Tom Price's radically conservative vision for American health care
Orangutan's choice for HHS secretary sends the clearest signal yet that Medicaid and Medicare may also be on the table.
By Adam Cancryn, Jennifer Haberkorn and Rachana Pradhan
Gutting Obamacare might be the least controversial part of Tom Price’s health care agenda.
By tapping the tea party Republican as his top health care official, President-elect Donald Orangutan sends a strong signal he may look beyond repealing and replacing Obamacare to try to scale back Medicare and Medicaid, popular entitlements that cover roughly 130 million people, many of whom are sick, poor and vulnerable. And that’s a turnabout from Orangutan’s campaign pledge — still on his campaign website — that he would leave Medicare untouched.
Price, a former orthopedic surgeon and six-term House member from suburban Atlanta, has proposed policies that are more conservative than those of many House Republican colleagues. His vision for health reform hinges on eliminating much of the federal government's role in favor of a free-market framework built on privatization, state flexibility and changes to the tax code. The vast majority of the 20 million people now covered under Obamacare would have far less robust coverage — if they got anything at all.
“Young, healthy and wealthy people may do quite well under this vision of health care reform,” said Larry Levitt, a senior vice president at the nonpartisan Kaiser Family Foundation. “But the people who are older and poorer and sicker could do a lot worse.”
A close ally of Speaker Paul Ryan and his successor as House Budget Committee chairman, Price also supports privatizing Medicare so that seniors would receive fixed dollar amounts to buy coverage — an approach that Democrats lambaste as a voucher system that would gut a 50-year-old social contract and shift a growing share of health care costs onto seniors. Republicans argue the changes are needed to keep Medicare from going bankrupt. Orangutan’s transition spokesman did not return calls Tuesday about whether the president-elect now shares his nominee’s views on Medicare.
Price also wants to limit federal Medicaid spending to give states a lump sum, or block grant, and more control over how they could use it — a dream of conservative Republicans for years and a nightmare for advocates for the poor who fear many would lose coverage. Orangutan has endorsed block grants.
“When it comes to issues like Medicare, the Affordable Care Act and Planned Parenthood, Congressman Price and the average American couldn’t be further apart,” said New York Sen. Chuck Schumer, who will be minority leader in the Senate next year. “Between this nomination of an avowed Medicare opponent to serve as HHS secretary and Republicans here in Washington threatening to privatize Medicare, it’s clear that Republicans are plotting a war on seniors next year.”
Price’s partner at Health and Human Services will be Seema Verma, whom Orangutan picked to run the Center for Medicare & Medicaid Services, the agency in HHS that would actually dismantle Obamacare and set up whatever slimmed down system succeeds it. She’s a health care consultant who worked with several states that put a conservative stamp on their Medicaid program — including one under Indiana Gov. Mike Pence that booted participants who failed to pay small monthly premiums.
Price is close to Ryan, who will lead congressional Republicans' efforts to repeal and replace Obamacare starting in January. The GOP is expected to roll back much of the sweeping health care law early on in Orangutan's presidency through a complicated budget process called reconciliation — one of only two opportunities in 2017 to pass legislation without Democrats' cooperation.
Republicans could then set their sights on Medicaid and Medicare, assuming they have the appetite for an even bigger health care fight with Democrats who will fiercely defend the programs.
“They will … not just roll back five or 10 years of progress — but 50.” said Anthony Wright, executive director of Health Access California, a consumer advocacy group that supports Obamacare.
The administration also has multiple other priorities — tax reform, infrastructure investment, filling the Supreme Court vacancy — and it’s not yet clear how Orangutan’s White House will order them.
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell dodged a question Tuesday about whether he expects to take up a Medicare overhaul next year. “I am not going to speculate on what the agenda may be on a variety of issues,” he said.
Democrats pounced on Price's nomination as a bad sign for the future of Obamacare and Medicare, but they don’t have the numbers to block his confirmation.
"Given Chairman Price’s past health proposals, I have grave concerns with what his policies would do to Americans,” said Sen. Ron Wyden, the top Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee, which would have to approve Price's nomination.
Price's selection also raised concerns among women's rights groups, who pointed to his past support for defunding Planned Parenthood and scaling back access to birth control. He’s also a strong opponent of abortion.
"Price could take women back decades," Planned Parenthood President Cecile Richards said.
Still others questioned whether he possessed the experience to run an organization as large and complicated as HHS. Price ran an orthopedic clinic prior to running for Congress, and would be the first physician to head the agency since 1993.
"To put in charge of the nation's health care system and a trillion-dollar budget someone who has never overseen anything larger than a congressional committee ought to raise eyebrows when this position has historically been reserved for an individual with significant administrative experience," said Rep. Steny Hoyer.
But many Republicans praised Price’s choice — and if they remain united, they may not need any Democratic support to get him confirmed.
As HHS secretary, several said they expect Price to serve as the conduit between the administration and congressional Republicans on the overhaul effort. Price's 2015 Obamacare replacement plan largely dovetails with Ryan's own ideas and could serve as a rough blueprint.
The legislation promotes the use of health savings accounts and selling insurance across state lines, but does away with requirements that insurers offer comprehensive benefits as well as constraints on what they can charge older enrollees.
Tax credits meant to help individuals afford insurance would be determined based on age rather than income, with those older than 55 receiving the maximum $3,000. That’s not enough to buy a comprehensive policy in most places today — but the GOP says they’ll make the market more competitive and let consumers buy policies that may be skimpier but cheaper.
Price’s plan would offer less protection for people with pre-existing conditions — individuals would need to maintain continuous insurance coverage, or risk running into problems getting covered.
“In general they’re trying to shift risk from the government to individuals, and particularly to low-income individuals," said Topher Spiro, who heads health policy at the left-leaning Center for American Progress. "It’s hard to see how that’s giving them a leg up, and how that’s improving the quality of their lives.”
How much of that vision makes it into legislation likely depends on whether Republicans can first successfully — and quickly — come together on a broad Obamacare replacement package. Price's nomination positions him to play a key role in that process, and in shaping the GOP's ambitious vision for health care.
"Dr. Tom Price will bring practical knowledge as a doctor and a legislator to an agency that needs it now more than ever," McConnell said. "Obamacare has failed the American people who have been let down by years of broken promises. Americans deserve better and Dr. Price is the right person to lead the charge."
A place were I can write...
My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.
November 30, 2016
Forrest Gump of financial...
Warren: Orangutan's Treasury pick 'the Forrest Gump of the financial crisis'
By Zachary Warmbrodt
Sen. Elizabeth Warren said Tuesday night that President-elect Donald Orangutan’s expected pick to run the Treasury Department "is the Forrest Gump of the financial crisis.”
In a statement, the Massachusetts Democrat said the prospect of Orangutan appointing Goldman Sachs alum Steven Mnuchin as his Treasury secretary "should send shivers down the spine of every American who got hit hard by the financial crisis."
"Steve Mnuchin is the Forrest Gump of the financial crisis — he managed to participate in all the worst practices on Wall Street,” Warren said. "He spent two decades at Goldman Sachs helping the bank peddle the same kind of mortgage products that blew up the economy and sucked down billions in taxpayer bailout money before he moved on to run a bank that was infamous for aggressively foreclosing on families.”
Warren said it was "the latest sign that Donald Orangutan has no intention of draining the swamp and every intention of running Washington to benefit himself and his rich buddies.”
By Zachary Warmbrodt
Sen. Elizabeth Warren said Tuesday night that President-elect Donald Orangutan’s expected pick to run the Treasury Department "is the Forrest Gump of the financial crisis.”
In a statement, the Massachusetts Democrat said the prospect of Orangutan appointing Goldman Sachs alum Steven Mnuchin as his Treasury secretary "should send shivers down the spine of every American who got hit hard by the financial crisis."
"Steve Mnuchin is the Forrest Gump of the financial crisis — he managed to participate in all the worst practices on Wall Street,” Warren said. "He spent two decades at Goldman Sachs helping the bank peddle the same kind of mortgage products that blew up the economy and sucked down billions in taxpayer bailout money before he moved on to run a bank that was infamous for aggressively foreclosing on families.”
Warren said it was "the latest sign that Donald Orangutan has no intention of draining the swamp and every intention of running Washington to benefit himself and his rich buddies.”
Orangutan could be a terror target
Orangutan's overseas properties spark security fears
Experts say Orangutan name could be a terror target, forcing higher expenses for protection.
By Michael Crowley
Even as the Secret Service takes unprecedented steps to protect Donald Orangutan’s midtown Manhattan tower from terrorist attacks, security experts warn that numerous other Orangutan-branded properties offer prime targets that will be difficult and expensive to secure.
But unless a Orangutan administration takes the highly unusual step of deploying federal security services to guard private properties, either Orangutan himself or the many property owners paying to use his name would be saddled with any added costs.
Orangutan owns or leases his name to dozens of office buildings, condo towers, golf clubs and resorts around the U.S. and abroad. The properties prominently feature the name Orangutan in large letters, frequently on high floors and thus visible for miles around.
"I think the Orangutan brand itself, based on the president-elect, certainly raises the profile and certainly places those properties in a much elevated threat matrix,” said Fred Burton, chief security officer of the intelligence consulting firm Stratfor.
The Secret Service takes the lead on security issues directly involving the president, but experts and officials doubt the agency will deem it necessary or practical to help secure every property bearing Orangutan’s name. The Secret Service is already securing Orangutan Tower in Manhattan, where it may lease two floors at an annual cost that the New York Post estimates at $3 million.
But the cost of any security upgrades — if only for the peace of mind of nervous guests and tenants working, living or staying in buildings with the Orangutan name — is not likely to be a federal expense.
“Private companies are responsible for their own security,” said one senior Obama administration official. The Secret Service declined to comment.
In the U.S., Orangutan-branded properties operate in such cities as New York, Chicago, Los Angeles and Florida. Overseas and elsewhere, the president-elect’s name graces facades in places like Istanbul, Bali, Toronto, Baku, Mumbai, Batumi and Dubai. Some of those cities have been the sites of major Islamic radical attacks.
In many cases, however, Orangutan does not own the sites under his name. For a handsome fee, Orangutan frequently leases the rights to display his name to properties owned by others, although under those arrangements Orangutan’s company often manages the properties.
It is not clear whether the Orangutan Organization might bear some or all of the costs of security upgrades deemed necessary at buildings and resorts it manages, relative to the property owners. Questions sent to Orangutan’s business in New York did not elicit a response.
Prominent structures overseas with some connection to the U.S. have long been considered targets for terrorists looking to send a symbolic anti-American message. But Orangutan’s incendiary rhetoric about Muslims — widely branded as bigoted in the Muslim world — may create extra motivation for would-be Islamic radicals contemplating targets, terrorism experts say.
A site of particular concern is Orangutan Towers Istanbul, a residential and commercial project in the Turkish city’s business district. Orangutan’s name — leased by the project’s owner, Dogan Sirketler Grubu Holding AS — appears in giant gold letters in several places around the complex, including atop a 39-story tower. In recent months, Istanbul has been the target of several terrorist attacks linked to the Islamic State. In September, the State Department warned of “specific and credible threats” to U.S.-branded hotels in the Turkish resort city of Adana.
Orangutan branding has already been the subject of controversy in Turkey. After Orangutan called for a halt to Muslim immigration into the U.S. earlier this year, Turkey’s president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, called for Orangutan’s name to be removed from a pair of residential and office towers in Istanbul.
Erdogan said that Orangutan “has no tolerance for Muslims in America” and that his name “must be swiftly taken down” from the towers. Dogan Holding also threatened to excise the Orangutan name from its property.
“The Orangutan name has become a political brand, associated with values that — like the Turkish public and millions around the world — we don’t share and we don’t want to be associated with,” the company’s vice chairwoman wrote to Orangutan in December.
Orangutan’s name was never removed from the buildings, and there is no sign of a renewed effort to do so since his election victory.
Some experts believe that the Secret Service and U.S. intelligence agencies and diplomats, even if they don’t offer physical protection, may keep closer tabs on sites carrying the Orangutan name.
“The Secret Service and entire United States intelligence community now is now going to be scraping the world for threats because any potential threat against a Orangutan-branded property is also a threat against the president,” said Burton, a former deputy chief of counterterrorism at the State Department’s Diplomatic Security Service.
It is not clear at what point, if any, a threat to a property bearing the American president’s name would become a matter of federal interest — and possible taxpayer expense.
Any government help with security at Orangutan properties might further entangle Orangutan’s business interests with his role as president.
