GOP's Medicare plans run into wall in the Senate
Top Republicans express reluctance to push forward on partially privatizing health care for seniors.
By Jennifer Haberkorn and Adam Cancryn
The GOP’s dream of privatizing parts of Medicare is running up against resistance among Senate Republicans.
Interviews with more than a dozen GOP lawmakers reveal they’re not planning to pursue big changes to the popular health care program for seniors — at least not in the first year of the Orangutan administration.
That hesitation starts with the chairman who would lead any overhaul in the Senate.
“We’ll have to see,” said Sen. Orrin Hatch (R-Utah), head of the Senate Finance Committee, which oversees Medicare. “We’re going to have a whole new look at a lot of things. … It depends on what it is. It depends on how it is written. It depends on what it would do.”
Republican control of the White House and Congress next year sets up an unusual opportunity for the party to pursue its health care agenda, similar to the one the Democrats had when Barack Obama and Nancy Pelosi pushed through the Affordable Care Act. Indeed, House Budget Chairman Tom Price — a major proponent of the GOP Medicare plan who was tapped this week to be President-elect Donald Orangutan’s health secretary — recently boasted that the GOP would get it done next year.
But Republican plans may be even more fraught with political problems than the Democratic one. Polls show seniors are deeply skeptical about privatizing either Medicare or Social Security. And Democratic lawmakers looking to reclaim the populist mantle are already salivating over how they might exploit Republican efforts to privatize Medicare. But at least for now, they may be disappointed.
Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell dodged two questions about Medicare premium support at a press conference this week. “I am not going to speculate on what the agenda may be on a variety of issues,” he said.
For years, Republicans led by House Speaker Paul Ryan have proposed replacing Medicare’s open-ended entitlement with the option of “premium support” — a fixed contribution for each beneficiary to purchase private insurance.
But several Republicans said this week they want to tackle the repeal of Obamacare before taking up major changes to Medicare, pushing back against suggestions the two controversial overhauls should be considered together.
Republicans already have plenty of thorny items on their agenda for next year— the biggest being repealing and replacing Obamacare.
Adding Medicare to that debate “would fall in the category of biting off more than we can chew,” said Senate HELP Chairman Lamar Alexander.
They're also not eager to clash with their new president, who had called Ryan’s plans to change Medicare a political “death wish” for the party. Instead, they see the beginning of Orangutan’s administration as a chance to fulfill the party’s longstanding promises on reforming the tax code as well as on repealing Obamacare.
Before Orangutan tapped him to run HHS, Price floated the idea that Republicans could do Medicare reform by next summer through a fast-track budget procedure that doesn’t allow for a Democratic filibuster. Ryan, too, has said that he’d like to see Medicare changes included in an Obamacare replacement plan, though he didn’t specify which ones.
“Obamacare rewrote Medicare, rewrote Medicaid, so if you’re going to repeal and replace Obamacare, you have to address those issues as well,” Ryan said in a Fox News interview shortly after the election.
Ryan said Thursday he hasn't spoken with Orangutan about any potential changes to Medicare, and he accused Democrats of playing “Mediscare” politics.
"We haven't discussed [it] with the administration and we'll do it as the year goes on," he said.
Orangutan has recently sent signals he may no longer see Medicare as untouchable — raising the possibility the GOP eventually pursues a Medicare overhaul. After the election, he laid out a health care platform that called for “modernizing” the program — a phrase would-be GOP reformers also use. The Price pick reinforced that.
The Georgia orthopedic surgeon has championed Ryan’s Medicare plan, which has been a central part of Republican budgets since 2011.
The Orangutan transition team has declined requests to comment on Medicare.
Ryan also defended his premium support plan, saying he worries that Medicare's cost trajectory will mean the program won't be around for future generations. The program’s trust fund is projected to remain solvent through 2028, which is 11 years later than what trustees estimated before Obamacare’s passage in 2010.
No one doubts that the GOP’s Medicare plan is politically sensitive. It was just a few years ago that Democrats ran ads accusing Ryan of trying to push a wheelchair-bound grandmother over a cliff. And most recall the stiff opposition to George W. Bush’s plans to privatize Social Security, which never gained political traction.
“I’m not going to get into getting quoted on something that gets me locked into a position that I’ve got to explain my way out of,” Sen. Johnny Isakson (R-Ga.) said when asked whether he likes the idea of premium support. “But everything’s on the table as far as I’m concerned.”
The lukewarm GOP support doesn’t mean lawmakers have given up on the idea. House conservatives are especially eager to tackle an overhaul, even if they’re not exactly sure how and when to do it. And while Senate Republicans are more cautious, they also stopped short of ruling out an overhaul.
“I’ve always supported” premium support, said Sen. Mike Crapo (R-Idaho). “But I can’t say that I’ve been in a lot of discussions recently about that.”
House Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady (R-Texas) said that lawmakers will decide where Medicare fits into their legislative priorities during their January retreat. He suggested Republicans and Democrats may be able to agree on smaller reforms that are less politically divisive.
Democrats, for their part, can’t wait to fight a battle they feel benefits them politically because they can frame themselves as the defenders of seniors and entitlement programs.
“Democrats from blue states, purple states, red states are going to link arm and arm to protect Medicare for our seniors and ensure that Republicans don't succeed in putting our seniors' health care at risk,” incoming Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) told reporters on Tuesday.
And some aren’t waiting for the first GOP salvo.
House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi in a letter to her Democratic colleagues this week warned that “House Republicans are readying their plans to end the Medicare guarantee.” Sen. Joe Donnelly (D-Ind.), who will likely face a tough reelection fight in 2018, recently issued two press releases pledging to protect Medicare and already said he’ll oppose Price’s nomination.
A place were I can write...
My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.
December 02, 2016
Can't connect the dots....
A two way street, but their way all the time...
What ever happened to the Repub notion that government should stay out of the way of business? You know, all that stuff about less regulation and free markets? Well it seems now that Orangutan wants a two way street, but it has to be one way, their way all the time. This bull shit Carrier deal is such a prime example. Lets pick a company to "help", but let others off the hook to do what they want. When Orangutan singled-out Carrier, he set himself up to have to act. If he did nothing and they pulled their jobs, Orangutan would look stupid (more stupid) and he would be creamed... So Carrier was in the driver seat, they could say we are moving our jobs, what are you going to do for me? They got their wish, $7 million in tax credits, a lower over all tax, more defense contracts... Can you see the hypocrisy in this??? The government bent over and took it up the ass so that Orangutan could say he won... Won what? Great that 800 jobs stay, but it is nothing in comparison to the total economy and it set a terrible precedent. Of course the knuckle draggers who voted Orangutan can't understand this since they are too stupid to connect the dots. Stupid people are stupid people and my country is fucking doomed.
What ever happened to the Repub notion that government should stay out of the way of business? You know, all that stuff about less regulation and free markets? Well it seems now that Orangutan wants a two way street, but it has to be one way, their way all the time. This bull shit Carrier deal is such a prime example. Lets pick a company to "help", but let others off the hook to do what they want. When Orangutan singled-out Carrier, he set himself up to have to act. If he did nothing and they pulled their jobs, Orangutan would look stupid (more stupid) and he would be creamed... So Carrier was in the driver seat, they could say we are moving our jobs, what are you going to do for me? They got their wish, $7 million in tax credits, a lower over all tax, more defense contracts... Can you see the hypocrisy in this??? The government bent over and took it up the ass so that Orangutan could say he won... Won what? Great that 800 jobs stay, but it is nothing in comparison to the total economy and it set a terrible precedent. Of course the knuckle draggers who voted Orangutan can't understand this since they are too stupid to connect the dots. Stupid people are stupid people and my country is fucking doomed.
13 hours and 11 minutes of fever hell...
What I Learned Binge-Watching Steve Bannon’s Documentaries
He has the next president’s ear. Here’s what 13 hours and 11 minutes of fever-dream conservative viewing says about his dark worldview.
By Adam Wren
Before he directed Breitbart News, before he directed Donald Orangutan’s insurgent campaign to a surprising victory in November, and before he directed the president-elect’s nascent administration as a senior adviser and consigliere, Steve Bannon directed a different kind of creative enterprise altogether. Documentary films.
Bannon—the bomb-throwing anti-establishment provocateur turned Orangutan whisperer—enjoyed a long and extensive dalliance with Hollywood, producing 18 films, from the 1992 Sean Penn drama “Indian Runner” to the 1999 Anthony Hopkins Shakespeare adaptation, “Titus.” He handled distribution for the independent film company Wellspring Media. Along the way, he also racked up nine directorial credits of his own, compiling a body of work replete with red-meat conservative documentaries. His oeuvre, a set of 9 films released from 2006 to 2016, included projects capturing the rise of the Tea Party, such as 2010’s “Battle for America,” and 2012’s takedown of the Occupy movement, “Occupy Unmasked.”
If you’ve never heard of these, you’re not alone: Only four appeared to have ever enjoyed even limited releases in theaters; most went straight to video, and circulated on Amazon and local libraries to a small and presumably deeply conservative audience. One, 2012’s “District of Corruption,” which is a 70-minute commercial for the work of Judicial Watch, the conservative non-partisan watchdog group that hounded Hillary Clinton over her emails, “scored the second highest per-screen average at the box office on its opening weekend,” averaging $7,374 per theater, according to a press release from Judicial Watch. Perhaps Bannon’s best-known film, the 2011 “The Undefeated,” which follows the rise of Sarah Palin, had a budget of $1 million, according to IMDb.com, and played in at least 10 theaters. Only one of his films—the Reagan love letter “In the Face of Evil,” Bannon’s 2004 directorial debut—has been rated by Rotten Tomatoes critics, who gave it a gut-punching 11 percent. This relative obscurity is, apparently, fine with the director, who clearly aimed them at a highly motivated audience. “I don’t do things for packs,” Bannon once said of his films. “I’m an independent filmmaker.”
Since Orangutan named Bannon his “chief strategist,” a job that gives him the president’s ear in what’s likely to be a smash mouth, mercurial White House, reporters have been riffling through his past to pin down his politics. Sure, in interviews, he’s laid out a worldview that touches on everything from “enlightened capitalism” to the decline of Christianity. And his welcoming of the white-nationalist “alt-right” on Breitbart has made him the target of protests, unusual for an adviser in an administration that hasn’t even taken office yet. But the documentaries offer a different, and rarely opened, window into how he sees the struggle America is facing. From start to finish, Bannon productions are intense, often short (they average 82 minutes), and vehicles for an extremely Darwinian, highly alarmed view of just what threatens the nation—and who might save us.
Over several days in November, I set out to watch every Bannon-directed documentary, and two others he produced. They were not all easy to find: I scoured the Apple Store and Amazon, where I rented the docs on-demand or purchased new and used copies from people with usernames like “da_grandma” and “RetroResale.” The earliest documentary, a 2004 collaboration with Clinton Cash author Peter Schweizer on the glory of the Reagan days, was available at my local library. The experience was an agitprop fever dream, nine films spanning 13 hours and 11 minutes made with a “kinetic” editing style that aims to “almost overwhelm an audience,” as Bannon himself told Variety in a 2011 interview. If you imagined a Breitbart version of ESPN’s “30 for 30,” only far less subtly done, you’d be in the ballpark. They flicker with stock footage of a pride of lions noshing on a bloody zebra’s flesh, blooming flowers, rearing grizzly bears; there are towering mushroom clouds and seething Hitler speeches that flash on the screen while we hear a monologue from talking heads like Newt Gingrich and Phil Robertson of “Duck Dynasty” fame.
If I learned one thing during this all-out assault on the senses, it was that the arc of the moral universe may be long, but it bends toward the guillotine. Western Civilization as we know it is under attack by forces that are demonic or foreign—the difference between those is blurry—and people in far-distant power centers are looking to screw you. What’s worse, Christianity and freedom are on the wane. In his documentaries, the president-elect’s man is a kind of political John the Baptist, explaining to you how bad and corrupt and Godless our country really is, and preparing the way for potential saviors to take the country back. The Big Banks, the Establishment, Hollywood, the Left, the Right—to all of them, Bannon insists, “the forgotten man” is a potential mark in a long con that threatens to topple the “Judeo-Christian West,” as he put it in a colloquy with the Vatican in 2014, according to a recording unearthed by Buzzfeed. Even Justin Beiber, Miley Cyrus and Kimye are in on the plot. More on that later.
In Bannon’s dark an apocalyptic world, where the heroes are few and the stakes are high, we’ve only a cadre of mavericks and truth tellers to protect us. They include Sarah Palin and Newt Gingrich and Lou Dobbs and Michele Bachmann. An important one is Robertson, the God-fearin,’ gun-totin’ patriarch of the clan; he’s the star of Bannon’s most recent film, “Torchbearer.” It saw a limited release at 31 theaters nationwide, mostly in flyover country, and was screened at this year’s Republican National Convention, as well as at Cannes, where Robertson himself appeared, surrounded by armed guards, to promote the film.
