The POLITICO Wrongometer
Our policy reporters truth-squad the Republican debate.
By POLITICO Staff
UM, SEN. CRUZ, WHAT 'BLEND WALL'?
Ted Cruz has been playing defense in Iowa for months over his opposition to the federal ethanol mandate. Thursday night, he promised to “tear down the EPA’s blend wall” – a move that he said could get the corn byproduct’s market share “up by 60 percent.”
But here’s the problem with that argument: EPA does not enforce a blend wall. In fact, it’s the opponents of ethanol who say the nation's gasoline supply cannot accommodate more than 10 percent ethanol. The EPA has agreed that such a blend wall presents a problem for ethanol sales, but it has sought to push through it.
Most gasoline sold in the U.S. is made up of 10 percent ethanol, and EPA has approved E15 — gasoline with 15 percent ethanol — to be sold by gas stations for most cars on the road today. EPA has also sought to help retail stations pay for new equipment that would enable them to sell higher ethanol blends.
-- Darren Goode
RUBIO'S SELECTIVE CAP-AND-TRADE MEMORY
Sen. Marco Rubio is displaying a bit of selective memory by pushing back on the assertion that he flip-flopped in his opposition to cap and trade.
Back when he was speaker of the Florida state House, Rubio in March 2008 did indeed say the Sunshine State "should position itself, for what I believe is inevitable, and that is a federal cap and trade program." The state should be an early mover on the issue, Rubio said on the Florida Face to Face program, and he supported giving the state's environmental agency "a mandate that they go out and design a cap and trade or a carbon tax program and bring it back to the legislature for ratification sometime in the next two years."
Rubio’s remarks all those years ago came during a different moment in climate politics, a pre-Barack Obama period when many Republicans were supportive of putting a price on greenhouse gas emissions, including Sen. John McCain and Florida’s own governor (who still flew under the GOP banner) at the time, Charlie Crist. The Florida senator has long stated that he generally opposes cap-and-trade programs, however he decided not to use his power to kill such legislation during his time in the state legislature leadership. Instead, he opted to pass a bill that he later said would result in no action, which never took place.
-- Darren Goode
KASICH'S FLINT ANSWER OVERLOOKS HIS OWN BACKYARD
When asked in tonight’s debate about the water crisis in Flint, Mich., Ohio Gov. John Kasich said it was important for government officials to take quick action — but he didn’t mention his state is dealing with a similar problem in which his administration has faced accusations of acting too slowly.
“Well, you’ve got to be on top of it right away … the fact is that every single engine of government has to move when you see a crisis like that,” Kasich said when asked about the lead-contaminated drinking water in Flint.
He cited storms, as well as a water crisis in Toledo, as events that he had dealt with in Ohio. “You go the extra mile,” he added.
But the Ohio village of Sebring is dealing with its own lead contamination. Though it’s not as dangerous as the situation in Flint, it has prompted sharp criticism of Kasich’s appointee to the head the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency, Craig Butler — and a call by Democratic Rep. Tim Ryan for Butler to resign.
“The men, women, & children of Sebring deserve better. I call for the immediate resignation of the Ohio EPA Director Craig Butler,” Ryan said in a Twitter post on Wednesday. He cited a Columbus Dispatch story that said the state EPA knew in October that Sebring’s water had elevated lead levels, but it didn’t warn the public there until Jan. 21.
-- Matt Daily
MEMO TO RUBIO: U.S. NOT AS GENEROUS AS GERMANY
Marco Rubio said the U.S. is the most generous country on Earth when it comes to immigration, accepting 1 million people a year, far more than anyone else.
He’s right about the number. But as of 2013 (the most recent data available from the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development), Germany took in slightly more migrants.
-- Isaac Arnsdorf
CRUZ'S MILITARY STATS MISLEADING
Ted Cruz ticked through a litany of statistics to question American military readiness, saying that fewer planes and warships than during the 1991 Persian Gulf War meant the U.S. was "sending our fighting men and women into combat with their arms tied behind their backs."
The facts may hold up to scrutiny but they are nonetheless misleading. Military technology has advanced significantly in the last quarter century and combat aircraft and warships are much more precise and pack a more powerful punch. Meanwhile, the first Iraq War targeted the large conventional military of Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein, its bases and headquarters, as well as Republican Guard units in open formation in the country’s western desert. The Islamic State terrorist group that has seized large swaths of Iraq and Syria is operating largely in populated areas where the likelihood of civilian deaths is highly likely in massive air attacks – and does so expressly to avoid attacks on the scale of the Gulf War.
Cruz’ definition of “carpet bombing” has also been singled out as inaccurate in the past. He has said the air attacks he would order against the Islamic State would not be designed to attack an entire city “but the location of the troops," with "embedded special forces to direct the air power."
“Since the defining characteristic of carpet bombing is the dropping of bombs indiscriminately, Cruz’s definition is essentially the opposite of carpet bombing,” concluded the political fact-checking website Politifact. “We rate his claim False.”
-- Bryan Bender
CRUZ NOT ONLY GOP SENATOR TO MISS 'AUDIT THE FED' VOTE
Rand Paul said his Senate colleague, Ted Cruz, was the only Republican to skip a vote on an "Audit the Fed" bill earlier this month.
Actually, Cruz wasn't the only GOP lawmaker who failed to participate in the Jan. 12 vote on the measure that Paul wrote. Sen. Dan Coats (R-Ind.) didn't cast a vote on the bill, either. Democrats blocked the bill in a 53-44 vote. The bill needed 60 votes to advance.
Cruz responded to Paul's attack by saying the bill didn't have the votes to pass anyway and that he had commitments in New Hampshire.
"I look forward to signing that bill as president," Cruz said.
-- Zachary Warmbrodt
BUSH MUDDIES CLINTON'S RECORDS: THEY'RE ONLINE
Jeb Bush bragged about how many years of tax returns he's released, trying to draw a contrast with Hillary Clinton. Getting records out of her, he said, takes an FBI subpoena.
It’s a cute line, riffing on the ongoing investigation of her private e-mail service But it’s not correct. Clinton’s health and financial records are on her website for anyone to see.
-- Isaac Arnsdorf
WHAT'S TED CRUZ'S DEFINITION OF AN INSULT?
Ted Cruz says he’s committed to running a substantial campaign and will not personally attack other candidates, including Donald Trump. “I have not insulted Donald Trump personally,” he said at the debate Thursday night.
So what exactly were these comments then? “Apparently Mr. Trump considers Megyn Kelly very, very scary,” Cruz said earlier this week. “Donald is a fragile soul. She might ask a mean question and who knows what could happen? I mean, his hair could stand on end.”
Sure sounds like a personal attack.
A place were I can write...
My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.
January 29, 2016
Calls out Obama
Sen. Warren calls out Obama for not being tougher on corporations
By POLITICO Staff
Elizabeth Warren is scolding President Barack Obama for failing to aggressively enforce laws against big corporations and their executives, and is urging the presidential candidates to start talking about it more.
The Massachusetts senator, whose populist screeds against Wall Street excess have vaulted her into a folk hero, penned an op-ed in the New York Times that lays into Obama — albeit not by name — for focusing on new agency rules and executive actions while not rolling out an equally assertive enforcement agenda.
"The administration’s record on enforcement falls short — and federal enforcement of laws that already exist has received far too little attention on the campaign trail," said Warren, who flirted with a presidential run before deciding to stay on the sidelines this cycle. "In a single year, in case after case, across many sectors of the economy, federal agencies caught big companies breaking the law — defrauding taxpayers, covering up deadly safety problems, even precipitating the financial collapse in 2008 — and let them off the hook with barely a slap on the wrist. Often, companies paid meager fines, which some will try to write off as a tax deduction."
Warren did call out certain corporations by name, faulting the administration for delivering light punishments to Education Management Corp, a for-profit college; drug company Novartis; JPMorgan Chase; and Massey Energy, despite a range of misdeeds.
And while she did give certain agencies credit for a more aggressive posture (include the Environmental Protection Agency and her former employer, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau), Warren said other government organizations have fallen short, namely the Securities and Exchange Commission.
But Warren said, ultimately, the buck stops at the top. "Presidents don’t control most day-to-day enforcement decisions, but they do nominate the heads of all the agencies, and these choices make all the difference," said wrote.
By POLITICO Staff
Elizabeth Warren is scolding President Barack Obama for failing to aggressively enforce laws against big corporations and their executives, and is urging the presidential candidates to start talking about it more.
The Massachusetts senator, whose populist screeds against Wall Street excess have vaulted her into a folk hero, penned an op-ed in the New York Times that lays into Obama — albeit not by name — for focusing on new agency rules and executive actions while not rolling out an equally assertive enforcement agenda.
"The administration’s record on enforcement falls short — and federal enforcement of laws that already exist has received far too little attention on the campaign trail," said Warren, who flirted with a presidential run before deciding to stay on the sidelines this cycle. "In a single year, in case after case, across many sectors of the economy, federal agencies caught big companies breaking the law — defrauding taxpayers, covering up deadly safety problems, even precipitating the financial collapse in 2008 — and let them off the hook with barely a slap on the wrist. Often, companies paid meager fines, which some will try to write off as a tax deduction."
Warren did call out certain corporations by name, faulting the administration for delivering light punishments to Education Management Corp, a for-profit college; drug company Novartis; JPMorgan Chase; and Massey Energy, despite a range of misdeeds.
And while she did give certain agencies credit for a more aggressive posture (include the Environmental Protection Agency and her former employer, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau), Warren said other government organizations have fallen short, namely the Securities and Exchange Commission.
But Warren said, ultimately, the buck stops at the top. "Presidents don’t control most day-to-day enforcement decisions, but they do nominate the heads of all the agencies, and these choices make all the difference," said wrote.
Trump Is Shocking
Donald Trump Is Shocking, Vulgar and Right
And, my dear fellow Republicans, he's all your fault.
By Tucker Carlson
bout 15 years ago, I said something nasty on CNN about Donald Trump’s hair. I can’t now remember the context, assuming there was one. In any case, Trump saw it and left a message the next day.
“It’s true you have better hair than I do,” Trump said matter-of-factly. “But I get more pussy than you do.” Click.
At the time, I’d never met Trump and I remember feeling amused but also surprised he’d say something like that. Now the pattern seems entirely familiar. The message had all the hallmarks of a Trump attack: shocking, vulgar and indisputably true.
