A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



May 31, 2016

Romney treatment

Clinton gives Trump the Mitt Romney treatment

The attacks on Donald Trump have a familiar ring to them. 

By Gabriel Debenedetti

He’s too rich and out of touch to understand the problems facing average Americans. He’s hiding something in his tax returns. He’s a cold-blooded capitalist predator — and there’s a recording to prove it.

If the Hillary Clinton campaign’s attacks on Donald Trump feel a little familiar, it’s because they appear to be straight from Barack Obama’s 2012 campaign against Mitt Romney.

That push was successful, as Clinton’s allies are quick to point out. But it also runs the risk of being a little too conventional for a candidate as unconventional as Trump, leaving some former Obama operatives and Never Trump Republicans eager for reassurance that the Romney approach isn’t the only arrow in the quiver.

“Donald Trump is a pretty nontraditional candidate, but in a lot of ways we’re about to see a very traditional campaign, because it works,” said one former top Obama campaign official. “We beat the drum on Romney for months on jobs and his record, calling him out of touch with most Americans — for months — through paid media, candidate appearances, using surrogates.”

“I don’t think it’s a mistake,” he added. “But I don’t think we’ll know if it’s a mistake for months."

The Clinton campaign shies away from the parallel, understanding the urgency for rewriting the rules against Trump. They point out that the strategy is just one push in their multi-front assault on the real estate developer, one that also brands him as risky and xenophobic — something far worse than Romney.

But the opening shots of what figures to be a brutal general election campaign still have the unmistakable residue of 2012 — by design. It’s a crucial part of the effort to lay down an early definition of Clinton’s opponent — a goal that closely mirrors Obama’s 2012 attempt, his 2008 campaign manager David Plouffe told Clinton fundraisers at a private meeting in San Francisco two weeks ago.

“This is the exact way to do it, it’s just like Mitt Romney, except worse,” said Ohio Rep. Tim Ryan, a Clinton supporter who has campaigned with her in the crucial swing state and spoken out against a 2006 recording of Trump admitting he hoped for a housing market collapse in order to capitalize on it.

“I actually think there’s a great parallel between the comments about rooting for the housing market to collapse and the ‘47 percent’ comment. It’s right out of the horse’s mouth. It’s on tape and it’s going to get played over and over and over again. Just being back in Ohio today, and running around the district this morning, people are already talking about that, and that’s what you want. It’s one thing to take advantage of the collapse, it’s another to root for it.”

“It speaks to his worldview and his lack of knowledge about what average people go through while you’re a billionaire sitting in Trump Tower,” he added.

Romney’s chief strategist, Stuart Stevens, said one benefit of the message is that it might work to help bring Bernie Sanders’ supporters into the fold to support Clinton.

“Their first task is to unify the party, so I think they’re asking themselves what message works best to bring Bernie Sanders voters to them, and I think that probably they’ve done an analysis showing that it moves Sanders voters, because it’s something that Bernie Sanders could be seen saying," he explained.

Clinton’s campaign spent much of last week trying to inject the 2006 recording — and denunciations of it — into the mainstream conversation, aiming to demonstrate to voters that Trump was actively rooting against their interests.

The campaign made a major surrogate effort over conference calls and speeches and dialed into swing state media to talk about the housing crisis, which hit crucial purple-state targets Florida and Nevada especially hard.

They’ve also attempted to highlight Trump’s uncommon attachment to money as another sign of his distance from everyday Americans, on Thursday circulating a report about his latest controversial statement: “You have to be wealthy in order to be great.” (He was referring to the United States as a whole.)

To people in the Clinton political operation, the Trump recording — which was part of his Trump University program — is a clear echo of the recording secretly taken by a bartender at a 2012 Romney fundraiser, which was immediately used by Democrats to paint the GOP nominee as out of touch.

Kevin Madden, a senior adviser to Romney in 2008 and 2012, warned that what worked against a more traditional candidate like Romney might not be as damaging to a candidate like Trump who has already established a connection with many lower-income voters.

“What [the Clinton team] saw in the 2012 template was that this one [tactic] was successful then, and it can be successful now. But the thing they have to be careful about is not all Republican candidates are alike,” he said. “Every cycle is unique. Mitt Romney is much more vulnerable on the question of reliability of lower-income, working-class voters than Donald Trump."

The recording isn’t the only thing ripped from the 2012 playbook — there’s also the matter of Trump’s refusal to release his tax returns. While some commentators have suggested that Trump is obscuring the records because he is not as wealthy as he claims, the Clinton campaign has focused on painting him as an unrelatable billionaire who is looking for special treatment — much like the Obama argument.

“Where I think the tax issue became a vulnerability was the Obama campaign tried to turn it into a character issue about trust and transparency. I think the initial hesitation [from Romney] on releasing them and drawing that issue out turned into an even greater vulnerability as a result,” said Madden. “They tried to make the 2012 central question: ‘Who’s on your side?’ And [our] being slow on releasing the tax returns was a way for them to use that to their advantage.”

Now, with Trump not just slow-walking his tax disclosure but altogether refusing to his release his returns, Clinton has taken to the trail to criticize the bilionaire’s unprecedented move. And in an echo of then-Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid’s controversial 2012 assertion that Romney hadn’t paid taxes for 10 years, Clinton has been suggesting that perhaps Trump is refusing to disclose his tax returns because he hasn’t paid taxes.

“[Trump] needs to release his tax returns. The only two we have show that he hasn’t paid a penny in taxes,” she said on “Meet The Press” on May 22, before continuing the attack while campaigning in California during the past week. “It may be that he hasn’t paid — ever — any federal income tax. That’s why we want to see his tax returns.”

So far, the various political groups associated with Clinton’s bid have pursued a different line of attack against Trump. The main super PAC supporting Clinton, for example, has started airing ads in swing states that focus on Trump’s controversial statements about women in an attempt to play up his divisiveness.

There is no immediate indication that the group, Priorities USA Action, will necessarily run testimonial ads like the ones it created against Romney, starring individuals who were harmed by his businesses. But their future spots will make the case that he’s dangerous and a con man.

