florida Legislature jumped the gun by scheduling a January primary. Hillary Clinton and Barack Obama pledged not to campaign in the state during their battle that year. In 2012, Florida again scheduled its primary at the end of January.
But in 2013, the state bowed to party wishes, passing legislation that moved its primary to mid-March on Super Tuesday II, avoiding further ire from both parties’ national committees while preserving the state’s must-win reputation.
Outside of the first Democratic debate in Miami in June, Democratic candidates so far have made few campaign stops in the state. In October, not a single contender attended the party’s annual Leadership Blue event.
And the surrogates who did attend were underwhelming. California Sen. Kamala Harris, who has since dropped out of the race, sent her husband, Douglas. South Bend, Ind., Mayor Pete Buttigieg also dispatched his husband, Chasten, who ended up addressing state party heavyweights via FaceTime from an Alabama airport after he had difficulty getting to Orlando.
But even as candidates focus on do-or-die early states such as Iowa and New Hampshire, Florida’s trove of delegates could be enough to solidify a frontrunner or shift the odds in a closely contested race after Super Tuesday.
That’s why Warren is building a staff infrastructure across Florida’s 67 counties. Biden has hustled for legislative endorsements and held South Florida fundraisers while his wife Jill has stumped in the Panhandle. Bloomberg has spent $10.5 million in television ads in Florida since he entered the race four weeks ago. Steyer is advertising, too.
“It’s so difficult to even play in Florida unless you have the resources,” said state Sen. Annette Taddeo (D-Miami). “With so many states ahead of Florida and with Biden having such a huge advantage when it comes to recognition, I think that that’s part of the reason why.”
Bloomberg on Dec. 20 hired 170 staffers in March primary states including Florida, where he tapped Brandon Miller to be state director. Miller is a former chief of staff to the Democratic National Committee and managed the campaign of Andrew Gillum, who lost his 2018 run for Florida governor.
“Florida will have a big role to play because it’s a very crowded Democratic field. You have some [campaigns] only competing in states outside of the first four,” said Ashley Walker, state director of For Our Future Florida, a progressive nonprofit that organizes Democratic grassroots efforts.
“That is shaking up the calendar and the more traditional way of thinking,” Walker said.
Florida Democrats interviewed by POLITICO said the characteristics of this year’s primary could make the state a kingmaker.
One reason: The four early states could fail to deliver a front runner headed into Super Tuesday. Based on Real Clear Politics’ average of polls, Buttigieg holds a 2-point lead in Iowa, Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders has 1.3-point lead in New Hampshire and Biden is up by 18 points in South Carolina and 8 points in Nevada.
“This year, the way it is shaping up, it is going to make Florida very much in play,” said Eric Johnson, a longtime South Florida Democratic operative. “It looks like we could come out of Super Tuesday without clarity. Right now, there quite possibly could be different winners in each of the early states.”
Juan Peñalosa, executive director of the Florida Democratic Party, pointed to the strong grassroots presence Warren, Buttigieg and other candidates have in the state as evidence of Florida’s importance. It’s also a good place for courting swing voters, a constituency key to winning in the state and setting up a roadblock to a Trump victory in November.
“I would argue that the late nature of Florida’s primary actually makes it even better for our state,” Peñalosa said. “We are growing. And a March primary comes at exactly the right time for our field operation in terms of kicking it up a notch right before the election.”
If this isn't a warning sign....
Kremlin: Putin calls to thank Trump for help on terrorism
The White House has not yet released a statement on the call.
By RISHIKA DUGYALA
The Kremlin on Sunday posted a readout of a thank you call from President Vladimir Putin of Russia to President Donald Trump.
According to the readout, Putin thanked Trump for information — “transmitted through the channels of U.S. special services” — that “helped thwart terrorist acts in Russia.”
The readout noted that the two presidents also discussed issues of mutual interest, agreeing to “continue bilateral cooperation in combating terrorism.” The Russian government news agency TASS, citing a spokesman from the FSB intelligence agency, reported that two Russian nationals were plotting terrorist attacks in St. Petersburg over the New Year holiday but were detained thanks to the information shared by the U.S.
The White House has not released a statement on the call, and reporters traveling with Trump in Florida asked for more information on Sunday.
The Kremlin’s readout is not the first time Russia has put out call statements ahead of the White House, even if the statements don’t fully reflect what was said.
In August, the Kremlin said in a statement that Trump offered Putin help in fighting vast wildfires in Siberia. The phone conversation had taken place on the “initiative of the American side,” the Kremlin added. The White House later confirmed the two leaders’ conversation.
And in 2017, photos from Trump‘s first Oval Office meeting with Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov of Russia surfaced online from the Kremlin. The meeting had been closed to the American media.
Lavrov had another a closed-door Oval Office meeting with Trump earlier this month — on the day House Democrats unveiled articles of impeachment against him. Afterward, Trump praised the “very good meeting“ in a tweet, saying the two had discussed “election meddling.“ But at a news conference at the Russian Embassy, Lavrov wouldn‘t answer that claim directly, suggesting only that Secretary of State Mike Pompeo had raised the issue during a separate meeting.
The White House has not yet released a statement on the call.
By RISHIKA DUGYALA
The Kremlin on Sunday posted a readout of a thank you call from President Vladimir Putin of Russia to President Donald Trump.
According to the readout, Putin thanked Trump for information — “transmitted through the channels of U.S. special services” — that “helped thwart terrorist acts in Russia.”
The readout noted that the two presidents also discussed issues of mutual interest, agreeing to “continue bilateral cooperation in combating terrorism.” The Russian government news agency TASS, citing a spokesman from the FSB intelligence agency, reported that two Russian nationals were plotting terrorist attacks in St. Petersburg over the New Year holiday but were detained thanks to the information shared by the U.S.
The White House has not released a statement on the call, and reporters traveling with Trump in Florida asked for more information on Sunday.
The Kremlin’s readout is not the first time Russia has put out call statements ahead of the White House, even if the statements don’t fully reflect what was said.
In August, the Kremlin said in a statement that Trump offered Putin help in fighting vast wildfires in Siberia. The phone conversation had taken place on the “initiative of the American side,” the Kremlin added. The White House later confirmed the two leaders’ conversation.
And in 2017, photos from Trump‘s first Oval Office meeting with Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov of Russia surfaced online from the Kremlin. The meeting had been closed to the American media.
Lavrov had another a closed-door Oval Office meeting with Trump earlier this month — on the day House Democrats unveiled articles of impeachment against him. Afterward, Trump praised the “very good meeting“ in a tweet, saying the two had discussed “election meddling.“ But at a news conference at the Russian Embassy, Lavrov wouldn‘t answer that claim directly, suggesting only that Secretary of State Mike Pompeo had raised the issue during a separate meeting.
Jersey’s 2nd Congressional District
Van Drew’s party switch upends GOP primary race
The New Jersey lawmaker changed the entire dynamic of the race when he switched parties and was quickly considered the frontrunner.
