A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



March 04, 2024

Restricting birth control

The anti-abortion playbook for restricting birth control

Contraception, like IVF, poses problems for those claiming personhood begins at conception.

By Rachel M. Cohen

The national debate over IVF, unfolding after an Alabama court decision prompted multiple clinics in the state to halt operations, prompts a question: What might be next? Could other fertility treatments and even birth control be under threat given that Roe v. Wade is no longer the law?

If the idea that birth control could be at risk in America strikes you as hard to believe, I understand. There’s no proposed legislation on the table to ban it, and it does seem unbelievable that contraception — which an overwhelming majority of US women, including religious and Republican women, have used and support — could one day disappear.

But attacks on reproductive rights have never really been about public opinion, as the overturn of Roe showed and the current national debate over IVF has further proved. While it’s not an immediate threat, anti-abortion leaders have been laying the groundwork to curtail contraception access for many decades, despite birth control being one of the most reliable ways to reduce the incidence of abortion.

Their fundamental opposition is rooted in a belief that penetrative sex is sacred and should only occur within a heterosexual marriage and in the service of having children. In their eyes, birth control has encouraged sex outside of marriage — a development they charge with weakening families, absolving men of responsibility, and steering women away from domestic duties.

These are fringe conservative views, but ones endorsed by religious institutions and groups that have long provided funding and power to the anti-abortion movement.

“I think contraception is disgusting, people using each other for pleasure,” said Joseph Scheidler, the late founder of the Pro-Life Action League, an activist group that pioneered confrontational tactics like sit-ins at abortion clinics and picketing outside doctors’ homes. The New York Times described Scheidler as the “godfather” of the movement.

Randall Terry, who founded the group Operation Rescue — known for blockading and protesting abortion clinics and patients — once laid out the logic against birth control plainly: “Any drug or device that prevents us from having children” is “anti-child,” he said. “How do we expect to defeat child-killing in the world when we cannot defeat child-rejection in our own midst?”

The political playbook for attacking birth control shares some similarities with the playbook for attacking abortion — a slow and steady chipping away of rights and access. Both efforts rely on measures like slashing funding for low-income patients, enacting parental consent laws to restrict minors’ use, and empowering ideologically supportive lawmakers and judges who push friendly legal frameworks.

But the major difference between pushing to restrict abortion access and pushing to restrict birth control is that leaders are typically much quieter about their goals for the latter, aware that open discussion will prompt fierce backlash. They typically try to paint those who suggest they’d take aim at contraception as alarmists and conspiracists.

When Democrats in Congress introduced a bill to codify access to birth control following the overturn of Roe, for example, they were met with emphatic performances of exasperation.

“This bill is completely unnecessary. In no way, shape, or form is access to contraception limited or at risk of being limited,” declared Florida Republican Rep. Kat Cammack during debate on the House floor. “The liberal majority is clearly trying to stoke fears and mislead the American people.”

Still, a growing number of Republican lawmakers — including Sens. Marsha Blackburn and Mike Braun — have recently declared that Griswold v. Connecticut, the 1965 Supreme Court decision establishing a constitutional right to birth control, was wrongly decided. Griswold relies on the same legal right to privacy that underpinned Roe, and in his concurring Dobbs v. Jackson opinion in 2022, Justice Clarence Thomas encouraged the Supreme Court to “reconsider” Griswold and other privacy-related decisions. Former Arizona Senate candidate Blake Masters went so far as to pledge to “vote only for federal judges who understand that Roe and Griswold” should be overturned.

Leaders more than occasionally reveal their underlying beliefs. Recent statements, as well as recent actions from reproductive rights opponents, have sent clear reminders about how some influential activists really think about contraception: that it’s just another form of abortion.

Activists aim to blur the line between birth control and abortion

Anti-abortion leaders tend to take advantage of one basic fact about the American people: There is great confusion about how pregnancy works, how abortion pills end it, and how birth control and emergency contraception (such as Plan B) prevent it. For example, one recent poll found that a stunning 73 percent of Americans think emergency contraception can end a pregnancy.

But among most medical experts, including those at the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists — there is no confusion. Birth control, including emergency contraception, prevents ovulation (when an egg is released) and fertilization (when egg and sperm meet). Pregnancy begins when a fertilized egg attaches to the lining of the uterine wall, a process called implantation. Many fertilized eggs never implant.

Yet for a highly motivated wing of the anti-abortion movement, pregnancy starts not at implantation but at conception, and human personhood begins then too, not at birth. These “fetal personhood” activists want to endow fetuses, embryos, and fertilized eggs with full rights and legal protections and thus frame any effort to prevent implantation — be it through discarding embryos from IVF or taking a daily birth control pill — as a form of killing unborn children.

It’s a stretch of scientific consensus, but certain Christian activists have long clung to this idea and have slowly been codifying it in state law through bills that claim human life begins at conception. More than a third of states currently have such laws on the books.

To blur the line between abortion and contraception, many of these activists call birth control methods “abortifacients” — agents that induce abortion. But this is misleading because there’s no pregnancy to abort. Real abortifacients are the medications that end pregnancies, namely misoprostol and mifepristone.

In rationalizing the idea that birth control can somehow abort a pregnancy before a pregnancy begins, activists make a number of claims. Human Life International, a global Catholic group, maintains that anything that prevents implantation is an abortion-inducing agent. IUDs, they insist, cause “early abortions.” Students for Life of America likewise claims all forms of hormonal birth control, including IUDs and the Pill, are abortifacients.

Georgia Republican Rep. Marjorie Taylor Greene went so far as to proclaim that Plan B emergency contraception “kills a baby in the womb once a woman is already pregnant” even though studies have shown the drug interferes with ovulation but does not inhibit implantation.

