A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



July 31, 2018

Serious Danger of Being Hacked

The Midterm Elections Are in Serious Danger of Being Hacked, Thanks to Trump

Why has the White House and its GOP allies in Congress done so little to combat the threat?

AJ VICENS AND PEMA LEVY

On July 12, 2016, Matthew Emmons, an IT technician, was settling into a quiet workday when a colleague approached his cubicle in the Springfield strip-mall office of the Illinois State Board of Elections. Servers holding the personal information of more than 7.5 million voters had ground to a halt, and there was something he had to see.

Within minutes, a handful of techs had anxiously gathered around a monitor showing the registration database servers hitting total capacity. “We knew we were under attack,” Emmons, now the IT director, recalls. “These are very powerful servers, and it had locked those things up.”

Emmons and his colleagues took the servers offline and started to investigate. What they discovered was mysterious and terrifying. The site’s online voter database had been overloaded by repeated queries. At peak, five requests arrived every second, and though now blocked by a new firewall, they continued to bombard the site for a month. These queries, known as SQL (pronounced “sequel”) injections, are among the most common types of computer attacks, allowing the hacker to send commands to a database to extract, modify, or erase what’s inside.

But what shocked the techs most was when the attack had begun. Activity logs showed that whoever had penetrated the database had been snooping inside for almost three weeks, learning about the system’s structure, figuring out what they could and could not do, and pilfering personal information on half a million voters. If the attackers hadn’t overloaded the servers, Emmons and his colleagues might have never known they were there.

Only later would the Illinois team officially learn, from a Senate hearing nearly a year after the incident, that they’d suffered the first known shot in a Russian campaign that would target every state. “It was a little scary, knowing that it’s a nation,” Emmons says. “This is a part of running elections in the United States now.”

To this day, it’s unclear why, after weeks of quietly poking around, the intruders shut down the servers with a blast of queries. Were they hoping to draw attention and trigger public panic? Or did someone sitting behind a keyboard in Moscow or Minsk botch a more sophisticated project?

“I have to be a little careful because of how we were briefed on that,” says Rep. Mike Quigley, a Chicago Democrat who serves on the House Intelligence Committee and is one of his caucus’ strongest advocates for election security funding. Seated in his Capitol Hill office, Quigley paused, tapping his fingers on his leg. “All I can say on the record is I don’t believe they wanted to be found.”

As President Barack Obama prepared to leave office, his administration had no doubt that Russia had mounted a devastating disinformation campaign and hacked our electoral systems—and would likely do it again. But President-­elect Donald Trump was notably uninterested in the threat. When FBI Director James Comey and other leaders of the intelligence community visited Trump Tower in January 2017 to explain how the country had been attacked, Comey recalled in his memoir, Trump’s team had “no questions about what the future Russian threat might be.” Instead, Comey wrote, they launched “immediately into a strategy session…about how they could spin what we’d just told them.”

The meeting set the tone for the administration. After four months as attorney general, Jeff Sessions told the Senate he had not once been briefed on Russian election interference, even though his department oversees the FBI, which investigates Russia’s disinformation campaigns and hacks like the one in Illinois. When John Bolton took over as national security adviser in April, he promptly pushed out two top White House cybersecurity experts. In May, Homeland Security Secretary Kirstjen Nielsen, whose department also plays a leading role in election security, told reporters she wasn’t aware of US intelligence agencies having found that Russia aimed to help Trump; she made similar remarks at a July security conference. The White House has acknowledged just one Cabinet-level meeting on election security, and it didn’t come until May.

After the 9/11 attacks, a bipartisan commission launched an investigation into what had happened and outlined reforms to confront newly salient threats. Even though a similar probe into Russia’s 2016 attack would have put Obama’s national security team on the spot, neither Trump nor the GOP-led Congress showed interest in any investigation that might appear to delegitimize the election that gave their party undivided control of Washington. While the main election security fixes pushed by experts—paper ballots or printed backups that make it possible to reliably audit election results—are simple, Congress has passed no new laws to protect the country’s election systems during the 19 months since the intelligence community publicly concluded America was attacked by Russia.

If hackers target this November’s midterm elections, the consequences could be far more serious than the mostly quiet probing of 2016 and would fall on an electorate that has yet to receive a full reckoning of Russia’s attack. Hackers could try to create chaos by causing machines to malfunction, deleting properly registered voters, or even going so far as manipulating vote totals. Evidence of foreign-­abetted fraud in just a handful of well-chosen counties could plunge the entire nation into crisis. Days after Trump prompted outrage by appearing alongside Russian President Vladimir Putin in Helsinki and backing his denial of involvement, the White House rushed a National Security Council meeting on election security as press secretary Sarah Huckabee Sanders defended her boss’ response to the assault, asserting he’s undertaking “bold action and reform to make sure it doesn’t happen again.” But an attack on this November’s midterm elections would undoubtedly be aided by what hackers learned two years ago—and by the president’s unwillingness to hold Russia accountable.

Intelligence services around the world—including America’s—have hacked parties and campaigns as part of standard intelligence gathering for many years. In 2008, China hacked both the Obama and John McCain teams, targeting staffers with simple phishing attacks. And in 2012, hackers—foreign and domestic—targeted the Obama and Mitt Romney campaigns. “We were fully expecting foreign intelligence services to heavily target the campaigns” in 2016, recalls Michael Daniel, who served as cyber czar on Obama’s National Security Council.

But as emails stolen from the Democratic National Committee and Hillary Clinton’s campaign were disseminated by WikiLeaks and Russian intelligence, Daniel and his colleagues were confronted with something new. These actors weren’t just snooping; they were weaponizing what they found, using a noxious brew of fake news, astroturfed social-media posts, and bots.

That part of the attack has been much discussed. Far less attention has been paid to Russia’s clandestine attacks on election systems, which were much more extensive than is generally understood. DHS officials believe every state’s voting system was cased by hackers. At least a handful, in places like Illinois, were breached, according to DHS. A classified National Security Agency report leaked to the Intercept by Reality Winner, the young intelligence contractor now serving 63 months in prison, says Russian military intelligence infiltrated an election software vendor’s systems, likely using data from the intrusion to target local election officials. Another attempt carried out by the team that targeted Illinois, according to special counsel Robert Mueller, involved emailing malware to Florida election officials that was disguised as a manual from an election software provider. There could have been other attacks that have yet to become public.

