A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



October 31, 2016

Stunning

Ex-AG Eric Holder: Comey's letter 'a stunning breach of protocol' and 'serious error'

By David Wright

Former Attorney General Eric Holder is criticizing FBI Director James Comey's decision to reveal the recent discovery of emails potentially related to the bureau's earlier investigation of Hillary Clinton's private server.

Writing in the Washington Post on Monday, Holder called Comey's decision "incorrect."

He said Comey's letter to Congress announcing a review of the new emails was "a stunning breach" of law enforcement protocol and one that carried "potentially severe implications" during a presidential campaign.

"I served with Jim Comey, and I know him well. This is a very difficult piece for me to write. He is a man of integrity and honor. I respect him. But good men make mistakes. In this instance, he has committed a serious error with potentially severe implications," Holder wrote.

"It is incumbent upon him -- or the leadership of the department -- to dispel the uncertainty he has created before Election Day. It is up to the director to correct his mistake — not for the sake of a political candidate or campaign but in order to protect our system of justice and best serve the American people."

The former Attorney General wrote that Comey's letter "violated long-standing Justice Department policies and tradition" not to comment publicly about politically sensitive investigations within 60 days of an election.

"It ran counter to guidance that I put in place four years ago laying out the proper way to conduct investigations during an election season. That guidance, which reinforced established policy, is still in effect and applies to the entire Justice Department -- including the FBI," he wrote.

Holder argued Comey "broke with these fundamental principles" with the announcement of the review.

"I fear he has unintentionally and negatively affected public trust in both the Justice Department and the FBI," Holder wrote. "And he has allowed -- again, without improper motive -- misinformation to be spread by partisans with less than pure intentions."

Holder acknowledged the charged political environment surrounding the Clinton email investigation, writing that he was "mindful" of the perception created by former President Bill Clinton's tarmac meeting with current Attorney General Loretta Lynch over the summer during the FBI's probe of the case.

But he added that "the solution was not for the FBI director to announce the department's decision about whether to proceed" with additional investigation or review of the newly discovered emails.

Anger on trail...

Anger unleashed: On the trail in Trump's America

By Sara Murray

Somewhere along the campaign trail I fell into the habit of smiling back at members of the crowd as they jeered at me.

Some days it felt like that was my armor -- a shield from the chants of "CNN sucks." Other times I hoped it would be a signal. "Hey, I'm just doing my job. I know you're mad at me, but I'm not mad at you."

It was evident early on that Donald Trump was a different kind of candidate. He didn't just hold a grudge against the media -- a battle that's become the norm for Republican candidates. No, he held grudges with specific members of the media.

I got an early taste of it in November 2015 when Trump called me out by name at a rally in South Carolina. He referred to me as a "total novice reporter" and did an unflattering impression of me doing a live shot. The crowd followed his lead, turning around to taunt me.

For a year and a half I have followed Trump around the United States and, at times, overseas in his unlikely and in many ways unprecedented bid for the presidency.

Whether it was an unexpected endorsement from New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie during the primaries, or a surprise appearance with women who have accused Bill Clinton of sexual misconduct, Trump has kept the press on its toes.

I've missed morning spin classes and nights at home with my fiancé. During a weekend off in Kansas City I frantically made phone calls between sips of coffee and bites of donut after Trump fired his first campaign manager, Corey Lewandowski.

At my sister's bachelorette party in New Orleans, I slipped away under the guise of getting a manicure and pedicure. Mostly I made calls about the drumbeat that prompted Trump to can his second campaign head, Paul Manafort.

Trump knows how to seize a news cycle, for better or for worse -- and sometimes for reasons he can't entirely control.

In March, we were in New Orleans for one of the last rallies before the Trump campaign beefed up their security. It felt like a tinderbox. Protests broke out continuously. Many of the protesters were young; some of them teenagers. Many of them were minorities. As security came to escort them out, members of the crowd tore at their clothes, grabbed for them, kicked them.

After the first few were removed, I wanted to scream at the protesters to stop resisting -- to yell that if they dragged their feet the crowd was going to turn on them. I held my tongue.

When we arrived in San Jose in June, I wanted to see the Trump event from the other side. I was roaming the streets on protest duty -- an assignment that was largely quiet until Trump's rally started to disperse.

Anti-Trump protesters started hunting for people in the signature "Make America Great Again" hats and t-shirts.

A flash caught my eye. It was a teenager in Trump gear, sprinting with a mob in pursuit. The kid didn't stop running until he was safely ensconced behind a wall of police officers wearing riot gear.

I interviewed him and his father afterward. They held up a pile of Trump campaign signs they hoped to bring home from the rally that night; each one had been ripped out of their hands, shredded by protesters who reviled Trump.

Over the course of a year and a half, I've seen Trump supporters who have spit in protesters' faces. I've seen them hurl racial slurs with abandon.

I've also watched protesters cold-cock Trump supporters -- and vice versa -- in fits of rage. And I've watched Trump opponents harass a woman and pelt her with eggs.

Time and time again, I have seen Americans from both sides of the aisle fail to treat one another with respect and dignity. I've watched them fail to treat one another as human beings.

In many ways, the final months of the campaign have been the darkest.

Now, members of the media walk into an event like Trump's mid-October rally in Cincinnati, greeted by a crowd of thousands screaming at us about biased coverage and flipping us off.

It didn't happen in a vacuum. The anger and emotion against the establishment -- whether that meant politicians, the press or the financial elite -- didn't build overnight.

The "dishonest media" had been one of Trump's favorite foils for a while by the time Christie endorsed him in February. That was the day someone tampered with the cables of our live truck. We struggled to take the news of the endorsement live while our cables were cut not once, but twice.

During the general election, we were at a stop in Florida when someone followed my producer to our car. When we left the event hours later, we discovered someone keyed our car on both sides.

The night of that raucous rally in Cincinnati, as thousands of Trump supporters bellowed at us, my mind was elsewhere.

When I landed at the Cincinnati airport the night before, my fellow passengers and I began to notice some activity on the tarmac as we were deplaning.

It was the honor guard.

We got off the plane and, one by one, started huddling in the corner near a window overlooking the tarmac. We watched as the honor guard stood in formation. The man next to me gasped as a family walked onto the tarmac.

We were separated by yards of darkness and by the cool glass walls of the airport terminal. But there was no mistaking that family's grief as they held one another and waited for the casket to come off the plane.

We didn't know the fallen soldier. We didn't know the family huddled on that tarmac. But as the casket came rolling off the plane, I wept with my fellow passengers. The man next to me held his hand to his forehead in a salute.

Amid the chaos of that Trump rally, all I could think about was that solemn moment the night before.

In a year where compassion has sometimes felt in short supply, where politicians from both political parties have at times failed to inspire, Americans are still quietly honoring one another for their sacrifices. They're propping each other up and empathizing with each other in moments of pain.

That's the kind of country we want to be.

Hubble Admires a Youthful Globular Star Cluster



Globular clusters offer some of the most spectacular sights in the night sky. These ornate spheres contain hundreds of thousands of stars, and reside in the outskirts of galaxies. The Milky Way contains over 150 such clusters — and the one shown in this NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope image, named NGC 362, is one of the more unusual ones.

As stars make their way through life they fuse elements together in their cores, creating heavier and heavier elements — known in astronomy as metals — in the process. When these stars die, they flood their surroundings with the material they have formed during their lifetimes, enriching the interstellar medium with metals. Stars that form later therefore contain higher proportions of metals than their older relatives.