Not everyone finds it funny. On my street in Northwest Washington, D.C., there’s never been anyone as unpopular as Trump. The Democrats assume he’s a bigot, pandering to the morons out there in the great dark space between Georgetown and Brentwood. The Republicans (those relatively few who live here) fully agree with that assessment, and they hate him even more. They sense Trump is a threat to them personally, to their legitimacy and their livelihoods. Idi Amin would get a warmer reception in our dog park.
I understand it of course. And, except in those moments when the self-righteous silliness of rich people overwhelms me and I feel like moving to Maine, I can see their points, some of them anyway. Trump might not be my first choice for president. I’m not even convinced he really wants the job. He’s smart enough to know it would be tough for him to govern.
But just because Trump is an imperfect candidate doesn’t mean his candidacy can’t be instructive. Trump could teach Republicans in Washington a lot if only they stopped posturing long enough to watch carefully. Here’s some of what they might learn:
He Exists Because You Failed
American presidential elections usually amount to a series of overcorrections: Clinton begat Bush, who produced Obama, whose lax border policies fueled the rise of Trump. In the case of Trump, though, the GOP shares the blame, and not just because his fellow Republicans misdirected their ad buys or waited so long to criticize him. Trump is in part a reaction to the intellectual corruption of the Republican Party. That ought to be obvious to his critics, yet somehow it isn’t.
Consider the conservative nonprofit establishment, which seems to employ most right-of-center adults in Washington. Over the past 40 years, how much donated money have all those think tanks and foundations consumed? Billions, certainly. (Someone better at math and less prone to melancholy should probably figure out the precise number.) Has America become more conservative over that same period? Come on. Most of that cash went to self-perpetuation: Salaries, bonuses, retirement funds, medical, dental, lunches, car services, leases on high-end office space, retreats in Mexico, more fundraising. Unless you were the direct beneficiary of any of that, you’d have to consider it wasted.
Pretty embarrassing. And yet they’re not embarrassed. Many of those same overpaid, underperforming tax-exempt sinecure-holders are now demanding that Trump be stopped. Why? Because, as his critics have noted in a rising chorus of hysteria, Trump represents “an existential threat to conservatism.”
Let that sink in. Conservative voters are being scolded for supporting a candidate they consider conservative because it would be bad for conservatism? And by the way, the people doing the scolding? They’re the ones who’ve been advocating for open borders, and nation-building in countries whose populations hate us, and trade deals that eliminated jobs while enriching their donors, all while implicitly mocking the base for its worries about abortion and gay marriage and the pace of demographic change. Now they’re telling their voters to shut up and obey, and if they don’t, they’re liberal.
It turns out the GOP wasn’t simply out of touch with its voters; the party had no idea who its voters were or what they believed. For decades, party leaders and intellectuals imagined that most Republicans were broadly libertarian on economics and basically neoconservative on foreign policy. That may sound absurd now, after Trump has attacked nearly the entire Republican catechism (he savaged the Iraq War and hedge fund managers in the same debate) and been greatly rewarded for it, but that was the assumption the GOP brain trust operated under. They had no way of knowing otherwise. The only Republicans they talked to read the Wall Street Journal too.
On immigration policy, party elders were caught completely by surprise. Even canny operators like Ted Cruz didn’t appreciate the depth of voter anger on the subject. And why would they? If you live in an affluent ZIP code, it’s hard to see a downside to mass low-wage immigration. Your kids don’t go to public school. You don’t take the bus or use the emergency room for health care. No immigrant is competing for your job. (The day Hondurans start getting hired as green energy lobbyists is the day my neighbors become nativists.) Plus, you get cheap servants, and get to feel welcoming and virtuous while paying them less per hour than your kids make at a summer job on Nantucket. It’s all good.
Apart from his line about Mexican rapists early in the campaign, Trump hasn’t said anything especially shocking about immigration. Control the border, deport lawbreakers, try not to admit violent criminals — these are the ravings of a Nazi? This is the “ghost of George Wallace” that a Politico piece described last August? A lot of Republican leaders think so. No wonder their voters are rebelling.
Truth Is Not Only A Defense, It’s Thrilling
When was the last time you stopped yourself from saying something you believed to be true for fear of being punished or criticized for saying it? If you live in America, it probably hasn’t been long. That’s not just a talking point about political correctness. It’s the central problem with our national conversation, the main reason our debates are so stilted and useless. You can’t fix a problem if you don’t have the words to describe it. You can’t even think about it clearly.
This depressing fact made Trump’s political career. In a country where almost everyone in public life lies reflexively, it’s thrilling to hear someone say what he really thinks, even if you believe he’s wrong. It’s especially exciting when you suspect he’s right.
A temporary ban on Muslim immigration? That sounds a little extreme (meaning nobody else has said it recently in public). But is it? Millions of Muslims have moved to Western Europe over the past 50 years, and a sizable number of them still haven’t assimilated. Instead, they remain hostile and sometimes dangerous to the cultures that welcomed them. By any measure, that experiment has failed. What’s our strategy for not repeating it here, especially after San Bernardino—attacks that seemed to come out of nowhere? Invoke American exceptionalism and hope for the best? Before Trump, that was the plan.
Republican primary voters should be forgiven for wondering who exactly is on the reckless side of this debate. At the very least, Trump seems like he wants to protect the country.
Evangelicals understand this better than most. You read surveys that indicate the majority of Christian conservatives support Trump, and then you see the video: Trump on stage with pastors, looking pained as they pray over him, misidentifying key books in the New Testament, and in general doing a ludicrous imitation of a faithful Christian, the least holy roller ever. You wonder as you watch this: How could they be that dumb? He’s so obviously faking it.
They know that already. I doubt there are many Christian voters who think Trump could recite the Nicene Creed, or even identify it. Evangelicals have given up trying to elect one of their own. What they’re looking for is a bodyguard, someone to shield them from mounting (and real) threats to their freedom of speech and worship. Trump fits that role nicely, better in fact than many church-going Republicans. For eight years, there was a born-again in the White House. How’d that work out for Christians, here and in Iraq?
Washington Really Is Corrupt
Everyone beats up on Washington, but most of the people I know who live here love it. Of course they do. It’s beautiful, the people are friendly, we’ve got good restaurants, not to mention full employment and construction cranes on virtually every corner. If you work on Capitol Hill or downtown, it’s hard to walk back from lunch without seeing someone you know. It’s a warm bath. Nobody wants to leave.
But let’s pretend for a second this isn’t Washington. Let’s imagine it’s the capital of an African country, say Burkina Faso, and we are doing a study on corruption. Probably the first question we’d ask: How many government officials have close relatives who make a living by influencing government spending? A huge percentage of them? OK. Case closed. Ouagadougou is obviously a very corrupt city.
That’s how the rest of the country views D.C. Washington is probably the richest city in America because the people who live there have the closest proximity to power. That seems obvious to most voters. It’s less obvious to us, because everyone here is so cheerful and familiar, and we’re too close to it. Chairman so-and-so’s son-in-law lobbies the committee? That doesn’t seem corrupt. He’s such a good guy.
All of which explains why almost nobody in Washington caught the significance of Trump’s finest moment in the first debate. One of the moderators asked, in effect: if you’re so opposed to Hillary Clinton, why did she come to your last wedding? It seemed like a revealing, even devastating question.
Trump’s response, delivered without pause or embarrassment: Because I paid her to be there. As if she was the wedding singer, or in charge of the catering.
Even then, I’ll confess, I didn’t get it. (Why would you pay someone to come to your wedding?) But the audience did. Trump is the ideal candidate to fight Washington corruption not simply because he opposes it, but because he has personally participated in it. He’s not just a reformer; like most effective populists, he’s a whistleblower, a traitor to his class. Before he became the most ferocious enemy American business had ever known, Teddy Roosevelt was a rich guy. His privilege wasn't incidental; it was key to his appeal. Anyone can peer through the window in envy. It takes a real man to throw furniture through it from the inside.
If Trump is leading a populist movement, many of his Republican critics have joined an elitist one. Deriding Trump is an act of class solidarity, visible evidence of refinement and proof that you live nowhere near a Wal-Mart. Early last summer, in a piece that greeted Trump when he entered the race, National Review described the candidate as “a ridiculous buffoon with the worst taste since Caligula.” Virtually every other critique of Trump from the right has voiced similar aesthetic concerns.
Why is the Party of Ideas suddenly so fixated on fashion and hair? Maybe all dying institutions devolve this way, from an insistence on intellectual rigor to a flabby preoccupation with appearances. It happened in the Episcopal Church, once renowned for its liturgy, now a stop on architectural and garden tours. Only tourists go there anymore.
He Could Win
Of all the dumb things that have been said about Trump by people who were too slow to get finance jobs and therefore wound up in journalism, perhaps the stupidest of all is the one you hear most: He’ll get killed in the general! This is a godsend for Democrats! Forty-state wipeout! And so it goes mindlessly on.
Actually — and this is no endorsement of Trump, just an interjection of reality — that’s a crock. Of the Republicans now running, Trump likely has the best chance to beat Hillary Clinton, for two reasons:
First, he’s the only Republican who can meaningfully expand the pie. Polls show a surprisingly large number of Democrats open to Trump. In one January survey by the polling form Mercury Analytics , almost 20 percent said they’d consider crossing over to him from Hillary. Even if that’s double the actual number, it’s still stunning. Could Ted Cruz expect to draw that many Democrats? Could Jeb?
It’s an article of faith in Washington that Trump would tank the party’s prospects with minority voters. Sounds logical, especially if you’re a sensitive white liberal who considers the suggestion of a border wall a form of hate speech, but consider the baseline. In the last election, Romney got 6 percent of the black vote, and 27 percent of Hispanics. Trump, who’s energetic, witty and successful, will do worse? I wouldn’t bet on it.
But the main reason Trump could win is because he’s the only candidate hard enough to call Hillary’s bluff. Republicans will say almost anything about Hillary, but almost none challenge her basic competence. She may be evil, but she’s tough and accomplished. This we know, all of us.
But do we? Or is this understanding of Hillary just another piety we repeat out of unthinking habit, the political equivalent of, “you can be whatever you want to be,” or “breakfast is the most important meal of the day”? Trump doesn’t think Hillary is impressive and strong. He sees her as brittle and afraid.