By MATT FRIEDMAN
Rep. Jeff Van Drew's switch from Democrat to Republican has upended an already crowded GOP primary field to replace him in South Jersey’s 2nd Congressional District, with Republicans who have promised to support President Donald Trump now running against the candidate the president has personally endorsed.
It was something David Richter, the 53-year-old former CEO of family-founded Hill International, never anticipated when the inspiration to run hit him more than a year ago.
Richter was pursuing his master‘s degree in public administration at Harvard University when he was tasked with developing a plan for a political campaign. He chose the 2nd District — a sprawling, predominantly working-class swing district represented at the time by retiring Republican Rep. Frank LoBiondo, who was replaced this year by Democrat Van Drew.
Richter researched the district‘s voting patterns, demographics and electoral history.
”I had an almost 2-inch thick binder of documents,” he said in a recent interview. “I surprised myself and got an A on it.”
Now Richter is putting his academic research to real-life use as he — along with three other Republicans — seek the district’s GOP nomination.
But Van Drew changed the entire dynamic of the race when he switched parties and was quickly considered the frontrunner.
Van Drew, who did not respond to a request for comment, had been planning to seek reelection as a Democrat, but saw his support plunge into in the 20s when he announced he would vote against impeaching Trump. After a frantic and unsuccessful effort to shore up party support — Democratic leaders were abandoning him — Van Drew switched to the GOP and, in a formal announcement, pledged his “undying support” to Trump as he sat next to the president in the Oval Office.
Richter quickly found his top political consultants and much of his staff leaving his campaign so as not to alienate the National Republican Congressional Committee, which is backing the newly-minted GOP incumbent.
“The NRCC basically pulled them in and said, ‘You need to be working for a Republican incumbent, and if you work for a Republican running against an incumbent, you’ll essentially be blackballed from doing further work,” Richter said.
Chris Russell, who had been one of Richter’s consultants, said his firm’s decision not to work against a party-endorsed incumbent was “our choice” because “we felt it was a conflict.“ NRCC spokesperson Michael McAdams said in a statement the committee “doesn’t blacklist consultants.”
The 2nd District includes all or parts of eight counties and stretches from the Jersey Shore to the Delaware River. While New Jersey’s more affluent districts in the north have turned against Trump, much of the 2nd has embraced him. Trump carried the district in 2016, even though former President Barack Obama won it in 2008 and 2012.
“I understand the decision of the president“ to openly support Van Drew, Richter said. “It benefited the president during impeachment week when he needed a positive story, and a Democrat flipping to the Republican Party over impeachment is a good story. The problem is the narrative isn’t accurate. Van Drew switched parties because he was going to lose, and this is an attempt to save his own job.”
Also running for the GOP nomination are Brian Fitzherbert, a defense contractor, and Bob Patterson, a former Trump administration Social Security aide who edited a conservative academic journal.
Fitzherbert, 30, said his background as a project manager and engineer in the aerospace industry makes him a good fit for the district.
“The district has a lot of assets that Frank LoBiondo was instrumental in getting off the ground,” he said.
Patterson, 66, said he wants to boost manufacturing in South Jersey and supports a bill that would move many federal agencies away from the Washington, D.C., area.
“I would see the possibility of bringing two or three agencies to South Jersey, and with that, all these jobs,” he said.
Despite his reputation as a conservative Democrat who bucked the party on impeachment, Van Drew typically cast major votes with his former party during his first year in Congress and has a record of supporting abortion rights.
Van Drew has broken with Trump on several issues: He opposed offshore drilling and the military’s ban on transgender soldiers, and favored a $15 federal minimum wage. His congressional record was arguably more liberal than his record as a state lawmaker, when he voted against a $15 minimum wage and against same-sex marriage.
Among New Jersey’s Democratic House delegation, several members have voted in line with the president’s position more often than Van Drew, according to the data-driven website FiveThirtyEight.
Van Drew has long, deep roots in the 2nd District, where he began his political career as a Cape May County freeholder and represented part of it for nearly two decades in the state Legislature.
The other three Republicans claim connection to the district, though they have all recently lived somewhere else.
Richter was a longtime Princeton resident, which is far outside the district, and rented a home less than two years ago in Miami Beach, Fla., where he planned to move and where he voted in 2018 before ultimately deciding to stay in New Jersey. He moved into the district in the fall, while his children continue to go to school in Princeton.
Fitzherbert, who grew up in North Jersey, has owned a home in the district since he was 23 but has moved around the country in recent years “as a result of the demands of the job,” and only began voting in the 2nd District in June 2018.
Patterson, who grew up in a different part of South Jersey, ran unsuccessfully for Congress in New Jersey’s neighboring 1st District in 2016 after living in Virginia for about 20 years.
Prior to Van Drew, Richter had been the main target of Fitzherbert and Patterson. They both pointed out that his company, Hill International, had hired former Vice President Joe Biden’s brother as an executive of a subsidiary around the same time it secured a housing contract in Iraq, which ultimately fell through.
Richter said it was his father’s decision to hire Biden‘s brother, and that he had warned against it. “The whole time we were in this business, I was pushing my dad to end it. And finally after several years of losses, he finally ended it and shut the whole thing down,” he said.
Fitzherbert’s campaign pointed out that Richter’s voting record was spotty, and that he had not voted in nearly half the primary and general elections in recent years.
Fitzherbert and Patterson have potential weaknesses as well.
Fitzherbert has struggled to raise money, while Patterson has a history of controversial public statements, including favorably summarizing a study in a conservative journal in which he and a co-author wrote that using condoms “robs a woman of all these remarkable chemicals” found in semen.
That statement, along with Patterson’s writings that criticized women choosing careers over marriage and raising children, led to his resignation in 2012 as an adviser to then-Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett after The Philadelphia Inquirer raised questions about them.
“I have written hundreds of articles over my career, and some of those articles dared to question or debunk liberal groupthink on many issues,” Patterson said. “In other cases, I was summarizing scientific findings of empirical studies that someone else conducted.”
With the support of Trump and the NRCC, Van Drew is the new frontrunner. Pressure will build on local leaders to back him as well, giving him the “party line,” which in most of the district bestows favorable ballot placement.
The fact that all three remain committed to the race poses another danger. Even if Republican primary voters are suspicious of Van Drew’s motives for fleeing the Democratic Party, they might split their votes among the three challengers.
In addition to Trump, Van Drew is being advised by former White House political director Bill Stepien, who worked for years as a New Jersey Republican operative, and managed by Ron Filan, a well-known Republican consultant in New Jersey.
Monmouth University pollster Patrick Murray suggested the primary may get less crowded if local Republican leaders fall in line behind Van Drew — something that’s already beginning with some local GOP chairs.
“Right now, it looks like it’s going to be crowded, but it could end up falling by the wayside if you have some key leaders ... coming out in support of a particular candidate,” Murray said. “If it happens to be Van Drew, you’re going to see the entire party get in line by the April filing deadline.”