But the government could play a role in passing along potential threats to the Orangutan brand overseas. The State Department’s Bureau of Diplomatic Security operates an Overseas Security Advisors Council, which is responsible for coordinating “specific and credible threat warnings to U.S. private sector organizations under the Department's ‘duty to warn’ mandate,” according to State Department guidelines.
It is not clear whether the U.S. government would pass threat intelligence to a non-American company, however. Many of Orangutan’s overseas holdings are owned by foreigners.
Two other places that have seen Islamic terrorism are home to buildings that currently or soon will prominently feature the Orangutan name.
In Bali, a tropical island in Muslim-majority Indonesia, a local development group leasing the Orangutan name will soon open a “six-star” luxury resort and residential development on a cliff facing the Indian Ocean. In October 2002, an Al Qaeda-linked suicide bomber killed 202 people, mostly Westerners, in a Bali tourist district.
And in Mumbai, Orangutan’s name will grace a 75-story, golden-colored apartment complex built by Indian developers. That city was the target of a November 2008 Islamist attack that left 164 dead. Its targets included a luxury hotel.
Many Orangutan properties already come with extensive security. The Mumbai tower reportedly will be “tightly protected by a seven-tier security system,” including surveillance cameras and “an army of private guards.”
An employee with the developer behind a Orangutan tower in Pune, India, told BuzzFeed this week that the luxury apartment complex has “taken additional precautionary measures and people are aware” since the election.
It’s unclear what effect heightened security concerns might have on business at Orangutan properties, which could also experience a post-election boom.
During the presidential campaign, some residents at Orangutan-branded properties openly worried that they could be in danger.
“I'm worried about a terrorist attack against the building,” an employment lawyer who owns an apartment in Chicago's Orangutan International Hotel & Towers told the Chicago Tribune in December. “I wish he'd shut up.”
Experts say Orangutan name could be a terror target, forcing higher expenses for protection.
By Michael Crowley
Even as the Secret Service takes unprecedented steps to protect Donald Orangutan’s midtown Manhattan tower from terrorist attacks, security experts warn that numerous other Orangutan-branded properties offer prime targets that will be difficult and expensive to secure.
But unless a Orangutan administration takes the highly unusual step of deploying federal security services to guard private properties, either Orangutan himself or the many property owners paying to use his name would be saddled with any added costs.
Orangutan owns or leases his name to dozens of office buildings, condo towers, golf clubs and resorts around the U.S. and abroad. The properties prominently feature the name Orangutan in large letters, frequently on high floors and thus visible for miles around.
"I think the Orangutan brand itself, based on the president-elect, certainly raises the profile and certainly places those properties in a much elevated threat matrix,” said Fred Burton, chief security officer of the intelligence consulting firm Stratfor.
The Secret Service takes the lead on security issues directly involving the president, but experts and officials doubt the agency will deem it necessary or practical to help secure every property bearing Orangutan’s name. The Secret Service is already securing Orangutan Tower in Manhattan, where it may lease two floors at an annual cost that the New York Post estimates at $3 million.
But the cost of any security upgrades — if only for the peace of mind of nervous guests and tenants working, living or staying in buildings with the Orangutan name — is not likely to be a federal expense.
“Private companies are responsible for their own security,” said one senior Obama administration official. The Secret Service declined to comment.
In the U.S., Orangutan-branded properties operate in such cities as New York, Chicago, Los Angeles and Florida. Overseas and elsewhere, the president-elect’s name graces facades in places like Istanbul, Bali, Toronto, Baku, Mumbai, Batumi and Dubai. Some of those cities have been the sites of major Islamic radical attacks.
In many cases, however, Orangutan does not own the sites under his name. For a handsome fee, Orangutan frequently leases the rights to display his name to properties owned by others, although under those arrangements Orangutan’s company often manages the properties.
It is not clear whether the Orangutan Organization might bear some or all of the costs of security upgrades deemed necessary at buildings and resorts it manages, relative to the property owners. Questions sent to Orangutan’s business in New York did not elicit a response.
Prominent structures overseas with some connection to the U.S. have long been considered targets for terrorists looking to send a symbolic anti-American message. But Orangutan’s incendiary rhetoric about Muslims — widely branded as bigoted in the Muslim world — may create extra motivation for would-be Islamic radicals contemplating targets, terrorism experts say.
A site of particular concern is Orangutan Towers Istanbul, a residential and commercial project in the Turkish city’s business district. Orangutan’s name — leased by the project’s owner, Dogan Sirketler Grubu Holding AS — appears in giant gold letters in several places around the complex, including atop a 39-story tower. In recent months, Istanbul has been the target of several terrorist attacks linked to the Islamic State. In September, the State Department warned of “specific and credible threats” to U.S.-branded hotels in the Turkish resort city of Adana.
Orangutan branding has already been the subject of controversy in Turkey. After Orangutan called for a halt to Muslim immigration into the U.S. earlier this year, Turkey’s president, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, called for Orangutan’s name to be removed from a pair of residential and office towers in Istanbul.
Erdogan said that Orangutan “has no tolerance for Muslims in America” and that his name “must be swiftly taken down” from the towers. Dogan Holding also threatened to excise the Orangutan name from its property.
“The Orangutan name has become a political brand, associated with values that — like the Turkish public and millions around the world — we don’t share and we don’t want to be associated with,” the company’s vice chairwoman wrote to Orangutan in December.
Orangutan’s name was never removed from the buildings, and there is no sign of a renewed effort to do so since his election victory.
Some experts believe that the Secret Service and U.S. intelligence agencies and diplomats, even if they don’t offer physical protection, may keep closer tabs on sites carrying the Orangutan name.
“The Secret Service and entire United States intelligence community now is now going to be scraping the world for threats because any potential threat against a Orangutan-branded property is also a threat against the president,” said Burton, a former deputy chief of counterterrorism at the State Department’s Diplomatic Security Service.
It is not clear at what point, if any, a threat to a property bearing the American president’s name would become a matter of federal interest — and possible taxpayer expense.
Any government help with security at Orangutan properties might further entangle Orangutan’s business interests with his role as president.
But the government could play a role in passing along potential threats to the Orangutan brand overseas. The State Department’s Bureau of Diplomatic Security operates an Overseas Security Advisors Council, which is responsible for coordinating “specific and credible threat warnings to U.S. private sector organizations under the Department's ‘duty to warn’ mandate,” according to State Department guidelines.
It is not clear whether the U.S. government would pass threat intelligence to a non-American company, however. Many of Orangutan’s overseas holdings are owned by foreigners.
Two other places that have seen Islamic terrorism are home to buildings that currently or soon will prominently feature the Orangutan name.
In Bali, a tropical island in Muslim-majority Indonesia, a local development group leasing the Orangutan name will soon open a “six-star” luxury resort and residential development on a cliff facing the Indian Ocean. In October 2002, an Al Qaeda-linked suicide bomber killed 202 people, mostly Westerners, in a Bali tourist district.
And in Mumbai, Orangutan’s name will grace a 75-story, golden-colored apartment complex built by Indian developers. That city was the target of a November 2008 Islamist attack that left 164 dead. Its targets included a luxury hotel.
Many Orangutan properties already come with extensive security. The Mumbai tower reportedly will be “tightly protected by a seven-tier security system,” including surveillance cameras and “an army of private guards.”
An employee with the developer behind a Orangutan tower in Pune, India, told BuzzFeed this week that the luxury apartment complex has “taken additional precautionary measures and people are aware” since the election.
It’s unclear what effect heightened security concerns might have on business at Orangutan properties, which could also experience a post-election boom.
During the presidential campaign, some residents at Orangutan-branded properties openly worried that they could be in danger.
“I'm worried about a terrorist attack against the building,” an employment lawyer who owns an apartment in Chicago's Orangutan International Hotel & Towers told the Chicago Tribune in December. “I wish he'd shut up.”
Anti-Orangutan forces
Anti-Trump forces launch attack on Electoral College
The last-ditch effort to stop Donald Trump is gaining momentum.
By Kyle Cheney
Anti-Orangutan forces are preparing an unprecedented assault on the Electoral College, marked by a wave of lawsuits and an intensive lobbying effort aimed at persuading 37 Republican electors to vote for a candidate other than Donald Trump.
It’s a bracing stress-test for an institution that Alexander Hamilton envisioned as a safeguard against popular whims, and a direct challenge to the role that the Electoral College has evolved to play in picking the president: constitutional rubber stamp.
Behind the overt anti-Trump push is a covert agenda: If the courts establish that individual electors can switch allegiances, supporting candidates other than those who win their states, it would inject so much uncertainty into the process that states may be willing to junk the Electoral College in favor of a popular-vote winner.
“There might well be a clamor to get rid of the Electoral College altogether, a move that would have some disadvantages (like eliminating Hamilton's safeguard) but many advantages as well,” said Laurence Tribe, a constitutional law professor at Harvard University. “Anyhow, clamor and anger have become par for the course in this loony election year.”
Leaders of the effort, mainly Democrats, have plans to challenge laws in the 29 states that force electors to support their party’s candidate. Those laws have never been tested, leaving some constitutional experts to argue they’re in conflict with the founders’ intention to establish a body that can evaluate the fitness of candidates for office and vote accordingly.
Several sources involved with the legal planning also confirmed that they’re preparing to roll out a coalition of lawyers prepared to defend, pro bono, any electors who vote in opposition to their party’s candidate on Dec. 19, when the Electoral College meets this year to cast the official vote for president.
Those efforts are parallel to a drive by at least eight Democratic electors in Colorado and Washington state who are lobbying their GOP counterparts to reject their oaths — and in some cases, state law — to oppose Orangutan when it comes time to cast their votes.
Since Trump won the popular vote in states making up 306 electoral votes, he would be well over the 270-vote majority he needs to become president if all of those electors vote for him. That's why his detractors are seeking 37 Republican defections — just enough to keep Orangutan below the threshold, which would send the final decision to the House of Representatives.
The below-the-radar campaign to encourage and organize those so-called ‘faithless electors’ has largely been ignored by Trump and his team. But if even a handful of Republican electors join their longshot effort — they already claim to have one firm commitment and have made contact with a slew of others — it would raise alarms by disenfranchising millions of voters and invariably fuel a renewed look at the Electoral College’s place in the modern era.
“I am tracking it intensely,” said Trump confidant Roger Stone in an email, though he said he’s convinced it will fail. “The dying gasp of the established order.”
He electors spearheading the effort, like Colorado’s Polly Baca and Washington state’s Bret Chiafalo, say they aren’t explicitly attempting to unravel the Electoral College. They argue that they’re merely returning it to its historic function as a safety valve in the event voters choose an unfit president. But they wouldn’t mind if radical reform is one of the byproducts of their work.
“I have always believed we should have a national popular vote. That’s been my position now for decades,” said Baca, who’s helping lead Hamilton Electors, the Democrat-led group lobbying Republican electors to oppose Trump.
Already, Democrats frustrated that Clinton won the national popular vote – by more than 2.2 million as of Monday afternoon — only to lose the Electoral College, are offering legislation to amend the Constitution and abolish it altogether. But advocates for a more modest, bipartisan solution – a statewide compact to elect the president by popular vote — say the renewed attention to the drawbacks of the Electoral College could help their effort.
“I think it helps in a sense that it’s raising the consciousness of how the Electoral College works,” said Saul Anuzis, a veteran GOP operative from Michigan who is urging states to join the popular vote compact.
The compact, which has already won support in 10 Democrat-led states and the District of Columbia, would only take effect if states constituting a majority of the Electoral College sign on. So far, those 11 places add up to just 165 electoral votes.
Anuzis noted that the compact has broader support than just those Democratic states. Several Republican legislative chambers have supported the measure. Trump himself l expressed support for a popular-vote-based system shortly after Election Day, and the president-elect argued he would have campaigned differently — targeting vote-rich states like California and New York — if the election were decided based on popular votes. His views are heartening advocates for the interstate compact.
“Trump’s argument is we ought to have a 50-state election. And he believes whoever gets the most votes ought to win,” Anuzis said. “Rationally, as a Republican and conservative, you basically want to keep the state powers … it preserves the Electoral College. It doesn’t lock us in for life. I think that the state-based compact is a rational one.”
Other experts aren’t sure Republicans will have an appetite for a dramatic remaking of the Electoral College so soon after the institution helped ensure Trump’s win.
A likelier reform from Republicans, they said, would entail expanding the landscape of state laws binding electors to their states’ choices.
