A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



February 02, 2016

Cruz on Bush

Bush congratulates Cruz on Iowa win

By Nolan D. McCaskill

Jeb Bush on Tuesday congratulated Ted Cruz on winning the Iowa caucuses but is viewing New Hampshire as an opportunity to “reset the race.”

“You know, I congratulate Ted Cruz for his victory,” Bush told “Fox & Friends.” “Hard-earned, well-fought and I congratulate him.”

Bush finished sixth in Iowa, with less than 3 percent support while earning one delegate. The former Florida governor is fourth in New Hampshire, according to a RealClearPolitics average of state polls. Bush has an average of 10.3 percent support — about 1 percent behind Ted Cruz and John Kasich, who are tied for second place, but about 1 percent ahead of Marco Rubio.

“Now we come to New Hampshire, where New Hampshire has a tendency to reset the race,” Bush said. “And I think what people are going to want is someone with a proven record, proven leader, someone who has detailed plans to fix the mess in Washington, and that’s my case here.”

New Hampshire will hold its first-in-the-nation primary next Tuesday.

Bernie

For Bernie, the revolution has begun

Aboard Bernie Sanders' campaign plane, the senator talks of taking "a giant step" forward. 

By Gabriel Debenedetti

Bernie Sanders’ campaign plane departed from Des Moines amid uncertainty over who exactly won the Iowa caucuses, but it didn’t matter to the candidate or his staff.

According to the candidate and his feisty gaggle of aides, the revolution had begun.

“I just wanted to thank the people of Iowa for giving us this opportunity to have a kickstart as we begin the campaign to take us to states throughout the country,” said a beaming, energetic Sanders at 3:30 a.m. Eastern Time, roughly an hour and a half into the flight at the end of the long day.

Echoing a line he also delivered to a cheering crowd back in Des Moines, Sanders declared “what Iowa has begun tonight is a political revolution.”

The scene would have been hard to imagine at the outset of his insurgent campaign. Flanked by his wife Jane, chief strategist Tad Devine, campaign manager Jeff Weaver, and communications director Michael Briggs, Sanders addressed a pack of reporters climbing over seats while juggling tape recorders at the back of his Eastern Airlines-branded jet.

When the 74-year-old Sanders addressed the mass of cameras and notebooks, he showed no signs of fatigue, even managing to muster his standard disdain for the process questions that followed a contest decided by a razor-thin margin.

As they flew over the Midwest in the airliner-sized charter destined for Manchester, New Hampshire, the Vermont senator and his exhausted top aides dismissed questions about whether the campaign was in it for the long-haul and, with a dose of swagger, insisted the campaign was newly energized.

His electability – and the long-term viability of his campaign -- has long been called into question by Clinton allies, and those questions only intensified after his performance on Monday. The senator has yet to prove he can win outside of states with demographics that match Vermont’s, the argument goes, making it unlikely he’ll gain traction with the minority-heavy and politically moderate Democratic bases in the states that vote after New Hampshire.

Fed up with that argument, Sanders said “tonight is a wonderful start-off to the national campaign.”

“As I’ve said many, many times, we’re taking this to the convention, and I think tonight shows the American people that this is a campaign that can win," he said.

That near-declaration of victory was an aggressive turn for a campaign that appeared weary in the final days before the caucuses, as polling showed Sanders trailing Clinton. Sanders had worked overtime to lower expectations about his Iowa performance, dismissing the idea that a loss by a few delegates would translate into a death blow for his campaign.

Sanders spoke after Weaver -- and before Jane Sanders took a few questions -- before being pulled back to the front of the plane.

“You know! Guys! We’re in this for the long haul,” the candidate laughed after he was asked whether anything short of a resounding win in New Hampshire would be enough to keep his campaign going. “We are going to win states all over this country. Please, don’t ask me after — gee, is your victory in Minnesota, if you don’t win Minnesota — we are in this to the convention. We’re gonna win some states, we’re gonna lose some states. But I think we now have shown the American people that we have confronted one of the very difficult issues that we face."

“I think that tonight we took a giant step to overcome that kind of doubt in many voters,” added sweater-clad senator, who had shed his tie between the speech and the flight.

On the flight, Weaver accused the Clinton camp of making a disingenuous move to game the results by declaring victory earlier in the evening before the results were clear.

"From our standpoint,” Weaver said, "staff going out like that at that particular moment was an attempt to manipulate the media into calling the race for Secretary Clinton before it had been decided so that they could then come out and give a victory speech in a climate where all the media was calling the race for her."

While Sanders was still in the air, the Clinton campaign came out with a definitive statement declaring victory -- with language designed to hem in the Sanders campaign and head off their anticipated pushback.