Greene isn’t the only Republican lawmaker blurring the lines. Colorado Rep. Lauren Boebert tried to block funds for “abortifacient contraceptive drugs,” while Montana Rep. Matt Rosendale tried adding emergency contraception to a bill barring use of the federal funding for abortion. In 2022, in perhaps one of the most glaring examples, Missouri Republicans pushed unsuccessfully to restrict public funding for IUDs and emergency contraception, with one of the state senators who led it proclaiming that “life begins at conception,” and “anything that destroys that life is abortion, it’s not birth control.”

Just this past week in Iowa, House Republicans attempted to amend a bipartisan bill to legalize over-the-counter birth control by adding new language that would require pharmacists to provide misleading and inaccurate information implying contraceptives are dangerous and a form of abortion. Pulse Life Advocates, an Iowa group opposing the contraception bill, claims on its website that birth control “kills babies.”

Many of these objections will sound familiar to anyone who followed the fight around the Affordable Care Act 15 years ago. The political groundwork was laid in 2010 when the Tea Party movement came into power and fought alongside the Catholic Church against requirements that employer health insurance plans cover birth control. And in 2014, the retail chain Hobby Lobby won its case before the US Supreme Court in which it argued it shouldn’t have to provide employees with IUDs or emergency contraception since its ownership viewed such things as abortion.

Wellness influencers have joined anti-abortion activists in raising fears about birth control

While many “fetal personhood” activists have long opposed birth control for religious reasons, over the last decade they’ve found new allies among secular “wellness” influencers who propagate dubious ideas online about vaccines, nutrition, and environmental toxins.

Many of these online influencers promote the idea of “natural” products and in the last few years have added hormonal birth control to their list of substances they claim people should avoid to live a healthy life.

Seizing on general distrust of medical institutions and the fact that some users do experience adverse side effects when using birth control, these influencers have insisted that hormonal contraceptives will likely lead to weight gain, to a diminished sex drive, and to emotional disorders. These warnings often go well beyond the scientific evidence and pair neatly with the exaggerated warnings anti-abortion groups spread about contraception, like that it will cause infertility, strokes, and cancer.

Alex Clark, a popular conservative online influencer, has told her young, female audience that she’s “on a mission to get young women off this pill.” Politico reported that Clark claimed hormonal birth control “is completely altering your personality” and insisted that many forms of birth control “are actually abortifacients.”

This fusion of feminine “wellness” content and anti-abortion advocacy can also be seen in the growth of Evie Magazine, an ostensibly nonsectarian outlet targeting young women that publishes stories like “13 Reasons Why You Should Quit Hormonal Birth Control” and “Abortion Is an Anti-Woman Issue That Has Nothing to Do with Bodily Autonomy or Reproductive Freedom.” Evie also promotes a venture-backed startup that encourages controlling fertility through “natural” means.

These tactics seem to be having an effect. One poll published in June 2023 found more than half of the roughly 4,000 women surveyed expressed fears about how hormonal birth control would affect their physical and mental health. An Instagram poll by theSkimm, a media company that focuses on Gen Z and millennial women, found that a third of respondents who weren’t on birth control had stopped taking it in the past year.

Meanwhile a study published recently in Health Affairs found statistically significant evidence that barriers to birth control had increased and “reports of receiving high-quality contraceptive care” had decreased since Roe was overturned.

“Fetal personhood” activists struggle to maintain the fiction they are neutral on birth control

When asked about their intentions to restrict or protect access to birth control, Republican lawmakers and leaders of the anti-abortion movement will typically point out the fact that there’s no bill currently under consideration explicitly aimed at banning contraception.

As journalist Jessica Valenti noted in her Abortion, Every Day newsletter, the president of Ohio Right to Life mocked a state Democrat who warned of the risk to birth control by saying, “she can’t cite a piece of legislation that bans contraception … it’s fear-mongering.” Susan B. Anthony Pro-Life America’s website calls it a “MYTH” that Republicans want to stop people from getting birth control. “FACT: No state anywhere has banned birth control,” it says.

And yet taking one big swing to restrict access has never been the strategy of the anti-contraception playbook. Rather, activists either maintain neutrality on birth control or say nothing while actively working to conflate abortion with birth control and pass laws that redefine life as beginning at conception.

As journalist Christina Cauterucci pointed out at Slate, the anti-abortion group Americans United for Life claims on its website that it takes “no stance on the underlying issue of contraceptive use,” but elsewhere it insists that people who use emergency contraception “take the lives of their unborn children.” When Mother Jones reporter Kiera Butler attended the annual conference of the anti-abortion group Heartbeat International in 2022, she found restriction of birth control to be a major theme, with several sessions dedicated to the topic.

The push to redefine the start of personhood as the point of conception holds real implications for fertility treatments and the wide range of available birth control methods. Many lawmakers in states with such “fetal personhood” laws on the books have not fully grappled with the practical consequences of how enforcing those laws in the post-Roe era might work.

In the near future, most Republicans will likely continue to dismiss the idea that there’s any threat to birth control at all, and leaders of anti-abortion organizations will surely do their best to change the subject.

But pay attention to how fights over expanding access to birth control — including nonhormonal methods like condoms — play out. Pay attention to proposals to gut funding for Title X, a federal program that provides birth control to millions of low-income people in the United States. Pay attention to efforts in Congress to restrict access to contraception in foreign aid spending bills. And pay attention to how courts and lawmakers aim to expand the definition of abortion.

March 01, 2024

Remember that fucking cum sucker??? His fault...