The campaign’s “strategy appears to be to throw the kitchen sink at Trump and force him to react. It certainly has an economic dimension — exploitation of workers, use of cheap foreign labor, nonpayment of taxes, etc. — aimed at challenging his claim to be a tribune of the middle class,” said David Axelrod, the architect of Obama’s campaigns, echoing the sentiment of a handful of other Obama alums who warned that the strategy would work only if it was one part of a much broader offensive.

“But it seems to me that the larger and more damaging attacks go to temperament. Do people want a guy this impulsive, reactive and volatile in the Oval Office, with life and death powers? By provoking him to react, the Clinton team is hoping to burnish that case.”

Shady accounting

Shady accounting underpins Trump’s wealth

The GOP nominee is rich. But how rich depends on odd accounting and subjective criteria.

By Ben White

Donald Trump claims a net worth of more than $10 billion and an income of $557 million. But he appears to get there only by overvaluing properties and ignoring his expenses.

POLITICO spoke with more than a dozen financial experts and Trump’s fellow multimillionaires about the presumptive Republican nominee’s financial statement. Their conclusion: The real estate magnate’s bottom line — what he actually puts in his own pocket — could be much lower than he suggests. Some financial analysts said this, and a very low tax rate, is why Trump won’t release his tax returns.

“I know Donald, I’ve known him a long time, and it gets under his skin if you start writing about the reasons he won’t disclose his returns,” said one prominent hedge fund manager who declined to be identified by name so as not to draw Trump’s ire. “You would see that he doesn’t have the money that he claims to have and he’s not paying much of anything in taxes.”

Trump is certainly wealthy. But in a campaign where the New Yorker has portrayed himself as the biggest, the richest, the classiest and the best at everything, disclosing that he is less rich than he lets on could be damaging. And it is a line of attack Democrats are already using and hope to pound away on until November.

The case against Trump’s accounting of his wealth: His businesses apparently generate a lot of revenue but may not put much cash in his pocket; he assigns himself a net worth that is impossible to verify and may be based in part on fantasy; and he is selling assets and increasing debt in ways that suggest a man scrambling for ready cash.

In response to a list of questions for this story, Trump campaign spokeswoman Hope Hicks emailed: “The report speaks for itself.” If it does, the report does not speak clearly.

The financial disclosure form showed Trump adding fresh debt of at least $50 million, though a campaign news release said Trump is using increased revenue to reduce his debt, which is now at least $315 million and possibly more than $500 million. The disclosure also suggests that Trump sold fund assets to raise as much as $7 million in cash and individual securities to raise up to $9 million more.

The apparent increase in debt and securities sales raises questions about the amount of cash Trump has on hand.

“If he is swimming in so much cash for all his holdings, why is he selling this stuff to raise cash?” asked another ultra-high net worth individual who also reviewed the filings and declined to be identified by name to avoid Trump’s wrath.

Trump’s tax returns could clarify a great deal about his actual income. But Trump’s campaign chairman, Paul Manafort, said in an interview with The Huffington Post last week that he would be “surprised” if Trump ever releases the returns, which is not required but which every major presidential candidate has done since 1976.

Trump attributes the refusal to ongoing audits. But there is no prohibition on individuals releasing returns under scrutiny by the IRS. The refusal has led to rampant speculation among Wall Street executives who have done deals with Trump that his returns would show surprisingly low income.

There is no dispute that Trump owns many valuable properties that contribute to a high net worth. But there is a great deal of dispute about how high that worth actually is. The financial disclosure form lists assets worth at least $1.5 billion, but the ranges included are far too wide for an observer to determine anything close to a precise figure.

“Trump has a tendency to value his brand at a very high amount, but these are usually intangible valuations just pulled out of thin air,” said Steve Stanganelli, a certified financial planner at Clear View Wealth Advisors. “And he appears to be reporting gross revenue. There is a huge difference between that and net income. What really matters is what you put in the bank.”

Estimates of Trump’s net worth range from a low of $150 million to $250 million asserted by journalist Timothy O’Brien in a 2005 book that earned him a libel lawsuit from Trump that was eventually dismissed. O’Brien saw Trump’s tax returns as part of the discovery in that suit but the records were sealed by the court and O’Brien is not allowed to discuss them in any detail.

One revelation made public as part of the suit was that Trump’s valuation of himself and his empire fluctuates based on his own “feelings.” Fortune magazine earlier this month estimated Trump’s net worth at $3.92 billion based on the latest financial disclosure.

A big chunk of Trump’s net worth figure comes from high valuations he bestows on his golf course properties. Trump values nine of his golf properties at “over $50 million” for a total of at least $450 million. He values at least four more at up to $25 million and a fifth at up to $50 million. But golf course valuation experts say there is nothing in the report to support these lofty figures.

“Unless we really know what the income and expenses for the clubs are, it’s impossible to even guess at what the value would be,” said Larry Hirsh, a founder of the Society of Golf Appraisers and the president of Golf Property Analysts. “He’s a classic example of a guy that, when he wants to get a loan or tell you how wealthy he is, he’ll tell you something is worth a bazillion dollars. But when he wants to get taxes reduced, he’ll tell you it’s worth $2.95.”

In fact, a New York state political official accuses Trump of doing exactly that.

On his disclosure report, Trump lists the Trump National Golf Club in Westchester Country, New York, as worth over $50 million. But ABC News reported earlier this month that for tax purposes, Trump’s attorneys at first argued the property was worth just $1.35 million before increasing the figure to $9 million, according to ABC.

A golf property’s valuation can be much lower for tax purposes than the price it might bring in a sale. Tax authorities don’t take into account what the underlying land might be used for by another owner, along with other variables.

But in this case, this difference was far too great, according to Dana Levenberg, the supervisor for Ossining, New York, which oversees the property. Levenberg argues that Trump’s undervaluation of the property is taking money away from children in the local Briarcliff School District.

“We have somebody on the one hand who has lawyers saying the value is less than $2 million while at the same time he’s claiming it’s worth over $50 million,” Levenberg said in an interview. “And we have seen no revenue or expense forms. It can’t be that he is making all this money but saying he doesn’t have to pay taxes on it. That’s less money for the children in school, less money for learning.”