"Hillary Clinton has won the Iowa Caucus. After thorough reporting – and analysis – of results, there is no uncertainty and Secretary Clinton has clearly won the most national and state delegates,” said Clinton’s Iowa State Director Matt Paul. “Statistically, there is no outstanding information that could change the results and no way that Senator Sanders can overcome Secretary Clinton's advantage."

Sanders demurred when asked about the Clinton statement upon his arrival in New Hampshire.

“We're going to have to look a little more closely at the election results,” he said. “Honestly, we just got off the plane.”

Silent

Trump goes silent on Twitter

By Nolan D. McCaskill

By this time Monday, Trump had declared to his millions of Twitter followers, “WE WILL FINALLY TAKE OUR COUNTRY BACK AND MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN!” At a rally in Iowa just hours ahead of caucusing, he predicted a “tremendous victory.”

But in the end he was 2016's first big loser, 4 percentage points behind Cruz and just 1 point ahead of Marco Rubio, who tied Trump with seven delegates. And his Twitter feed, which boasts more than 30,000 tweets broadcast to his nearly 6 million followers, has been quiet for more than 14 hours.

As of 10 a.m. Tuesday, the political outsider known for speaking his mind hasn’t had anything to say since the caucuses concluded. The bombastic billionaire hasn’t cast a single retweet or made mention of a poll, called on voters to “Make America Great Again,” given a heads-up for TV appearances or an upcoming rally, or even thrown an attack or insult at the media. Trump’s last tweet encouraged Iowans to caucus and was sent Monday at 7:34 p.m.

Trump improvisation

How Trump Did It

It looks improvisational, but he planned this run for years, making a pipe dream look like a prophecy.

By Eli Stokols and Ben Schreckinger

What they heard as they ate deli sandwiches around Donald Trump’s hulking wooden conference table sounded like the businessman’s typical bravado. These 25 New York political operatives had come to ask him to run for governor. But Trump had another plan—a very specific plan—to run for president.

“You guys are going to be very helpful when I do the big thing,” he said, according to people who were in the room that day.

To the GOP county chairs and assemblymen there in Trump Tower’s glass-enclosed conference room overlooking Fifth Avenue and Central Park, Trump’s aspirations seemed far-fetched and the plan itself sounded downright implausible.

“He said, ‘I’m going to walk away with it and win it outright,’” a long-time New York political consultant recalled. “Trump told us, ‘I’m going to get in and all the polls are going to go crazy. I’m going to suck all the oxygen out of the room. I know how to work the media in a way that they will never take the lights off of me.’”

This gathering of New York’s political class was not held on the eve of Trump’s announcement. It was much earlier than that – 25 months ago, in the weeks before Christmas of 2013, a period well before most Americans and even many politicians were thinking about the 2016 presidential contest. Well before Trump would come to utterly dominate the GOP race from the very moment he declared himself a candidate.

In this meeting, Trump showed his cards, laying out the route he would take to tonight’s Iowa caucuses.

Notoriously frugal, Trump insisted he wouldn’t need to spend much money on paid advertising, drawing disbelief from the professionals gathered around his table.

“You can’t run for president on earned media,” one attendee recalled telling Trump.

The billionaire looked up, and paused for a long moment. “I think you’re wrong,” Trump said.

“Are you going to do all those little events at the Pizza Ranches?” another person asked, referring to the Iowa fast-food franchises that are a staple of presidential campaign stops.

“Maybe a little,” Trump replied. “But it’s really about the power of the mass audience.”

I’m going to get in and all the polls are going to go crazy. I’m going to suck all the oxygen out of the room. I know how to work the media in a way that they will never take the lights off of me.”

What sounded then like fantasy now looks like prophecy. Trump’s long-planned but largely improvisational campaign, propelled by a high-wattage personality, has him in position to win the Iowa caucuses, and perhaps steamroll his rivals on his way to the GOP nomination.

It couldn’t have worked for anyone else. Everything that explains the first-time candidate’s mind-blowing success—his uncanny ability to read and react to people and to bait his foes into positions of weakness, his eagerness to accept risk, and, above all, his ability to trust his gut to navigate the race while eschewing professional guidance—is the result of an entire career in the public spotlight and the ruthless worlds of New York real estate, media and politics.

“When he looks down his nose at the political consulting class, no wonder,” said veteran Republican pollster and Trump acquaintance Tony Fabrizio. “And I’m one of them!”

And yet, all Trump’s brash confidence obscures another truth: As much as he’s succeeded in consistently conveying confidence and strength, he, too, has been beset by the same uncertainty and self-doubt throughout the campaign that all candidates face.

COLD FEET

In the months before he entered the race, Trump’s then-advisers, Roger Stone and his young associate Sam Nunberg, proposed that the real estate developer and celebrity enter as late as possible, perhaps even skipping Iowa, and storm to the nomination a la Richard Nixon, who declared his candidacy for the 1968 Republican nomination on February 1 of that year.