How Todd Akin’s “Legitimate Rape” Debacle Previewed the Abortion Agenda of Today’s GOP

The Alabama IVF ruling shows that Republicans are ready and able to shut down reproductive freedom.

PEMA LEVY

A few months before the 2012 elections, Todd Akin, the Republicans’ Senate candidate in Missouri, sent his party scrambling when he explained his opposition to abortion even in cases of rape with a now infamous line: “If it’s a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that whole thing down.”

Republicans rushed to distance themselves from a comment that ultimately represented Akin’s political suicide. Amid the firestorm, the National Republican Senatorial Committee temporarily withdrew their support, and presidential nominee Mitt Romney immediately clarified that his “administration would not oppose abortion in instances of rape.” 

I was reminded of Akin last week when Republican appointed justices on the Alabama Supreme Court similarly sent the party into a disarrayed retreat, this time over in vitro fertilization. The judges ruled that embryos are “extrauterine children” protected by state law. As a result, multiple IVF clinics in Alabama suspended services. But IVF and its ability to help families have children are immensely popular. To stem the political consequences, the NRSC urged its candidates to loudly back access to IVF. Similarly, Donald Trump quickly announced his support. 

While the broader Republican Party faced some struggles in 2012 over its attacks on reproductive freedom—beyond Akin, Indiana Senate hopeful Richard Mourdock, who similarly wanted rape victims to give birth, lost his race—other evidence suggests a modest effect. Despite all the talk about abortion and contraception that election cycle, surveys showed the economy, not abortion, was top of mind when voters headed to the polls. Nor did the gender gap grow in that year’s presidential vote. While its hard to know exactly what voters were thinking, they were making choices with the knowledge that Roe v. Wade protected them from the GOP’s anti-abortion, anti-contraception agenda. 

This year, reproductive rights will again be a prominent part of the election conversation, but without Roe, the debate is far less hypothetical. As Debbie Walsh, director of the Center for American Women and Politics at Rutgers University, puts it, reproductive rights will be completely “front and center” in 2024. And as opposed to 2012 when “everyone told women, ‘Don’t be silly, this will never happen,’” she says, in a post-Dobbs world, a broad rollback of reproductive healthcare can happen, and is happening. 

Republican rhetoric from a dozen years ago has transformed into a workable legal and legislative roadmap. And while Akin’s comments were extreme, they were not an aberration: as a congressman, Akin had signed onto a 2011 bill backed by a majority of the Republican caucus that would have rewritten the definition of rape and limited federal abortion funding to a narrower range of victims. That followed the party’s attempts to block an Obama administration mandate that insurers cover contraception. Presidential candidate Rick Santorum, who won the first in the nation Iowa caucus that year, argued states should be able to ban contraception. Romney ran on defunding Planned Parenthood. 

Twelve years ago, Akin and his allies couldn’t actually enact this agenda, including laws that would have forced rape victims to give birth. But today, states have banned abortion in cases of rape. Even where abortion bans technically have a rape exception, it’s proven virtually impossible for assault survivors to access an abortion. As a result, research suggests that thousands of adults and children who are raped are giving birth against their will. Iowa has stopped paying for emergency contraceptives for victims of sexual assault. In 2012, Mourdock said that if a woman gets pregnant from rape “that’s something God intended.” This month, Alabama’s GOP-appointed chief justice wrote that destroying an embryo would incur “the wrath of a holy God.”

In 2012, Santorum ran on the idea that not only Roe v. Wade, but Griswold v. Connecticut—the landmark Supreme Court case that created a right to contraception—had been wrongly decided, and that states should be allowed to ban birth control. Now, the Supreme Court has overturned Roe and several justices have signaled that Griswold may fall. In 2022, nearly every House Republican opposed legislation to protect contraception access. A new poll from Americans for Contraception found most Americans believe access to contraception is at risk, with 80 percent—including 72 percent of Republicans—saying preserving access is “deeply important.” 

During his White House campaign, Romney rebuffed the idea that a state would try to ban contraception: “I don’t know whether a state has a right to ban contraception. No state wants to.” Of course, at the time, it was clear that states did not have the right to ban contraception. But twelve years on, the truth is murkier. Without Roe, many GOP-controlled states are moving toward policies of fetal personhood, just as Alabama now considers embryos to be children. And this principle is being used to take aim not only at IVF, but also at emergency contraception and IUDs, which the anti-abortion movement claims are abortifacients: A new bill proposed in Oklahoma explicitly bans EC, and in Indiana, a bill to provide access to contraception excludes IUDs on the false premise that they cause abortions. Even the iconic and widely-prescribed pill is a target. After Elon Musk posted on X this month that hormonal birth control “makes you fat, doubles risk of depression & triples risk of suicide,” a GOP Michigan lawmaker responded that it should be banned. Last year, the conservative Heritage Foundation tweeted that the Republican Party should return the “consequentiality to sex,” with a goal of “ending recreational sex” by stopping the “senseless use of birth control pills.”

In 2012, it was the idea of fetal personhood embedded in Akin’s worldview that frightened voters. But in 2024, the fear comes from real-world ramifications of fetal personhood that are harming actual people. Alabamans have had their IVF treatments cancelled, and Republican Gov. Greg Abbott recently admitted to a CNN interviewer that Texans pursuing IVF might soon be in the same boat: “You raise fine questions that are complex, that I simply don’t know the answer to.” Indeed, last year, a lawyer currently employed by Trump, Jonathan Mitchell, filed a wrongful death suit in a Texas state court over an abortion—the same kind of case that led to Alabama’s new IVF ban.