By studying the different elements present within individual stars in NGC 362, astronomers discovered that the cluster boasts a surprisingly high metal content, indicating that it is younger than expected. Although most globular clusters are much older than the majority of stars in their host galaxy, NGC 362 bucks the trend, with an age lying between 10 and 11 billion years old. For reference, the age of the Milky Way is estimated to be above 13 billion years.

This image, in which you can view NGC 362’s individual stars, was taken by Hubble’s Advanced Camera for Surveys (ACS).

Astronauts Return From the Space Station

NASA Astronaut Kate Rubins, Crewmates Safely Return From the Space Station

NASA astronaut and Expedition 49 crew member Kate Rubins, who became the first person to sequence DNA in space, returned to Earth Saturday after a successful mission aboard the International Space Station.

Rubins and her crewmates Anatoly Ivanishin of the Russian space agency Roscosmos and Takuya Onishi of the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency, touched down in their Soyuz MS-01 at 11:58 p.m. EDT (9:58 a.m. Oct. 30, Kazakhstan time) southeast of the remote town of Dzhezkazgan in Kazakhstan.

Rubins, who has a degree in molecular biology, contributed to several new studies taking place for the first time aboard the space station, including the Biomolecule Sequencer experiment. The ability to sequence the DNA of living organisms in space could enable astronauts to diagnose an illness, or identify microbes growing in the space station and determine whether they represent a health threat.

During her time on the orbiting complex, Rubins ventured outside the confines of the station for two spacewalks. During the first one on Aug. 19, she and NASA astronaut Jeff Williams installed the first international docking adapter. Outfitted with a host of sensors and systems, the adapter’s main purpose is to provide a port for spacecraft bringing astronauts to the station in the future. Its first users are expected to be the Boeing Starliner and SpaceX Crew Dragon spacecraft now in development in partnership with NASA's Commercial Crew Program. During her second spacewalk Sept. 1, Rubins and Williams retracted a spare thermal control radiator and installed two new high-definition cameras.

Together, the Expedition 49 crew members contributed to hundreds of experiments in biology, biotechnology, physical science and Earth science aboard the world-class orbiting laboratory during their 115 days in space.

The trio also welcomed three cargo spacecraft delivering several tons of supplies and research experiments. Rubins was involved in the grapple of Orbital ATK’s Cygnus spacecraft to the station in October, the company's sixth contracted commercial resupply mission, and SpaceX’s Dragon ninth contracted mission in July. One Russian ISS Progress cargo spacecraft also docked to the station in July.

Rubins and Onishi have each spent a total of 115 days in space during their first mission. Ivanishin now has 280 days in space from two flights.

Expedition 50, with Shane Kimbrough of NASA in command and his crewmates Sergey Ryzhikov and Andrey Borisenko of Roscosmos, will operate the station for three weeks until the arrival of three new crew members.

Comey 5 takeaways

5 takeaways from Comey’s October surprise

Hillary Clinton doesn’t believe in good luck, and Friday’s bombshell shows why.

By Glenn Thrush

Hillary Clinton has never met a sunny day she completely trusted, and Friday proved why.

The front-running Democrat has always been weakest when protecting a lead, and, according to the people around her, chronically suspicious of any overlong stretches of good fortune or blue-sky forecasting. She needn’t have worried. The last 10 days of her historic campaign are now socked in by a lowering overcast of suspicion, and a depressingly familiar threat.

Friday started off brightly enough in Des Moines, Iowa, as a cheerful Clinton rallied her supporters during the first round of early voting in a state she wants, but doesn’t need, to win. She seemed chilled out in an aqua-blue suit that suggested marine tranquility and was buoyed by the presence of her childhood friend Betsy Ebeling and the superstar photographer Annie Leibovitz.

But by the afternoon, a candidate and campaign that thrive on preparation were blindsided by a bombshell (that might ultimately prove to be a blank): FBI Director James Comey — who in July declared Clinton's handling of classified information “careless” but not criminal — has begun looking into what are said to be thousands of new emails for possible violations of the classification laws.

Then, the elect-ile dysfunction: The source of the new controversy, Clinton’s surrogate daughter Huma Abedin and her estranged husband, Anthony Weiner, package-proud proof that not every horny narcissist with bad judgment is named Donald Trump.

How much the latest email eruption affects the race depends on how both campaigns handle it over the next few days — and how much voters give a damn. Still, it’s a drag. The best peppy self-talk one Clinton ally could muster today was: “People don’t trust her already, so that’s baked in the cake. But she’s better than Trump.”

Here are five takeaways from Clinton’s very bad Friday — that could turn into something much worse.

Blame Huma and Tony — for now. According to numerous published reports, thousands of potentially sensitive (and possibly classified) government emails from Abedin’s account were discovered on devices owned by Weiner — seized by the FBI in connection with their probe into the former congressman’s alleged social media lewdness with a 15-year-old girl.

How the emails got into Abedin’s possession isn’t clear (though Clinton often emailed her aide-de-camp documents to print out). But the fact that the material being examined didn’t come from Clinton’s account gives the candidate a degree of separation she didn’t have in Comey’s prior investigation — and the correspondence being looked at, according to some reports, come from Abedin’s account, and not the “homebrew” server that has been the source of so much controversy and reputational damage. That helps, if only a bit.

Trump and Republicans — giddy to get the old email band back together — wanted to keep the focus squarely on Clinton and, for an hour before the Weiner connection was known, they succeeded. But the sexting angle, the Huma angle, the tabloid marriage-gone-sour angle made it seem a lot less sinister — and more the continuation of a political soap opera in which Clinton has played a starring but supporting role.

The CNN, MSNBC and Fox screens at POLITICO world headquarters said it all — they split-screened between dour, preoccupied snapshots of Clinton and more whimsical images of the once happy Weiner-Abedin glamour couple. Clinton will ultimately bear responsibility for whatever happened to her emails — and Comey made it clear that the new messages “appear to be pertinent” to his earlier look at the former secretary of state’s handling of classified and secret missives.

But unlike the first go-around — when Clinton stood alone — she now shares the stage with Anthony and Huma.

It takes the focus off of Trump. We are in the final stretch of a psoriasis-vs.-eczema election — and whichever candidate gets the greatest scrutiny tends to make the voters the most itchy.

Trump has had them scratching for a month — what with his 2005 hot-mic admission that he committed what sounded like sexual assault, followed by a procession of a dozen or so women who accused him of being a cad, groper and commando kisser. He denied it, but he compounded his problem by attacking regular, non-famous-type people who had the gall to criticize him — and washed it all down with three of the rottenest debate performances in the history of people moving their lips to emit sound. Trump capped it all with a threat to destabilize 240 years of American democracy by claiming any vote against him was automatically rigged.

Clinton, who hates everything about campaigning except reading briefing books and debating her opponents, has been happy to coast in Trump’s turbulent wake — tsk-tsk-tsk-ing him and deploying a Hall of Fame roster of surrogates from the Obamas to Bernie Sanders to Elizabeth Warren to Katy Perry. But gradually, inevitably, the focus has turned back on the second-most detested candidate running for president — in part because of the drip-drip of WikiLeaks, in part because voters are now forced to grapple with the reality that she’s likely to be the country’s next leader.

She doesn’t fare especially well alone in the spotlight — while she’s held her own in most polls, and retains a commanding advantage in many battleground states (and the Electoral College), Trump has begun to finally consolidate support among core Republicans, which has brought him as high as 44 percent in one national poll and to par with her in Florida and Nevada.

So look for a new oppo dump on Trump — and a new line of attack — or anything, really, that will turn the race back into a referendum on his fitness to serve, not hers.

Never underestimate Trump’s ability to misplay a winning hand. Trump is about as good a political poker player as he was a casino owner. Case in point: His first comments about Clinton’s new email problems were aimed not at a wider audience of Donald-skeptical conservatives and persuadable voters but the cheering throng at his most recent rally in New Hampshire, where he trails in most polls.