Trump nixed that strategy in favor of a June entrance for two reasons. The first was that it would allow him to test the waters long enough to exit the race in time for the fall season of his reality show The Apprentice in case his campaign flopped.

The second was that Trump, an astute observer of the television industry, saw a news void he wanted to fill during the summer doldrums of the campaign — when most candidates are busy fundraising and building ground organizations.

But the entire thing almost didn’t get off the ground. A week before he took that slow escalator ride down from his office and into the presidential race, Trump was overwhelmed by what he was about to do. He got cold feet.

Trump was in Aberdeen, on the east coast of Scotland, to open a new clubhouse for one of his golf courses when he called the man who would soon be his campaign manager, Corey Lewandowski, and said he wasn’t sure he wanted to go through with it. He told Lewandowski he wanted to put the announcement off for two weeks, according to two people with knowledge of the conversation.

One Trump confidant described the episode as “last-minute stage fright.”

“He was all over the map,” said another Trump intimate. “Totally out; delay it; do some events in the early states, but not others.”

The call from Lewandowski’s mercurial new boss threw the operative — sitting back at Trump Tower in New York — for a loop, according to both Trump insiders. Lewandowski had uprooted from New Hampshire and been working since January to build Trump a campaign infrastructure, which included some of the earliest staff hires of any campaign-in-waiting in Iowa and New Hampshire.

But, just as he would when facing a tough decision in the months to come, Trump worked through his discomfort quickly. Whatever doubts plagued him in Scotland, by the time his plane returned home from the country of his mother’s birth, now just days before the planned announcement, Trump had resolved to push ahead. “How can I not give this a shot and let these politicians ruin the country?” a third confidant recalled an apprehensive Trump saying the day before he announced.

Lewandowski disputed this version of events, saying the June 16 launch date was decided on May 9 and that Trump never wavered from it.

Trump’s 2016 kickoff foreshadowed exactly how nontraditional his campaign would turn out to be.

Trump, according to those who have known him for years, has never relied on scripts, talking points or a teleprompter. During his 14 seasons on The Apprentice, Trump would tell producers, “I don’t work with scripts.” He was content to glance quickly at the bullet points on a notecard. “In these scenes for the show, it was very intimate and he’d be eye to eye, face to face with these contestants and looking to get reactions and reading their facial and emotional reactions,” said another Trump ally. “It’s what he does now, but just in front of larger crowds.”

On the day of his announcement, his staff distributed four pages of polished, prepared, remarks. In them, he stated he was running in the tenth sentence. But instead of following the plan, Trump spoke for 15 minutes before announcing, “I am officially running for president of the United States.”

In a moment that’s been scrubbed from Trump’s official video of the event, the house speakers began playing him off with Neil Young’s “Rockin’ in the Free World” before the real estate mogul signaled for the music to be cut off. Rather than leave the stage, he spoke off the cuff for another 30 minutes, and said: “When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.”

Trump didn’t foresee the furor his Mexico comments would generate; it was a reaction that built slowly and broke into a fever pitch in early July. But even if he didn’t predict what exactly would kick off the media frenzy, he had planned all along to offer the media a candidacy it couldn’t resist covering.

“Immigration was always at the top of everything he said,” one Trump confidant said. “He’d been saying it for years: ‘We need a wall, we have no borders, we don’t have a country.’ He was just incredulous about it.”

Cable networks were immediately riveted by Trump, whose every move was seemingly broadcast live. Hordes of cameras and reporters scrambled to follow him from one sensational campaign stop to the next, including a tour of the Mexican border at Laredo, Texas in July.

After weeks of dominating the political news cycle thanks to an uproar around his immigration comments, Trump sparked another controversy so large it had Republican leaders certain this would be the end of their unwelcome front-runner. After Fox News anchor Megyn Kelly asked Trump during a debate some tough questions about his penchant for insulting women, Trump shot back, saying Kelly chose that line of questioning because she “had blood coming out of her eyes, blood coming out of her…wherever.”

Like the Mexican controversy, Trump’s feud with Kelly and Fox was unplanned. But unlike with that first episode, his team was eager for him to walk it back. Lewandowski and Trump’s daughter, Ivanka, prepared memos outlining various ways to ease off the Kelly story. But Trump wouldn’t relent; he doesn’t do damage control.

“In all these cases, he’ll take the memos people put in his hands and listen to people’s comments, but he’s still going to do his own thing,” said a source close to Trump’s inner circle. “On some things, Corey is the last arbiter of charting the final course, but most of it is Donald.”

Trump had worked months earlier to establish what his team thought would be a strong, supportive relationship with the television network that has become so central to Republican messaging. Before his candidacy, he had been appearing regularly on Fox and enjoyed a friendly relationship with Fox News chief Roger Ailes. The two had dined together several times.