“It looks like the Russians were setting up several different lines of effort and testing out which ones they wanted to use,” says Neil Jenkins, who helped run DHS’s cyber­security teams under Obama. They “picked and chose what was being the most successful as they went.”

At a September 2016 summit, Obama pulled Putin aside and told him to stop his interference, a meeting remembered for a photo of the men staring face-to-face. Using a never-­before-deployed hotline meant to deter cyberwar—akin to the nation’s long-standing nuclear red phone—Daniel told his Kremlin counterpart to, in diplomatic terms, “knock it off.”

To the Obama security experts’ relief, Election Day seemed normal. “That there did not end up being disruption attempts beyond what they had already done I think was a result of the counterpressure that we applied,” Daniel says. “We got off easy.” But the lack of a dramatic meltdown also meant that Trump and his allies have been able to put off doing anything meaningful about election security.

Meanwhile, the Russians—and other attackers—haven’t gone away. In fact, what they did in 2016 likely gave them critical information about vulnerabilities in America’s election systems that could make another attack far more destructive. “They have been doing their planning and their homework,” says J. Alex Halderman, a University of Michigan computer scientist and a leading expert on voting security. State election officials have testified that their systems are scanned for vulnerabilities, whether to run-of-the-mill cybercriminals or hostile nation-states, thousands of times a day.

According to a recent Senate Intelligence Committee report, the Kremlin has been quietly building capacity to disrupt US elections since at least 2014 while engaging in brazen attacks elsewhere. That year, Russian hackers likely targeted Ukraine’s elections so initial vote totals would suggest the wrong winner. Officials caught the hack, but not before a Russian TV station reported the fake victor. Russia flooded British social-media feeds with anti-EU trolls in the lead-up to 2016’s Brexit referendum, and US intelligence concluded in 2017 that Russia had hacked emails associated with the party of Emmanuel Macron in France, releasing them two days before his presidential election victory.

There is a vast buffet of options for Russia or another hostile nation looking to disrupt US elections, from simple attacks on voter registration databases to more sophisticated exploits. A top concern for Halderman is the manipulation of voting software ahead of Election Day: “An attacker could spread malicious code to all the voting machines in an entire state,” he warns. Other experts worry about a Ukraine-like attack on a key state’s reporting system, prompting the Associated Press or TV networks to broadcast inaccurate information, plunging races into chaos.

Nothing, not even changing vote tallies, is off-limits. “We’re talking about state-level attackers,” says Halderman. “Quite possibly, the kinds of probing that we saw in 2016 were just part of that planning process to have the capability in place to strike in a broader and more damaging way at a time of their choosing.”

“Any disruptive or complex operation is almost always preceded by years of probing and learning,” says John Hultquist, an analyst at the private cyberintelligence firm FireEye. “Sometimes we wonder if places were merely targeted because they’re testing grounds. They are playing a long game here.”

In the late summer and fall of 2016, as Obama administration officials tried to mitigate the Russian operation, DHS Secretary Jeh Johnson was struggling to engage state officials. Johnson held a contentious August call with them, during which he proposed designating election systems as “critical infrastructure,” a step that would have freed up resources and prioritized election security assessments.

But in the face of what he later recalled as a “neutral to negative” reaction, he backed off. It was only on January 6, 2017—the same day the intelligence community released its bombshell report blaming Russia—that Johnson moved forward, angering state officials who felt the designation intruded on their turf. As the Trump administration took over, the Election Assistance Commission, a tiny agency set up after the 2000 Florida recount, tried to smooth ruffled feathers. Its Republican chairman, Matthew Masterson, was instrumental. When it comes to “the universe of people who are beloved by the state election community but are also willing and able to do nudging on security,” one former congressional aide mused, “you’re down to like one guy.” That guy was Masterson.

So it came as a surprise in February 2018 when House Speaker Paul Ryan declined to reappoint Masterson to the four-member commission. As an official who has worked with Masterson wryly noted, “Even the idiot commissioners have gotten second terms.” A spokeswoman for Ryan declined to comment to Mother Jones but in a February statement said the speaker was considering one of his “own folks.”

Masterson was quickly hired to work on election security at DHS. But he has still not been replaced on the commission, leaving the group short of a quorum and unable to issue new security guidelines. One remaining commissioner, Republican Christy McCormick, has suggested Russian meddling was a hoax.

Meanwhile, states requesting DHS assessments of their election systems under the critical infrastructure designation faced waits of up to nine months, according to a December Politico article. Under pressure from lawmakers, the department sped things up by delaying assessments of other vulnerable sectors, some of which—like nuclear plants—have also been attacked by Russia. “Demand exceeds our ability to meet all requests in a timely manner,” a department official told Mother Jones.

Rep. Jim Langevin, the Democratic co-chair of the House’s cybersecurity caucus and a former Rhode Island secretary of state, says the department’s balky response is due to a distinct lack of interest from the White House: “DHS is putting the personnel and the resources [to immigration] because the president has made it a priority. Likewise, the president isn’t making election security enough of a priority.”

In April, the White House removed two of its top cyber­security specialists, homeland security adviser Tom Bossert and White House cybersecurity coordinator Rob Joyce, an elite hacker detailed from the NSA. Bolton, the pugnacious new national security adviser, eliminated Joyce’s position; Bossert was replaced by a Coast Guard rear admiral with far less cybersecurity expertise. Agencies and legislators looking to the White House for leadership were now on their own.

Michele Reagan, Arizona’s Republican secretary of state, was outside with her dogs on a June day in 2016 when her chief of staff called and suggested she sit down. The FBI had found a password to the state’s voter registration data­base for sale on the dark web. No records were stolen or altered, but to this day Reagan fields questions from Arizona voters who have heard about “election hacking” and are frightened their votes won’t count.

“We’re all talking about, ‘Did they get in? Did they get in?’ You know what? It doesn’t matter if they got in. They already won that round,” Reagan argues. “The intent of their whole campaign was to make us scared.”

Hultquist worries about the deeply negative and long-­lasting impact on voter confidence of an attack tainting the outcome of a close, heavily watched race—with talk of fraud potentially amplified by Russian disinformation networks.

