A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



February 28, 2018

Profoundly affect

A Supreme Court Ruling Against Unions Would Hit Black Women Hardest

The decision could profoundly affect “the livelihoods of millions of individuals…all at once.”

ELI DAY

On Monday, the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Janus v. AFSCME, a case that could kneecap public-sector union funding if the court rules in the plaintiff’s favor. Union opponents have celebrated the case for targeting the financial heart of the labor movement. Beyond the lively legal arguments, some labor supporters have noted that an unfavorable decision for unions would disproportionately affect women and people of color.

The legal team for Mark Janus, an Illinois state employee who is represented by the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, is arguing that the required fee he pays to the union for bargaining on his behalf violates his First Amendment rights. If the Supreme Court rules in Janus’s favor, it will undo the precedent in the 1977 case Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, in which the court ruled unanimously that public employees who disagree with the union representing them are not denied their right to free speech.

During Monday’s arguments, the court’s liberal justices raised flags about how reversing a 40-year-old precedent would affect the livelihoods of millions of workers. Justice Sonia Sotomayor observed that the arguments against union fees were essentially no different from ones to “do away with unions.” And Justice Elana Kagan cautioned, “This is a case in which there are tens of thousands of contracts with these provisions. Those contracts affect millions of employees, maybe as high as 10 million employees.” About five million workers in 24 states are currently covered by the “fair-share” fees at the heart of the case.

If the court’s conservative justices rule against the union, it will hurt some workers more than others. In an amicus brief, the National Women’s Law Center and dozens of other groups “committed to civil rights and economic opportunity” argue that unions have been a vital tool for shrinking economic inequality for women and people and color: “Unions are associated with smaller wage gaps related to gender and race in part because they promote transparency in criteria and decisions on compensation, recruitment, and promotions. Gender-based wage gaps persist throughout the economy, but the wage gap for union members is 53 percent smaller than the wage gap among non-union workers.” The brief goes on to argue that union benefits like pensions, health insurance, and paid leave are especially important for women and people of color, who face greater vulnerability in the labor market.

The Economic Policy Institute, a liberal think tank, says that unionized black women would suffer the most from an anti-union decision in Janus. Black women make up a disproportionate share of public employees (18 percent, or roughly 1.5 million workers). Despite their ugly histories of racist exclusion, unions have emerged as a key vehicle for collapsing the vast inequality between black women and the rest of the workforce. According to the NWLC, black women who belong to unions make 30 percent more than those who don’t. And while black women earn 65 cents for every dollar earned by white men, that wage gap is 20 percent smaller for unionized black women.

Justice Kagan acknowledged the significant real-world impact of this case, which could be decided this summer. Ruling against the union, she cautioned, would not only challenge laws across several states, but would affect “the livelihoods of millions of individuals…all at once. When have we ever done something like that?”

Leg 6 of the Volvo Ocean Race

VOR 6

From Sailing Anarchy

Leg 6 of the Volvo Ocean Race was one of snakes and ladders and it all came down to a nail-biting finish in the dead of night in Auckland, New Zealand. Despite the ungodly hour the City of Sails, as Auckland bills itself, was out in force to greet the sailors and to cheer on leg winner AkzoNobel. It’s the first leg win for the Dutch  team and well deserved. They fought off not only Team Sun Hung Kai Scallywag who finished a scant two minutes behind them, but the rest of the chasing pack that was closing fast.

A ridge of high pressure off the northeast coast of New Zealand stalled the progress of the leaders, but the lead that the two front boats had established was enough of a buffer to fend off third place MAPFRE who finished 22 minutes astern of AkzoNobel. The tension on Waitematā Harbour must have been palpable, but AkzoNobel were the deserved winners and may I say, since I have been criticized for not saying this before, that Team Sun Hung Kai Scallywag sailed a brilliant race to finish second.  “It’s been a 6,500-mile match race,” said Simeon Tienpont, the skipper of AkzoNobel. “I’ve never sailed a race like this in my life. We’ve always been in each other’s sights. They were always there. It’s been neck and neck. Huge respect to Scallywag, they never stopped fighting and we never stopped defending. I’m so proud of our crew. They never flinched.”

It was a bold move early on in the leg that gave AkzoNobel and Scallywag a break. They spotted some weather that the others hadn’t seen, or perhaps deemed too risky to go after, and the gamble gave them the shot in the arm they needed to jump into the lead. At times the Hong Kong team on Scallywag were in front and at other times it was AkzoNobel in a cat and mouse game that must have caused more than few grey hairs on both boats. They were able to hold onto the lead through the doldrums and even into an unusual patch of calm weather in the South Pacific caused by Cyclone Gita which literally sucked the wind out of a thousand mile area.

After days of tedious sailing there was a sudden charge by Dee Caffari and her crew on Turn the Tide on Plastic and the other Dutch entry, Team Brunel who jetted to the front of the pack sailing just a couple of miles apart, but in the dark of night Caffari and company found their own private wind lane and took off to establish a 20 mile lead. It wouldn’t last, however, as the new breeze finally filled and gave AkzoNobel and Scally a boost that pushed them back into the lead.