In overturning Roe, Justice Samuel Alito wrote that he was returning the issue of abortion to the states. But Republicans in Washington—not to mention anti-abortion rights legal advocates—have national ambitions. Republicans in Congress have introduced the Life at Conception Act which, as the title suggests, defines life as beginning at conception. Trump has reportedly expressed support for a national abortion ban starting at 16 weeks. This month, the Supreme Court will consider whether to ban medication abortion, the most common form of abortion and the one used during the first trimester, nationwide. 

The 2012 election was more than just a prelude to today’s political reality; it can serve as a reminder that the current reality was always part of the plan.

Bring 10 feet of snow

Extraordinary storm could bring 10 feet of snow to California Sierra

By Amy Graff

An extraordinary winter storm is poised to sweep California’s Sierra Nevada from Thursday through Sunday. Meteorologists are predicting it will bring the heaviest snowfall so far this season, with up to 10 feet of snow possible at the highest elevations, according to the National Weather Service. 

Snowfall rates could reach up to 1 to 3 inches of snow per hour, bringing whiteout conditions with zero visibility across the Sierra.

“Snow amounts will be so much and difficult to accurately measure due to strong winds producing prolonged periods of near zero visibility, and blowing/drifting snow capable of burying vehicles and making it difficult to locate roads,” the weather service’s Reno office, which provides the forecast for the Lake Tahoe Basin, wrote in its forecast. “Even walking outside would not be advised during this storm as a person could quickly become lost or disoriented.”

The message meteorologists are trying to get out: Stay home.

Rich Bann, a forecaster with the weather service’s Weather Prediction Center, said the storm will dump snow across Washington and Oregon on Wednesday and Thursday before pushing into California on Thursday. He suspects the heaviest snowfall across the southern Cascades and the Sierra Nevada will occur on Friday into Saturday. 

“There will also be a lot of strong winds and that will cause a lot of drifting of snow, making travel difficult to impossible in the mountains,” Bann said. “It goes without saying as the storm continues inland, much colder air will sweep in by the weekend with temperatures 10 to 20 degrees below normal.”

Truckee, a Sierra town that’s a popular spot for skiers to stay overnight, is expected to see a low of 18 degrees on Friday night and 11 degrees on Saturday night. 

“A big deal” is what UCLA climate scientist Daniel Swain called the storm on social media. Swain, who has become a spokesperson for California weather through his Weather West blog, said the storm will bring snow whiplash, as the Sierra has seen a generally slow snow season. Fall was abnormally dry and winter has seen several warmer storms that brought more rain than snow. This storm is expected to bolster the snowpack. 

The weather service’s Sacramento office, which provides the forecast for people driving highways 50 and 80 between Tahoe and the Central Valley, sounded the alarm bells on Tuesday, warning people to stay home this weekend. 

“A MAJOR winter storm will bring EXTREMELY HEAVY mountain snow Thursday-Weekend,” the weather service posted on X, formerly Twitter. “Multiple FEET of snow are forecast with whiteout conditions and road closures likely. Heaviest snow above 3000 ft.”

Snowfall levels could reach as low as 2,000 feet by the weekend, warned the Sacramento office, which covers the southern Cascades and western side of the Northern Sierra, including the highly traveled Donner and Echo passes. Elevations above 5,000 feet could see 5 to 10 feet of snow Thursday into Sunday. 

The office said Friday will be the worst day for travel in its forecast region. 

The Tahoe Basin could see 3 to 4 feet in South Lake and Truckee, as well as 5 to 8 feet for elevations above 7,000 feet, according to the weather service’s Reno office.

What I’m saying is obvious.......

McHenry’s ‘extreme candor’ on Johnson splits GOP

McHenry told POLITICO “what I’m saying is obvious to a majority of the House Republican Conference.”

By ELEANOR MUELLER, JASPER GOODMAN and ZACHARY WARMBRODT

Rep. Patrick McHenry is closing out two decades in Congress by returning to the bomb-throwing days of his youth. His new target is House Speaker Mike Johnson, and it’s starting to rattle fellow conservatives.

McHenry, the bow-tied North Carolina Republican who plans to retire at the end of this session, has been ratcheting up his criticism of Johnson in recent weeks over what he views as a serial mishandling of big issues before the House, including government funding, the border and Ukraine aid.

The underlying tension is that McHenry believes Johnson is holding back activity in the House because of fears that he’ll suffer the same fate as his predecessor, Kevin McCarthy. McHenry told reporters last month that under Johnson’s leadership “we’ve yet to actually fulfill and execute policy.” He went further in a CBS News interview last week, warning of a “50-50” chance of a shutdown and calling it a “preventable disaster.”

One banking lobbyist granted anonymity to speak candidly said McHenry “speaks for what I would call the leadership class of the conference.”

“Patrick uses the ‘Shawshank Redemption’ metaphor,” the person said. “Andy Dufresne has to crawl three miles through a pipe full of human shit to go and reach freedom. And Patrick’s like, ‘Well, you can crawl slowly, or you can crawl quickly.’ … The analogy is supposed to be like, just make a decision.”

McHenry’s public critique of Johnson and the path that led him here is an illustration of the extent to which the House GOP has been turned upside down during his tenure. The 48-year-old lawmaker was once a self-described “bomb-thrower” — also referred to by others as the “the GOP’s attack dog-in-training” — but then took on the mantle as an aspiring deal-maker and McCarthy fixer before finding himself on the outside again in the Johnson era.

“You’re getting extreme candor from Patrick based upon his 20 years of work on the Hill,” said Rep. Garret Graves (R-La.), another McCarthy ally, in an interview. “Patrick’s candor is not just motivated by the fact that he’s leaving. But I think it’s motivated by an extraordinary amount of frustration that he feels.”