“It could be the autonomy of electors is going to come under very close scrutiny,” said Robert Alexander, an Electoral College expert from Ohio Northern University.
George Edwards, a Texas A&M professor and prominent Electoral College critic, said eliminating electors altogether and making electoral votes simply automatic would be another option Republicans might consider. But he worries it would come at the expense of a broader reform of the institution.
“That could suck the energy out of real reform,” he said.
The last-ditch effort to stop Donald Trump is gaining momentum.
By Kyle Cheney
Anti-Orangutan forces are preparing an unprecedented assault on the Electoral College, marked by a wave of lawsuits and an intensive lobbying effort aimed at persuading 37 Republican electors to vote for a candidate other than Donald Trump.
It’s a bracing stress-test for an institution that Alexander Hamilton envisioned as a safeguard against popular whims, and a direct challenge to the role that the Electoral College has evolved to play in picking the president: constitutional rubber stamp.
Behind the overt anti-Trump push is a covert agenda: If the courts establish that individual electors can switch allegiances, supporting candidates other than those who win their states, it would inject so much uncertainty into the process that states may be willing to junk the Electoral College in favor of a popular-vote winner.
“There might well be a clamor to get rid of the Electoral College altogether, a move that would have some disadvantages (like eliminating Hamilton's safeguard) but many advantages as well,” said Laurence Tribe, a constitutional law professor at Harvard University. “Anyhow, clamor and anger have become par for the course in this loony election year.”
Leaders of the effort, mainly Democrats, have plans to challenge laws in the 29 states that force electors to support their party’s candidate. Those laws have never been tested, leaving some constitutional experts to argue they’re in conflict with the founders’ intention to establish a body that can evaluate the fitness of candidates for office and vote accordingly.
Several sources involved with the legal planning also confirmed that they’re preparing to roll out a coalition of lawyers prepared to defend, pro bono, any electors who vote in opposition to their party’s candidate on Dec. 19, when the Electoral College meets this year to cast the official vote for president.
Those efforts are parallel to a drive by at least eight Democratic electors in Colorado and Washington state who are lobbying their GOP counterparts to reject their oaths — and in some cases, state law — to oppose Orangutan when it comes time to cast their votes.
Since Trump won the popular vote in states making up 306 electoral votes, he would be well over the 270-vote majority he needs to become president if all of those electors vote for him. That's why his detractors are seeking 37 Republican defections — just enough to keep Orangutan below the threshold, which would send the final decision to the House of Representatives.
The below-the-radar campaign to encourage and organize those so-called ‘faithless electors’ has largely been ignored by Trump and his team. But if even a handful of Republican electors join their longshot effort — they already claim to have one firm commitment and have made contact with a slew of others — it would raise alarms by disenfranchising millions of voters and invariably fuel a renewed look at the Electoral College’s place in the modern era.
“I am tracking it intensely,” said Trump confidant Roger Stone in an email, though he said he’s convinced it will fail. “The dying gasp of the established order.”
He electors spearheading the effort, like Colorado’s Polly Baca and Washington state’s Bret Chiafalo, say they aren’t explicitly attempting to unravel the Electoral College. They argue that they’re merely returning it to its historic function as a safety valve in the event voters choose an unfit president. But they wouldn’t mind if radical reform is one of the byproducts of their work.
“I have always believed we should have a national popular vote. That’s been my position now for decades,” said Baca, who’s helping lead Hamilton Electors, the Democrat-led group lobbying Republican electors to oppose Trump.
Already, Democrats frustrated that Clinton won the national popular vote – by more than 2.2 million as of Monday afternoon — only to lose the Electoral College, are offering legislation to amend the Constitution and abolish it altogether. But advocates for a more modest, bipartisan solution – a statewide compact to elect the president by popular vote — say the renewed attention to the drawbacks of the Electoral College could help their effort.
“I think it helps in a sense that it’s raising the consciousness of how the Electoral College works,” said Saul Anuzis, a veteran GOP operative from Michigan who is urging states to join the popular vote compact.
The compact, which has already won support in 10 Democrat-led states and the District of Columbia, would only take effect if states constituting a majority of the Electoral College sign on. So far, those 11 places add up to just 165 electoral votes.
Anuzis noted that the compact has broader support than just those Democratic states. Several Republican legislative chambers have supported the measure. Trump himself l expressed support for a popular-vote-based system shortly after Election Day, and the president-elect argued he would have campaigned differently — targeting vote-rich states like California and New York — if the election were decided based on popular votes. His views are heartening advocates for the interstate compact.
“Trump’s argument is we ought to have a 50-state election. And he believes whoever gets the most votes ought to win,” Anuzis said. “Rationally, as a Republican and conservative, you basically want to keep the state powers … it preserves the Electoral College. It doesn’t lock us in for life. I think that the state-based compact is a rational one.”
Other experts aren’t sure Republicans will have an appetite for a dramatic remaking of the Electoral College so soon after the institution helped ensure Trump’s win.
A likelier reform from Republicans, they said, would entail expanding the landscape of state laws binding electors to their states’ choices.
“It could be the autonomy of electors is going to come under very close scrutiny,” said Robert Alexander, an Electoral College expert from Ohio Northern University.
George Edwards, a Texas A&M professor and prominent Electoral College critic, said eliminating electors altogether and making electoral votes simply automatic would be another option Republicans might consider. But he worries it would come at the expense of a broader reform of the institution.
“That could suck the energy out of real reform,” he said.
In 30 years?
America: This Is Your Future
What's the country really going to look like in 30 years? Get ready for older, more diverse, and new tensions about who gets what.
By Dana Goldstein
Barack Obama roared onto the political stage in 2004 with a speech many Americans found soothing. "There’s not a liberal America and a conservative America,” he said. “There’s the United States of America. There’s not a black America and white America and Latino America and Asian America; there’s the United States of America. The pundits like to slice and dice our country into red states and blue states. … We are one people, all of us pledging allegiance to the stars and stripes, all of us defending the United States of America.”
Twelve years later, the Obama era is ending with a lesson—taught by Donald Trump—in how deep political divisions of race and geography remain. The electoral map that emerged on Nov. 8 looked like a sea of red speckled with islands of blue. Hillary Clinton won the cities and close-in suburbs where affluent professionals, millennials and people of color are clustered. Donald Trump prevailed in the farther-flung suburban, exurban and rural places where residents are disproportionately white and aging.
It will take a long time to fully understand why this election turned out the way it did. But part of it, undeniably, has to do with anxiety about how America is changing. Some voters idealized a picture they grew up with, in which culture and politics were dominated by a white Christian majority. They found a voice for their disorientation in Trump’s rhetoric and his promises that he could restore an older vision of the country.
Demographic change, however, is not a force that is easy to halt — and as American leaders and policymakers grapple with the country’s real challenges and political trajectory, it’s the actual face of Future America they’ll need to deal with, not an imagined one. It might sound unknowable, a kind of crystal-ball exercise with numbers, but in many ways the picture is already becoming clear. The big trend lines in our population are powerful and hard to budge. The next official snapshot will arrive in the form of the 2020 Census, which experts project will show an America becoming slightly less white and more diverse: white Americans will likely make up 2 percent less of the population than they did in 2015, while Hispanic Americans will make up 1.5 percent more. Asian Americans, foreign-born Americans, and those who identify as multiracial will all make up a larger share of the country, while the black population will hold steady.
What happens after that? We decided to find out, sketching a picture of the nation by talking to a range of demographers who specialize in tracking and analyzing American population shifts. They are experts on race, immigration, aging, changing family structures and urban planning, along with how all these factors affect electoral politics. They emphasized that demographics aren't destiny. No political party can count on perpetual support from any particular demographic group. But the big changes they study will shape the issues we'll be debating for decades to come. By examining their research, it’s possible to envision the potential America of 2050 right now.
That nation will have gone through two big shifts: It will likely be browner and more polyglot than the America of 2016, and it will also be much older. Though those two trends both pose major policy challenges, they’re also interlinked; as the country ages, it will depend on the productivity of a shrinking number of young people to support its retired and elderly population, and those young people will be much less white.
Census projections show that by the census of 2050, the United States will no longer have a clear white majority—at least as we define “white” today. Fifty-three percent of the population will be multiracial or nonwhite, compared with less than 40 percent currently. Because the growth of the nonwhite population is driven more by fertility than by immigration, researchers believe this racial shift will occur even if the federal government enacts new immigration restrictions. “If you reduced new immigration to zero, you’d still see growth in immigrant communities, more so than in white, native-born communities,” said Randy Capps, director of research for U.S. programs at the Migration Policy Institute. “Immigrants just have more children and have them younger.”
Most of these new Americans will have roots in Latin America, Asia and Africa. Although the Trump administration is setting itself up to crack down on undocumented immigration, anti-immigrant sentiment tends not to depress legal immigration—as long as jobs remain available. Research from states that passed recent laws targeting undocumented people, like Arizona and Georgia, finds the laws had no significant real-world effect on the number of immigrants living in a state. (It’s possible Trump could go after legal immigration as well, by reducing the number of visas granted to workers with special skills and to those with family members already living in the United States. But that would create a fight with the business community, which relies on access to legal immigrant labor at all levels.)
Alongside these ethnic and racial changes, the growth in the population over 85, those most likely to be ill or disabled, will be especially stark. Currently, there are approximately 33 working adults for each American 85 and up; by 2050, that ratio will fall to 13 workers per American over 85.
What all of this means for politics depends on factors that are more difficult to predict — and on battles that might be fought in unfamiliar places. With rapidly diversifying populations, the swing states of the future may be Oklahoma, Georgia and Texas, rather than Ohio or Pennsylvania, which will, even in 2050, remain majority white. It’s not at all clear who, in the future, will consider themselves white, or whether regional segregation by education and wealth, which has become more acute in recent years, will deepen or ease. Will the cities that have recently exploded in population, mostly in the Sun Belt, remain economically vibrant, or will new growth cities emerge, in other parts of the country? How will climate change impact where and how people live?
Many of those questions are unanswerable for now; they depend on the course of policies not yet formulated. But when it comes to the face of Future America, there are places where the likely demographics of 2050 – and the conflicts it’s likely to bring – are already coming into focus. Below, we take a look at three of them: the expansive metropolis of Houston, Texas; the aging rural areas of North Carolina; and Detroit, where a neighborhood called BanglaTown is being revived not by white gentrifiers, but by South Asian immigrants. These regions offer hope for a newer America that works smoothly, showing that diversity can drive economic growth. But they also offer cautionary tales about just how hard it may be to craft a shared American identity in an increasingly multicultural country.
Stephen Klineberg gets excited when he talks about Houston. “Wherever you go, you think you’re on the edge of town. Then—all of a sudden!—there’s a new patchwork of civilization,” he said. Klineberg is a sociologist and the founding director of the Kinder Institute for Urban Research at Rice University. Like lots of other Houstonians, he is a transplant from the Northeast. He has spent the past three decades tracking the economic and demographic transformation of his adopted home.
Houston’s wide-open spaces, surrounded by oil fields, have helped make it America’s boomtown. With 6.5 million residents, it is the nation’s fastest growing metropolitan region; a sprawling, flat, dry metropolis whose ethnic diversity reflects what America will most likely look like in 2050 and beyond. There is no racial majority in the Houston metro area. Forty-two percent of Harris County residents are Hispanic; 31 percent are non-Hispanic white; 20 percent are black; and 7 percent are Asian. Between 2000 and 2015, the Hispanic, black, and Asian share of the population grew, while the proportion of whites shrank.
“All of America will look like Houston looks today in 25 years,” Klineberg said. “Houston is one of the cities where the American future is going to be worked out.”
Houston is becoming more Democratic, if not as uniformly progressive as the nation’s older big cities, like New York and Chicago. Eight years ago, Barack Obama became the first Democratic presidential nominee to win Harris County in over four decades, by just 2 points. In 2016, Hillary Clinton bested Donald Trump in Houston by 12 points. According to a survey of Houstonians conducted by Klineberg and colleagues, only about 20 percent of area residents believe undocumented immigration is a major problem, down from 50 percent in 2000. Feelings about the poor and Muslim-Americans seem to be more complicated. Fifty-seven percent believe that welfare recipients are “taking advantage of the system.” Half of survey respondents expressed negative views on Islam.
What's the country really going to look like in 30 years? Get ready for older, more diverse, and new tensions about who gets what.