“The legitimacy problem is the nightmare,” he says. “If there was some suggestion that the outcome had been changed, how would our system even begin to deal with that? How would everyday citizens react?”

Only two states moved to paper ballots or printed backups in the wake of 2016—Virginia and Nevada. Edgardo Cortés, then Virginia’s chief elections administrator, says he decided to act after a July 2017 demonstration at DEF CON, the Las Vegas hacker convention, where organizers procured more than two dozen voting machines. Attendees with limited knowledge, tools, or resources were able to hack them all. Cortés remembers his reaction: “Oh my God, this is out there.” Virginia rushed the change just before its 2017 elections; control of the Statehouse ended up turning on recounts of a tiny number of votes in one district.

But as news of the Las Vegas demonstration traveled in election security circles, some state officials dismissed its significance. Testifying before a House technology subcommittee last November, Louisiana Secretary of State Tom Schedler claimed his constituents trust electronic machines over paper ballots. The DEF CON demonstration wasn’t realistic “by any stretch of the imagination,” he said, adding that “absent the hype about Russian hacking, we have received no complaints from voters at all about the performance or accuracy of our voting machines.”

But DEF CON was hardly the first time electronic voting machines have been revealed as frighteningly insecure. Videos of similar demonstrations have circulated for more than a decade. In 2007, researchers testing Ohio’s voting machines found they were vulnerable to “undetectable manipulation” and unable to “guarantee a trustworthy election.” That same year, California’s secretary of state found similar holes. “There are states that still have not patched those vulnerabilities, that are still running the same versions of the software on the same voting machines from more than 10 years ago,” says Halderman, who participated in the California assessment. In 2016, Wisconsin, a swing state, was one of them.

“If we were criminals and weren’t worried about going to jail, I think my undergraduate computer security class could have probably changed the 2016 result in Michigan,” says Halderman. In April, he demonstrated to the New York Times how to hack the AccuVote-TSX—a machine used without a paper trail in 10 states—so Michigan students would select rival Ohio State as their favorite school.

Election officials have for years decried such demonstrations, knocking researchers for frightening voters about vulnerabilities yet to be exploited. But Halderman says that line of thinking prevents voters from understanding how shoddy security can be while stymieing the political resolve needed to fix it.

“When you start taking things apart, when you start looking at the details, in so many parts of the country things just are not okay,” he says, adding that open conversation is “the only way that we are going to break the pattern of chronically underinvesting in the administration of elections.”

That’s why Halderman and other experts keep insisting that every vote should leave a paper trail and be subject to postelection audits. “We’d be able to come back and say, ‘Yes, we know that something went wrong here, but this is why we know that no votes were changed,’” he explains. “The best assertion we can make right now is, ‘We have so far seen no evidence that any vote was changed’—which is, if you parse it carefully, a much, much, much weaker statement.”

According to an analysis by the group Verified Voting, 15 states still use paperless ballots for some voters, five of them statewide. In a world where even sophisticated systems are routinely penetrated, 41 states use voter registration databases that are more than a decade old, and 43 states use equipment that is no longer manufactured. Only Colorado mandates the sort of postelection audit backed by most cybersecurity experts.

Election security “hasn’t changed in any material way” since 2016, Halderman says. “More resources are being thrown at the problem in a patchy way,” he adds, but “adversaries I’m sure have not been standing still. If Russia is planning to attack the 2018 election, they right now already have found their ways into the computer systems they’re going to use.”

On March 20, 2017, FBI Director Comey sat before the House Intelligence Committee and in a historic admission calmly confirmed the FBI was investigating not just Russian interference, but the possibility that Trump campaign officials had collaborated with the Kremlin. The hearing quickly devolved into a showcase for GOP attempts to downplay Russia’s assault on voting systems. Rep. Devin Nunes (R-Calif.), chairman of the committee, asked then-NSA Director Mike Rogers whether he had “any evidence that Russia cyber actors changed vote tallies.” Rogers replied he did not.

Republicans have chosen not to tackle the threat, congressional Democrats say, in part because the subject upsets the president and his base, a decision that looks ever more disastrous as Trump continues to downplay the attacks and refuses to confront Putin over them. Democrats have introduced a number of bills to strengthen election security—and found precious few Republicans willing to sign on. Rep. Mark Meadows (R-N.C.), chairman of the conservative Freedom Caucus, agreed to co-­sponsor the PAPER Act alongside Langevin, to encourage the creation of nationwide cybersecurity recommendations while pushing paper ballot trails and postelection audits. But the bill, along with a similar Senate measure backed by Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), still awaits a hearing, and there’s no reason to expect either will move forward; while Langevin continues to push the measure, Meadows has been mum. In the Senate, a handful of Republicans joined Democrats to back legislation distributing security grants to local jurisdictions and closing a loophole allowing private election software and hardware vendors to keep attacks on their products secret. But the bill remains bottled up.

Left to go it alone, House Democrats put forth a bill in February allocating $1.7 billion to elections, including funding for paper ballots, audits, and new machines. That same month, Director of National Intelligence Dan Coats came to Capitol Hill to say the threat was ongoing and likely to get worse: “Frankly, the United States is under attack.” Russia and others, Coats warned, “are likely to pursue even more aggressive cyberattacks.” Weeks later, Rogers joined the chorus, telling a congressional committee that “Putin has clearly come to the conclusion there’s little price to pay here and that therefore ‘I can continue this activity…’ What we have done hasn’t been enough.” Despite such warnings from Trump’s own intelligence advisers, the overwhelming majority of Republicans have declined to engage.

“We have over 100 co-sponsors now,” Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.), the ranking member on the House Homeland Security Committee, says of the Democrats’ February bill. “To date, there’s not a single Republican.” Most Republicans won’t touch such legislation, Thompson says, because of their “absolute fear of being on the wrong side of Donald Trump.” In March, the Senate Intelligence Committee—which has been extensively briefed on Russia’s 2016 actions—encouraged states to use paper trails and urged funding to help implement postelection audits. That same month, Congress finally made $380 million available for election improvement, but lawmakers failed to require that the paltry sum actually be spent on security.