Trump’s valuations of his golf properties is much higher than recent golf property sales would appear to support. According to Bloomberg, Orlando-based CNL Lifestyle Properties in 2015 sold 48 golf courses, with $158 million in revenue in 2013, for $320 million. Dallas-based ClubCorp Holdings last year agreed to pay $265 million for 50 golf courses with around $100 million in total annual revenue, according to Bloomberg.

Trump also claims high revenues at many of his golf properties.

The biggest revenue generator listed on Trump’s report is Trump National Doral in Miami at $132 million. In total, 14 golf properties listed on the disclosure form provided at least $300 million in revenue, more than half of Trump’s total claimed income, for an average of around $21 million per property.

That is far higher than the revenue typical of many golf courses. But several of Trump’s properties, including Doral, feature multiple courses and revenue-producing resorts, making the numbers somewhat less outlandish. “I would use 23 as the number of courses,” said Steven Ekovich, managing director for the Leisure Investment Properties Group at Marcus & Millichap, who has sold golf properties to Trump and said the revenues “comport with some other high-end clubs.”

Regardless of revenue, Ekovich said, it’s difficult to use any standard revenue-multiple model to evaluate the ultimate worth for golf properties. “It’s really an art form in pricing golf assets because each one is so unique.”

That art form is expected to come under relentless scrutiny from Democrats in a general election campaign that is expected to pit Trump against former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. The Clinton campaign wants to portray Trump’s business empire as a Potemkin village, showy on the surface, but with little underneath.

People familiar with the matter say Democrats have leading forensic accountants poring over all of Trump’s public records and disclosures with a plan to release whatever they find to support this narrative as the campaign shifts into general election mode this summer and fall.

“Some of the stuff is supposedly dynamite,” one senior Democratic operative with ties to the Clinton campaign said. “They are very confident about the opposition research. But I wouldn't expect anything cataclysmic until the fall.”

Clinton supporters have been taunting Trump on Twitter with the #PoorDonald hashtag and Clinton herself has questioned the mogul’s statements about his wealth. “We’ve got to get below the hype,” Clinton said recently on NBC’s “Meet the Press.” “I think we’re beginning to find out, but I don’t think we know enough, and that’s why he should release his tax returns.”

Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) has also emerged as a high-profile Democratic surrogate prosecuting the case that Trump might not be as rich as he says he is. “We don’t know what Trump pays in taxes because he is the first presidential nominee in 40 years to refuse to disclose his tax returns,” Warren said in a fiery speech last week, followed by an extended Twitter war with the presumptive GOP nominee. “Maybe he’s just a lousy businessman who doesn’t want you to find out that he’s worth a lot less money than he claims.”

Thus far, Trump has proved impervious to this line of argument, backing up claims from Manafort and others that voters simply don’t care about Trump’s tax returns and believe that he is the fabulously successful titan he says he is.

But if anything could damage the Trump brand, some analysts say, it would be persistent revelations about his business record and personal riches. “By any stretch, Trump is rich. But the perception now is that he is richer and huger and better than everyone,” said Stanganelli. “What happens if that perception changes?”

Happy Tuesday








May 27, 2016

Pesticides Great Again

GOP Lawmakers Capitalize on Zika Threat to Pass Bill Dubbed 'Making Pesticides Great Again' Act

House Democrats and Obama administration, meanwhile, criticize bill's assault on Clean Water Act

by Andrea Germanos

The Republican-controlled U.S. House on Tuesday passed legislation—newly rebranded with the word "Zika" in it—that Democrats say is in fact not at all about the addressing the threat of the virus but making it easier for pesticides to contaminate the nation's waterways.

Previously called the "Reducing Regulatory Burdens Act," the "Zika Vector Control Act" passed the House 258-156.

According to House Democratic Whip Steny H. Hoyer (Md), H.R. 897 "is nothing but a Trojan horse, with practically nothing to do with Zika."

It was sponsored by Rep. Bob Gibbs (R-Ohio), who, as Cleveland.com reported last week, "For years [...] has tried to get Congress to change permitting requirements for pesticides sprayed near water."

The Obama administration issued a statement earlier this week saying (pdf) that it "strongly opposes" the legislation, as it "would weaken environmental protections under the Clean Water Act." Indeed, the Act's summary states that it

'establishes exemptions for the following discharges containing a pesticide or pesticide residue: (1) a discharge resulting from the application of a pesticide in violation of FIFRA that is relevant to protecting water quality, if the discharge would not have occurred but for the violation or the amount of pesticide or pesticide residue contained in the discharge is greater than would have occurred without the violation; (2) stormwater discharges regulated under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES); and (3) discharges regulated under NPDES of manufacturing or industrial effluent or treatment works effluent and discharges incidental to the normal operation of a vessel, including a discharge resulting from operations concerning ballast water held in ships to increase stability or vessel biofouling prevention.'

Gibbs, The Hill notes, "said it would help to eliminate a 'duplicative and unnecessary permitting regulation' that has made it more difficult for some local governments to spread for mosquitoes."

Journalist and documentary filmmaker Leighton Woodhouse, for his part, referred to the bill as "Straight up #disastercapitalism."

Representative Rosa L. DeLauro (D-Conn.)., meanwhile, said it "is a sham."

"It is nothing but trying to weaken the environmental regulations. It exempts, a broad exemption, of toxic pesticides from the Clean Water Act," she said to PBS Newshour Monday, adding that the bill stands to "pollute our rivers and contaminate our water."

Rep. Grace F. Napolitano (D-Calif.) spoke out against the measure on the House floor Tuesday, calling it "misguided" and "harmful."

"I am very concerned about the effect of these pesticides on the health of our rivers, on our streams, and especially the drinking water supplies of all our citizens, including pregnant women," Napolitano added.

Slamming the repeated iterations of the bill that threatens "to undo protections that safeguard our environment and public health," Hoyer said that to "bring the same bill back to the Floor last week and again today, renamed with 'Zika' in the title, is one of the most egregious displays of dishonesty I've seen while serving in the House."

