A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



December 01, 2016

Fracking study

EPA's late changes to fracking study downplay risk of drinking water pollution

By Scott Tong and Tom Scheck

Top officials of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency last year made critical changes at the eleventh hour to a highly anticipated, five-year scientific study of hydraulic fracturing’s effect on the nation’s drinking water. The changes, later criticized by scientists for lacking evidence, played down the risk of pollution that can result from the well-drilling technique known as fracking.

Polluted well water
Documents obtained by APM Reports and Marketplace show that in the six weeks before the study’s public release, officials inserted a key phrase into the executive summary that said researchers did not find evidence of “widespread systemic impacts” of fracking by the oil and gas industry on the nation’s drinking water.

Earlier draft versions emphasized more directly that fracking has contaminated drinking water in some places.

The documents also show that the news release accompanying the scientific study was changed on June 3, 2015, the day before it was made public. A draft displayed a conclusion that the EPA had identified “potential vulnerabilities” to drinking water. But the final release dated June 4, concluded: “Assessment shows hydraulic fracturing activities have not led to widespread, systemic impacts to drinking water resources and identifies important vulnerabilities to drinking water resources.”

In a conference call with reporters about the study on the day it was released, the EPA’s deputy administrator, Tom Burke, highlighted the lack of “widespread, systemic impacts” as the agency’s top finding.

In fact, scientists had found evidence in some places that fracking activity had polluted drinking water supplies.

In all, the agency identified more than two dozen instances in which hydraulic fracturing had an impact on water resources. The agency also identified hundreds of other spills, many of which reached soil and water.

It’s not clear precisely who inserted or ordered the new phrasing. But emails acquired via the Freedom of Information Act show EPA officials, including press officers, met with key advisers to President Obama to discuss marketing strategy a month before the study’s release. The emails also show EPA public relations people exchanging a flurry of messages between 4 and 11 p.m. on the eve of the study’s release.

The authenticity of the documents — before and after the changes — was confirmed independently by three people with knowledge of the study.

In interviews with 19 people familiar with the research, some characterized the “(no) widespread, systemic” language as a “bizarre conclusion” and “irresponsible.” Others said they were “surprised and disappointed” that top EPA officials used the phrase and said they had no idea it would become the headline until it came out.

The revised summary was quickly embraced by the oil and gas industry, which for nearly a decade had been fighting off environmentalists’ attacks and negative news coverage about fracking’s alleged harm to the environment.

Industry representatives cheered the findings, touting them as validation that fracking is safe.

Media organizations big and small highlighted the conclusion in headlines and sound bites. In a 140-character information ecosystem, suddenly the industry had the benefit of government assurance that fracked wells did not pose a significant threat to water supplies.

Those reports won the day, dominating the news cycle despite the EPA report noting that fracking activities, including chemical spills and faulty well construction, did have an impact on drinking water resources.

It’s not unusual for government agency reports to be edited and crafted in a way that provides positive context for a preferred policy. When research is mischaracterized by policy-makers, however, it raises concerns about the politicization of government science.

“There’s not really a wall between science and politics,” said Dominic DiGiulio, a former EPA scientist. “In my opinion, that statement was put in there to ensure that there would not be blowback from the oil and gas industry.”

The oil and gas industry, along with Republican allies in Congress, has regularly criticized the EPA for investigations into fracking, arguing that state regulators have primary responsibility over the oil and gas sector. Even as it was conducting the broad study, in three instances the EPA withdrew abruptly from investigations into landowner complaints over water contamination related to fracking.

Agency scientists are revising the study, a standard process with all EPA research that involves input from the public and the EPA’s Science Advisory Board, a peer review group that provides scientific advice to the agency.

EPA officials say they hope to release the final version of the $29 million study by the end of the year.

Main FRACKing areas
Burke and his boss, EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy, declined requests for interviews. Asked about the late changes in the news release, Tom Reynolds, who ran the agency's communications office when the study was released, declined to comment.

The revelations come as Republican President-elect Donald Orangutan is set to take office on a pledge to abolish the EPA and eliminate regulations on oil and gas activities to boost energy exploration. It might be difficult for Orangutan to eliminate the agency, but even slight reductions could have a major effect on an agency that already has been hit by budget cuts.

