A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



March 03, 2023

Rail safety bill... Again...

Biden hails bipartisan rail safety bill

The Railway Safety Act was introduced by Ohio Sens. Sherrod Brown and J.D. Vance along with four other senators.

By KELLY GARRITY

President Joe Biden on Thursday praised bipartisan legislation that would strengthen safety rules governing railroads, following the fiery Ohio train derailment that left residents concerned about the air and water quality in the town of East Palestine.

The legislation was introduced by Ohio Sens. Sherrod Brown, a Democrat, and J.D. Vance, a Republican, and four other senators Wednesday. The Railway Safety Act would bolster a slew of railroad safety measures including raising fines for safety infractions, increasing inspections and imposing new requirements for trains carrying toxic or hazardous materials.

“I applaud the bipartisan group of senators for proposing rail safety legislation that provides many of the solutions that my administration has been calling for,” Biden said in a statement Thursday. “This legislation provides us with tools to hold companies accountable to prevent terrible tragedies like the Norfolk Southern derailment in East Palestine and to make those communities whole.”

Republicans have been critical of the White House’s response to the derailment, accusing the administration of moving too slowly. But the White House has repeatedly pushed back, noting that federal officials were at the site hours after the crash. Biden, who has been criticized for having yet to visit East Palestine, said on Thursday that he planned to travel there “at some point.”

“I’ve spoken with every official in Ohio, Democrat and Republican, on a continuous basis, as in Pennsylvania. I laid out a little bit in there what I think the answers are, and we put it together. And we will be implementing an awful lot to the legislation here. And I will be out there at some point,” the president told reporters.

March 02, 2023

Never a real news network

Fox News was never a real news network

Opinion by David Zurawik

Since Fox Chairman Rupert Murdoch’s deposition in the Dominion Voting Systems lawsuit was recently made public, there has been an avalanche of speculation about the effect his words will have on the network. Murdoch acknowledged that some Fox News hosts – Sean Hannity, Jeanine Pirro, Maria Bartiromo and former host Lou Dobbs – endorsed lies that the 2020 presidential election was stolen; and that he gave Jared Kushner confidential information about President Joe Biden’s ads and debate strategy in 2020.

Murdoch’s deposition clearly shows the hypocrisy, dishonesty and lack of anything resembling journalistic ethics at the top and in front of the camera at Fox News. And some viewers will surely be turned off by the network’s craven disregard for the truth. But has its credibility really been damaged beyond repair?

Hardly. For one thing, Fox was never a news network to begin with. Whereas a news network is a platform built on the premise that one of its first obligations is providing citizens with vetted information that they can use to be free and self-governing, Fox was founded in 1996 as a political platform and run by Roger Ailes, a political operative.

Ailes, a key member of the media team that helped put Richard Nixon in the White House in 1968, saw it as an outlet that could be used to promulgate and amplify a conservative viewpoint. From day one, it was about propaganda – not information. It was created as a counterbalance to what Ailes saw as a liberal bias in network TV, public radio and the top newspapers in the country. He cleverly referred to the channel as news, but it was always about politics and ideology first.

As conservative politics and the Republican Party have moved further to the right in the last decade, so has Fox, which came to understand it could make piles of money giving that viewing and voting public what it wants. It’s addicted to that money now, and there is no room for integrity – if there ever was any at Fox.

Now, it’s all about right-wing politics (the hotter and nastier, the better) and money. And not necessarily in that order, as Murdoch suggested in his description of why he allowed Mike Lindell, CEO of MyPillow, to espouse unfounded election conspiracies on Fox:

“It is not red or blue, it is green,” Murdoch said, according to the court documents. “The man is on every night. Pays us a lot of money … “

Think of how hard its primetime stars like Tucker Carlson were flogging anti-Covid-vaccine rhetoric during the pandemic, adding to the risk of death for some of the channel’s most vulnerable viewers. If you are willing to play fast and loose with the truth when it could mean life or death for viewers, how hard is it to lie to them about the results of an election? Why should anyone who had been paying attention to Covid-19 programming at Fox be surprised by the level of dishonesty the Dominion depositions revealed?

Today, Fox is further away from the news part of its name than ever. It still presents itself as a news channel in name using the tropes of anchor desks, correspondents and panels of guests.

But it’s become so much deeper culturally. Fox News is a world view, a lifestyle, a way of seeing the world, a 24/7 warm bath of false nostalgia and aggrievement primarily for older adults – some of whom are likely feeling left behind or threatened by the changes in American life. Fox tells them that if they are struggling, it is not their fault. The Democrats in Washington are giving the country away to immigrants and minorities – and the money is coming out of the viewers’ pockets, as illogical and false as that is.

If you look rationally at the potential effect of Murdoch’s admission, you might think some audience members would be so angry they might tune out the channel forever.

But that would be rational, and I believe that some of our most important relationships with media are anything but rational. They are visceral and often rooted in profound psychological and emotional needs, as anthropologist John L. Caughey chronicled in his groundbreaking book, “Imaginary Social Worlds: A Cultural Approach.”

I have relatives who turn on Fox News in the morning when they get up and turn it off when they go to bed at night.

As shocking and even disgusting as some of us in the mainstream media find Murdoch’s deposition, my relatives won’t be changing their viewing habits because of it. And I suspect most other viewers who have let Fox News that far into their lives won’t be either.

Major victory for insulin....

The campaign to make insulin less expensive just scored a major victory

The price of insulin has skyrocketed, but now one major drug company will limit patients’ costs.

By Dylan Scott

Drug companies are coming under immense pressure over prescription drug prices, particularly essential medicines like insulin — and they are starting to respond more aggressively.

On Wednesday, Eli Lilly, one of the three major US manufacturers of insulin, announced it would cap the out-of-pocket cost for virtually all customers at $35 per month. People who have private insurance will automatically have their out-of-pocket costs limited to $35 per month. People who are uninsured will need to download a savings card created by the company in order to receive the same benefit. The move is an expansion of a previous program that provided a $35 out-of-pocket maximum to only certain eligible patients.

The $35 monthly limit will match the provision passed by Congress in the Inflation Reduction Act that caps the out-of-pocket costs for an insulin prescription for people on Medicare to $35 per month. Democrats in Congress had originally wanted to extend that cap to other forms of insurance as well, but they could not under the special legislative process they used to avoid a Republican filibuster, the rules of which limit their ability to regulate the private sector. Now one manufacturer is taking the step voluntarily.

Eli Lilly also announced it was reducing the list price of its non-branded insulin to $25 per month, and cutting the list price of its brand-name and most commonly prescribed insulin, Humalog, by 70 percent by the end of 2023. (The list price of a 10 milliliter vial is currently about $275.) Many people do not currently pay the list price, but people who are uninsured or who have a high-deductible health plan can have particularly high out-of-pocket costs because of how high the list prices are set.