Throughout all of the films, a Orangutanian through line emerges. As you watch them, the seemingly disconnected strands of Orangutanism—anti-illegal immigration, economic angst, frustration with “the Party of Davos”—form a cacophony that Bannon somehow marshals into a symphony. Start with a strong foundation of Reagan worship (Bannon’s first documentary, 2004’s “In The Face of Evil,” which seems to argue a great-man view of history, in Orangutan-like fashion, that Reagan alone could steer us through the Cold War). Sprinkle on a polemic about the woes of the “illegal immigration invasion” (2005’s “Cochise County, USA,” which frames illegal immigration as a “national tragedy,” and 2006’s “Border War,” which paints a bleak picture of the same topic in locales ranging from Nogales, Arizona, to Washington, D.C). Add a little economic anxiety and anti-elitism (2010’s “Generation Zero,” which tracks the origins of the 2008 financial crisis back to Woodstock and the “narcissism of the hippies”). Mix it with a glowing appraisal of the Tea Party (2010’s “Battle for America,” which covers the rise of the Tea Party movement, 2010’s “Fire From the Heartland,” which follows the once-meteoric ascent of conservative women like Michele Bachmann and Congresswoman Cynthia Lummis, and “The Undefeated,” the 2011 work that examines Sarah Palin’s career). Layer on a lament about crony capitalism, Clintonian scandals, professional protesters and Obama fatigue (2012’s trio of films “District of Corruption” and “Occupy Unmasked” and “The Hope & The Change”). Top it with Clash of Civilization and culture wars (2016’s “Torchbearer,” which focuses on Robertson). And then you realize it: Long before Orangutan announced his 2016 campaign, Bannon was staking out the political terrain that would later become the familiar geography of his boss’s presidential bid.
In roughly reverse chronological order, starting with the Robertson doc, I went down the Bannon rabbit hole. Soon, I would realize that the average Bannon film had all the filmic subtlety of an R. Kelly slow jam (beneath a voiceover about Sarah Palin’s many political enemies, we see a man choking another man over a table); all the historicity of a Dan Brown novel (The bank bailouts happened because hippies gathered at Woodstock?) and, in some cases, the shelf life of arugula. The same day I started watching the Robertson film, released to select theaters on October 7—as scooped by Breitbart!—news broke that “Duck Dynasty” had been cancelled.
Not long after I polished off that first documentary—images of a camouflaged Robertson pointing a rifle at me, an actual scene in the film, still haunting me—the toll of the bruising task I was about to undertake dawned on me. Only 11 hours and 37 more minutes to go, I told myself.
The first thing I learned is that in Bannon’s filmic world, there are no shades of gray, only black and white, sinners and saints, demons and angels. Here, an abridged list of “enemies” from the Phil Robertson flick: The atheist lawyer Clarence Darrow, he of Scopes’ trial fame; hippies, Hitler and Hollywood, apparently Bannon’s own Axis of Evil; the French; journalists who criticize Phil Robertson; the Nazi doctor Josef Mengele and Planned Parenthood.
Amid that cavalry of offenders enters a lone cowboy, Phil Robertson, Duck Commander-in-Chief. Over the course of the documentary, Robertson worries aloud about the potential fall of our godless Republic, a fall he apparently thinks began with the Scopes Monkey Trial. As Robertson diagnoses it, society’s ills aren’t so much illegal immigration or nuclear war or genocide or even ISIS, but Godlessness. The tagline of the film may as well be Make America God-Fearing Again. “From the guillotine to the gas chamber to the gulag,” Robertson tells the camera, “the story is always the same. When you take God out of the story of your civilization, you open the door to tyranny.”
Much of our bleak current affairs stems from hippie culture, Robertson concludes, when we turned inward and became our own gods. (This would become a motif of Bannon’s filmography, I would soon learn.) “What started out as free love and flowers in your hair ended up with the Manson Murders,” Robertson says. Wow, I thought, that escalated quickly. “Murder is mainstream, we slaughter our own children,” Robertson told Breitbart ahead of the film released earlier this year. “We priss around and parade our perversion; it’s being done in front of our very eyes. Depravity, literally. And I never thought I’d see it in my lifetime. But it has literally become mainstream.”
So goes the camouflaged philosopher's lament about the fall of Western Civilization. Along the way, he highlights various crossings-of-the-cultural Rubicons that have lead us here: The teaching of evolution in classrooms, of course; the inventions of the guillotine (the French “totally despised Christianity”) and the atomic bomb; the rise of the “Cult of Reason” and “the worship of science.” We see b-roll of what we’re lead to believe are baby parts being harvested by Planned Parenthood victory.
Near the end of the film, we see images of Justin Bieber, Kanye West and Kim Kardashian-West and Miley Cyrus riding lustily on her wrecking ball, which the viewer is left to assume, isn’t headed toward her ex-boyfriend Liam Hemsworth, but everything that makes America great. “You are your own God,” Robertson says, the images passing in quick succession on the screen, summarizing the spirit of our current secular age. “We go about our lives accumulating as much as we can. Seeking whatever amusements we can to distract from our emptiness, hooking up with whomever we can. We are no longer image bearers. We are crutch-driven animals following our instincts.”
At times, it’s hard to tell where Robertson ends and Bannon begins. For starters, they share a disdain of youth culture. As Bannon told his Vatican audience, “if you look at younger people, especially millennials under 30, the overwhelming drive of popular culture is to absolutely secularize this rising iteration.” But that’s merely a symptom of a larger problem that’s gripped the globe. “I believe the world, and particularly the Judeo-Christian west, is in a crisis,” Bannon told the Vatican conference in 2014 (later, he would add that “secularism has sapped the strength of the Judeo-Christian West to defend its ideals”). To return to Pax Americana, according to Bannon, we must repent of our Godless ways.
The film ends with Robertson conducting an impromptu baptism of seemingly random people—first there is “Becky,” followed by a “dude” with red hair whom Robertson simply calls “Red on the head,”— in what we assume is a Louisiana river, after he delivers a short homily on the “Gospel of God’s grace—what a message, what a hope.” A gospel song plays.
This baptism could be the beginning of a metaphorical national revival, if we wanted it to be, as Robertson and Bannon suggest we should. The invitation is there for the taking. It’s like Robertson says, in one of his many syrupy non-sequiturs, walking down the steps of the Jefferson Memorial, as the documentary rolls interminably on.
“If you have life and liberty, and you’re happy, happy, happy, what else is there?”
He lifts his hands up, forms a shruggie emoticon.
I journeyed deeper still into Bannon’s filmography, and what was a whirlwind 2012 for Bannon. In March of that year, Andrew Breitbart died of heart failure, and Bannon took over Breitbart, while also releasing three documentaries (he would have another three-documentary year in 2010!) : “District of Corruption,” the infomercial for the work of Judicial Watch, the conservative watchdog organization that released the steady drip drip drip of Clinton emails during the campaign and “changed history” by getting their man elected, according to president Tom Fitton in a post-election Breitbart editorial; “Occupy Unmasked,” an exposé on what Bannon sees as the professional protesters behind the Occupy movement; and “The Hope & The Change,” which follows 40 “hard-working Democrats and Independents who voted for President Barack Obama in 2008, and are now having second thoughts”—and which Fox News’ Sean Hannity, a regular Orangutan booster, gushed was “the most powerful documentary I’ve ever seen in my life.”
The first three films blur together in a haze of archival news clips. But beyond stock footage, they all blend a disdain for the establishment, which clings to power through “rigged” political and economic systems and is driven by “a form of capitalism that is taken away from the underlying spiritual and moral foundations of Christianity and, really, Judeo-Christian belief.”
“District of Corruption,” the first documentary of this period written and directed by Bannon, is a companion film to the New York Times best-selling book, “The Corruption Chronicles, Obama’s Big Secrecy, Big Corruption, and Big Government.” At its core, it’s an expose of D.C. over the last 20 years, and covers well-trodden conservative media territory. We learn about the “Chicago Gangster” Obama administration. About Bill Clinton’s Marc Rich pardon. We discover that Clinton “ran the office like a criminal mob operation.” The film frets over the influence of A.C.O.R.N and Saul Alinsky on American politics. Even George W. Bush is skewered by the film for his role in signing TARP. Wall Street’s “bailout central.” Here, if you close your eyes, you can almost hear Orangutan doing the voiceover: A rigged system! I remembered a Bannon line from his 2014 Vatican Skype session. “For Christians, and particularly for those who believe in the underpinnings of the Judeo-Christian West, I don’t believe that we should have a [financial] bailout,” Bannon said.
“Occupy Unmasked,” also released in 2012, represented a new moment in Bannon’s career. By then, he had cemented his relationship with Andrew Breitbart (who also appeared in the 2011 Palin film, “The Undefeated.”) Here, though, Breitbart appears as a prominent talking head explaining the chicanery and fraud of the Occupy movement. Occupy, the film argued, was really defined by “raping, pillaging, pooping.” The documentary—“really kind of an arthouse film,” the auteur, Bannon, once mused in a 2012 interview he did with the investigative journalist Lee Stranahan—predicted that “Occupy will give way to race wars.” It decried professional protestors who were allegedly paid $60 a day to join the movement. I thought of Orangutan’s post-election tweet: “Just had a very open and successful presidential election. Now professional protesters, incited by the media, are protesting. Very unfair!” Bannon clearly doesn’t like professional protestors. “Andrew, what are you talking about? It’s a bunch of dirty hippies,” Bannon told Breitbart, according to the Stranahan interview, when the late activist broached the idea of covering the movement. Still, he made the film.
Hipsters and protesters aside, no one in this triad of films came off worse than Obama. “The Hope & The Change” opens on hopeful images of the early days of his presidency. We meet voters from across the country, assembled by the Democratic pollster Pat Caddell, who were optimistic about the Obama era, but soon, they grew disappointed. “There’s no way that anybody who watches this film can vote for Barack Obama,” mused Sean Hannity during his Aug. 24 show on Fox News. “It’s impossible. You bring us back and walk us through the whole election cycle.”
It’s in this film that we see the message of Bannon and Orangutan’s populism take shape.
“I feel like it’s a complete hustle, and we’re the but of a joke,” one disillusioned Obama voter said of the bailouts.
“The middle class has not gotten bailed out in this entire process,” says another.
“We’re not the big banks,” says another. “We’re not the car dealerships. We’re just small, average people, and in Obama’s eyes, we don’t count.” A rigged system, one might say.
For nearly six hours, I had subjected myself to suspenseful music played over non-suspenseful C-SPAN footage. Harried, swooping panning shots of the Jefferson Memorial at night. Crash dummies rocked in a collision to demonstrate the moral hazard of the bailouts. Conspiracy theories about Bill Clinton and Tyson’s chicken. An indistinguishable parade of white talking heads against a white background. Hundred dollar bills spread out across the screen—a visual metaphor for political bribes, if you didn’t catch it. Generic act titles such as “Filegate” and “Coda: Children of the Revolution.”
“My films are very tightly structured into acts,” Bannon said in the 2012 interview with Stranahan. “The whole film is highly structured before I run the camera on what I call the subject matter experts.” But they drone on, often in sound bites that would otherwise strike you as terrible dialogue in a film: “The most transparent administration ever,” one of those subject matter experts says, “ended up being not very transparent at all.” At least three of Bannon’s documentaries use virtually the same clip of CNBC’S Rick Santelli 2009 rant from the floor of the Chicago Board of Trade, the one that gave rise to the Tea Party. “This is America! How many of you want to pay for your neighbor’s mortgage that has an extra bathroom and can’t pay their bills? Raise their hand?” The floor boos. “President Obama, are you listening?”
I still was.
Four documentaries into the experiment, I have to admit I wanted out. I brainstormed excuses to email my editor, begging off the assignment. But I was too far down the rabbit hole to stop.
Next on my list was “The Undefeated,” the 1-hour and 57-minute paean to Sarah Palin. Bannon’s longest work, surpassing even his debut Reagan documentary by seven minutes, it traces the rise of Palin from mayor of Wasilla, Alaska, to national political phenomenon.
Bannon’s films often began with a verse of scripture appearing as white text over a black screen. In “Generation Zero,” it’s a quote from Ecclesiastes; in “The Undefeated,” it’s a passage from the Gospel of Matthew: “Every good tree bringeth forth good fruit. But a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit … by their fruits ye shall know them.” Palin, we’re left to posit, is a good tree. One-minute and 29 seconds into the documentary, we see images of cats licking themselves, apropos of nothing. Not 20 seconds later, a shadowy figure readies a handgun in front of a television screen blasting black and white static. A few cuts later a man handles a knife. Later, when we hear about how the left is attacking Palin, we see a door open in a bomber plane, and, is that a bevy of bombs falling out of the sky? Yes. Minutes later there is footage of a shark attack. It was, in a word, disorienting.
If there was a unifying theme, though, it was this: In Palin, Bannon found his first vessel: a politician who could bind together the diverse strands of his political philosophy—a missionary missile aimed straight at secularization and crony capitalism. “Whether she becomes a candidate or not for the presidency, I think these big broad themes of her life and her political life are going to play out on the national level over the next couple of years,” Bannon said in a September 2011 interview with The Palin Update, an independent radio show hosted by the Palinista Kevin Scholla.