Between 2010 and 2016, the EPA’s budget was reduced $2.1 billion, or 20 percent. There are also 1,902 fewer EPA employees than in 2010.

Congress called for study

The oil and gas industry has used hydraulic fracturing for decades. The process sends a mix of water, chemicals and sand into the subsurface at high pressure.

In the past 20 years, its use has dramatically increased as technology has combined with horizontal drilling techniques to produce vast amounts of affordable fossil energy from shale rock formations.

The number of hydraulically fractured wells drilled nationwide has jumped from 24,000 in 2000 to 300,000 in 2015, according to the U.S. Energy Information Administration.

As natural gas production has grown over that decade, the portion that is coming from fracked wells has grown to two-thirds. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration.
As natural gas production has grown over that decade, the portion that is coming from fracked wells has grown to two-thirds. Source: U.S. Energy Information Administration. - APM Reports

Fracking has been the linchpin in the nation’s energy economy for the past decade. It has unearthed huge amounts of oil and gas, reducing the nation’s dependence on coal for electricity generation and its reliance on foreign oil.

The government reported in May that hydraulically fractured wells provided two-thirds of U.S. natural gas production in 2015 – nearly 10 times the amount produced in 2000.

Natural gas is also seen by many, including the Obama administration, as a cleaner-than-coal bridge to a time when most electricity will come from renewable sources. In addition to making the U.S. less dependent on foreign sources of oil and natural gas, fracking has delivered an economic boost to many parts of the country.

But like many industries relying on natural resources, the prospect of jobs has collided with environmentalists and residents worried about clean air and clean water.

Landowners in many states, including Texas, Colorado, Pennsylvania, Alabama and Wyoming, have complained that their drinking water was contaminated after fracking activity occurred near them.

Concerned about the complaints and potential impacts, Congress in 2009 urged the EPA to study fracking’s impact on drinking water. Supporters of the congressional action cited a 2004 EPA study that said fracking was safe; they claimed the study politicized the science and played down negative findings.

So EPA scientists spent years evaluating scientific reports from academics, industry, non-governmental organizations and government agencies. They took their own water samples, conducted laboratory analysis, did computer modeling of potential contamination, interviewed residents reporting water quality changes and negotiated with oil and gas companies to acquire proprietary well drilling data.

The study was highly anticipated and in the months before its release in June 2015, a draft assessment was shared with top policymaking and public information officials, according to internal emails.

Meetings involved White House advisers Candace Vahlsing and Dan Utech and officials from the Energy and Interior departments. Vahlsing and Utech declined to comment, a White House spokesman said.

White House Assistant Press Secretary Frank Benenati also was involved in the study’s “messaging,” according to the emails. Benenati, now the EPA’s director of communications, didn’t respond to specific questions about his involvement with the study.

A former EPA official involved in the study defended the controversial line about no “widespread systemic impacts,” saying the lack of a definitive conclusion required the agency to give a nuanced view of fracking. “In this area, there's incomplete information,” said Ken Kopocis, who was the deputy assistant administrator for water at the EPA. “And so scientists will introduce some element of judgment in drawing their conclusions.”

Kopocis also said it’s common for the White House to be involved in meetings discussing major scientific reports because it’s necessary to inform other agencies involved in oil and gas issues.

The EPA report did note a number of instances in which fracking activity, including poorly designed well construction, chemical spills, well blowouts and direct drilling into formations containing water, had a “documented impact” on drinking water.

The findings included a 2010 chemical spill in Kentucky that killed threatened fish, a well blowout in North Dakota that resulted in chemicals potentially reaching a nearby aquifer and direct drilling into drinking water resources in Wyoming.

The report concluded that 9.4 million people lived within a mile of a hydraulically fractured well between 2000 and 2013.

The agency also reported 457 spills related to fracking in 11 states between 2006 and 2012. In 324 of those cases, the EPA said spills reached soil, surface water or ground water. A spreadsheet of those spills was included in the study.