Drugmakers are under a lot of pressure on insulin costs — and it seems to be working

The company’s move comes amid a sustained storm of scrutiny and hints of dramatic actions by the government to try to rein in costs for insulin. More than 8 million Americans with diabetes rely on insulin; for people with Type 1 diabetes, it is essential, and it becomes a necessity for some people with Type 2 diabetes as well. Yet recent surveys have found that one in six people who use insulin say they ration the drug because of the cost.

That’s because the price of some insulin has grown by 1,000 percent over the past 20 years, far outpacing inflation. Though insulin generally costs less than $10 per dose to produce, some versions of the drug currently have a list price above $200. In the US, a warped market has allowed three companies to dominate the insulin business: Sanofi, Novo Nordisk, and Eli Lilly.

Though the original discovers of insulin sold its patent for $1 a century ago, private companies soon entered the market for this new miracle drug. They developed important improvements, making different versions of the drug that last longer or act quickly in order to meet a patient’s needs. But those innovations have also served to justify price increases and patent protections that have driven the drug’s costs skyward in recent decades, even as the medicine at its heart remains fundamentally the same.

Patients and the public at large are furious, and the companies have also had some embarrassing public episodes — like a case of Twitter impersonation proclaiming free insulin that briefly tanked Eli Lilly stocks and an acknowledgement by its CEO that insulin should “probably” be cheaper — that have only heightened the crisis.

One in 10 Americans has diabetes. The insulin cost crisis seems to have struck the general public as too absurd even for America’s dysfunctional health care system. The sheer number of people potentially affected or who know someone who could be affected, insulin’s life-saving properties for the people who depend on it, and the gross disparity between the cost to produce it and the price these companies charge for it has created sustained pressure for the government to act. Voters of both parties say in overwhelming numbers that they want lawmakers to do something about the cost of insulin and on drug prices more broadly.

Congress took a noteworthy step with the $35 monthly cap for Medicare in the IRA. But states have been moving on even grander plans.

California has authorized $100 million for a public insulin project, putting real money behind the idea of the government production of essential medications like insulin. In the short term, the state plans to partner with an existing enterprise — such as CivicaRx, a nonprofit conglomerate of hospital systems developing cheap generic drugs — to get its hands on a cheaper insulin supply sooner. But in the long term, the idea is to build a publicly owned factory, staffed by civil workers, which would produce its own generic insulin and sell it at roughly the price of the drug’s production. There will likely be legal, regulatory, and scientific obstacles to achieving that goal, but that is the plan.

Other states, such as Washington and Maine, have signaled an interest in similar projects. Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer, with a freshly won Democratic majority in the legislature, recently called for that state to invest $150 million to eventually produce its own insulin.

Advocates advising California’s effort told me that the state’s plan could succeed one of two ways: Either the state builds its own factory and sells cheap insulin, or the current manufacturers decide to drop their own prices in response. Because California also buys a lot of insulin through its Medicaid program (with 15 million enrollees, more than the entire population of most states) and state employee health plan, it wins either way.

“If we can drop the cost of insulin, we don’t have to make money on selling it,” Anthony Wright, executive director of Health Access California, a health care consumer advocacy group, told me. “We get the savings as a purchaser.”

A possible sign that drugmakers are feeling that pressure came on Wednesday, with Eli Lilly’s announcement: Its $35 cap would be effective immediately.

Free lunch

America’s school lunch crisis

A federal program allowed schools to provide free lunch to all children. Why did it have to end?

By Anna North

In 2020, when schools across the country closed to slow the spread of Covid-19, federal lawmakers did something unprecedented: They decided to pay for free lunch for every public school student in America, every day, no questions asked. Millions of children rely on free or reduced price meals at school, and policymakers knew that need would only grow as families faced a devastating pandemic.

The effect of the free meals was dramatic. Parents, many of them facing layoffs, illness, and grief, no longer had to worry about the cost of lunch for their kids — which, at about $2.50 a meal, was a $50 monthly expense per child that stretched many families even in normal times. Instead, they could pick up a free, nutritious meal at their children’s school, or in some cases even have it delivered by school bus. As a result, food insecurity in at-risk households with children declined by about 7 percentage points between the beginning of the pandemic and summer 2021.

Schools, meanwhile, were able to skip the time-consuming paperwork necessary prior to the pandemic to determine which students were eligible for federally subsidized meals. And kids no longer faced lunch “debt” — a running tally kept by schools when students ate but didn’t pay — that too often resulted in humiliation and anxiety for hungry children. Such debts were widespread before the pandemic because the threshold for free lunch was set at a household income of $33,475 for a family of four, leaving out many families who couldn’t afford the meals but made too much to qualify for subsidies. Students in lunch debt could be subjected to humiliating treatment, anything from a stamp on the hand branding them as indebted to having their lunch thrown away by cafeteria workers, according to the Washington Post.

The shift to universal free lunch “worked beautifully,” said Diane Pratt-Heavner, director of media relations for the School Nutrition Association, which represents school food workers. “There were just tremendous benefits.”

Then it ended.

The federal waiver program, which cost about $11 billion per school year, expired last fall, forcing school districts to start charging for lunch again just as inflation was decimating family food budgets.

As some families struggled to add another daily expense, districts were faced with a choice: Let kids go hungry, or go into debt themselves, potentially sacrificing other necessities from computers to teacher pay. In a November 2022 survey by the School Nutrition Association, 96.3 percent of districts reported that the end of federal waivers have led to an increase in unpaid debt. At East Hampton Public Schools in central Connecticut, for example, debt is going up by $500 every week. At one district, the Washington Post reported, debt for the school year has already reached $1.7 million.

“We had a sixth-grader crying in line, because she had heard her parents talking the night before about how they didn’t have money for lunch,” said Jennifer Bove, director of food and nutrition services for the East Hampton district. Another student asked his teacher if he could borrow money for lunch. “I almost quit my job that first day,” Bove said. “It was so awful.”

Children and families are generally on their own in America when it comes to policies that would help them lead healthy, thriving lives. But the beginning of the pandemic was a time of unusually broad support for child-friendly programs, including the expanded child tax credit, which kept nearly 4 million children out of poverty and helped countless families afford necessities like utilities and food. After that program expired at the end of 2021, child poverty increased 41 percent. Families are now facing the same kind of whiplash with the expiration of federal waivers for school lunch, as a program many had come to depend on is suddenly ripped out from under them.

But there’s a simple fix, education and nutrition experts agree: make universal free school lunch permanent. Making sure kids are fed is like making sure they have textbooks to learn from, Pratt-Heavner said: “It just makes sense.” But so far, there’s no momentum in Congress to bring the free meals back, leaving families and schools scrambling, and kids, in some places, struggling to learn.

“If a child is hungry,” Bove said, “that is all they think about all day.”