Some House and Senate Republicans say it’s not helpful, but McHenry told POLITICO on Thursday that he’s voicing concerns shared by others in his party.

“I’ve been around leadership decisions for quite a while,” he said. “I’ve never been bashful about sharing my views, either in the room or outside the room. And what I’m saying is obvious to a majority of the House Republican Conference.”

As he picks a public fight with leadership, some fellow Republicans and K Street lobbyists are questioning whether McHenry is sacrificing a shot at advancing legislative priorities he has as Financial Services chairman. GOP allies are coming to his defense.

“That’s just Patrick McHenry being Patrick McHenry,” Sen. Thom Tillis (R-N.C.) said. “He’s willing to speak out. That’s good leadership.”

Others are less admiring. Sen. J.D. Vance (R-Ohio) said, “if you want to criticize leadership in your own chamber, you should stick around and actually fight for the future.” Johnson’s office did not respond to requests for comment.

“I don’t think that’s constructive,” House Foreign Affairs Chair Michael McCaul (R-Texas) said of McHenry’s approach. “[Johnson’s] in an extremely difficult position with the motion to vacate over his head and a very difficult process to go through. … We can’t afford a vacant chair again. We gotta solidify around our leader and try to do something constructive.”

It’s been a brutal ride for McHenry. He said he felt “pure anger” in the moments after McCarthy was deposed. He was left to serve as acting speaker for three weeks as Republicans struggled to coalesce around new leadership. Once Johnson got the job, McHenry found himself on the periphery, and he’s grown increasingly frustrated.

“He’s watching as people that are out there under the banner of being conservatives … [are] actually forcing decisions that are resulting in higher spending and really playing into the White House’s hands,” Graves said.

McHenry told reporters last month that “many House Republicans that took out McCarthy recognize that we’re in a much worse public policy position now because of this.” He slammed colleagues for becoming “enamored with all this other bullshit.”

Rep. Andy Barr (R-Ky.), one of McHenry’s top deputies at House Financial Services and a potential successor at the committee, said he has confidence in Johnson but that “Patrick is one of those voices who should be listened to because he’s got a perspective.”

“I don’t think it’s destructive,” said Rep. Dan Meuser (R-Pa.), who also serves on Financial Services. “I think it’s truly intended to help. And if he wants to voice that, I think it’s fine. Being speaker right now is a tough job for Mike Johnson. Because I don’t have that level of experience at all, I try to be constructive with him privately. But I think Patrick feels it could probably be more effective doing it in the manner he’s doing it.”

Asked whether it’s more effective to speak out publicly versus privately, McHenry told POLITICO “you take the venues you’re given.” He commended Johnson for passing a stop-gap funding bill Thursday and “dealing with the reality of the situation.”

“I’m doing what I think is the responsibility of any leader in this place, which is to try to make things better,” McHenry said. “I’m making my point of view clear. And I think there are other members that have larger concerns that don’t want to do that, and that’s OK.”

Call out the Fatso...

Mike Johnson’s plan for getting the House in line: Deploy Trump

The speaker met with the former president earlier this month, making a seemingly successful pitch for how to handle upcoming primaries.

By OLIVIA BEAVERS and ALLY MUTNICK

Speaker Mike Johnson is eager to escape the chaos of a two-seat House majority. And he’s leaning on Donald Trump for help.

During a February meeting with the former president at Mar-a-Lago, Johnson and his House GOP campaigns chief briefed Trump on several upcoming primary races, making the case that certain extreme candidates could blow the party’s chances in battleground districts with primaries this month.

Johnson’s requests included seeking the president’s help neutralizing the controversial J.R. Majewski, who has roiled the GOP primary for a must-win Ohio swing seat. The House GOP leaders also inquired if Trump could endorse other candidates, including Rep. Mike Bost (R-Ill.), and updated him on their preferences in key upcoming primaries in California and North Carolina.

Trump was generally receptive to their requests, according to three people familiar with the meeting who were granted anonymity to speak candidly about it. Given Majewski’s strong MAGA lean and Rep. Matt Gaetz’s (R-Fla.) support for Bost’s opponent, it was hardly a given. Overall, the meeting signaled that Johnson has developed a strategic partnership with the former president, who is again the de facto chief of the Republican Party.

Since that meeting, Majewski has indicated he might drop out. And the former president did endorse Bost a day later, though the Republican lawmaker says talks with Trump about an endorsement preceded the meeting with the speaker.

Johnson’s ability to both effectively manage the House and stay on as speaker is heavily linked to whether he can expand the GOP’s paltry majority. He has to protect well-liked incumbents like Bost and avoid candidates like Majewski who risk blowing Republicans’ chances in swing seats next fall.

While the two talk regularly, Johnson will also have to be careful to avoid alienating the ex-president, whose off-the-cuff style could limit the speaker’s room to maneuver on matters of government spending, Ukraine aid and border security.

Though some argue the speaker’s interest in winning more seats serves Trump as well, assuming he wins in November.

“The former president — hopefully the next president — is smart enough to know that he needs people here to keep the majority to hand him exactly what he asks of them,” Bost said of Trump in an interview.

Johnson and Rep. Richard Hudson (R-N.C.), chair of the National Republican Congressional Committee, made a particularly strong case against Majewski in the Mar-a-Lago meeting, according to the three people, who said they argued he wasn’t a serious candidate and would not survive a general election.

One example they used: Majewski’s recent controversial remarks on a podcast where he argued that Special Olympics athletes with mental disabilities, no matter how they ultimately perform, are still “retarded.”

“[They] talked about Ohio-9 and what a mess it was. And that Majewski can’t win,” said one of the people with knowledge of the closed-door discussion.