He may be right, based on his exchange with her just before Christmas. During a speech in Grand Rapids, Michigan, Trump said Hillary had been “schlonged” by Obama in the 2008 race. In response, the Clinton campaign called Trump a sexist. It’s a charge Hillary has leveled against virtually every opponent she’s faced, but Trump responded differently. Instead of scrambling to donate to breast cancer research, he pointed out that Hillary spent years attacking the alleged victims of her husband’s sexual assaults. That ended the conversation almost immediately.
It was the most effective possible response, though more obvious than brilliant. Why was Trump the only Republican to use it?
Republican primary voters may be wondering the same thing. Or maybe they already know. They seem to know a lot about Trump, more than the people who run their party. They know that he isn’t a conventional ideological conservative. They seem relieved. They can see that he’s emotionally incontinent. They find it exciting.
Washington Republicans look on at this in horror, their suspicions confirmed. Beneath the thin topsoil of rural conservatism, they see the seeds of proto-fascism beginning to sprout. But that’s not quite right. Republicans in the states aren’t dangerous. They’ve just evaluated the alternatives and decided those are worse.
And, my dear fellow Republicans, he's all your fault.
By Tucker Carlson
bout 15 years ago, I said something nasty on CNN about Donald Trump’s hair. I can’t now remember the context, assuming there was one. In any case, Trump saw it and left a message the next day.
“It’s true you have better hair than I do,” Trump said matter-of-factly. “But I get more pussy than you do.” Click.
At the time, I’d never met Trump and I remember feeling amused but also surprised he’d say something like that. Now the pattern seems entirely familiar. The message had all the hallmarks of a Trump attack: shocking, vulgar and indisputably true.
Not everyone finds it funny. On my street in Northwest Washington, D.C., there’s never been anyone as unpopular as Trump. The Democrats assume he’s a bigot, pandering to the morons out there in the great dark space between Georgetown and Brentwood. The Republicans (those relatively few who live here) fully agree with that assessment, and they hate him even more. They sense Trump is a threat to them personally, to their legitimacy and their livelihoods. Idi Amin would get a warmer reception in our dog park.
I understand it of course. And, except in those moments when the self-righteous silliness of rich people overwhelms me and I feel like moving to Maine, I can see their points, some of them anyway. Trump might not be my first choice for president. I’m not even convinced he really wants the job. He’s smart enough to know it would be tough for him to govern.
But just because Trump is an imperfect candidate doesn’t mean his candidacy can’t be instructive. Trump could teach Republicans in Washington a lot if only they stopped posturing long enough to watch carefully. Here’s some of what they might learn:
He Exists Because You Failed
American presidential elections usually amount to a series of overcorrections: Clinton begat Bush, who produced Obama, whose lax border policies fueled the rise of Trump. In the case of Trump, though, the GOP shares the blame, and not just because his fellow Republicans misdirected their ad buys or waited so long to criticize him. Trump is in part a reaction to the intellectual corruption of the Republican Party. That ought to be obvious to his critics, yet somehow it isn’t.
Consider the conservative nonprofit establishment, which seems to employ most right-of-center adults in Washington. Over the past 40 years, how much donated money have all those think tanks and foundations consumed? Billions, certainly. (Someone better at math and less prone to melancholy should probably figure out the precise number.) Has America become more conservative over that same period? Come on. Most of that cash went to self-perpetuation: Salaries, bonuses, retirement funds, medical, dental, lunches, car services, leases on high-end office space, retreats in Mexico, more fundraising. Unless you were the direct beneficiary of any of that, you’d have to consider it wasted.
Pretty embarrassing. And yet they’re not embarrassed. Many of those same overpaid, underperforming tax-exempt sinecure-holders are now demanding that Trump be stopped. Why? Because, as his critics have noted in a rising chorus of hysteria, Trump represents “an existential threat to conservatism.”
Let that sink in. Conservative voters are being scolded for supporting a candidate they consider conservative because it would be bad for conservatism? And by the way, the people doing the scolding? They’re the ones who’ve been advocating for open borders, and nation-building in countries whose populations hate us, and trade deals that eliminated jobs while enriching their donors, all while implicitly mocking the base for its worries about abortion and gay marriage and the pace of demographic change. Now they’re telling their voters to shut up and obey, and if they don’t, they’re liberal.
It turns out the GOP wasn’t simply out of touch with its voters; the party had no idea who its voters were or what they believed. For decades, party leaders and intellectuals imagined that most Republicans were broadly libertarian on economics and basically neoconservative on foreign policy. That may sound absurd now, after Trump has attacked nearly the entire Republican catechism (he savaged the Iraq War and hedge fund managers in the same debate) and been greatly rewarded for it, but that was the assumption the GOP brain trust operated under. They had no way of knowing otherwise. The only Republicans they talked to read the Wall Street Journal too.
On immigration policy, party elders were caught completely by surprise. Even canny operators like Ted Cruz didn’t appreciate the depth of voter anger on the subject. And why would they? If you live in an affluent ZIP code, it’s hard to see a downside to mass low-wage immigration. Your kids don’t go to public school. You don’t take the bus or use the emergency room for health care. No immigrant is competing for your job. (The day Hondurans start getting hired as green energy lobbyists is the day my neighbors become nativists.) Plus, you get cheap servants, and get to feel welcoming and virtuous while paying them less per hour than your kids make at a summer job on Nantucket. It’s all good.
Apart from his line about Mexican rapists early in the campaign, Trump hasn’t said anything especially shocking about immigration. Control the border, deport lawbreakers, try not to admit violent criminals — these are the ravings of a Nazi? This is the “ghost of George Wallace” that a Politico piece described last August? A lot of Republican leaders think so. No wonder their voters are rebelling.
Truth Is Not Only A Defense, It’s Thrilling
When was the last time you stopped yourself from saying something you believed to be true for fear of being punished or criticized for saying it? If you live in America, it probably hasn’t been long. That’s not just a talking point about political correctness. It’s the central problem with our national conversation, the main reason our debates are so stilted and useless. You can’t fix a problem if you don’t have the words to describe it. You can’t even think about it clearly.
This depressing fact made Trump’s political career. In a country where almost everyone in public life lies reflexively, it’s thrilling to hear someone say what he really thinks, even if you believe he’s wrong. It’s especially exciting when you suspect he’s right.
A temporary ban on Muslim immigration? That sounds a little extreme (meaning nobody else has said it recently in public). But is it? Millions of Muslims have moved to Western Europe over the past 50 years, and a sizable number of them still haven’t assimilated. Instead, they remain hostile and sometimes dangerous to the cultures that welcomed them. By any measure, that experiment has failed. What’s our strategy for not repeating it here, especially after San Bernardino—attacks that seemed to come out of nowhere? Invoke American exceptionalism and hope for the best? Before Trump, that was the plan.
Republican primary voters should be forgiven for wondering who exactly is on the reckless side of this debate. At the very least, Trump seems like he wants to protect the country.
Evangelicals understand this better than most. You read surveys that indicate the majority of Christian conservatives support Trump, and then you see the video: Trump on stage with pastors, looking pained as they pray over him, misidentifying key books in the New Testament, and in general doing a ludicrous imitation of a faithful Christian, the least holy roller ever. You wonder as you watch this: How could they be that dumb? He’s so obviously faking it.
They know that already. I doubt there are many Christian voters who think Trump could recite the Nicene Creed, or even identify it. Evangelicals have given up trying to elect one of their own. What they’re looking for is a bodyguard, someone to shield them from mounting (and real) threats to their freedom of speech and worship. Trump fits that role nicely, better in fact than many church-going Republicans. For eight years, there was a born-again in the White House. How’d that work out for Christians, here and in Iraq?
Washington Really Is Corrupt
Everyone beats up on Washington, but most of the people I know who live here love it. Of course they do. It’s beautiful, the people are friendly, we’ve got good restaurants, not to mention full employment and construction cranes on virtually every corner. If you work on Capitol Hill or downtown, it’s hard to walk back from lunch without seeing someone you know. It’s a warm bath. Nobody wants to leave.
But let’s pretend for a second this isn’t Washington. Let’s imagine it’s the capital of an African country, say Burkina Faso, and we are doing a study on corruption. Probably the first question we’d ask: How many government officials have close relatives who make a living by influencing government spending? A huge percentage of them? OK. Case closed. Ouagadougou is obviously a very corrupt city.
That’s how the rest of the country views D.C. Washington is probably the richest city in America because the people who live there have the closest proximity to power. That seems obvious to most voters. It’s less obvious to us, because everyone here is so cheerful and familiar, and we’re too close to it. Chairman so-and-so’s son-in-law lobbies the committee? That doesn’t seem corrupt. He’s such a good guy.
All of which explains why almost nobody in Washington caught the significance of Trump’s finest moment in the first debate. One of the moderators asked, in effect: if you’re so opposed to Hillary Clinton, why did she come to your last wedding? It seemed like a revealing, even devastating question.
Trump’s response, delivered without pause or embarrassment: Because I paid her to be there. As if she was the wedding singer, or in charge of the catering.
Even then, I’ll confess, I didn’t get it. (Why would you pay someone to come to your wedding?) But the audience did. Trump is the ideal candidate to fight Washington corruption not simply because he opposes it, but because he has personally participated in it. He’s not just a reformer; like most effective populists, he’s a whistleblower, a traitor to his class. Before he became the most ferocious enemy American business had ever known, Teddy Roosevelt was a rich guy. His privilege wasn't incidental; it was key to his appeal. Anyone can peer through the window in envy. It takes a real man to throw furniture through it from the inside.
If Trump is leading a populist movement, many of his Republican critics have joined an elitist one. Deriding Trump is an act of class solidarity, visible evidence of refinement and proof that you live nowhere near a Wal-Mart. Early last summer, in a piece that greeted Trump when he entered the race, National Review described the candidate as “a ridiculous buffoon with the worst taste since Caligula.” Virtually every other critique of Trump from the right has voiced similar aesthetic concerns.
Why is the Party of Ideas suddenly so fixated on fashion and hair? Maybe all dying institutions devolve this way, from an insistence on intellectual rigor to a flabby preoccupation with appearances. It happened in the Episcopal Church, once renowned for its liturgy, now a stop on architectural and garden tours. Only tourists go there anymore.