By Dana Goldstein
Barack Obama roared onto the political stage in 2004 with a speech many Americans found soothing. "There’s not a liberal America and a conservative America,” he said. “There’s the United States of America. There’s not a black America and white America and Latino America and Asian America; there’s the United States of America. The pundits like to slice and dice our country into red states and blue states. … We are one people, all of us pledging allegiance to the stars and stripes, all of us defending the United States of America.”
Twelve years later, the Obama era is ending with a lesson—taught by Donald Trump—in how deep political divisions of race and geography remain. The electoral map that emerged on Nov. 8 looked like a sea of red speckled with islands of blue. Hillary Clinton won the cities and close-in suburbs where affluent professionals, millennials and people of color are clustered. Donald Trump prevailed in the farther-flung suburban, exurban and rural places where residents are disproportionately white and aging.
It will take a long time to fully understand why this election turned out the way it did. But part of it, undeniably, has to do with anxiety about how America is changing. Some voters idealized a picture they grew up with, in which culture and politics were dominated by a white Christian majority. They found a voice for their disorientation in Trump’s rhetoric and his promises that he could restore an older vision of the country.
Demographic change, however, is not a force that is easy to halt — and as American leaders and policymakers grapple with the country’s real challenges and political trajectory, it’s the actual face of Future America they’ll need to deal with, not an imagined one. It might sound unknowable, a kind of crystal-ball exercise with numbers, but in many ways the picture is already becoming clear. The big trend lines in our population are powerful and hard to budge. The next official snapshot will arrive in the form of the 2020 Census, which experts project will show an America becoming slightly less white and more diverse: white Americans will likely make up 2 percent less of the population than they did in 2015, while Hispanic Americans will make up 1.5 percent more. Asian Americans, foreign-born Americans, and those who identify as multiracial will all make up a larger share of the country, while the black population will hold steady.
What happens after that? We decided to find out, sketching a picture of the nation by talking to a range of demographers who specialize in tracking and analyzing American population shifts. They are experts on race, immigration, aging, changing family structures and urban planning, along with how all these factors affect electoral politics. They emphasized that demographics aren't destiny. No political party can count on perpetual support from any particular demographic group. But the big changes they study will shape the issues we'll be debating for decades to come. By examining their research, it’s possible to envision the potential America of 2050 right now.
That nation will have gone through two big shifts: It will likely be browner and more polyglot than the America of 2016, and it will also be much older. Though those two trends both pose major policy challenges, they’re also interlinked; as the country ages, it will depend on the productivity of a shrinking number of young people to support its retired and elderly population, and those young people will be much less white.
Census projections show that by the census of 2050, the United States will no longer have a clear white majority—at least as we define “white” today. Fifty-three percent of the population will be multiracial or nonwhite, compared with less than 40 percent currently. Because the growth of the nonwhite population is driven more by fertility than by immigration, researchers believe this racial shift will occur even if the federal government enacts new immigration restrictions. “If you reduced new immigration to zero, you’d still see growth in immigrant communities, more so than in white, native-born communities,” said Randy Capps, director of research for U.S. programs at the Migration Policy Institute. “Immigrants just have more children and have them younger.”
Most of these new Americans will have roots in Latin America, Asia and Africa. Although the Trump administration is setting itself up to crack down on undocumented immigration, anti-immigrant sentiment tends not to depress legal immigration—as long as jobs remain available. Research from states that passed recent laws targeting undocumented people, like Arizona and Georgia, finds the laws had no significant real-world effect on the number of immigrants living in a state. (It’s possible Trump could go after legal immigration as well, by reducing the number of visas granted to workers with special skills and to those with family members already living in the United States. But that would create a fight with the business community, which relies on access to legal immigrant labor at all levels.)
Alongside these ethnic and racial changes, the growth in the population over 85, those most likely to be ill or disabled, will be especially stark. Currently, there are approximately 33 working adults for each American 85 and up; by 2050, that ratio will fall to 13 workers per American over 85.
What all of this means for politics depends on factors that are more difficult to predict — and on battles that might be fought in unfamiliar places. With rapidly diversifying populations, the swing states of the future may be Oklahoma, Georgia and Texas, rather than Ohio or Pennsylvania, which will, even in 2050, remain majority white. It’s not at all clear who, in the future, will consider themselves white, or whether regional segregation by education and wealth, which has become more acute in recent years, will deepen or ease. Will the cities that have recently exploded in population, mostly in the Sun Belt, remain economically vibrant, or will new growth cities emerge, in other parts of the country? How will climate change impact where and how people live?
Many of those questions are unanswerable for now; they depend on the course of policies not yet formulated. But when it comes to the face of Future America, there are places where the likely demographics of 2050 – and the conflicts it’s likely to bring – are already coming into focus. Below, we take a look at three of them: the expansive metropolis of Houston, Texas; the aging rural areas of North Carolina; and Detroit, where a neighborhood called BanglaTown is being revived not by white gentrifiers, but by South Asian immigrants. These regions offer hope for a newer America that works smoothly, showing that diversity can drive economic growth. But they also offer cautionary tales about just how hard it may be to craft a shared American identity in an increasingly multicultural country.
Stephen Klineberg gets excited when he talks about Houston. “Wherever you go, you think you’re on the edge of town. Then—all of a sudden!—there’s a new patchwork of civilization,” he said. Klineberg is a sociologist and the founding director of the Kinder Institute for Urban Research at Rice University. Like lots of other Houstonians, he is a transplant from the Northeast. He has spent the past three decades tracking the economic and demographic transformation of his adopted home.
Houston’s wide-open spaces, surrounded by oil fields, have helped make it America’s boomtown. With 6.5 million residents, it is the nation’s fastest growing metropolitan region; a sprawling, flat, dry metropolis whose ethnic diversity reflects what America will most likely look like in 2050 and beyond. There is no racial majority in the Houston metro area. Forty-two percent of Harris County residents are Hispanic; 31 percent are non-Hispanic white; 20 percent are black; and 7 percent are Asian. Between 2000 and 2015, the Hispanic, black, and Asian share of the population grew, while the proportion of whites shrank.
“All of America will look like Houston looks today in 25 years,” Klineberg said. “Houston is one of the cities where the American future is going to be worked out.”
Houston is becoming more Democratic, if not as uniformly progressive as the nation’s older big cities, like New York and Chicago. Eight years ago, Barack Obama became the first Democratic presidential nominee to win Harris County in over four decades, by just 2 points. In 2016, Hillary Clinton bested Donald Trump in Houston by 12 points. According to a survey of Houstonians conducted by Klineberg and colleagues, only about 20 percent of area residents believe undocumented immigration is a major problem, down from 50 percent in 2000. Feelings about the poor and Muslim-Americans seem to be more complicated. Fifty-seven percent believe that welfare recipients are “taking advantage of the system.” Half of survey respondents expressed negative views on Islam.
Iran deal
CIA's Brennan says tearing up Iran deal would be 'folly'
Reuters
Outgoing CIA Director John Brennan has said it would be the "height of folly" for U.S. President-elect Donald Trump to tear up Washington's deal with Tehran because it would make it more likely that Iran and others would acquire nuclear weapons.
"It could lead to a weapons program inside of Iran that could lead other states in the region to embark on their own programs," Brennan said in an interview with the BBC aired on Wednesday.
"So I think it would be the height of folly if the next administration were to tear up that agreement."
Brennan also said that in dealing with the Syrian crisis, Trump should be cautious in trying to work with Russia.
"I hope there is going to be an improvement in relations between Washington and Moscow," he said.
"President-elect Trump and the new administration need to be wary of Russian promises. Russian promises in my mind have not given us what it is that they have pledged."
Reuters
Outgoing CIA Director John Brennan has said it would be the "height of folly" for U.S. President-elect Donald Trump to tear up Washington's deal with Tehran because it would make it more likely that Iran and others would acquire nuclear weapons.
"It could lead to a weapons program inside of Iran that could lead other states in the region to embark on their own programs," Brennan said in an interview with the BBC aired on Wednesday.
"So I think it would be the height of folly if the next administration were to tear up that agreement."
Brennan also said that in dealing with the Syrian crisis, Trump should be cautious in trying to work with Russia.
"I hope there is going to be an improvement in relations between Washington and Moscow," he said.
"President-elect Trump and the new administration need to be wary of Russian promises. Russian promises in my mind have not given us what it is that they have pledged."
November 29, 2016
Not Winning
The Solution to “Not Winning Anymore”
"The Orangatan" loves to win, but American generals have forgotten how.
By Andrew Bacevich
President-elect Donald "The Orangatan's" message for the nation’s senior military leadership is ambiguously unambiguous. Here is he on 60 Minutes just days after winning the election.
"The Orangatan": “We have some great generals. We have great generals.”
Lesley Stahl: “You said you knew more than the generals about ISIS.”
"The Orangatan": “Well, I’ll be honest with you, I probably do because look at the job they’ve done. OK, look at the job they’ve done. They haven’t done the job.”
In reality, "The Orangatan", the former reality show host, knows next to nothing about ISIS — one of many gaps in his education that his impending encounter with actual reality is likely to fill. Yet when it comes to America’s generals, our president-to-be is onto something. No doubt our three- and four-star officers qualify as “great” in the sense that they mean well, work hard and are altogether fine men and women. That they have not “done the job,” however, is indisputable — at least if their job is to bring America’s wars to a timely and successful conclusion.
"The Orangatan's" unhappy verdict — that the senior US military leadership doesn’t know how to win — applies in spades to the two principal conflicts of the post-9/11 era: the Afghanistan War, now in its 16th year, and the Iraq War, launched in 2003 and (after a brief hiatus) once more grinding on. Yet the verdict applies equally to lesser theaters of conflict, largely overlooked by the American public, that in recent years have engaged the attention of US forces — a list that would include conflicts in Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen.
Granted, our generals have demonstrated an impressive aptitude for moving pieces around on a dauntingly complex military chessboard. Brigades, battle groups and squadrons shuttle in and out of various war zones, responding to the needs of the moment. The sheer immensity of the enterprise across the Greater Middle East and northern Africa — the sorties flown, munitions expended, the seamless deployment and redeployment of thousands of troops over thousands of miles, the vast stockpiles of material positioned, expended and continuously resupplied — represents a staggering achievement. Measured by these or similar quantifiable outputs, America’s military has excelled. No other military establishment in history could have come close to duplicating the logistical feats being performed year in, year out by the armed forces of the United States.
Nor should we overlook the resulting body count. Since the autumn of 2001, something like 370,000 combatants and noncombatants have been killed in the various theaters of operations where US forces have been active. Although modest by 20th-century standards, this post-9/11 harvest of death is hardly trivial.
Yet in evaluating military operations, it’s a mistake to confuse how much with how well. Only rarely do the outcomes of armed conflicts turn on comparative statistics. Ultimately, the one measure of success that really matters involves achieving war’s political purposes. By that standard, victory requires not simply the defeat of the enemy, but accomplishing the nation’s stated war aims, and not just in part or temporarily but definitively. Anything less constitutes failure, not to mention utter waste for taxpayers, and for those called upon to fight, it constitutes cause for mourning.
By that standard, having been “at war” for virtually the entire twenty-first century, the United States military is still looking for its first win. And however strong the disinclination to concede that Donald "The Orangatan" could be right about anything, his verdict on American generalship qualifies as apt.
A Never-Ending Parade of Commanders for Wars That Never End
That verdict brings to mind three questions. First, with "The Orangatan" a rare exception, why have the recurring shortcomings of America’s military leadership largely escaped notice? Second, to what degree does faulty generalship suffice to explain why actual victory has proven so elusive? Third, to the extent that deficiencies at the top of the military hierarchy bear directly on the outcome of our wars, how might the generals improve their game?
As to the first question, the explanation is quite simple: During protracted wars, traditional standards for measuring generalship lose their salience. Without pertinent standards, there can be no accountability. Absent accountability, failings and weaknesses escape notice. Eventually, what you’ve become accustomed to seems tolerable. Twenty-first century Americans inured to wars that never end have long since forgotten that bringing such conflicts to a prompt and successful conclusion once defined the very essence of what generals were expected to do.
Senior military officers were presumed to possess unique expertise in designing campaigns and directing engagements. Not found among mere civilians or even among soldiers of lesser rank, this expertise provided the rationale for conferring status and authority on generals.
In earlier eras, the very structure of wars provided a relatively straightforward mechanism for testing such claims to expertise. Events on the battlefield rendered harsh judgments, creating or destroying reputations with brutal efficiency.