Majewski previously told POLITICO that he has been in contact with Trump’s team amid the push for him to drop out. And while Majewski considered the possibility of exiting the race against Democratic Rep. Marcy Kaptur, the involvement of Trump and his team does not yet appear to have worked: Majewski decided against that idea, tweeting in a statement Wednesday morning that he will not “ cower to corruption” of the establishment.

But people who have spoken to him say that Majewski has indicated that he may still drop out of the race despite his public remarks. A spokesperson for Majewski reiterated Thursday that he has no plans to.

Beyond Ohio, Johnson also made a case for Trump to help Republicans hold onto the seat occupied by Bost, who is facing a far-right primary challenger. The Illinois Republican has a March 19 primary against Darren Bailey, a failed 2022 gubernatorial candidate who has advocated for Chicago to be excised from the state and once compared an opponent to Satan.

“We talked about Bost. He has always been a Trump supporter, and he agreed to endorse him, but I haven’t spoken to him in detail about a lot of the other races,” Johnson told POLITICO Thursday.

Bost, the first House committee chair to back Trump’s reelection bid, described himself as a “governing conservative.”

“I’m not somebody who wants to come here and blow it up,” he said.

Bost and Majewski won’t know their fates until their respective primaries in late March. But other contests are slated to begin in just a few days, winnowing large fields in California, North Carolina and Texas.

That includes the district of Rep. David Valadao (R-Calif.), who is facing a pro-Trump challenger. If that candidate boxes Valadao out of the jungle primary, which advances the top two vote-getters regardless of party, it would severely complicate the GOP’s ability to hold on to the Democratic-leaning seat.

And Trump could harbor a grudge against Valadao, one of the two remaining House Republicans who voted to impeach the ex-president over the Capitol attack on Jan. 6, 2021. The other eight were voted out or opted to retire after crossing their party’s leader.

Trump was briefed on that race and Valadao’s uncanny ability to hold a seat in tough, Biden-friendly territory, according to two of the people familiar with the meeting.

Right by that district, in the race for Kevin McCarthy’s old seat, Johnson expressed a preference for California state Assemblymember Vince Fong, according to two people familiar with the meeting, who was also McCarthy’s preferred successor. Trump endorsed him soon after.

A contested GOP primary for a North Carolina swing seat has also been a source of anxiety for party leaders. Johnson-aligned groups are backing retired Army Col. Laurie Buckhout and vociferously working to block the candidacy of Sandy Smith.

Smith, the 2022 nominee for the seat, has faced allegations of domestic abuse; her ex-husband claims she tried to run him over with a car. She denies the allegations.

The GOP leaders went over Smith’s liabilities with the former president. The Congressional Leadership Fund, the largest House GOP super PAC that has close ties to Johnson, has spent more than $200,000 on ads in that race on behalf of Buckhout.

While the NRCC remains neutral in open-seat GOP primaries, Johnson and other groups have still signaled their top picks. The Trump meeting simply took that practice a step further.

Which makes some in the House unhappy.

House Freedom Caucus Chair Rep. Bob Good (R-Va.), who backs Smith, took issue with the CLF spending in the race.

“I have great concerns about us playing in primaries, spending resources that ought to be reserved for the general election. These campaigns ought to rise and fall on their own merits,” Good said in an interview. “Resources are finite. And it’s sad and unfortunate those resources always seemed to be directed against a conservative in the race.”

Bluffing on nukes

Putin’s bluffing on nukes (for now), says top NATO official

“We do not see any imminent threat of Russia using these weapons,” said military alliance’s deputy secretary-general.

BY STUART LAU

NATO's No. 2 official said Russian President Vladimir Putin's nuclear threat is currently just "psychological intimidation."

Putin issued the warning Thursday as French President Emmanuel Macron stood by his message that the West could not rule out sending troops to help Ukraine fend off Putin's full-scale invasion. "This really threatens a conflict with nuclear weapons," Putin said.

NATO Deputy Secretary-General Mircea Geoană characterized Putin's nuclear saber-rattling as "a discourse that delves into the logic of psychological intimidation rather than real intentions," in an interview with Spanish newspaper El País published Friday.

He added, "We do not see any imminent threat of Russia using these weapons. But these statements are in themselves very dangerous, because they erode trust. Russia knows the consequences of taking such a step."

Geoană, who could step down later this year to run in the Romanian presidential election in September, also said NATO would "continue to make sure that we support Ukraine and avoid escalation with Russia."

On Macron's boots-on-the-ground proposal, he said: "We fully respect the right of our allies to bring new ideas to the table. But we at NATO have no intention or plans to deploy troops to Ukraine."

Geoană expressed hope that the alliance would remain strong even if NATO-skeptic Donald Trump wins the U.S. presidency this November. "Both Republicans and Democrats understand all too well the very complicated competition with China, Russia, Iran and North Korea. The U.S. will need all its allies in Europe and the rest of the world," said Geoană.

Testy interview

In testy interview with GOP, Hunter Biden says father was not involved in business deals

President Joe Biden's son fielded questions behind closed doors for several hours.

JORDAIN CARNEY

Hunter Biden repeatedly told House investigators behind closed doors that his father was not involved in his business deals as part of an hours-long and, at times, contentious interview.

Republicans on the House Judiciary and Oversight committees released the nearly 230-page transcript on Thursday, about 24 hours after they concluded their private deposition that is part of a sweeping impeachment inquiry into President Joe Biden. Much of the GOP investigation has focused on the business deals of Joe Biden’s family members, as lawmakers have struggled to find a smoking gun linking official actions he took as president or vice president to those financial agreements.