He Could Win
Of all the dumb things that have been said about Trump by people who were too slow to get finance jobs and therefore wound up in journalism, perhaps the stupidest of all is the one you hear most: He’ll get killed in the general! This is a godsend for Democrats! Forty-state wipeout! And so it goes mindlessly on.
Actually — and this is no endorsement of Trump, just an interjection of reality — that’s a crock. Of the Republicans now running, Trump likely has the best chance to beat Hillary Clinton, for two reasons:
First, he’s the only Republican who can meaningfully expand the pie. Polls show a surprisingly large number of Democrats open to Trump. In one January survey by the polling form Mercury Analytics , almost 20 percent said they’d consider crossing over to him from Hillary. Even if that’s double the actual number, it’s still stunning. Could Ted Cruz expect to draw that many Democrats? Could Jeb?
It’s an article of faith in Washington that Trump would tank the party’s prospects with minority voters. Sounds logical, especially if you’re a sensitive white liberal who considers the suggestion of a border wall a form of hate speech, but consider the baseline. In the last election, Romney got 6 percent of the black vote, and 27 percent of Hispanics. Trump, who’s energetic, witty and successful, will do worse? I wouldn’t bet on it.
But the main reason Trump could win is because he’s the only candidate hard enough to call Hillary’s bluff. Republicans will say almost anything about Hillary, but almost none challenge her basic competence. She may be evil, but she’s tough and accomplished. This we know, all of us.
But do we? Or is this understanding of Hillary just another piety we repeat out of unthinking habit, the political equivalent of, “you can be whatever you want to be,” or “breakfast is the most important meal of the day”? Trump doesn’t think Hillary is impressive and strong. He sees her as brittle and afraid.
He may be right, based on his exchange with her just before Christmas. During a speech in Grand Rapids, Michigan, Trump said Hillary had been “schlonged” by Obama in the 2008 race. In response, the Clinton campaign called Trump a sexist. It’s a charge Hillary has leveled against virtually every opponent she’s faced, but Trump responded differently. Instead of scrambling to donate to breast cancer research, he pointed out that Hillary spent years attacking the alleged victims of her husband’s sexual assaults. That ended the conversation almost immediately.
It was the most effective possible response, though more obvious than brilliant. Why was Trump the only Republican to use it?
Republican primary voters may be wondering the same thing. Or maybe they already know. They seem to know a lot about Trump, more than the people who run their party. They know that he isn’t a conventional ideological conservative. They seem relieved. They can see that he’s emotionally incontinent. They find it exciting.
Washington Republicans look on at this in horror, their suspicions confirmed. Beneath the thin topsoil of rural conservatism, they see the seeds of proto-fascism beginning to sprout. But that’s not quite right. Republicans in the states aren’t dangerous. They’ve just evaluated the alternatives and decided those are worse.
Life is tough, for some..
Paul Ryan huddles with Mitt Romney, Scott Walker at Palm Beach retreat
By Alex Isenstadt
Paul Ryan is hosting a fundraising retreat in Palm Beach, Florida this week that is drawing a number of major donors — in addition to the House speaker’s 2012 running mate.
Mitt Romney was among those who addressed the confab on Thursday, according to two sources present. Also speaking were two former 2016 GOP contenders, Scott Walker and Lindsey Graham. The group gathered at the posh Eau Palm Beach Resort & Spa.
Unlike his predecessor John Boehner, Ryan is not known for his prodigious fundraising skills. But he is taking steps to expand his network. The new House speaker recently tapped Spencer Zwick, a longtime Romney confidant, to help oversee his fundraising operation.
By Alex Isenstadt
Paul Ryan is hosting a fundraising retreat in Palm Beach, Florida this week that is drawing a number of major donors — in addition to the House speaker’s 2012 running mate.
Mitt Romney was among those who addressed the confab on Thursday, according to two sources present. Also speaking were two former 2016 GOP contenders, Scott Walker and Lindsey Graham. The group gathered at the posh Eau Palm Beach Resort & Spa.
Unlike his predecessor John Boehner, Ryan is not known for his prodigious fundraising skills. But he is taking steps to expand his network. The new House speaker recently tapped Spencer Zwick, a longtime Romney confidant, to help oversee his fundraising operation.
Rough night
GOP insiders: It was a rough night for Ted Cruz
A majority thought Donald Trump's decision to boycott the debate was a bad idea.
By Steven Shepard
In the final debate before Iowa's first-in-the-nation caucuses, Ted Cruz had the worst night of the seven GOP presidential candidates on stage Thursday .
That’s according to a plurality of the Republican members of The POLITICO Caucus – a panel of strategists, operatives and activists in Iowa and the other three February-voting states: New Hampshire, South Carolina and Nevada. The insiders participated in the survey immediately following the debate in Des Moines, an event more notable for the absence of Iowa and national poll-leader Donald Trump than anything else.
More than 4-in-10 GOP insiders – given the choice of the seven GOP candidates on the stage, plus Trump – rated Cruz as the loser of Thursday night’s debate, citing his defensive posture on his past immigration stances and opposition to ethanol subsidies.
“He seemed plastic and insincere,” said one Iowa Republican, who, like all respondents, completed the post-debate survey anonymously. “The crowd clearly liked Gov. [Terry] Branstad a lot more than they like Ted Cruz.”
“His entanglement with the moderators was one of the worst moments for a candidate in any of the debates,” added a New Hampshire Republican, alluding to the Texas senator’s sparring with Fox News Channel’s Chris Wallace. “His opposition to ethanol was also highlighted on the eve of the Iowa caucuses.”
“He did not explain his switch on immigration policy very well,” another New Hampshire Republican said, citing Cruz’s attempts to address questions about his legislative maneuvering in the Senate during the 2013 immigration debate.
As for the winner of Thursday night’s debate, Marco Rubio (36 percent) and former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush (29 percent) were the top two finishers, according to the insiders.
One Iowa Republican called Rubio the “strongest and most articulate” candidate participating in the debate. A New Hampshire Republican agreed, saying the Florida senator was “the most articulate of the candidates on a variety of issues and is the most aspirational of the Republicans on stage."
As for Bush, a number of insiders called the debate his strongest performance to date – and noted that it coincided with the absence of Trump, who has antagonized Bush more than his other competitors for the Republican nomination.
“Given his previous performances, few would believe that Jeb Bush would [come] out of one of these debates as the winner,” one New Hampshire Republican said. “Yet he stood and delivered in a strong way. It may not help him in Iowa, but it comes at an opportune time for him as he sees a surge in New Hampshire.”
Another New Hampshire Republican said Bush “seemed at ease” without Trump’s presence. And a Nevada Republican lamented: “Oh, what might have been with no Trump.”
Cruz ranked third on the winners list – but even some of those who picked him inserted a caveat.
“He did not lose [and] that is a win,” a Nevada Republican said, “but the ethanol question may have hurt him.”
Cruz stood center-stage because Trump, who leads the polls nationally and in Iowa, declined to participate over what he said was poor treatment by Fox News and Megyn Kelly, one of the channel’s personalities and a moderator Thursday night.
Caucus insiders were asked whether Trump’s decision to bag the final debate before the Iowa caucuses was smart, and GOP insiders – who at various turns during the campaign mistakenly predicted Trump’s demise – again said the brash real-estate magnate had miscalculated.
Republicans – nearly three-quarters of whom said Trump's decision to ditch the debate wasn’t smart – replied to the survey with a number of invectives, calling Trump a “petulant child,” “narcissistic,” “petty,” “whiny, pouty and childish.”
“His fight might be [with] Fox,” said one Iowa Republican, “but he took it out on the people of Iowa.”
“When Donald Trump fails to meet expectations and loses Iowa on Monday, his decision to skip the debate will immediately be the scapegoat,” a South Carolina Republican predicted. “Like Rick Perry's ‘Oops’ moment in [2011], skipping the debate will be viewed in history as the singular event leading to the implosion of the Trump campaign.”
Just over a quarter of Republicans disagreed, arguing that Trump's move made sense because is effectively running out the clock.
“The gamble paid off,” said a South Carolina Republican. “Trump had the most to lose and didn't lose a thing. And he didn't get those Megyn Kelly video montages fired into his backside. He'd have never been able to respond as effectively as Rubio and Cruz did. Sitting out helped him sit on his lead.”
“Trump got exactly what he wanted,” an Iowa Republican added. “Nobody lays a glove on him, while the rest of the field beat each other up. Better yet, Trump got both former caucus winners to attend his event, and his main competitor, Ted Cruz, might have had his worst debate performance of the campaign.”
A majority thought Donald Trump's decision to boycott the debate was a bad idea.
By Steven Shepard
In the final debate before Iowa's first-in-the-nation caucuses, Ted Cruz had the worst night of the seven GOP presidential candidates on stage Thursday .
That’s according to a plurality of the Republican members of The POLITICO Caucus – a panel of strategists, operatives and activists in Iowa and the other three February-voting states: New Hampshire, South Carolina and Nevada. The insiders participated in the survey immediately following the debate in Des Moines, an event more notable for the absence of Iowa and national poll-leader Donald Trump than anything else.
More than 4-in-10 GOP insiders – given the choice of the seven GOP candidates on the stage, plus Trump – rated Cruz as the loser of Thursday night’s debate, citing his defensive posture on his past immigration stances and opposition to ethanol subsidies.
“He seemed plastic and insincere,” said one Iowa Republican, who, like all respondents, completed the post-debate survey anonymously. “The crowd clearly liked Gov. [Terry] Branstad a lot more than they like Ted Cruz.”
“His entanglement with the moderators was one of the worst moments for a candidate in any of the debates,” added a New Hampshire Republican, alluding to the Texas senator’s sparring with Fox News Channel’s Chris Wallace. “His opposition to ethanol was also highlighted on the eve of the Iowa caucuses.”
“He did not explain his switch on immigration policy very well,” another New Hampshire Republican said, citing Cruz’s attempts to address questions about his legislative maneuvering in the Senate during the 2013 immigration debate.
As for the winner of Thursday night’s debate, Marco Rubio (36 percent) and former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush (29 percent) were the top two finishers, according to the insiders.
One Iowa Republican called Rubio the “strongest and most articulate” candidate participating in the debate. A New Hampshire Republican agreed, saying the Florida senator was “the most articulate of the candidates on a variety of issues and is the most aspirational of the Republicans on stage."