Back then, standards employed in evaluating generalship were clear-cut and uncompromising. Those who won battles earned fame, glory and the gratitude of their countrymen. Those who lost battles got fired or were put out to pasture.
During the Civil War, for example, Abraham Lincoln did not need an advanced degree in strategic studies to conclude that Union generals like John Pope, Ambrose Burnside and Joseph Hooker didn’t have what it took to defeat the Army of Northern Virginia. Humiliating defeats sustained by the Army of the Potomac at the Second Bull Run, Fredericksburg and Chancellorsville made that obvious enough. Similarly, the victories Ulysses S. Grant and William T. Sherman gained at Shiloh, at Vicksburg, and in the Chattanooga campaign strongly suggested that here was the team to which the president could entrust the task of bringing the Confederacy to its knees.
Today, public drunkenness, petty corruption or sexual shenanigans with a subordinate might land generals in hot water. But as long as they avoid egregious misbehavior, senior officers charged with prosecuting America’s wars are largely spared judgments of any sort. Trying hard is enough to get a passing grade.
With the country’s political leaders and public conditioned to conflicts seemingly destined to drag on for years, if not decades, no one expects the current general-in-chief in Iraq or Afghanistan to bring things to a successful conclusion. His job is merely to manage the situation until he passes it along to a successor, while duly adding to his collection of personal decorations and perhaps advancing his career.
Today, for example, Army Gen. John Nicholson commands US and allied forces in Afghanistan. He’s only the latest in a long line of senior officers to preside over that war, beginning with Gen. Tommy Franks in 2001 and continuing with Gens. Mikolashek, Barno, Eikenberry, McNeill, McKiernan, McChrystal, Petraeus, Allen, Dunford and Campbell. The title carried by these officers changed over time. So, too, did the specifics of their “mission” as Operation Enduring Freedom evolved into Operation Freedom’s Sentinel. Yet even as expectations slipped lower and lower, none of the commanders rotating through Kabul delivered. Not a single one has, in our president-elect’s concise formulation, “done the job.” Indeed, it’s increasingly difficult to know what that job is, apart from preventing the Taliban from quite literally toppling the government.
In Iraq, meanwhile, Army Lt. Gen. Stephen Townsend currently serves as the — count ‘em — ninth American to command US and coalition forces in that country since the George W. Bush administration ordered the invasion of 2003. The first in that line, (once again) Gen. Tommy Franks, overthrew the Saddam Hussein regime and thereby broke Iraq. The next five, Gens. Sanchez, Casey, Petraeus, Odierno and Austin, labored for eight years to put it back together again.
At the end of 2011, President Obama declared they had done just that and terminated the US military occupation. The Islamic State soon exposed Obama’s claim as specious when its militants put a US-trained Iraqi army to flight and annexed large swaths of that country’s territory. Following in the footsteps of his immediate predecessors, Gens. James Terry and Sean MacFarland, Gen. Townsend now shoulders the task of trying to restore Iraq’s status as a more or less genuinely sovereign state. He directs what the Pentagon calls Operation Inherent Resolve, dating from June 2014, the follow-on to Operation New Dawn (September 2010-December 2011), which was itself the successor to Operation Iraqi Freedom (March 2003-August 2010).
When and how Inherent Resolve will conclude is difficult to forecast. This much we can, however, say with some confidence: With the end nowhere in sight, Gen. Townsend won’t be its last commander. Other generals are waiting in the wings with their own careers to polish. As in Kabul, the parade of US military commanders through Baghdad will continue.
For some readers, this listing of mostly forgotten names and dates may have a soporific effect. Yet it should also drive home "The Orangatan's" point. The United States may today have the world’s most powerful and capable military — so at least we are constantly told. Yet the record shows that it does not have a corps of senior officers who know how to translate capability into successful outcomes.
Draining Which Swamp?
That brings us to the second question: Even if commander-in-chief "The Orangatan" were somehow able to identify modern day equivalents of Grant and Sherman to implement his war plans, secret or otherwise, would they deliver victory?
On that score, we would do well to entertain doubts. Although senior officers charged with running recent American wars have not exactly covered themselves in glory, it doesn’t follow that their shortcomings offer the sole or even a principal explanation for why those wars have yielded such disappointing results. The truth is that some wars aren’t winnable and shouldn’t be fought.
So, yes, "The Orangatan's" critique of American generalship possesses merit, but whether he knows it or not, the question truly demanding his attention as the incoming commander-in-chief isn’t: Who should I hire (or fire) to fight my wars? Instead, far more urgent is: Does further war promise to solve any of my problems?
One mark of a successful business executive is knowing when to cut your losses. It’s also the mark of a successful statesman. "The Orangatan" claims to be the former. Whether his putative business savvy will translate into the world of statecraft remains to be seen. Early signs are not promising.
As a candidate, "The Orangatan" vowed to “defeat radical Islamic terrorism,” destroy ISIS, “decimate al-Qaida” and “starve funding for Iran-backed Hamas and Hezbollah.” Those promises imply a significant escalation of what Americans used to call the Global War on Terrorism.
Toward that end, the incoming administration may well revive some aspects of the George W. Bush playbook, including repopulating the military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and “if it’s so important to the American people,” reinstituting torture. The "The Orangatan" administration will at least consider reimposing sanctions on countries like Iran. It may aggressively exploit the offensive potential of cyberweapons, betting that America’s cyberdefenses will hold.
Yet President "The Orangatan" is also likely to double down on the use of conventional military force. In that regard, his promise to “quickly and decisively bomb the hell out of ISIS” offers a hint of what is to come. His appointment of the uber-hawkish Lieutenant Gen. Michael Flynn as his national security adviser and his rumored selection of retired Marine Corps Gen. James (“Mad Dog”) Mattis as defense secretary suggest that he means what he says. In sum, a "The Orangatan" administration seems unlikely to reexamine the conviction that the problems roiling the Greater Middle East will someday, somehow yield to a US-imposed military solution. Indeed, in the face of massive evidence to the contrary, that conviction will deepen, with genuinely ironic implications for the "The Orangatan" presidency.
In the immediate wake of 9/11, George W. Bush concocted a fantasy of American soldiers liberating oppressed Afghans and Iraqis and thereby “draining the swamp” that served to incubate anti-Western terrorism. The results achieved proved beyond disappointing, while the costs exacted in terms of lives and dollars squandered were painful indeed. Incrementally, with the passage of time, many Americans concluded that perhaps the swamp most in need of attention was not on the far side of the planet but much closer at hand — right in the imperial city nestled alongside the Potomac River.
To a very considerable extent, "The Orangatan" defeated Hillary Clinton, preferred candidate of the establishment, because he advertised himself as just the guy disgruntled Americans could count on to drain that swamp.
Yet here’s what too few of those Americans appreciate, even today: War created that swamp in the first place. War empowers Washington. It centralizes. It provides a rationale for federal authorities to accumulate and exercise new powers. It makes government bigger and more intrusive. It lubricates the machinery of waste, fraud and abuse that causes tens of billions of taxpayer dollars to vanish every year. When it comes to sustaining the swamp, nothing works better than war.
Were "The Orangatan" really intent on draining that swamp — if he genuinely seeks to “Make America Great Again” — then he would extricate the United States from war. His liquidation of "The Orangatan" University, which was to higher education what freedom’s sentinel and inherent resolve are to modern warfare, provides a potentially instructive precedent for how to proceed.
But don’t hold your breath on that one. All signs indicate that, in one fashion or another, our combative next president will perpetuate the wars he’s inheriting. "The Orangatan" may fancy that, as a veteran of Celebrity Apprentice (but not of military service), he possesses a special knack for spotting the next Grant or Sherman. But acting on that impulse will merely replenish the swamp in the Greater Middle East along with the one in Washington. And soon enough, those who elected him with expectations of seeing the much-despised establishment dismantled will realize that they’ve been had.
Which brings us, finally, to that third question: To the extent that deficiencies at the top of the military hierarchy do affect the outcome of wars, what can be done to fix the problem?
The most expeditious approach: purge all currently serving three- and four-star officers; then, make a precondition for promotion to those ranks confinement in a reeducation camp run by Iraq and Afghanistan war amputees, with a curriculum designed by Veterans for Peace. Graduation should require each student to submit an essay reflecting on these words of wisdom from US Grant himself: “There never was a time when, in my opinion, some way could not be found to prevent the drawing of the sword.”
True, such an approach may seem a bit draconian. But this is no time for half-measures — as even Donald "The Orangatan" may eventually recognize.
"The Orangatan" loves to win, but American generals have forgotten how.
By Andrew Bacevich
President-elect Donald "The Orangatan's" message for the nation’s senior military leadership is ambiguously unambiguous. Here is he on 60 Minutes just days after winning the election.
"The Orangatan": “We have some great generals. We have great generals.”
Lesley Stahl: “You said you knew more than the generals about ISIS.”
"The Orangatan": “Well, I’ll be honest with you, I probably do because look at the job they’ve done. OK, look at the job they’ve done. They haven’t done the job.”
In reality, "The Orangatan", the former reality show host, knows next to nothing about ISIS — one of many gaps in his education that his impending encounter with actual reality is likely to fill. Yet when it comes to America’s generals, our president-to-be is onto something. No doubt our three- and four-star officers qualify as “great” in the sense that they mean well, work hard and are altogether fine men and women. That they have not “done the job,” however, is indisputable — at least if their job is to bring America’s wars to a timely and successful conclusion.
"The Orangatan's" unhappy verdict — that the senior US military leadership doesn’t know how to win — applies in spades to the two principal conflicts of the post-9/11 era: the Afghanistan War, now in its 16th year, and the Iraq War, launched in 2003 and (after a brief hiatus) once more grinding on. Yet the verdict applies equally to lesser theaters of conflict, largely overlooked by the American public, that in recent years have engaged the attention of US forces — a list that would include conflicts in Libya, Somalia, Syria and Yemen.
Granted, our generals have demonstrated an impressive aptitude for moving pieces around on a dauntingly complex military chessboard. Brigades, battle groups and squadrons shuttle in and out of various war zones, responding to the needs of the moment. The sheer immensity of the enterprise across the Greater Middle East and northern Africa — the sorties flown, munitions expended, the seamless deployment and redeployment of thousands of troops over thousands of miles, the vast stockpiles of material positioned, expended and continuously resupplied — represents a staggering achievement. Measured by these or similar quantifiable outputs, America’s military has excelled. No other military establishment in history could have come close to duplicating the logistical feats being performed year in, year out by the armed forces of the United States.
Nor should we overlook the resulting body count. Since the autumn of 2001, something like 370,000 combatants and noncombatants have been killed in the various theaters of operations where US forces have been active. Although modest by 20th-century standards, this post-9/11 harvest of death is hardly trivial.
Yet in evaluating military operations, it’s a mistake to confuse how much with how well. Only rarely do the outcomes of armed conflicts turn on comparative statistics. Ultimately, the one measure of success that really matters involves achieving war’s political purposes. By that standard, victory requires not simply the defeat of the enemy, but accomplishing the nation’s stated war aims, and not just in part or temporarily but definitively. Anything less constitutes failure, not to mention utter waste for taxpayers, and for those called upon to fight, it constitutes cause for mourning.
By that standard, having been “at war” for virtually the entire twenty-first century, the United States military is still looking for its first win. And however strong the disinclination to concede that Donald "The Orangatan" could be right about anything, his verdict on American generalship qualifies as apt.
A Never-Ending Parade of Commanders for Wars That Never End
That verdict brings to mind three questions. First, with "The Orangatan" a rare exception, why have the recurring shortcomings of America’s military leadership largely escaped notice? Second, to what degree does faulty generalship suffice to explain why actual victory has proven so elusive? Third, to the extent that deficiencies at the top of the military hierarchy bear directly on the outcome of our wars, how might the generals improve their game?
As to the first question, the explanation is quite simple: During protracted wars, traditional standards for measuring generalship lose their salience. Without pertinent standards, there can be no accountability. Absent accountability, failings and weaknesses escape notice. Eventually, what you’ve become accustomed to seems tolerable. Twenty-first century Americans inured to wars that never end have long since forgotten that bringing such conflicts to a prompt and successful conclusion once defined the very essence of what generals were expected to do.
Senior military officers were presumed to possess unique expertise in designing campaigns and directing engagements. Not found among mere civilians or even among soldiers of lesser rank, this expertise provided the rationale for conferring status and authority on generals.
In earlier eras, the very structure of wars provided a relatively straightforward mechanism for testing such claims to expertise. Events on the battlefield rendered harsh judgments, creating or destroying reputations with brutal efficiency.