The last 24 hours of the race must have been the most nail-biting. The east coast of New Zealand has stunning scenery but it’s also a minefield of potholes where any one of the boats could have parked up, but they didn’t. The most surprising performance was that turned in by the Spanish team MAPFRE. They had been languishing at the back of the pack for much of the leg. Two days ago they were well over a 100 miles behind, but skipper Xabi Fernández is nothing if not persistent and add to that he is a brilliant strategist and when the counting was done MAPFRE took the last spot on the podium.

Auckland is an absolutely awesome place for a stopover. The public is sailing crazy and revere the Volvo Ocean Race sailors as their sporting hero’s. On my first Whitbread back in ’82 I took some time off to get as far away from the water as possible. I rented a room in a farm house in the middle of the North Island thinking that the farmer and his wife would never have heard of the Whitbread. I could not have been more wrong.

When I arrived I saw that the farmer had a huge chart on his wall and that he had been plotting the daily positions of all the boats, such was their fanatic love of sailing. The Volvo Ocean Race sailors are going to bask in sailing heaven for a couple of weeks to recharge their souls before the next ball breaking leg around Cape Horn to Itajaí in Brazil.

– Brian Hancock.

Hide a submarine...

Congress tries to hide a submarine

Inside the fight to take a $90 billion ship program off the Navy's books.

By MICHAEL GRUNWALD

America’s next generation of nuclear submarines are supposed to have stealth capabilities. But at $5 billion a pop, they’re hard to hide in a budget.

That doesn’t mean Congress can’t try.

 When the House of Representatives debates its 2016 defense spending bill next week, there will be a floor battle over an arcane gimmick designed to keep these subs of the future –the Navy’s most expensive shipbuilding program ever - out of the Navy’s shipbuilding budget. It’s not a partisan or an ideological fight, just a bit of Washington gamesmanship that in another context might not be particularly noteworthy, except that it involves Pentagon-sized sums of money, and could have a major impact on Pentagon spending down the road.

The dispute has its roots in the Navy’s need for a lethal replacement for its Ohio-class submarines, which were built in the 1970s and still carry a big chunk of America’s nuclear arsenal under the seas. As the subs approach retirement age, the Navy is gearing up to build their 21st-century successors, which the Congressional Budget Office has estimated will end up costing taxpayers more than $90 billion. That’s more than three decades worth of funding for all of America’s national parks, or about three times the annual Iranian defense budget.

The problem is how to pay for it. In last year’s defense authorization bill, Congress created the National Sea-Based Deterrence Fund, a new Pentagon account for the spiffy new subs. The Navy normally pays for new vessels out of its own shipbuilding account, but as the House Armed Services committee warned in its official rationale for the fund last year, the new sub program “threatens to crowd out all other Navy shipbuilding resources.”

The fund’s sponsor, Rep. Randy Forbes (R-Va.), who represents a region stocked with naval shipyards and chairs the Seapower and Projection Forces subcommittee on Armed Services, argued that nuclear-armed subs are really national assets, not Navy assets, so they shouldn’t drain the Navy budget. “You’re talking about the nuclear triad,” Forbes told me. “This is 70 percent of our deterrence capability. It’s a national thing.”

Wait a minute. Why exactly would the subs serve a more “national” function than land-based intercontinental missiles, or the Air Force bombers that carry nukes through the air—or, for that matter, Army infantry units or overseas military bases or anything else the Pentagon controls? One supportive House aide suggested to me that the underwater drama of Hunt for Red October demonstrated the unusual nature of nuclear-armed subs, but there are plenty of dramatic military films that haven’t inspired expansive new line items.

Nobody can say precisely where the money for the new fund would end up coming from—whether it would be diverted from other military functions, like special operations and even commissaries that are also funded through Pentagon-wide accounts, or whether it would simply be added to military spending once the budget caps imposed by the 2013 “sequester” are relaxed. But either way, it would be real money, not just a quirk of congressional bookkeeping.

“What a crock!” said Steve Ellis, vice president of Taxpayers for Common Sense. “Let’s face it: Every weapons system the Pentagon buys is a national asset. This is just a shell game to try to avoid tough choices about the Navy budget.”

 In part, the dispute reflects an age-old Capitol Hill rivalry pitting authorizing committees like Armed Services, which establish rules and funding limits for various programs, against the appropriations committees, which dole out the cash. Appropriators tend to resist when authorizers try to limit their power and flexibility. For example, the latest authorizing language would empower the defense secretary to divert unspent money from anywhere in the Pentagon into the submarine fund without having to secure permission from appropriators.

Now the fight has been joined. The House Appropriations Committee gutted the fund in the $578.6 billion Pentagon spending bill it approved on Tuesday. Section 8122 of the bill reads: “None of the funds provided in this or any other Act may be transferred to the National Sea-Based Deterrence Fund.” It’s a not-very-veiled message to the authorizers: Don’t try to tell us how to finance new subs.

But when the bill hits the floor, Forbes plans to offer an amendment that would delete Section 8122 and breathe life into the Sea-Based Deterrence Fund. He says this battle isn’t about turf, but about protecting other Navy shipbuilding activities from potential budget cuts.

The various combatants over the fund all agree the subs need to be paid for; in fact, the appropriations bill includes $971 million for their design work, the same amount specified in the authorization bill. But it matters where that money comes from, especially now that appropriators face budget caps, and it will matter much more once construction begins and the newfangled replacement subs start sucking up much more money. Forbes warns that unless they can be financed through the separate fund, they will end up overwhelming the Navy’s shipbuilding account, which had $16 billion this year for vessels ranging from aircraft carriers to oilers.