The race won’t be over with the primary. Despite its Trump leaning, the 2nd District remains highly competitive, and Democrats plan to compete there. Three candidates — political science professor Brigid Harrison, Atlantic County Freeholder Ashley Bennett and environmentalist John Francis — are seeking the Democratic nomination.
“Certainly this leans Republican, and whoever the nominee is will be considered the favorite,’ but by how much of a favorite really depends on the presidential election,” Murray said.
The New Jersey lawmaker changed the entire dynamic of the race when he switched parties and was quickly considered the frontrunner.
By MATT FRIEDMAN
Rep. Jeff Van Drew's switch from Democrat to Republican has upended an already crowded GOP primary field to replace him in South Jersey’s 2nd Congressional District, with Republicans who have promised to support President Donald Trump now running against the candidate the president has personally endorsed.
It was something David Richter, the 53-year-old former CEO of family-founded Hill International, never anticipated when the inspiration to run hit him more than a year ago.
Richter was pursuing his master‘s degree in public administration at Harvard University when he was tasked with developing a plan for a political campaign. He chose the 2nd District — a sprawling, predominantly working-class swing district represented at the time by retiring Republican Rep. Frank LoBiondo, who was replaced this year by Democrat Van Drew.
Richter researched the district‘s voting patterns, demographics and electoral history.
”I had an almost 2-inch thick binder of documents,” he said in a recent interview. “I surprised myself and got an A on it.”
Now Richter is putting his academic research to real-life use as he — along with three other Republicans — seek the district’s GOP nomination.
But Van Drew changed the entire dynamic of the race when he switched parties and was quickly considered the frontrunner.
Van Drew, who did not respond to a request for comment, had been planning to seek reelection as a Democrat, but saw his support plunge into in the 20s when he announced he would vote against impeaching Trump. After a frantic and unsuccessful effort to shore up party support — Democratic leaders were abandoning him — Van Drew switched to the GOP and, in a formal announcement, pledged his “undying support” to Trump as he sat next to the president in the Oval Office.
Richter quickly found his top political consultants and much of his staff leaving his campaign so as not to alienate the National Republican Congressional Committee, which is backing the newly-minted GOP incumbent.
“The NRCC basically pulled them in and said, ‘You need to be working for a Republican incumbent, and if you work for a Republican running against an incumbent, you’ll essentially be blackballed from doing further work,” Richter said.
Chris Russell, who had been one of Richter’s consultants, said his firm’s decision not to work against a party-endorsed incumbent was “our choice” because “we felt it was a conflict.“ NRCC spokesperson Michael McAdams said in a statement the committee “doesn’t blacklist consultants.”
The 2nd District includes all or parts of eight counties and stretches from the Jersey Shore to the Delaware River. While New Jersey’s more affluent districts in the north have turned against Trump, much of the 2nd has embraced him. Trump carried the district in 2016, even though former President Barack Obama won it in 2008 and 2012.
“I understand the decision of the president“ to openly support Van Drew, Richter said. “It benefited the president during impeachment week when he needed a positive story, and a Democrat flipping to the Republican Party over impeachment is a good story. The problem is the narrative isn’t accurate. Van Drew switched parties because he was going to lose, and this is an attempt to save his own job.”
Also running for the GOP nomination are Brian Fitzherbert, a defense contractor, and Bob Patterson, a former Trump administration Social Security aide who edited a conservative academic journal.
Fitzherbert, 30, said his background as a project manager and engineer in the aerospace industry makes him a good fit for the district.
“The district has a lot of assets that Frank LoBiondo was instrumental in getting off the ground,” he said.
Patterson, 66, said he wants to boost manufacturing in South Jersey and supports a bill that would move many federal agencies away from the Washington, D.C., area.
“I would see the possibility of bringing two or three agencies to South Jersey, and with that, all these jobs,” he said.
Despite his reputation as a conservative Democrat who bucked the party on impeachment, Van Drew typically cast major votes with his former party during his first year in Congress and has a record of supporting abortion rights.
Van Drew has broken with Trump on several issues: He opposed offshore drilling and the military’s ban on transgender soldiers, and favored a $15 federal minimum wage. His congressional record was arguably more liberal than his record as a state lawmaker, when he voted against a $15 minimum wage and against same-sex marriage.
Among New Jersey’s Democratic House delegation, several members have voted in line with the president’s position more often than Van Drew, according to the data-driven website FiveThirtyEight.
Van Drew has long, deep roots in the 2nd District, where he began his political career as a Cape May County freeholder and represented part of it for nearly two decades in the state Legislature.
The other three Republicans claim connection to the district, though they have all recently lived somewhere else.
Richter was a longtime Princeton resident, which is far outside the district, and rented a home less than two years ago in Miami Beach, Fla., where he planned to move and where he voted in 2018 before ultimately deciding to stay in New Jersey. He moved into the district in the fall, while his children continue to go to school in Princeton.
Fitzherbert, who grew up in North Jersey, has owned a home in the district since he was 23 but has moved around the country in recent years “as a result of the demands of the job,” and only began voting in the 2nd District in June 2018.
Patterson, who grew up in a different part of South Jersey, ran unsuccessfully for Congress in New Jersey’s neighboring 1st District in 2016 after living in Virginia for about 20 years.
Prior to Van Drew, Richter had been the main target of Fitzherbert and Patterson. They both pointed out that his company, Hill International, had hired former Vice President Joe Biden’s brother as an executive of a subsidiary around the same time it secured a housing contract in Iraq, which ultimately fell through.
Richter said it was his father’s decision to hire Biden‘s brother, and that he had warned against it. “The whole time we were in this business, I was pushing my dad to end it. And finally after several years of losses, he finally ended it and shut the whole thing down,” he said.
Fitzherbert’s campaign pointed out that Richter’s voting record was spotty, and that he had not voted in nearly half the primary and general elections in recent years.
Fitzherbert and Patterson have potential weaknesses as well.
Fitzherbert has struggled to raise money, while Patterson has a history of controversial public statements, including favorably summarizing a study in a conservative journal in which he and a co-author wrote that using condoms “robs a woman of all these remarkable chemicals” found in semen.
That statement, along with Patterson’s writings that criticized women choosing careers over marriage and raising children, led to his resignation in 2012 as an adviser to then-Pennsylvania Gov. Tom Corbett after The Philadelphia Inquirer raised questions about them.
“I have written hundreds of articles over my career, and some of those articles dared to question or debunk liberal groupthink on many issues,” Patterson said. “In other cases, I was summarizing scientific findings of empirical studies that someone else conducted.”
With the support of Trump and the NRCC, Van Drew is the new frontrunner. Pressure will build on local leaders to back him as well, giving him the “party line,” which in most of the district bestows favorable ballot placement.
The fact that all three remain committed to the race poses another danger. Even if Republican primary voters are suspicious of Van Drew’s motives for fleeing the Democratic Party, they might split their votes among the three challengers.