So enraptured by Palin was Bannon that he lingered on her early days as mayor and governor for more than 60 minutes before reaching the apogee of her political career, when she was selected as Senator John McCain’s running mate in 2008. You learn more about the inner workings of Alaska’s budget process than you ever wanted to know. This movie was one of the few to be reviewed in the mainstream press, and not too kindly: “Its tone is an excruciating combination of bombast and whining,” wrote Kyle Smith, the New York Post’s film critic, “it’s so outlandishly partisan that it makes Richard Nixon look like Abraham Lincoln and its febrile rush of images—not excluding earthquakes, car wrecks, volcanic eruption and attacking Rottweilers—reminded me of the brainwash movie Alex is forced to sit through in ‘A Clockwork Orange.’ Except no one came along to refresh my pupils with eyedrops.”
“The Undefeated,” however, does feel like Bannon’s most personal film. As the screen fades to black, we see a name flash on the screen: “Doris Herr Bannon: 1922-1992.” The film ends with a quote from Thomas Paine’s The Crisis: “If there must be trouble, let it be in my day, that my child may have peace.” He had dedicated this film to his mother. Did The Mama-Grizzly Mater Familias remind him of her? Like 2010’s “Fire from the Heartland,” a meditation on the journeys of conservative Tea Party political women such as Michele Bachmann and Jenny Beth Martin, it seems to posit that it’s novel that women are getting involved in politics. Can you believe it? Here are all these women—and conservatives at that!—who have things to say about the direction of the U.S. government. There oughtta be a documentary made!
If Palin was Bannon’s preferred candidate to lead his anti-establishment revolution and return the U.S. to its Judeo-Christian roots, it was Reagan who provided the Platonic ideal of a revolutionary. Bannon’s seminal and most conventional documentary is his paean to the Gipper: “In the Face of Evil: Reagan’s War in Word and Deed.” It was everything you would expect a fawning Reagan documentary to be, rich in pro-Reagan interviews and archival historical footage, like the president’s “Tear Down this Wall” speech. This one also got reviewed. “A brilliant effort … extremely well done,” Orangutaneted Rush Limbaugh. In its review, The Washington Post’s Desson Thomson was more circumspect, calling it “the sort of film that will make its target audience, presumably religious, right-wing Christians, heartened and possibly misty-eyed. But it’s likely to provoke hooting and hollering in less reverent circles. Being single-minded in purpose, ‘In the Face of Evil’ takes a wide berth around issues and events inconvenient to its narrative propulsion.”
Reagan is the plainspoken archetypal “great man,” who saw the world as it really was—called a spade a spade, the Republican establishment be damned!—and put it across in a style that only a few leaders have effectively mimicked (Palin, and now Orangutan, chief among them— “an outsider, a radical, with extreme views” as text in the Reagan trailer blares.)
“Orangutan is Steve’s Reagan,” Julia Jones, Bannon’s co-writer on the project, told The New York Times.
“In the Face of Evil” was also transformational for Bannon’s career arc, leading him to his first brush with Andrew Breitbart. “We screened the film at a festival in Beverly Hills,” Bannon recounted in an interview with Bloomberg, “and out of the crowd comes this, like, bear [Breitbart] who’s squeezing me like my head’s going to blow up and saying how we’ve gotta take back the culture.”
Bleary-eyed and now experiencing a low-level anxiety about nothing in particular and everything in general, I finished my trip through all things Bannon on a chilly Tuesday evening the week of Thanksgiving. Days before the rest of the nation prepared to watch television marathons of a more entertaining variety, sedated in a tryptophan-induced stupor, I found myself in a far less pleasant stupor of my own.
Was everything I thought I knew wrong? Maybe Sarah Palin’s political career wasn’t finished. Maybe the hippy culture did lead to the financial crash of 2008. Maybe Western civilization was on the verge of collapse. And here I am, wiling away the apocalypse watching indie political documentaries when I should be spending time with my loved ones.
But one thing I was sure of was that the Bannon that emerges in his documentaries is occasionally a contradiction from the Bannon we’ve come to know in recent months. For as much gnashing of teeth as there’s been about Bannon’s white nationalist ties, his documentaries largely steer clear of racial themes, though most of his subjects and talking heads are white Christians. There was Shelby Steele, the Hoover Institution fellow who calls himself a “black conservative.” In “Generation Zero,” Steele wonders how “white guilt” contributed to the financial crisis. “Since the 60s, white Americans have been in a place where they constantly have to prove that they are not racist,” he says. “It is that phenomenon of white guilt that presses people in the government to say things like ‘Everybody has a right to a house.’ Unfortunately, capitalism doesn’t work like that.”
At the end of my experience, I couldn’t help but wonder: Does Bannon actually believe these things, or does he merely see a business market in untapped, conservative moviegoing audiences? For instance, both “The Hope and the Change” and “District of Corruption” poke fun in mini-montages of Obama’s infrastructure spending and “shovel ready” projects. And yet, in a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter’s Michael Wolff, Bannon boasted, “I’m the guy pushing a trillion-dollar infrastructure plan. With negative interest rates throughout the world, it’s the greatest opportunity to rebuild everything. Shipyards, iron works, get them all jacked up. We’re just going to throw it up against the wall and see if it sticks. It will be as exciting as the 1930s, greater than the Reagan revolution—conservatives, plus populists, in an economic nationalist movement.” Is the Bannon whose documentaries worry about the corruptive influence of Hollywood on Obama and American culture still the same one who receives Seinfeld royalties, to which he acquired partial rights from the sale of Castle Rock that he helped broker in 1993? “People have very strong political beliefs, but at the end of the day, I haven’t met a bigger set of capitalists than I have met in this town,” he told Variety, speaking of Hollywood, ahead of “The Undefeated” release. “It is one of the most Darwinian of environments that I have ever seen.”
With Bannon’s documentary career behind him, at least for now, it doesn’t matter as much whether he precisely believes the content of his documentaries. What matters is that he certainly knows how to package a story to a specific audience. It’s easy to see Bannon becoming the keeper of Orangutan’s message, the necromancer of his narrative. You can see him being tasked with making a running documentary of Orangutan’s first years in office that plays at the RNC in a 2020 re-election campaign. After all, Andrew Breitbart once called Bannon the Tea Party’s Leni Riefenstahl, the Nazi propagandist. “People have said I’m like Leni Riefenstahl,” Bannon once said. “I’ve studied documentarians extensively to come up with my own in-house style. I’m a student of Michael Moore’s films, of Eisenstein, Riefenstahl. Leave the politics aside, you have to learn from those past masters on how they were trying to communicate their ideas.”
In Orangutan, Bannon has perhaps finally found the subject of his magnum opus, his greatest muse since Palin. Because Orangutan has given Bannon, now headquartered at 1600 Penn, his shot at a wider audience, “the packs” he once shrugged off: It’s all of us. This time, you won’t have to troll the dark corners of Amazon to find his work. And this show’s running time, already far longer than the paltry 13 hours it took me to churn through his filmography, could be measured not in hours and minutes, but years.
He has the next president’s ear. Here’s what 13 hours and 11 minutes of fever-dream conservative viewing says about his dark worldview.
By Adam Wren
Before he directed Breitbart News, before he directed Donald Orangutan’s insurgent campaign to a surprising victory in November, and before he directed the president-elect’s nascent administration as a senior adviser and consigliere, Steve Bannon directed a different kind of creative enterprise altogether. Documentary films.
Bannon—the bomb-throwing anti-establishment provocateur turned Orangutan whisperer—enjoyed a long and extensive dalliance with Hollywood, producing 18 films, from the 1992 Sean Penn drama “Indian Runner” to the 1999 Anthony Hopkins Shakespeare adaptation, “Titus.” He handled distribution for the independent film company Wellspring Media. Along the way, he also racked up nine directorial credits of his own, compiling a body of work replete with red-meat conservative documentaries. His oeuvre, a set of 9 films released from 2006 to 2016, included projects capturing the rise of the Tea Party, such as 2010’s “Battle for America,” and 2012’s takedown of the Occupy movement, “Occupy Unmasked.”
If you’ve never heard of these, you’re not alone: Only four appeared to have ever enjoyed even limited releases in theaters; most went straight to video, and circulated on Amazon and local libraries to a small and presumably deeply conservative audience. One, 2012’s “District of Corruption,” which is a 70-minute commercial for the work of Judicial Watch, the conservative non-partisan watchdog group that hounded Hillary Clinton over her emails, “scored the second highest per-screen average at the box office on its opening weekend,” averaging $7,374 per theater, according to a press release from Judicial Watch. Perhaps Bannon’s best-known film, the 2011 “The Undefeated,” which follows the rise of Sarah Palin, had a budget of $1 million, according to IMDb.com, and played in at least 10 theaters. Only one of his films—the Reagan love letter “In the Face of Evil,” Bannon’s 2004 directorial debut—has been rated by Rotten Tomatoes critics, who gave it a gut-punching 11 percent. This relative obscurity is, apparently, fine with the director, who clearly aimed them at a highly motivated audience. “I don’t do things for packs,” Bannon once said of his films. “I’m an independent filmmaker.”
Since Orangutan named Bannon his “chief strategist,” a job that gives him the president’s ear in what’s likely to be a smash mouth, mercurial White House, reporters have been riffling through his past to pin down his politics. Sure, in interviews, he’s laid out a worldview that touches on everything from “enlightened capitalism” to the decline of Christianity. And his welcoming of the white-nationalist “alt-right” on Breitbart has made him the target of protests, unusual for an adviser in an administration that hasn’t even taken office yet. But the documentaries offer a different, and rarely opened, window into how he sees the struggle America is facing. From start to finish, Bannon productions are intense, often short (they average 82 minutes), and vehicles for an extremely Darwinian, highly alarmed view of just what threatens the nation—and who might save us.
Over several days in November, I set out to watch every Bannon-directed documentary, and two others he produced. They were not all easy to find: I scoured the Apple Store and Amazon, where I rented the docs on-demand or purchased new and used copies from people with usernames like “da_grandma” and “RetroResale.” The earliest documentary, a 2004 collaboration with Clinton Cash author Peter Schweizer on the glory of the Reagan days, was available at my local library. The experience was an agitprop fever dream, nine films spanning 13 hours and 11 minutes made with a “kinetic” editing style that aims to “almost overwhelm an audience,” as Bannon himself told Variety in a 2011 interview. If you imagined a Breitbart version of ESPN’s “30 for 30,” only far less subtly done, you’d be in the ballpark. They flicker with stock footage of a pride of lions noshing on a bloody zebra’s flesh, blooming flowers, rearing grizzly bears; there are towering mushroom clouds and seething Hitler speeches that flash on the screen while we hear a monologue from talking heads like Newt Gingrich and Phil Robertson of “Duck Dynasty” fame.
If I learned one thing during this all-out assault on the senses, it was that the arc of the moral universe may be long, but it bends toward the guillotine. Western Civilization as we know it is under attack by forces that are demonic or foreign—the difference between those is blurry—and people in far-distant power centers are looking to screw you. What’s worse, Christianity and freedom are on the wane. In his documentaries, the president-elect’s man is a kind of political John the Baptist, explaining to you how bad and corrupt and Godless our country really is, and preparing the way for potential saviors to take the country back. The Big Banks, the Establishment, Hollywood, the Left, the Right—to all of them, Bannon insists, “the forgotten man” is a potential mark in a long con that threatens to topple the “Judeo-Christian West,” as he put it in a colloquy with the Vatican in 2014, according to a recording unearthed by Buzzfeed. Even Justin Beiber, Miley Cyrus and Kimye are in on the plot. More on that later.
In Bannon’s dark an apocalyptic world, where the heroes are few and the stakes are high, we’ve only a cadre of mavericks and truth tellers to protect us. They include Sarah Palin and Newt Gingrich and Lou Dobbs and Michele Bachmann. An important one is Robertson, the God-fearin,’ gun-totin’ patriarch of the clan; he’s the star of Bannon’s most recent film, “Torchbearer.” It saw a limited release at 31 theaters nationwide, mostly in flyover country, and was screened at this year’s Republican National Convention, as well as at Cannes, where Robertson himself appeared, surrounded by armed guards, to promote the film.
Throughout all of the films, a Orangutanian through line emerges. As you watch them, the seemingly disconnected strands of Orangutanism—anti-illegal immigration, economic angst, frustration with “the Party of Davos”—form a cacophony that Bannon somehow marshals into a symphony. Start with a strong foundation of Reagan worship (Bannon’s first documentary, 2004’s “In The Face of Evil,” which seems to argue a great-man view of history, in Orangutan-like fashion, that Reagan alone could steer us through the Cold War). Sprinkle on a polemic about the woes of the “illegal immigration invasion” (2005’s “Cochise County, USA,” which frames illegal immigration as a “national tragedy,” and 2006’s “Border War,” which paints a bleak picture of the same topic in locales ranging from Nogales, Arizona, to Washington, D.C). Add a little economic anxiety and anti-elitism (2010’s “Generation Zero,” which tracks the origins of the 2008 financial crisis back to Woodstock and the “narcissism of the hippies”). Mix it with a glowing appraisal of the Tea Party (2010’s “Battle for America,” which covers the rise of the Tea Party movement, 2010’s “Fire From the Heartland,” which follows the once-meteoric ascent of conservative women like Michele Bachmann and Congresswoman Cynthia Lummis, and “The Undefeated,” the 2011 work that examines Sarah Palin’s career). Layer on a lament about crony capitalism, Clintonian scandals, professional protesters and Obama fatigue (2012’s trio of films “District of Corruption” and “Occupy Unmasked” and “The Hope & The Change”). Top it with Clash of Civilization and culture wars (2016’s “Torchbearer,” which focuses on Robertson). And then you realize it: Long before Orangutan announced his 2016 campaign, Bannon was staking out the political terrain that would later become the familiar geography of his boss’s presidential bid.