 “This is a once-in-a-generation kind of expenditure. It wouldn’t be fiscally responsible to wait until the night before to figure out how to pay for it,” Forbes said.

I asked him why, if the new subs are so vital and the Navy’s other shipbuilding efforts are also vital, Congress couldn’t just jack up the shipbuilding budget instead. “Sure, we could do that, but it hasn’t been done in your generation or mine,” Forbes replied. “This is a very big lift, and it has to get done. I’m not saying this is the only approach we could take. If the appropriators have another suggestion, we’re happy to entertain that. But right now, this is the only approach out there.”

Ellis says that if Congress is determined to fund the new subs, there is plenty of fat it could cut in the Navy’s shipbuilding account. For example, a Government Accounting Office report found that the new Ford-class aircraft carrier was more than $2 billion over budget. The House bill also includes new Littoral Combat Ships, near-shore vessels that former Defense Secretary Chuck Hagel once testified were best-suited for missions in “relatively permissive environments.” Critics suggest it might make more sense to focus on military equipment for hostile environments. And if Congress didn’t want to cut shipbuilding, Ellis said, it could cut elsewhere in the $168 billion Navy budget, or raid the other military branches in order to boost the Navy budget.

But the Republican Congress is not interested in cutting military spending. It wants to spend more on the Pentagon. The House’s defense bill blew through the caps in the sequester, in part by stashing a slew of overseas spending into an uncapped war account. Ellis fears that ultimately, the sea-based deterrence fund will just boost the baseline for future defense spending—and inspire similar maneuvers for other expensive Pentagon toys.

Ellis said the other military branches have yet to raise any alarms about the potential Navy raid on their budgets, perhaps because they can imagine pursuing similar accounts for their own weapons systems in the future.

“They’re watching and waiting,” Ellis said. “If this gambit works, you can be sure we’re going to see it again.”

Repealed already repealed...

Trump’s strange plan to issue a rule that he already repealed

A new drug-testing regulation could stretch the limits of his rollback of Obama’s legacy.

By DANNY VINIK

As the GOP Congress scrambled last year to roll back as many Obama-era regulations as possible, one target was a Department of Labor rule on worker drug testing. The rule they rolled back wasn’t exactly a liberal employee protection: In fact it gave states permission to drug test certain workers receiving unemployment insurance, though it set limits around which workers.

On March 31, President Donald Trump signed the bill that officially eliminated the rule.

Now, less than a year later, Trump's Department of Labor is planning to reissue a similar regulation—once again allowing states to drug test certain workers, only broadening it so that it applies to an even larger population.

The planned rulemaking, which the DOL expects to begin later this year, has raised fears among the left that the department will enable states to drug test many more workers. But it also may set up a deeper conflict within the government—one that has the Trump administration testing the limits of just how much it can rewrite the Obama legacy.

The GOP rolled the rule back using an obscure 1996 law called the Congressional Review Act, which allows Congress to repeal recently issued regulations with a simple majority vote. Previously used only once, back in 2001, it became a favorite tool of the Trump GOP, which used it early last year to kill no fewer than 14 late-term Obama rules without a single Democratic vote.

But there’s a catch, and Trump’s proposed new drug-testing policy may trigger it.

Under the Congressional Review Act, agencies actually can't just re-issue new rules to replace the repealed ones. The law prohibits them from reissuing a rule that is “substantially the same” as the one that Congress repealed. Republicans have generally celebrated this feature of the law, saying they were permanently wiping away regulations that could never be reinstated. (In fact, according to a recent Axios report, Trump officials considered a bizarre plan to issue a batch of ultra-liberal regulations just so the GOP Congress would immediately repeal them, blocking a future Democratic administration from issuing real ones.)

But in the case of the drug-testing rule, Republicans actually do like the idea of drug-testing people who get unemployment checks. In fact, their main complaint with the Obama rule was that they found it too narrow. After Trump signed the repeal into law last March, Acting Secretary of Labor Ed Hugler said in a statement that the agency “looks forward to examining additional flexibilities for states” to drug test unemployment insurance applicants. In other words, they planned all along to expand drug testing.

But can they? That's less clear. In replacing a rule repealed under the Congressional Review Act, the administration appears to be steering into a messy—perhaps unprecedented—legal question.

The question mark over the whole idea underscores just how novel 2017 was when it came to repealing regulations. The first months of the Trump administration were the first sustained experiment in using the Congressional Review Act to overturn multiple regulations. Its only previous successful use, ever, was to repeal a single ergonomics rule issued at the end of the Clinton administration. In the first four months of Trump's presidency, by contrast, an enthusiastic Congress used it to roll back rules on everything from workplace safety to individual retirement accounts.

When the law was written, it contained a provision to ensure that if Congress objected to a certain rule and used the CRA to repeal it, the executive branch couldn’t just reissue it. Under the law, an agency cannot issue a rule “substantially the same” as one eliminated under the CRA, unless Congress grants the agency express authority to reissue it.

But the Trump administration, in its semi-annual regulatory agenda, released in December, now appears ready to test that: It plans to write a new and more permissive version of the drug-testing rule.

“The Trump administration appears to be [trying to] prove that not only can agencies issue new rules when past rules have been overturned by the CRA, but that those rules can be even stronger,” said Amit Narang, a regulatory expert at Public Citizen.

