Dems feel the need for speed in Trump oversight push
Court fights over congressional subpoenas often drag on for years.
By Josh Gerstein and Kyle Cheney
Democrats aren’t in power yet, but the clock on their ambitious oversight agenda — aimed squarely at President Donald Trump and his inner circle — is ticking.
For all the chest-thumping calls for Trump associates to “lawyer up,” it’s not lost on Democratic leaders that congressional oversight is often a slow, plodding process. They also know Trump has a track record of outlasting his investigators, both criminal and congressional. And the courts may not be much help.
Against that backdrop, Democrats know they need to launch their investigations quickly to have any chance to clear those hurdles while Trump remains in power.
“There is such a cesspool of corruption that they are swimming in that the subpoenas of the Trump administration will have to begin rather early,” Rep. Jamie Raskin (D-Md.), who is slated to chair the powerful House Judiciary Committee, said in an interview Monday.
It typically takes a month for a new Congress to set up committees, which must meet and establish rules, and engage their executive branch counterparts, before they can start issuing subpoenas. And by fall 2028, Congress is likely to be scarce as members return to the campaign trail and attention turns to the next presidential race. Congress’ two-year session is, functionally, more like an 18-month timeline for investigators.
When administration officials resist those subpoenas — as they’ve already indicated they’re likely to do — congressional Democrats will have to turn to the courts to enforce their demands. That is also a slow, laborious process.
“Look, there's just no simple way to enforce congressional subpoenas. This has been true forever,” said Stan Brand, who served as the House’s general counsel under Speaker Tip O’Neill. “There’s just no quick way to do it. …. This is not going to get resolved in court before a long period of curation.”
Jim Townsend, a former aide to Rep. Nita Lowey (D-N.Y.) and Sen. Frank Lautenberg (D-N.J.), said there’s a clear “mismatch” between Congress seeking to move quickly and the courts’ desire to largely stay out of such disputes.
“The picture is not very rosy for Congress when it comes to hoping that it can enforce its subpoenas to the courts in time to redeem its interest in the information,” Townsend added.
“The pace of litigation is incompatible with the political calendar,” said Sara Zdeb, a former Democratic Senate Judiciary Committee counsel and senior official in the Justice Department’s Office of Legislative Affairs during the Biden administration.
One of Democrats’ best bets to speed up the process may come from Trump’s vocal defiance.
White House counsel Will Scharf warned Democrats this week that their investigations could generate a criminal counter-investigation from the Trump administration. Democrats are certain to point to that letter as evidence that negotiation and compromise on their demands for information is not possible, and that the courts therefore must help them enforce subpoenas.
Raskin, in an interview that preceded the House’s receipt of the White House’s letter, said Democrats would allow for some period of negotiation but will be prepared to “lay down the law” if the White House drags its feet.
Examples are legion of congressional investigations bogging down in court. In 2011, House Republicans subpoenaed the Justice Department for details about Operation Fast and Furious, a gun-trafficking investigation that allegedly allowed thousands of weapons to cross the border from the U.S. into Mexico.
The demand led to President Barack Obama asserting executive privilege, Attorney General Eric Holder being held in contempt of Congress and the House suing to enforce its subpoena. The court battle dragged on for eight years, before being finally settled in 2019 — after Trump came into office.
A fight over the House’s 2019 demand for testimony from Trump’s first White House counsel, Don McGahn, as part of its Russiagate probe, spanned well over two years and could have evaporated completely if Republicans had won in 2020.
One of the biggest oversight battles in recent years also kicked off in April 2019, when House Democrats subpoenaed Trump’s financial and tax records from his longtime accountant, Mazars. Trump sued a week later, arguing that the subpoena was illegitimate.
The dispute reached the Supreme Court fairly quickly, with the justices issuing a ruling in July 2020 that found lower courts were too lax in scrutinizing Congress’ need for the records. The matter returned to lower courts and lingered for another two years before Trump and congressional Democrats negotiated a resolution.
The Supreme Court’s ruling in that case set out a complicated test for discerning when privacy concerns could outweigh lawmakers’ demands for a president’s personal information. That test could slow House Democrats’ efforts if they dig into the Trump family’s business dealings — as Rep. Robert Garcia, who is likely the next Oversight Committee chair, has pledged to do.
Some Democrats appear spring-loaded to escalate these fights almost immediately after they get the gavel in January.
Sen. Richard Blumenthal (D-Conn.), who’s expected to take over leadership of the Senate Homeland Security Committee’s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations, last week sent a flurry of demands for documents from Trump-linked crypto firms, donors to Trump’s White House ballroom project and administration officials.
Each letter carried an implicit threat that it will be backed by a subpoena if records aren’t immediately turned over by Jan. 4 — the day after the new Congress is sworn in.
Raskin said Democrats “have already heard from a whole bunch of whistleblowers. We have lots of tips about things happening” — which also could help speed up the process and focus committees’ time and resources.
Investigators are likely to focus much of their oversight on people, companies and institutions outside the federal government, in an effort to sidestep long and potentially losing legal battles over executive privilege.
“Private sector entities have fewer tools with which to slow down the process, and they have to be concerned about not only running afoul of Congress, but just simply their reputations in the public,” said Townsend, director of the Carl Levin Center for Oversight and Democracy at the Wayne State University Law School. “The notion that you can probably move more quickly with private sector witnesses and documents seems well founded.”
But the administration has already moved to preempt that strategy. DOJ is arguing that Trump enjoys a right to confidentiality even with advisers who are not government employees.
The administration also has some new ammunition it didn’t have during Trump’s first term: language in the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in the Trump criminal immunity case that appears to rule out demands for information relating to the president’s core powers.
Some Hill veterans have speculated about invoking Congress’ power to jail recalcitrant witnesses — power the Senate last exercised in 1934 and the House in 1916.
Despite some saber-rattling, lawmakers have been reluctant to use the arrest power for fear it would lead to a dangerous standoff between Congress and the executive branch. And it doesn’t really cut out the courts, since anyone who is arrested would almost certainly file a legal challenge to their detention.
Zdeb, now a law professor at Emory University, said Congress would be wise to try instead to use its other levers of power, like withholding confirmation of Trump nominees or holding back money for Trump priorities. Even under Republican control, the Senate has gotten creative: threatening to cut Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth’s travel budget by 75% if lawmakers don’t get information they’re demanding about Pentagon activities.
“For my money, appropriations and nominations are two of the most effective levers that Congress can pull to get information because they don't require any help from the courts,” Zdeb said. “In addition to moving swiftly to litigate, Congress can and should be pulling all of the levers at its disposal.”
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.