Weinergate, he declared, “is bigger than Watergate.”

It totally isn’t, at least not yet — and there isn’t a voter not already committed to Trump who believes the hype. No, the target for his message now needs to be higher-educated Republican voters (and, perish the thought, GOP women) who are considering defecting to vote for Clinton. They aren’t looking for another Trump body slam, but a little reason and rhetorical subtlety — a permission structure to accept him as an alternative to hated-but-tolerated Hillary.

There are smarter ways to do this, obviously. Take Paul Ryan, Trump’s intraparty nemesis, who offered a more targeted and legalistic attack on Clinton that undermined her legitimacy as a potential commander in chief by calling for the suspension of her national security briefings. "Yet again, Hillary Clinton has nobody but herself to blame," the House speaker said in his statement. "She was entrusted with some of our nation's most important secrets, and she betrayed that trust by carelessly mishandling highly classified information."

Clinton vs. Comey. It wasn’t so very long ago that Trump and his surrogates were hammering Comey and the once-sacrosanct bureau for allegedly covering up Clinton’s abominable email offenses. “FBI director said Crooked Hillary compromised our national security. No charges. Wow! #RiggedSystem,” Trump Tweeted when Comey cleared Clinton of criminal wrongdoing.

On Friday, he was in a J. Edgar state of mind with his opponent back in the investigative cross hairs. “I have great respect for the fact that the FBI and the Department of Justice are now willing to have the courage to right the horrible mistake that they made,” he said, with faintest flip-floppy grin. “This was a grave miscarriage of justice that the American people fully understood. And it is everybody's hope that it is about to be corrected.”

Now it was the Democrats’ turn to accuse Comey and Co. of unfairness — with surrogates like former Obama Justice Department official Matt Miller flat out accusing the director of needlessly publicizing the details of an ongoing investigation to burnish his own image. The reaction among Clinton’s top aides and lawyers was fury — they had been given no advance warning by the bureau before Comey sent a letter to congressional Republicans, copying Hill Democrats — and they questioned whether the timing was, somehow, intended to scuttle Clinton’s chances of winning the White House.

By late afternoon, it was Clinton’s turn to play the old Trump card against Comey, demanding that all the details of the probe — especially the involvement of Abedin and Weiner — be made immediately public.

“We don’t know the facts, which is why we are calling on the FBI to release all the information that it has,” a clearly ticked-off Clinton told reporters between campaign stops. “Even Director Comey noted that this new information might not be significant, so let’s get it out.”

Trump’s not the only candidate with a self-destructive streak. Among the most revealing (and funny) emails released as part of WikiLeaks’ (allegedly) Kremlin-supplied hack were the tart, accurate observations by longtime Hillaryland adviser Neera Tanden, who couldn’t believe the Clintons would have set up a private server in the first place. “Do we actually know who told Hillary she could use a private email? And has that person been drawn and quartered?” Tanden asked her friend John Podesta, who was subsequently hacked — adding that the “whole thing is f---ing insane.”

What made it especially insane was the candidate’s own propensity for self-protective self-immolation: The server was set up, in part, to shield the hyperscrutinized former first family from scrutiny, embarrassment and scandal. Worked like a charm, if that charm was to foment an already burbling suspicion among the American people that Clinton was secretive, self-interested and not to be trusted. In September 2015, before the email server scandal was weaponized by Trump (her primary opponent Bernie Sanders famously eschewed using the issue against her), The Atlantic hosted a focus group to figure out why more than half of Americans didn’t trust an international superstar who was almost always voted the most admired woman in the world.

“She’s lied again and again and again in the pursuit of power,” one man told the magazine’s pollster. “This has been her entire life’s work, it seems like, has been building up to this moment, so she doesn’t have any shots left.”

“She wants it so much she’ll say anything, she’ll do anything,” a female respondent said, adding that “the people behind her will say anything or do anything. Do I want those kind of people in power? Oh, please no.”

Those opinions have taken deep root, even among her supporters; Mind you, voters often vote for candidates they don’t trust, but Clinton’s no-trust numbers are abysmal — topping 60 percent in some polls, with solid majorities of voters expressing unease about her handling of the emails and her family’s charitable foundation. This won’t help.

Trump hasn’t done much to burnish his own image, but he’s been relentless in degrading public esteem for “Crooked Hillary” — leading rally chants of “Lock her up!” despite Comey’s July exoneration of Clinton. The FBI’s decision was hailed with relief in Clinton’s Brooklyn headquarters, but it came ahead of her deepest swan dive in the polls to date: For a few days in late July, Trump briefly seized the national lead, and poll aggregators gave him a roughly 55 percent chance of winning the election on the eve of Clinton’s successful convention in Philadelphia.

She’s in better shape now; the handicappers give her between an 80 percent and 90 percent chance of winning, and roughly 30 percent of votes have already been cast, thanks to early balloting and absentee voting in many states. And the scandal (or pseudo-scandal) doesn’t yet directly involve her.

But by late Friday, all the Democratic talk of landslides and big down-ballot victories had given way, yet again, to nervous chatter about a candidate who never seems to be able to seal the deal.

How Congress can step up...

How Congress can protect the U.S. from Russia

Presidents typically take the lead on foreign policy. But Congress has a major role to play too.

By Jason Bruder

Moscow’s attempts to interfere with the presidential election is clear evidence that Russian President Vladimir Putin poses a direct threat to the United States. Despite the U.S. military advantage, Russia has demonstrated the ability to use espionage, diplomacy and military force to undermine our security.

While most observers believe that the challenge of countering Russia and navigating the complicated relationship with Putin will fall to the next president, the legislative branch will have a major role to play as well. The 115th Congress has an opportunity to address this threat by focusing time and resources on legislation and oversight to safeguard U.S. interests and influence abroad, demonstrating real leadership to fulfill its constitutionally mandated role in foreign policy.

While Congress is not institutionally structured to manage daily crises in Syria or Ukraine, the legislative branch does have a track record of making constructive contributions to foreign policy. After the collapse of the Soviet Union in 1991, for instance, Congress led efforts to secure nuclear weapons in the newly independent countries of the former USSR, authorized economic assistance to the people of these countries, and established exchange programs to achieve dialogue between Americans and their former adversaries. During the Cold War, Congress also successfully pressed to end military interventions in Southeast Asia and Central America and provided leadership on human rights issues. Americans remember the excesses of Sen. Joe McCarthy (R-Wis.), but Sen. Arthur Vandenberg (R-Mich.) may have had more impact on history by working behind the scenes for Senate approval of forming the United Nations and NATO and funding the Marshall Plan.

Putin and his government are firmly in power and are unlikely to change their attitude toward the United States any time soon. Responding to Moscow and managing this important relationship will require patience and a long-term approach. The incoming Congress should actively help the next president defend and promote U.S. interests in the face of increasingly assertive Russian diplomacy.

To start, Congress must ensure that America’s future leaders within and outside government possess the deep understanding of Russia required to cope with its newfound assertiveness. For more than 20 years, the Title VIII program, administered by the State Department, provided funding for American scholars to undertake research and language training related to Russia and its neighbors and built a cadre of American intellectuals with the requisite knowledge to inform U.S. policy toward these countries. Title VIII was heavily defunded in 2013, and the number of American scholars and experts having the opportunity to pursue Russia-related research and language training has steadily decreased as a result. This is an investment in American intellectual capital, and Congress should fully restore its funding.