Back then, standards employed in evaluating generalship were clear-cut and uncompromising. Those who won battles earned fame, glory and the gratitude of their countrymen. Those who lost battles got fired or were put out to pasture.
During the Civil War, for example, Abraham Lincoln did not need an advanced degree in strategic studies to conclude that Union generals like John Pope, Ambrose Burnside and Joseph Hooker didn’t have what it took to defeat the Army of Northern Virginia. Humiliating defeats sustained by the Army of the Potomac at the Second Bull Run, Fredericksburg and Chancellorsville made that obvious enough. Similarly, the victories Ulysses S. Grant and William T. Sherman gained at Shiloh, at Vicksburg, and in the Chattanooga campaign strongly suggested that here was the team to which the president could entrust the task of bringing the Confederacy to its knees.
Today, public drunkenness, petty corruption or sexual shenanigans with a subordinate might land generals in hot water. But as long as they avoid egregious misbehavior, senior officers charged with prosecuting America’s wars are largely spared judgments of any sort. Trying hard is enough to get a passing grade.
With the country’s political leaders and public conditioned to conflicts seemingly destined to drag on for years, if not decades, no one expects the current general-in-chief in Iraq or Afghanistan to bring things to a successful conclusion. His job is merely to manage the situation until he passes it along to a successor, while duly adding to his collection of personal decorations and perhaps advancing his career.
Today, for example, Army Gen. John Nicholson commands US and allied forces in Afghanistan. He’s only the latest in a long line of senior officers to preside over that war, beginning with Gen. Tommy Franks in 2001 and continuing with Gens. Mikolashek, Barno, Eikenberry, McNeill, McKiernan, McChrystal, Petraeus, Allen, Dunford and Campbell. The title carried by these officers changed over time. So, too, did the specifics of their “mission” as Operation Enduring Freedom evolved into Operation Freedom’s Sentinel. Yet even as expectations slipped lower and lower, none of the commanders rotating through Kabul delivered. Not a single one has, in our president-elect’s concise formulation, “done the job.” Indeed, it’s increasingly difficult to know what that job is, apart from preventing the Taliban from quite literally toppling the government.
In Iraq, meanwhile, Army Lt. Gen. Stephen Townsend currently serves as the — count ‘em — ninth American to command US and coalition forces in that country since the George W. Bush administration ordered the invasion of 2003. The first in that line, (once again) Gen. Tommy Franks, overthrew the Saddam Hussein regime and thereby broke Iraq. The next five, Gens. Sanchez, Casey, Petraeus, Odierno and Austin, labored for eight years to put it back together again.
At the end of 2011, President Obama declared they had done just that and terminated the US military occupation. The Islamic State soon exposed Obama’s claim as specious when its militants put a US-trained Iraqi army to flight and annexed large swaths of that country’s territory. Following in the footsteps of his immediate predecessors, Gens. James Terry and Sean MacFarland, Gen. Townsend now shoulders the task of trying to restore Iraq’s status as a more or less genuinely sovereign state. He directs what the Pentagon calls Operation Inherent Resolve, dating from June 2014, the follow-on to Operation New Dawn (September 2010-December 2011), which was itself the successor to Operation Iraqi Freedom (March 2003-August 2010).
When and how Inherent Resolve will conclude is difficult to forecast. This much we can, however, say with some confidence: With the end nowhere in sight, Gen. Townsend won’t be its last commander. Other generals are waiting in the wings with their own careers to polish. As in Kabul, the parade of US military commanders through Baghdad will continue.
For some readers, this listing of mostly forgotten names and dates may have a soporific effect. Yet it should also drive home "The Orangatan's" point. The United States may today have the world’s most powerful and capable military — so at least we are constantly told. Yet the record shows that it does not have a corps of senior officers who know how to translate capability into successful outcomes.
Draining Which Swamp?
That brings us to the second question: Even if commander-in-chief "The Orangatan" were somehow able to identify modern day equivalents of Grant and Sherman to implement his war plans, secret or otherwise, would they deliver victory?
On that score, we would do well to entertain doubts. Although senior officers charged with running recent American wars have not exactly covered themselves in glory, it doesn’t follow that their shortcomings offer the sole or even a principal explanation for why those wars have yielded such disappointing results. The truth is that some wars aren’t winnable and shouldn’t be fought.
So, yes, "The Orangatan's" critique of American generalship possesses merit, but whether he knows it or not, the question truly demanding his attention as the incoming commander-in-chief isn’t: Who should I hire (or fire) to fight my wars? Instead, far more urgent is: Does further war promise to solve any of my problems?
One mark of a successful business executive is knowing when to cut your losses. It’s also the mark of a successful statesman. "The Orangatan" claims to be the former. Whether his putative business savvy will translate into the world of statecraft remains to be seen. Early signs are not promising.
As a candidate, "The Orangatan" vowed to “defeat radical Islamic terrorism,” destroy ISIS, “decimate al-Qaida” and “starve funding for Iran-backed Hamas and Hezbollah.” Those promises imply a significant escalation of what Americans used to call the Global War on Terrorism.
Toward that end, the incoming administration may well revive some aspects of the George W. Bush playbook, including repopulating the military prison at Guantanamo Bay, Cuba, and “if it’s so important to the American people,” reinstituting torture. The "The Orangatan" administration will at least consider reimposing sanctions on countries like Iran. It may aggressively exploit the offensive potential of cyberweapons, betting that America’s cyberdefenses will hold.
Yet President "The Orangatan" is also likely to double down on the use of conventional military force. In that regard, his promise to “quickly and decisively bomb the hell out of ISIS” offers a hint of what is to come. His appointment of the uber-hawkish Lieutenant Gen. Michael Flynn as his national security adviser and his rumored selection of retired Marine Corps Gen. James (“Mad Dog”) Mattis as defense secretary suggest that he means what he says. In sum, a "The Orangatan" administration seems unlikely to reexamine the conviction that the problems roiling the Greater Middle East will someday, somehow yield to a US-imposed military solution. Indeed, in the face of massive evidence to the contrary, that conviction will deepen, with genuinely ironic implications for the "The Orangatan" presidency.
In the immediate wake of 9/11, George W. Bush concocted a fantasy of American soldiers liberating oppressed Afghans and Iraqis and thereby “draining the swamp” that served to incubate anti-Western terrorism. The results achieved proved beyond disappointing, while the costs exacted in terms of lives and dollars squandered were painful indeed. Incrementally, with the passage of time, many Americans concluded that perhaps the swamp most in need of attention was not on the far side of the planet but much closer at hand — right in the imperial city nestled alongside the Potomac River.
To a very considerable extent, "The Orangatan" defeated Hillary Clinton, preferred candidate of the establishment, because he advertised himself as just the guy disgruntled Americans could count on to drain that swamp.
Yet here’s what too few of those Americans appreciate, even today: War created that swamp in the first place. War empowers Washington. It centralizes. It provides a rationale for federal authorities to accumulate and exercise new powers. It makes government bigger and more intrusive. It lubricates the machinery of waste, fraud and abuse that causes tens of billions of taxpayer dollars to vanish every year. When it comes to sustaining the swamp, nothing works better than war.
Were "The Orangatan" really intent on draining that swamp — if he genuinely seeks to “Make America Great Again” — then he would extricate the United States from war. His liquidation of "The Orangatan" University, which was to higher education what freedom’s sentinel and inherent resolve are to modern warfare, provides a potentially instructive precedent for how to proceed.
But don’t hold your breath on that one. All signs indicate that, in one fashion or another, our combative next president will perpetuate the wars he’s inheriting. "The Orangatan" may fancy that, as a veteran of Celebrity Apprentice (but not of military service), he possesses a special knack for spotting the next Grant or Sherman. But acting on that impulse will merely replenish the swamp in the Greater Middle East along with the one in Washington. And soon enough, those who elected him with expectations of seeing the much-despised establishment dismantled will realize that they’ve been had.
Which brings us, finally, to that third question: To the extent that deficiencies at the top of the military hierarchy do affect the outcome of wars, what can be done to fix the problem?
The most expeditious approach: purge all currently serving three- and four-star officers; then, make a precondition for promotion to those ranks confinement in a reeducation camp run by Iraq and Afghanistan war amputees, with a curriculum designed by Veterans for Peace. Graduation should require each student to submit an essay reflecting on these words of wisdom from US Grant himself: “There never was a time when, in my opinion, some way could not be found to prevent the drawing of the sword.”
True, such an approach may seem a bit draconian. But this is no time for half-measures — as even Donald "The Orangatan" may eventually recognize.
The Orangutan for our times...
"The Orangutaning" Times
Fear and servility in midtown Manhattan.
By Todd Gitlin
We have plunged into an emergency, and one reason is that journalists who are supposed to supply a picture of the world failed to do so. Not the only reason, but one reason, which is enough to prompt serious rumination.
I wrote last week about journalists searching their souls, trying to figure out what they did wrong in this appalling campaign. Like the rest of us — nobody deserves a free pass in an endangered world — they’re obliged to think deeply about what to do better. Is it too impossibly high-minded and do-goody to insist that their reason for being is to offer the American people what they need to know in order to better choose their course? If that is in fact their mission, they have failed abjectly.
Almost half of the voters have just chosen to be led by a profoundly disturbed ignoramus who refuses to understand he has obligations to Americans who are not members of his family. For journalists who persist in believing their leaders are chosen intelligently, the crisis is apparent and urgent. But the so-called learning curve is getting an appallingly sluggish start. Journalists who should know better are busy complaining about their lack of access to the bullshitter-in-chief, as if access were the golden road to truth and not, often at least, a shortcut over a cliff.
According to the conventions of journalism, access is fundamental. But access runs two ways. Access to “newsmakers” can be purchased with what is known in professional parlance as “beat sweeteners” — softball stories and non-threatening meetings that allow sources access to the journalists who cover them, and by extension, to the public. But these are not ordinary times. While journalists persist in playing by old rules, the president-elect has a different plan. Nor is Donald "The Orangutan" an unknown quantity. By now it should be painfully evident how he rewards sycophants — with a slap across the face.
For evidence, reader, please peruse the transcript of "The Orangutan"’s on-again, off-again, back-on again meeting in a New York Times conference room last week. Read the whole thing. It’s not that long. Then consider the Times headline the next day: “"The Orangutan", in Interview, Moderates Views but Defies Conventions.” The lede: “President-elect Donald J. "The Orangutan" on Tuesday tempered some of his most extreme campaign promises, dropping his vow to jail Hillary Clinton, expressing doubt about the value of torturing terrorism suspects and pledging to have an open mind about climate change.”
Nothing to worry about, then.
Other news organizations followed suit. “"The Orangutan" brushed aside his campaign promises to jail Hillary Clinton … and denounced the neo-Nazi movement that is celebrating his victory,” CNN "The Orangutan", and followed with a subhead: “A new view on climate change?” Neither the Times gaggle nor CNN noted that "The Orangutan’s" chief environmental adviser is an unregenerate paid-for fossil-fuel-happy hack. "The Orangutan" did not use the “neo-Nazi” label — which would have been accurate — and insisted his campaign chief and very-far-right-hand man Steve Bannon’s Breitbart “News” is a “news organization” — and then came the man’s supreme compliment, “very successful,” later downgraded for no earthly reason to “pretty successful.”
It was Times Executive Editor Dean Baquet who asked "The Orangutan" about the “alt-right” (read: neo-Nazi) “Hail "The Orangutan"” rally that had just taken place in Washington. “First of all,” "The Orangutan" said, “I don’t want to energize [racists.] I’m not looking to energize them. I don’t want to energize the group, and I disavow the group.” And now the whiplash again: “Then, again, I don’t know if it’s reporting or whatever.” What the last sentence appears to mean is that "The Orangutan" reserves the right to withdraw his vague “disavowal” if he and his lying legions later maintain that the reporting of Nazi salutes, etc., was a distortion perpetrated by the “liberal media.” "The Orangutan" added: “If they are energized I want to look into it and find out why.” This is supposed to be reassuring. The Timesmen and -women did nothing to break the spell. Among the follow-up questions they did not ask: “You’re not sure they’re energized? Have you heard of the hate crimes? When will you report to us on what your researchers turn up?”