In addition to Trump, Van Drew is being advised by former White House political director Bill Stepien, who worked for years as a New Jersey Republican operative, and managed by Ron Filan, a well-known Republican consultant in New Jersey.
Monmouth University pollster Patrick Murray suggested the primary may get less crowded if local Republican leaders fall in line behind Van Drew — something that’s already beginning with some local GOP chairs.
“Right now, it looks like it’s going to be crowded, but it could end up falling by the wayside if you have some key leaders ... coming out in support of a particular candidate,” Murray said. “If it happens to be Van Drew, you’re going to see the entire party get in line by the April filing deadline.”
The race won’t be over with the primary. Despite its Trump leaning, the 2nd District remains highly competitive, and Democrats plan to compete there. Three candidates — political science professor Brigid Harrison, Atlantic County Freeholder Ashley Bennett and environmentalist John Francis — are seeking the Democratic nomination.
“Certainly this leans Republican, and whoever the nominee is will be considered the favorite,’ but by how much of a favorite really depends on the presidential election,” Murray said.
5G America
The big barrier to Trump’s 5G America
As Trump tries to edge out Beijing in the race to 5G, the U.S. is facing a shortage of workers.
By JOHN HENDEL
President Donald Trump envisions a not-too-distant future in which super-fast 5G networks span the country, powering everything from smart cities to remote surgeries — and getting there before China does.
There's just one thing: He doesn't have the workforce to build it. And he's not even close.
For starters, the U.S. needs to train another 20,000 tower climbers to install equipment, according to industry figures cited by Brendan Carr, a Republican member of the Federal Communications Commission.
The 27,000 tower hands working nationwide right now won't be able to handle the workload, he told POLITICO. “We’re talking about the ability to double the existing workforce.”
These next-generation wireless networks, made up of thousands of tightly clustered suitcase-sized cell sites, are already coming online in a smattering of U.S. cities such as Minneapolis and Sacramento, Calif., and parts of China. They're roughly 100 times faster than current networks and predicted to radically reshape the global economy, ushering in a new era of connected devices, driverless cars and enhanced telemedicine.
As Trump tries to edge out Beijing in the race to 5G, the U.S. is facing a shortage of not just tower climbers, but many other workers skilled enough to roll out the infrastructure on behalf of wireless giants like AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile, upping pressure on the administration given the economic promise of this new technology.
But the low unemployment rate that Trump loves to tout could actually slow the rollout of 5G. The broader network-building process, which includes laying fiber, climbing cell towers and placing hundreds of thousands of smaller pieces of infrastructure known as small cells, could call for as many as 100,000 new jobs to fill, Carr estimates.
The wireless industry has suggested a need to build some 800,000 5G small cells by 2026. Although apprenticeship efforts, in-house training and academic and technical training partnerships are underway, some industry officials caution that won’t be anywhere near enough to meet demand in the short term.
“It’s almost a crisis,” said Jonathan Adelstein, president of the Wireless Infrastructure Association. “Because if it’s not a crisis today it will be by tomorrow if we don’t act now. You can’t just invent a new workforce overnight. … The lack of a properly skilled workforce is a top obstacle we’re facing right now to winning the race to 5G.”
The total price tag to train the 5G workforce is unknown, although current investments seem modest. A Department of Labor grant to kick-start even one statewide apprentice program in North Carolina cost $2.3 million.
Meanwhile, China is “actively mobilizing” and has “undertaken significant investments in building up a more robust digital infrastructure of fiber optic networks that are important to facilitate the large-scale deployment of 5G,” according to a November report from the Center for a New American Security, amounting to hundreds of billions of dollars.
“China can much more quickly redeploy labor,” said Adelstein. “They have much cheaper labor and much more readily available labor than we do. So if they make it a national priority, they can use state instruments to quickly ramp up and clear blockages to broadband.”
There’s “no doubt that Beijing has made 5G a national priority, and the pace of infrastructure build out on 5G has been impressive,” especially compared to U.S. build-outs, said Adam Segal, director of the Digital and Cyberspace Policy Program at the Council on Foreign Relations.
But Chinese telecom companies have closely cooperated with local governments to make this happen, Segal added, questioning the idea of the government “dragooning” people into service. China may also face some of the same shortages of skilled workers as the U.S., according to Segal, who noted that China faces some shortages in other tech areas such as artificial intelligence and cybersecurity.
Western policymakers have warned that if China wins the race to fully deploy next-generation wireless technology nationwide, it would have first-mover advantage to exert influence over the broader global 5G industry.
The U.S. has sought to blunt the spread of Chinese 5G technology, waging a campaign at home and across Europe to block the use of components from telecom companies Huawei and ZTE.
American lawmakers, military officials and China hawks warn those companies pose security risks, claiming Beijing could manipulate the equipment and use it against Americans. The military has already banned the use of the equipment and the Commerce Department is weighing rules for a much broader nationwide ban.
And the cost of the U.S.'s build-out of 5G will likely be higher without access to inexpensive Huawei components, adding to the workforce challenges.
It’s unclear if the 5G workforce shortage is even on the White House’s radar. Last spring, Trump said he sided against “leading through the government” on 5G in favor of a “private sector-driven and private sector-led” approach, spurning some advisers including Newt Gingrich.
Trump, meanwhile, caught many off guard in November when he suggested that Apple, a tech giant that doesn’t build telecommunications networks, take up the task. “I asked Tim Cook to see if he could get Apple involved in building 5G in the U.S.,” Trump tweeted. “They have it all - Money, Technology, Vision & Cook!!”
Still, many telecommunication companies are looking to the Trump administration for guidance on how to build a next-generation network without access to Chinese parts and few skilled American workers, especially as federal legislation that would help spur 5G workforce training has stalled.
“There’s no question that in 2020 there will generally be a shortage of workers to do this work, and more demand for faster deployment than the industry has the capacity to provide,” said Josh Broder, CEO of Maine-based network construction firm Tilson, a 600-person company that’s hiring for about 100 open positions, even with 80 apprentices in training now.
“This year we’ve turned away as much work as we’ve performed,” he added.
The federal government could “provide some sort of broader, more uniform federal support for workforce reskilling,” relieving the burden from companies such as his, Broder said.
The Department of Labor has partnered with industry and government officials on a telecom apprenticeship program known as the Telecommunications Industry Registered Apprenticeship Program.
Adelstein, a board member for that apprenticeship effort, recommends the administration put the apprenticeship effort “on steroids” with more resources to help close the worker shortfall. Although the department seems to sympathize with concerns, he called it a “slow-moving train.”
“While I appreciate the Department of Labor’s commitment to developing a skilled workforce, I would like to see a concerted effort from DoL to ensure we have the workforce necessary to build up 5G, especially as we are racing other countries like China," Rep. Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.), co-chairman of the Spectrum Caucus, told POLITICO, following assurances from the department.