Along with increased funding for the Title VIII program, lawmakers should make sure to facilitate the approval of presidential nominees. Given current tensions with Russia, it is critical that we have capable senior leadership in place during the presidential transition to address the challenges posed by the U.S.-Russia relationship and prevent any breaks in leadership that Russia could exploit. Senators might expedite approval of all nominees for positions dealing with Russia and its neighbors and should avoid placing holds on Russia-related nominations.

Congress should also work to counter Russia’s informational warfare. Putin’s government has almost completely suppressed independent voices in Russian media and has engaged in an effective international media campaign domestically and internationally. The Counter-Disinformation bill introduced by Sens. Rob Portman (R-Ohio) and Chris Murphy (D-Conn.) is an important first step toward bolstering U.S. ability to offer alternative sources of information by centralizing and focusing government efforts to provide facts to counter destabilizing narratives spread by Moscow. A further step might be the creation of a special Senate subcommittee for the upcoming session that would study the long-neglected area of U.S. broadcasting and issue a report with legislative recommendations.

Lawmakers should also promote person-to-person diplomacy. When official U.S.-Russia contact shrinks, alternative channels of communication become more important, as they did during the Cold War. The Russian government has shut down certain student and scholar exchange programs, while others have withered as a result of our budget cuts. Congress should reinforce existing programs and work to reinstate programs that have been eliminated. Members can do their part too, making a greater effort to meet with counterparts and officials from Russia’s neighborhood, which will inform their own ability to make informed decisions.

Finally, on the military front, Congress must upgrade our cyberdefenses and prepare for an escalation of the Ukraine crisis. Russia’s cyberwarfare capability is well-known and should be taken seriously. In light of the evidence that election networks were compromised in Arizona and Illinois, Congress should investigate and legislate ways to protect the integrity of our electoral process. Moreover, the possibility that Russia may suddenly escalate its military involvement in Ukraine cannot be discounted. Presidential foreign policy is always strongest when it’s backed by demonstrable congressional support and preparing a joint response to possible Russian escalation in Ukraine could become an important test case for foreign policy collaboration between the two branches.

Given Russia’s nuclear arsenal, flirting with direct military conflict would open a Pandora’s box of unthinkable outcomes. As war powers and treaty-approval powers have drifted away from Congress, sanctions have become a powerful tool. Lawmakers may be tempted to use that tool in response to provocations by Russia. But they should be careful in using them. Sanctions can have serious and unforeseen consequences and Congress should consider their use very judiciously lest they further escalate a situation.

Russia must be dealt with as a longer-term challenge in a firm and measured way. Members of Congress should make investments to enhance our national capacity to deal with the ongoing challenge from Moscow. They also can invest personally in terms of their own knowledge, firsthand experience, and relationships to maintain and develop their important role in U.S.-Russia relations.

33 Things

33 Things This Election Will Decide That Have Nothing to Do With Trump or Clinton

A marijuana wave, a bisexual governor, the first state carbon tax, and other small revolutions Nov. 8 could bring.

By Taylor Gee and Zack Stanton

his year in particular, it’s easy to get swept away in the breathless coverage of the presidential race—Did you hear what Trump said? Is pneumonia going to cost Clinton the race? Miss Finland? More emails? Really?

If that’s all you’ve been paying attention to, 2016 could be one of the most surprising elections of your life. After November 8, medical marijuana could be legal in a majority of the country. America could elect its first openly bisexual governor. The food-stamp program could be dismantled. A tax on carbon could get enacted—without much support from environmentalists. Washington, D.C., could be one step closer to statehood. House Republicans could see their black membership completely wiped out.

For all the oxygen sucked up by the presidential race, it’s often these less-prominent elections that have the most immediate and lasting impact on American lives. Sometimes, they can spur national trends—like Hawai‘i’s first-in-the-nation initiative banning same-sex marriage—or inspire a backlash that remakes American politics—as happened with California’s hard-line anti-immigration Prop 187. Other times, they can aid in the snowballing of a movement, creating enough momentum behind a reform that it’s adopted nationally (as seems to be happening with marijuana amid an avalanche of state and local legalization efforts).

Here is a peek at some of the many issues at stake his election — ones that have nothing to do with Hillary Clinton or Donald Trump, but which have the potential to reshape America in the years to come.

1. Medical marijuana will probably be legal in a majority of states—and the number of states with legalized recreational pot could double

As medical marijuana wins over skeptics—even conservatives like South Carolina Senator Lindsey Graham are warming to the idea—it continues to get support in the voting booth. This year, the issue scored a place on ballots in Florida, North Dakota and Arkansas, and a “yes” in any one of those places would legalize medical marijuana in a majority of U.S. states. Given the trend of the past decade, it wouldn’t be surprising if recreational marijuana followed suit.

Right now, recreational marijuana is legal in four states. But with four more states voting on marijuana-related ballot initiatives this year, pot could soon be legal for an additional 33 million Americans. This year, states voting on marijuana ballot initiatives include Nevada, Arizona, California, Maine and Massachusetts.

2. Oregon could elect America’s first openly bisexual governor

True, Kate Brown is already Oregon’s governor—as secretary of state, she assumed the role after Governor John Kitzhaber resigned in a corruption scandal. But there’s a big difference between that and the validation that comes with winning an election while out of the closet. This is a test—running while openly bisexual—that no other gubernatorial candidate has faced in American history, and it’s looking likely that Brown will pass it: Polls currently have her up by double digits.

3. You may soon have a constitutional right to hunt and fish

One week before Indiana’s hunters mark the start of deer season, they’ll vote on whether to amend the state’s constitution to establish a defined right to hunt and fish. Similar initiatives will be on the ballot in Montana, which has a referendum over whether to prohibit the use of animal traps on state lands, and Kansas, which is mulling a proposed amendment that would ensure the right to hunt, fish and trap wildlife. If the measures pass, the right to hunt and fish will be recognized in at least 20 state constitutions.

4. For the first time, a state government might institute a carbon tax

Among environmentalists, one of the most controversial, big-picture policy proposals is a carbon tax—penalizing pollution by charging businesses for the amount of carbon dioxide released into the atmosphere. Nationally, it has drawn interest from liberals and conservatives—and even some ginger support from oil companies—but it’s a political impossibility in Congress.

Which is why Washington’s Initiative 732 is so audacious. This year, voters across the state will decide whether to enact a tax on carbon—the first such statewide tax in the country. One would expect such an environmentalist proposal to win the support of the Democratic Party and the Sierra Club, organizations traditionally on board with policies that would curb climate change. But in Washington state, both groups, along with organized labor and social justice activists, are opposing the initiative.

The cause of the scrambled political alliances is the initiative’s plan for how to use any revenue the tax would generate. In an attempt to win bipartisan support, the current proposal would use the new revenue to fund tax cuts and tax breaks for businesses and employees hurt by the carbon tax. Ironically, that prescription has essentially assured that the support won’t be bipartisan. The left-wing groups opposing the plan would rather see the money going to clean energy and transit, as well as the minority communities often hit hardest by nearby refineries.

5. The number of states banning the death penalty could reach a new high: 21

Since 1846, when Michigan became the first English-speaking government in the Western world to ban capital punishment, the number of states with a moratorium on the practice has grown — albeit slowly and in small bursts. But 2016 is a critical year for the cause, as voters in California, Nebraska and Oklahoma will decide state initiatives on the topic. If California and Nebraska ban the use of capital punishment, that will make a total of 21 states where executions are illegal.

Oklahomans, on the other hand, are voting on whether to enshrine the death penalty in their state constitution, which would make it easier for the state to carry out executions in the future.

6. Colorado could implement the nation’s only statewide single-payer health care system

Supporters of ColoradoCares, the proposed single-payer health care system on the ballot this year in Colorado, say that they like Obamacare—they just don’t think the president’s plan goes far enough. If their proposed solution is given a green light by voters, it would increase the payroll tax in Colorado by 10 percentage points and provide premium-free health care to all citizens.