School lunch in America dates back to the late 19th century, when the passage of compulsory education laws and child-labor bans led to more kids in school for more hours per day than ever before, according to A.R. Ruis, a research scientist at the Wisconsin Center for Education Research and the author of Eating to Learn, Learning to Eat: The Origins of School Lunch in the United States. Health screenings in schools gave rise to concerns about malnutrition, which in turn sparked privately funded school meal programs in many cities. The programs were popular, but most were wiped out by the Great Depression, at which point the federal government stepped in with emergency programs. Those programs were so popular that they eventually gave rise to the National School Lunch Act, passed in 1946.

The act created a three-tiered system: Children in poverty received a free lunch, children whose families were above the poverty line but still struggling economically got a price reduction, and everyone else paid full price. The cost of a full-price lunch was set by states and sometimes by districts: in 2014-2015, the last pre-pandemic school year for which data is available, the average was $2.42.

This system was “better than nothing,” Ruis said — millions of children in poverty received free lunch under the program, but it had problems. The income thresholds — set at 130 percent of the federal poverty line for a free lunch — were too low to help all families in need, especially in areas with a high cost of living. For example, “most families in New York are going to be struggling at 200 percent of the poverty line, 250 percent of the poverty line, 300 percent of the poverty line,” said Crystal FitzSimons, who leads work on school meal access at the nonprofit Food Research and Action Center.

News of lunch debt and “lunch-shaming” repeatedly went viral in the late 2010s, sometimes inspiring individuals to pay off the debt of entire schools. But this philanthropy didn’t solve the root problem: School lunches were unaffordable for too many families.

Meanwhile, lunch-shaming revealed another big problem with the three-tiered system: stigma.

When free lunch is only available to kids in poverty, those kids invariably feel singled out, even in the absence of overt lunch-shaming tactics. East Hampton schools don’t identify kids receiving free lunch in any way, Bove said, but “it doesn’t matter. They feel it. They feel that they are different.”

The result is often that kids who can’t afford lunch, especially older ones, just don’t eat lunch at all. “If all your friends are packing their lunch, you’re not going to go into the cafeteria and get your free meal,” Bove said. “You’re going to just sit hungry with them.”

In March 2020, however, everything about school lunch suddenly changed. Kids weren’t going to the cafeteria anymore, but “everyone was very aware of the millions of kids who rely on free and reduced price school meals,” FitzSimons said. In fact, there was more need than ever as the economy plunged sharply into a recession and food banks became overwhelmed. Schools needed to be able to give students meals quickly and without a lot of face-to-face interaction in a time when vaccines were not yet available. So Congress passed a series of waivers allowing schools to give a free meal to any student, without regard to their family income.

Besides helping families and relieving schools of the administrative burden of processing free lunch applications, the waivers were also a welcome change for cafeteria workers and other school staff. “People who work in schools are caregivers,” Ruis said. “They care about their kids, and they don’t want to be enforcing debt collection.”

The new system wasn’t perfect. Some districts offered food pickup only during very limited time windows, making it difficult for families to get meals, said GeDá Jones Herbert, education special counsel at the NAACP Legal Defense Fund. At least one district, in Leeds, Alabama, simply shut down its food distribution program when it became overwhelmed by the number of families who needed free meals. Such shutdowns and access barriers disproportionately impacted Black families, who were less likely to live near a meal distribution site.

In many cases, however, the Legal Defense Fund and other advocates were able to improve access — the Leeds district, for example, reinstated meal distribution after the group sued. And overall, experts say the federal waivers were a huge step in the right direction. They allowed school nutrition programs to “operate the way they always should,” FitzSimons said. “Kids are in school for six-and-a-half, seven hours a day. They need to have access to nutrition in order to learn and focus and concentrate.”

After several extensions, Congress allowed the waivers to lapse just as the 2022-23 school year was beginning. Districts notified families that they’d have to apply if they wanted their child to keep receiving free meals. In East Hampton, it didn’t go well. “I was getting calls constantly trying to figure out how to apply,” Bove said. And when the applications were in, those calls turned into questions about why they don’t qualify and why they no longer get free meals.

East Hampton never turns a child down for a meal, Bove said. But when they eat and don’t pay, they rack up debt — and often, they know it. One middle schooler, Bove said, asked the cafeteria cashier every day if his application for free lunch had gone through yet: “He was so worried about the debt.”

East Hampton is on pace to have $13,000 in lunch debt this year, up from a previous high of around $3,000. The problem is even worse now than before the pandemic “because people are so in need right now,” Bove said.

The district tries to collect the debt from parents, but often, that doesn’t work. “I know the families who have these large balances,” Bove said. “They’re not just choosing not to pay it; they cannot pay it.” So at the end of the year, the debt will have to come out of the district budget. That could mean putting off getting new Chromebooks for students, or not hiring a paraprofessional for one of the classrooms. “I don’t know where it comes from, because we’ve never had to deal with this before,” Bove said.

For many district officials and nutrition advocates, the success of the federal waivers and the mess that schools find themselves in now send a clear message that free meals should be permanent for all children. A bill introduced in 2019 by Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) and Rep. Ilhan Omar (D-MN) would do that, but it gained little traction at the time, and its prospects in the current Congress are slim. That leaves states and districts on their own to figure out how to feed kids.

Two states, California and Maine, have made universal free meals permanent, while several others are considering such a move. Meanwhile, a growing number of districts across the country are taking advantage of a provision in the 2010 Healthy, Hunger-Free Kids Act, signed by President Barack Obama, that allows schools and districts to offer free meals to all if a certain percentage of students are low-income.

This approach has shown big benefits for schools and districts that can meet the threshold. In New York City, for example, which began offering lunch free to all students in 2017, a recent report found that free meals made students feel safer at school, and improved their perceptions of bullying and fighting. “School cafeterias are particularly salient in shaping school climate,” said Emily Gutierrez, a research associate at the Urban Institute who wrote the report. And “providing universal free meals takes away any visible indicators of kids having less than someone else,” which in turn can reduce bullying. Other research in New York City found that the free meals improved math and reading test scores as well.

In the absence of federal action, though, these benefits are reserved for districts that can qualify — and those that can’t have to go it alone. For Bove, it makes no sense.

“If we don’t prioritize hungry children, I don’t know what we prioritize,” she said. “I don’t know what else is more important than that.”

The end of civilization...

How the Great Recession paved the way for influencers to inherit the earth

Are we all influencers now?

By Rebecca Jennings

It was when I was researching a story on micro-famous LinkedIn users that I realized there truly was no escape from the influencer industry. If business bros with corporate jobs in tech and finance — stable, high-paying careers with cushy benefits! — felt the need to supplement their status (and possibly their income) by becoming influencers, what hope was there for the rest of us?

In truth, I should have realized this a long time ago. In an increasingly unpredictable economy, one with massive wealth disparity and mass layoffs, where landing a solid career path feels out of reach for so many, of course the industry that promises self-employment and creative freedom sounds like the best possible option.