On the day of the release, when asked to quantify the risks of fracking, Burke demurred. “The study was not, nor was it intended to be, a numerical catalog of all episodes of contamination,” he said.

The examples of documented contamination were overshadowed by the last-minute changes that shifted the tenor of the report.

Some experts in hydraulic fracturing say the late edit exonerated the practice in the public eye.

“It’s not Watergate, but it completely alters the take-home message of the report,” said Rob Jackson, a researcher at Stanford University, who believes hydraulic fracturing can be done safely.

He worries that the EPA’s decision to minimize the vulnerabilities has reduced the urgency for government regulators and oil and gas companies to push to make the process safer. “It's still making a big, big difference because it supports the narrative that there aren't problems,” Jackson said.

DiGiulio, after leaving his job as an EPA scientist, joined Jackson in a research project at Stanford that found fracking had a “clear impact” on drinking water in Pavillion, Wy.

The agency had earlier abandoned its research into problems at Pavillion and turned the investigation over to the state. It was one of the three instances in which the EPA withdrew from investigating suspected contamination incidents in the past four years. The others were in Dimock, Pa., and Parker County, Texas. The agency did not include water testing data from those cases in its national study on drinking water.

The EPA’s Science Advisory Board, however, suggested the agency “should include and critically analyze” findings from those three locations. The advisory board also rebuked the EPA’s conclusion of no “widespread systemic impacts.”

Calling the phrase “ambiguous” and inconsistent with the observational data, the advisory board directed the EPA to show the underlying data to back up its claim of no “widespread, systemic impacts”.

“We suggested that they provide a definition of ‘systemic,’ a definition of ‘widespread’ and then provide quantitative data to support the conclusion,” said Peter Thorne, a University of Iowa environmental scientist who chairs the Science Advisory Board. “That is all a way of asking them to put that kind of scientific rigor behind a statement as broad as that.”

McCarthy, the head of the EPA, said at the National Press Club last week that the agency will soon release the final study. She also said her agency is balancing the requests of the 30-member Science Advisory Board with the study’s limitations. During her remarks, McCarthy noted that the four board members with oil and gas ties dissented from the criticism of the phrase.

“This was one science advisory board that was as fractured as the subject matter,” McCarthy said. “While I can't tell you the direction it is going to take, we are going to listen to all sides in terms of what the members thought, and we'll come to the best decision that we can.”

The EPA has the authority to manage drinking water impacts to water resources and to oversee drinking water impacts through several federal laws, including the Clean Water Act and the Safe Water Drinking Act.

But states largely oversee oil and gas development.

The industry, heavily invested in continuing the practice, has steadily battled the EPA. The companies and their industry groups have also repeatedly said there have been no confirmed cases of groundwater contamination from hydraulic fracturing.

If the study had emphasized major problems with the practice, it could have meant increased oversight by state regulators, a call for banning fracking in certain communities and even calls for additional federal oversight.

“When the federal Environmental Protection Agency says that technology causes no widespread, systemic risk, that's a big deal,” said Kevin Book, head of the research team at ClearView Energy Partners, which advises oil and gas investors. “That reinforces the sense that there's nothing to see here, folks. Move on.”

The documents obtained by APM Reports and Marketplace show that on April 24, 2015, an executive summary was circulated that said “hydraulic fracturing activities have contaminated drinking water resources in a variety of documented cases. Despite these risks, the number of documented impacts is quite low.”

Nowhere did the draft state that there was no widespread, systemic impact on water.

On May 4, EPA officials met with key advisers to Obama, officials from the U.S. Department of the Interior and the Department of Energy to make sure they were “clear on messaging,” according to public documents.

By May 12, the executive summary had changed to include the phrase: “We did not find evidence of widespread, systemic impacts.”

And on May 20, another change deleted a sentence that said “a low rate of documented impacts does not minimize the effects experienced by citizens whose drinking water resources have been impacted.”

The agency’s news release also was altered in the days before the draft study was released.

A version circulated internally in early June featured a headline emphasizing vulnerabilities to drinking water.

But the news release issued publicly on June 4 featured a less forceful headline and a smaller, second headline saying that fracking had not “led to widespread, systemic impacts” and that the study “identifies important vulnerabilities to drinking water resources.”