The current Telecommunications Industry Registered Apprenticeship Program counts more than 2,000 apprentices enrolled so far across 28 participating employers, according to the Wireless Infrastructure Association. The group touts that 94 percent of these apprentices remain with the employer upon completion.
Despite the broader 5G worker shortfall, Carr says there is a spike in build-out projects, partly due to the administration’s attempts to streamline infrastructure rules. He expects that about 200,000 small cells will be in place by the end of 2019.
And he still believes the U.S. can beat China in the 5G race.
“When you have central planners in Beijing directing construction projects, they can’t match supply and demand,” Carr told POLITICO. “I believe in the American free-market, free-enterprise system.”
As Trump tries to edge out Beijing in the race to 5G, the U.S. is facing a shortage of workers.
By JOHN HENDEL
President Donald Trump envisions a not-too-distant future in which super-fast 5G networks span the country, powering everything from smart cities to remote surgeries — and getting there before China does.
There's just one thing: He doesn't have the workforce to build it. And he's not even close.
For starters, the U.S. needs to train another 20,000 tower climbers to install equipment, according to industry figures cited by Brendan Carr, a Republican member of the Federal Communications Commission.
The 27,000 tower hands working nationwide right now won't be able to handle the workload, he told POLITICO. “We’re talking about the ability to double the existing workforce.”
These next-generation wireless networks, made up of thousands of tightly clustered suitcase-sized cell sites, are already coming online in a smattering of U.S. cities such as Minneapolis and Sacramento, Calif., and parts of China. They're roughly 100 times faster than current networks and predicted to radically reshape the global economy, ushering in a new era of connected devices, driverless cars and enhanced telemedicine.
As Trump tries to edge out Beijing in the race to 5G, the U.S. is facing a shortage of not just tower climbers, but many other workers skilled enough to roll out the infrastructure on behalf of wireless giants like AT&T, Verizon and T-Mobile, upping pressure on the administration given the economic promise of this new technology.
But the low unemployment rate that Trump loves to tout could actually slow the rollout of 5G. The broader network-building process, which includes laying fiber, climbing cell towers and placing hundreds of thousands of smaller pieces of infrastructure known as small cells, could call for as many as 100,000 new jobs to fill, Carr estimates.
The wireless industry has suggested a need to build some 800,000 5G small cells by 2026. Although apprenticeship efforts, in-house training and academic and technical training partnerships are underway, some industry officials caution that won’t be anywhere near enough to meet demand in the short term.
“It’s almost a crisis,” said Jonathan Adelstein, president of the Wireless Infrastructure Association. “Because if it’s not a crisis today it will be by tomorrow if we don’t act now. You can’t just invent a new workforce overnight. … The lack of a properly skilled workforce is a top obstacle we’re facing right now to winning the race to 5G.”
The total price tag to train the 5G workforce is unknown, although current investments seem modest. A Department of Labor grant to kick-start even one statewide apprentice program in North Carolina cost $2.3 million.
Meanwhile, China is “actively mobilizing” and has “undertaken significant investments in building up a more robust digital infrastructure of fiber optic networks that are important to facilitate the large-scale deployment of 5G,” according to a November report from the Center for a New American Security, amounting to hundreds of billions of dollars.
“China can much more quickly redeploy labor,” said Adelstein. “They have much cheaper labor and much more readily available labor than we do. So if they make it a national priority, they can use state instruments to quickly ramp up and clear blockages to broadband.”
There’s “no doubt that Beijing has made 5G a national priority, and the pace of infrastructure build out on 5G has been impressive,” especially compared to U.S. build-outs, said Adam Segal, director of the Digital and Cyberspace Policy Program at the Council on Foreign Relations.
But Chinese telecom companies have closely cooperated with local governments to make this happen, Segal added, questioning the idea of the government “dragooning” people into service. China may also face some of the same shortages of skilled workers as the U.S., according to Segal, who noted that China faces some shortages in other tech areas such as artificial intelligence and cybersecurity.
Western policymakers have warned that if China wins the race to fully deploy next-generation wireless technology nationwide, it would have first-mover advantage to exert influence over the broader global 5G industry.
The U.S. has sought to blunt the spread of Chinese 5G technology, waging a campaign at home and across Europe to block the use of components from telecom companies Huawei and ZTE.
American lawmakers, military officials and China hawks warn those companies pose security risks, claiming Beijing could manipulate the equipment and use it against Americans. The military has already banned the use of the equipment and the Commerce Department is weighing rules for a much broader nationwide ban.
And the cost of the U.S.'s build-out of 5G will likely be higher without access to inexpensive Huawei components, adding to the workforce challenges.
It’s unclear if the 5G workforce shortage is even on the White House’s radar. Last spring, Trump said he sided against “leading through the government” on 5G in favor of a “private sector-driven and private sector-led” approach, spurning some advisers including Newt Gingrich.
Trump, meanwhile, caught many off guard in November when he suggested that Apple, a tech giant that doesn’t build telecommunications networks, take up the task. “I asked Tim Cook to see if he could get Apple involved in building 5G in the U.S.,” Trump tweeted. “They have it all - Money, Technology, Vision & Cook!!”
Still, many telecommunication companies are looking to the Trump administration for guidance on how to build a next-generation network without access to Chinese parts and few skilled American workers, especially as federal legislation that would help spur 5G workforce training has stalled.
“There’s no question that in 2020 there will generally be a shortage of workers to do this work, and more demand for faster deployment than the industry has the capacity to provide,” said Josh Broder, CEO of Maine-based network construction firm Tilson, a 600-person company that’s hiring for about 100 open positions, even with 80 apprentices in training now.
“This year we’ve turned away as much work as we’ve performed,” he added.
The federal government could “provide some sort of broader, more uniform federal support for workforce reskilling,” relieving the burden from companies such as his, Broder said.
The Department of Labor has partnered with industry and government officials on a telecom apprenticeship program known as the Telecommunications Industry Registered Apprenticeship Program.
Adelstein, a board member for that apprenticeship effort, recommends the administration put the apprenticeship effort “on steroids” with more resources to help close the worker shortfall. Although the department seems to sympathize with concerns, he called it a “slow-moving train.”
“While I appreciate the Department of Labor’s commitment to developing a skilled workforce, I would like to see a concerted effort from DoL to ensure we have the workforce necessary to build up 5G, especially as we are racing other countries like China," Rep. Brett Guthrie (R-Ky.), co-chairman of the Spectrum Caucus, told POLITICO, following assurances from the department.
The current Telecommunications Industry Registered Apprenticeship Program counts more than 2,000 apprentices enrolled so far across 28 participating employers, according to the Wireless Infrastructure Association. The group touts that 94 percent of these apprentices remain with the employer upon completion.
Despite the broader 5G worker shortfall, Carr says there is a spike in build-out projects, partly due to the administration’s attempts to streamline infrastructure rules. He expects that about 200,000 small cells will be in place by the end of 2019.