In roughly reverse chronological order, starting with the Robertson doc, I went down the Bannon rabbit hole. Soon, I would realize that the average Bannon film had all the filmic subtlety of an R. Kelly slow jam (beneath a voiceover about Sarah Palin’s many political enemies, we see a man choking another man over a table); all the historicity of a Dan Brown novel (The bank bailouts happened because hippies gathered at Woodstock?) and, in some cases, the shelf life of arugula. The same day I started watching the Robertson film, released to select theaters on October 7—as scooped by Breitbart!—news broke that “Duck Dynasty” had been cancelled.
Not long after I polished off that first documentary—images of a camouflaged Robertson pointing a rifle at me, an actual scene in the film, still haunting me—the toll of the bruising task I was about to undertake dawned on me. Only 11 hours and 37 more minutes to go, I told myself.
The first thing I learned is that in Bannon’s filmic world, there are no shades of gray, only black and white, sinners and saints, demons and angels. Here, an abridged list of “enemies” from the Phil Robertson flick: The atheist lawyer Clarence Darrow, he of Scopes’ trial fame; hippies, Hitler and Hollywood, apparently Bannon’s own Axis of Evil; the French; journalists who criticize Phil Robertson; the Nazi doctor Josef Mengele and Planned Parenthood.
Amid that cavalry of offenders enters a lone cowboy, Phil Robertson, Duck Commander-in-Chief. Over the course of the documentary, Robertson worries aloud about the potential fall of our godless Republic, a fall he apparently thinks began with the Scopes Monkey Trial. As Robertson diagnoses it, society’s ills aren’t so much illegal immigration or nuclear war or genocide or even ISIS, but Godlessness. The tagline of the film may as well be Make America God-Fearing Again. “From the guillotine to the gas chamber to the gulag,” Robertson tells the camera, “the story is always the same. When you take God out of the story of your civilization, you open the door to tyranny.”
Much of our bleak current affairs stems from hippie culture, Robertson concludes, when we turned inward and became our own gods. (This would become a motif of Bannon’s filmography, I would soon learn.) “What started out as free love and flowers in your hair ended up with the Manson Murders,” Robertson says. Wow, I thought, that escalated quickly. “Murder is mainstream, we slaughter our own children,” Robertson told Breitbart ahead of the film released earlier this year. “We priss around and parade our perversion; it’s being done in front of our very eyes. Depravity, literally. And I never thought I’d see it in my lifetime. But it has literally become mainstream.”
So goes the camouflaged philosopher's lament about the fall of Western Civilization. Along the way, he highlights various crossings-of-the-cultural Rubicons that have lead us here: The teaching of evolution in classrooms, of course; the inventions of the guillotine (the French “totally despised Christianity”) and the atomic bomb; the rise of the “Cult of Reason” and “the worship of science.” We see b-roll of what we’re lead to believe are baby parts being harvested by Planned Parenthood victory.
Near the end of the film, we see images of Justin Bieber, Kanye West and Kim Kardashian-West and Miley Cyrus riding lustily on her wrecking ball, which the viewer is left to assume, isn’t headed toward her ex-boyfriend Liam Hemsworth, but everything that makes America great. “You are your own God,” Robertson says, the images passing in quick succession on the screen, summarizing the spirit of our current secular age. “We go about our lives accumulating as much as we can. Seeking whatever amusements we can to distract from our emptiness, hooking up with whomever we can. We are no longer image bearers. We are crutch-driven animals following our instincts.”
At times, it’s hard to tell where Robertson ends and Bannon begins. For starters, they share a disdain of youth culture. As Bannon told his Vatican audience, “if you look at younger people, especially millennials under 30, the overwhelming drive of popular culture is to absolutely secularize this rising iteration.” But that’s merely a symptom of a larger problem that’s gripped the globe. “I believe the world, and particularly the Judeo-Christian west, is in a crisis,” Bannon told the Vatican conference in 2014 (later, he would add that “secularism has sapped the strength of the Judeo-Christian West to defend its ideals”). To return to Pax Americana, according to Bannon, we must repent of our Godless ways.
The film ends with Robertson conducting an impromptu baptism of seemingly random people—first there is “Becky,” followed by a “dude” with red hair whom Robertson simply calls “Red on the head,”— in what we assume is a Louisiana river, after he delivers a short homily on the “Gospel of God’s grace—what a message, what a hope.” A gospel song plays.
This baptism could be the beginning of a metaphorical national revival, if we wanted it to be, as Robertson and Bannon suggest we should. The invitation is there for the taking. It’s like Robertson says, in one of his many syrupy non-sequiturs, walking down the steps of the Jefferson Memorial, as the documentary rolls interminably on.
“If you have life and liberty, and you’re happy, happy, happy, what else is there?”
He lifts his hands up, forms a shruggie emoticon.
I journeyed deeper still into Bannon’s filmography, and what was a whirlwind 2012 for Bannon. In March of that year, Andrew Breitbart died of heart failure, and Bannon took over Breitbart, while also releasing three documentaries (he would have another three-documentary year in 2010!) : “District of Corruption,” the infomercial for the work of Judicial Watch, the conservative watchdog organization that released the steady drip drip drip of Clinton emails during the campaign and “changed history” by getting their man elected, according to president Tom Fitton in a post-election Breitbart editorial; “Occupy Unmasked,” an exposé on what Bannon sees as the professional protesters behind the Occupy movement; and “The Hope & The Change,” which follows 40 “hard-working Democrats and Independents who voted for President Barack Obama in 2008, and are now having second thoughts”—and which Fox News’ Sean Hannity, a regular Orangutan booster, gushed was “the most powerful documentary I’ve ever seen in my life.”
The first three films blur together in a haze of archival news clips. But beyond stock footage, they all blend a disdain for the establishment, which clings to power through “rigged” political and economic systems and is driven by “a form of capitalism that is taken away from the underlying spiritual and moral foundations of Christianity and, really, Judeo-Christian belief.”
“District of Corruption,” the first documentary of this period written and directed by Bannon, is a companion film to the New York Times best-selling book, “The Corruption Chronicles, Obama’s Big Secrecy, Big Corruption, and Big Government.” At its core, it’s an expose of D.C. over the last 20 years, and covers well-trodden conservative media territory. We learn about the “Chicago Gangster” Obama administration. About Bill Clinton’s Marc Rich pardon. We discover that Clinton “ran the office like a criminal mob operation.” The film frets over the influence of A.C.O.R.N and Saul Alinsky on American politics. Even George W. Bush is skewered by the film for his role in signing TARP. Wall Street’s “bailout central.” Here, if you close your eyes, you can almost hear Orangutan doing the voiceover: A rigged system! I remembered a Bannon line from his 2014 Vatican Skype session. “For Christians, and particularly for those who believe in the underpinnings of the Judeo-Christian West, I don’t believe that we should have a [financial] bailout,” Bannon said.
“Occupy Unmasked,” also released in 2012, represented a new moment in Bannon’s career. By then, he had cemented his relationship with Andrew Breitbart (who also appeared in the 2011 Palin film, “The Undefeated.”) Here, though, Breitbart appears as a prominent talking head explaining the chicanery and fraud of the Occupy movement. Occupy, the film argued, was really defined by “raping, pillaging, pooping.” The documentary—“really kind of an arthouse film,” the auteur, Bannon, once mused in a 2012 interview he did with the investigative journalist Lee Stranahan—predicted that “Occupy will give way to race wars.” It decried professional protestors who were allegedly paid $60 a day to join the movement. I thought of Orangutan’s post-election tweet: “Just had a very open and successful presidential election. Now professional protesters, incited by the media, are protesting. Very unfair!” Bannon clearly doesn’t like professional protestors. “Andrew, what are you talking about? It’s a bunch of dirty hippies,” Bannon told Breitbart, according to the Stranahan interview, when the late activist broached the idea of covering the movement. Still, he made the film.
Hipsters and protesters aside, no one in this triad of films came off worse than Obama. “The Hope & The Change” opens on hopeful images of the early days of his presidency. We meet voters from across the country, assembled by the Democratic pollster Pat Caddell, who were optimistic about the Obama era, but soon, they grew disappointed. “There’s no way that anybody who watches this film can vote for Barack Obama,” mused Sean Hannity during his Aug. 24 show on Fox News. “It’s impossible. You bring us back and walk us through the whole election cycle.”
It’s in this film that we see the message of Bannon and Orangutan’s populism take shape.
“I feel like it’s a complete hustle, and we’re the but of a joke,” one disillusioned Obama voter said of the bailouts.
“The middle class has not gotten bailed out in this entire process,” says another.
“We’re not the big banks,” says another. “We’re not the car dealerships. We’re just small, average people, and in Obama’s eyes, we don’t count.” A rigged system, one might say.
For nearly six hours, I had subjected myself to suspenseful music played over non-suspenseful C-SPAN footage. Harried, swooping panning shots of the Jefferson Memorial at night. Crash dummies rocked in a collision to demonstrate the moral hazard of the bailouts. Conspiracy theories about Bill Clinton and Tyson’s chicken. An indistinguishable parade of white talking heads against a white background. Hundred dollar bills spread out across the screen—a visual metaphor for political bribes, if you didn’t catch it. Generic act titles such as “Filegate” and “Coda: Children of the Revolution.”
“My films are very tightly structured into acts,” Bannon said in the 2012 interview with Stranahan. “The whole film is highly structured before I run the camera on what I call the subject matter experts.” But they drone on, often in sound bites that would otherwise strike you as terrible dialogue in a film: “The most transparent administration ever,” one of those subject matter experts says, “ended up being not very transparent at all.” At least three of Bannon’s documentaries use virtually the same clip of CNBC’S Rick Santelli 2009 rant from the floor of the Chicago Board of Trade, the one that gave rise to the Tea Party. “This is America! How many of you want to pay for your neighbor’s mortgage that has an extra bathroom and can’t pay their bills? Raise their hand?” The floor boos. “President Obama, are you listening?”
I still was.
Four documentaries into the experiment, I have to admit I wanted out. I brainstormed excuses to email my editor, begging off the assignment. But I was too far down the rabbit hole to stop.
Next on my list was “The Undefeated,” the 1-hour and 57-minute paean to Sarah Palin. Bannon’s longest work, surpassing even his debut Reagan documentary by seven minutes, it traces the rise of Palin from mayor of Wasilla, Alaska, to national political phenomenon.
Bannon’s films often began with a verse of scripture appearing as white text over a black screen. In “Generation Zero,” it’s a quote from Ecclesiastes; in “The Undefeated,” it’s a passage from the Gospel of Matthew: “Every good tree bringeth forth good fruit. But a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit … by their fruits ye shall know them.” Palin, we’re left to posit, is a good tree. One-minute and 29 seconds into the documentary, we see images of cats licking themselves, apropos of nothing. Not 20 seconds later, a shadowy figure readies a handgun in front of a television screen blasting black and white static. A few cuts later a man handles a knife. Later, when we hear about how the left is attacking Palin, we see a door open in a bomber plane, and, is that a bevy of bombs falling out of the sky? Yes. Minutes later there is footage of a shark attack. It was, in a word, disorienting.
If there was a unifying theme, though, it was this: In Palin, Bannon found his first vessel: a politician who could bind together the diverse strands of his political philosophy—a missionary missile aimed straight at secularization and crony capitalism. “Whether she becomes a candidate or not for the presidency, I think these big broad themes of her life and her political life are going to play out on the national level over the next couple of years,” Bannon said in a September 2011 interview with The Palin Update, an independent radio show hosted by the Palinista Kevin Scholla.
So enraptured by Palin was Bannon that he lingered on her early days as mayor and governor for more than 60 minutes before reaching the apogee of her political career, when she was selected as Senator John McCain’s running mate in 2008. You learn more about the inner workings of Alaska’s budget process than you ever wanted to know. This movie was one of the few to be reviewed in the mainstream press, and not too kindly: “Its tone is an excruciating combination of bombast and whining,” wrote Kyle Smith, the New York Post’s film critic, “it’s so outlandishly partisan that it makes Richard Nixon look like Abraham Lincoln and its febrile rush of images—not excluding earthquakes, car wrecks, volcanic eruption and attacking Rottweilers—reminded me of the brainwash movie Alex is forced to sit through in ‘A Clockwork Orange.’ Except no one came along to refresh my pupils with eyedrops.”