"The Orangutan" practices the dark art of the perfunctory reassurance and gets rewarded with passing grades: He “moderates” and is “tempered.” He teases one executive (“is he a tough boss?”) and compliments another (“very powerful man”). The article, as opposed to the transcript, gives the strongman an unearned gift: a veneer of coherence. Is this a moment to break into laughter or screaming or crying — this spectacle of bad cop "The Orangutan" sending good cop "The Orangutan" out to meet with journalists whom he has described as “sleaze,” and presto! emerging as a moderate who solicits the good opinion of Thomas Friedman.
When journalists sit down at a table with a man so fundamentally ignorant, self-seeking, unscrupulous and unreliable, a man who, when he doesn’t lie, characteristically emits bullshit — the now academically canonized term for propositions whose truth or falsity he doesn’t know or care to know — is it not evident that they must gird themselves at the first sign of flattery, to realize that his mission is to play them, to keep them off-balance?
Here were his first words to the Times group: “Well, I just appreciate the meeting and I have great respect for The New York Times. Tremendous respect. It’s very special. Always has been very special.” And then the lightning, bipolar pivot: “I think I’ve been treated very rough….”
“Failed” is one of "The Orangutan"’s favorite adjectives for The Times. In his wholly amoral universe, “failed” is tantamount to “evil.”
And there was Friedman, sucking up to the billionaire by crooning about the splendor of his world-wonders on the way to asking about socially caused climate change, the existence of which "The Orangutan" has frequently denied. This was not only shoddy questioning, it was a confession of weakness, which matters hugely, since the only human qualities that register in "The Orangutan" World are strength and weakness. When you genuflect to the majesty of the man’s Pharaonic achievements, you show weakness, and so he proceeds to bullshit you. Thus on climate change: “I have an open mind to it. We’re going to look very carefully. It’s one issue that’s interesting because there are few things where there’s more division than climate change. You don’t tend to hear this, but there are people on the other side of that issue….I have a very open mind.”
Friedman’s response was a whimper: “But you have an open mind on this?” I suppose that is called nailing down news. It should be called: Giving "The Orangutan" a gift by putting words in his mouth.
"The Orangutan" was happy to play along: “I do have an open mind.” Instantly then, he switched the subject back to one of the science-deniers’ go-to canards: “And we’ve had storms always,” whereupon he lurched farther into ignorance and irrelevancy: “You know the hottest day ever was in 1890-something, 98. You know, you can make lots of cases for different views. I have a totally open mind.” The man does not know the difference between climate and weather. Was Friedman off-duty?
Next, El Caudillo de Mar-a-Lago was off to a riff about “clean air” and “crystal clean water” and “safety.” He was an inch away from a reprise of Gen. Jack D. Ripper’s memorable, Strangelovian warning against the Communist conspiracy “to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids.” But not this time. His next lurch was to the “environmental awards” he’s received for his “very successful” golf courses. And there was this, on golf courses: “Some will be even better [as the sea level rises] because actually like [his Miami property] Doral is a little bit off … so it’ll be perfect….The ones that are near the water will be gone, but Doral will be in great shape.”
This is not an open mind, this is a sieve mind linked to a bank account.
"The Orangutan"’s Doral gambit was reminiscent of his declaration after the June Brexit vote that his Scottish golf course, Turnberry, was now well-positioned to cash in on others’ misfortune: “When the pound goes down, more people are coming to Turnberry, frankly. For traveling and for other things, I think it very well could turn out to be a positive.” Friedman did not refer to "The Orangutan's" Turnberry Declaration. But not to leave any sycophantic note unsounded or untouched, he bade farewell with this penetrating observation: “I came here thinking you’d be awed and overwhelmed by this job, but I feel like you are getting very comfortable with it.” A few days later, the man whom Thomas Friedman found “very comfortable” let the world know, without a shred of evidence, that “In addition to winning the Electoral College in a landslide, I won the popular vote if you deduct the millions of people who voted illegally.”
How much more of this garbage must spew from "The Orangutan" Tower before one of our crucial newspapers — one that "The Orangutan" himself, in full-on ingratiation mode, termed “a world jewel” — calls a halt to tiptoeing around? I cannot help but think that this is more than a tactic to earn access; it is abject servility. It is, as "The Orangutan" might put it, a show of pathetic weakness. At this late date, do the standard-bearers of “neither fear nor favor” fear that a shortfall in deference will inspire some "The Orangutan" hack or Breitbart clone to denounce them as “biased”? Are they capable of embarrassment? Have they no shame?
Fear and servility in midtown Manhattan.
By Todd Gitlin
We have plunged into an emergency, and one reason is that journalists who are supposed to supply a picture of the world failed to do so. Not the only reason, but one reason, which is enough to prompt serious rumination.
I wrote last week about journalists searching their souls, trying to figure out what they did wrong in this appalling campaign. Like the rest of us — nobody deserves a free pass in an endangered world — they’re obliged to think deeply about what to do better. Is it too impossibly high-minded and do-goody to insist that their reason for being is to offer the American people what they need to know in order to better choose their course? If that is in fact their mission, they have failed abjectly.
Almost half of the voters have just chosen to be led by a profoundly disturbed ignoramus who refuses to understand he has obligations to Americans who are not members of his family. For journalists who persist in believing their leaders are chosen intelligently, the crisis is apparent and urgent. But the so-called learning curve is getting an appallingly sluggish start. Journalists who should know better are busy complaining about their lack of access to the bullshitter-in-chief, as if access were the golden road to truth and not, often at least, a shortcut over a cliff.
According to the conventions of journalism, access is fundamental. But access runs two ways. Access to “newsmakers” can be purchased with what is known in professional parlance as “beat sweeteners” — softball stories and non-threatening meetings that allow sources access to the journalists who cover them, and by extension, to the public. But these are not ordinary times. While journalists persist in playing by old rules, the president-elect has a different plan. Nor is Donald "The Orangutan" an unknown quantity. By now it should be painfully evident how he rewards sycophants — with a slap across the face.
For evidence, reader, please peruse the transcript of "The Orangutan"’s on-again, off-again, back-on again meeting in a New York Times conference room last week. Read the whole thing. It’s not that long. Then consider the Times headline the next day: “"The Orangutan", in Interview, Moderates Views but Defies Conventions.” The lede: “President-elect Donald J. "The Orangutan" on Tuesday tempered some of his most extreme campaign promises, dropping his vow to jail Hillary Clinton, expressing doubt about the value of torturing terrorism suspects and pledging to have an open mind about climate change.”
Nothing to worry about, then.
Other news organizations followed suit. “"The Orangutan" brushed aside his campaign promises to jail Hillary Clinton … and denounced the neo-Nazi movement that is celebrating his victory,” CNN "The Orangutan", and followed with a subhead: “A new view on climate change?” Neither the Times gaggle nor CNN noted that "The Orangutan’s" chief environmental adviser is an unregenerate paid-for fossil-fuel-happy hack. "The Orangutan" did not use the “neo-Nazi” label — which would have been accurate — and insisted his campaign chief and very-far-right-hand man Steve Bannon’s Breitbart “News” is a “news organization” — and then came the man’s supreme compliment, “very successful,” later downgraded for no earthly reason to “pretty successful.”
It was Times Executive Editor Dean Baquet who asked "The Orangutan" about the “alt-right” (read: neo-Nazi) “Hail "The Orangutan"” rally that had just taken place in Washington. “First of all,” "The Orangutan" said, “I don’t want to energize [racists.] I’m not looking to energize them. I don’t want to energize the group, and I disavow the group.” And now the whiplash again: “Then, again, I don’t know if it’s reporting or whatever.” What the last sentence appears to mean is that "The Orangutan" reserves the right to withdraw his vague “disavowal” if he and his lying legions later maintain that the reporting of Nazi salutes, etc., was a distortion perpetrated by the “liberal media.” "The Orangutan" added: “If they are energized I want to look into it and find out why.” This is supposed to be reassuring. The Timesmen and -women did nothing to break the spell. Among the follow-up questions they did not ask: “You’re not sure they’re energized? Have you heard of the hate crimes? When will you report to us on what your researchers turn up?”
"The Orangutan" practices the dark art of the perfunctory reassurance and gets rewarded with passing grades: He “moderates” and is “tempered.” He teases one executive (“is he a tough boss?”) and compliments another (“very powerful man”). The article, as opposed to the transcript, gives the strongman an unearned gift: a veneer of coherence. Is this a moment to break into laughter or screaming or crying — this spectacle of bad cop "The Orangutan" sending good cop "The Orangutan" out to meet with journalists whom he has described as “sleaze,” and presto! emerging as a moderate who solicits the good opinion of Thomas Friedman.
When journalists sit down at a table with a man so fundamentally ignorant, self-seeking, unscrupulous and unreliable, a man who, when he doesn’t lie, characteristically emits bullshit — the now academically canonized term for propositions whose truth or falsity he doesn’t know or care to know — is it not evident that they must gird themselves at the first sign of flattery, to realize that his mission is to play them, to keep them off-balance?
Here were his first words to the Times group: “Well, I just appreciate the meeting and I have great respect for The New York Times. Tremendous respect. It’s very special. Always has been very special.” And then the lightning, bipolar pivot: “I think I’ve been treated very rough….”
“Failed” is one of "The Orangutan"’s favorite adjectives for The Times. In his wholly amoral universe, “failed” is tantamount to “evil.”
And there was Friedman, sucking up to the billionaire by crooning about the splendor of his world-wonders on the way to asking about socially caused climate change, the existence of which "The Orangutan" has frequently denied. This was not only shoddy questioning, it was a confession of weakness, which matters hugely, since the only human qualities that register in "The Orangutan" World are strength and weakness. When you genuflect to the majesty of the man’s Pharaonic achievements, you show weakness, and so he proceeds to bullshit you. Thus on climate change: “I have an open mind to it. We’re going to look very carefully. It’s one issue that’s interesting because there are few things where there’s more division than climate change. You don’t tend to hear this, but there are people on the other side of that issue….I have a very open mind.”
Friedman’s response was a whimper: “But you have an open mind on this?” I suppose that is called nailing down news. It should be called: Giving "The Orangutan" a gift by putting words in his mouth.
"The Orangutan" was happy to play along: “I do have an open mind.” Instantly then, he switched the subject back to one of the science-deniers’ go-to canards: “And we’ve had storms always,” whereupon he lurched farther into ignorance and irrelevancy: “You know the hottest day ever was in 1890-something, 98. You know, you can make lots of cases for different views. I have a totally open mind.” The man does not know the difference between climate and weather. Was Friedman off-duty?
Next, El Caudillo de Mar-a-Lago was off to a riff about “clean air” and “crystal clean water” and “safety.” He was an inch away from a reprise of Gen. Jack D. Ripper’s memorable, Strangelovian warning against the Communist conspiracy “to sap and impurify all of our precious bodily fluids.” But not this time. His next lurch was to the “environmental awards” he’s received for his “very successful” golf courses. And there was this, on golf courses: “Some will be even better [as the sea level rises] because actually like [his Miami property] Doral is a little bit off … so it’ll be perfect….The ones that are near the water will be gone, but Doral will be in great shape.”
This is not an open mind, this is a sieve mind linked to a bank account.
"The Orangutan"’s Doral gambit was reminiscent of his declaration after the June Brexit vote that his Scottish golf course, Turnberry, was now well-positioned to cash in on others’ misfortune: “When the pound goes down, more people are coming to Turnberry, frankly. For traveling and for other things, I think it very well could turn out to be a positive.” Friedman did not refer to "The Orangutan's" Turnberry Declaration. But not to leave any sycophantic note unsounded or untouched, he bade farewell with this penetrating observation: “I came here thinking you’d be awed and overwhelmed by this job, but I feel like you are getting very comfortable with it.” A few days later, the man whom Thomas Friedman found “very comfortable” let the world know, without a shred of evidence, that “In addition to winning the Electoral College in a landslide, I won the popular vote if you deduct the millions of people who voted illegally.”
How much more of this garbage must spew from "The Orangutan" Tower before one of our crucial newspapers — one that "The Orangutan" himself, in full-on ingratiation mode, termed “a world jewel” — calls a halt to tiptoeing around? I cannot help but think that this is more than a tactic to earn access; it is abject servility. It is, as "The Orangutan" might put it, a show of pathetic weakness. At this late date, do the standard-bearers of “neither fear nor favor” fear that a shortfall in deference will inspire some "The Orangutan" hack or Breitbart clone to denounce them as “biased”? Are they capable of embarrassment? Have they no shame?
Conflicts of interest... Again and again...