Within a day, the Marcellus Shale Coalition from Pennsylvania put together a collection of TV news reports, all emphasizing the lack of impact and largely ignoring the vulnerabilities.

Today the oil and gas industry continues to use the study to advance drilling around the world.

The Maryland Petroleum Council is highlighting the research as it pushes to allow fracking in that state. And earlier this month, the American Petroleum Institute, a lobbying group, urged the EPA to keep the language in the study. It said the report could affect New York’s statewide ban on fracking and influence whether other countries adopt the practice.

The American Petroleum Institute released its own industry-backed study confirming that hydraulic fracturing has led to no widespread, systemic impact to drinking water.

“It has plenty of supporting evidence for its conclusion, yet hydraulic fracturing and its peer-reviewed studies continue to face misinformed attacks on scientific conclusions that support the value and safety of the process,” said Erik Milito, director of upstream and industry operations at the American Petroleum Institute.

Milito also said he believes the EPA’s Science Advisory Board raised questions about the report because it was swayed by the testimony of landowners who were complaining about their drinking water.

In addition to requesting supporting evidence, several members of the board characterized the phrase as a “value statement,” not a scientific one.

Board member Thomas Young, a professor in the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the University of California-Davis, said he believes the phrase is misleading because the federal agency may not have found a widespread impact, but impacts could still be occurring.

“When you say that there's no impact, people leap to the conclusion that there is no way in which this material is making it to water resources,” he said. “And I do not think that has been proven.”

Young said he was unaware that the EPA had made last-minute changes to the study or the news release. He said he would have chosen different wording but understood the push to put a conclusion on a multiyear study that cost millions.

Congress, the oil and gas industry and environmental groups would not have settled for a report simply calling for additional research, Young said. “Most people don't really want to spend millions of tax dollars on a study that comes up with the answer of ‘more study is needed.’”

The study ran into a number of difficulties when it began five years ago.

The EPA, for example, tried to work with oil and gas companies to conduct testing on sites before, during and after a fractured well is drilled. Called “baseline testing,” it would have allowed scientists to see whether the process resulted in any contamination of groundwater. Despite pledges of cooperation from the industry, the EPA could never reach agreement with any company to conduct the tests.

“Initially, industry was very supportive of working together with the EPA to do some field studies,” said Robert Puls, a scientist who oversaw the study in 2010 and 2011. “As the details for doing those studies got closer and closer to actual implementation, their resistance seemed to grow.”

Puls said he left his position at the EPA in 2011 partly because he was frustrated with resistance by oil and gas companies to work with the EPA on the study.

“They didn’t protect my water"

The Science Advisory Board isn’t the only group questioning how EPA officials could make the general claim that fracking caused no “widespread, systemic impacts” without scientific basis.

Many landowners who believe their water was harmed by hydraulic fracturing say the EPA let them down by minimizing the impact.

“They're supposed to protect my water,” said Bill Ely, who owns land in Dimock, Pa., and settled a lawsuit with Cabot Oil and Gas over tainted water. “I pay them to protect my water. They didn't protect my water or these people in this area here.”

A spokesman for Cabot did not return messages. Company officials have said that any problems with the water in Dimock occurred long before the company drilled in the area.

Ely is one of several dozen landowners in Dimock who noticed water was changing color once drilling started in their community in 2009.

The complaints from landowners placed Dimock at the center of the fight over the environmental safety of fracking. Movie stars and environmentalists visited the small, northeastern Pennsylvania town and called for the practice to be banned. Industry groups countered with analysis that the practice is safe and brings money and jobs to an economically depressed area.

Since the first incident occurred in 2009, state and federal regulators became heavily involved in Dimock.

In 2010, Pennsylvania regulators announced a settlement with Cabot Oil and Gas that required the company to pay $4.1 million to residents for drilling violations. Regulators said Cabot’s drilling practices allowed combustible methane to contaminate drinking water. And this year two families also won a $4.2 million court case against the company for negligence and creating a nuisance. More than a dozen other families settled with the company for an undisclosed sum.