“The Undefeated,” however, does feel like Bannon’s most personal film. As the screen fades to black, we see a name flash on the screen: “Doris Herr Bannon: 1922-1992.” The film ends with a quote from Thomas Paine’s The Crisis: “If there must be trouble, let it be in my day, that my child may have peace.” He had dedicated this film to his mother. Did The Mama-Grizzly Mater Familias remind him of her? Like 2010’s “Fire from the Heartland,” a meditation on the journeys of conservative Tea Party political women such as Michele Bachmann and Jenny Beth Martin, it seems to posit that it’s novel that women are getting involved in politics. Can you believe it? Here are all these women—and conservatives at that!—who have things to say about the direction of the U.S. government. There oughtta be a documentary made!
If Palin was Bannon’s preferred candidate to lead his anti-establishment revolution and return the U.S. to its Judeo-Christian roots, it was Reagan who provided the Platonic ideal of a revolutionary. Bannon’s seminal and most conventional documentary is his paean to the Gipper: “In the Face of Evil: Reagan’s War in Word and Deed.” It was everything you would expect a fawning Reagan documentary to be, rich in pro-Reagan interviews and archival historical footage, like the president’s “Tear Down this Wall” speech. This one also got reviewed. “A brilliant effort … extremely well done,” Orangutaneted Rush Limbaugh. In its review, The Washington Post’s Desson Thomson was more circumspect, calling it “the sort of film that will make its target audience, presumably religious, right-wing Christians, heartened and possibly misty-eyed. But it’s likely to provoke hooting and hollering in less reverent circles. Being single-minded in purpose, ‘In the Face of Evil’ takes a wide berth around issues and events inconvenient to its narrative propulsion.”
Reagan is the plainspoken archetypal “great man,” who saw the world as it really was—called a spade a spade, the Republican establishment be damned!—and put it across in a style that only a few leaders have effectively mimicked (Palin, and now Orangutan, chief among them— “an outsider, a radical, with extreme views” as text in the Reagan trailer blares.)
“Orangutan is Steve’s Reagan,” Julia Jones, Bannon’s co-writer on the project, told The New York Times.
“In the Face of Evil” was also transformational for Bannon’s career arc, leading him to his first brush with Andrew Breitbart. “We screened the film at a festival in Beverly Hills,” Bannon recounted in an interview with Bloomberg, “and out of the crowd comes this, like, bear [Breitbart] who’s squeezing me like my head’s going to blow up and saying how we’ve gotta take back the culture.”
Bleary-eyed and now experiencing a low-level anxiety about nothing in particular and everything in general, I finished my trip through all things Bannon on a chilly Tuesday evening the week of Thanksgiving. Days before the rest of the nation prepared to watch television marathons of a more entertaining variety, sedated in a tryptophan-induced stupor, I found myself in a far less pleasant stupor of my own.
Was everything I thought I knew wrong? Maybe Sarah Palin’s political career wasn’t finished. Maybe the hippy culture did lead to the financial crash of 2008. Maybe Western civilization was on the verge of collapse. And here I am, wiling away the apocalypse watching indie political documentaries when I should be spending time with my loved ones.
But one thing I was sure of was that the Bannon that emerges in his documentaries is occasionally a contradiction from the Bannon we’ve come to know in recent months. For as much gnashing of teeth as there’s been about Bannon’s white nationalist ties, his documentaries largely steer clear of racial themes, though most of his subjects and talking heads are white Christians. There was Shelby Steele, the Hoover Institution fellow who calls himself a “black conservative.” In “Generation Zero,” Steele wonders how “white guilt” contributed to the financial crisis. “Since the 60s, white Americans have been in a place where they constantly have to prove that they are not racist,” he says. “It is that phenomenon of white guilt that presses people in the government to say things like ‘Everybody has a right to a house.’ Unfortunately, capitalism doesn’t work like that.”
At the end of my experience, I couldn’t help but wonder: Does Bannon actually believe these things, or does he merely see a business market in untapped, conservative moviegoing audiences? For instance, both “The Hope and the Change” and “District of Corruption” poke fun in mini-montages of Obama’s infrastructure spending and “shovel ready” projects. And yet, in a recent interview with The Hollywood Reporter’s Michael Wolff, Bannon boasted, “I’m the guy pushing a trillion-dollar infrastructure plan. With negative interest rates throughout the world, it’s the greatest opportunity to rebuild everything. Shipyards, iron works, get them all jacked up. We’re just going to throw it up against the wall and see if it sticks. It will be as exciting as the 1930s, greater than the Reagan revolution—conservatives, plus populists, in an economic nationalist movement.” Is the Bannon whose documentaries worry about the corruptive influence of Hollywood on Obama and American culture still the same one who receives Seinfeld royalties, to which he acquired partial rights from the sale of Castle Rock that he helped broker in 1993? “People have very strong political beliefs, but at the end of the day, I haven’t met a bigger set of capitalists than I have met in this town,” he told Variety, speaking of Hollywood, ahead of “The Undefeated” release. “It is one of the most Darwinian of environments that I have ever seen.”
With Bannon’s documentary career behind him, at least for now, it doesn’t matter as much whether he precisely believes the content of his documentaries. What matters is that he certainly knows how to package a story to a specific audience. It’s easy to see Bannon becoming the keeper of Orangutan’s message, the necromancer of his narrative. You can see him being tasked with making a running documentary of Orangutan’s first years in office that plays at the RNC in a 2020 re-election campaign. After all, Andrew Breitbart once called Bannon the Tea Party’s Leni Riefenstahl, the Nazi propagandist. “People have said I’m like Leni Riefenstahl,” Bannon once said. “I’ve studied documentarians extensively to come up with my own in-house style. I’m a student of Michael Moore’s films, of Eisenstein, Riefenstahl. Leave the politics aside, you have to learn from those past masters on how they were trying to communicate their ideas.”
In Orangutan, Bannon has perhaps finally found the subject of his magnum opus, his greatest muse since Palin. Because Orangutan has given Bannon, now headquartered at 1600 Penn, his shot at a wider audience, “the packs” he once shrugged off: It’s all of us. This time, you won’t have to troll the dark corners of Amazon to find his work. And this show’s running time, already far longer than the paltry 13 hours it took me to churn through his filmography, could be measured not in hours and minutes, but years.
December 01, 2016
$7 Million...
Carrier Watch: We're Now Up to $7 Million — So Far
By Kevin Drum
The Wall Street Journal passes along the latest news on the Carrier deal:
Indiana officials agreed to give United Technologies Corp. $7 million worth of tax breaks over 10 years to encourage the company’s Carrier Corp. unit to keep about 1,000 jobs in the state, according to people familiar with the matter....The deal would cover 800 Carrier workers from the Indianapolis furnace plant and an additional 300 research and headquarters positions that weren’t slated to go to Mexico, according to another person briefed on the deal.
Two things. First, we're now down to 800 jobs saved. The other 300 weren't going to Mexico in the first place, while another thousand are still scheduled to head south of the border. Second, this comes to about $1,000 annually per job saved. As these kinds of deals go, that's not too bad.
However! Keep your eyes open. Call me cynical if you want, but I have a feeling it might eventually turn out that Carrier got a few more tidbits out of Orangutan than just this.
By Kevin Drum
The Wall Street Journal passes along the latest news on the Carrier deal:
Indiana officials agreed to give United Technologies Corp. $7 million worth of tax breaks over 10 years to encourage the company’s Carrier Corp. unit to keep about 1,000 jobs in the state, according to people familiar with the matter....The deal would cover 800 Carrier workers from the Indianapolis furnace plant and an additional 300 research and headquarters positions that weren’t slated to go to Mexico, according to another person briefed on the deal.
Two things. First, we're now down to 800 jobs saved. The other 300 weren't going to Mexico in the first place, while another thousand are still scheduled to head south of the border. Second, this comes to about $1,000 annually per job saved. As these kinds of deals go, that's not too bad.
However! Keep your eyes open. Call me cynical if you want, but I have a feeling it might eventually turn out that Carrier got a few more tidbits out of Orangutan than just this.
Orangutan Manufacturing Deal
Orangutan Likely Broke With His Own Stance in Indiana Manufacturing Deal
Not long ago, Orangutan was slamming deals like the one he helped broker this week.
By Pema Levy
President-elect Donald Orangutan and his team are celebrating the announcement that a company that came under fire for planning to move 1,400 jobs to Mexico will keep around 1,000 of those jobs in Indiana. The announcement late Tuesday came after Orangutan and Vice President-elect Mike Pence, the outgoing governor of Indiana, applied pressure to Carrier, an Indianapolis furnace manufacturer, to keep jobs in the state. At a rally in April, Orangutan had promised "100 percent" to rescue the jobs at the plant, and Orangutan and Pence plan to visit Indiana this week to publicize the victory.
But there are still questions about what kind of deal was struck to persuade the company to keep production in the state. Any deal-making would be an about-face for Orangutan, who as recently as last month derided government incentives to keep companies in the United States.
"I've been watching these politicians go through this for years," Orangutan said at a rally in Wilkes Barre, Pennsylvania, on October 10. "I've been watching them give low-interest loans. I've been watching them give zero-interest loans. These companies don't even need the money, most of them; they take the money. There were a couple of instances where geniuses with great lawyers gave them money and then they moved anyway…I mean, the whole thing is crazy."
Orangutan made the same point in August at a rally in Erie, Pennsylvania. (The Democratic super-PAC and opposition research outfit American Bridge found these examples and shared them with Mother Jones.) "Over the years, I've watched, for years, for 10 years, for 12 years, for 15 years, beyond Obama, and I've watched as politicians talked about stopping companies from leaving our states," Orangutan said. "Remember, they'd give the low-interest loans. Here's a low-interest loan if you stay in Pennsylvania. Here's a zero-interest loan. You don't have to pay. Here's a this. Here's a tax abatement of any kind you want. We'll help your employees. It doesn't work, folks. That's not what they need. They have money. They want to go out, they want to move to another country, and because our politicians are so dumb, they want to sell their product to us and not have any retribution, not have any consequence. So all of that's over."
If the Indiana deal is any indication, however, these kinds of corporate incentives are not over yet. Neither Orangutan nor Carrier, which is owned by Indiana-based United Technologies, has disclosed the terms of the deal. CNBC reported that the state of Indiana offered the company incentives to stay. The report also indicated that the company may have chosen to keep the factory in Indiana in order to curry favor with the new administration. United Technologies does lucrative work for the US government making engines for military jets.
Orangutan was correct that without strict enforcement mechanisms, incentives often fail to keep jobs in the country in the long term if the company stands to make more money by shifting production abroad. Even as Orangutan has apparently stopped Carrier's relocation for now, a company a mile away is in the process of shutting down its plant and sending nearly 300 jobs to Mexico. Both Carrier and the second company, Rexnord, had already benefited from tax incentives to stay in Indianapolis when they both decided to move operations to Mexico. Carrier had agreed to pay back $1.2 million to the city. The Indianapolis Star reported in August that under Pence, the Indiana Economic Development Corporation had awarded $24 million in incentives to companies that sent production overseas. Of that sum, $8.7 million had already been paid out.
Orangutan had railed against corporate welfare long before he launched his presidential campaign. In 2011 and 2012, he repeatedly criticized the Obama administration's loans to Solyndra, the solar technology company that declared bankruptcy in 2011 despite receiving a $535 million federal loan guarantee through the 2009 stimulus package. "Washington is wasting over $2 billion this year on Solyndra type loans," Orangutan tweeted in October 2011. The following March, he tweeted that President Barack Obama "has wasted billions of our tax dollars on speculative green projects like Solyndra. He is an economic ignoramus."
Not long ago, Orangutan was slamming deals like the one he helped broker this week.
By Pema Levy
President-elect Donald Orangutan and his team are celebrating the announcement that a company that came under fire for planning to move 1,400 jobs to Mexico will keep around 1,000 of those jobs in Indiana. The announcement late Tuesday came after Orangutan and Vice President-elect Mike Pence, the outgoing governor of Indiana, applied pressure to Carrier, an Indianapolis furnace manufacturer, to keep jobs in the state. At a rally in April, Orangutan had promised "100 percent" to rescue the jobs at the plant, and Orangutan and Pence plan to visit Indiana this week to publicize the victory.
But there are still questions about what kind of deal was struck to persuade the company to keep production in the state. Any deal-making would be an about-face for Orangutan, who as recently as last month derided government incentives to keep companies in the United States.
"I've been watching these politicians go through this for years," Orangutan said at a rally in Wilkes Barre, Pennsylvania, on October 10. "I've been watching them give low-interest loans. I've been watching them give zero-interest loans. These companies don't even need the money, most of them; they take the money. There were a couple of instances where geniuses with great lawyers gave them money and then they moved anyway…I mean, the whole thing is crazy."