The fight over the drug testing rule itself dates back to 2012, when Democrats struck a deal with Republicans to extend an emergency unemployment program in return for allowing states to drug test unemployment applicants, which was previously prohibited under federal law. Under that deal, states could only drug test workers in two specific scenarios: those who were fired from their last job because of drug use, which generally makes them ineligible to collect jobless benefits anyway, and workers looking for a job in an industry that regularly drug tests its workers, a category determined by the Department of Labor. The resulting regulation, issued in August 2016, interpreted the latter category to include industries where drug testing is required, such as aviation, trucking and law enforcement. As of September 2016, when the regulation took effect, states could—for the first time—drug test certain people seeking unemployment benefits.

Republicans strongly objected to the interpretation by Obama’s Department of Labor, arguing that it should include industries where drug testing is merely permitted, a much broader standard that would sweep many more workers into state drug testing programs. Last year, using the CRA, they repealed the Obama-era rule, rescinding—at least temporarily—states’ authority to drug test unemployment applicants. (While three states had created drug testing programs between 2012 and 2016 in anticipation of the DOL rule, no state actually set up a program after the rule was finalized.)

The big question: Could the Department of Labor actually issue this new rule under the CRA? Or had Republicans just permanently repealed states’ authority to drug test unemployed workers?

Regulatory experts aren’t exactly sure about the answer, since no agency has ever tried to issue a rule that was previously repealed under the CRA, and therefore no court has issued an opinion. Neither the DOL or the White House budget office responded to a request for comment.

Some regulatory experts think the judiciary may be powerless over such a case because a separate provision in the CRA expressly exempts the law from judicial review. In other words, if a person or organization attempted to challenge a reissued rule, arguing that it violates the “substantially the same” clause, a court might just throw the case out. “It’s basically a requirement that has no enforcement mechanism,” said Curtis Copeland, a regulatory expert who previously worked for the Congressional Research Service.

Todd Gaziano, a senior fellow at the Pacific Legal Foundation who helped craft the Congressional Review Act as a congressional staffer, disagreed. He argued that outside parties would be challenging the new rule, not the CRA itself, which would permit judicial review of agency actions. “They are not looking behind the law into the CRA procedures,” he said. “They are only applying the law.”

It’s unclear whether liberal groups will force the issue by challenging the Trump drug-testing rule as “substantially the same” as the Obama-era rule. For one thing, the rule hasn’t been issued and it’s not clear when that will happen. For another, many of those groups believe that the courts should interpret “substantially the same” narrowly, so that agencies would have significant flexibility to reissue rules repealed under the CRA. They may instead challenge it on other legal grounds, potentially arguing that it violates the 2012 unemployment insurance law or violates the Fourth Amendment rights of workers, which protects against unlawful searches.

Gaziano, for his part, said that Trump’s Department of Labor is likely to be on sound legal footing if it issues a new, broader rule on drug testing unemployment applicants, because the agency is adhering to congressional intent in repealing the Obama-era rule. The CRA, he said, was written to give Congress greater influence over the regulatory process, forcing regulators to issue rules that more closely track Congress’s expectations under the original legislation. The only situation where an agency couldn’t reissue a rule, he argued, would be when Congress has given the agency such limited flexibility in statute that it is unable to write a “substantially” different rule.

If that’s the case, then—ironically—the Trump administration may have provided a roadmap for a future Democratic president to emulate Trump’s example and re-issue all those Obama-era rules—as long as they make sure they are “substantially” different from the originals.

Steel war...

If Trump really wants to save American steel, he'd nationalize it

He's right that the industry deserves support. But tariffs aren't the solution.

By TODD TUCKER

Last Friday, the Commerce Department set off an uproar in the trade world when it recommended that President Donald Trump use an obscure law to impose tariffs of up to 53 percent on steel imports. The agency argued that current import levels pose a risk to U.S. national security, potentially leaving the manufacturing workforce without the skills and experience to carry out a major military buildup.

But if Trump wants to address the real national security concerns, stabilize the steel industry and save these high-paying manufacturing jobs, a tariff is a clumsy way of doing so, likely violating international trade rules and infuriating important allies. There is a much simpler, straightforward idea that could work: Nationalize the industry altogether.

That may sound crazy—after all, nationalizations are rare, and political lightning rods. But it would solve the central problem the steel industry faces. No tariff, no matter how high, will reverse China’s domination of the steel industry and put U.S. steel companies onto long-term stable footing. Trying to fix the problem with trade policy creates needless complications and global tensions, all for the sake of a relatively small—though strategically vital—industry. Nationalization, in effect, sidesteps this problem altogether by eliminating the need to turn a profit. If Trump is committed to turning around the steel industry, nationalization is his best option.

This is, admittedly, not a free market solution—and critics, including much of Trump’s own party, will likely recoil at the notion. But the truth is that the free market has already failed the basic metals industry, failing to generate prices that reflect the true long-term social value of the industry. In fact, there’s no such thing as a free market for steel. Internationally, steel production is shot through with political interventions by foreign governments such as China. In the U.S., steel companies are stuck in a cycle of requiring more and more government protection just to buy them another few months or years. In other words, the industry is already totally dependent on the U.S. government to stay alive.