And he still believes the U.S. can beat China in the 5G race.
“When you have central planners in Beijing directing construction projects, they can’t match supply and demand,” Carr told POLITICO. “I believe in the American free-market, free-enterprise system.”
Where and how to deploy facial recognition.
Fight against facial recognition hits wall across the West
The result is an impasse that has left tech companies largely in control of where and how to deploy facial recognition.
By JANOSCH DELCKER and CRISTIANO LIMA
Face-scanning technology is inspiring a wave of privacy fears as the software creeps into every corner of life in the United States and Europe — at border crossings, on police vehicles and in stadiums, airports and high schools. But efforts to check its spread are hitting a wall of resistance on both sides of the Atlantic.
One big reason: Western governments are embracing this technology for their own use, valuing security and data collection over privacy and civil liberties. And in Washington, President Donald Trump’s impeachment and the death of a key civil rights and privacy champion have snarled expectations for a congressional drive to enact restrictions.
The result is an impasse that has left tech companies largely in control of where and how to deploy facial recognition, which they have sold to police agencies and embedded in consumers’ apps and smartphones. The stalemate has persisted even in Europe’s most privacy-minded countries, such as Germany, and despite a bipartisan U.S. alliance of civil-libertarian Democrats and Republicans.
Advocates for tighter regulations point to China as an example of the technology’s nightmare potential, amid reports authorities are using it to indiscriminately track citizens in public, identify pro-democracy protesters in Hong Kong and oppress millions of Muslim Uighurs in Xinjiang. Current implementations of the software also perpetuate racial bias by misidentifying people of color far more frequently than white people, according to a U.S. government study released just before Congress left town for Christmas.
“Facial recognition needs to be stopped before a fait accompli is established,” Patrick Breyer, a member of the European Parliament for the Pirate Party Germany, told POLITICO.
"The use of facial recognition technology poses a staggering threat to Americans’ privacy," Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.), who is prepping legislation to crack down on the software, said in June.
But police and security forces across the West are still rapidly testing or rolling out the technology, adopting it as an inexpensive way to keep tabs on large groups of people. Cameras and artificial intelligence that can identify people based on their facial features are also showing up at border crossings, on police vehicles, at the entrances to stadiums and even in some high schools in the U.S. and Europe, where they are used to identify students. Such examples far outnumber the facial recognition bans enacted in San Francisco and some other U.S. cities.
In Washington, a once-promising bipartisan push in the House of Representatives to limit the federal government's use of facial recognition has stalled for unrelated reasons, including the death of former House Oversight Chairman Elijah Cummings (D-Md.) and acrimony over impeachment. And in the Senate, more limited proposals to rein in federal agencies' use of the technology have been slow to pick up support.
But privacy activists are drawing a broader lesson from governments’ failure to check the technology’s spread, saying it is eroding the differences between the way Western governments and China approach public surveillance.
“There is growing evidence that the U.S. is increasingly using AI in oppressive and harmful ways that echo China’s use,” AI Now, a research group at New York University, wrote in a report published this month that underscored the spread of "invasive" artificial intelligence technology.
'Fundamental rights'
In both the U.S. and Europe, the stuttering progress of efforts to regulate facial recognition stems from a blend of reluctance by security-obsessed governments and setbacks that have stymied lawmakers’ focus.
The latter obstacles have included the death in October of Cummings, whose panel had seemed poised to craft bipartisan legislation restricting face-scanning by federal agencies. Several top Democrats and Republicans on the committee have also been embroiled in the monthslong dispute over Trump's impeachment and upcoming Senate trial.
Democratic and Republican lawmakers alike acknowledged in interviews with POLITICO that the effort has stalled.
"Unfortunately impeachment has sucked all the energy out of the room," Rep. Stephen Lynch (D-Mass.), who chairs the Oversight National Security Subcommittee, said this month.
"There hasn't been anything that's happened right now. … Elijah's death put that on hold," said Rep. Mark Meadows of North Carolina, the top Republican on the Oversight Government Operations Subcommittee.
In the European Union, meanwhile, calls by top leaders for quick action on regulating artificial intelligence aren’t guaranteed to result in any binding EU-wide restrictions.
Even the strict limits on gathering of “sensitive data" in the EU’s premier privacy rule, the General Data Protection Regulation, contain a broad carve-out for public authorities that can collect sensitive biometric data if they can justify it. That loophole has allowed facial recognition technology to pop up in locations such as a major Berlin train station, where an experimental project by the authorities has scanned tens of thousands of passersby.
Even so, Breyer said he is confident Europe will ultimately end up with stricter limits on facial recognition than the United States. The lawmaker argues that the EU’s Charter of Fundamental Rights, which grants every European citizen “the right to the protection of personal data concerning him or her,” will protect Europeans from indiscriminate use of facial recognition, while the U.S. Constitution says nothing to that effect, and will not.
“In the U.S., if you’re moving around public spaces, there essentially is no right to privacy,” said Breyer, who was trained as a lawyer.
“Here, it’s the other way around: There is a basic right to data protection and informational self-determination, which means that every piece of data that’s collected and processed about us means an intrusion into our basic rights, and [law enforcement agencies] can only do that on a legal basis, and after being granted permission.”
Tech industry leaders are meanwhile seizing on the opportunity to shape any global rules that may emerge. In December 2018, Microsoft President Brad Smith unveiled principles for facial recognition regulations in a rare call to action from a leading industry figure. Amazon Web Services' public policy chief, Michael Punke, urged lawmakers to enact legislation that would both "protect civil rights while also allowing for continued innovation and practical application of the technology."
For now, though, face-scanning tools are rapidly becoming commonplace, embraced by the public and private sector alike.
Say goodbye to anonymity
At the same time, companies like Facebook, Apple and Google have built facial recognition into their most popular devices, for instance as a means of unlocking phones or automatically tagging friends in photos. Amazon has emerged as a top supplier of easy-to-use facial recognition systems, whose customers have included police departments and U.S. government agencies.
Among public authorities, the appetite for facial recognition systems seems to know no bounds. Across the United States, federal, state and local agencies have been conducting so-called experiments for years, with the Transportation Security Administration and U.S. Customs and Border Protection both use facial recognition at select points of entry. On the state and local levels, police departments in Florida, Colorado and Oregon have begun to adopt the technology, with others exploring its use.
The situation is no different in Europe. In the U.K., two police forces have been testing facial recognition technology to identify passersby in real time with street cameras. The French government has rolled out a facial-recognition-enabled ID card over protests from digital rights groups. Meanwhile, Hungary’s interior ministry is installing 35,000 cameras across its capital, Budapest, and the rest of the country to capture both facial images and license plates.
Facial recognition is already up and running at some European airports from Lisbon to Prague, where passengers from the EU and Switzerland can skip long lines by opting for an automated border control system scanning their faces.