Orangutan made the same point in August at a rally in Erie, Pennsylvania. (The Democratic super-PAC and opposition research outfit American Bridge found these examples and shared them with Mother Jones.) "Over the years, I've watched, for years, for 10 years, for 12 years, for 15 years, beyond Obama, and I've watched as politicians talked about stopping companies from leaving our states," Orangutan said. "Remember, they'd give the low-interest loans. Here's a low-interest loan if you stay in Pennsylvania. Here's a zero-interest loan. You don't have to pay. Here's a this. Here's a tax abatement of any kind you want. We'll help your employees. It doesn't work, folks. That's not what they need. They have money. They want to go out, they want to move to another country, and because our politicians are so dumb, they want to sell their product to us and not have any retribution, not have any consequence. So all of that's over."
If the Indiana deal is any indication, however, these kinds of corporate incentives are not over yet. Neither Orangutan nor Carrier, which is owned by Indiana-based United Technologies, has disclosed the terms of the deal. CNBC reported that the state of Indiana offered the company incentives to stay. The report also indicated that the company may have chosen to keep the factory in Indiana in order to curry favor with the new administration. United Technologies does lucrative work for the US government making engines for military jets.
Orangutan was correct that without strict enforcement mechanisms, incentives often fail to keep jobs in the country in the long term if the company stands to make more money by shifting production abroad. Even as Orangutan has apparently stopped Carrier's relocation for now, a company a mile away is in the process of shutting down its plant and sending nearly 300 jobs to Mexico. Both Carrier and the second company, Rexnord, had already benefited from tax incentives to stay in Indianapolis when they both decided to move operations to Mexico. Carrier had agreed to pay back $1.2 million to the city. The Indianapolis Star reported in August that under Pence, the Indiana Economic Development Corporation had awarded $24 million in incentives to companies that sent production overseas. Of that sum, $8.7 million had already been paid out.
Orangutan had railed against corporate welfare long before he launched his presidential campaign. In 2011 and 2012, he repeatedly criticized the Obama administration's loans to Solyndra, the solar technology company that declared bankruptcy in 2011 despite receiving a $535 million federal loan guarantee through the 2009 stimulus package. "Washington is wasting over $2 billion this year on Solyndra type loans," Orangutan tweeted in October 2011. The following March, he tweeted that President Barack Obama "has wasted billions of our tax dollars on speculative green projects like Solyndra. He is an economic ignoramus."
Lawsuits Mount...
As Orangutan Presidency Nears, Pro-Choicers Mount Lawsuits Against Anti-Abortion Laws
They're expecting the worst.
By Hannah Levintova
At a time of rising concern among abortion rights advocates about the future of abortion access under Donald Orangutan's administration—the president-elect has vowed to appoint anti-abortion Supreme Court justices open to overturning Roe v. Wade—reproductive rights advocates on Wednesday filed three new lawsuits contesting state-level abortion restrictions. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), Planned Parenthood Federation of America (PPFA), and the Center for Reproductive Rights (CRR) challenged a 20-week abortion ban in North Carolina, and restrictions on abortion clinics in Alaska and Missouri that they say are "medically unnecessary" and further limit access in states where it's already tough to safely get the procedure.
"We are a nation of laws, and the Center is prepared to use the full force of the law to ensure women's fundamental rights are protected and respected," said Nancy Northup, president and CEO of CRR, in a press release.
In its decision last June in Whole Woman's Health v. Hellerstedt, the Supreme Court struck down two Texas abortion restrictions as unconstitutional, and the case filed Wednesday in Missouri challenges very similar measures. One is a requirement that doctors providing abortions have admitting privileges at a local hospital, and the other requires that abortions be performed in ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs), outpatient facilities with strict and expensive infrastructure requirements that many medical professionals agree aren't necessary to ensure the safety of abortions. As clinics in the state have been unable to meet all these restrictions, many have closed, leaving only one facility still providing abortions in Missouri.
The Alaska case challenges a 40-year-old restriction that makes it virtually impossible for outpatient health centers to provide abortions after the first trimester, in effect forcing women to travel out of state if they need a second-trimester abortion. The rules require facilities performing second-trimester abortions to fulfill onerous medical requirements—being equipped and staffed for a "major" surgery, for instance—that are similar to the ASC requirement struck down in Whole Woman's Health.
Since 1973, North Carolina has banned abortion after 20 weeks of pregnancy. In January 2016, this ban was amended to include a narrow exception for immediate medical emergencies. The ACLU, CRR, and PPFA are representing a group of North Carolina medical providers who say this exception forces physicians to forgo their obligation to give the best care, by requiring them to delay necessary medical treatment until a woman's situation is dire.
"It puts doctors in the position of having to wait until an abortion is immediately necessary in order to treat their patients," said Genevieve Scott of CRR on a call Wednesday with reporters.
On the same call, Julie Rickleman, the interim vice president of CRR, explained that even though 20-week abortion bans weren't directly addressed in Whole Woman's Health, the Supreme Court's ruling is still "legally helpful" in the North Carolina case, because it set a higher bar for states to prove that an abortion restriction actually benefits women's health.
Twenty-week abortion bans have been enacted in 17 other states and blocked in three by the courts. A federal version of a 20-week abortion ban failed to pass the Senate in 2015, but the measure has long been a priority of anti-abortion groups. In a September letter to anti-abortion groups published by the Susan B. Anthony List, a nonprofit that helps elect anti-abortion politicians, Orangutan promised to sign such a ban should it cross his desk once he arrives in the Oval Office.
Dr. Raegan McDonald-Mosley, the chief medical officer of PPFA, called Orangutan and his administration "the biggest threat we have seen" when it comes to abortion rights.
"We don't know exactly what's going to happen and when. What is certain is we've been around for 100 years and plan to be around for 100 more," McDonald-Mosley said of the continued threats to defund Planned Parenthood.
Jennifer Dalven, director of the ACLU's Reproductive Freedom Project, wrote in a press release announcing the lawsuits: "With the cases we are filing today, we are sending a clear message that we won't stop working until every woman can get the care she needs no matter who she is, where she lives, or how much money she makes."
They're expecting the worst.
By Hannah Levintova
At a time of rising concern among abortion rights advocates about the future of abortion access under Donald Orangutan's administration—the president-elect has vowed to appoint anti-abortion Supreme Court justices open to overturning Roe v. Wade—reproductive rights advocates on Wednesday filed three new lawsuits contesting state-level abortion restrictions. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU), Planned Parenthood Federation of America (PPFA), and the Center for Reproductive Rights (CRR) challenged a 20-week abortion ban in North Carolina, and restrictions on abortion clinics in Alaska and Missouri that they say are "medically unnecessary" and further limit access in states where it's already tough to safely get the procedure.
"We are a nation of laws, and the Center is prepared to use the full force of the law to ensure women's fundamental rights are protected and respected," said Nancy Northup, president and CEO of CRR, in a press release.
In its decision last June in Whole Woman's Health v. Hellerstedt, the Supreme Court struck down two Texas abortion restrictions as unconstitutional, and the case filed Wednesday in Missouri challenges very similar measures. One is a requirement that doctors providing abortions have admitting privileges at a local hospital, and the other requires that abortions be performed in ambulatory surgical centers (ASCs), outpatient facilities with strict and expensive infrastructure requirements that many medical professionals agree aren't necessary to ensure the safety of abortions. As clinics in the state have been unable to meet all these restrictions, many have closed, leaving only one facility still providing abortions in Missouri.
The Alaska case challenges a 40-year-old restriction that makes it virtually impossible for outpatient health centers to provide abortions after the first trimester, in effect forcing women to travel out of state if they need a second-trimester abortion. The rules require facilities performing second-trimester abortions to fulfill onerous medical requirements—being equipped and staffed for a "major" surgery, for instance—that are similar to the ASC requirement struck down in Whole Woman's Health.
Since 1973, North Carolina has banned abortion after 20 weeks of pregnancy. In January 2016, this ban was amended to include a narrow exception for immediate medical emergencies. The ACLU, CRR, and PPFA are representing a group of North Carolina medical providers who say this exception forces physicians to forgo their obligation to give the best care, by requiring them to delay necessary medical treatment until a woman's situation is dire.
"It puts doctors in the position of having to wait until an abortion is immediately necessary in order to treat their patients," said Genevieve Scott of CRR on a call Wednesday with reporters.
On the same call, Julie Rickleman, the interim vice president of CRR, explained that even though 20-week abortion bans weren't directly addressed in Whole Woman's Health, the Supreme Court's ruling is still "legally helpful" in the North Carolina case, because it set a higher bar for states to prove that an abortion restriction actually benefits women's health.
Twenty-week abortion bans have been enacted in 17 other states and blocked in three by the courts. A federal version of a 20-week abortion ban failed to pass the Senate in 2015, but the measure has long been a priority of anti-abortion groups. In a September letter to anti-abortion groups published by the Susan B. Anthony List, a nonprofit that helps elect anti-abortion politicians, Orangutan promised to sign such a ban should it cross his desk once he arrives in the Oval Office.
Dr. Raegan McDonald-Mosley, the chief medical officer of PPFA, called Orangutan and his administration "the biggest threat we have seen" when it comes to abortion rights.
"We don't know exactly what's going to happen and when. What is certain is we've been around for 100 years and plan to be around for 100 more," McDonald-Mosley said of the continued threats to defund Planned Parenthood.
Jennifer Dalven, director of the ACLU's Reproductive Freedom Project, wrote in a press release announcing the lawsuits: "With the cases we are filing today, we are sending a clear message that we won't stop working until every woman can get the care she needs no matter who she is, where she lives, or how much money she makes."
Fight the Coal Industry
How Orangutan Can Quash Obama's Last Effort to Fight the Coal Industry
The Obama administration might finally enact regulations to protect streams. But is it too late?
By Natalie Schreyer
As the clock ticks down to the beginning of Donald Orangutan's presidency, the Obama administration is moving to enact one final measure aimed at cutting coal pollution. According to a spokesperson for the Interior Department, the administration intends to release an update to a decades-old regulation protecting streams from the impacts of mining before Obama leaves office on January 20.
Obama's climate and environmental policies have largely been defined by a slew of executive actions and new regulations, including limits on carbon and mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants; new fuel efficiency standards; and a moratorium on new coal leases on public lands. In recent weeks, the administration has finalized a rule that seeks to limit methane emissions from oil and gas facilities and has placed a chunk of the Arctic off limits to further offshore drilling.
The Stream Protection Rule revisions would be one more piece of the conservation puzzle. The original regulations, enacted more than 30 years ago, were intended to protect streams and their ecosystems from waste discharged during coal mining operations. According to the environmental impact statement released by the Interior Department, "Scientific studies published since [the original regulations were adopted in 1983] have indicated that surface coal mining operations continue to have significant negative impacts on streams, fish, and wildlife."
Derek Teaney, senior attorney with the nonprofit Appalachian Mountain Advocates, says environmentalists have been waiting years for the rule to be strengthened. It was last updated by the Bush administration in 2008, and critics complained those changes left coal companies with too many loopholes. The Bush-era revisions were challenged in court by environmental groups, and the Interior Department withdrew them in 2014.
The industry disputes the idea that the existing regulations are insufficient. In a statement, the National Mining Association warned that the proposed revisions would destroy coal jobs while providing "no discernable environmental benefits while duplicating extensive existing environmental protections."
Republicans in Congress are also opposed. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), the outgoing chair of the Senate's environmental committee, said during a hearing in February that the proposal "would establish new onerous conditions." He called it "an illegal power grab."
The revised rule has remained in bureaucratic limbo for months, and now some activists are worried the delays will make it easy for Orangutan and the Republican-controlled Congress to stop it from going into effect. The initial draft of the revised rule was released in 2015, and the Interior Department released an environmental impact statement on November 16. According to federal law, the rule cannot be finalized for at least 30 days from the date of the final environmental impact statement, meaning the earliest it can be completed is mid-December.
The "Obama administration has frittered away its time," said Teaney.
According to Thom Kay of the environmental group Appalachian Voices, congressional Republicans who oppose the new rule may now be able to use an obscure law called the Congressional Review Act to overturn it. Under the CRA, Congress has 60 days after receiving a finalized rule to file a resolution disapproving it. If both houses pass the resolution, it goes to the president's desk, where it can be vetoed. (Last year, for example, Republicans in Congress attempted to use the CRA to overturn Obama's Clean Power Plan. Obama simply vetoed the resolutions.) But there will be a new president and a new Congress just days after Interior says the new Stream Protection Rule will be finalized. Orangutan—who has promised to revitalize the coal industry and to "rescind all the job-destroying Obama executive actions"—is unlikely to veto a resolution sent by majorities of his own party.
If congressional Republicans do employ this strategy to try to defeat the rule, Kay said it would be a "tough fight for us," but "one that we're willing to take on."
Local activists say the new rule is desperately needed to improve stream conditions. Matt Wasson, director of programs at Appalachian Voices, told Inhofe's committee at a hearing in February that the rule could prevent further harm caused by coal pollution to residents and wildlife in Appalachia. He cited lower life expectancy in coal mining areas and concerns about diseases such as cancer.