"It is an act that seeks to provide political cover for Republicans who refused to act on President Obama's urgent request for funding to address the Zika outbreak in a serious way. House Republicans might as well bring this bill to the Floor and rename it the 'Making Pesticides Great Again' Act, because in truth it would remove virtually all federal oversight concerning the use of chemical pesticides to ensure they do not end up in our water supply," he charged.

Rattled

Obama: Trump Candidacy Has 'Rattled' World Leaders

by Cassandra Vinograd

 President Barack Obama said Thursday that world leaders are "rattled" by Donald Trump — and "for good reason."

During a press conference in Japan, Obama said the American presidential election is being "very" closely watched oversees. He told reporters that "it's fair to say" world leaders are "surprised" Trump is the presumptive Republican nominee.

"They are not sure how seriously to take some of his pronouncements but they're rattled by him — and for good reason, because a lot of the proposals that he's made display either ignorance of world affairs or a cavalier attitude," Obama added.

He suggested Trump's controversial proposals were more about "getting tweets and headlines" than "actually thinking through" what's needed to keep America safe or the "world on an even keel."

Trump has made China a frequent target of his attacks — such as saying the country will "suck the blood" out of the U.S.

 He also has said he wants to ban Muslims from entering the U.S., called the Iran deal "horrendous," pledged to "build a wall" along the Mexican border and that he'd have "no problem speaking to" North Korea's dictator.

Such a conversation would mark a major shift in U.S. policy towards Pyongyang — a country Obama earlier Thursday said was a "big worry."

North Korea's U.K. ambassador dismissed Trump's offer as "dramatics of a popular actors."

Trump also said he was unlikely to have a "very good relationship" with the U.K. — one of America's strongest allies — though later walked those comments back.

 Obama spoke to reporters in Japan, where he on Friday will become the first sitting U.S. president to visit the Hiroshima Peace Park Memorial.

While he addressed the historic event in his opening remarks, questions quickly shifted to the U.S. election race.

Obama acknowledged the challenges of the long-running battle for the Democratic candidacy.

"During primaries people get grumpy with each other," Obama said.

He told reporters that he's sure the contenders wish the fight was over.

"It's a grind," he added.

 As the race continues, a recent NBC News/Wall Street Journal Poll showed 61 percent of American voters said they were unsure about Trump's lack of military or government experience.

More than half of those polled — 56 percent — chose Democrat Hillary Clinton as the better candidate to handle foreign policy, compared to just 29 percent who picked Trump.

A lower total percentage of voters — 51 percent — expressed concern about Bernie Sanders potentially becoming the first self-described Democratic socialist to lead the country.

Unite / Disarray...

Role reversal: GOP unites behind Trump, Democrats in disarray

By Julian Zelizer

Just when it seemed that the election could not get any crazier, it has.

A month ago, it seemed that the Democrats were sitting pretty. Republicans were in disarray. All the talk revolved around a contested convention in Cleveland as Sen. Ted Cruz kept winning delegates in state conventions who would vote for him on the second round. The #Never Trump Movement was gaining steam as prominent members of the GOP announced that they would not be able to support the New York billionaire's candidacy.

In contrast, the Democrats had themselves an apparently solid nominee. After a series of strong wins, including in New York and Pennsylvania, it looked like Hillary Clinton would finally bring her competition with Bernie Sanders to an end. Clinton, it appeared, was poised to run a campaign that could replicate the events of 1964 when Lyndon Johnson trounced Barry Goldwater in a landslide victory that produced huge liberal majorities in the House and Senate.

Yet only a few weeks later, the story looks very different. Now it is the Democrats who are struggling through some fierce internecine divisions. Sanders' attacks have intensified in recent weeks. He has raised the volume of his comments about Clinton and charged that the entire nomination process has been problematic and unfair. His supporters have flooded the airwaves to complain about the superdelegates, while Sanders announced he would support Democratic National Committee Chairwoman Debbie Wasserman Schultz's primary opponent given her alleged favoritism toward Clinton. Sanders warned that the convention could be "messy," adding, "Democracy is not always nice and gentle."

On the GOP side, Donald Trump has clinched the nomination by reaching the required number of 1,237 convention delegates. Republicans are uniting around him. The Never Trump Movement has vanished almost as quickly as it started. House Speaker Paul Ryan, who began with some harsh words about Trump, mellowed soon after the two had their meeting on Capitol Hill.

While there are some Republicans like Mitt Romney who are still standing firm in their opposition, a significant number of prominent Republicans, including Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell, have announced their support.

Even Sen. Lindsey Graham, who was extremely harsh about Trump in recent weeks, allegedly told donors to stand behind their nominee (Graham disputed the account). Republican mega-donor Sheldon Adelson penned an op-ed proclaiming that Trump was the Republican candidate and thus his man.

Most ominously for Democrats, a number of recent polls are showing the gap between Clinton and Trump has been shrinking, with Trump actually taking the lead in some of them. "As we near the close of the primary season, Hillary Clinton has somehow succeeded in turning the election into a close contest that she could conceivably lose," wrote Thomas Edsall in The New York Times. What's going on? How and why did the situation change so dramatically within such a short period?

For Democrats, those who were hoping the tensions between Sanders and Clinton would dissipate greatly underestimated how serious the tensions are between Sanders, his supporters and the Clinton campaign.

The energy that has been moving his candidacy is much more than a cult of personality or a quixotic hope for socialism in America. Sanders and many of his supporters have been motivated by a principled argument about the problems with the Democratic Party and American politics.

In their minds, Hillary Clinton — and her husband — are symbols and leaders of a damaging development that has taken place since the 1970s. They argue that since Ronald Reagan was President, the Democratic Party decided to embrace the basic arguments of the conservative movement.

Democrats, they say, started to champion free markets, deregulation, nonunionized workplaces and a militaristic approach to foreign policy. As Democratic candidates catered to wealthier suburban voters, they left behind working-class Americans, unions, African-Americans, the poor and other disadvantaged groups.