“Probably the decimal point was in the wrong spot,” Quigley, the Illinois Democrat, deadpanned during an interview with Mother Jones. “It should have been more like $3.8 billion.”

Some Republican senators, in line with the views of many secretaries of state, insist the federal government has no business getting involved in elections. Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.) disagrees, arguing that foreign attacks make protecting our elections a matter of national defense: “You wouldn’t say to the state of Iowa or Minne­sota, ‘Well, why don’t you fund an aircraft carrier just in case someone comes into Lake Superior?’” Republicans agreed to put the $380 million toward the problem, Klobuchar says, in part because some realized election hacking could affect them too. During a March 2017 Senate hearing, Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Fla.) revealed that his presidential campaign staffers had been targeted from suspected Russian IP addresses.

Quigley’s perch on the Intelligence Committee means he’s privy to classified information about election hacking, making him a bit of a Cassandra when he joins Appropriations Committee debates over money for the problem. Easing onto a couch in his office on a June afternoon, one leg draped over the other, Quigley prepared for an appropriations markup, during which he hoped to wrangle another $380 million in next year’s budget, a small but ongoing investment in upgrading election security.

Like most experts and legislators who have studied the issue, Quigley is less afraid of a Russian attack on vote tallies than of the chaos and lack of confidence that would come from unleashing suspicious activity in, say, a few key counties: “You don’t have to convince Americans about a conspiracy. America rests on a grassy knoll.”

“I don’t think the Republicans and their leadership fully understand the threat,” he says. “When history looks back at this, all they’re in effect doing is protecting the president.”

A few minutes later, he headed out the door to the Appropriations Committee. He lost on a party-line vote.

Is Afraid...

Andrew Wheeler Is Afraid to Revoke California’s Fuel Waiver. He Should Be.

“It’s going to be a hard case for the EPA to win.”

SHANNON OSAKA

There’s trouble in Trumpland, and California is caught in the middle. According to 11 sources cited in the New York Times on Friday, acting EPA chief Andrew Wheeler has stalled plans to roll back the hallmark California fuel emissions waiver, which allows the state to place stricter limits on car and truck emissions than the rest of the country. Wheeler, the sources say, doesn’t believe the administration’s plan will hold up in court.

Experts say he’s right to have cold feet.

“It’s going to be a hard case for the EPA to win,” says Cary Coglianese, professor of law and political science at the University of Pennsylvania. “If you had to place a bet right now, you’d probably be wise to bet on California.”

Under the 1970 Clean Air Act, California can request a waiver from the federal government to set higher emissions standards for cars and trucks. The waiver was introduced to allow the state to tackle its particularly severe air pollution. (Eight of the country’s 10 most polluted cities are in California.) The state’s most recent waiver was granted in 2013 by President Obama, and it allows California to limit carbon emissions and require automakers to sell a certain number of low-emission and zero-emission vehicles in the state.

Over the past several months, however, the Trump administration has signaled that it hopes to end this decades-old regulatory tradition—first by revoking the 2013 waiver. If the EPA does pull the plug on the state-specific standards, California will certainly sue, setting up a conflict between state and federal rights to regulate the environment. And history, in this case, supports California.

Revoking the waiver “would be unprecedented,” says Jody Freeman, a Harvard law professor. “There have been dozens of waivers that California has gotten over the decades since the 1970s, and [the EPA] has never revoked one.”

So the EPA would have to buck tradition and its own previous rulings. “When the EPA grants the waiver in the first place, they build an administrative record to support the decision,” Coglianese tells Grist. “To revoke a waiver, the new administration will have to somehow put forward a case that is in direct contradiction to the administrative record under Obama.” That kind of regulatory flip-flop would look sketchy in court.

But the EPA might have one final argument up its regulatory sleeve. The 1975 Corporate Average Fuel Economy rules give the agency exclusive power to regulate fuel economy. The federal government could argue that these rules “preempt” the debate over the waiver. That means that even if California can win on the waiver question, the state might still be restricted from regulating greenhouse gas emissions and requiring low and zero-emission vehicle sales within its borders.

“It’s a belt-and-suspenders argument,” Freeman says. “It’s like saying, ‘We’re revoking your waiver, but even if it doesn’t work, you’re preempted.'”

That would be a strong statement of federal power for an administration—and an EPA—that has vocally supported states’ rights. “Andrew Wheeler and Scott Pruitt have said that a core principle is to return regulatory power to the states,” Ann Carlson, professor of law at UCLA, tells Grist. “And at the same time, they’re undermining California’s ability to regulate.”

So will Wheeler bend to Trump administration pressure and try to revoke the waiver? It could still easily happen. But even if the EPA does try to step on California’s authority, the length of the court battle ahead means that the standards will stay in place for some time.

Many of Pruitt’s environmental rollbacks have stalled in court, as the embattled former EPA chief rarely did his due diligence to help them withstand judicial review. Wheeler thus far seems more careful about wielding the EPA’s power so rashly. But that may also mean that the acting EPA chief is ultimately more effective at rescinding Obama-era regulations.

Still, the California waiver question won’t be decided until after the midterm elections, and perhaps (dare we hope?) until after the 2020 election.

Says Nothing

“Russia Says Nothing Exists”: A Dozen Times Trump Has Downplayed Hacking

“It also could be somebody sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds, okay?”

HANNAH LEVINTOVA

Despite the conclusions of US intelligence and the indictments of more than two dozen Russian nationals allegedly involved with the plot, Donald Trump has repeatedly downplayed Russia’s attack on the 2016 elections, suggesting it didn’t happen or that, if it did, someone else was responsible.

June 15, 2016: Amid early reports of the Democratic National Committee hack, Trump’s team issues a statement: “We believe it was the DNC that did the ‘hacking’ as a way to distract from the many issues facing their deeply flawed candidate.”

July 27: Trump makes an infamous request: “Russia, if you’re listening, I hope you’re able to find the 30,000 emails that are missing.” A later indictment discloses Russian intelligence first targeted a key Hillary Clinton email provider “on or about” the same day.

September 7-8: An Obama administration official publicly suggests Russians could be behind the hack. Trump responds on Kremlin-­backed RT: “I think maybe the Democrats are putting that out,” he says. “Who knows, but I think it’s pretty unlikely.”