Trump and Lewandowski entered the race with an impression that Fox would be friendly to Trump’s candidacy, according to Republican consultant Cheri Jacobus, who entered into talks with the campaign for a communications role last spring.

At an interview at Trump Tower in May, Jacobus said Lewandowski predicted a rosy relationship with Fox and suggested Trump could eventually help her land a contract with the network. A source at Fox said Trump did not have any influence over such decision-making. “He basically indicated that their press strategy was Fox — that they had Fox. I said, ‘I don’t think Roger Ailes operates that way,’” said Jacobus, a longtime Fox guest. Instead, she responded that the network’s CEO gives individual hosts the freedom to go their own way.

Donald Trump’s visage hovers over the road, just north of a large shopping complex in West Des Moines, Iowa. The property owner, George Davey, declines to reveal whether or not he supports Trump. The sign divides viewers as much as the candidate does: Davey told the Des Moines Register that those who dislike Trump see the sign as a way of mocking the candidate, while Trump fans see it as supportive. Curious passersby left their footprints in the snow below the sign.

Donald Trump’s visage hovers over the road, just north of a large shopping complex in West Des Moines, Iowa. | M. Scott Mahaskey/POLITICO

According to Jacobus, Lewandowski countered by producing a printout of an email from Ailes to Trump, offering to be helpful in any way that he could. A source at the network said that it is not uncommon for Ailes to sign emails by offering a helping hand, but that it would be a mistake for that to ever be interpreted as helping a political candidate with editorial coverage. Lewandowski also told Jacobus that Trump would give his first big post-announcement interview on the network to the mogul’s friend, Bill O’Reilly. Jacobus said that move could miff Sean Hannity, who traditionally scored the first interview with candidates. Trump went ahead with his O’Reilly interview on the night of his announcement. Hannity brought Bush — at the time the much bigger get — on the same night.

The belief that Fox was supposed to be in his corner may have contributed to Trump’s vivid and enduring rage at Kelly for the tough questioning of him at the first debate.

Stone, a close confidant of Trump’s for 30 years, departed the campaign in the aftermath of the candidate’s suggestion that Kelly asked tough questions because she was menstruating, giving Trump's comments as his reason for leaving. But those who know Stone said the operative was also frustrated by a general lack of influence with a candidate who served as his own chief adviser.

“He is his own strategist. He is his own message maven. He is his own publicist,” Stone, who has continued to serve as a surrogate, said of Trump.

CALCULATED BLUSTER

That the media saturation was driven by controversies that led to widespread condemnation of Trump in the mainstream press and by pillars of the Republican Party didn’t matter to Trump. His team knew that the more Republican voters got to see of Trump the politician, the more they would like him.

They knew because they’d studied the polls.

When Trump first surged to the top of the Republican pack just weeks after his announcement, pundits pointed to Trump’s terrible favorability numbers to argue that his support had a hard ceiling and that other candidates would overtake him when the sprawling 17-member Republican field thinned. Indeed, Trump walked into the contest with a poll showing only 16 percent of Republicans viewed him favorably while 65 percent viewed him unfavorably.

But when Trump touched off controversy, his favorability skyrocketed, and by mid-July that same ABC/Washington Post poll found that 57 percent of Republicans viewed him favorably.


If you don’t have the same risk tolerance, he’s got you beat before you’re even in the game.”

It was an unprecedented jump. “I’ve never seen a candidate who’s so well-known who was able to suddenly turn around people’s opinions of him,” Monmouth University’s director of polling, Patrick Murray, told Politico last summer.

Pollsters were dumbfounded. Trump wasn’t. He had been testing his ability to turn his favorability numbers around for four months already. His team studied a PPP poll from February 2014 that showed Trump’s favorability rating 21 points underwater with Iowa Republicans. But by April, as he made appearances and courted local politicians while testing the waters ahead of a formal announcement, he had pulled even.

Trump’s team, said one insider, knew that “once you approached the national media it would work that way as well.”

And it has.

Not apologizing has only bolstered a candidate who appeals to voters fed up with political correctness and establishment niceties. Many of Trump’s most controversial statements and proposals, in fact, have been validated by the polls. And just as significant as the media oxygen they’ve sucked up, Trump’s most outrageous comments have baited his opponents into reactions he has strategically exploited.

It was, for instance, Trump saying that Hillary Clinton got “schlonged” in losing the 2008 Democratic primary and his calling her “disgusting” for using the bathroom during a debate that prompted her to call out his “sexism.” That, in turn, is what he cited as his reason for focusing again on Bill Clinton’s sex scandals, which he claimed are “fair game” because Hillary was attacking him.