Unsurprisingly, such an audacious plan has its skeptics. Hospital associations, private insurance companies and even progressive politicians like Governor John Hickenlooper charge that the program isn’t financially feasible. They point to Vermont, which passed similar legislation in 2011 before giving up in 2014 for financial reasons. But some Coloradans—plus Vermont Senator Bernie Sanders—want the Colorado measure to succeed. If it does, it will be the only active statewide single-payer system in America.

7. The end of food stamps as we know it?

What’s at stake in control of the House? With congressional Republicans overwhelmed by the fallout from Hurricane Trump, House Speaker Paul Ryan has had trouble getting people to pay attention to his “Better Way” agenda. That may change after the election. Presuming Ryan keeps his speakership and finds willing partners in the White House and Senate (which is unlikely), he could pursue his plan to overhaul the country’s food stamp system. The House GOP wants to split food stamps out of the farm bill and devolve the program to states, paid via block grants—a move that would also dismantle the urban-rural coalition that historically has gotten the bill to pass.

By ending the federal program that sends low-income families food assistance every month and putting that money instead in the hands of state governments, the plan would essentially end a federal effort that dates back to FDR’s New Deal.

8. The number of black Republicans in the U.S. House could drop from two to zero

When Will Hurd and Mia Love won election to the House in 2014, it was a historic moment for the Republican Party, whose House conference has historically lacked racial diversity. Fast forward two years, and both promising freshmen are locked in tight battles for reelection. In his district along the Texas-Mexico border, Hurd faces former Democratic Rep. Pete Gallego, in what is widely regarded as the Lone Star State’s sole competitive House race. In Utah, Love, a charismatic speaker whose star is rising in conservative circles, faces a rematch against Doug Owens, her 2014 opponent. While she’s currently ahead in most polls, the sizable X-factor for Utah Republicans is how Trump—a candidate widely disliked by the state’s influential Mormon population—affects down-ballot Republicans.

9. Maine might become America’s biggest voting experiment

Fed up with Hillary Clinton and Donald Trump? Interested in voting for a third-party candidate, but don’t want to risk throwing the election to the candidate you dislike the most? An experiment in Maine could offer a solution: Question 5 on the state ballot proposes replacing Maine’s current electoral system with ranked-choice voting, allowing voters to express their numerical preferences for all state offices, including U.S. senators and U.S. representatives. When ballots are tallied, if no candidate has more than 50 percent of voters’ first choices, then the least-popular candidate will be eliminated. His or her supporters would have their top-ranked candidate crossed off their ballots, and their votes would fall to their second-ranked candidates.

Supporters believe that ranked-choice voting empowers third parties and gives voters more options. Detractors believe that there’s nothing wrong with the simple “majority or plurality rules” setup right now, and point to studies linking ranked-choice voting to lower voter turnout.

While Maine would be the first state to adopt such a system, San Francisco, Oakland, St. Paul and Minneapolis currently use ranked-choice voting, as does the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences in selection of the Academy Award for Best Picture.

10. Background-check loopholes on gun purchases could be closed in a fifth of the country

Both Republican-backed and Democrat-backed bills to reform America’s background-check system failed this year in the Senate, so gun control advocates are taking the fight to the states. Maine and Nevada are poised to become the ninth and 10th states requiring universal background checks, and Californians will decide whether to join New York, Connecticut and Washington, D.C., in requiring background checks for ammunition purchases.

11. Massachusetts could be the first state to regulate how chickens and cows live

Massachusetts isn’t a large producer of eggs or meat, but animal-rights groups and national trade associations are paying close attention to the state this year. Question 3 on the ballot would require giving farm animals enough space to lie down, stand up, extend their limbs and turn around — essentially banning inhumane confined animal feeding operations.

Proponents don’t think that is asking for much, but opponents insist it would substantially raise egg prices because farms from outside the state would have to comply if they wished to import and sell their products in Massachusetts. The Humane Society of the United States has poured more than a million dollars into the “yes” campaign, and if the measure passes, it could soon show up on ballots in other states.

12. The first Latina could be elected to the U.S. Senate

It depends on the outcome of Senate elections in California and Nevada, but 2017 could see the first Latina member of the U.S. Senate.

In California, Democratic Congresswoman Loretta Sanchez is running to succeed outgoing Senator Barbara Boxer. Due to the oddities of California’s electoral system, her general-election matchup pits her against California Attorney General Kamala Harris, a fellow Democrat. Polls currently have Sanchez down by double digits, but even if she loses, history could be made in the state next door.

Former Nevada Attorney General Catherine Cortez Masto is locked in a tight race against Republican Rep. Joe Heck for the Senate seat being vacated by Harry Reid. Most recent polls give Masto a slight edge, and if those numbers hold—and Loretta Sanchez loses in California—Cortez Masto would become the first Latina to serve in the United States Senate.

13. As state referendums become more common in the U.S., California could push direct democracy one step further

Since 1996, California has averaged an eye-popping 18 statewide ballot propositions every two years. That could intensify after 2016: This year, Proposition 53 would give even more control to voters. Under its language, any infrastructure project costing more than $2 billion would automatically require voter approval.

In the foreseeable future, this would require a ballot measure to approve any major infrastructure project in the state—including, notably, existing plans for a major water tunnel project in central California and the high-speed rail project that Sacramento has discussed for years. The power to fund big budget items could now be in the hands of Californians, and that alone would be an unprecedented experiment in direct democracy.

14. New funding for high-risk, high-reward biomedical research could die in the Senate 

If the Senate shifts to Democratic control—depending on the results of the lame-duck session—it could signal the death knell for the 21st Century Cures legislation, which passed the House but is being held up in the Senate by a partisan budget conflict. Democratic leadership in the Senate supports the bill, but it isn't particularly passionate about it, and the legislation might not be the priority for Democrats that it has been under the stewardship of Republican Senators Lamar Alexander and Bill Cassidy.

15. Washington and South Dakota may introduce new public financing of political campaigns

Currently, South Dakota imposes no limits on individual contributions to parties and PACs. But if Ballot Measure 22 passes, not only will there be a $2,000 limit, the state’s entire campaign finance system will be overhauled. Measure 22 would allow voters to direct up to $12 million of state funding in the form of $50 vouchers to candidates of their choice. To accept those vouchers, candidates would have to waive most traditional fundraising methods.

Washington state is proposing a similar “democracy credits” system, and could also cap campaign contributions from lobbyists and government contractors to a mere $100, an effort to curb “pay to play” corruption.

16. Cigarettes could get a whole lot more expensive for 51.4 million Americans

Thirty years ago, there were nearly 180,000 tobacco farms in the U.S. Today, that number is closer to 10,000. Unfortunately for Big Tobacco, that trend looks to continue: Cigarettes are already one of the most heavily taxed products in the U.S., but that hasn't stopped tobacco tax measures from making it on the ballots in four states this November.

Cigarette taxes could increase by $2 per pack in California, by $1.75 per pack in Colorado, by 60 or 23 cents in Missouri—where 1 in 4 residents are smokers—and by $1.76 in North Dakota.

17. Washington, D.C., could take a big step toward statehood

After years of decrying the sad state of taxation without congressional representation for D.C. residents, Mayor Muriel Bowser decided to try a new, old method to push for statehood. Modeling the approach on the one Tennessee used in 1796, when the territory first approved a state constitution and then applied for statehood, D.C. ballots will give voters the opportunity to authorize the City Council to approve a constitution for the proposed state of New Columbia.