September 26: During the first presidential debate, Trump says, “I don’t think anybody knows it was Russia…It could also be China. It could also be lots of other people. It also could be somebody sitting on their bed that weighs 400 pounds, okay?”

October 9: In the second debate, Clinton accuses Trump of benefiting from Russian interference. “She doesn’t know if it’s the Russians doing the hacking,” he says. “Maybe there is no hacking.”

December 9: Trump’s transition team blasts the CIA’s reported conclusion that Russia intervened to help Trump: “These are the same people that said Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction.”

December 31: Trump claims, “I also know things that other people don’t know, and so they cannot be sure of the situation.”

January 13, 2017: Trump tweets, “Russia says nothing exists.”

September 22: Trump calls Facebook’s conclusion that Russian operatives bought ads on the platform a “hoax.”

November 12: After meeting Vladimir Putin, Trump says, “He said he absolutely did not meddle in our election. He did not do what they are saying.” Trump adds, “I really believe that when he tells me that, he means it.”

July 16, 2018: In a joint appearance in Helsinki, Trump takes Putin’s side over US intelligence: “They said they think it’s Russia. I have President Putin. He just said it’s not Russia. I will say this: I don’t see any reason why it would be.”

July 17: Back in Washington, Trump claims he misspoke: “The sentence should have been: ‘I don’t see any reason why it WOULDN’T be Russia’—a double negative… I think that probably clarifies things pretty good by itself.”

South Pole of Mars

What lies beneath the layered south pole of Mars? A recent measurement with ground-penetrating radar from ESA's Mars Express satellite has detected a bright reflection layer consistent with an underground lake of salty water. The reflection comes from about 1.5-km down but covers an area 200-km across. Liquid water evaporates quickly from the surface of Mars, but a briny confined lake, such as implied by the radar reflection, could last much longer and be a candidate to host life such as microbes. Pictured, an infrared, green, and blue image of the south pole of Mars taken by Mars Express in 2012 shows a complex mixture of layers of dirt, frozen carbon dioxide, and frozen water.

NGC 6744

This image taken by the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope’s Wide Field Camera 3 (WFC3) shows a beautiful spiral galaxy called NGC 6744. At first glance, it resembles our Milky Way albeit larger, measuring more than 200,000 light-years across compared to a 100,000-light-year diameter for our home galaxy.

NGC 6744 is similar to our home galaxy in more ways than one. Like the Milky Way, NGC 6744 has a prominent central region packed with old yellow stars. Moving away from the galactic core, one can see parts of the dusty spiral arms painted in shades of pink and blue; while the blue sites are full of young star clusters, the pink ones are regions of active star formation, indicating that the galaxy is still very lively.

In 2005, a supernova named 2005at (not visible in this image) was discovered within NGC 6744, adding to the argument of this galaxy’s liveliness. SN 2005at is a Type Ic supernova, formed when a massive star collapses on itself and loses its hydrogen envelope.

GOP leaders yawn

GOP leaders yawn at Trump’s shutdown threats

Republicans say the president isn’t going to close the government right before the midterms — even though he’s unlikely to get his full border wall funding by then.

By BURGESS EVERETT

President Donald Trump keeps threatening a government shutdown over his border wall. And Republican leaders keep ignoring his warnings.

The congressional GOP is intent on sending Trump a series of government spending bills over the next two months that would fund the vast majority of the federal government. And despite the president’s statement on Monday that he would have “no problem doing a shutdown,” Republicans seem sure that he’s not talking about a funding lapse right before the midterm elections.

“I’m optimistic we can avoid a government shutdown,” said Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell (R-Ky.), twice, when asked about Trump’s latest remarks on Monday, which followed several presidential tweets hitting Democrats for being lax on border security and demanding the country "keep building, but much faster, THE WALL!"

Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell
McConnell and House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) believe that Trump has bought into their plan to leave the border wall fight until after the election, a strategy first reported by POLITICO last week.

If everything goes smoothly this fall, the two Republican leaders anticipate funding all but a small slice of government through the regular appropriations process, and leaving Homeland Security funding and the border wall fight until a lame-duck session.

In a Senate Republican meeting on Monday afternoon, senators discussed the president’s renewed shutdown vows, according to two GOP sources familiar with the meeting.

Echoing his public remarks, McConnell told them that the Senate would move as many spending bills as it can to the president’s desk ahead of the Sept. 30 funding deadline and told Republicans that the budget deal passed earlier this year will finance work on border security through the election, according to one of those sources.

In other words, Trump’s outburst on Monday is not causing top Republicans to change course.

“I know he’s frustrated and I am too that we haven’t taken steps to adequately deal with border security. But we’ve got an orderly appropriations process going through here and I’m hopeful we can get most if not all the appropriations done,” said Senate Majority Whip John Cornyn (R-Texas). “If there is some small failure to meet deadlines, it will be for a small piece of the appropriations process.”

The Senate hopes to have as many as 9 of the 12 annual spending bills done by the end of August; the House has gone home for a 5-week recess but has passed six of its own. The two chambers must still reconcile those bills before Trump signs them into law, and then would pass stopgap spending bills to cover the rest of the government, including the Department of Homeland Security, according to Republican senators.

Under that line of thinking, voters would head to the ballot boxes after the Senate confirms Trump Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh — not after a government shutdown.

Asked whether he took Trump's shutdown threats seriously, Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) replied: “No.”

“He knows that would be a disaster. I think he wants to throw everything out there so everyone knows it’s an important thing,” Hatch said. “He knows the game.”

Still, there is some risk to Republicans’ strategy of avoiding a showy fight in Congress for Trump's wall right before the elections.

Trump has sounded increasingly dug in on using a shutdown threat to amplify his demands to begin building a physical wall along the border with Mexico, bringing it up unprompted on Monday during his opening remarks at a news conference alongside the Italian prime minister and demanding cuts to legal immigration that Congress has already rejected this year.

“The whole thing is ridiculous. And we have to change our laws. We do that through Congress. So I would certainly be willing to close it down, to get it done,” Trump said on Monday. “I would be certainly willing to consider a shutdown if we don't get proper border security.“

Trump notably said he did not have a “red line” where he would insist on getting the full $25 billion for the wall upfront. He told Ryan and McConnell last week that he wants a $5 billion down payment on the wall, the same amount of the House’s Homeland Security funding bill. The Senate’s bipartisan bill contains $1.6 billion, and Democrats say they won’t provide more than that.