His proposed ban on Muslim immigrants after the ISIL-coordinated attacks in Paris and San Bernardino drew condemnation from many of his rivals and top Republican leaders in Washington for going “too far” and being antithetical to “American values.” But for many primary voters suddenly fearful of the real possibility of more terrorist attacks on American soil, it was those other candidates who didn’t seem willing to go far enough to keep them safe.

“Most campaigns aren’t so secure as to make such declarative statements or shrewd enough to understand where it’s going to go,” said an operative close to the Trump campaign. “If you don’t have the same risk tolerance, he’s got you beat before you’re even in the game because you’re not willing to risk the way he is. These other guys—they have a lot more to lose than he does. They’re afraid to take the stands he does.”

“No one is going to out-Trump Trump,” this insider said.

Trump has been confident of that much all along.

Asked by Politico in July whether he thought Hillary Clinton or Jeb Bush would be a worse president, the mogul paused in the back seat of his black SUV at the Texas-Mexico border and said only, “Trump will be the best president.”

Palin explodes...

Palin explodes at 'Today' show hosts

By Eliza Collins

Sarah Palin went off on the hosts of NBC's “Today” show on Monday after being asked about comments she made at a Donald Trump rally that seemed to blame President Barack Obama for her son’s post-traumatic stress disorder.

“I want to ask you about something you said on the campaign trail, which is the arrest of your son Track. And you talked about it and you mentioned PTSD and you said that President Obama may be to blame for some of the PTSD that’s out there,” host Savannah Guthrie said.

“I never said that, I never said that,” the former Alaska governor interrupted.

“Let’s take it piece by piece and talk about exactly what you mean,” Guthrie said.

“You guys brought me here to talk about Iowa politics and the caucus tonight not to talk about my kids,” Palin shot back. "And that was a promise. But as things go in the world of media, you guys don't always keep your promises, evidently.”

Palin said she never blamed Obama for PTSD, although she acknowledged that she has blamed him for problems related to military budgets in the past.

After endorsing Trump last month, Palin was speaking at a rally just days after her son was arrested for domestic violence charges.

“I can talk personally about this. I guess it’s kind of the elephant in the room — because my own family, going through what we’re going through today with my son, a combat vet having served in a Stryker brigade fighting for you all, America, in the war zone. But my son, like so many others, they come back a bit different. They come back hardened,” Palin said.

“It’s a shame that our military personnel even have to question, have to wonder if they’re respected anymore. It starts from the top," she continued. "The question, though, it comes from the top, the question, though, that comes from our own president where they have to look at him and wonder, ‘Do you know what we go through? Do you know what we’re trying to do to secure America and to secure the freedoms that have been bequeathed us?'"

In Monday's interview, Palin was pressed on whether she regretted the comments, and she responded, “What did I say that is offensive?”

“I don’t regret any comment that I made, because I didn’t lay PTSD at the foot of the president,” she said.

Later in the show, host Matt Lauer clarified that there had not been any specific promises made before Palin did the interview, which was her first since the endorsement.

Bush worse than expected...

Bush's Iowa performance is even worse than expected

Campaign instructs aides to argue Bush has greater potential in New Hampshire.

By Daniel Strauss and Alex Isenstadt

The bar was low for Jeb Bush's finish in Monday's Iowa caucus. He failed to clear it anyway.

After a blowout defeat that landed him in sixth place with just 2.8 percent of the vote, Bush's campaign is now directing top aides and surrogates to highlight the lack of emphasis the one-time front-runner placed on the state – and to make the case that he has far higher expectations in New Hampshire.

“The real race for the nomination begins on February 9th in New Hampshire,” the campaign wrote in a “talking points” memo sent to advisers and high-profile supporters. “It will set the race going forward and today, Jeb Bush is in a very strong position in the state.”

It goes on to add: “The Jeb 2016 campaign has never made Iowa a centerpiece to winning the nomination. We have long viewed Iowa as just one of 56 contests, electing 30 delegates out of 2,472 going to the Convention to select our nominee.”

Surrogates are then reminded that in November a “strategic decision” was made to “shift resources away from Iowa.” Bush’s time in Iowa, it notes, was “significantly scaled back.” In December and January, it says, Bush “went 40 days without visiting Iowa.”

Bush rival Marco Rubio, meanwhile, “invested far more significantly in” the state.

The memo identifies New Hampshire as “better terrain” for the former governor, and it provides extensive historical detail for why it’s a far better barometer of who goes on to win the nomination than Iowa.

Bush has more than 40 paid campaign staff across five offices in New Hampshire. The memo points to a series of recent favorable polls and high profile endorsements, and notes that “we have the largest voter contact effort in the state.”

“With a field unprecedented in its depth and size, we don’t expect Iowa to be a factor in winnowing the field,” the memo concludes. “By contrast, New Hampshire has a much stronger record of indicating the eventual Republican nominee. The Republican Party’s previous two nominees lost Iowa and won New Hampshire.”