Hunter Biden — in a theme he previewed in a defiant opening statement on Wednesday morning — told lawmakers and congressional aides that his father had no involvement in his business arrangements as he fielded questions on years-old financial deals and his own well-publicized struggle with addiction. Republicans have said they now want to have a public hearing with Hunter Biden — something neither he nor his legal team has committed to this week, after pushing for one last year before they agreed to the private deposition.

“All I know is this: My father was never involved in any of my business, ever. Never received a cent from anybody or never benefited in any way. Never took any actions on behalf in any way. And I can absolutely, 100 percent state, that is not just in my case but in every family member's case,” Hunter Biden told lawmakers, according to the transcript.

Republicans largely used the closed-door interview to press Hunter Biden on his business deals with companies in China and Ukraine, as well as testimony from previous business associates that he would put his father on speakerphone or that Joe Biden dropped by dinners or lunches. Those same associates have testified that business was not discussed.

Hunter Biden didn’t deny that he put his father on speakerphone when at dinner with business associates, saying that he always answers when his dad calls and quipping to investigators: “Over the course of the last 30 years when speakerphone was invented on a cell phone? I’m certain my dad has called me.”

He also confirmed that he would invite his father to stop by for lunch or dinners and didn’t contest testimony from former business associate Rob Walker that Joe Biden had stopped by a lunch in 2017, but tried to draw a bright line between his father briefly meeting someone and having a meeting with them. Walker previously told investigators that Joe Biden wasn’t involved in their business deals and characterized his appearance at the lunch as exchanging pleasantries.

“He was not involved with any business activity. Would you call it involvement if my dad was in New York City at the same time I was in New York City and I was having lunch with some of my business associates, and I said, ‘Hey, dad, come by for lunch?’” Hunter Biden asked congressional investigators.

Hunter Biden also addressed a 2017 WhatsApp message where he claimed to be with his father. He told lawmakers that that his father was not sitting next to him, that he had sent the message to the wrong person and that the IRS agents who had handed over the message had conflated it and a separate message from a person with the same last name.

“Addiction is not an excuse, but I can tell you this: I am more embarrassed of this text message, if it actually did come from me, than any text message I've ever sent. The fact of the matter is, is that there's no other text message that you have in which I say anything remotely to this. And I was out of my mind,” he said.

The hours-long interview at times turned contentious, as Republicans pressed Hunter Biden on details, including dates, of his struggle with addiction.

When Rep. Matt Gaetz (R-Fla.), as part of a lengthy back-and-forth over addiction, asked him if he was on drugs while serving on the board of Burisma, Biden shot back: “Mr. Gaetz, look me in the eye. You really think that's appropriate to ask me?”

Government shutdown patch

Senate sends government shutdown patch to Biden’s desk

Congress now has another week to pass six of the dozen government spending bills. The other half expire on March 22.

By CAITLIN EMMA and JENNIFER SCHOLTES

The Senate approved a stopgap funding bill Thursday night for President Joe Biden’s signature, thwarting a partial government shutdown on Saturday and buying more time to finalize half a dozen spending bills that congressional leaders aim to pass next week.

Congress now officially has until March 8 to clear that initial six-bill bundle, which leaders struck a deal on earlier this week. But they're still working on an agreement to fund the rest of the government, including the military and some of the biggest domestic programs, before a second deadline on March 22. The upper chamber cleared the measure in a 77-13 vote, following votes on four Republican amendments that were defeated on the floor.

Senate Appropriations Chair Patty Murray (D-Wash.) said on the floor Thursday night that leaders plan to release bill text of the six finalized bills "in the coming days" to give lawmakers time to review them before a vote next week. "We are genuinely close. And if bipartisan cooperation prevails, I am very confident we can, at long last — at long last — wrap up our FY24 bills," she said. "It is full speed ahead."

Appropriators are optimistic that this latest stopgap — the fourth enacted by Congress this fiscal year alone — will finally deliver enough time to wrap up funding negotiations after a particularly chaotic cycle largely derailed by House Republican infighting. If congressional leaders can successfully pass the six bills next week to fund the departments of Agriculture, Energy, Veterans’ Affairs and Transportation, they’ll face an even bigger test in trying to strike a compromise on the remaining six bills that fund the rest of the federal government.

“I think people are optimistic right now. This has been a slog. It has kind of worn people down a little bit,” said Rep. Steve Womack (R-Ark.), a senior appropriator. “The first six are, I mean, they’re not easy by any means, but they’re easier than what we’re going to deal with by the 22nd.”

Under the deal to fast-track passage of the stopgap, Senate leaders agreed to a vote by the end of next week on a bill sponsored by Sens. Josh Hawley (R-Mo.) and Ben Ray Luján (D-N.M.) that would compensate people diagnosed with cancer after being exposed to nuclear waste stored as a byproduct of the top-secret program to make an atomic bomb during World War II.

Before passage, the chamber rejected three different proposals from Republican Sens. Roger Marshall of Kansas, Mike Lee of Utah and Ted Cruz of Texas that would fund federal agencies at current levels through the end of the fiscal year, triggering an estimated $73 billion in cuts to non-defense programs and forgoing billions of dollars in agreed-upon funding for the Pentagon. Marshall's plan also included emergency aid to Israel, and Cruz's proposal included H.R. 2, the House-passed border security bill.

The Senate's top Republican appropriator, Maine Sen. Susan Collins, argued against the yearlong stopgaps her GOP colleagues proposed, saying that they would "lock in dangerously inadequate funding levels" for the Pentagon, while cutting other "vital" programs and resulting in budgets that are "misaligned" with current military needs.