“There’s an easy way out of this,” said a facetious Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-Vt.), the ranking Democrat on the Appropriations Committee. “He said Mexico is going to pay for it. We’re going to open up the account, Mexico pays the money in, we take it out for the wall.”

The fight on immigration and border wall funding has bedeviled Congress since Trump became president. This year, Trump’s plan to build the wall, cut legal immigration and offer citizenship to 1.8 million young immigrants failed on the Senate floor, as did a bipartisan plan that focused more narrowly on protecting young immigrants and boosting border security.

Now the hope among Republicans is for the stalemate to hold past the election, and put off the border wall fight until the end of the year. But there’s no guarantee the president is any more likely to get his funding in December, particularly if Democrats take back the House or the Senate. Unless Trump is willing to cut a deal.

“The Dems are going to resist any attempt to significantly increase above what they’ve already agreed to in terms of wall funding. The president wants it all now,” said Sen. John Thune (R-S.D). “For Democrats to go along with that, you’d have to have some concessions on other immigration issues.”

3D-printed guns

Trump says public availability of 3D-printed guns 'doesn't seem to make much sense'

By LOUIS NELSON

President Donald Trump said Tuesday that he is “looking into” the availability of plans for the 3D printing of guns, writing on Twitter that he had already been in touch with the NRA on the issue.

“I am looking into 3-D Plastic Guns being sold to the public. Already spoke to NRA, doesn’t seem to make much sense!” the president wrote on Twitter Tuesday morning.

After a years-long legal battle, Defense Distributed, a Texas-based group, has announced plans to release instructions on Wednesday for guns that can be created by a 3-D printer, including a handgun and parts for a semi-automatic assault rifle. Although plans were not supposed to be available until Wednesday, instructions have already begun to appear online for download, CNN reported Tuesday.

3D-printed weapons could be printed without serial numbers, spurring concern about the impact such untraceable weapons could have. Attorneys general from eight states, plus the District of Columbia, filed a lawsuit Monday against the Trump administration, according to NPR, seeking a nationwide temporary restraining order that would block Defense Distributed from publishing its 3D printing instructions for guns.

"I have a question for the Trump Administration: Why are you allowing dangerous criminals easy access to weapons?" Washington state Attorney General Bob Ferguson asked in a statement released on Monday. "These downloadable guns are unregistered and very difficult to detect, even with metal detectors, and will be available to anyone regardless of age, mental health or criminal history.”

Trump has long touted his credentials as a strong supporter of gun rights, addressing the NRA’s national convention and regularly reminding conservative audiences that he received the earliest ever endorsement from the gun rights advocacy group.

But the president has also, at times, shown a willingness to break with the NRA, including in the wake of a mass shooting at a Florida high school last spring, after which Trump briefly expressed support for certain gun control measures and accused lawmakers of being “afraid of the NRA.” Trump later backed away from the gun control proposals, which included tougher age restrictions for the purchase of certain guns, and has advocated for training and arming teachers in order to keep schools safe.

The NRA did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Just say he's fucking crazy...

‘Never happened’: Giuliani walks back confusing claim of secret Trump Tower meeting

By REBECCA MORIN

In a day of confusing statements, President Donald Trump's lawyer Rudy Giuliani first startled observers with a public claim of a previously unknown meeting involving top Trump associates and Kremlin-linked Russians — then recanted the claim and said the meeting "never happened."

During a nearly 45-minute interview on CNN at 8 a.m., Giuliani said Trump's longtime lawyer Michael Cohen, who appears to have turned on his former boss, claims that top Trump officials met at Trump Tower to plan for a scheduled June 9, 2016 meeting days later with a Kremlin-linked Russian lawyer promising dirt on Trump's campaign rival, Hillary Clinton.

In a subsequent interview four hours later — and after some Democrats said the earlier meeting amounted to new evidence of calculated collusion with Russia — Giuliani denied it ever took place, saying he was merely repeating a claim that multiple reporters had been asking him about.

It was the latest of several instances in which Giuliani — a former New York City mayor, federal prosecutor and presidential candidate — seemed to confuse or distort key facts about the Russia investigation and related legal headaches for his presidential client.

Giuliani told CNN the earlier meeting happened two days before the well-publicized June 9 Trump Tower meeting, and allegedly involved Trump Jr., Jared Kushner, Paul Manafort, Rick Gates and another individual Giuliani could not remember. Trump Jr., Kushner and Manafort all attended the undisputed June 9 meeting, which — after shifting accounts from the White House about its purpose — they have said came to nothing.

Giuliani mentioned the meeting twice during his CNN interview, first saying that Cohen leaked that this meeting took place. He then mentioned that it was Cohen's lawyer, Lanny Davis, who had revealed the gathering had occurred.

The confused statements came days after a leaked report that Cohen is prepared to tell federal investigators that Trump, contrary to his public claims, had knowledge of and even approved the June 9 meeting with the Russian lawyer, Natalia Veselnitskaya. That meeting was arranged between Trump's son, Donald Trump Jr., and Emin Agalarov, the pop singer and son of a Russian billionaire who had joined the elder Trump in co-hosting the 2013 Miss Universe pageant in Moscow.

Asked by CNN how he could be sure that Trump didn't have advance knowledge about the June 9 meeting, Giuliani said, "Nobody can be sure of anything."

He then described an additional meeting to prove that Cohen and Davis could not be trusted.

"Lanny Davis added there was a meeting two days before, the meeting took place with Donald Jr., Jared, Manafort and two others, Gates and one other person."

Giuliani was then asked whether the meeting was real.

"That's a real meeting on another provable subject in which he would not (inaudible)," he replied.

Around noon, Giuliani called into Fox News' "Outnumbered" to clarify his statement, saying only that reporters had asked him about the separate meeting.

"All I have are two reporters telling me Cohen told him there was a meeting three days before with a group of people that I said, and that they discussed the meeting and that the president was not there," Giuliani said.

He added that Cohen didn't say whether the president knew about it.

"I am telling you the meeting didn't take place, never happened," Giuliani said.