It may not be enough to move Congress to grant statehood to the District, but longtime advocates for the cause are holding out hope that a clear mandate from the city’s residents could force the government into action.

18. California’s porn industry could be forced to use condoms

In 2012, the AIDS Healthcare Foundation pushed Measure B through Los Angeles County, requiring actors in pornographic films to wear condoms in all scenes depicting penetrative sex. Now, the foundation wants to expand the regulation statewide.

Unsurprisingly, the adult film industry thinks the proposed regulation is a horrible idea. Perhaps more surprisingly, though, the state’s Democratic and Republican parties share their opposition to the proposal. But if voters say yes, then the nation’s largest adult film industry would have a choice: Go underground, leave the state, or invest in safe sex.

19. The Senate will almost certainly get its first biracial, and first Indian-American, woman

Kamala Harris is a trailblazing Democrat currently in her second term as California’s attorney general—she is the first Asian-American and first African-American woman to hold the position. In the race to succeed retiring Senator Barbara Boxer, Harris locked up most of the Democratic Party’s heavy hitters early on, including Elizabeth Warren, Cory Booker, Joe Biden and President Barack Obama, and that support has thrust her into a double-digit lead in the open Senate race.

If elected, she’ll make history as just the second African-American woman to serve in the U.S. Senate, as well as the first Indian-American and first biracial woman elected to the chamber. And if Hillary Clinton wins the presidency, you can count on her to be part of a Washington power couple of sorts: her sister, Maya Harris, is one of Clinton’s top policy advisers.

20. Several states that have opted out of Obamacare’s Medicaid expansion could flip their positions

Medicaid expansion was a major victory for President Obama in his push for health care reform, but not even the president can force every state to accept the expansion. As of today, 19 states (mostly with Republican governors) have opted out of the expansion, but in a few—such as Georgia, North Carolina, and Missouri—possible shakeups in state legislatures and governors’ houses could tip the balance in favor of expansion. Even crimson-red Alabama might choose to opt in.

21. The momentum behind soda taxes could go down the drain

When the liberal bastion of Berkeley, California, imposed the nation's first soda tax in 2014, it was a defeat for the soft-drink industry, but not altogether surprising. It makes sense that a notoriously crunchy college town would be the first domino to fall. But if the industry believed the damage could be contained there, they were wrong: Earlier this year, Philadelphia's City Council followed Berkeley's footsteps, enacting its own version of the soda tax.

Now, Big Soda faces a supersized obstacle: a three-front war in California. Voters in San Francisco, Oakland and Albany will weigh in on the sugary sin tax this November. Both the pro and anti sides have their wallets at the ready for the upcoming showdown: The beverage industry has already spent more than $30 million this election cycle, and anti-soda crusader Michael Bloomberg has personally contributed $9 million to the cause.

22. Your doctor could legally help end your life in one-sixth of the country

Colorado voters will decide via a statewide referendum in November whether to enact “Death with Dignity” legislation that allows terminally ill patients to receive life-ending treatment from their doctors. If the measure passes, Colorado will join Washington, Oregon, California and Vermont as the only states with such laws on the books (Montana also allows assisted suicide, but via a court ruling rather than legislation). Next year it’s likely that even more of the nation will join their ranks: the legislatures of at least 20 states are considering the issue.

23. Minimum wage raises could soon be coming to 23 states — and the minimum wage could actually go down in South Dakota

The federal minimum wage of $7.25 hasn’t budged in seven years, and many states aren’t waiting for Congress to push it higher. Voters in Colorado, Arizona, and Maine will decide whether to increase the minimum wage to $12 by 2020, and Washingtonians will consider raising it to $13.50.

If these measures succeed, 14 states will have scheduled future increases in the minimum wage, along with eight others with plans to annually adjust their minimum wages as the cost of living rises.

One state, South Dakota, will vote on whether to decrease the minimum wage by a dollar for workers under the age of 18.

24. States will decide whether to grant special tax exemptions to seniors, first responders and other interest groups 

The idea isn’t entirely new: after 9/11, Congress authorized major tax breaks for first responders, survivors and their families. Now, voters in some states are considering granting property tax exemptions to a variety of politically powerful groups: Senior citizens and first responders in Florida; the surviving spouses of first responders in Louisiana; and the spouses of public employees killed in the line of duty in Virginia could all receive property tax exemptions if voters signal their consent on Election Day.

25. Schools could get a lot more money in eight states

The economy has largely recovered from the Great Recession, but education funding has not. At least 23 states provide less general-education funding today than they did the year the economy tanked.

Now, some states want to fix that problem, but there are disputes over how to raise the money. Ballot initiatives in California, New Mexico and Rhode Island would issue bonds; an initiative in Oregon would tax corporations; Oklahoma would raise its sales tax; and North Dakota would divert some of its newfound oil wealth to the cause.

Billions in education funding is on the line, and the initiatives’ supporters and opponents have already pooled more than $50 million in campaign contributions.

26. Atlantic City could get another nail in the coffin

In the past two decades, more than a dozen casinos have opened in New York, Maryland and Pennsylvania. Now, voters could give the green light for more casinos in Massachusetts and Rhode Island, and voters in New Jersey face a choice: Public Question 1 would allow two new casinos to be built in New Jersey outside of Atlantic City.

Opponents to the New Jersey measure say that breaking Atlantic City’s statewide monopoly would doom the town, while proponents contend that new casinos are Atlantic City’s only hope, because one third of the revenue the state gets from them would go to an Atlantic City revitalization fund.

But with increasing competition from other casinos—like those on ballots in Rhode Island and Massachusetts—it’s hard to know if New Jersey’s proposed plan could realistically raise enough revenue to revive the city of Donald Trump’s failed Taj Mahal, which shuttered its windows for good earlier this fall.

27. Voters will decide whether there should be an age limit for judges

In some communities, this election is turning out to be something of a referendum on an issue that doesn’t get much coverage: age limits for judges. As of today, 32 states have enacted age limits for judges, and some of them are beginning to regret it: Pennsylvania voters could raise the maximum age from 70 to 75, and Oregon could repeal its age limit of 75 altogether. Alabama is considering ballot initiatives that would change the existing age limits for both some of its judges and civic servants. Supporters argue that people are living longer, medicine has improved the quality of life for senior citizens, and therefore it only makes sense that judges can serve longer.

28. California will push the upper limits of how much it can tax its wealthiest residents

When Californians voted for Proposition 30 in 2012, it created four high-income tax brackets that would be effective for seven years. The top bracket, a 13.3 percent charge on income over $1 million, is easily the highest state tax in the country. Now, voters have the opportunity to extend the high-income tax hikes through 2030. If they do, the question is whether other blue states will follow. Maine, for its part, will also be voting on whether to raise the income tax by 3 percent on household income over $200,000.

29. Washington could enact one of the nation’s toughest gun laws ever

In 2014, in the wake of the UCSB shooting, California Governor Jerry Brown passed a law allowing family members and law enforcement to petition a judge to issue Gun Violence Restraining Orders, which can temporarily prohibit a person at danger of hurting themselves or others from purchasing or possessing a firearm. Now, Washington state has a similar initiative on the ballot, the first time the proposal has ever been placed directly in front of voters.

30. A state government might set a groundbreaking cap on drug prices

Just because Medicare is legally prevented from negotiating drug prices—which is one reason why pharmaceutical costs are going up—doesn’t mean that California can’t.

In what is becoming one of the most expensive initiative campaigns in the country’s history—with $123 million raised and counting—Californians are considering an unprecedented rebuke to the Big Pharma. Proposition 61 would prohibit the state from buying drugs above the price given to the U.S. Department of Veteran Affairs, which receives an average discount of 24 percent off manufacturers’ prices.