The first inkling that the influencer industry would become a very big deal occurred during a different period of economic precarity. In her new book, The Influencer Industry: The Quest for Authenticity on Social Media, Emily Hund, a research affiliate at the Center on Digital Culture and Society at the University of Pennsylvania’s Annenberg School for Communication, analyzes how in the wake of the Great Recession starting in late 2007, individual bloggers charted a new path to financial and social fulfillment, and launched an entirely new cottage industry that would threaten the institutions it circumvented.

“While individual participants looked for a route to autonomy, stability, and professional fulfillment that seemed impossible elsewhere, they ended up creating a value system that advanced the erosion of boundaries between individuals’ inner lives and commercialism, asking us to view ourselves as products perpetually ready for market, our relationships as monetizable, and our daily activities as potential shopping experiences,” Hund writes. “Influencers are neither ‘a flash in the pan’ nor ‘a bubble about to burst,’ but indicators of a paradigm shift in the way we think about each other and ourselves.”

I spoke to Hund about her book, where we discussed the past, present, and future of this paradigm shift and its effects on what we buy, post, and think. The following interview has been edited and condensed.

What happened in the 2000s that created a perfect storm for the rise of the influencer industry?

The economic crisis was the last straw that pushed this industry forward. Before that, we had lots of other factors that had been bubbling for a long time: in the US, the valorization of entrepreneurialism and self-branding, especially since the 1980s. We love public figures who we think are just being themselves and are still successful at whatever they do.

Then there was software that made it really easy and accessible for people who were not technical experts to create a web presence for themselves and build newsletters and personal websites. There was also this optimism at the time that social media was going to democratize culture, that it was going to be a way for you to take control of your selfhood. At the same time, the media industry was facing significant challenges adapting to the digital world, and advertisers were looking for new places that had a greater return on their investment for their ads. They discovered these individual people who had really loyal audiences, and that was appealing to advertisers.

Then we had an economic crisis that unmoored millions of people from their jobs and from their lifestyles and how they thought their lives were going to go. It was both a very material financial break for many people and an ideological break for a lot of people as well, where they started to think, “Wow, this system is not going to save me, and I have to do something to try to survive.” There was all this rhetoric about the wonders of social media, and it drove a lot of people online to try to keep themselves afloat in some way. A lot of creative people started blogging, started using Pinterest and YouTube and Tumblr and then Instagram, in the hopes of getting freelance work or networking so that they seem more legitimate. Influencing was not an established path yet, but this drove so many people online that it created a situation where certain people were able to cultivate really sizable or loyal followings for advertisers to notice.

Women were really the ones who invented this method of selling oneself. How were women essential to creating this new industry?

The biggest thing that came through in my research — consistently and across women with different jobs and different backgrounds — is that a lot of the women [influencers] I interviewed pointed to the failure of traditional industries to offer them a viable way forward. Whether it’s because of a lack of flexibility or a toxic workplace culture, traditional career options are often hostile to them. That’s obviously a huge issue in our society today, the way work is hostile to parenthood. It drives capable workers who would be really valuable contributors out. So a lot of these women decided, “Social media seems to offer everything I need: the opportunity to make money, use the skills that I know I have, and take the time that I need to, either to parent or take care of myself.” That attracted a lot of women to the space.

The first and most visible example of influencers taking over an industry was within fashion: Bloggers went from unwanted party crashers to sitting front row, and in the years since, magazine editors and fashion designers have had to become influencers themselves. How did that process happen?

In the beginning, “blogger” was, like, a dirty word. Some editors were starting to embrace them, some were not. Then publications continued to shut down and working within fashion media became more and more precarious. At the same time, Instagram was eating everything in the early part of the 2010s. Eventually, it became really clear that editors needed to cultivate themselves and their publications online and that drawing from the monetization strategies that bloggers and influencers used, like RewardStyle and affiliate links. They realized they had to become more influencer-like to survive.

What’s happening in fashion right now is interesting because there’s another blowback with the rise of TikTok and videos that are more bold-faced, like, “Here’s how to lie to get into Fashion Week.” Even influencers who have been accepted [into the industry] are looking at this TikTok genre like, “What the heck? No!” It’s happening again.

What other industries is this happening in?

One where it’s really apparent to me is journalism. Journalists, for 15-plus years, have felt pressure to self-brand online, and this has only become more and more heightened in recent years when we’ve had mass layoffs. You have to walk a very thin line because if you’re acting too much like an influencer, that’s not okay, but you still have to put in all this unpaid labor to post on these platforms and maintain visibility. You see it in all creative industries: book publishing, music, comedy, academia. You have to post in consistent and reliable ways on social media to maintain a certain level of visibility, in hopes that you can translate that visibility into financial and social rewards. In journalism, there was a huge migration to Substack and the idea that you should subscribe to individual journalists. On one hand, it’s great because you really like this person’s writing, but then if you are only subscribing to those few people who you’ve decided you like, that seriously shapes your worldview.

People tend to get really freaked out when they feel like they need to become an influencer in order to maintain professional relevance. Do you see a future in which everyone is an influencer in some capacity?

I feel like we are already there, to some degree. Obviously, the importance of content creation in people’s lives varies widely. But we’re still experiencing economic precarity in career paths generally. That continues to place a lot of pressure on regular people to consider, “Should I be trying to make a name for myself on social media, if for nothing than a safety net so if the career that I want doesn’t pan out?” Even people like a friend who works in finance or something, they’re like, “Should I be posting more on LinkedIn or trying to become a LinkedIn personality?” I would love for that pressure to be reduced, but I don’t pretend to have the exact right answer.

There’s also the rise of so-called “expert” influencers. It’s all pushing this trend forward of like, “Listen, I’m gonna give it to you straight. You can’t trust institutions, but you can trust me.”

You reference the “virtual influencer” Lil Miquela in the book, and I find her and projects like her to be so boring and irrelevant, but what are your thoughts? Do you expect virtual reality and AI to have an even bigger relationship to the influencer industry than it does now?

In the case of influencers like Lil Miquela, I think that trend seems to have been really overblown. From the brand perspective, it’s perfect because this is someone that you can easily control. But it’s been five or six years since she was launched and clearly it did not incite a wave of CGI influencers. I think AI will play a larger role going forward; a lot of marketing companies have been touting their AI-driven tools that could pinpoint influencers for campaigns or negotiate rates. I think that is where the potential for AI is in this industry. It is potentially worrisome because it is behind the scenes, it’s not something that many people are privy to, unless you work for a brand or marketing firm, or you’re an influencer, who’s, you know, actually intimately engaged in making these deals. I can absolutely see brands and marketers leveraging AI more heavily to help them make decisions.

You wrote about how the influencer industry has seen these macro shifts from fashion influencers to beauty influencers, then fitness influencers, then wellness influencers, then spirituality influencers. Do you get the sense that that trend will continue toward the philosophical or existential?