As for Bush, a number of insiders called the debate his strongest performance to date – and noted that it coincided with the absence of Trump, who has antagonized Bush more than his other competitors for the Republican nomination.
“Given his previous performances, few would believe that Jeb Bush would [come] out of one of these debates as the winner,” one New Hampshire Republican said. “Yet he stood and delivered in a strong way. It may not help him in Iowa, but it comes at an opportune time for him as he sees a surge in New Hampshire.”
Another New Hampshire Republican said Bush “seemed at ease” without Trump’s presence. And a Nevada Republican lamented: “Oh, what might have been with no Trump.”
Cruz ranked third on the winners list – but even some of those who picked him inserted a caveat.
“He did not lose [and] that is a win,” a Nevada Republican said, “but the ethanol question may have hurt him.”
Cruz stood center-stage because Trump, who leads the polls nationally and in Iowa, declined to participate over what he said was poor treatment by Fox News and Megyn Kelly, one of the channel’s personalities and a moderator Thursday night.
Caucus insiders were asked whether Trump’s decision to bag the final debate before the Iowa caucuses was smart, and GOP insiders – who at various turns during the campaign mistakenly predicted Trump’s demise – again said the brash real-estate magnate had miscalculated.
Republicans – nearly three-quarters of whom said Trump's decision to ditch the debate wasn’t smart – replied to the survey with a number of invectives, calling Trump a “petulant child,” “narcissistic,” “petty,” “whiny, pouty and childish.”
“His fight might be [with] Fox,” said one Iowa Republican, “but he took it out on the people of Iowa.”
“When Donald Trump fails to meet expectations and loses Iowa on Monday, his decision to skip the debate will immediately be the scapegoat,” a South Carolina Republican predicted. “Like Rick Perry's ‘Oops’ moment in [2011], skipping the debate will be viewed in history as the singular event leading to the implosion of the Trump campaign.”
Just over a quarter of Republicans disagreed, arguing that Trump's move made sense because is effectively running out the clock.
“The gamble paid off,” said a South Carolina Republican. “Trump had the most to lose and didn't lose a thing. And he didn't get those Megyn Kelly video montages fired into his backside. He'd have never been able to respond as effectively as Rubio and Cruz did. Sitting out helped him sit on his lead.”
“Trump got exactly what he wanted,” an Iowa Republican added. “Nobody lays a glove on him, while the rest of the field beat each other up. Better yet, Trump got both former caucus winners to attend his event, and his main competitor, Ted Cruz, might have had his worst debate performance of the campaign.”
GOP debate
Five takeaways from the GOP debate
Cruz mocks Trump, Rubio speeds through, and Bush lightens up a little.
By Glenn Thrush
A Republican debate without Donald Trump is like a fern bar without a bouncer.
Without enforcer Trump around to make everybody stutter and flinch, all those nice guys in carefully pressed dress shirts were free to mouth off and pick fights with one another. While the punches drew less blood, the debate had an air of freedom with the oft-bullied likes of Rand Paul and Jeb Bush liberated from the oppressive presence of the party’s frontrunner.
The ratings for these GOP Trump-fests have been steadily slipping, so it will interesting to see if Trump’s absence decreased or enhanced viewership – and whether or not the unobstructed view of the other candidates solidified or undermined his position. With that in mind, here are five takeaways.
Cruz: Why is everybody always picking on me? Trump claimed that FOX was rude and biased against him (absolutely nobody apart from the Donald faithful bought that), so, yeah, chuck the debate. But he had plenty of tactical reasons to ditch the madding crowd. First, if the debate ratings dip (as they would likely have done even if he was onstage) he gets to chalk it up to his absence. But the real reason he skipped out was to create a circular GOP firing squad – with Ted Cruz at the center. And it worked.
The other candidates, no dummies, knew what Trump was up to – but they had plenty of incentive to cut the Texas Tea Party hero down to size, and they whacked Cruz early and often, especially on immigration and his annoying habit (to them) of demeaning the conservative credentials of any Republican who opposed him. Rand Paul was particularly cutting, pointing out Cruz’s support for a comprehensive immigration reform “compromise” – before hardening his position to oppose anything that smacked of amnesty. “What is particularly insulting, though, is that he is the king of saying, ‘you're for amnesty,’” Paul said. “Everybody's for amnesty except for Ted Cruz. But it's a falseness, and that's an authenticity problem.”
Cruz responded to the attacks, at times, by whining. And unlike Trump, he let the FOX moderating team – including Chris Wallace -- best him in several testy exchanges. “Chris, I would note that the last four questions have been, Rand, please attack Ted. Marco, please attack Ted. Chris, please attack Ted. Jeb, please attack Ted,” he complained to Wallace – who shock back with, “It is a debate, sir.”
Then, Cruz, unconvincingly threatened to pull a Trump. “Gosh, if you guys ask one more mean question I may have to leave the stage,” he said. He may have meant it tongue-and-cheek, but it came off as petulant.
It was the worst possible time – on the eve of the deadlocked Iowa caucuses – for Cruz to stumble, and Trump dug the pothole.
Rand Paul, reanimated. The Kentucky libertarian, in days of yore regarded as the most interesting Republican in the race, has disappeared almost entirely from the presidential political consciousness – and his low polling earned him ejection from the main debate stage. Granted readmission in Iowa, he made the most of it: He spoke slowly – and seemed to benefit most from Trump’s absence – to launch a series of razor-sharp attacks on the character of Cruz and Rubio. And freed from the constraints of actually running to win, he reverted back to his heartfelt and idiosyncratic brand of Republicanism, speaking passionately about issues that almost never reach the GOP debate stage: Poverty, discrimination against blacks, urban economic development, the evils of civil forfeiture and mandatory federal drug sentences.
“I… think the war on drugs has disproportionately affected our African-American community, and what we need to do is make sure that the war on drugs is equal protection under the law and that we don't unfairly incarcerate another generation of young African-American males,” he said.
Chris Christie just won’t answer a question. It’s uncanny. The bellicose New Jersey governor, who is staking all on a decent showing in New Hampshire, simply wouldn’t address anything the moderators threw at him – turning every answer into a rousing am-I-right-guys attack on the easiest of targets, Hillary Clinton.
When Megyn Kelly asked Christie about entitlement reform – the single most important element of federal deficit reduction (“Can you name even one thing that the federal government does now that it should not do at all?” she asked) – he hit a bumper-sticker talking point that had zilch to do with entitlement reform. “How about one that I've done in New Jersey for the last six years -- that's get rid of Planned Parenthood funding from the United States of America,” he intoned to applause.
When asked about how he would stop terrorists without racial profiling, he dodged the policy question and punted: “Let law enforcement make those decisions,” he said. What guidelines they would use to make those decisions, he didn’t say.
Marco Rubio needed to be great -- not grating. For months and months, Rubio’s team opted for a low-key strategy of avoiding big debate-night fights to focus on his competence, eloquence and mastery of semi-hawkish foreign policy. All that has bought the Florida senator are middling poll numbers and a predicted fourth place finish in his home state. In recent days, however, Iowa Republicans say he’s hit a stride – and have been talking up a late-January surge that could upend the Trump-or-Cruz conventional wisdom.
But Rubio seemed overly tense, hyper-emphatic and prone to his unflattering habit of delivering his answers in an annoying Gatling Gun crescendo of ever-increasing volume. Style points like these matter -- Rubio is well liked by voters (even those who plan to vote for other candidates) and his less-than-calm performance undermines the boyish senator's contention that he's seasoned enough for the big job.
Jeb, unleashed. The knock on Jeb Bush in earlier debates was that he lacked the rhetorical zip and testosterone to go one-on-one with Trump. In the frontrunner's absence, he seemed more confident and more competently combative, training many of his blows at Rubio.
In one memorable exchange, Bush accused Rubio of choosing to "cut and run" from his commitment to pass comprehensive immigration reform in the Senate - in order to avoid the conservative backlash against supporting path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants.
"He led the charge to finally fix this immigration problem that has existed now for, as Marco says, for 30 years. And then he cut and run because it wasn't popular amongst conservatives, I guess," Bush said.
But he saved the most lacerating line for himself - acknowledging that his own support for a citizenship pathway is a no-sale in a GOP increasingly tilting toward the hard-line Trump position -- which includes building a massive border wall to keep out foreigners. "I wrote a book about this called Immigration Wars," he said. "You can get it at $2.99 on Amazon. It's not a bestseller. I can promise you."
Cruz mocks Trump, Rubio speeds through, and Bush lightens up a little.
By Glenn Thrush
A Republican debate without Donald Trump is like a fern bar without a bouncer.
Without enforcer Trump around to make everybody stutter and flinch, all those nice guys in carefully pressed dress shirts were free to mouth off and pick fights with one another. While the punches drew less blood, the debate had an air of freedom with the oft-bullied likes of Rand Paul and Jeb Bush liberated from the oppressive presence of the party’s frontrunner.
The ratings for these GOP Trump-fests have been steadily slipping, so it will interesting to see if Trump’s absence decreased or enhanced viewership – and whether or not the unobstructed view of the other candidates solidified or undermined his position. With that in mind, here are five takeaways.
Cruz: Why is everybody always picking on me? Trump claimed that FOX was rude and biased against him (absolutely nobody apart from the Donald faithful bought that), so, yeah, chuck the debate. But he had plenty of tactical reasons to ditch the madding crowd. First, if the debate ratings dip (as they would likely have done even if he was onstage) he gets to chalk it up to his absence. But the real reason he skipped out was to create a circular GOP firing squad – with Ted Cruz at the center. And it worked.
The other candidates, no dummies, knew what Trump was up to – but they had plenty of incentive to cut the Texas Tea Party hero down to size, and they whacked Cruz early and often, especially on immigration and his annoying habit (to them) of demeaning the conservative credentials of any Republican who opposed him. Rand Paul was particularly cutting, pointing out Cruz’s support for a comprehensive immigration reform “compromise” – before hardening his position to oppose anything that smacked of amnesty. “What is particularly insulting, though, is that he is the king of saying, ‘you're for amnesty,’” Paul said. “Everybody's for amnesty except for Ted Cruz. But it's a falseness, and that's an authenticity problem.”