The government isn’t wrong to offer that protection, either. Concern about American steel is well-founded. Over the past 15 years, China has become the world leader in steel, a position it shows no sign of surrendering. It now has as much capacity as the rest of the world combined, going from 128 million metric tons of production in 2000 to 808 million metric tons in 2016. The country’s rising production lowered global prices and boosted overall imports into the U.S., leading to chronic profitability problems in the U.S. The six big domestic producers went from nearly $5 billion in profits in 2008 to an average annual loss of $666 million in the years since. Before China entered the World Trade Organization in 2001, the U.S. steel industry employed over 200,000 workers. By 2016, it dropped to 142,000. To be sure, automation has also contributed to these job losses, but China’s rising dominance in the steel industry played a central role.

This isn’t just, or even primarily, an economic problem for the United States. As the Commerce report argues, it’s also a national security threat. According to the most recent available numbers, roughly half of the steel consumed in the U.S. is by industries deemed critical by Congress, including dams and nuclear production. This is on top of the steel directly consumed by the government. If the domestic steel industry atrophies, the U.S. would be stuck trying to rebuild capacity if or when another military conflict arises just to make the trains run on time, let alone to fight a war.

To address this risk, Commerce recommended invoking an obscure trade statute called Section 232, which dates back to the Eisenhower and Kennedy era and allows the federal government to impose tariffs on foreign imports to protect U.S. national security. The agency argued that the U.S. steel industry needs to be operating at 80 percent capacity to survive, instead of its current 72 percent. By effectively raising the price of foreign steel, tariffs would allow the U.S. steel industry to better compete with foreign suppliers.

At least, that’s the idea. But there are good reasons to be skeptical it would work. For starters, the WTO would almost surely rule against it. Under one option put forward by Commerce, the U.S. would target the 12 countries most responsible for the steel surge with a 53 percent tariff while exempting others like Canada. But this move risks violating the WTO’s most-favored nation rules — something the South Korean government has preemptively promised to challenge legally. Alternatively, if the U.S. applies a lower 24 percent tariff on all imports regardless of origin, it will risk undermining key allies like Canada and Europe while still likely violating WTO rules. Either way, the costs to steel-using industries will go up, perhaps as much as $150 per metric ton.

Moreover, even with a tariff, there’s no guarantee the industry will be able to compete with a Chinese state-directed industry in the future, or that steelworker jobs will be well-paying and sustainable. The steel tariffs imposed by George W. Bush in 2002 — the most recent action of the type Trump is contemplating — were struck down at the WTO and arguably cost more jobs in steel-using industries than they created in steel itself. In other words, while Trump has pinpointed a real problem in our trade and security policy, Commerce’s recommendations are unlikely to work.

Luckily, there’s a better way. The U.S. could simply buy up existing U.S. steel producers and ensure that they are working at 80 percent capacity, regardless of the global price of steel or Chinese competition. It would create a more stable supply of steel, ensure the U.S. has a capable industrial base and save high-paying jobs. Importantly, this plan wouldn’t risk violating trade rules, since there are no WTO rules against nationalization. Steel could be rebuilt without raising costs through tariffs or risking trade conflicts — the two primary concerns of opponents of the Commerce recommendations.

There are other benefits as well. Rather than shedding jobs or pushing for labor concessions in contract negotiations, a public steel industry could support high-paying union jobs. Rather than attempting to cajole private companies to adopt environmentally friendly production methods, Congress could directly require the public industry to adopt cutting edge green technologies. Moreover, any profit the public enterprise did generate could be used to fund infrastructure investments and other public priorities at a time of falling government revenues from other sources. Indeed, a nationalized steel industry could provide even cheaper steel to industries that use it, all while maintaining high labor and other standards.

Nationalization may also be truer to Congress’ intent when it passed Section 232. The statute gives the executive branch broad authority to use trade sanctions to prop up industries for a wide array of problems, from “substantial unemployment” to “loss of skills or investment.” In other words, it basically gives the U.S. a mandate to pursue a forward-looking industrial policy and to determine which industries are indispensable to the nation’s well-being and ensure their longevity. The newly public steel factories would allow the government to maintain and build out centers of manufacturing excellence throughout the country and preserve vital skills — the exact intent of Eisenhower-Kennedy era law.

Of course, nationalization comes with real costs. How much would depend on the specific path taken. An uncompensated nationalization would be free, but would likely be struck down by courts as a violation of Fifth Amendment protections against such takings of private property, as the Supreme Court did when President Harry Truman sought to seize the steel mills during the Korean War. If the government were to obtain congressional agreement to offer compensation to steel company shareholders, the amount could be in the tens of billions of dollars. (Though it would have been cheaper before Commerce released its recommendations, which pumped up share prices of steel companies on the expectation the government would swoop in to help them.) If the price tag seems high, consider that the U.S. spent hundreds of billions bailing out Wall Street and Detroit.

It’s also possible that the government would be a worse manager of the industry, leading to inefficiencies and wasted resources. But while many critics of government often level this charge against public enterprises, economic scholars have found the evidence is mixed, with a number of successful companies run with government ownership. In fact, market failures often plague capital markets, while well-run public bureaucracies can impose political discipline on public entities.

Nationalization of an entire industry may seem like an extreme option for a president who has promised to shrink the government. But throughout his business and political career, Trump has worried about the threat of foreign countries’ trade policies, and advocated for significant government action. With steel, he has now rightly targeted a real problem. But tariffs won’t provide a lasting solution: nationalization will.