[Philosophy] has actually always been part of the appeal of [influencers]. I thought it was troubling enough when we were just talking about clothes and beauty products, and now that we are talking about how to parent, your spirituality, your political identification, it’s beyond concerning. Part of what allowed it to gain steam is because people were particularly confused in 2020 and 2021 and it was very destabilizing to the entire world. We have social chaos happening between COVID and the election and George Floyd, which gave a huge boost to people who claim to know what they’re talking about, giving you the illusion of autonomy and ability to manage the chaos. That is what influencers have always done, and now the stakes are just higher.

When you hear people dismiss the influencer industry as vapid or insignificant, what do you think they fail to understand about it?

First of all, in a totally crass way, they don’t understand the financial weight of the industry, and how much money is changing hands, because for better or for worse, that often attracts people’s attention and respect.

I think they also don’t understand its cultural weight. Over time, what happens in the influencer industry has had a tremendous impact on the world around us, whether it’s the way our news is presented and delivered or the way our clothes look and the way our clothes are marketed to us. Our daily lives have been shaped by this industry. People notice it when they go to Target and they see an influencer [fashion] line, and they get annoyed, or when the Fyre Festival happened or when the FTC tried to make an example of Kim Kardashian. But there’s a lot more to it than Target looking at a shiny influencer. Of course the gendered nature of it has played a huge role in it not being taken seriously for a long time.

Good at being president

Joe Biden is pretty good at being president. He should run again.

Some Democrats aren’t excited about Biden 2024. Here’s why they’re wrong.

By Dylan Matthews

I’ve written some hot takes in my time, and this is not one of them. This is an unbelievably cold take, a zero Kelvin take.

My argument in this piece is simple: Joe Biden, the incumbent president of the United States, should run for reelection.

Just six presidents out of the previous 45 have chosen not to run for reelection. The last two who didn’t, Harry Truman and Lyndon Johnson, were accidental presidents who ascended due to the previous president’s death (though they did each win a general election outright), and both were embroiled in brutal and increasingly unpopular wars at the time they declined to run.

You have to go back to Rutherford B. Hayes in 1880 for a situation that would be analogous to Biden declining to run for reelection — a president who won election in their own right and then chose not to run again — and Hayes had pledged in his 1876 campaign to only serve one term.

So why is “Joe Biden should run for president” even worth saying? For one thing, because less than two years before 2024’s Election Day, he’s not running yet. Politico reported last week that Biden has yet to make a final decision on whether to seek reelection, and while most people in his orbit are absolutely confident he will run eventually, that tiny glimmer of a doubt enables all manner of speculation.

Does that mean anything, anything at all? Probably not! As first lady Jill Biden told the Associated Press last week: “He says he’s not done. How many times does he have to say it for you to believe it?”

Still, the persistence of the “Will he run?” question has a basis in something more solid than the bored speculation of DC reporters. Biden was the oldest person ever elected US president, breaking Donald Trump’s record by over seven years. Because of the linear nature of time, he would break his own record by four years should he be reelected. He would be inaugurated at age 82, and leave office at 86.

There is a non-trivial chance Biden will die in office if reelected. “Using a standard US life table from the Social Security Administration, his survival probability would be 59.1 percent,” S. Jay Olshansky, a professor of public health at the University of Illinois at Chicago who has written specifically about Biden’s life expectancy, told me in an email.

“However, Biden is likely to be higher than that because of his highly favorable risk profile,” he said. Biden had two brain aneurysms in 1988, when he was 45, but subsequent brain scans have shown no recurrence. He doesn’t smoke or drink, is not diabetic, and has what the White House physician calls “remarkably low” levels of cholesterol.

“Should someone with high odds of dying in office run for president?” is a fair question. “Should someone with elevated odds of undergoing cognitive decline during his term run for president?” is an even better question.

But I think in this case the answer is clearly yes.

Joe Biden has been a pretty good president

The most basic reason for a president to decline reelection is if they’re doing a bad job and are calamitously unpopular — if they’re overseeing a brutal war like Johnson and Truman were, or surging inflation or joblessness, or some other kind of disaster.

Biden is not in the strongest position you can imagine for a president seeking reelection; he’s less popular than the last three presidents to win reelection were at this point. But he’s more popular than Ronald Reagan was at this point, which — given that Reagan went on to win 49 states in 1984 on his way to reelection — tells you a bit about how poor an indicator approval ratings are this far from Election Day.

But Biden is not at all in the position that Johnson or Truman were in. He is not prosecuting a war with US troops; in fact, he ended the war in Afghanistan after 20 crushing years (a move that, somewhat ironically, marked the beginning of a prolonged dip in his approval ratings). And while the way that withdrawal happened left a lot to be desired, nothing like the sight of US troops being slaughtered during the Tet Offensive (as preceded Johnson’s decision not to seek election) is happening now.

Nor, contrary to much speculation, is the US economy in recession. The economy grew at a steady if unspectacular 2.7 percent last quarter; unemployment is the lowest it’s been since 1969 (LBJ’s war was bad for humans but great for jobs in defense industries); inflation is elevated but falling, or at least relatively stable. Wages are rising quickly, especially for less-educated workers in service and manual labor jobs. You have to go back to the dot-com boom of the late ’90s to get a better economic picture than the one Americans are enjoying right now, and this one is arguably more equitable.

Biden deserves a lot of credit for that state of affairs — more than the credit or blame that presidents usually deserve for the state of the economy.

Learning from the overly tepid fiscal stimulus enacted by the Obama administration in response to the 2007-2009 recession, at the start of his term Biden ushered through a massive $1.9 trillion package, the American Rescue Plan, that kept progress on jobs and wages from stalling out as Trump-era measures faded.

The package overshot significantly; he made the opposite mistake that Obama made in 2009. But his was the better direction in which to err: the inflation that resulted, while painful, was less painful than the many years of excess unemployment and depressed demand that resulted after 2009. In the meantime, the measure plunged child poverty to a record low by expanding the child tax credit.

Much has been made of the ways in which moderate Sens. Joe Manchin (D-WV) and Krysten Sinema (I-AZ) frustrated Biden’s grander ambitions. It’s certainly true that Sinema blocked his plans to tax high earners more heavily, and Manchin kept the child tax credit improvements from being made permanent.

But looking at what actually did pass during Biden’s first two years, one gets a different picture. Biden signed the largest investment in R&D and deployment of clean energy in US history into law; the head of the International Energy Agency termed it the world’s most important climate action since the Paris accords.

Separately, Biden signed into law hundreds of billions in new science funding, passed on a bipartisan basis as part of an effort to strengthen semiconductor manufacturing. After the Trump administration’s famous failure to pass an infrastructure bill, Biden did it.

Looking abroad, the administration’s handling of the Ukraine war has been outstanding. Choosing to release intelligence showing Russia’s invasion plans in the weeks leading up to the attack was a masterstroke, denying Russian President Vladimir Putin any ability to claim that Ukraine provoked him. Biden has kept his G7 counterparts aligned in imposing sanctions on Russia, denying it oil revenue, and supplying weapons to Ukraine.