"That’s worrying," said Matthias Monroy, a civil liberties activist who works for the leftist Die Linke party in the German parliament. Paired with the power of artificial intelligence and high-powered computing, such technology may soon “make it impossible to move around anonymously in a public space," he added.
‘Virtually unrestricted’
In the U.S., the debate around facial recognition has focused mainly on government's use of the technology. After the American Civil Liberties Union issued a report on Amazon's sale of its Rekognition software to police departments, San Francisco became the first city in the world to ban local agencies from using the technology, in a blueprint that activists hope will be replicated elsewhere.
That cause has also found a following in Washington, where a coalition of congressional Democrats and libertarian-leaning Republicans, worried about the implications of unchecked government surveillance, wants to restrict the use of facial recognition by federal agencies like the FBI, TSA and Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Leaders of the House Oversight Committee have explored a bill that would block funding for any new use or expanded use of the technology by the federal government, the panel’s top Republican told POLITICO in August.
“We don’t want any more money being used, no money used to expand what we have or to purchase any new ability to impact or use this technology,” Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) told POLITICO at the time. A “vast majority” of House Oversight Republicans still favor a federal timeout, Jordan said more recently, though he conceded that “I’ve been all focused all on impeachment.”
Before his death, then-committee chairman Cummings warned at a hearing last spring that under current law, the government can use the technology to “monitor you without your knowledge and enter your face into a database that could be used in virtually unrestricted ways.” He later called the issue “one of the few things that everybody, Democrats and Republicans, seem to agree on.”
The committee’s new chairwoman, Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.), has expressed a desire to revisit the issue but has not committed to pushing for a moratorium on federal use.
And even if such a proposal were to advance in the Democratic-controlled House, it would likely face opposition in the GOP-controlled Senate from moderate Republicans, many of whom see the emerging technology as a crucial law enforcement tool.
"I think that is unlikely to gain support in the Senate," Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.) told POLITICO this month when asked about the prospects of a moratorium.
Coons in November partnered with Sen. Mike Lee of Utah, a libertarian-leaning Republican, to introduce legislation requiring that federal agencies obtain a warrant before using facial recognition for targeted surveillance. But even more narrow proposals such as that bill, which has yet to pick up any additional co-sponsors, have failed to gain traction in the chamber to this point.
In Brussels, new European Commission leader Ursula von der Leyen has promised to take on facial recognition as part of a pledge to write binding rules for artificial intelligence during the first 100 days of her term in office, which started on Dec. 1.
That call coincides with a series of rulings from data protection authorities in various EU states, which have called for caution in deploying mainly "live" facial recognition and urged public authorities to draft legislation around its use. In the past few weeks, privacy watchdogs in Sweden, France and the United Kingdom have all issued position papers on the subject, with the French and Swedish regulators halting efforts to deploy facial recognition at the entrances to high schools.
However, the Commission’s road map for AI does does not necessarily mean any EU-wide rules on facial recognition will ever see the light of day. Despite promises to encode accepted practices in law, European officials have voiced a cacophony of opinions on what exactly the law on AI should contain, with high-ranking bureaucrats hinting that it may skew toward guiding principles instead of hard rules.
That is why it's likely that courts and data protection watchdogs will write those rules in Europe. In late August, a British court rejected the first major attempt to curtail police use of facial recognition, saying security benefits outweighed the risk to privacy and individual freedoms.
Legal experts expect European rules for facial recognition in law enforcement to come in the form of what’s known as “ex post” regulation: First, law enforcement will take advantage of existing legal gray zones and start deploying the technology — until either a judge or a data protection authority will restrict or stop that use, or rule that it conforms with existing law. Cases that could set such precedent are underway.
The result is an impasse that has left tech companies largely in control of where and how to deploy facial recognition.
By JANOSCH DELCKER and CRISTIANO LIMA
Face-scanning technology is inspiring a wave of privacy fears as the software creeps into every corner of life in the United States and Europe — at border crossings, on police vehicles and in stadiums, airports and high schools. But efforts to check its spread are hitting a wall of resistance on both sides of the Atlantic.
One big reason: Western governments are embracing this technology for their own use, valuing security and data collection over privacy and civil liberties. And in Washington, President Donald Trump’s impeachment and the death of a key civil rights and privacy champion have snarled expectations for a congressional drive to enact restrictions.
The result is an impasse that has left tech companies largely in control of where and how to deploy facial recognition, which they have sold to police agencies and embedded in consumers’ apps and smartphones. The stalemate has persisted even in Europe’s most privacy-minded countries, such as Germany, and despite a bipartisan U.S. alliance of civil-libertarian Democrats and Republicans.
Advocates for tighter regulations point to China as an example of the technology’s nightmare potential, amid reports authorities are using it to indiscriminately track citizens in public, identify pro-democracy protesters in Hong Kong and oppress millions of Muslim Uighurs in Xinjiang. Current implementations of the software also perpetuate racial bias by misidentifying people of color far more frequently than white people, according to a U.S. government study released just before Congress left town for Christmas.
“Facial recognition needs to be stopped before a fait accompli is established,” Patrick Breyer, a member of the European Parliament for the Pirate Party Germany, told POLITICO.
"The use of facial recognition technology poses a staggering threat to Americans’ privacy," Sen. Ed Markey (D-Mass.), who is prepping legislation to crack down on the software, said in June.
But police and security forces across the West are still rapidly testing or rolling out the technology, adopting it as an inexpensive way to keep tabs on large groups of people. Cameras and artificial intelligence that can identify people based on their facial features are also showing up at border crossings, on police vehicles, at the entrances to stadiums and even in some high schools in the U.S. and Europe, where they are used to identify students. Such examples far outnumber the facial recognition bans enacted in San Francisco and some other U.S. cities.
In Washington, a once-promising bipartisan push in the House of Representatives to limit the federal government's use of facial recognition has stalled for unrelated reasons, including the death of former House Oversight Chairman Elijah Cummings (D-Md.) and acrimony over impeachment. And in the Senate, more limited proposals to rein in federal agencies' use of the technology have been slow to pick up support.
But privacy activists are drawing a broader lesson from governments’ failure to check the technology’s spread, saying it is eroding the differences between the way Western governments and China approach public surveillance.
“There is growing evidence that the U.S. is increasingly using AI in oppressive and harmful ways that echo China’s use,” AI Now, a research group at New York University, wrote in a report published this month that underscored the spread of "invasive" artificial intelligence technology.
'Fundamental rights'
In both the U.S. and Europe, the stuttering progress of efforts to regulate facial recognition stems from a blend of reluctance by security-obsessed governments and setbacks that have stymied lawmakers’ focus.
The latter obstacles have included the death in October of Cummings, whose panel had seemed poised to craft bipartisan legislation restricting face-scanning by federal agencies. Several top Democrats and Republicans on the committee have also been embroiled in the monthslong dispute over Trump's impeachment and upcoming Senate trial.
Democratic and Republican lawmakers alike acknowledged in interviews with POLITICO that the effort has stalled.