Bush came in behind Sen. Ted Cruz, Donald Trump, Sen. Marco Rubio, Ben Carson and even Sen. Rand Paul. He inched past John Kasich, Carly Fiorina, Mike Huckabee, Chris Christie and Rick Santorum.

Such a Bush finish once seemed impossible. The former Florida governor made a thunderous entry into the race last year, and he made a splash in Iowa as well, assigning David Kochel, a top GOP operative with strong ties to Iowa, to help lead the effort there. But he never captured voter enthusiasm like Cruz and Trump did, and he struggled mightily in the first handful of GOP debates.

For Bush, the best thing about the Iowa caucuses is that they're over, and now the campaign moves to New Hampshire, where Bush has concentrated his efforts. Further complicating his efforts, however, is a strong finish from Rubio. As the GOP establishment looks for a candidate to beat back Cruz and Trump, Bush will have to convince them that he is a better standard bearer than a rival, who bested him by around 20 percentage points.

"I think it’s a very rough night for all of the Establishment candidates. I wrote earlier this week that finishing in 6th or worse makes getting to New Hampshire a difficult slog and severely dents the aura of viability," GOP operative Reed Galen said Monday night of the Iowa returns so far.

Christian Ferry, who served as Sen. Lindsey Graham's presidential campaign manager before the South Carolina senator dropped out, brushed off the results and the prospect of Bush ending up near the end of the pack in Iowa. "I think voters in New Hampshire don't normally too much about what happens in Iowa," Ferry said.

O'Malley out....

Martin O'Malley suspends bid for the Democratic nomination

By Gabriel Debenedetti

Former Maryland governor Martin O’Malley suspended his campaign after a dismal showing in Iowa’s caucuses on Monday.

O’Malley never caught on, consistently polling in the single digits nationally and in the early voting states since launching his campaign in May.

A data-driven manager during his tenure in Maryland, he aimed to play the true progressive in the race but lost that role to Bernie Sanders. Similarly, O’Malley couldn’t escape the shadow of 2008, when he was one of Hillary Clinton’s most dogged supporters and surrogates.

His best moments on the campaign trail instead came when he was railing against the party’s leadership over its debate schedule, which he said was designed to protect Clinton.

And while he occasionally showed flashes of potential during Democratic Party events in both Iowa and New Hampshire, O’Malley’s pitch that he is the candidate for the next generation failed to spark the enthusiasm he needed to build a real base of support, even when he tried tying himself to President Barack Obama’s legacy.

Huckabee out....

Mike Huckabee suspends his 2016 campaign

By Daniel Strauss

Mike Huckabee suspended his bid for the Republican nomination, ending a second run that overshadowed by other candidates in the former Arkansas governor’s social-conservative lane.

Huckabee’s announcement concludes a campaign that was not nearly as prominent as his previous run at the Republican nomination in 2008, where he won eight states, including the Iowa caucus.

In 2016, Huckabee struggled to consistently stay on the main stage in Republican presidential debates, never raised more than $15 million at one time, and failed to rally the same evangelical support he won in his last presidential run. One of the most conspicuous blows to his campaign came when Bob Vander Plaats endorsed Sen. Ted Cruz, denying Huckabee a critical ally in the contest to win over Iowa’s evangelicals.

Internally, Huckabee’s team suffered staffing bumps. In December 2015 Alice Stewart, Huckabee’s communications director, departed due to divergent visions with other staffers on the direction of the campaign and the press shop. Stewart, like Vander Plaats, joined up with Cruz.

Near the end of Huckabee’s campaign, amid lackluster polling nationally (he never averaged at 10 percent nationally) and in all of the early primary states, he opted to throw all of his chips in in Iowa, cutting the salaries of senior staff and directing most of the campaign’s team and resources to a last ditch push there. Huckabee and Sarah Huckabee Sanders, the former governor’s daughter and campaign manager, said that if he didn’t perform well there the campaign was unlikely to continue.

5 takeaways

5 takeaways from the Iowa caucuses

Cruz outfoxed Trump, Clinton showed her soft underbelly, and Rubio flashed greatness.

By Glenn Thrush

Here’s one little 2016 tradition that should bite the dust after Monday night: Donald Trump’s giddy recitation of the public polling showcasing his supremacy over the lesser, more vulnerable candidates in his party.

The Iowa polls — which showed him with a big edge in Monday’s caucuses — turned out to be worse than meaningless, and the bully billionaire nearly slipped to third place behind Ted Cruz and a suddenly surging Marco Rubio. Trump is not exactly known for his shame — but he isn’t keen on ridicule, so he’ll have to figure out some other way to while away the time at his big rallies, if the rallies aren’t quite as well attended as they were before he became, well, a loser.