The result is a war that is already vastly more costly than Putin bargained for, without US or NATO troops being dragged into the conflict, and backdoor progress on something US presidents had been fruitlessly pursuing for years: increased European military spending.

Biden does have some notable failures, most importantly the continuing massive death toll of Covid-19. In his first year, he mobilized the largest vaccination campaign in our history to face it, with shots going from coveted and hard-to-access to ubiquitous and available at any pharmacy in a matter of months.

But the Supreme Court’s unwillingness to allow a vaccine mandate for most employers slowed adoption, as did partisan resistance to the shots among conservatives. The emergence of the more transmissible delta and omicron variants meant the disease surged even as vaccines were readily available.

While it’s unclear how much the administration could have done to encourage more mitigation steps, like funding for better ventilation systems, Biden once said in a debate with Trump that anyone responsible for 220,000 dead Americans “should not remain as president of the United States of America.” Given that the US Covid death toll currently stands at 1.1 million, it’s fair to say he hasn’t fared much better.

Taking the good with the bad, Biden looks like a fairly successful president, overseeing an unusually good economy without US troops in danger. That’s not normally someone you want stepping aside.

Sidestepping a contested primary and the Kamala Harris problem

Of course, presidential performance is in the eye of the beholder, and perhaps you disagree that voters will look at Biden and see a reasonably successful president. But if you’re a Democrat and care about Democrats winning the election — alternately, if you simply dislike Donald Trump and/or Ron DeSantis and want to minimize the odds they win the election — you should still hope he runs.

Biden is simply the best chance Democrats have in 2024. If he runs, it avoids a heavily contested primary; outside a few gadflies like Marianne Williamson, he is not likely to attract any challengers. That saves literally hundreds of millions of Democratic donor dollars that can then be poured into the general election. And while incumbents’ electoral advantages have attenuated as the country has polarized, if there’s even a modest bump to be gained from incumbency, it will redound to Biden and not to any alternative candidates.

If Biden doesn’t seek reelection, the Democratic nominee will likely be Vice President Kamala Harris. It’s tempting for Democrats to imagine that Harris would lose an open primary to contenders like Govs. J.B. Pritzker (D-IL) or Gavin Newsom (D-CA), or maybe Sens. Bernie Sanders (I-VT) or Amy Klobuchar (D-MN) if they run again, to list four names recently floated in Politico. But I doubt it.

For one thing, the sheer size of the field — there’ll be many more than the four above, if I had to guess — makes it harder for any anti-Harris candidate to break out. For another, she appears to have consolidated support among Black Democratic voters in a way she never did in 2020, when she was just a senator. The most recent polling covering a plausible field (that is, excluding stunt polls that ask about possibilities like Hillary Clinton or Michelle Obama running) shows Harris is solidly if not overwhelmingly ahead of the likes of Sanders or Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg.

Beyond the cost of the primary, the prospect of Harris as nominee should make Democrats nervous. While Trump and Biden are essentially tied in national polls, Trump leads Harris by 4 percentage points in a hypothetical matchup. Polling this far out is at best a hazy guide, but her weaker performance is at least suggestive.

Outside her circle of loyalists, Harris’s reputation has taken a beating since Biden took office. “Even some Democrats whom her own advisers referred reporters to for supportive quotes confided privately that they had lost hope in her,” the New York Times reported in one painful dispatch. A slew of Democratic Party activists told the Washington Post’s Cleve Wootson they doubted her ability to win the presidency, and Biden’s decision to make her the face of his administration’s controversial border policy has not helped matters at all.

It’s not a good sign when people like Obama’s White House counsel Greg Craig are proposing an open primary for the vice presidential job, which would mostly function as a way to get rid of Harris.

The risk of a Biden in decline

There’s another risk of a Biden run worth highlighting here: that he doesn’t die in office, but gradually undergoes cognitive decline serious enough to make him unable to serve.

The particular danger of this situation is that it’s not clear-cut. Biden is either alive or dead; he is not, in a binary way, either impaired or non-impaired. It’s a gradient and the change is gradual. We can agree that he seems fine now, and that if he were to start forgetting his own name or that he’s the president, that would be too far. It’s harder to agree at what point between those extremes he should step aside.

I don’t have an especially satisfying answer here, other than to say that his doctors see no signs of cognitive decline to date, that I subjectively agree, and that thankfully the 25th Amendment provides procedures for Harris to becoming acting president should Biden’s decline worsen dramatically. In an ideal world, this is why you run younger nominees for president. But Biden’s other advantages as a candidate, I think, outweigh the risk of cognitive decline.

Taking together all these factors, the case for Biden running again is simple. Joe Biden has been a pretty good president. He stands a better chance of winning the presidency in 2024 than any other Democrat. Those points alone should suffice.

Mayor’s race

The Chicago mayor’s race shows Democrats still have a crime problem

Incumbent mayors in Chicago almost never lose a reelection bid. But Lori Lightfoot ran into an issue that’s plaguing Democrats across the country.

By Christian Paz

Lori Lightfoot made history four years ago when she won every ward in the city of Chicago to become the first Black woman and first openly gay person to be elected mayor of America’s third-largest city. She made it again last night, becoming the first Chicago mayor in 40 years to lose a reelection bid.

Lightfoot’s loss was expected, but it also served as a referendum on her first four years in office and on crime in Chicago. The coronavirus pandemic dealt a huge economic hit to the city, and violent crime surged during the outbreak, reaching levels not seen in the city since the 1990s. Because of this, and because of Lightfoot’s poor relationship with other political leaders, she was viewed as the underdog, just like in her last race. Nearly half of Chicago voters rated crime and public safety as their top electoral issues, and more than 60 percent of voters said they felt personally unsafe in the city, according to an early February poll.

That continues a trend in many American cities dominated by Democrats. Crime rates rose during the pandemic and have since moderated a bit, but some visible kinds of crime have continued to test Democrats politically. In Chicago, homicides and shootings have trended down after drastic rises in 2021 and 2022, while property crimes have risen over the last four years. The city has also seen high-profile shootings, increasing crime in downtown, constant media coverage about the violence, and heated rhetoric about how bad crime has become by the police union and Lightfoot herself.

Those conditions have meant Chicago’s mayoral race has echoed local races in New York, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Philadelphia, and Washington, DC over the last two years. And in some national elections as well: Republicans had mixed success in trying to make it a political cudgel during midterm elections last year, when 61 percent of Americans cited it as a major electoral issue.

Violence was a constant topic of the Chicago mayor’s race with challengers taking every opportunity to criticize Lightfoot’s approach to crime and policing. The 60-year-old Democrat and former prosecutor did not get enough votes to make it to a runoff election in April, coming in third behind challengers to her ideological right and left: Paul Vallas, the former head of Chicago’s public school system, took in the most votes Tuesday night, mostly from the city’s predominantly white neighborhoods. A progressive challenger, Cook County commissioner Brandon Johnson, came in second, with support concentrated in the city’s racially diverse and mixed north and northwest neighborhoods, where he spoke about crime in a more nuanced way.