Cruz responded to the attacks, at times, by whining. And unlike Trump, he let the FOX moderating team – including Chris Wallace -- best him in several testy exchanges. “Chris, I would note that the last four questions have been, Rand, please attack Ted. Marco, please attack Ted. Chris, please attack Ted. Jeb, please attack Ted,” he complained to Wallace – who shock back with, “It is a debate, sir.”
Then, Cruz, unconvincingly threatened to pull a Trump. “Gosh, if you guys ask one more mean question I may have to leave the stage,” he said. He may have meant it tongue-and-cheek, but it came off as petulant.
It was the worst possible time – on the eve of the deadlocked Iowa caucuses – for Cruz to stumble, and Trump dug the pothole.
Rand Paul, reanimated. The Kentucky libertarian, in days of yore regarded as the most interesting Republican in the race, has disappeared almost entirely from the presidential political consciousness – and his low polling earned him ejection from the main debate stage. Granted readmission in Iowa, he made the most of it: He spoke slowly – and seemed to benefit most from Trump’s absence – to launch a series of razor-sharp attacks on the character of Cruz and Rubio. And freed from the constraints of actually running to win, he reverted back to his heartfelt and idiosyncratic brand of Republicanism, speaking passionately about issues that almost never reach the GOP debate stage: Poverty, discrimination against blacks, urban economic development, the evils of civil forfeiture and mandatory federal drug sentences.
“I… think the war on drugs has disproportionately affected our African-American community, and what we need to do is make sure that the war on drugs is equal protection under the law and that we don't unfairly incarcerate another generation of young African-American males,” he said.
Chris Christie just won’t answer a question. It’s uncanny. The bellicose New Jersey governor, who is staking all on a decent showing in New Hampshire, simply wouldn’t address anything the moderators threw at him – turning every answer into a rousing am-I-right-guys attack on the easiest of targets, Hillary Clinton.
When Megyn Kelly asked Christie about entitlement reform – the single most important element of federal deficit reduction (“Can you name even one thing that the federal government does now that it should not do at all?” she asked) – he hit a bumper-sticker talking point that had zilch to do with entitlement reform. “How about one that I've done in New Jersey for the last six years -- that's get rid of Planned Parenthood funding from the United States of America,” he intoned to applause.
When asked about how he would stop terrorists without racial profiling, he dodged the policy question and punted: “Let law enforcement make those decisions,” he said. What guidelines they would use to make those decisions, he didn’t say.
Marco Rubio needed to be great -- not grating. For months and months, Rubio’s team opted for a low-key strategy of avoiding big debate-night fights to focus on his competence, eloquence and mastery of semi-hawkish foreign policy. All that has bought the Florida senator are middling poll numbers and a predicted fourth place finish in his home state. In recent days, however, Iowa Republicans say he’s hit a stride – and have been talking up a late-January surge that could upend the Trump-or-Cruz conventional wisdom.
But Rubio seemed overly tense, hyper-emphatic and prone to his unflattering habit of delivering his answers in an annoying Gatling Gun crescendo of ever-increasing volume. Style points like these matter -- Rubio is well liked by voters (even those who plan to vote for other candidates) and his less-than-calm performance undermines the boyish senator's contention that he's seasoned enough for the big job.
Jeb, unleashed. The knock on Jeb Bush in earlier debates was that he lacked the rhetorical zip and testosterone to go one-on-one with Trump. In the frontrunner's absence, he seemed more confident and more competently combative, training many of his blows at Rubio.
In one memorable exchange, Bush accused Rubio of choosing to "cut and run" from his commitment to pass comprehensive immigration reform in the Senate - in order to avoid the conservative backlash against supporting path to citizenship for undocumented immigrants.
"He led the charge to finally fix this immigration problem that has existed now for, as Marco says, for 30 years. And then he cut and run because it wasn't popular amongst conservatives, I guess," Bush said.
But he saved the most lacerating line for himself - acknowledging that his own support for a citizenship pathway is a no-sale in a GOP increasingly tilting toward the hard-line Trump position -- which includes building a massive border wall to keep out foreigners. "I wrote a book about this called Immigration Wars," he said. "You can get it at $2.99 on Amazon. It's not a bestseller. I can promise you."
Dirty Work
Megyn Kelly Just Did Trump’s Dirty Work for Him
Last night she kneecapped his rivals on immigration. At this rate, he'll get to skip his own inaugural.
By Michael Grunwald
Donald Trump skipped last night’s Fox Entertainment News debate in a fit of pique over the “very biased” Megyn Kelly. But since the shocking things he does and says always seem to work out for him, someone else used his pet issue of immigration to tie his top Republican rivals into knots. And that someone else was Megyn Kelly.
Kelly flummoxed Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio, currently polling second and third in Iowa, with brutal video montages that vividly demonstrated their flip-flops on immigration reform. To make things even more delicious for Trump, his other favorite bullying target, “low-energy” Jeb Bush, helped twist the knife into Rubio. And another one of his punching bags, Rand Paul, helped deliver the beatdown to Cruz.
It’s hard to see how the debate could have gone any better for Trump if he had actually participated. Meanwhile, Democrats who hope to expand their majorities among Latino voters had to enjoy watching two Cuban-American Republicans scrambling to walk back their previous flirtations with reform.
The star of the show was Kelly, the allegedly anti-Trump “lightweight” who devoted an entire segment to shredding Rubio and Cruz over immigration. She began by airing several video clips of Rubio promising to oppose “amnesty” when he ran for Senate in 2010, at one point arguing that “earned path to citizenship is basically code for amnesty.” She then pointed out that in the Senate, Rubio helped lead the push for a bill that included an earned path to citizenship.
“Haven’t you already proven that you cannot be trusted on this issue?” Kelly asked.
When Rubio tried to wriggle away, arguing that the “earned citizenship” he opposed in 2010 was different than the “earned citizenship” he supported in 2013, Kelly threw a softball to Bush: “Do you agree Senator Rubio has not reversed himself on his immigration promise?” Bush essentially committed the Republican primary equivalent of a murder-suicide, reminding the audience that he and Rubio both supported versions of amnesty—but that only Rubio lacked the guts to admit it.
“He cut and run because it wasn’t popular among conservatives, I guess,” Bush said.
Bush acknowledged that his position might not be popular in the primary, but with a touch of charming I’m-not-Trump self-deprecation, he urged the audience to read his book stating his case, Immigration Wars. “You can get it at $2.99 on Amazon,” Bush said. “It’s not a best-seller, I can promise you.” When Rubio pointed out that Bush had changed his position on citizenship, Bush didn’t even deny it.
“So did you,” he said.
Rubio seemed taken aback. “Well, but you changed the—in the book…”
“Yeah,” Bush replied. “So did you, Marco.”
Immigration is the issue that most starkly divides the Republican base, which loves Trump’s push for a giant wall and mass deportations, from the Republican establishment. That’s both the business establishment, which supports a free flow of immigration for labor-supply reasons, and the political establishment, which worries that anti-immigrant positions will alienate Latinos and keep the GOP out of the White House. While Rubio has tried to thread the needle during the primary, renouncing his support for his own reform bill but retaining some nuance on the issue, Cruz has portrayed himself as a Trump-style hard-liner, touting his support from reform opponents like Senator Jeff Sessions and Congressman Steve King.
Cruz once filed an amendment to Rubio’s bill that would have created a path to “legalization,” but he has argued that it was really a poison pill designed to kill reform. Last night, though, Kelly effectively quashed that argument, playing several clips of Cruz insisting that he did want reform to pass. “Was that all an act?” Kelly asked him. “It was pretty convincing!” After Cruz flailed around for a few minutes, arguing that it was unfair for Kelly to focus on 38 words in a 1000-page bill, Kelly turned to Rand Paul, yet another frequent target of Trump’s barbs. “Senator Paul, you know how Washington works,” she said. “Do you buy that?”
Paul—who has denounced Trump as unfit for office, and who has been mocked by Trump for his poll numbers and even his looks—obligingly continued the evisceration of Cruz. “He can’t have it both ways,” he said. “What is particularly insulting is, he’s the king of saying ‘You’re for amnesty.’ Everyone’s for amnesty except for Ted Cruz. But it’s a falseness, and that’s an authenticity problem….I was for legalization. So was Ted, but now he says he wasn’t. That’s not true.”
To recap: Megyn Kelly, derided by Trump as a vapid Trump-basher, along with Jeb Bush and Rand Paul, derided by Trump as pathetic losers, led the attacks on Trump’s leading competitors. And in the process, they helped remind Republican primary voters worried about immigration that Bush, Paul, Rubio and Cruz have all supported versions of “amnesty.” Of course, Trump was conveniently absent, so he didn’t have to field any tough questions about his own inconsistencies on immigration or other issues, from Kelly or anyone else.
At this rate, Trump might get a chance to skip his own inaugural.
Last night she kneecapped his rivals on immigration. At this rate, he'll get to skip his own inaugural.
By Michael Grunwald
Donald Trump skipped last night’s Fox Entertainment News debate in a fit of pique over the “very biased” Megyn Kelly. But since the shocking things he does and says always seem to work out for him, someone else used his pet issue of immigration to tie his top Republican rivals into knots. And that someone else was Megyn Kelly.
Kelly flummoxed Ted Cruz and Marco Rubio, currently polling second and third in Iowa, with brutal video montages that vividly demonstrated their flip-flops on immigration reform. To make things even more delicious for Trump, his other favorite bullying target, “low-energy” Jeb Bush, helped twist the knife into Rubio. And another one of his punching bags, Rand Paul, helped deliver the beatdown to Cruz.
It’s hard to see how the debate could have gone any better for Trump if he had actually participated. Meanwhile, Democrats who hope to expand their majorities among Latino voters had to enjoy watching two Cuban-American Republicans scrambling to walk back their previous flirtations with reform.
The star of the show was Kelly, the allegedly anti-Trump “lightweight” who devoted an entire segment to shredding Rubio and Cruz over immigration. She began by airing several video clips of Rubio promising to oppose “amnesty” when he ran for Senate in 2010, at one point arguing that “earned path to citizenship is basically code for amnesty.” She then pointed out that in the Senate, Rubio helped lead the push for a bill that included an earned path to citizenship.
“Haven’t you already proven that you cannot be trusted on this issue?” Kelly asked.