Democrats, according to the Sanders campaign, have also agreed to work in a campaign finance system that ensures wealthier Americans as well as business and financial institutions will always win out in debates over public policy. Voters thus face a choice between Tweedledee and Tweedledum. Unless progressive forces fight for fundamental change, each election will involve a pragmatic decision that leaves the underlying status quo in place, they argue. The 2016 primaries are thus a battle for the soul of the Democratic Party and the future of American politics.

The fact that Hillary Clinton has continued to lose primaries and caucuses to Sanders fuels this narrative, that somehow even the Democratic Party's nomination process is also corrupt. When you have a debate that revolves so much around fundamental principles it is difficult to persuade your opponent to gracefully concede. It is unlikely that this is going to happen. Not only does this force Clinton to keep focusing on the primaries, rather than Trump, but the ongoing attacks on her keep hurting her standing and image in the polls.

Trump said Thursday that "Bernie has given me some great lines" to use against her. Polls are now showing that the June 7 primary in California is neck and neck, and a loss there would be a huge blow to Clinton's campaign, even if she could have enough votes to win the nomination at the convention in Philadelphia, given support from superdelegates. The State Department Inspector General's report on Clinton's email provides more fodder for Trump in his attacks on "Crooked Hillary" with the imprimatur of a nonpartisan body.

Trump and Sanders have even traded challenges to debate each other, at a time when Clinton has opted not to engage in a debate with Sanders before the California vote.

In contrast, much of the Republican party's primary battle over Donald Trump was more about personality than policy. To be sure, Trump's eclectic and unorthodox agenda has caused considerable consternation among many Republicans. The fact that he rejects reform of Social Security and Medicare doesn't sit well with many fiscal hawks, including Ryan.

Trump has lashed out against the free trade principles that Republican economists have been espousing. To have your front-runner support a higher minimum wage and agree that, at least sometimes, tax increases could be necessary is to utter words that are antithetical to what the party has been fighting for since Reagan.

Yet much of the real concern stemmed from who he was, not what he said. The truth is that his statements have been all over the place, other than his harsh stand toward immigrants, so Republicans can find reason to believe he might not be that serious about anything.

While Trump has said that some tax increases are acceptable, overall he remains an adherent of the supply side approach to the economy. Although he has argued that Planned Parenthood does good things for women, he has made some very tough statements against abortion.

Trump has also been increasingly shifting to the right in recent months. As a savvy political figure, he understands that his best bet as president would be to work closely with the party that brought him to the dance. And his harshest words, about immigrants and the need to build walls to stop them, have strong support in many parts of the GOP.

What has rubbed them the wrong way is who he is and what he says about the party. His crass mannerisms and harsh rhetoric don't make the party look serious. To have a bombastic television star at the head of the party ticket can make the GOP look silly, not like the party of governance.

But the reality is that the forces of partisanship are incredibly strong, particularly on the Republican side. It is difficult to dislodge voters in this day and age, as polls are showing. There are also many parts of the electorate in red states that are excited about Trump, and legislators are seeing this reality in the polls. This, combined with the intense antipathy toward Clinton and Barack Obama, has been enough to dampen the concerns that exist about Trump as a person.

If the Republicans see a winner, many are willing to line up behind whoever can bring them the White House even if they may find Trump's personality distasteful.

With one party's civil war about personality and the other about principle, it is not that surprising the Democrat Party fight is lasting longer than expected, and the Republican battles are dying down. This should cause concern for Democrats who might be looking at two more months, at a minimum, of bitter infighting, unless Clinton can find a way to win over Sanders supporters. While the Republican convention in Cleveland, once predicted to be a disorderly free-for-all, is looking more and more like it will be a well produced, sleek, televised coronation for the would-be king.

Perfectly diagnosed...

Jon Stewart perfectly diagnosed the problem with Hillary Clinton’s candidacy

By Chris Cillizza

Let's stipulate this: Hillary Clinton is going to be the Democratic presidential nominee.

But Clinton's path to that nomination has been far rockier than she or her supporters expected it to be when Bernie Sanders emerged as her main competition. (Don't believe the Clinton spin that they always knew that the 74-year-old democratic socialist from Vermont was going to pose a major threat to her candidacy.)

Some of that rockiness has to do with Sanders, who has emerged as a sort of cause celebre to the liberal left. Even in Sanders's surprising rise, however, are the seeds of Clinton's broader problem in the race: People struggle to relate to her. She often comes across as inauthentic or lacking a basic core of beliefs. The idea of finding out who the "real" Hillary Clinton is seems far-fetched. Even many people who believe she should  be president acknowledge, usually privately, that she is fundamentally unknowable.

Jon Stewart, the comedian turned late-night talk show host, summed up Clinton's candidate problems very well in a recent podcast interview with Democratic strategist David Axelrod. Here's the key bit:

That's a brutal assessment. But it's not wrong.

Awkward, right? As Stewart said, Magic's inability to pull off the late-night host gig wasn't a judgment against his broader persona — the guy is remarkably successful on and off the court — but simply reflected the fact that not everyone is good at everything. Magic didn't have a feel for what it took to host a late-night show. And there was no amount of coaching or studying that could make it all seem natural.

That's a very good diagnosis of Clinton the candidate, too. She is, without question, someone with long experience in public policy and public service. She has oodles of details about everything she would do if elected president. Her command of issues on a debate stage or in a media interview is without equal.

And yet, when she is out on the campaign trail, the word that most often comes to mind for Clinton is "clunky." Or "formulaic." "Guarded." Inauthentic." "Rehearsed."  You get the idea.  If connecting is the coin of the realm in politics, Clinton doesn't have much money in her pocket.

"Hillary is ... a bright woman without the courage of her convictions, because I don't know what they even are," says Stewart — an assessment I have heard time and again in private conversations with Democratic strategists over the last few years.

While Clinton's closest allies insist she is warm and funny in private, the candidate has never been able to translate those character traits into her public persona. People want Hillary Clinton, but all they ever get is "Hillary Clinton."

That's somewhat understandable, given that Clinton has not only been in the public eye for three decades but has also been the focus of Republican attacks for much of that time. Clinton fundamentally distrusts many of the actors in the political world — including the media — which makes it tough for her to show her true self.