How Chicago became disillusioned with a trailblazer

Lightfoot faced serious struggles as an incumbent who managed the city during one of its toughest times, and many of the challenges that helped bring her down have also tested Democrats in the country’s biggest, bluest strongholds.

The coronavirus pandemic and its shutdowns, a surge in crime, and battles with the city’s police union and the teachers union all dragged down Lightfoot’s political shine. She is also famously short-tempered (she has acknowledged some criticism of her leadership style before), and Lightfoot’s clashes with the press and city council didn’t help her: Many of her former supporters there backed her challengers.

The Chicago Teachers Union backed Johnson, the progressive in the race, while the police union backed Vallas, the conservative Democrat who ran on a tough-on-crime message.

Crime and policing were frequently cited as the top issues for voters this year — both topics where Lightfoot was at a disadvantage because of her incumbency and her campaign promises four years ago. Back then, she had pledged to clean up the city’s political machine, reduce violence across the city, and invest in Black and brown neighborhoods. Though she did make progress on the economic front (including passing a higher minimum wage and planning and investing in more affordable housing), Lightfoot has floundered on her public safety and police reform efforts.

And after union clashes in 2019, the pandemic halted hopes of rapid change and saw a spike in violence: 2021 was the deadliest year in the city since the 1990s: nearly 800 homicides, the highest total number since 1996 and 300 more than in 2019, when Lightfoot took over.

While she told Chicagoans that crime was trending down — and homicides and shootings were down from their pandemic peak last year — those statistics didn’t resonate with the lived experiences of many voters. Much of this feeling was driven by the spike in shootings and homicides during her tenure, and more visible property crimes in the touristy areas downtown that got a lot of media coverage. Also not helping Lightfoot’s case was the fact that particularly visible property crimes, like burglaries and theft, did increase last year (as they have in other cities).

Chicago is indicative of a larger trend in Democratic city politics

The next round of voting will take place on April 4 and will see a new standard-bearer of Chicago progressive politics. Johnson will square off against the conservative top vote-getter, Vallas. Though Vallas currently identifies as a Democrat, he was attacked throughout the race for previously saying he’s “more of a Republican than a Democrat.”

The result of that clash in ideology, race (Vallas was the only white candidate in the field), and class fits in with the broader trend among big-city Democrats to moderate their politics and resort to more conservative proposals for dealing with crime and policing. Vallas has called for hiring more police officers, more patrolling of the city’s public transportation system, and dismissing the city’s current public safety leadership. Johnson is running as a progressive hoping to attack root causes for crime: Instead of cuts to police budgets, he calls for better mental health treatment and schools, addressing poverty, and training new detectives to solve homicides and find illegal guns.

That same kind of dynamic has played out in cities across the country since the pandemic’s outbreak. In New York, it led to the election of Eric Adams as mayor, who pledged to make crime his top priority. (The jury is out on Adams’s agenda, and on his popularity.) In Los Angeles, it meant a billionaire former Republican forced a top Democratic Congress member into a runoff election to lead the city, in what is a bit of a parallel to Chicago’s race. Vallas shares the tough-on-crime message that Rick Caruso, the centrist LA billionaire used, and Johnson has sought to talk about crime with nuance, like now-Mayor Karen Bass.

In DC, it forced an incumbent mayor to move to the right on crime policy in 2022, and set up a clash with the city council as Congress scrutinizes a new local law that would reform the city’s criminal code. And congressional Democrats are responding with scrutiny on local crime policy after facing a flurry of attacks from Republicans during the midterms for their supposed weakness on crime. (Those attacks didn’t fare well everywhere, but did in New York.)

In this context, Chicagoans might give another example of how the Democratic base and its elected leaders are recalibrating their approaches to crime as the party finds a middle ground between conservative and progressive solutions.

What can go wrong?????

OpenAI wants to build systems smarter than us

The (problematic) case for building AI as fast as we can.

By Kelsey Piper

OpenAI, the creators of ChatGPT and the underlying technology for Bing’s Sydney chatbot, have always had a ludicrously ambitious mission: to bring the world AI systems that are generally smarter than humans.

In a post last week titled “Planning for AGI and Beyond,” OpenAI CEO Sam Altman explained what the company means by that: OpenAI is going to build and release successively more powerful systems, which he argues is the best approach to ensuring that the terrifying transition to a world with superintelligence goes well.

“Successfully transitioning to a world with superintelligence is perhaps the most important—and hopeful, and scary—project in human history,” Altman wrote. “Success is far from guaranteed, and the stakes (boundless downside and boundless upside) will hopefully unite all of us.”

I disagree with many details of OpenAI’s plan for reaching AGI, but I think this statement does one incredibly valuable thing: It makes clear what OpenAI is working to do, so that it can be subject to the kind of accountability and external scrutiny that its leadership acknowledges is needed.

Taking OpenAI at its word

Until recently, I think relatively few people really took OpenAI’s declaration that it was working on a world-changing technology very seriously. After all, tech companies often declare they’re going to “change the world,” and just as often, it’s all marketing and no substance. There was little reason to dig into the details of OpenAI’s plans, talk about accountability, or try to engage with the question of how to make powerful AI go well if you thought OpenAI was just engaging in substance-free hype.

“One thing that struck me, reading some of the critical reactions to Open AI LP, was that most of your critics don’t believe you that you’re gonna build AGI,” I said to Greg Brockman, the co-founder and president of OpenAI, in 2019. “So most of the criticism was: ‘That’s a fairy tale.’ And that’s certainly one important angle of critique. But it seems like there’s maybe a dearth of critics who are like, ‘All right. I believe you that there’s a significant chance — a chance worth thinking about — that you’re going to build AGI ... and I want to hold you accountable.’”

“I think I go even one step further,” Brockman said at the time, “and say that it’s not just people who don’t believe that we’re gonna do it but people who don’t even believe that we believe we’re going to do it.”

It’s become much clearer since that OpenAI means it when it says it aims to develop very powerful AI systems, systems where “The bad case — and I think this is important to say — is like lights out for all of us,” as Altman recently said.

ChatGPT has more than 100 million users and has sparked a race among tech companies to surpass it with their own language models. OpenAI’s valuation has soared to more than $100 billion. OpenAI is at this point pushing forward public knowledge of AI, enthusiasm about AI, competition around AI, and development of powerful systems.

“Tech companies have not fully prepared for the consequences of this dizzying pace of deployment of next-generation AI technology,” NYU professor Gary Marcus pointed out recently, arguing that the “global absence of a comprehensive policy framework to ensure AI alignment — that is, safeguards to ensure an AI’s function doesn’t harm humans — begs for a new approach.” An obvious new approach — and the one he favors — is slowing down deployment of powerful systems.