5 things under the radar..

5 things Trump did this week while you weren't looking

Beneath the gun debate, Trump made some big policy moves.

By DANNY VINIK

In the aftermath of the Parkland shooting, debates over gun control raged across the nation; President Donald Trump strongly defended the National Rifle Association, though he also got behind a couple of modest restrictions. Despite the wall-to-wall coverage and widespread student protests, few political analysts in Washington expect any congressional action on gun control this year.

But behind that news, the Trump administration did continue to make other important policy moves—including continuing to undermine Obamacare’s consumer protections and weakening other Obama-era rules. And Trump officially rolled back one of Obama’s most important policy achievements, on net neutrality. Here’s how Trump changed policy this week:

1. HHS takes another shot at Obamacare
Republicans failed in their attempt to repeal Obamacare last year, and have shown no sign of taking another shot in 2018. Instead, they continue to slowly take apart the law, repealing the individual mandate in tax reform and using executive authority to undermine key components of the ACA.

This week, the Department of Health and Human Services, along with two other agencies, issued a proposed rule that expands a category of insurance plans exempt from Obamacare’s consumer protections, including the requirement that plans cover people with pre-existing conditions. These short-term plans are designed for consumers who have a short gap in insurance coverage. The Obama administration defined “short-term” as three months or less, effectively steering consumers to Obamacare’s insurance markets. Under the proposed rule, these short-term plans could provide coverage for up to a year.

Supporters say the expansion will allow consumers who face high premiums on Obamacare’s marketplaces to purchase cheaper coverage that better meets their needs. But critics decry the plans as “junk insurance” that will undermine Obamacare by siphoning young, healthy people away from the main insurance marketplaces, where they’re critical to keep the system afloat.

The announcement wasn’t exactly a surprise, as Trump had issued an executive order last fall directing HHS to issue such a rule. And it doesn’t take effect right away: The agencies are accepting comments on the proposal until April 23 and will issue a final rule sometime thereafter.

2. Department of Education considers changes to student debt rules
During the Trump administration, students with high levels of debt haven’t received much good news. The Department of Education, under Secretary Betsy DeVos, blocked an Obama-era rule that allowed students defrauded by for-profit colleges to have their loans forgiven. It also effectively neutered another rule that imposed tough new standards on schools or risk losing access to federal student loans.

But on Wednesday, those students received some positive news when the Education Department announced that it was seeking comments on when borrowers can have their loans wiped out in bankruptcy, a preliminary but noteworthy move. Under the current rules, the law allows borrowers to discharge student loans only when they face “undue hardship,” a narrowly defined category that makes it basically impossible to wipe out debt during the bankruptcy process. Now, DeVos has cracked open the door to a broader definition of “undue hardship,” a change that could bring huge relief to the nearly 5 million borrowers currently in default.

3. The DOT modifies Obama-era rule on "quiet cars"
In December 2016, at the end of the Obama administration, the Department of Transportation finalized a rule that required “quiet cars,” such as hybrid and electric vehicles, to emit an alert sound when they travel under 18.6 miles per hour. Advocates for the blind and visually impaired cheered the news, arguing that such people face a higher injury risk as hybrid and electric vehicles grow in popularity.

But this week, after receiving pushback from automakers, the Trump administration issued a revised rule that modifies some of those requirements, including delaying the compliance date from 2019 to 2020. It also allows automakers to vary the sound emitted by vehicles in certain situations, a victory for automakers who had argued that the original “sameness” requirement was unworkable. However it wasn’t all good news for automakers: The agency also denied a request from automakers to reduce the speed threshold to 12.4 miles per hour, saying that “no new data” would justify such a change.

4. USDA considers tightening food-stamp work requirements
The Trump administration has already opened the door to work requirements in state Medicaid programs. Now, it is considering stricter work requirements in another program: food stamps.

Under the law, able-bodied adults without dependents—ABAWDs, for short—are required to work or undertake a work-related activity, such as job training, to receive more than three months of food stamps in a 36-month period. However, that requirement has some big loopholes: Individuals may receive an exemption due to age or if they are medically unfit for work. And states can request a populationwide waiver from the requirement during times of high unemployment; those waivers were frequently granted during the Obama administration as states recovered from the Great Recession.

This week, the Department of Agriculture announced that it is considering reforms around ABAWDs, requesting comment on potential policy changes that would tighten the work requirements, including narrowing how and when states can request a waiver. Supporters of work requirements say they help get recipients back on their feet, while critics say they unfairly target the poor.

Like the Department of Education’s move on student loans, this is just a preliminary step. But it is a strong indicator of how the Trump administration intends to reform the program.

5. Net neutrality is officially dead
Few policy moves during the Trump administration attracted as much attention as the Federal Communications Commission’s decision to repeal Obama-era net neutrality rules, which required internet service providers to treat all traffic in the same. Supporters and critics flooded the agency with millions of comments, and lawmakers loudly cheered or slammed the decision.

But this week, when the FCC officially published the repeal in the Federal Register, there wasn’t much noise. Democratic lawmakers blasted out statements condemning the move, but the news received little attention in Washington, where the focus was almost entirely on guns in the aftermath of the Parkland shooting. That’s not exactly surprising; the real news reaction came when the FCC voted to repeal net neutrality in December, and this was just a procedural step. Still, this week, it became official: The Obama-era net neutrality rules are gone. And with that, the lawsuits over the repeal can begin.