"Unfortunately impeachment has sucked all the energy out of the room," Rep. Stephen Lynch (D-Mass.), who chairs the Oversight National Security Subcommittee, said this month.
"There hasn't been anything that's happened right now. … Elijah's death put that on hold," said Rep. Mark Meadows of North Carolina, the top Republican on the Oversight Government Operations Subcommittee.
In the European Union, meanwhile, calls by top leaders for quick action on regulating artificial intelligence aren’t guaranteed to result in any binding EU-wide restrictions.
Even the strict limits on gathering of “sensitive data" in the EU’s premier privacy rule, the General Data Protection Regulation, contain a broad carve-out for public authorities that can collect sensitive biometric data if they can justify it. That loophole has allowed facial recognition technology to pop up in locations such as a major Berlin train station, where an experimental project by the authorities has scanned tens of thousands of passersby.
Even so, Breyer said he is confident Europe will ultimately end up with stricter limits on facial recognition than the United States. The lawmaker argues that the EU’s Charter of Fundamental Rights, which grants every European citizen “the right to the protection of personal data concerning him or her,” will protect Europeans from indiscriminate use of facial recognition, while the U.S. Constitution says nothing to that effect, and will not.
“In the U.S., if you’re moving around public spaces, there essentially is no right to privacy,” said Breyer, who was trained as a lawyer.
“Here, it’s the other way around: There is a basic right to data protection and informational self-determination, which means that every piece of data that’s collected and processed about us means an intrusion into our basic rights, and [law enforcement agencies] can only do that on a legal basis, and after being granted permission.”
Tech industry leaders are meanwhile seizing on the opportunity to shape any global rules that may emerge. In December 2018, Microsoft President Brad Smith unveiled principles for facial recognition regulations in a rare call to action from a leading industry figure. Amazon Web Services' public policy chief, Michael Punke, urged lawmakers to enact legislation that would both "protect civil rights while also allowing for continued innovation and practical application of the technology."
For now, though, face-scanning tools are rapidly becoming commonplace, embraced by the public and private sector alike.
Say goodbye to anonymity
At the same time, companies like Facebook, Apple and Google have built facial recognition into their most popular devices, for instance as a means of unlocking phones or automatically tagging friends in photos. Amazon has emerged as a top supplier of easy-to-use facial recognition systems, whose customers have included police departments and U.S. government agencies.
Among public authorities, the appetite for facial recognition systems seems to know no bounds. Across the United States, federal, state and local agencies have been conducting so-called experiments for years, with the Transportation Security Administration and U.S. Customs and Border Protection both use facial recognition at select points of entry. On the state and local levels, police departments in Florida, Colorado and Oregon have begun to adopt the technology, with others exploring its use.
The situation is no different in Europe. In the U.K., two police forces have been testing facial recognition technology to identify passersby in real time with street cameras. The French government has rolled out a facial-recognition-enabled ID card over protests from digital rights groups. Meanwhile, Hungary’s interior ministry is installing 35,000 cameras across its capital, Budapest, and the rest of the country to capture both facial images and license plates.
Facial recognition is already up and running at some European airports from Lisbon to Prague, where passengers from the EU and Switzerland can skip long lines by opting for an automated border control system scanning their faces.
"That’s worrying," said Matthias Monroy, a civil liberties activist who works for the leftist Die Linke party in the German parliament. Paired with the power of artificial intelligence and high-powered computing, such technology may soon “make it impossible to move around anonymously in a public space," he added.
‘Virtually unrestricted’
In the U.S., the debate around facial recognition has focused mainly on government's use of the technology. After the American Civil Liberties Union issued a report on Amazon's sale of its Rekognition software to police departments, San Francisco became the first city in the world to ban local agencies from using the technology, in a blueprint that activists hope will be replicated elsewhere.
That cause has also found a following in Washington, where a coalition of congressional Democrats and libertarian-leaning Republicans, worried about the implications of unchecked government surveillance, wants to restrict the use of facial recognition by federal agencies like the FBI, TSA and Immigration and Customs Enforcement. Leaders of the House Oversight Committee have explored a bill that would block funding for any new use or expanded use of the technology by the federal government, the panel’s top Republican told POLITICO in August.
“We don’t want any more money being used, no money used to expand what we have or to purchase any new ability to impact or use this technology,” Rep. Jim Jordan (R-Ohio) told POLITICO at the time. A “vast majority” of House Oversight Republicans still favor a federal timeout, Jordan said more recently, though he conceded that “I’ve been all focused all on impeachment.”
Before his death, then-committee chairman Cummings warned at a hearing last spring that under current law, the government can use the technology to “monitor you without your knowledge and enter your face into a database that could be used in virtually unrestricted ways.” He later called the issue “one of the few things that everybody, Democrats and Republicans, seem to agree on.”
The committee’s new chairwoman, Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-N.Y.), has expressed a desire to revisit the issue but has not committed to pushing for a moratorium on federal use.
And even if such a proposal were to advance in the Democratic-controlled House, it would likely face opposition in the GOP-controlled Senate from moderate Republicans, many of whom see the emerging technology as a crucial law enforcement tool.
"I think that is unlikely to gain support in the Senate," Sen. Chris Coons (D-Del.) told POLITICO this month when asked about the prospects of a moratorium.
Coons in November partnered with Sen. Mike Lee of Utah, a libertarian-leaning Republican, to introduce legislation requiring that federal agencies obtain a warrant before using facial recognition for targeted surveillance. But even more narrow proposals such as that bill, which has yet to pick up any additional co-sponsors, have failed to gain traction in the chamber to this point.
In Brussels, new European Commission leader Ursula von der Leyen has promised to take on facial recognition as part of a pledge to write binding rules for artificial intelligence during the first 100 days of her term in office, which started on Dec. 1.
That call coincides with a series of rulings from data protection authorities in various EU states, which have called for caution in deploying mainly "live" facial recognition and urged public authorities to draft legislation around its use. In the past few weeks, privacy watchdogs in Sweden, France and the United Kingdom have all issued position papers on the subject, with the French and Swedish regulators halting efforts to deploy facial recognition at the entrances to high schools.
However, the Commission’s road map for AI does does not necessarily mean any EU-wide rules on facial recognition will ever see the light of day. Despite promises to encode accepted practices in law, European officials have voiced a cacophony of opinions on what exactly the law on AI should contain, with high-ranking bureaucrats hinting that it may skew toward guiding principles instead of hard rules.
That is why it's likely that courts and data protection watchdogs will write those rules in Europe. In late August, a British court rejected the first major attempt to curtail police use of facial recognition, saying security benefits outweighed the risk to privacy and individual freedoms.
Legal experts expect European rules for facial recognition in law enforcement to come in the form of what’s known as “ex post” regulation: First, law enforcement will take advantage of existing legal gray zones and start deploying the technology — until either a judge or a data protection authority will restrict or stop that use, or rule that it conforms with existing law. Cases that could set such precedent are underway.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