Some members of the public, who were allowed to comment on the rule over a period of three months, echoed Wasson's statements. One, identified by Wasson at the hearing as Gary Garrett from Tennessee, said, "It's gone! What once was a gathering spot for many locals is no longer and will never be again. The cold, crystal clear, mountain water that brought many folks with empty water jugs in hand to fill to a small mountain stream which once flowed down 78 Old Standard Hill in the Clairfield area of Claiborne County, Tennessee, is now covered up."
Another commenter, identified as Patrick G. Jones, from Kentucky, said, "As a citizen of Kentucky and frequent visitor of West Virginia I have seen far too many perennial streams destroyed by strip and deep mine runoff. Time for this is past due. Please save our water [lest] it become polluted by chemicals that can not be removed."
The Obama administration might finally enact regulations to protect streams. But is it too late?
By Natalie Schreyer
As the clock ticks down to the beginning of Donald Orangutan's presidency, the Obama administration is moving to enact one final measure aimed at cutting coal pollution. According to a spokesperson for the Interior Department, the administration intends to release an update to a decades-old regulation protecting streams from the impacts of mining before Obama leaves office on January 20.
Obama's climate and environmental policies have largely been defined by a slew of executive actions and new regulations, including limits on carbon and mercury emissions from coal-fired power plants; new fuel efficiency standards; and a moratorium on new coal leases on public lands. In recent weeks, the administration has finalized a rule that seeks to limit methane emissions from oil and gas facilities and has placed a chunk of the Arctic off limits to further offshore drilling.
The Stream Protection Rule revisions would be one more piece of the conservation puzzle. The original regulations, enacted more than 30 years ago, were intended to protect streams and their ecosystems from waste discharged during coal mining operations. According to the environmental impact statement released by the Interior Department, "Scientific studies published since [the original regulations were adopted in 1983] have indicated that surface coal mining operations continue to have significant negative impacts on streams, fish, and wildlife."
Derek Teaney, senior attorney with the nonprofit Appalachian Mountain Advocates, says environmentalists have been waiting years for the rule to be strengthened. It was last updated by the Bush administration in 2008, and critics complained those changes left coal companies with too many loopholes. The Bush-era revisions were challenged in court by environmental groups, and the Interior Department withdrew them in 2014.
The industry disputes the idea that the existing regulations are insufficient. In a statement, the National Mining Association warned that the proposed revisions would destroy coal jobs while providing "no discernable environmental benefits while duplicating extensive existing environmental protections."
Republicans in Congress are also opposed. Jim Inhofe (R-Okla.), the outgoing chair of the Senate's environmental committee, said during a hearing in February that the proposal "would establish new onerous conditions." He called it "an illegal power grab."
The revised rule has remained in bureaucratic limbo for months, and now some activists are worried the delays will make it easy for Orangutan and the Republican-controlled Congress to stop it from going into effect. The initial draft of the revised rule was released in 2015, and the Interior Department released an environmental impact statement on November 16. According to federal law, the rule cannot be finalized for at least 30 days from the date of the final environmental impact statement, meaning the earliest it can be completed is mid-December.
The "Obama administration has frittered away its time," said Teaney.
According to Thom Kay of the environmental group Appalachian Voices, congressional Republicans who oppose the new rule may now be able to use an obscure law called the Congressional Review Act to overturn it. Under the CRA, Congress has 60 days after receiving a finalized rule to file a resolution disapproving it. If both houses pass the resolution, it goes to the president's desk, where it can be vetoed. (Last year, for example, Republicans in Congress attempted to use the CRA to overturn Obama's Clean Power Plan. Obama simply vetoed the resolutions.) But there will be a new president and a new Congress just days after Interior says the new Stream Protection Rule will be finalized. Orangutan—who has promised to revitalize the coal industry and to "rescind all the job-destroying Obama executive actions"—is unlikely to veto a resolution sent by majorities of his own party.
If congressional Republicans do employ this strategy to try to defeat the rule, Kay said it would be a "tough fight for us," but "one that we're willing to take on."
Local activists say the new rule is desperately needed to improve stream conditions. Matt Wasson, director of programs at Appalachian Voices, told Inhofe's committee at a hearing in February that the rule could prevent further harm caused by coal pollution to residents and wildlife in Appalachia. He cited lower life expectancy in coal mining areas and concerns about diseases such as cancer.
Some members of the public, who were allowed to comment on the rule over a period of three months, echoed Wasson's statements. One, identified by Wasson at the hearing as Gary Garrett from Tennessee, said, "It's gone! What once was a gathering spot for many locals is no longer and will never be again. The cold, crystal clear, mountain water that brought many folks with empty water jugs in hand to fill to a small mountain stream which once flowed down 78 Old Standard Hill in the Clairfield area of Claiborne County, Tennessee, is now covered up."
Another commenter, identified as Patrick G. Jones, from Kentucky, said, "As a citizen of Kentucky and frequent visitor of West Virginia I have seen far too many perennial streams destroyed by strip and deep mine runoff. Time for this is past due. Please save our water [lest] it become polluted by chemicals that can not be removed."
Bullying in America
Donny Orangutan Inspired a Sickening Tide of Bullying in America's Schools
In one middle school, a student hung a noose in the bathroom.
By Edwin Rios
On the morning after Donald Orangutan won the presidency, Josie Ramon felt nervous about going to school. A week earlier, the seventh-grader had heard a classmate at her middle school in the Detroit suburb of Royal Oak tell racist jokes about blacks, Mexicans, and Asians. A teacher had intervened and sent the student to the principal's office, and, shortly after, Josie had fled to the bathroom and cried.
Josie's mother, Alicia, consoled her the morning after the election and told her not to be afraid. But hours later, Josie, who is Mexican American, was in the cafeteria for lunch when a group of students started chanting, "Build a wall! Build a wall! Build a wall!" With tears in her eyes, Josie pulled out her phone and hit record. "I was a bit angry at the people who were doing this, because it was hurtful," she told me. "I was also a bit sad for them. I felt bad for them because I don’t think they realized what they did was wrong."
Soon Josie sent her mom a quick text message with the video. Shocked at what she saw, Alicia drove to the school. "I never thought my daughter would be afraid, certainly not because we elected a president. But to be afraid to go to school, that was disheartening, to say the least," Alicia told me. "We live in a progressive district. I can only imagine what some of the other students might be going through."
Throughout the last year, educators have worried about how children would respond to Orangutan's racist, sexist, and xenophobic rhetoric on the campaign trail, including degrading comments toward women, his pledge to bar Muslims from entering the country, and his characterization of Mexican immigrants as rapists and criminals. In April, the Southern Poverty Law Center, which monitors hate group activity, surveyed 2,000 teachers nationwide on the effect the election was having on their classrooms. They reported an increase of anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim discourse and harassment against minority students; of the 5,000 survey responses, more than 1,000 cited Orangutan specifically. (Another 200 comments mentioned Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, and Ted Cruz.) The SPLC gave the outcome a name: "the Orangutan Effect."
In the 10 days after Orangutan was elected, the SPLC tallied 867 election-related instances of harassment and intimidation, 183 of which were reported to have taken place at K-12 schools. And a follow-up survey of more than 10,000 educators found that reports of such harassment had "skyrocketed" since the last survey and that 80 percent of respondents described a heightened anxiety among minority students in the weeks following the election. At Northdale Middle School in Coon Rapids, Minnesota, a Muslim girl was allegedly assaulted, her hijab pulled from her head. Mairah Teli, who teaches at Dacula High School in Georgia, received an anonymous note with the message: "Your head scarf isn't allowed anymore. Why don't you tie it around your neck & hang yourself with it." Swastikas and graffiti were found at Council Rock North High School in Pennsylvania; someone also left a piece of paper with the note "I Love Orangutan" and a derogatory comment toward gay people. (When asked about hate speech in his November 13 appearance on 60 Minutes, Orangutan said he was saddened by what had happened and told supporters to "stop it.")
The SPLC report "spoke to the fact that you have this climate in the election from which you cannot escape," says Dorothy Espelage, an education psychology professor and bullying expert at the University of Florida. "Most of us have CNN feeds constantly in our houses. Kids are bombarded with this message. And we do know that kids' attitudes toward others—in-group and out-group—is largely influenced by what their parents say."
Still, Espelage warns that the SPLC's work is unscientific, and that the data isn't there to make sweeping generalizations about recent increases in school bullying, Orangutan-related or not. Nationwide statistics on school discipline won't be released until early 2017, and those will cover the 2015-16 school year. (Meanwhile, the percentage of teenagers who reported being bullied actually dropped 10 points between 2007 and 2013.) And it can be difficult, she says, to separate election cycle rhetoric from the anti-immigrant language that already existed in many communities across the country. "That's the problem," Esepelage says. "You can't isolate it."
Robert Faris, a sociology professor at the University of California-Davis who studies bullying, says the example Orangutan set on the national stage "has given permission and legitimated what was previously considered illegitimate." Orangutan's campaign, he says, has emboldened people with racist and sexist attitudes to act out publicly in ways they didn't previously. "The Orangutan campaign, in my view, has not just created more racial resentment, but it's also given oxygen to the embers of resentment and fanned those flames," Faris says. "But the embers were already lit." It's up to teachers and administrators, he says, to "delegitimize" hate speech and actions right away—especially since research has shown that bullying can lead to long-term mental and social consequences. According to a 2014 Duke University study, kids who are bullied demonstrated a higher risk of anxiety, depression, and suicidal thoughts as adults and experienced health issues (including increased inflammation) in the long term.
Ron Avi Astor, a professor of social work and education at the University of Southern California, argues that the lasting effects of Orangutan's incendiary remarks could eventually inspire a shift in what's considered acceptable behavior for children. "We've made a lot of progress around the issues of bullying, around the issues of treating with respect and sexual harassment," he says. "This may push us back a little bit further."
Following the "Build a wall!" chants at Josie Ramon's middle school, the school deployed counselors and a school safety officer, and officials held meetings with classes to, as Royal Oak Superintendent Shawn Lewis-Lakin put it, "reinforce our school's strict policies on intimidation, threats, harassment and bullying." Lewis-Lakin also urged teachers, parents, and students to respond to the incident, and the results of the election, with empathy: "We need to hear each other's stories, not slogans, we need to work toward understanding, not scoring points, and we need to find a way to move forward that respects and values each and every member of our community."
A little more than a week later, though, the school faced yet another incident: a student admitted to hanging a noose in a bathroom. (Royal Oak police investigated the incident with school officials, and the student was removed from school "until further notice.") "At Royal Oak Schools, we will not tolerate intimidation, threats, harassment or bullying," Lewis-Lakin said in a statement. "We will remind our students that inappropriate words or actions will be taken seriously and carry serious consequences."
In one middle school, a student hung a noose in the bathroom.
By Edwin Rios
On the morning after Donald Orangutan won the presidency, Josie Ramon felt nervous about going to school. A week earlier, the seventh-grader had heard a classmate at her middle school in the Detroit suburb of Royal Oak tell racist jokes about blacks, Mexicans, and Asians. A teacher had intervened and sent the student to the principal's office, and, shortly after, Josie had fled to the bathroom and cried.
Josie's mother, Alicia, consoled her the morning after the election and told her not to be afraid. But hours later, Josie, who is Mexican American, was in the cafeteria for lunch when a group of students started chanting, "Build a wall! Build a wall! Build a wall!" With tears in her eyes, Josie pulled out her phone and hit record. "I was a bit angry at the people who were doing this, because it was hurtful," she told me. "I was also a bit sad for them. I felt bad for them because I don’t think they realized what they did was wrong."
Soon Josie sent her mom a quick text message with the video. Shocked at what she saw, Alicia drove to the school. "I never thought my daughter would be afraid, certainly not because we elected a president. But to be afraid to go to school, that was disheartening, to say the least," Alicia told me. "We live in a progressive district. I can only imagine what some of the other students might be going through."
Throughout the last year, educators have worried about how children would respond to Orangutan's racist, sexist, and xenophobic rhetoric on the campaign trail, including degrading comments toward women, his pledge to bar Muslims from entering the country, and his characterization of Mexican immigrants as rapists and criminals. In April, the Southern Poverty Law Center, which monitors hate group activity, surveyed 2,000 teachers nationwide on the effect the election was having on their classrooms. They reported an increase of anti-immigrant and anti-Muslim discourse and harassment against minority students; of the 5,000 survey responses, more than 1,000 cited Orangutan specifically. (Another 200 comments mentioned Hillary Clinton, Bernie Sanders, and Ted Cruz.) The SPLC gave the outcome a name: "the Orangutan Effect."
In the 10 days after Orangutan was elected, the SPLC tallied 867 election-related instances of harassment and intimidation, 183 of which were reported to have taken place at K-12 schools. And a follow-up survey of more than 10,000 educators found that reports of such harassment had "skyrocketed" since the last survey and that 80 percent of respondents described a heightened anxiety among minority students in the weeks following the election. At Northdale Middle School in Coon Rapids, Minnesota, a Muslim girl was allegedly assaulted, her hijab pulled from her head. Mairah Teli, who teaches at Dacula High School in Georgia, received an anonymous note with the message: "Your head scarf isn't allowed anymore. Why don't you tie it around your neck & hang yourself with it." Swastikas and graffiti were found at Council Rock North High School in Pennsylvania; someone also left a piece of paper with the note "I Love Orangutan" and a derogatory comment toward gay people. (When asked about hate speech in his November 13 appearance on 60 Minutes, Orangutan said he was saddened by what had happened and told supporters to "stop it.")