Many opponents have no sympathy for pharmaceutical companies, but warn that there is no telling how the pharmaceutical industry would react—possibly hurting Californians in the long term. But if the proposition passes, it would be the largest legal reproach of Big Pharma yet, and could set a precedent. It’s the nation’s largest state by far, a huge market for medicine, is a center of the industry, and its price caps could have an impact that reverberates through health care markets throughout the nation—making the proposal meaningful both practically and symbolically.

Next year, Ohioans will vote on a near-identical ballot measure.

31. The country's only statewide ban on plastic bags could be thrown out

Every county of Hawaii has banned single-use plastic bags, but technically California can still become the first state to implement the ban this November. The legislation was enacted by the California State Legislature, but could be overturned by a “no” vote from Californians. If the proposition passes, stores could only sell recyclable paper bags or reusable bags to its customers.

32. Former refugees could arrive in legislatures

Refugees in the U.S., stuck in the spotlight thanks to Donald Trump, may be ready for 2016 to end. But the election could give them cause to celebrate: several refugees are en route to becoming elected officials.

Bao Nguyen, a Vietnamese-American born in a Thailand refugee camp, is the young Democratic mayor of Garden Grove, California, and is running for Congress in the state's 46th District. If he wins, he could become the second Vietnamese-American ever to serve in Congress.

Another promising race is in Minnesota, where 33-year-old Ilhan Omar, a Somali-born woman who as a child spent four years in a refugee camp, is expected to win a seat in the state Legislature. If elected, she would become America’s first Somali-American state legislator.

33. Vermont could get the world’s spaciest baseball player as governor

Those who know Bill "Spaceman" Lee aren't shocked to hear about the former Boston Red Sox pitcher's gubernatorial bid in Vermont. Observers have long thought Lee’s head is in the clouds: In 1971, Lee, while being interviewed by reporters in the Fenway Park locker room, abruptly switched the conversation from baseball to the Apollo 15 moon landing (hence the nickname, “Spaceman”).

In 1998, the Spaceman ran for president as the nominee of the Rhinoceros Party. His platform included bulldozing the Rocky Mountains so Alberta, Canada, could receive more sunlight. His slogan was, “No guns, no butter. Both can kill.”

Now, his name (nickname included) is on the Vermont ballot, this time as the gubernatorial nominee of the Liberty Union Party—the same party that once nominated Bernie Sanders in a failed gubernatorial effort. Lee has also changed up his pitch: "So far left, we're right." He promises that if elected, he will not do much.

Will the Spaceman win the race for governor? Probably not. According to Vermont Public Radio, he is currently polling at 2 percent. On the other hand, that might be enough to swing the race to Republican Phil Scott, who is neck-and-neck with Democratic nominee Sue Minter.

Confer with Comey...

Senior lawmakers confer with Comey about email review

By Colin Wilhelm

House Judiciary Committee Chairman Bob Goodlatte said on Sunday that he and the committee's top Democrat, Michigan Rep. John Conyers, had conferred over the weekend with FBI Director James Comey about the new review of emails that might involve Hillary Clinton's tenure as secretary of state.

“We both encouraged him to make sure that the American people have as much information as possible before they have to make a decision on Nov. 8, based upon this stunning new development, that the bureau is examining new evidence in this case, that they said they had completed several months ago,” Goodlatte said, explaining the conversation Saturday with Comey.

The Virginia Republican appeared on ABC's "This Week" with Rep. Adam Schiff of California, the top Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, who said that if Comey found no new evidence of wrongdoing he would need to "acknowledge he's made a serious mistake.”

Schiff added that Comey’s letter disclosing the review to congressional leaders on Friday constituted an “ambiguity bomb” that “clearly wasn't in the public interest.”

Goodlatte pushed back.

“I think the director is very conscious of this and he feels, I think, in a very difficult situation, but one which he thinks that given the fact that Mrs. Clinton has been traveling around the country for 3 ½ months saying that the FBI has cleared her of wrongdoing, that when there is new, and I believe, substantial information available why wouldn't he tell the American people that this is still under investigation?”

Goodlatte added that he questioned Comey about a potential perjury referral he and House Oversight Committee Chairman Jason Chaffetz (R-Utah) might make regarding Clinton’s earlier testimony to Congress, accidentally calling it an “impeachment” referral before correcting himself. And Comey directed the congressmen to the Justice Department, Goodlatte said.

Obama ratchets up

Obama ratchets up fight to unseat Rubio 

By Sarah Wheaton

If Rep. Patrick Murphy manages a come-from-behind victory in his bid to unseat Sen. Marco Rubio, he may have to say, “Thanks, Obama.”

National Democrats cut bait on Murphy last week, essentially ceding the Florida contest to Rubio as the Republican rose in the polls despite Donald Trump’s decline. It’s President Barack Obama who has come to Murphy’s rescue, touting the two-term congressman during his second trip to Florida in just eight days. And, the White House announced, Obama will head to both Miami and Jacksonville on Thursday.

Officially, Obama is campaigning for Hillary Clinton in the top swing state. But his efforts on Murphy’s behalf appear to be the trailing Democrat’s most significant bit of outside help.

On Friday, Obama called Murphy a “hard worker” in the mold of the Democratic nominee. The president touted Murphy’s work on Everglades restoration and led the crowd of some 9,000 people in the University of Central Florida’s basketball arena in a chant of “Patrick! Patrick! Patrick!”

There was no mention in Obama’s speech of the FBI taking renewed interest in Clinton's emails, which in turn had given embattled Senate Republicans nationwide the opportunity to play some offense after the news broke Friday afternoon.

Instead, Obama talked up Clinton’s experience, reveled in his own record and expounded on the ways in which Murphy was unlike the incumbent.

“Unlike his opponent, Marco Rubio, Patrick actually shows up to his job,” an apparent reference to Rubio’s many missed votes while he was running for the GOP nomination.

“He didn't say that he was supportive of Florida's Latino community but then, when the politics got tough, you walk away from comprehensive immigration reform,” Obama continued. “Unlike his opponent, he actually believes in science and that climate change is happening.”

All that was relatively mild compared to the broadside Obama launched against Rubio the week before.

Just two days after the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee reneged on $6 million in planned spending, Obama traveled to Miami on October 20 and ripped into Rubio for showing the “height of cynicism” in supporting the Republican nominee.

Democratic turnout in early and absentee voting has encouraged party operatives. But Murphy has consistently trailed Rubio in public polling, even if the margin has varied from survey to survey.

Murphy easily won his primary against Rep. Alan Grayson (D-Fla.), a race in which Obama also endorsed him. But since then, Murphy has been plagued by low name recognition and –- when his name does get out – by damaging opposition hits on his record in private business

Murphy especially has underperformed with black and Hispanic voters, who his campaign acknowledges have little knowledge of his candidacy. Obama’s trips to Florida to rip Rubio are the best earned media Murphy can get.

Other national Democrats appear to be reconsidering the Sunshine State write-off. Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid has been frustrated that his party has given the once, and likely future, presidential candidate Rubio a pass. His Senate Majority PAC on Thursday transferred at least $1 million to a super PAC backing Murphy.

“It’s great to have this kind of enthusiasm, this kind of support – from a sitting president,” marveled Murphy, who had spoken at the rally shortly before Obama. “This isn’t that common, to have a sort of a hand-off happening, a president with these sort of favorables, really unprecedented in recent history.”

In an interview with POLITICO, he said Obama’s help was coming at just the right time, though he stopped short of crediting the president’s attention with any shift in momentum.

“I would say in general you’ve got a lot of people starting to pay attention more and more to down-ballot races,” Murphy said. “My name ID obviously isn’t as high as Sen. Rubio’s. I haven’t run for president. So having this kind of thing is very helpful.”