Regardless of the reasons (and how justified they may nor may not be), the Clinton that voters meet tends to be someone who comes across as overly cautious and too political — afraid to say what she thinks about anything for fear of alienating this or that constituency.

In a political environment where a sizable chunk of voters have responded to the blunt realism of Donald Trump, that struggle to connect is a problem. Given Democrats' clear electoral and demographic edges in the 2016 election, Clinton's connectivity issues may not matter. But if her struggles to put away Sanders in the Democratic primary are any indication, then Stewart is really on to something.

Trump the Destroyer...

How Donald Trump Destroyed the Interview

A century-old political institution may have met its match.

By Jack Shafer

The interview is the Niagara that fills the news ocean. A quick check of the front page of the New York Times, a scan of any 30-minute block of CNN, or a few clicks on the POLITICO home page establish it: For generations, the interview has been a linchpin of the Fourth Estate, a way for journalists to assemble the authoritative story of who our leaders are, sort the false from the true, and hold power accountable. Conducted in person, over the phone, via email, and over Skype, the interview has become indispensable to the free press and especially to political journalists, who depend on it to X-ray politicians for the truth.

But in 2016, the interview appears to have met its match: Over the past 12 months of the presidential campaign, Donald Trump has dulled its power with his systematic evasions, contradictions and deceptions, making a general mockery of the form. Thanks to his skills at quibbling, his talent for the nonsequitur, and his willingness to reverse himself inside a single sentence, Trump has figured out how to soften rather than sharpen public discourse every time he is interviewed, blurring it into yet another form of meaningless PR, and—if he continues—destroying a journalistic institution in the process.

The latest example was his most-hyped appearance yet, his one-on-one prime-time interview with Fox News Channel anchor Megyn Kelly. In any normal cycle this meeting would have culminated in a campaign-defining shootout. As an attorney, Kelly brings to her news interrogatories a mindfulness that makes other journalists look slack, something she proved in the first Republican debate when she prompted Trump to overreact by confronting him with his own misogyny. From the starting gun, he undercut it completely. Trump even opened with a lie, when Kelly asked him to confirm what he had conceded to New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd in April—that retweeting an unflattering photo of Ted Cruz’s wife Heidi had been a “mistake.” Trump denied it—“Actually, I didn’t say it that way,” he said, when of course he had said it exactly that way. Kelly bore down on him, contesting the lie. But from his experience, Trump knows that even tenacious interviewers will give up and move on to the next question if faced with repeated categorical denials. He dug in deeper with that time-sucking ploy of his that occupies the semantic territory between double-talk and filibuster. Kelly moved on, her lawyerly spirit broken by his word-scramble, and the interview degenerated into a soft-focus meeting between frenemies.

That was only the latest example of Trump sabotaging a Q&A. He sabotages interviews not because he hates to be interviewed. More than any candidate running for president this year, he loves to engage the press in conversation. What he refuses to do is to be pinned down by and defend his own comments, repeatedly denying having said some easily verifiable thing. If Trump has been anywhere on an issue, chances are he’s been everywhere, expressing wildly incongruous positions on abortion, on immigration, on refugee issues, on health-care policy, on defeating ISIS, and more. The interview has gone from invaluable franchise into another forum for his lies. “Play [the tape] for me. Because I’d like to hear it,” he told the Washington Post over the phone this week when told he had claimed to have raised $6 million for veterans. But before the tape could be cued and played, Trump exited the Post interview, presumably to lie to a journalist holding on another line.

As a candidate, Trump’s fibs make entertaining copy. But as president, not even the cynics will be laughing at his fictions—and it’s worth thinking just how much this damage matters to America.

The interview enjoyed a central place in journalism for more than a century and a half before Trump arrived to corrupt the form. According to scholar Michael Schudson, the interview emerged as an American journalistic convention in the 1860s as the press transitioned from serving as the political parties mouthpieces into genuine diggers of news. The historical record of those earliest interviews is sketchy, Schudson writes, with the term “interview” being applied to “any kind of meeting and conversation between people,” even if it didn’t result in verbatim quotation. The interview gave journalists an almost unique mechanism to enquire and to test—that is, extract useful, newsworthy information from sources, and to get them to confirm what is already thought to be true. Its aggressive nature caused one English correspondent to liken the interview to a “modern and American Inquisition” in 1871.

The interview also changed the nature of presidential politics. At one time, getting a president’s views on the record meant quoting one of his speeches. Presidents would talk to reporters about the issues, but generally forbid them to quote the conversations because interviews seemed too familiar and undignified. That changed in 1867 when President Andrew Johnson, on the verge of being impeached, summoned correspondent Joseph B. McCullagh to the White House to hear and broadcast his side of the story. “The damn newspapers are as bad as the politicians in misrepresenting me,” Johnson told McCullagh, asking only to be quoted accurately. What Johnson instigated soon spread across the land, on to Europe, and eventually conquered all of journalism.

The interview became indispensable to journalism not because it works as a truth detector, but because it established useful ground rules for news reporting. As an act of “impersonal surveillance”—Schudson’s term—the interview put news subjects (politicians, potentates, captains of industry) on notice that their words and action were being noted and recorded for posterity. This surveillance, in turn, creating a sort of “impersonal social control”—Schudson’s coinage, again—that kept some sort of semblance of order in the house of truth. Yes, news subjects could still use the interview form to lie, but at the price of being found out and humbled and shamed. Even Richard Nixon, as wily a liar ever to submit to an interview, could not escape its censuring power, as David Frost wore him down in a set of 1977 interviews and got him to apologize for his transgressions.

Trump has defeated the interview by ignoring the impersonal social control it thrusts upon its subjects. Adopting a policy of maximum self-contradiction, he made a practice of reversing himself when expressing something as fact, frustrating his monitors. For example, one day in March he told ABC’s Good Morning America that he had seen a TV ad criticizing him. Minutes later he told NBC’s Today program that he hadn’t seen the ad. One day he says he’ll pay for the legal fees of supporters who punch protesters, the next day he says, “I didn’t say that.”