But OpenAI argues that we should instead do the exact opposite.

The theory for hurrying to develop powerful AI as fast as possible

If you believe that AI is very risky, as many experts do and as Altman himself says he does, it might seem strange to rush new and more powerful models to release as fast as possible. OpenAI has been (justifiably, I think) fiercely criticized for its fast pace of release in light of serious concerns about existing models, and “Planning for AGI and Beyond” is best read as, in part, a response to those criticisms.

That response has basically two elements. One is that Altman argues we will learn through doing when it comes to AI: releasing models will help us notice the problems with them, explore their eccentricities, and figure out what’s up with them. “We believe we have to continuously learn and adapt by deploying less powerful versions of the technology in order to minimize ‘one shot to get it right’ scenarios,” he writes.

The other crucial half of the argument (mostly made in a footnote) is that it will be good for humanity’s efforts to solve the alignment problem if we develop very powerful, human-level AI systems when it is still very expensive to do so, instead of holding off until it becomes very inexpensive to do so. (Computer chips get cheaper over time, so anything we can do in 2030 we should expect we’ll be able to do more cheaply in 2040.)

I’ve seen this read as a post hoc rationalization for what OpenAI wanted to do anyway, which is invent lots of really cool stuff and not be stuck doing less rewarding safety work on existing models. It’s hard to rule out an element of that, but I think there’s a genuine argument here, too.

There are a lot of advantages to extremely powerful and dangerous systems being developed while it’s expensive to do so: Fewer actors will be involved in the race, it’ll be easier to regulate and audit advanced AI systems without impacting huge swaths of the economy, and some AI catastrophe scenarios become less likely because it may be harder for an AI system’s capabilities to increase quite as fast.

With AI, we are all a stakeholder

But the real problem — as Altman more or less acknowledges — is that this is a ludicrously high-stakes decision for OpenAI to be in a position to make more or less on its own. Rushing ahead with developing powerful systems may literally kill every person on the face of the planet. But it’s not pure downside — some of the advantages OpenAI discusses are real.

Should we do it? I lean no, but I am sure it is absurd that the way the decision gets made is by every AI company deciding for itself whether to go full steam ahead.

OpenAI says all the right things about not wanting to proceed unilaterally, arguing for external audits and oversight and promising that it may reconsider its fast-moving approach as more and more powerful systems are deployed. But in practice, worrying about powerful AI systems is still pretty niche, and there aren’t good ways for the other stakeholders — which is to say, every person alive — to offer OpenAI useful oversight.

I don’t want to specifically go after OpenAI here. In describing what it’s doing and what it thinks is at stake, it is attracting a lot of attention that it could have avoided if it had just never admitted that AGI is its ultimate aim.

Many other AI labs are worse. Yann LeCun at Facebook, who has also said he aims to build machines that can “reason and plan” and “learn as efficiently as humans and animals,” has written in Scientific American that all the discussion of the extraordinary risks is silly: “Why would a sentient AI want to take over the world? It wouldn’t.”

But while I commend OpenAI for saying that the risks are real, and explaining its case that its approach is the best one for managing risks, I remain skeptical that the benefits of developing incredibly powerful AI systems as fast as possible outweigh the risks of doing so — and I hope that OpenAI means it when it says it’s open to external checks on the work it does.

Kind of 2001ish... Moon, Venus and Jupiter...


 

Zero road death plan? Are they going to outlaw cars????

EU plots to get its zero road death plan back on track

The Commission’s plans include a digital driving license and a ‘no-brainer’ EU-wide driver disqualification for serious offenses.

BY HANNE COKELAERE

The EU aims to halve traffic deaths by 2030, but the trend is moving in the wrong direction — prompting the European Commission on Wednesday to present plans to revamp driver permit rules and to ensure bad drivers face bloc-wide sanctions.

"The improvement in road safety has not been as strong as needed," said the Commission proposal for a directive on driving licenses.

The package includes plans to introduce a digital driving license recognized in all member countries, rules for new drivers, and also aims to ensure penalties are enforced across the bloc — including a new proposal to get drivers disqualified everywhere in the EU if they commit a serious road offense outside their home country.

Out of 14.5 million traffic offenses committed in 2019 with a vehicle registered in another EU country by a driver who wasn’t identified on the spot, just 8.2 million penalties were paid — meaning about 40 percent of offenses went unpunished.

“This gives the impression that while you’re abroad, you can do whatever, because you’re not going to be caught,” said Transport Commmissioner Adina Vălean.

The EU has a target to halve road fatalities and serious injuries between 2020 and 2030, and get close to zero road deaths by 2050 — after missing a previous target to halve road deaths between 2010 and 2020. But while EU roads are some of the safest in the world, progress toward those targets has been slow.

The number of road fatalities fell from 51,400 in 2001 to 18,800 in 2020, but that year was unique thanks to sweeping pandemic lockdowns. As cars and pedestrians return to the roads, deaths are creeping back up. According to preliminary data the Commission published last week, 20,600 people lost their lives on EU roads in 2022. 

Getting deaths to continue falling will mean rethinking how new drivers are licensed and how dangerous drivers are punished.

Under the Commission’s proposal, the minimum age for taking a driving test will be lowered to 17, but new drivers won't be allowed to drive alone until they’re 18. That would also apply to truck permits — an attempt to lure young people into the profession to remedy Europe’s growing driver shortage.

"The higher level of accidents and fatalities of novice drivers indicates that the requirements for issuing driving licences are not fully adapted to road safety objectives," says the proposal.

At the same time, the executive wants to change driving permit rules to put greater focus on vulnerable road users and new forms of mobility such as e-scooters and impose zero tolerance for alcohol on new drivers for at least two years.

The Commission also wants to "make the small piece of plastic history” by introducing an EU-wide digital driving license that drivers could keep on their phones or another digital device, Vălean said. Drivers will still be able to get a physical version.

Several EU countries have already introduced digital driving licenses, but they aren't currently recognized across the EU.

Fighting impunity

The Commission also proposed a new system that would pull the licenses of drivers committing serious infractions in other EU countries.

That comes on top of a separate update, aimed at improving the exchange of information about traffic offenses between countries to help authorities track down offenders.

Currently, drivers only get disqualified if they committed a serious offense in the country that issued their permit. “I’m from Denmark: If I lose my driver license in France for serious offense — speeding, or killing someone — I can go straight back to Denmark and get my driver license back from the commune to keep driving,” said a senior Commission official.

The new system would apply to drivers committing a severe offense, such as driving under the influence of drugs or alcohol, causing death or serious injury, or excessive speeding — defined as driving 50 kilometers per hour above the speed limit.

There will be an obligation to notify the license-issuing country of the breach, which would have to make sure it applies across the bloc.

"If somebody drives so dangerously that an EU member state deems it appropriate to remove their driving license, that person should not be allowed to drive in any other EU country," Vălean said. “This is a no-brainer in terms of safety."