More than once since he became Trump's counsel, Giuliani has raised more questions while trying to defend Trump and his personal dealings.

Giuliani said in May said that Trump had reimbursed Cohen for a sum of money he allegedly paid to adult film actress Stormy Daniels to stay quiet about her alleged affair with Trump. But Giuliani quickly walked back that statement as well.

Needs to be Keel-hauled....

Scott Walker broke the unions. Now he says he’s the ‘education governor’

The Wisconsin governor’s reelection could hang on how well his education message plays with moderate voters.

By CAITLIN EMMA and DANIEL STRAUSS

Republican Gov. Scott Walker became a conservative icon by breaking the teachers union in Wisconsin. Seven years later, he’s facing the political fight of his life against the state schools superintendent, and trying to reinvent himself.

His likely Democratic opponent is the head of the Wisconsin school system, Tony Evers, meaning the election likely will be won or lost on how moderate voters view Walker’s turnaround on education.

Rather than run from the controversy that nearly shut down Wisconsin state government in 2011, Walker is embracing it. He insists that battling the teachers unions, giving school districts more control over their staff and balancing the state budget have made schools better.

"I am proud to be the pro-education governor because our reforms are working," Walker said in a statement to POLITICO.

It’s a highly risky strategy. The crackdown on teachers made Walker a national hero among Republicans who have long disdained the political power of teachers unions. Walker had a brief presidential run in 2016, but now he’s trailing Evers in head-to-head polls back in Wisconsin. The Democratic primary field remains divided, with eight candidates competing for the nomination, but most public polling has shown Evers in the lead.

Already the two-term governor's reelection campaign is rolling out a steady stream of education-pegged ads aimed at moderate voters. A new poll from NBC News and Marist shows Walker trailing Evers in a head-to-head matchup.

Evers, for his part, is more than happy to make the race about education policy.

One of the only statewide officials elected with Democratic support, Evers was first elected in 2009 and cruised to a third term last year. Before entering politics he was a school district superintendent, a high school principal and a teacher.

Walker is being corralled into focusing on education and defending his record, Evers told POLITICO.

"It borders on a joke," he said. "The proof is in the pudding ... I don't think many people believe him."

But Walker spokesman Brian Reisinger said the governor isn't playing defense. Walker's campaign ads tout the benefits of Act 10 — explosive legislation that he championed in 2011 that gutted the collective bargaining rights of labor unions and devastated the resources and membership rolls of the state teachers union.

Walker argues that the law reformed collective bargaining and gave school districts more control over their funding and personnel.

"Thanks to our reforms, local school leaders can staff based on merit and pay based on performance," Walker said in a statement. "That means they can put the best and the brightest in the classroom and keep them there."

His ads also tout his budget proposal, which was adopted by the state legislature last year and included a $649 million boost in state education funding. The increase was about $227 million more than what Evers had asked for — and Evers praised Walker’s budget at the time as a “pro-kid budget.” Walker is also touting increases in funding for rural schools.

Evers has gone after Walker for cutting education funding or keeping it flat during the first years of his administration — saying the cuts prompted Wisconsinites to raise property taxes — in addition to attacking teachers by essentially dismantling their collective bargaining rights.

Evers took credit for “90 percent” of Walker’s recent budget proposal and said if elected, he would seek to increase funding for public education. Evers also said he would pursue a full repeal of Act 10, or at least seek to roll back what he can with a Republican-controlled state legislature. On Monday, Evers announced that he’s seeking $600 million more in special education funding in the next biennial budget, up from $369 million.

Nathan Henry, a Democratic strategist who served as Evers’ campaign manager earlier in the 2018 cycle, said an emphasis on education puts Walker at a disadvantage.

“I'm not really sure why Scott Walker would want to talk about his education record. It's a pretty bad record,” Henry said. “If you look at the overall breadth that he's made as governor — the cuts that they've made to education far exceed any money that they've actually put into education.”

“So I guess I can't exactly explain why Walker would want to make it a focus of his campaign except for maybe to inoculate himself from future attacks,” he said. “I think it's easy to see why Tony would want to see the campaign play out on education. The guy spent his entire life in education.”

Walker has also previously sought deep cuts to higher education and weakened tenure protections for professors at public colleges and universities.

There’s an extra incentive for Walker to focus on his education record: He can talk about what he’s done while the Democratic field, once a chaotic dozen-plus candidates, is still slowly shrinking down to a more manageable group.

Brandon Scholz, a Republican strategist who served as chief of staff to then-Rep. Scott Klug, said the governor will win any fight on education against Evers because a chief executive‘s responsibilities are bigger.

Scholz predicted Evers will try to discredit Walker by saying he did little and cut education spending. “Gov. Walker will come back and say 'Look at this last budget we've done. We've done this and done this and done this,'” Scholz said.

“At some point it's a he-said he-said and Evers is neutralized,” he said. “I don't see Evers having a one-up on the governor on education just because he's had this job. The governor's pulpit and budget is a lot bigger than Tony Evers' department of public instruction.”

State Republicans have attacked Evers in ads for failing to revoke the license of middle school teacher Andrew Harris in 2014 because Harris watched porn on his work computer. But state law at the time set a high bar, stating that students must be in danger in order for a teacher to lose their license.

Walker’s relationship with the soft-spoken Evers has also devolved as Evers has eyed a run for governor. The two are locked in a legal battle over how much authority Evers has to write his own education policies.

Evers was also in charge last year of pulling together a plan for holding Wisconsin schools accountable for student learning and progress under the Every Student Succeeds Act, a federal education law that replaced No Child Left Behind in 2015.

Walker refused to sign off on that plan before it was sent to Education Secretary Betsy DeVos for approval, telling Evers in a stinging letter that “it does little to challenge the status quo for the benefit of Wisconsin’s students.”

Evers contended that the race hasn’t affected his working relationship with the governor.

“We can walk and chew gum at the same time,” he said.

Takes fresh look.....

'It’s a significant shift in our thinking': Business takes fresh look at Democrats

If businesses shift significant support away from Republicans, it could deal a blow to GOP fundraising. But some Democrats are skeptical that the talk will translate into cash for their campaigns.