Mining giveaway

Trump's mining giveaway

Thanks to an 1872 law, Trump's decision to shrink two national monuments will give a huge windfall to miners.

By AUBREY MENARNDT

On Feb. 2, President Donald Trump’s directive shrinking the size of two national monuments in Utah, the largest reduction in U.S. history, officially took effect. Bears Ears and Grand Staircase-Escalante National Monuments saw their collective size shrink by nearly 2 million acres, land with lucrative deposits of coal and uranium.

Conservatives cheered the news, arguing that the monuments infringed on the public’s ability to use its land and that Trump’s directive would allow states to make the most of their resources. Utah Gov. Gary Herbert heralded the news as a “grand compromise” that will prevent the monument land from harming local residents’ “opportunities for tourism and travel, farming and ranching, for multiple use.”

But even the most ardent supporters of Trump’s decision should still be alarmed by its fiscal consequences. Due to a law older than Utah itself, miners will be able to extract resources from the 1.84 million acres of land for just a few hundred dollars, reaping huge profits on land owned by the federal government. This subsidy already costs Washington hundreds of millions of dollars annually—and without any legislative changes, Trump just made it even larger.

Without national monument status, these federal lands fall under the General Mining Act of 1872, a comically outdated Gold Rush-era piece of legislation. The law was created in a time of seemingly endless resources as people were headed West in search of fortune and there weren’t yet rules to broker the transfer of minerals on federally owned lands to miners. Under that law, miners could originally claim land by putting stakes or piles of rocks around their desired territory, filing a claim at the Bureau of Land Management and paying a maximum fee of $5 per acre. These days, the per-acre fees are gone but the costs are still small: Miners must pay just a $212 filing fee and an annual maintenance fee of $155 to extract minerals from federal lands.

Perhaps those fees were a fair price in 1872, but they certainly aren’t now. The law doesn’t require miners to pay royalties, the method the government typically uses to collect money for extracted resources. In other words, extraction companies are essentially getting mined resources for free. As Mother Jones journalist Josh Harkinson writes, the General Mining Act of 1872 is “a legal blank check that’s allowed miners to take an estimated $408 billion worth of gold and other hard rock minerals from public lands without paying a single cent in federal royalties—ever.” If the United States used the same royalty rates for hard-rock minerals that it does for oil and gas, the government would receive an estimated $100 million to $200 million in royalty payments annually.

There have been many attempts over the past century and a half to amend the legislation. In 2007, the House passed a bill to end new mining patents under the 1872 Act and impose royalty payments on the existing claims but it died in the Senate. In 2009, New Mexico Sen. Jeff Bingaman again tried and failed to introduce royalty payments for hard-rock minerals. More than 150 years after the General Mining Act became law, miners are still paying almost nothing to mine federal lands.

Even worse, while Americans don’t get much money from these deals, they are stuck with the cleanup. The government spends $80 million to $85 million annually attempting to clean up an estimated 500,000 abandoned mines in the U.S., an expensive and dangerous process. That doesn’t even count the major costs for rehabilitating abandoned coal mines.

There is still some hope the courts will reverse Trump’s move. Numerous groups are suing the government for cutting the size of these national monuments, which will likely delay mining activity for some time. Miners might also decide to leave the uranium in the ground since uranium prices are currently quite low. But even if those court cases succeed in reversing Trump’s move, it doesn’t change the fact that Americans are already losing millions on uncompensated natural resources every year.

Environmentalists like myself may never convince Trump supporters that Bears Ears National Park deserves protection because it contains historical and cultural resources and is the ancestral home to five Native American tribes. We may never agree that Grand Staircase-Escalante National Park is worthy of protection because it is filled with dinosaur fossils and colorful sandstone cliffs. But we should agree that giving national park land to mining companies for almost nothing is bad fiscal policy.

Even if these lands were barren wastelands with no cultural, historical, or aesthetic value, the American people would still be better off leaving the land unexploited so that we don’t continue to trade away our national treasures to get nothing in return. Until there is a modern law in place, Americans will continue to give millions of dollars to mining companies, degrading our national lands for no gain. Ending this egregious subsidy—not expanding it—is one area we should find common ground.

Retaliation after red-flagging Carson's decorating

HUD civil servant claims retaliation after red-flagging Carson's decorating

By LORRAINE WOELLERT

A high-ranking civil servant at the Department of Housing and Urban Development claims she was demoted after raising concerns about agency spending and Secretary Ben Carson’s redecorating plans.

In a sworn complaint to the Office of Special Counsel, HUD official Helen Foster said she was targeted for reprisals in part because incoming Trump administration officials believed her to be a Democrat.

In December 2016, after six months at the agency, Foster was promoted to chief administrative officer, a high-level job that includes oversight of spending and office space. By July 2017, she was demoted without warning or explanation, her lawyer says.

Foster’s trouble began in January 2017, shortly after her promotion, when she was told to “find money” beyond the $5,000 legally allowed for decorating because Carson’s wife asked for funds to buy furniture. When she objected, the agency’s designated acting secretary, Craig Clemmensen, himself a longtime career employee, told her that $5,000 “will not even buy a decent chair,” according to Foster’s complaint, which was submitted in November. The Guardian newspaper reported the story earlier on Tuesday.