When Rubio tried to wriggle away, arguing that the “earned citizenship” he opposed in 2010 was different than the “earned citizenship” he supported in 2013, Kelly threw a softball to Bush: “Do you agree Senator Rubio has not reversed himself on his immigration promise?” Bush essentially committed the Republican primary equivalent of a murder-suicide, reminding the audience that he and Rubio both supported versions of amnesty—but that only Rubio lacked the guts to admit it.
“He cut and run because it wasn’t popular among conservatives, I guess,” Bush said.
Bush acknowledged that his position might not be popular in the primary, but with a touch of charming I’m-not-Trump self-deprecation, he urged the audience to read his book stating his case, Immigration Wars. “You can get it at $2.99 on Amazon,” Bush said. “It’s not a best-seller, I can promise you.” When Rubio pointed out that Bush had changed his position on citizenship, Bush didn’t even deny it.
“So did you,” he said.
Rubio seemed taken aback. “Well, but you changed the—in the book…”
“Yeah,” Bush replied. “So did you, Marco.”
Immigration is the issue that most starkly divides the Republican base, which loves Trump’s push for a giant wall and mass deportations, from the Republican establishment. That’s both the business establishment, which supports a free flow of immigration for labor-supply reasons, and the political establishment, which worries that anti-immigrant positions will alienate Latinos and keep the GOP out of the White House. While Rubio has tried to thread the needle during the primary, renouncing his support for his own reform bill but retaining some nuance on the issue, Cruz has portrayed himself as a Trump-style hard-liner, touting his support from reform opponents like Senator Jeff Sessions and Congressman Steve King.
Cruz once filed an amendment to Rubio’s bill that would have created a path to “legalization,” but he has argued that it was really a poison pill designed to kill reform. Last night, though, Kelly effectively quashed that argument, playing several clips of Cruz insisting that he did want reform to pass. “Was that all an act?” Kelly asked him. “It was pretty convincing!” After Cruz flailed around for a few minutes, arguing that it was unfair for Kelly to focus on 38 words in a 1000-page bill, Kelly turned to Rand Paul, yet another frequent target of Trump’s barbs. “Senator Paul, you know how Washington works,” she said. “Do you buy that?”
Paul—who has denounced Trump as unfit for office, and who has been mocked by Trump for his poll numbers and even his looks—obligingly continued the evisceration of Cruz. “He can’t have it both ways,” he said. “What is particularly insulting is, he’s the king of saying ‘You’re for amnesty.’ Everyone’s for amnesty except for Ted Cruz. But it’s a falseness, and that’s an authenticity problem….I was for legalization. So was Ted, but now he says he wasn’t. That’s not true.”
To recap: Megyn Kelly, derided by Trump as a vapid Trump-basher, along with Jeb Bush and Rand Paul, derided by Trump as pathetic losers, led the attacks on Trump’s leading competitors. And in the process, they helped remind Republican primary voters worried about immigration that Bush, Paul, Rubio and Cruz have all supported versions of “amnesty.” Of course, Trump was conveniently absent, so he didn’t have to field any tough questions about his own inconsistencies on immigration or other issues, from Kelly or anyone else.
At this rate, Trump might get a chance to skip his own inaugural.
Killed by police
Father charged after girl, 12, is killed by police constable
By Faith Karimi and Greg Botelho
The father of a 12-year-old has been charged with homicide after the girl was accidentally shot to death by a police constable in Pennsylvania, authorities said.
Ciara Meyer was killed by a police constable who was serving eviction papers at their apartment in Perry County on January 11.
Constable Clark Steele's action was justified, and he did not face any charges in the shooting, authorities said.
Her father, Donald Meyer, 57, was charged with homicide and involuntary manslaughter Thursday, according to CNN affiliate WHP .
"Meyer's reckless conduct, knowing his daughter was standing behind him, triggered a chain of events that tragically led to the death of Ciara Meyer," District Attorney Andrew Bender told the affiliate.
Eviction notice
During the incident this month, the constable was at Meyer's apartment to serve a valid eviction notice, authorities said.
The girl's father pointed a loaded rifle at Steele, and the constable fired a single shot, authorities said. The bullet traveled through Meyer's arm and struck Ciara, who was standing behind her father.
"They're responsible for the murder and shooting of my daughter and me, and now it's a big cover up," Meyer told the affiliate. "They're charging me with a felony for protecting my family?"
More charges
Meyer's latest charges of homicide and involuntary manslaughter add on to previous ones that included aggravated assault and recklessly endangering another person, according to a Pennsylvania State Police report.
Meyer also faces a firearms charge, because under state law he was not allowed to have a gun because of past mental issues, authorities told the affiliate.
'They knew who it was'
Donald Meyer knew the constable was coming, Pennsylvania State Trooper Robert Hicks told CNN affiliate WPMT. His family had received multiple notifications, with the last making it clear a constable was on the way with an eviction notice.
"When they heard the knock, they knew who it was," Hicks said. When Steele arrived at 10 a.m. Monday, "the suspect opened the door to the residence and then shut it," according to the police report.
Meyer then reopened the door and, after "a brief exchange of words," leveled a rifle that had been concealed and aimed it at Steele.
"Constable Steele, who was in uniform, quickly removed his .40 caliber duty weapon from its holster and fired a single round," the police report said, noting that employees of the apartment complex witnessed the encounter.
That bullet "shattered the bone in (Meyer's) left arm," Hicks told CNN affiliate WHTM-TV, then went into the body of Ciara, who had stayed home sick from school.
Pennsylvania constables are not police officers but elected officials. They may be tasked with certain aspects of law enforcement in the duty of the courts, according to the Pennsylvania court system.
By Faith Karimi and Greg Botelho
The father of a 12-year-old has been charged with homicide after the girl was accidentally shot to death by a police constable in Pennsylvania, authorities said.
Ciara Meyer was killed by a police constable who was serving eviction papers at their apartment in Perry County on January 11.
Constable Clark Steele's action was justified, and he did not face any charges in the shooting, authorities said.
Her father, Donald Meyer, 57, was charged with homicide and involuntary manslaughter Thursday, according to CNN affiliate WHP .
"Meyer's reckless conduct, knowing his daughter was standing behind him, triggered a chain of events that tragically led to the death of Ciara Meyer," District Attorney Andrew Bender told the affiliate.
Eviction notice
During the incident this month, the constable was at Meyer's apartment to serve a valid eviction notice, authorities said.
The girl's father pointed a loaded rifle at Steele, and the constable fired a single shot, authorities said. The bullet traveled through Meyer's arm and struck Ciara, who was standing behind her father.
"They're responsible for the murder and shooting of my daughter and me, and now it's a big cover up," Meyer told the affiliate. "They're charging me with a felony for protecting my family?"
More charges
Meyer's latest charges of homicide and involuntary manslaughter add on to previous ones that included aggravated assault and recklessly endangering another person, according to a Pennsylvania State Police report.
Meyer also faces a firearms charge, because under state law he was not allowed to have a gun because of past mental issues, authorities told the affiliate.
'They knew who it was'
Donald Meyer knew the constable was coming, Pennsylvania State Trooper Robert Hicks told CNN affiliate WPMT. His family had received multiple notifications, with the last making it clear a constable was on the way with an eviction notice.
"When they heard the knock, they knew who it was," Hicks said. When Steele arrived at 10 a.m. Monday, "the suspect opened the door to the residence and then shut it," according to the police report.
Meyer then reopened the door and, after "a brief exchange of words," leveled a rifle that had been concealed and aimed it at Steele.
"Constable Steele, who was in uniform, quickly removed his .40 caliber duty weapon from its holster and fired a single round," the police report said, noting that employees of the apartment complex witnessed the encounter.
That bullet "shattered the bone in (Meyer's) left arm," Hicks told CNN affiliate WHTM-TV, then went into the body of Ciara, who had stayed home sick from school.
Pennsylvania constables are not police officers but elected officials. They may be tasked with certain aspects of law enforcement in the duty of the courts, according to the Pennsylvania court system.
Debate-Rivaling Rally
What Donald Trump's Debate-Rivaling Rally Says About His Candidacy
It drew a lot of spectators but few die-hard fans.
By Pema Levy
When Donald Trump announced, with just two-days notice, that instead of attending the Republican debate Thursday night he would host a rival event at Drake University in Des Moines, the question was, would his supporters flock to him? Would they come from across the city, the state, even around the country to see him?
Judging from the line outside his event, billed as a fundraiser to support veterans, it seemed that they had. The queue stretched so far back that you couldn't make out the end of it, and people waited in the cold for hours to get in (and many were ultimately turned away when the venue reached capacity). If Trump could muster this much support at a moment's notice, you would think he should be well on his way to winning the Iowa caucuses. But on further inspection, the impressive crowd was composed largely of Drake University students, few of whom actually seemed prepared to caucus for Trump—or even to caucus at all.
"I'm just here cause I think he's hilarious," said one Drake student, who declined to give her name. Her friend, a 20-year-old Drake student wearing a "Make America Great Again" baseball cap, agreed. The reason "Drake students are attending tonight is more the comedic factor," she said. "We've had all these very serious events with random raffles and drawings, and then Trump shows up on campus and he gives out around 3,000 tickets on an app to an event happening in an auditorium that holds around 700 people."
Even among students who identified as Republicans, few were planning to turn out for Trump. The student with the "Make America Great Again" hat said she probably won't caucus for him. She just bought the hat because it looked "cool" and it was "really cold."
Standing ahead of her was Michael Harvey, a junior and a Republican. He agreed that the event was basically a spectacle. Standing in line, he said, "I've seen at least 40 Drake students that I know personally that are not supporting Donald Trump that are here tonight." Harvey hasn't decided which Republican he'll caucus for yet, but he's already ruled out the bombastic real estate mogul. Harvey was standing in line with his friend, Travis Brauer, a fellow junior and Republican who did not support Trump.
"I want to see Donald Trump," said Taylor Zant, a Drake junior who was excitedly braving the cold. "I just think it would be awesome to see him. I mean, who gets to say they get to see Donald Trump on their own school campus? I think it's pretty cool." But Zant won't be caucusing on Monday. She's headed to Prague to study abroad.