By LORRAINE WOELLERT and MARIANNE LEVINE

Business groups, at war with President Donald Trump over trade and immigration, say they’re taking steps to rebuild the political center — including taking fresh looks at moderate Democrats.

The American Bankers Association this month began airing ads in support of candidates for the first time, including Democrats Sen. Jon Tester of Montana and Rep. Lou Correa of California. The International Franchise Association has more than doubled its support to Democrats this cycle, with 27 percent of its donations going to centrists in the party. The U.S. Chamber of Commerce, which leans heavily Republican, endorsed Democratic Rep. Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey over Republican John McCann, who has the support of former Trump aide Sebastian Gorka.

Even the powerful Koch network appears to be withholding some support for the Republican Party, if not outright supporting Democrats. Americans for Prosperity President Tim Phillips said at a donor retreat Monday that the political network would not help Rep. Kevin Cramer (R-N.D.) in his Senate race against Democratic incumbent Heidi Heitkamp (D-N.D.), citing inconsistencies on a range of Koch priorities.

“Republicans aren’t the only people who have great ideas for business,” International Franchise Association President Robert Cresanti said. “We really need more members of Congress that are in the middle and are willing to listen to both sides.”

“It’s a significant shift in our thinking,” Cresanti said. “Before, it was you’re either with us 100 percent of the time or you’re against us.”

Smaller players, too, said they are rethinking their midterm strategies. Aaron Lowe, senior vice president of regulatory and government affairs at the Auto Care Association, said his group will likely focus its spending on members of committees that oversee trade. The Household & Commercial Products Association re-established its PAC this cycle and will back “candidates from both parties that want to legislate in a bipartisan matter,” President Steve Caldeira said.

If businesses shift significant support away from Republicans, it could deal a blow to GOP fundraising and the party's hopes to retain control of the House and Senate in midterm elections in which Democrats are expected to be energized. But some Democrats are skeptical that the talk about boosting moderates will translate into cash for their campaigns.

Data compiled by the Center for Responsive Politics show that business still favors Republicans. About 44 percent of contributions from industry political action committees have gone to Democrats so far this year, an increase from about 41 percent in 2016 but down slightly from 2014, according to data provided to POLITICO.

“We’ve heard this story before,” said Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.), a member of the moderate New Democrat Coalition. “Until these business groups genuinely prove, through behavior as well as words, that they’ve had a conversion and they’re going to actually behave fairly instead of make an empty promise, frankly Democrats have no reason to trust those folks.”

Some of the endorsements so far aren’t game changers; Gottheimer and Correa are incumbents with comfortable leads. But support from traditionally Republican-leaning business groups carries symbolic weight, coming amid growing frustration with the Trump administration and with Republicans who opposed raising the federal debt ceiling or tried to kill the Export-Import Bank.

“As we’ve lost the middle in Congress, we have leaders like Josh Gottheimer who are willing to go and embrace the middle,” Chamber Senior Vice President Rob Engstrom told the crowd at a rally in Paramus, New Jersey, last week. “That’s really the tradition in our country, when you think about the big things that have gotten done, people who have the courage to reach across the aisle.”

The soul-searching dates back to 2010, with the rise of the tea party and a centrist rout. The New Democrat Coalition lost a third of its members that cycle, and half the Blue Dog Coalition, whose members identified themselves as conservative Democrats, was wiped out. Moderates in both parties bemoaned a shift in U.S. politics toward extremes.

That year, Connolly said, he spoke to a gathering of financial services lobbyists.

“You’re all uncorking champagne to celebrate the results of the 2010 midterm, you’re all bankers, and I don’t understand how you can feel comfortable electing a bunch of tea party people who want to shut down government,” Connolly said, recounting his remarks. “You are now responsible for having financed the election of a bunch of Neanderthals when it comes to fiscal and monetary policy.”

Eight years later, business lobbyists are thrilled with the administration’s deregulatory push, judicial appointees and tax cuts. But Trump’s disdain for a fundamental tenet of capitalism — free trade — has overshadowed everything else.

A day after the Chamber's Gottheimer event, the president doubled down on his trade war, promising to send $12 billion in aid to farmers hurt by threatened tariffs. Speaking in Kansas City, Missouri, Trump knocked free-trade lobbyists such as his neighbors at the Chamber, which faces the White House from across Lafayette Square.

“They have some of the greatest lobbying teams,” Trump said derisively of the free-trade groups.

Chamber President Tom Donohue spared no criticism of Trump on the campaign trail in 2016. When the candidate talked about slapping a 45 percent tax on imports, Donohue told Bloomberg that Americans would "probably impeach [him] when they figured out what that really meant."

With Trump in office, Donohue has launched an anti-tariff campaign, bashed the administration’s family-separation border policy, and urged senators to block the president’s first pick for the Ex-Im Bank. When the White House asked business groups to support Supreme Court nominee Brett Kavanaugh, the Chamber declined to issue an endorsement.

Now comes the latest aggravation: Trump’s threat of another government shutdown this fall, right before the election.

The American Bankers Association has been holding candidate-training schools to support business-friendly politicians and will endorse more Democrats between now and November, said Rob Nichols, the group's president and CEO. He noted that one legislative achievement this year was a revamp of the Dodd-Frank Act, which required the votes of several Democrats to get to the president’s desk.

“Bipartisan pieces of legislation are more durable and more long-lasting than things that are more partisan,” Nichols said. “If a member has taken some tough votes to support economic growth, we want to help them.”

Democrats acknowledge that this cycle’s business overtures might be little more than an admission that industry needs to make nice in case Democrats take control of the House or Senate.

“Enlightened self-interest is a great motivator,” said Rep. Kurt Schrader (D-Ore.), co-chairman of the Blue Dog PAC. “We’re seeing a big uptick in interest by the business community. Between the Freedom Caucus and the president and the chance we take the majority, all those things add up to the business community looking at Democrats.”

Still, both sides agree there’s a long way to go to before business and Democrats strike an alliance.

“When it comes to running the Congress, setting the committees, setting terms of the debate, we’re the pro-growth guys,” said Chamber senior political strategist Scott Reed, a Republican. “At the end of the day we prefer pro-growth candidates, period. If the Democrats can get themselves in a position where they’re pro-growth, we’ll take a look.”