One day he tells Fox and Friends that Ted Cruz’s father was somehow implicated in the assassination of John F. Kennedy—”I mean, what was he doing with Lee Harvey Oswald, shortly before the death—before the shooting? It’s horrible.” The next he’s denying that implication to a reporter: “Of course I don’t believe that [about Cruz’s father]. I don’t believe it, but I did say ‘Let people read it.’ Speaking about the use of nuclear weapons at an MSNBC town hall in March, Trump set some sort of record in contradicting himself in one screwy sentence, saying, “I’m not going to use nuclear, but I’m not taking any cards off the table.”

What of Trump’s reputation for being a liar? “I don’t lie, I mean I don’t lie. In fact, if anything, I’m so truthful that it gets me in trouble, OK? They say I’m too truthful. And, no I don’t lie,” he told Greta Van Susteren in February. As my colleagues Michael Kruse and Noah Weiland documented earlier this month in a lengthy piece, almost everything that comes out of Trump’s mouth is provisional. Give him a few minutes, a couple hours, or even several years, and he’ll reverse most of what he has previously said.

Of course, Trump isn’t the only politician whose views turn elastic. This video supercut, for example, traps Hillary Clinton reversing her views on big issues over several years. But Clinton’s shifts aren’t directly comparable with Trump’s. It takes her months and sometimes years to revise her views, and most often the changes are guided by political calculation. Plus, interviewers make her forfeit a measure of credibility every time she switches views, as when she changed from being against gay marriage to being for it. But Trump’s are so frequent as to be arbitrary. Does he not remember from day to day what positions he’s taken? Or does it not matter to him what his position is, just that he has one?

Trump consistency about being inconsistent seems almost calculated to destroy the accountability that comes with being interviewed. It has already managed to displace the usual policy wonkery and debate of issues with something showier and more grand. A Trump political rally seeks to focus collective emotions, not make reasoned cases for one set of policies over another. To borrow a page from the rhetoricians, Trump rejects logos (the appeal to reason) when making his pitch and goes directly to pathos (the appeal to emotion) as he strives to elicit tears, laughter, and ultimately agreement from his supporters.

In dismissing logic and consistency for pure emotion, Trump has created a powerful reality-distortion field in both politics and journalism. The field doesn’t actually permit Trump to “get away with” lying in interviews: If you query his supporters, most will concede their man’s many fibs. In their minds, though, the “truth” matters less than what’s in Trump’s heart. It’s not that truth and fact don’t matter to them—it’s that truth and facts don’t matter enough to affect whether you want to vote for him. In an environment in which political success is almost totally detached from information, the “truth-finding” interview is becoming one of the first casualties.

By rejecting the authority of the press to judge him, Trump has debilitated if not destroyed the power of the interview, befuddling a press corps that still believes it can bring him down with one more gotcha, one more “Pinocchio“, one more “Pants On Fire“ from the fact-checkers. Trump is laughing at them now.

Heartland...

Trump woos the heartland

The magnate has polled especially well in rural counties — notwithstanding his hard-line positions on illegal immigration and trade, which might have ruinous consequences for farmers. 

By Helena Bottemiller Evich

Donald Trump may be a penthouse-dwelling New York City slicker, but he’s winning hearts in rural America — and his campaign has quietly started reaching out to farmers to bolster support in key agricultural states.

A group called Farmers for Trump, launched recently in Georgia, has been working with the campaign to answer farmers’ questions about where the real estate mogul stands on their issues — topics he has mostly avoided on the campaign trail.

Chad Etheridge, who founded the group after learning how Trump saved a Georgia farm from foreclosure in 1986, made a YouTube video about the little-known episode. Since then, Etheridge’s group has made about 300 calls to farmers asking them if they would support the businessman, and all but 10 have answered “yes.”

“I am positive not all farmers support Trump,” Etheridge said, “but it sure seems like the numbers are in his favor.”

Efforts by such fledgling groups to turn out the rural vote could be crucial to the presumptive nominee’s hopes of winning Rust Belt states like Michigan, Ohio and Pennsylvania in November — all of which also happen to be big farm states. Though farmers themselves make up less than 2 percent of the population, agriculture remains an anchor of rural economies.

“When you look at the states that Trump wants to put in play … agriculture could play a bigger role in this election than in the recent past,” predicts Marshall Matz, principal at Olsson Frank Weeda Terman Matz, a law and lobbying firm, who chaired President Barack Obama’s rural council in 2008. “People don’t realize those states have significant agricultural economies.”

But Matz, who is active in Democratic politics, doesn’t see Trump as a slam dunk with farmers despite their strong Republican leanings. He notes Hillary Clinton’s promises to boost support for farms of all sizes, while Trump has been silent on such issues — or worse, pledged to deport 11 million illegal immigrants, which would devastate farmers who rely on their labor.

“With Donald Trump as the Republican nominee, the farm vote is in play,” Matz contends.

The view from the ground is different: From the rural South through Nevada, the magnate has polled especially well in rural counties — notwithstanding his hard-line positions on illegal immigration and trade, which might have ruinous consequences for farmers.

“Donald Trump says things that I would never say, but the voters want change,” John Block, an agriculture secretary under Ronald Reagan who also works forOlsson Frank Weeda, wrote in a recent column.

While Trump has not formally named farm advisers — by this point in 2012, Mitt Romney had announced an entire advisory committee — the Trump campaign has developed the beginnings of a platform in conversations with grassroots supporters like Etheridge’s farmers’ group.

Besides Trump’s proposal to build a wall on the Mexican border, his campaign told farmers that he supports reviewing the guest worker programs that give farmers access to legal migrants — a stance many farmers applaud.

Trump endorses crop insurance, a top priority for farmers and, like House Speaker Paul Ryan, advocates separating the food stamp program from the farm bill, adding that he believes “agriculture is not about food — it is about national security,” according to another campaign response. That idea is divisive among farm-state lawmakers because it threatens the urban-rural coalition that has won passage of the farm bill every five years.