"I just thought it would be an interesting opportunity," said Michael Dolan, a 20-year-old Drake student. "And tickets were free, too." He said he could could see himself supporting Trump, but he doesn't plan to caucus on Monday. "I have class, schoolwork and such." Dolan's friend, a bearded senior named Philip Dgraffenreid, also will not be caucusing. "I'm not really firm on anything so I'm just gonna hold out till the elections" in November, he said. But he didn't think many of his fellow students would be caucusing for Trump either. Drake, he said, is a pretty liberal school. He feels like a "lonely Republican." Prague-bound Zant agreed. "There's like Bernie Sanders signs everywhere, everyone's a Democrat here I feel like," she said.
When I spotted a young man wearing just a long-sleeve shirt waiting out in the long line, I thought I had perhaps found a die-hard fan. But he wasn't. "I'm still deciding," said Tim Celander, a 23-year-old engineer who, after going to college in North Dakota, found the Iowa weather balmy (and he left his jacket in the car). But he said he won't be backing Trump. "I can't think of any policies that I agree with him on," said Celander. He's leaning toward Marco Rubio or John Kasich instead.
This is not to say that there were no Trump supporters in the crowd—only that they were hard to find. There was Gavin Yusten, 22, who when asked if he supported Trump responded: "Probably, pro-America. That's about it. I'm not a big politics guy." But Gavin, who was in town to visit his girlfriend who attends Drake, actually lives in Lincoln, Nebraska. So he can't caucus for Trump. And there was Clay Rogers, 21, who identified himself as "Trump's biggest supporter" because "he puts America first, he puts the American worker first, he protects our borders."
The Trump supporters in the crowd tended to be older then the largely college-aged crowd. Lisa Gomez, 45, of Des Moines. She is a Trump supporter, she said, because "he's self-funded" and therefore "not beholden to anybody."
Near the back of the line were two older-looking men, who I approached thinking they might be Trump die-hards. "No, by no means," said one of them when I asked if he would vote for Trump. "I'm curious about the experience, and I'm curious about his supporters." He won't be caucusing on Monday, but if he were, he would go for Bernie Sanders. His friend, who also did not want his name in print, said he had been "dragged" to the event and was supporting Democrat Martin O'Malley. "We're few and proud," he said. His second choice is Hillary Clinton.
It drew a lot of spectators but few die-hard fans.
By Pema Levy
When Donald Trump announced, with just two-days notice, that instead of attending the Republican debate Thursday night he would host a rival event at Drake University in Des Moines, the question was, would his supporters flock to him? Would they come from across the city, the state, even around the country to see him?
Judging from the line outside his event, billed as a fundraiser to support veterans, it seemed that they had. The queue stretched so far back that you couldn't make out the end of it, and people waited in the cold for hours to get in (and many were ultimately turned away when the venue reached capacity). If Trump could muster this much support at a moment's notice, you would think he should be well on his way to winning the Iowa caucuses. But on further inspection, the impressive crowd was composed largely of Drake University students, few of whom actually seemed prepared to caucus for Trump—or even to caucus at all.
"I'm just here cause I think he's hilarious," said one Drake student, who declined to give her name. Her friend, a 20-year-old Drake student wearing a "Make America Great Again" baseball cap, agreed. The reason "Drake students are attending tonight is more the comedic factor," she said. "We've had all these very serious events with random raffles and drawings, and then Trump shows up on campus and he gives out around 3,000 tickets on an app to an event happening in an auditorium that holds around 700 people."
Even among students who identified as Republicans, few were planning to turn out for Trump. The student with the "Make America Great Again" hat said she probably won't caucus for him. She just bought the hat because it looked "cool" and it was "really cold."
Standing ahead of her was Michael Harvey, a junior and a Republican. He agreed that the event was basically a spectacle. Standing in line, he said, "I've seen at least 40 Drake students that I know personally that are not supporting Donald Trump that are here tonight." Harvey hasn't decided which Republican he'll caucus for yet, but he's already ruled out the bombastic real estate mogul. Harvey was standing in line with his friend, Travis Brauer, a fellow junior and Republican who did not support Trump.
"I want to see Donald Trump," said Taylor Zant, a Drake junior who was excitedly braving the cold. "I just think it would be awesome to see him. I mean, who gets to say they get to see Donald Trump on their own school campus? I think it's pretty cool." But Zant won't be caucusing on Monday. She's headed to Prague to study abroad.
"I just thought it would be an interesting opportunity," said Michael Dolan, a 20-year-old Drake student. "And tickets were free, too." He said he could could see himself supporting Trump, but he doesn't plan to caucus on Monday. "I have class, schoolwork and such." Dolan's friend, a bearded senior named Philip Dgraffenreid, also will not be caucusing. "I'm not really firm on anything so I'm just gonna hold out till the elections" in November, he said. But he didn't think many of his fellow students would be caucusing for Trump either. Drake, he said, is a pretty liberal school. He feels like a "lonely Republican." Prague-bound Zant agreed. "There's like Bernie Sanders signs everywhere, everyone's a Democrat here I feel like," she said.
When I spotted a young man wearing just a long-sleeve shirt waiting out in the long line, I thought I had perhaps found a die-hard fan. But he wasn't. "I'm still deciding," said Tim Celander, a 23-year-old engineer who, after going to college in North Dakota, found the Iowa weather balmy (and he left his jacket in the car). But he said he won't be backing Trump. "I can't think of any policies that I agree with him on," said Celander. He's leaning toward Marco Rubio or John Kasich instead.
This is not to say that there were no Trump supporters in the crowd—only that they were hard to find. There was Gavin Yusten, 22, who when asked if he supported Trump responded: "Probably, pro-America. That's about it. I'm not a big politics guy." But Gavin, who was in town to visit his girlfriend who attends Drake, actually lives in Lincoln, Nebraska. So he can't caucus for Trump. And there was Clay Rogers, 21, who identified himself as "Trump's biggest supporter" because "he puts America first, he puts the American worker first, he protects our borders."
The Trump supporters in the crowd tended to be older then the largely college-aged crowd. Lisa Gomez, 45, of Des Moines. She is a Trump supporter, she said, because "he's self-funded" and therefore "not beholden to anybody."
Near the back of the line were two older-looking men, who I approached thinking they might be Trump die-hards. "No, by no means," said one of them when I asked if he would vote for Trump. "I'm curious about the experience, and I'm curious about his supporters." He won't be caucusing on Monday, but if he were, he would go for Bernie Sanders. His friend, who also did not want his name in print, said he had been "dragged" to the event and was supporting Democrat Martin O'Malley. "We're few and proud," he said. His second choice is Hillary Clinton.
Perfect Answer
This Prosecutor Gave the Perfect Answer to People Defending the Anti-Abortion Activists Behind Those Deceptive Videos
By Hannah Levintova
On Monday, the district attorney in Harris County, Texas, announced that a grand jury tasked with investigating Planned Parenthood had instead issued indictments against two anti-abortion activists, David Daleiden and Susan Merritt, who released a series of doctored Planned Parenthood videos last summer. Since the indictments, district attorney Devon Anderson has faced an onslaught of criticism from the anti-abortion movement about both the severity of the charges—one is a felony—and a department employee's affiliation with Planned Parenthood.
Today, in a video on KHOU, a Houston TV network, Anderson explained why her office indicted David Daleiden and Susan Merritt. Even though the decision goes against her opinions on abortion, she says, it follows the law.
"An inconvenient truth of a criminal investigation is that it doesn't always lead where you want to go," Anderson says at the start of the video. "Anyone who pays attention knows that I'm pro-life. I believe abortion is wrong. But my personal belief does not relieve me of my obligation to follow the law."
Anderson dispels some of the misconceptions that have sprung up about her office's decision. For example, defense attorneys have argued that charging both Daleiden and Merritt with a felony for using fake driver's licenses is too extreme because young people caught with fake IDs often receive a misdemeanor charge. But Anderson explains that in Texas, using a fake ID from another state is a felony. "That's the law," she says.
Anderson also addresses the allegation—repeatedly emphasized by the anti-abortion news site LifeNews—that a prosecutor in her department who is involved with the Planned Parenthood board actively participated in the presentation of this case to the grand jury. "That is simply not true," she says. She noted that soon after the lieutenant governor asked her department to review this case in August, this particular prosecutor made her relationship to Planned Parenthood known, and the department issued a press release saying she would not be involved in the case.
Some defense attorneys have asked for another grand jury to review the case. Anderson says she won't do that because it constitutes "grand jury shopping."
"That violates the integrity of the whole system," she says. "Twelve Harris County citizens have spoken, and I respect their decision."
By Hannah Levintova
On Monday, the district attorney in Harris County, Texas, announced that a grand jury tasked with investigating Planned Parenthood had instead issued indictments against two anti-abortion activists, David Daleiden and Susan Merritt, who released a series of doctored Planned Parenthood videos last summer. Since the indictments, district attorney Devon Anderson has faced an onslaught of criticism from the anti-abortion movement about both the severity of the charges—one is a felony—and a department employee's affiliation with Planned Parenthood.
Today, in a video on KHOU, a Houston TV network, Anderson explained why her office indicted David Daleiden and Susan Merritt. Even though the decision goes against her opinions on abortion, she says, it follows the law.
"An inconvenient truth of a criminal investigation is that it doesn't always lead where you want to go," Anderson says at the start of the video. "Anyone who pays attention knows that I'm pro-life. I believe abortion is wrong. But my personal belief does not relieve me of my obligation to follow the law."
Anderson dispels some of the misconceptions that have sprung up about her office's decision. For example, defense attorneys have argued that charging both Daleiden and Merritt with a felony for using fake driver's licenses is too extreme because young people caught with fake IDs often receive a misdemeanor charge. But Anderson explains that in Texas, using a fake ID from another state is a felony. "That's the law," she says.
Anderson also addresses the allegation—repeatedly emphasized by the anti-abortion news site LifeNews—that a prosecutor in her department who is involved with the Planned Parenthood board actively participated in the presentation of this case to the grand jury. "That is simply not true," she says. She noted that soon after the lieutenant governor asked her department to review this case in August, this particular prosecutor made her relationship to Planned Parenthood known, and the department issued a press release saying she would not be involved in the case.
Some defense attorneys have asked for another grand jury to review the case. Anderson says she won't do that because it constitutes "grand jury shopping."
"That violates the integrity of the whole system," she says. "Twelve Harris County citizens have spoken, and I respect their decision."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)