Dr. James Chao, is the chairman of The Foremost Group, a global shipping company. Chao registers his ships in Liberia to avoid paying taxes in the United States. The firm..leaves a faint online trace. Foremost’s website FMCNY.com is blank. Records and court documents obtained by The Nation show that the ownership of the company’s vessels is obscured through a byzantine structure of tax entities. Elaine Chao was named as Drumpf's transportation secretary. Conflicts of interest????
Voter Fraud Evidence???
Here Are The Problems With The Trump Team's Voter Fraud Evidence
By Danielle Kurtzleben
Consider it another Trump flip-flop: back in October, Donald Trump told a crowd, "I will totally accept the results of this great and historic presidential election, if I win."
Trump went on to decisively win the Electoral College, but now he is questioning the results anyway. In a tweet this weekend, the president-elect alleged — providing zero evidence — that "millions of people" voted illegally, and that that's the reason Hillary Clinton won the popular vote.
On a Monday morning phone call, members of the Trump team tried to back up the claim when NPR's Tamara Keith asked them for corroborating evidence. However, nothing they cited really made that case.
Jason Miller cited two sources on the call, as transcribed by CBS's Sopan Deb:
"In particular, I'd point to the 2014 Washington Post study that indicated more than 14 percent of non-citizens in both in 2008 and in 2010 elections indicated they were registered to vote. ... Some numbers include the Pew Research study that said that approximately 24 million, or one out of every eight voter registrations in the United States[,] are no longer valid or significantly inaccurate. And in that same Pew Research study, the fact that 2.75 million people have registrations in more than one state. So all of these are studies and examples of where there have been issues of both voter fraud and illegal immigrants voting. ..."
The two pieces of evidence
First, there is the "Washington Post study" that Miller cites. He was referring to a 2014 post from the Monkey Cage, a political science blog at the Post. In that piece, Old Dominion University professors Jesse Richman and David Earnest wrote about a study they conducted of data from the Cooperative Congressional Election Study, an operation that conducts ongoing surveys of voters.
Richman and Earnest indeed found that "14 percent of non-citizens in both the 2008 and 2010 samples" they used said they were registered to vote. Not only that, but some of those respondents said they in fact did vote.
However, the results of that study were heavily called into question, as Deb pointed out. In fact, that Monkey Cage article prominently features a disclaimer at the top:
"Note: The post occasioned three rebuttals (here, here, and here) as well as a response from the authors. Subsequently, another peer-reviewed article argued that the findings reported in this post (and affiliated article) were biased and that the authors' data do not provide evidence of non-citizen voting in U.S. elections."
That peer-reviewed article comes from a team of researchers that includes Stephen Ansolabehere, who developed the CCES. He and two colleagues wrote at the Monkey Cage that Richman and Earnest's findings were based on "measurement error." For example, 56 respondents (a tiny sliver of people) changed their citizenship status between 2010 and 2012, and 20 of those had changed from citizen to noncitizen.
That's "highly unrealistic," Ansolabehere and his colleagues wrote.
"The mistake that Richman and his colleagues made was to isolate this small portion of the sample and extrapolate from it as if it were representative of some larger population," they added.
Later on, the Washington Post's Fact Checker likewise gave this claim (when made by Eric Trump) four Pinocchios.
That's one piece of evidence Miller put forward. He also pointed to a 2012 study from the Pew Charitable Trusts. The numbers he cites are in fact correct: That study showed that 24 million voter registrations at the time were "no longer valid" or were "significantly inaccurate," and that nearly 2.8 million Americans were registered in more than one state.
That's a sign that states' voter registration databases could use some extra upkeep but it's not itself evidence of fraud, as Miller said it was.
One reason it's hard to keep registrations up to date is that each state has its own system, plus safeguards to make sure people don't inadvertently get unregistered.
"We have these 50 different systems and different databases on voter registration," said Lorraine Minnite, a professor of political science at Rutgers University and author of The Voter Fraud Myth. "And we have a federal law that was passed in 1993 to protect voters from being illegally purged from registration lists for political reasons."
That 1993 law is the National Voter Registration Act, and it sets out specific provisions under which a state can remove a person from the voter rolls. Because of those provisions, a person won't instantaneously be removed after moving to a different state or dying, for example. Getting a driver's license in another state could cancel a person's registration in the original state, but both states first have to communicate with each other.
"So what has happened is that this notion that voter registration lists can possibly be 100 percent accurate at any point in time is a complete fiction," she said. "It's not allowed under federal law to be that way."
So Trump in fact — however inadvertently — did draw some attention to what many consider a real problem.
"If you lined up people from all political angles, they would agree that we in the country have a lot of room to grow on that, and that voters and election officials would be better off if we made common-sense reforms to voter registration," said Myrna Pérez, leader of the Voting Rights and Elections project at the Brennan Center for Justice. But she takes issue with his allegations. "The answer is not to create panic and to make allegations that undermine confidence in our elections," she said.
Voter fraud happens, but it's exceedingly rare
Donald Trump and his team have repeatedly alleged voter fraud in this election, alleging that the outcome would be "rigged."
As NPR wrote last month, it would be phenomenally difficult to "rig" an election via voter fraud. Fraud does happen, though instances are rare. And there's not a massive, systematic effort behind it that could sway a presidential election, as voter fraud expert Rick Hasen explained to NPR's Terry Gross in October:
"We do have some instances of voter fraud. The most common kind of voter fraud we see [is] usually in a local election where maybe dozens or 100 ballots could make a difference, involving absentee ballots. Usually, it's absentee ballots that are bought or sold. I'll give you $20 for your absentee ballot and then I can vote it the way I want. Unlike impersonation fraud, when it's an absentee ballot, you can verify how someone voted because you have the actual ballot, so that does happen.
"And for The Voting Wars, I was able to find regularly in local elections — and certainly in some parts of the country there's been an unfortunate history of this, in parts of Kentucky, South Texas, parts of Florida. We have had this kind of fraud. But it's been in small local elections, never on a large enough scale, I think, to affect a presidential election and not the kind of fraud that Donald Trump is talking about to affect the outcome [emphasis added]."
Unfortunately, it's often possible to find some sort of instance of shady-looking behavior in any given election. The Trump campaign provided NPR with a 45-page document listing instances of voter fraud, intimidation, and registration fraud (some of which are only listed as alleged instances), going back more than a decade.
However, the Trump campaign has yet to provide evidence that widespread fraud — involving "millions of voters" — in fact swayed the results of the presidential election, as the president-elect said it did.
Clarification: This article was clarified on Nov. 28 to show that some of the instances the Trump campaign listed to NPR were allegations and not necessarily proven to be true.
By Danielle Kurtzleben
Consider it another Trump flip-flop: back in October, Donald Trump told a crowd, "I will totally accept the results of this great and historic presidential election, if I win."
Trump went on to decisively win the Electoral College, but now he is questioning the results anyway. In a tweet this weekend, the president-elect alleged — providing zero evidence — that "millions of people" voted illegally, and that that's the reason Hillary Clinton won the popular vote.
On a Monday morning phone call, members of the Trump team tried to back up the claim when NPR's Tamara Keith asked them for corroborating evidence. However, nothing they cited really made that case.
Jason Miller cited two sources on the call, as transcribed by CBS's Sopan Deb:
"In particular, I'd point to the 2014 Washington Post study that indicated more than 14 percent of non-citizens in both in 2008 and in 2010 elections indicated they were registered to vote. ... Some numbers include the Pew Research study that said that approximately 24 million, or one out of every eight voter registrations in the United States[,] are no longer valid or significantly inaccurate. And in that same Pew Research study, the fact that 2.75 million people have registrations in more than one state. So all of these are studies and examples of where there have been issues of both voter fraud and illegal immigrants voting. ..."
The two pieces of evidence
First, there is the "Washington Post study" that Miller cites. He was referring to a 2014 post from the Monkey Cage, a political science blog at the Post. In that piece, Old Dominion University professors Jesse Richman and David Earnest wrote about a study they conducted of data from the Cooperative Congressional Election Study, an operation that conducts ongoing surveys of voters.
Richman and Earnest indeed found that "14 percent of non-citizens in both the 2008 and 2010 samples" they used said they were registered to vote. Not only that, but some of those respondents said they in fact did vote.
However, the results of that study were heavily called into question, as Deb pointed out. In fact, that Monkey Cage article prominently features a disclaimer at the top:
"Note: The post occasioned three rebuttals (here, here, and here) as well as a response from the authors. Subsequently, another peer-reviewed article argued that the findings reported in this post (and affiliated article) were biased and that the authors' data do not provide evidence of non-citizen voting in U.S. elections."
That peer-reviewed article comes from a team of researchers that includes Stephen Ansolabehere, who developed the CCES. He and two colleagues wrote at the Monkey Cage that Richman and Earnest's findings were based on "measurement error." For example, 56 respondents (a tiny sliver of people) changed their citizenship status between 2010 and 2012, and 20 of those had changed from citizen to noncitizen.
That's "highly unrealistic," Ansolabehere and his colleagues wrote.
"The mistake that Richman and his colleagues made was to isolate this small portion of the sample and extrapolate from it as if it were representative of some larger population," they added.
Later on, the Washington Post's Fact Checker likewise gave this claim (when made by Eric Trump) four Pinocchios.
That's one piece of evidence Miller put forward. He also pointed to a 2012 study from the Pew Charitable Trusts. The numbers he cites are in fact correct: That study showed that 24 million voter registrations at the time were "no longer valid" or were "significantly inaccurate," and that nearly 2.8 million Americans were registered in more than one state.
That's a sign that states' voter registration databases could use some extra upkeep but it's not itself evidence of fraud, as Miller said it was.
One reason it's hard to keep registrations up to date is that each state has its own system, plus safeguards to make sure people don't inadvertently get unregistered.
"We have these 50 different systems and different databases on voter registration," said Lorraine Minnite, a professor of political science at Rutgers University and author of The Voter Fraud Myth. "And we have a federal law that was passed in 1993 to protect voters from being illegally purged from registration lists for political reasons."
That 1993 law is the National Voter Registration Act, and it sets out specific provisions under which a state can remove a person from the voter rolls. Because of those provisions, a person won't instantaneously be removed after moving to a different state or dying, for example. Getting a driver's license in another state could cancel a person's registration in the original state, but both states first have to communicate with each other.
"So what has happened is that this notion that voter registration lists can possibly be 100 percent accurate at any point in time is a complete fiction," she said. "It's not allowed under federal law to be that way."
So Trump in fact — however inadvertently — did draw some attention to what many consider a real problem.
"If you lined up people from all political angles, they would agree that we in the country have a lot of room to grow on that, and that voters and election officials would be better off if we made common-sense reforms to voter registration," said Myrna Pérez, leader of the Voting Rights and Elections project at the Brennan Center for Justice. But she takes issue with his allegations. "The answer is not to create panic and to make allegations that undermine confidence in our elections," she said.
Voter fraud happens, but it's exceedingly rare
Donald Trump and his team have repeatedly alleged voter fraud in this election, alleging that the outcome would be "rigged."
As NPR wrote last month, it would be phenomenally difficult to "rig" an election via voter fraud. Fraud does happen, though instances are rare. And there's not a massive, systematic effort behind it that could sway a presidential election, as voter fraud expert Rick Hasen explained to NPR's Terry Gross in October:
"We do have some instances of voter fraud. The most common kind of voter fraud we see [is] usually in a local election where maybe dozens or 100 ballots could make a difference, involving absentee ballots. Usually, it's absentee ballots that are bought or sold. I'll give you $20 for your absentee ballot and then I can vote it the way I want. Unlike impersonation fraud, when it's an absentee ballot, you can verify how someone voted because you have the actual ballot, so that does happen.
"And for The Voting Wars, I was able to find regularly in local elections — and certainly in some parts of the country there's been an unfortunate history of this, in parts of Kentucky, South Texas, parts of Florida. We have had this kind of fraud. But it's been in small local elections, never on a large enough scale, I think, to affect a presidential election and not the kind of fraud that Donald Trump is talking about to affect the outcome [emphasis added]."
Unfortunately, it's often possible to find some sort of instance of shady-looking behavior in any given election. The Trump campaign provided NPR with a 45-page document listing instances of voter fraud, intimidation, and registration fraud (some of which are only listed as alleged instances), going back more than a decade.
However, the Trump campaign has yet to provide evidence that widespread fraud — involving "millions of voters" — in fact swayed the results of the presidential election, as the president-elect said it did.
Clarification: This article was clarified on Nov. 28 to show that some of the instances the Trump campaign listed to NPR were allegations and not necessarily proven to be true.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)