Trump has also been making personal pitches to agriculture leaders. He meets Friday with farm leaders in Fresno, California, to talk about water management in the Central Valley — one of the nation’s most productive agricultural regions.

And in February, shortly after Georgia poultry and cattle farmer Zippy Duvall was elected president of the American Farm Bureau Federation, the country’s largest and most powerful farm group, Trump got on the phone to congratulate him.

“It was a good conversation,” said spokesman Will Rogers, who said Trump asked Duvall for the group’s endorsement. The Farm Bureau does not endorse candidates, but Duvall encouraged Trump to talk about agriculture policy on the campaign trail.

“Trump said he agreed that farmers are in fact over-regulated and that he would fix that as soon as he became president,” Rogers said.

Leaders of the Farm Bureau said they were unaware the Trump campaign was engaging in direct conversations with farmers. House Agriculture Committee Chairman Mike Conaway, a Trump supporter who has offered the candidate help in crafting a platform, also had no idea such talks were happening.

"Right now, none of us have a clue what his agriculture policies might be,” Conaway told reporters two weeks ago.

‘Saving a poor Georgia farmer’

The effort to connect farmers with the Trump campaign dates to December, when Growing America, a Georgia-based farm news site that Etheridge runs, tracked down Betsy Sharp to talk about how Trump had saved her family’s farm.

In the video, Sharp tells how her late father, Lenard Hill committed suicide in 1986 in a tragic attempt to keep his farm from being seized. He mistakenly thought his life insurance would pay off the debt and allow his family to keep the land. But the policy prohibited a payout for suicide and the bank moved to foreclose on the property that had been in the family for generations.

“When Trump heard the story, he reached out to help save it,” Sharp said. Trump gave her mother, Annabel Hill, $20,000 to hold off the bank and then helped to raise more, according to news accounts at the time. In the end, Trump and a group of businessmen contributed $78,000 to clear the debt, the accounts said.

“We were very shocked and very appreciative of a man who was ... very famous and had lots of money would be interested in saving a poor Georgia farmer,” Sharp said in the video.

Brandon Phillips, director of the Trump campaign in Georgia, saw the video — which has been viewed almost 127,000 times — and reached out to Growing America with “an interest in developing a deeper relationship with farmers,” said Etheridge.

Etheridge, who said he has never worked for a campaign, was receptive, later founding Farmers for Trump and chairing the Georgia Farm Team for Trump — roles he’s assumed as a private citizen.

Ever since, Farmers for Trump, which has about 820 followers on Facebook, has been engaging regularly with the campaign.

“They made their senior policy advisers available to answer questions farmers had and they didn’t shy away from giving real answers,” said Etheridge. “He really grew his support among farmers when he explained farming wasn’t just about feeding the world, but ultimately, it was about national security.”

Etheridge declined to name the Trump advisers he has worked with. In the past, the campaign has pointed reporters to Sam Clovis, an Iowa Republican operative, for policy questions, but the campaign declined to respond to several recent inquiries about their agriculture advisers.

It has responded to farmers, however — with Farmers for Trump acting as the go-between, fielding questions from Facebook and email and then getting the campaign’s responses back to the farmers, usually within a few days.

Farmers ask mostly about immigration and the farm bill, Etheridge said, and the Trump campaign has given them responses on both.

“Visa programs will have to be reviewed and when we have confidence that the programs comport with all security requirements, we will make sure that people who want to enter this country legally can do so,” the Trump campaign said in a statement to Farmers for Trump. “This includes the H1 and H2 programs.” (The H2 visa program is heavily relied upon by farmers for a migrant workforce, but the program has been plagued with bureaucratic delays and red tape).

The campaign also laid out Trump’s stance on the farm bill, an issue the candidate has never addressed on the campaign trail.

“Like energy, America must be self-sufficient and must protect our nation's ability to feed itself and the rest of the world. Separating the Food Stamp Program from the farm bill will allow Congress to do its job and focus on agriculture as a national security issue.”

Last February, Farmers for Trump held its first rally in Sasser, Georgia, complete with barbecue, crop dusters flying overhead and several hundred farmers. Roughly 800 people showed up — a figure more than three times the town’s population. A folk band sang “Don’t be a chump, vote for Trump.”

Farmers reject stereotypes of Trump voters

The farmers POLITICO spoke to bristled at how Trump supporters have been characterized in the media as largely angry and uneducated.

Randy Hudson, who describes himself as a fifth-generation pecan grower and a third-generation Democrat, and who has a Ph.D. in entomology, began leaning Republican in 2012 and says he is now an enthusiastic Trump supporter.

Hudson, who leads the export promotion group, U.S. Pecans (his support for Trump is separate from the group), said he travels the world promoting pecans and is frustrated that other countries have invested so heavily in infrastructure while the U.S. lets its roads, airports and waterways crumble.

He also believes Trump will moderate his stance on immigration. “Is he going to deport 15 million people? No he’s not. He’s going to come back to the middle.”

And he is convinced that Trump will go to bat for exports, despite the candidate’s opposition to the recently negotiated Trans-Pacific Partnership trade deal that gets strong support from most farm groups.

“One of these days, I’ll have to answer to my grandfather,” Hudson said, noting both his father and grandfather served as Democratic lawmakers in the Georgia Legislature. “I can just see him standing at the pearly gates saying, ‘I see you have a big R on your forehead, you need to explain that!’”

Of course, the vast majority of farmers still don’t know where Trump stands on their issues, but that may not be an obstacle for the candidate. Policy, after all, doesn’t seem really central to Trump’s appeal, said Tim Marema, editor of the Daily Yonder, a rural-focused news site based in Knoxville, Tennessee, and Whitesburg, Kentucky, that tracks closely rural voting trends.

“Trump's approach to policy comes down to narrative sound bites,” he said. “Immigration: Build a wall. Women: Women love me. Foreign policy: Make America great again. Coal: Bring the jobs back ... If Trump remembers that he helped pay the mortgage of the farm widow, perhaps that will become his ag narrative: I care about farmers; I saved a farm widow once. In other words, there are no policies to examine, only stories.”

Smile it's Friday...