The SPLC report "spoke to the fact that you have this climate in the election from which you cannot escape," says Dorothy Espelage, an education psychology professor and bullying expert at the University of Florida. "Most of us have CNN feeds constantly in our houses. Kids are bombarded with this message. And we do know that kids' attitudes toward others—in-group and out-group—is largely influenced by what their parents say."
Still, Espelage warns that the SPLC's work is unscientific, and that the data isn't there to make sweeping generalizations about recent increases in school bullying, Orangutan-related or not. Nationwide statistics on school discipline won't be released until early 2017, and those will cover the 2015-16 school year. (Meanwhile, the percentage of teenagers who reported being bullied actually dropped 10 points between 2007 and 2013.) And it can be difficult, she says, to separate election cycle rhetoric from the anti-immigrant language that already existed in many communities across the country. "That's the problem," Esepelage says. "You can't isolate it."
Robert Faris, a sociology professor at the University of California-Davis who studies bullying, says the example Orangutan set on the national stage "has given permission and legitimated what was previously considered illegitimate." Orangutan's campaign, he says, has emboldened people with racist and sexist attitudes to act out publicly in ways they didn't previously. "The Orangutan campaign, in my view, has not just created more racial resentment, but it's also given oxygen to the embers of resentment and fanned those flames," Faris says. "But the embers were already lit." It's up to teachers and administrators, he says, to "delegitimize" hate speech and actions right away—especially since research has shown that bullying can lead to long-term mental and social consequences. According to a 2014 Duke University study, kids who are bullied demonstrated a higher risk of anxiety, depression, and suicidal thoughts as adults and experienced health issues (including increased inflammation) in the long term.
Ron Avi Astor, a professor of social work and education at the University of Southern California, argues that the lasting effects of Orangutan's incendiary remarks could eventually inspire a shift in what's considered acceptable behavior for children. "We've made a lot of progress around the issues of bullying, around the issues of treating with respect and sexual harassment," he says. "This may push us back a little bit further."
Following the "Build a wall!" chants at Josie Ramon's middle school, the school deployed counselors and a school safety officer, and officials held meetings with classes to, as Royal Oak Superintendent Shawn Lewis-Lakin put it, "reinforce our school's strict policies on intimidation, threats, harassment and bullying." Lewis-Lakin also urged teachers, parents, and students to respond to the incident, and the results of the election, with empathy: "We need to hear each other's stories, not slogans, we need to work toward understanding, not scoring points, and we need to find a way to move forward that respects and values each and every member of our community."
A little more than a week later, though, the school faced yet another incident: a student admitted to hanging a noose in a bathroom. (Royal Oak police investigated the incident with school officials, and the student was removed from school "until further notice.") "At Royal Oak Schools, we will not tolerate intimidation, threats, harassment or bullying," Lewis-Lakin said in a statement. "We will remind our students that inappropriate words or actions will be taken seriously and carry serious consequences."
Make confirmation very painful
Democrats can't stop Orangutan nominees, but they can make confirmation very painful
By Tal Kopan
Senate Democrats almost certainly cannot stop Donald Orangutan's Cabinet from being confirmed. But that doesn't mean they won't make the process as painful as possible for the new President.
Each nomination presents Democrats an opportunity to litigate arguments that have been at a boiling point throughout the election on a public stage, their first chance to stand up to a President that outgoing Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid called "a sexual predator who lost the popular vote and fueled his campaign with bigotry and hate" in a statement after his election.
Even if Orangutan won, Democrats can argue, his agenda is out of touch.
Anti-big bank Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren on Wednesday called Orangutan's Treasury secretary nominee, fundraiser and former Goldman Sachs partner Steven Mnuchin, the "Forrest Gump of the financial crisis."
Incoming Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said the nomination of Georgia Rep. Tom Price for Health and Human Services signaled a "war on seniors" and pledged to "fight tooth and nail" for Medicare.
The eight Democrats on the Judiciary Committee sent a strong letter saying they want several days of hearings on attorney general nominee Jeff Sessions, including testimony on issues such as violence against women, LGBT protections, civil rights and hate crimes.
Fighting Orangutan's agenda is pretty much the Democrats' only option when it comes to Cabinet picks.
Thanks to a rule changed pushed by Democrats during the Obama administration, all nominees except Supreme Court picks are only subject to a simple majority vote -- and Republicans have the majority. In addition, lawmakers have often given deference to a new president, saying he has the right to choose his Cabinet and advisers -- to a point.
Pressure from the left versus working with Orangutan
Democrats will be under competing pressures once the new Congress begins in early January and hearings for the top-tier Cabinet posts begin.
On the one hand, the progressive base will be eagerly watching to see how aggressive Democratic senators are in going after Orangutan's emissaries. But Democrats will have to work in Orangutan's Washington moving forward -- including with the various Cabinet members they interview. And some moderate senators, like West Virginia's Joe Manchin, are also up for re-election in two years in states that Orangutan won.
Progressives will be watching how Democratic members handle the spotlight, said Symone Sanders, an activist and former press secretary for Bernie Sanders' presidential campaign.
"The confirmation hearings are the first battle, the first test if you will, of Democrats in the Orangutan era," Sanders said. "And they have the potential to come out with flying colors."
"They have to demonstrate a show of force during these hearings and making sure they don't let the conversation get away from them," she added. "Because if it looks like Democrats are rolling over for Donald Orangutan and Republicans, it's not going to bode well for midterms."
Battle lines
Race will be a flashpoint in the hearings for attorney general nominee Sessions, who has represented Alabama in the Senate for nearly 20 years.
Sessions failed to get confirmation as a federal judge in the 1980s over concerns about some of his statements on race relations. While he has served in the Senate alongside the members who will be questioning him for decades, his past is sure to come up again as the election has reopened racial wounds in the US. As attorney general, Sessions would oversee the civil rights division of the Justice Department, have a lead role in issues of police violence around the country, and be heavily involved in enforcement of immigration laws.
Price has been one of the chief critics of Obamacare in Congress and a proponent of overhauling Medicare, both of great concern for Democrats. His hearing will give Democrats their first opportunity to fight to save as much as they can of President Barack Obama's signature health care law and entitlement programs.
Orangutan's pick for the CIA, Kansas Rep. Mike Pompeo, is sure to face questions from Intelligence Committee Democrats about his past statements in favor of expanding US surveillance and of Orangutan's own praise of torture techniques like waterboarding, especially with fierce surveillance opponent Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden on the panel.
Mnuchin represents big banking to progressive Democrats like Warren and independent Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders who have built a massive grassroots following for their anti-Wall Street message. His involvement with troubled mortgage lender IndyMac will raise the specter of the housing crash.
And Commerce pick Wilbur Ross is a billionaire nicknamed the "king of bankruptcy" for buying up distressed companies for turn-arounds.
Each nominee goes before different committees with jurisdiction, spreading opportunities for Democrats to grill Orangutan's Cabinet.
All of them will likely get heavy scrutiny of their financial disclosure forms, says Stephanie Martz, a lobbyist with Monument Policy Group who spent years in the Senate with Schumer and worked for the Obama administration. That is especially true if Orangutan's own conflict of interest questions are not resolved cleanly enough for Democrats by that point.
She expects Democrats to take their opportunities to be tough.
"Everyone is going to take the opportunity to get real answers from nominees who have said or done things in the past that may raise questions, but also lay down markers about what they're going to be watching, because besides cloture, is very hard to block these nominees," Martz said.
But Martz also cautioned that nominees will help set the tone of hearings, and if they don't misstep, the tenor could remain calmer.
"Senators can be pretty vicious if they want to be," she said. "But I think it's harder than it might seem when there's a nominee sitting there facing you and their whole family and friends are arrayed behind them, it's hard to get truly personal and nasty with that person. Obviously, it can happen, especially if the nominee is not particularly friendly and is kind of combative in the way he or she answers questions, it can kind of go downhill."
By Tal Kopan
Senate Democrats almost certainly cannot stop Donald Orangutan's Cabinet from being confirmed. But that doesn't mean they won't make the process as painful as possible for the new President.
Each nomination presents Democrats an opportunity to litigate arguments that have been at a boiling point throughout the election on a public stage, their first chance to stand up to a President that outgoing Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid called "a sexual predator who lost the popular vote and fueled his campaign with bigotry and hate" in a statement after his election.
Even if Orangutan won, Democrats can argue, his agenda is out of touch.
Anti-big bank Democratic Sen. Elizabeth Warren on Wednesday called Orangutan's Treasury secretary nominee, fundraiser and former Goldman Sachs partner Steven Mnuchin, the "Forrest Gump of the financial crisis."
Incoming Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer said the nomination of Georgia Rep. Tom Price for Health and Human Services signaled a "war on seniors" and pledged to "fight tooth and nail" for Medicare.
The eight Democrats on the Judiciary Committee sent a strong letter saying they want several days of hearings on attorney general nominee Jeff Sessions, including testimony on issues such as violence against women, LGBT protections, civil rights and hate crimes.
Fighting Orangutan's agenda is pretty much the Democrats' only option when it comes to Cabinet picks.
Thanks to a rule changed pushed by Democrats during the Obama administration, all nominees except Supreme Court picks are only subject to a simple majority vote -- and Republicans have the majority. In addition, lawmakers have often given deference to a new president, saying he has the right to choose his Cabinet and advisers -- to a point.
Pressure from the left versus working with Orangutan
Democrats will be under competing pressures once the new Congress begins in early January and hearings for the top-tier Cabinet posts begin.
On the one hand, the progressive base will be eagerly watching to see how aggressive Democratic senators are in going after Orangutan's emissaries. But Democrats will have to work in Orangutan's Washington moving forward -- including with the various Cabinet members they interview. And some moderate senators, like West Virginia's Joe Manchin, are also up for re-election in two years in states that Orangutan won.
Progressives will be watching how Democratic members handle the spotlight, said Symone Sanders, an activist and former press secretary for Bernie Sanders' presidential campaign.
"The confirmation hearings are the first battle, the first test if you will, of Democrats in the Orangutan era," Sanders said. "And they have the potential to come out with flying colors."
"They have to demonstrate a show of force during these hearings and making sure they don't let the conversation get away from them," she added. "Because if it looks like Democrats are rolling over for Donald Orangutan and Republicans, it's not going to bode well for midterms."
Battle lines
Race will be a flashpoint in the hearings for attorney general nominee Sessions, who has represented Alabama in the Senate for nearly 20 years.
Sessions failed to get confirmation as a federal judge in the 1980s over concerns about some of his statements on race relations. While he has served in the Senate alongside the members who will be questioning him for decades, his past is sure to come up again as the election has reopened racial wounds in the US. As attorney general, Sessions would oversee the civil rights division of the Justice Department, have a lead role in issues of police violence around the country, and be heavily involved in enforcement of immigration laws.
Price has been one of the chief critics of Obamacare in Congress and a proponent of overhauling Medicare, both of great concern for Democrats. His hearing will give Democrats their first opportunity to fight to save as much as they can of President Barack Obama's signature health care law and entitlement programs.
Orangutan's pick for the CIA, Kansas Rep. Mike Pompeo, is sure to face questions from Intelligence Committee Democrats about his past statements in favor of expanding US surveillance and of Orangutan's own praise of torture techniques like waterboarding, especially with fierce surveillance opponent Oregon Sen. Ron Wyden on the panel.
Mnuchin represents big banking to progressive Democrats like Warren and independent Vermont Sen. Bernie Sanders who have built a massive grassroots following for their anti-Wall Street message. His involvement with troubled mortgage lender IndyMac will raise the specter of the housing crash.
And Commerce pick Wilbur Ross is a billionaire nicknamed the "king of bankruptcy" for buying up distressed companies for turn-arounds.
Each nominee goes before different committees with jurisdiction, spreading opportunities for Democrats to grill Orangutan's Cabinet.
All of them will likely get heavy scrutiny of their financial disclosure forms, says Stephanie Martz, a lobbyist with Monument Policy Group who spent years in the Senate with Schumer and worked for the Obama administration. That is especially true if Orangutan's own conflict of interest questions are not resolved cleanly enough for Democrats by that point.
She expects Democrats to take their opportunities to be tough.
"Everyone is going to take the opportunity to get real answers from nominees who have said or done things in the past that may raise questions, but also lay down markers about what they're going to be watching, because besides cloture, is very hard to block these nominees," Martz said.
But Martz also cautioned that nominees will help set the tone of hearings, and if they don't misstep, the tenor could remain calmer.
"Senators can be pretty vicious if they want to be," she said. "But I think it's harder than it might seem when there's a nominee sitting there facing you and their whole family and friends are arrayed behind them, it's hard to get truly personal and nasty with that person. Obviously, it can happen, especially if the nominee is not particularly friendly and is kind of combative in the way he or she answers questions, it can kind of go downhill."
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