Murphy’s not understating his name ID problem.

“I just wish that there was more information about him,” said Olga Zhorzholiani, a UCF student attending the rally. Before this, I don’t think anyone really knew that much about him, and he does seem like a nice guy.”

Zhorzholiani said she already voted early, and didn’t want to divulge her choices. “I’m more familiar with Marco Rubio,” she added, “but I don’t support any of his policies.”

Obama’s efforts appear to be a strategic split from Sen. Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) and the DSCC. White House spokesman Eric Schultz, noting to reporters that he used to work for the Senate campaign arm, said, “I am familiar with how hard it is, how complicated it is to make decisions regarding spending as campaigns wind down. So I’m not going to be in a position to second-guess those decisions.”

But the president, Schultz reiterated, “believes Congressman Murphy should be promoted to the United States Senate.”

Obama has been campaigning aggressively for down-ballot Democrats in recent weeks, working to lasso Republican Senate candidates to Trump even as he touts Clinton in Nevada and Ohio. His campaign schedule next week includes states that are both presidential and Senate battlegrounds, in addition to Florida: Ohio on Tuesday and North Carolina on Wednesday. He’s trying to help Clinton avoid Republican majorities in Congress, which stymied his efforts for all but the first two years of his presidency.

“If you think that the slogan, ‘Vote for us because we’re going to give you gridlock’ -- if you think that’s a good slogan –- then you should vote Republican,” Obama said. But if you care about things like equal pay and raising the minimum wage, he told the crowd, “then I need you not just to vote for Hillary, but I need you to vote up and down the ticket.”

Senate Leadership Fund, a PAC allied with Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, is one of several right-leaning groups that’s been hammering Murphy. Its communications director, Ian Prior, was underwhelmed by Obama’s plugs for the Democratic candidate.

“Him giving Murphy a few crumbs at rallies isn’t going to change the dynamic in a swing state where just under half of the voters pulled the lever for Romney,” Prior said. But the efforts might satiate another key constituency, Prior added in an email: Tom Murphy, the candidate’s mega-donor father.

“Let’s not forget that Patrick Murphy’s Republican father has donated well over $100,000 to Obama’s campaign and supportive entities over the years; that doesn’t even include all the money he’s given to the DNC and other Washington Democrat power players,” Prior said. “Looks like the perfect time for Democrats to return the favor, even if it isn’t with outside money.”

Obama, for his part, is also just having fun: he taped a video with the YouTube stars Liza Koshy, Lia Marie Johnson, and Adande Thorne (known to fans as Swoozie) to drill in his early voting message to their millions of millennial fans. And he even got to hang out briefly with Aerosmith on Air Force One as they passed through Orlando.

But it’s not time to declare victory yet, Obama warned, even though recent Florida polls show Clinton ahead.

“You know, sometimes when you get a lead, whether it's in sports or in politics, you start feeling good,” he said. “You start celebrating too early … You start missing some free throws… And next thing you know, you look up, and you let it slip away.”

He added, “See, I don't want y’all feeling too good.”

McCain campaigns

Confident McCain campaigns to keep his clout

The Arizona senator is crisscrossing the country to help the GOP hold the Senate — and retain his own perch overseeing the Pentagon.

By Seung Min Kim and Jeremy Herb

Sen. John McCain is hitting the road to save the Senate GOP majority — and his own job.

McCain knows that his clout in his sixth and probably final term in the Senate hinges on keeping the gavel of the powerful Armed Services Committee. So with his own reelection all but secured, the 80-year-old former presidential nominee has been barnstorming the country for other Republican candidates as the GOP looks to defy the odds on Nov. 8 and hang on to the majority.

Just last week, McCain ventured to Reno, Nevada, along with close pal Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-S.C.) to host a national security roundtable with GOP Senate candidate Joe Heck. Earlier this month, it was a veterans event in Indianapolis alongside Rep. Todd Young (R-Ind.). And right before Congress recessed in September, McCain took a quick jaunt to Folsom, Pennsylvania, to campaign with Sen. Pat Toomey (R-Pa.).

McCain's gaping lead against Democratic Rep. Ann Kirkpatrick in Arizona has allowed him to log all these frequent flier miles. McCain said in May he was bracing for "the race of my life" after Donald Trump became the presumptive GOP nominee, but it's turned out to be less than a nail-biter.

"As you know, I'm running for reelection," McCain said while campaigning for Toomey last month. "And I'm here for Pat Toomey because I believe Pat Toomey is critical for me to do my job."

Thanks to Senate Republican Conference rules governing committees, McCain would remain the top Republican on the Armed Services Committee only if his party keeps control of the chamber next year.

If Democrats win back the majority, Sen. Jim Inhofe of Oklahoma would assume the top Republican spot on Armed Services because McCain is term-limited as ranking member after serving in that role from 2007 to 2013. A senator can serve as ranking member for only three two-year terms, and chairman for another three terms.

McCain has operated his committee with a sense of urgency since he took over in 2015, acknowledging that his tenure could be short-lived. He’s pushed a host of changes to the Pentagon’s command structure and acquisition system, including eliminating the position of a key acquisition official he’s clashed with in the past.

Looking ahead to the prospect of Republicans losing the chamber, McCain noted last year that “every pundit says it’s 50/50 right now. So 50/50 motivates me to try to get as much done in a two-year period as I possibly can.”

A campaign spokeswoman did not return a request for comment on McCain's out-of-state travels.

Though Democratic presidential nominee Hillary Clinton is making a late push in Arizona, looking to capitalize on anti-Trump sentiment among the state's sizable Latino population, McCain still looks safe. The RealClearPolitics average of recent polls has McCain — who recently disavowed Trump after refusing to for more than a year — with a comfortable 14.5-point lead over Kirkpatrick.

Kirkpatrick’s campaign aides insist she's closing on McCain, and they're hitting the senator for what they say are fewer public appearances and less accessibility to the press. The Wall Street Journal reported recently that McCain didn't show up to a veterans event at an American Legion post that he was expected to attend.

“McCain's crass political opportunism on everything from immigration reform to his 60-plus endorsements of Donald Trump is embarrassingly transparent, and voters are fed up,” said Kirkpatrick campaign spokesman D.B. Mitchell, who accused the incumbent of "running from Arizona voters and reporters — both literally and figuratively."

But McCain seems undeterred by the pressure back home, proceeding apace with his campaign efforts for other Republicans, particularly those with a military background.

That was a key point McCain made as he stumped in Indianapolis this month for Young, a former Marine Corps intelligence officer, along with retiring Sen. Dan Coats (R-Ind.), a fellow veteran.

“I came here because I believe that it’s Dan’s and my obligation to bring forward another generation of men and women who have served this nation and know what this nation needs to defend itself and what we need to do to care for our veterans,” McCain said at the event.

Republicans in tough races are eager for an assist from McCain, whose stature in the GOP can help draw news coverage. Toomey’s campaign called McCain a “personal hero.”

McCain’s fate is being watched closely by the defense industry, which has changed its tune this election cycle and doled out cash for McCain. He has received more than $190,000 from defense industry political action committees this cycle, according to a POLITICO review of Federal Election Commission filings.

McCain has been a double-edged sword for the defense industry as head of the military panel. The Arizona Republican is a clear booster for more defense dollars and unsuccessfully pushed the Senate to approve more funding for fighter jets, ships and helicopters earlier this year.

At the same time, he's known for going hard after programs he considers wasteful. McCain has pushed for stricter, cost-controlled contracts for weapons programs and caps on major programs like the new USS Gerald R. Ford aircraft carrier.