Here are five other takeaways from the eventful and unexpected Iowa caucuses that have shifted the dynamics of the 2016 race in both parties.

1. Meet Ted Cruz, your new front-runner. The Texas tea party favorite has run a nearly flawless three-step campaign: 1) Keep out of Trump’s way to avoid the incessant abuse; 2) quietly marshal the support of evangelical voters; and 3) offer targeted attacks on Trump late in the caucus campaign to let voters know you can’t be bullied.

Cruz faced a moment of truth last week when a wily Trump picked a phony fight with Fox to take a powder on the last pre-Iowa debate. At the time, this seemed like a tactically canny maneuver — in his absence, the other candidates savaged Cruz on immigration and other issues. But his controversial attack on Trump’s “New York values” — while roundly criticized by the media — hit the mark with Great Plains religious conservatives, and he eked out an impressive 28 percentto 24 percent win over the heavily favored developer.

2. Hillary Clinton isn’t a very good presidential candidate. Bernie Sanders looks like a septuagenarian physicist caught in a wind tunnel and happily espouses a theory of big-government democratic socialism that had been thought forever killed during the Reagan years. But he understands, with a Cruz-like ear for his party’s base, that the politics of grievance are the politics that will succeed — at least in a primary in state like Iowa, where 43 percent of voters self-identify as “socialists.”

Yet whatever virtues Sanders possesses, it’s hard to discount the role Clinton’s political ineptitude — and tin ear — played in his rapid rise. President Barack Obama charitably described her to me as “rusty” when she first began campaigning in mid-2015. The problem for Clinton is that she’s never quite stripped away the rust .

It’s ironic that she rails against the big drug companies, because there are times when a Clinton speech sounds like a read-aloud pharmaceutical disclaimer — with policy proposal piled upon policy proposal with parsimonious dollops of anecdote or personal revelation. Sanders is no Lincoln, but his spiel is sharply focused on income inequality and is seductively simple enough for any progressive, no matter how uninterested in politics, to understand.

3. Marco’s the man. Ted Cruz is the guy who may have put a 2-by-4 to Trump but Marco Rubio, who came within 2 percentage points of making the domineering developer into a third-place also-ran, might turn out to be the real long-term winner. Until Iowa, he was a talented but electorally rootless political prodigy who seemed to own no particular state or wedge of the Republican electorate, a perpetual No. 3 everywhere and on every subject.

Now he’s No. 3 with a bullet. On Monday, the boyish and policy-focused Florida senator came close to doubling his predicted finish in Iowa — with much of his 23 percent support poached (unexpectedly) from Trump’s tally. In doing so, he established himself as (in the eyes of many party elders and himself) the Republican with the most potential crossover appeal in a general election.

4. Hey Bernie, have fun in New Hampshire! Clinton’s slim but apparently legally validated victory in Iowa — coupled with Sanders’ seemingly insurmountable lead in his neighboring New England state — means that the Clinton campaign is likely to quietly shift resources (and candidate time) to Nevada and South Carolina.

The candidate, according to a person in her orbit, has told her staff that she wants to replicate her 2008 comeback in New Hampshire — but it doesn’t make a ton of political sense: Public polling has the Vermont senator up by as much as 25 percent (Clinton’s own internals show him up by approximately half that margin) — and a resounding win over Sanders in two states with substantial Hispanic (Nevada) and black (South Carolina) voting populations is more important than a quixotic quest. And this seems to be a major difference in Clinton’s approach in 2016 — she’s more pragmatic, and less prone to take on a fight in a state she’s unlikely to win.

5. Trump and Rubio are on a collision course. So far, Rubio has pursued a nonconfrontational approach to Trump — in hopes of goading the once (and perhaps future) front-runner into attacking Cruz. But that was before Rubio invaded Trump’s turf — and very nearly shoved the man who was supposed to win Iowa handily into third place. Trump — a practiced, if sometimes nervous, debater — will certainly go after him and Rubio had better be ready.

Trump looses but also wins...

Donald Trump, 2016's first loser

The billionaire’s unsophisticated, shoe-string campaign catches up with him. 

By Ben Schreckinger and Kenneth P. Vogel

Donald Trump wakes up Tuesday as a loser.

Now, will it matter?

After dominating the Republican race and predicting a win in Monday’s caucuses, Trump looks to New Hampshire with his veneer of invincibility shattered and fresh proof that winning in the polls does not prevent losing when it matters.

Even as his team expressed confidence about next week’s primary, Republican operatives and Trump allies saw what his critics had long predicted — a campaign that was not equipped to capitalize on its candidate’s popularity and momentum. Now they expect polls to tighten in New Hampshire and for the loss to take a psychological toll on supporters of a contender who has sold himself as the ultimate winner.