The chamber also voted 37-53 to defeat an amendment from Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) that would prevent the Federal Reserve from buying the debt of states.

Earlier Thursday, the House passed the stopgap in a 320-99 vote. Speaker Mike Johnson secured support from a majority of his conference, despite simmering conservative discontent.

While congressional leaders plan to release text for the first tranche of bills this weekend, the second tranche of those fiscal 2024 spending measures are in various states of completion, according to Collins, the top Republican appropriator in the Senate. The funding bill for the military, for example, is in pretty good shape, Collins said. Measures that would fund the Department of Homeland Security, or the departments of Labor, Health and Human Services and Education, still have a ways to go, according to appropriators.

Republicans and Democrats are still sparring over how to split up a limited pot of money across a variety of tricky issues in the DHS budget, including salaries, detention beds, processing and asylum policies, technology and other border security efforts.

Rep. Robert Aderholt (R-Ala.), who oversees the massive Labor-HHS-Education measure, said appropriators are still working toward an agreement on the funding details of his bill. Policy riders are sure to snag endgame negotiations as lawmakers inch closer to their new deadline of March 22, he said.

The first slate of bills set to lapse at the end of next week cover funding for the EPA and the Department of Energy, as well as federal transportation, housing and science programs, plus military construction and water projects. Those measures also fund the departments of Justice, Veterans Affairs, Agriculture, Commerce and Interior, along with the FDA and urban development projects.

Mounting legal debts.

Can the RNC bail out Trump’s legal bills? Probably not.

Even if Trump reshapes the Republican National Committee, campaign-finance laws limit how much the party can help pay his mounting legal debts.

By ERICA ORDEN

Donald Trump’s dizzying legal bills have sparked a debate within his party: Should the Republican National Committee help bail him out?

Trump’s daughter-in-law Lara Trump, whom the former president has endorsed to be the RNC’s new co-chair, floated the idea last week — and was met with quick opposition from other party insiders.

But even if the party wanted to cut Trump a check, it would run into both practical and legal problems: The RNC is strapped for cash, and campaign-finance laws restrict how it can spend the money it does have.

“I don’t think that the drafters of the Federal Election Campaign Act envisioned a situation where a national party committee might be asked to pay hundreds of millions of dollars to satisfy a candidate’s legal debts,” Jessica Levinson, a law professor at Loyola Marymount University, wrote in an email.

Yet that is the magnitude of debt that Trump is facing. His bills fall into two buckets: the legal fees he owes his lawyers and the civil judgments that courts have ordered him to pay. His judgments alone now total over $500 million after massive verdicts in a business fraud case brought by the New York attorney general and a defamation case brought by the writer E. Jean Carroll.

Trump has relied heavily on his political operation, especially his leadership PAC, Save America, to fund his legal defense — to the tune of over $50 million just last year — and he’s sure to continue doing so. Individuals can donate up to $5,000 a year to a leadership PAC — but the donation limit is more than eight times that, $41,300, to a national party committee like the RNC.

But federal law limits the RNC’s ability to chip in, campaign-finance experts say.

And the party probably can’t afford to make a meaningful dent in Trump’s bills anyway. The RNC’s cash on hand at the end of January was $8.7 million, a tiny fraction of Trump’s debts.

None of that has stopped Republicans from mulling the issue.

Lara Trump told reporters she believes Republicans have “a big interest” in the party paying her father-in-law’s legal bills, though she added that she isn’t familiar with the legal restrictions on doing so.

Henry Barbour, a Mississippi committee member, is trying to quash the idea. He introduced a pair of draft resolutions declaring that “spending any RNC financial resources for any candidate’s personal, business, or political legal expenses, not related to the 2024 election cycle, does not serve the RNC’s primary mission of helping to elect our candidates in 2024.”

Chris LaCivita, a senior adviser to Trump’s campaign whom Trump has endorsed for chief operating officer of the RNC, has repeatedly said the committee won’t pay Trump’s legal bills.

Fees for lawyers

The RNC does have a history of helping Trump pay his lawyers: The committee spent nearly $2 million on two law firms working on Trump cases in 2021 and 2022.

But Trump was not an official candidate for office at that time.

Under the Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United ruling, parties cannot use money they raised from corporations or labor unions to pay the legal bills of declared candidates, said Samuel Issacharoff, a constitutional law professor at NYU Law School.

So once Trump launched his campaign to return to the White House, the RNC stopped paying his lawyers’ fees.

“We cannot pay legal bills for any candidate that’s announced,” Ronna McDaniel, the outgoing RNC chairwoman, said in 2022, before Trump announced his bid to return to the White House.

Hefty civil judgments

Trump signaled this week that he does not have enough cash to cover the full amount of his civil judgments. But he likely cannot count on the RNC to help him on that front, either.

It would be illegal for a political party to pay a legal judgment arising from someone’s personal conduct (as opposed to a judgment tied to the person’s conduct as an officeholder or candidate), according to legal experts.

Issacharoff said the judgments against Trump in both the civil fraud trial and the Carroll trial fall into the “personal conduct” category.

Ciara Torres-Spelliscy, a professor who specializes in election law at Stetson University law school, said there would be a “high risk” of the RNC violating campaign finance laws if it were to pay the civil fraud judgment because that case concerned only Trump’s family business.

“That cost was generated by his running the Trump Org fraudulently,” she wrote in an email. “That has nothing to do with him being a candidate or an office holder.”

And even setting the law aside, there is the matter of whether the party can afford his bills.

Lara Trump has set a goal of raising $500 million, and even if it were successful in doing so, directing some of all of those funds toward the former president would quickly diminish the party’s ability to pay for anything else, including the presidential election or congressional races.

Not Funny