Foster also raised questions about more than $10 million in 2016 budget shortfalls that occurred under the watch of her predecessor, a lifelong civil servant. Those concerns were ignored, she said. She also objected to the agency’s handling of a DNC request for public documents under the Freedom of Information Act.

At her own request, Foster has been detailed temporarily to the Treasury Department while her complaint is investigated, said her lawyer, Joseph Kaplan of Passman & Kaplan in Washington.

“She essentially thinks that she’s unemployable now,” Kaplan said. “When she’s gone on job interviews they see she held this high-level position for only seven months. Where does Helen Foster go now to get her reputation back?”

HUD rejected Foster’s accusations and on Tuesday released photographs and purchase receipts showing that Carson spent $3,373 to replace the drapes in his office with wood blinds.

He also sought to fix a conference table and chairs, but HUD staff determined that the furniture, purchased in 1967, was beyond repair. Career staff, without input from Carson or his wife, made the decision to spend $31,561 to purchase a new table, chairs and hutch, HUD spokesman Raphael Williams said.

Other furniture in the office, including chairs and a sofa, was swapped out and replaced with old items stored in HUD’s basement.

“Secretary Carson, to our knowledge, is the only HUD secretary to go to the sub-basement of his agency to select the furniture for his office,” Williams said.

The agency distributed before-and-after pictures of the secretary’s office, as well as agency photographs showing Foster attending work dressed in a bee costume. Foster’s motto-like tagline on her HUD emails was “Bee the change,” a play on Mahatma Gandhi’s quote, “Be the change that you wish to see in the world.”

In response to a Freedom of Information request filed by POLITICO, HUD also released a lengthy email in which Foster sought to tamp down office gossip about her leadership. These included rumors that she was a “bully” on the verge of being fired and that she forced HUD staff to care for her autistic and intellectually disabled daughter, who once accompanied her to the office on a snow day.

“There is nothing more distracting and damaging than a runaway rumor mill,” Foster wrote in the May 2017 email. “Let me ‘flatten’ a few of these rumors with the truth so we can all just go back to beeing awesome.”

Kaplan, saying that Foster had received top performance ratings up until her demotion, accused HUD of “attempting to smear her yet again for standing up and doing the right thing.”

The Office of Special Counsel, which is not connected to Robert Mueller’s special investigation into Russian meddling in the 2016 election, will make a determination by next week whether to proceed with an investigation into Foster’s complaint, Kaplan said.

Declined to comment

Sessions won't comment on Trump 'coward' remark about Florida deputy

By JOSH GERSTEIN

Attorney General Jeff Sessions declined to comment Tuesday when asked whether he agrees with President Donald Trump's suggestion that a sheriff's deputy who failed to intervene in a deadly school shooting earlier this month was a "coward."

"I don't have any comment on that," Sessions said in respond to a question from POLITICO at an event focused on anti-opioid abuse efforts. "I haven't examined that matter in detail and would prefer not to comment."

Last Friday, Trump singled out by name Broward County deputy Scot Peterson, who was assigned to the Parkland, Florida, high school where 17 people were slain earlier this month.

"When it came time to get in there and do something, he didn’t have the courage or something happened. But he certainly did a poor job. There’s no question about that," Trump told reporters. "So, he certainly did a poor job. But that’s a case where somebody was outside, they’re trained, they didn’t act properly or under pressure or they were a coward."

Following the incident, Peterson resigned. But through an attorney Monday, he defended his actions.

"The allegations that Mr. Peterson was a coward and that his performance, under the circumstances, failed to meet the standards of police officers are patently untrue," lawyer Joseph DiRuzzo said in a statement. "Mr. Peterson is confident that his actions on that day were appropriate under the circumstances and that the video (together with the eyewitness testimony of those on the scene) will exonerate him of any sub-par performance."

In explaining why the deputy did not enter the school, DiRuzzo said that Peterson was initially told the shooting was firecrackers and later believed the shooting was coming from outside the building.

Sessions is frequently critical of others, including his predecessors in the Obama administration, for being too quick to fault law enforcement officers over their conduct.

Earlier in the press conference Tuesday, Sessions stressed the importance of respecting the role played by local law enforcement personnel.

"We all need to recognize that 85 percent of law enforcement in America are our state and local officers throughout this country," the attorney general said. "They are out there every day on the front lines. We are working with them. We will support them to make their efforts even more successful."

A loss for environment..

Trump welcomes border ruling from judge he attacked

By LOUIS NELSON

President Donald Trump on Tuesday celebrated a “big legal win” delivered by a federal judge against whom he once leveled racial criticism.

Earlier Tuesday, U.S. District Court Judge Gonzalo Curiel rejected lawsuits brought by environmentalists and the state of California related to the Trump administration’s efforts to construct a wall along the U.S.-Mexico border.

“Big legal win today. U.S. judge sided with the Trump Administration and rejected the attempt to stop the government from building a great Border Wall on the Southern Border. Now this important project can go forward!” the president wrote online.

Trump made no mention in his Tuesday tweet of his previous feud with Curiel, which dates back to the summer of 2016, when the then-GOP candidate characterized the federal judge as a “Mexican” whose heritage meant he could not capably oversee a lawsuit against Trump, even though Curiel was born in Indiana.

The president’s criticism of Curiel prompted significant backlash at the time, with House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) labeling Trump’s remark as the “textbook definition of a racist comment."