“Tonight showed that Trump is mortal and his strategy of hyping himself has the potential to backfire,” said Republican operative Ryan Williams, a former Mitt Romney aide, speaking from New Hampshire.

Roger Stone, a longtime political adviser to Trump who left the campaign in August, said Trump had the supporters, but he couldn’t make them caucus-goers. “Trump created a large enough pool of people to win the Iowa caucuses and unfortunately his campaign was unable to convert them to voters.”

Stone noted that Trump’s vote total underperformed his polling numbers. Meanwhile, Ted Cruz’s vaunted get-out-the vote operation pulled through. Trump’s campaign manager, Corey Lewandowski, his Iowa state director, Chuck Laudner, and his national co-chair, Sam Clovis, an Iowa activist, did not respond to requests for comment.

Multiple GOP operatives said the loss reflects a lack of sophistication and political know-how in Trump’s organization. “Tonight’s results … should have showed Team Trump that shooting from the gut all the time only gets you so far and that there is a real value to professionals who have been through this rodeo before,” said Republican pollster Tony Fabrizio, an adviser to several presidential campaigns, including Rand Paul’s this cycle.

Trump’s camp didn’t start actively building a data operation to assemble voter targeting models until October ― giving Cruz and other candidates a head start of several months on the type of costly and intensive analytics used to power modern turnout operations.

Even then, Trump’s forces did not act with urgency, waiting until late November or early December to sign an agreement allowing it to use the Republican National Committee’s massive voter file. The RNC initially offered its file to Trump not long after he declared his candidacy in June, and it’s unclear what caused the delay in executing the agreement.

Most of his rivals’ campaigns had signed similar agreements months earlier and spent heavily to build teams of staffers and consultants who could enhance and manipulate the data to power their voter outreach and mobilization efforts. Cruz’s campaign, for instance, in the last three months of 2015, racked up $3.6 million in bills from a data firm called Cambridge Analytica that builds what it calls “psychographic” profiles of voters to try to win them over with narrowly targeted micro-messages. Sources say the firm, which is owned by one of Cruz’s biggest donors, has embedded multiple staffers within the campaign to work with a substantial in-house data operation.

A source said the Trump campaign balked at the price tag associated with Cambridge Analytica’s services.

Instead, Trump’s data shop is headed by a pair of low-profile former RNC data engineers, Matt Braynard and Witold Chrabaszcz, who are regarded as technically savvy but who do not have previous high-level campaign experience. And, while Trump’s team late last year entered into an agreement with the political data outfit L2, the campaign has paid the firm only $235,000 for “research consulting” through the end of 2015, the period covered by the most recent Federal Election Commission reports.

Trump’s reports show that his self-funded campaign has spent relatively little on voter data or outreach. They showed $200,000 in list rental payments to the conservative Newsmax Media, and $47,000 to Targeted Victory, a leading GOP digital firm, as well as $700,000 on field staff and consultants.

By contrast, the campaign has spent at least $1.2 million on hats ― presumably mostly for the now-iconic hats bearing Trump’s campaign slogan “Make America Great Again.”

But the defeat exposed not just the deficiencies of Trump’s infrastructure, but also the risks of his “I’m a winner” message as well.

“You can’t get up on stage, wave around polls and push some halfhearted spin when you lose that you weren’t supposed to win,” said Williams.

Williams said Trump’s easing off that bravado in his concession speech was the right move, as did Republican strategist Henry Barbour, a strident critic of Trump. “No doubt polls will tighten, but Trump post-caucus comments were gracious and that’s a good start,” said Barbour.

Trump’s supporters, gathered in a ballroom at the Sheraton Hotel here, expressed anxiety as results showed Cruz’s lead holding throughout the night, and booed when CNN projected Cruz would win.

But Trump’s circle, from the candidate on down, expressed confidence that New Hampshire and South Carolina, where the businessman’s leads in polls are larger and where turnout operations matter less, would be kinder to their candidate.

“New Hampshire will be the beginning of Trump’s momentum,” said a close ally of Trump and his campaign. “He’s led in New Hampshire for months. He showed well in a state no one thought he could do well in, and only in the last three days did polls show him coming on. This is not a surprise.” Added the Trump ally: “Can’t wait to get to the South.”

“Voting will be more universal. New Hampshire and South Carolina are less of an organization-driven effort and more of a message-driven effort. I actually think that Trump closed the gap some at the end,” said Stone, citing both public polling and internal polls from other campaigns that he has reviewed.

Another former Trump adviser, Sam Nunberg, tweeted, “Chuck Laudner did an amazing job for @realDonaldTrump. He is an outstanding organizer and pulled off a miracle with 40K+ votes.#YUGE” and “If anyone told me Mr. @realDonaldTrump would have received 40K IA caucus votes a year ago I would have said you're crazy. Mr. Trump won!”