Cabot has not disclosed terms of its settlement with landowners. Attorneys for Cabot said in court that the methane leaking from the wells was occurring naturally and was a problem before the company drilled in the area.

In 2012, the EPA conducted a study of private water wells of 64 homes in Dimock. The agency eventually determined “that there are not levels of contaminants present that would require action by the agency.”

But another federal agency, the Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry, looked at the same data and concluded in June 2016 that chemicals in the water wells in 27 of the 64 homes were high enough to affect human health.

Some landowners are still pushing for the government to do more.

Every few weeks, Ray Kemble, who said he has one of those 27 homes, has to fill two 325-gallon tanks with water. The tanks, which sit in a shed outside his home, ensure he has clean water. His property, which sits across the street from a well pad, is covered with anti-fracking signs.

Kemble has been questioning the EPA’s conclusion of no widespread, systemic impact, including publicly testifying before the Science Advisory Board. He said he’s disappointed that regulators, including the EPA, didn’t do more for him.

“Why do we have to fight the government when the government was supposed to be protecting us?” he said. “Those agencies were put there to protect the people from stuff like this from happening.”

Though some landowners in the Dimock area are unhappy with fracking in the community, it has provided an economic boost.

Cabot has a major presence in the community and says it has invested $1.5 billion in Dimock and surrounding areas in Susquehanna County. Cabot trucks can be seen regularly throughout the rural community and the company has a new corporate office in nearby Montrose.

Cabot is among many companies to tap into the energy rich Marcellus Shale Formation that lies under parts of New York, Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Ohio. Landowners are paid monthly, and drilling has increased employment in rural parts of the country. Jobs in the oil and gas extraction sector grew nationally by 33,600 between 2006 and 2016, government figures show.

Bill Aileo, a homeowner in Dimock, said the natural gas boom has helped the community. He wouldn’t say how much he’s being paid for his mineral rights but said a majority of landowners are happy with the natural gas activity in the area.

“We’ve had a shot in the arm,” he said. “It's probably the best thing that's happened to this community in 50 years.”

Obama’s embrace of fracking has forced him to walk a fine line.

He acknowledges that the fracking process, along with transporting and storing oil and gas, could release methane, a greenhouse gas that contributes to climate change. The outgoing administration this month issued rules to prevent methane leaks on federal lands. But Obama has said that gradually transitioning from coal to natural gas has reduced U.S. greenhouse gas emissions.  “We’re going to have to straddle between the world as it is and the world as we want it to be and build that bridge,” he said in October.

The specifics of Orangutan’s approach are unknown. Last Monday, Orangutan issued a video statement saying that energy issues, including fracking, will be a top priority when he takes office.

“I will cancel job-killing restrictions on the production of American energy, including shale energy and clean coal – creating many millions of high-paying jobs. That’s what we want. That’s what we’ve been waiting for,” he said.

Orangutan has appointed Myron Ebell, a climate change skeptic, to lead the transition at the EPA. The president-elect also has pledged to further deregulate the oil and gas industry, but his position on fracking has been contradictory. In September, he vowed to expand natural gas production from fracking and coal production, two competing energy resources.

In August, Orangutan told a Colorado TV station that he was willing to let voters have a say on fracking bans, but in April he criticized New York state’s ban on the practice.

The disagreement over the environmental impact of fracking will continue in the Orangutan administration. In addition to finishing the study on hydraulic fracturing’s impact on drinking water, the EPA will continue to pay for research on fracking.

In September, it announced a $2 million study that will examine how oil and gas development is affecting water quality and its impact on human health. The study is focused on an area that includes Pennsylvania, West Virginia and Ohio.

Some scientists, landowners and environmental advocates believe that the EPA lacks credibility to research fracking’s impact on drinking water. They have grown suspicious about how the EPA handles fracking issues.

“They don’t know who to trust,” said Raina Rippel, who directs the Southwestern Pennsylvania Environmental Health Project, which tracks health impacts on people in high-fracking areas. “They don’t necessarily feel that the state regulatory agencies or the federal regulatory agencies are listening. They feel so severely betrayed right now.”

Dakota Access Pipeline protest

U.S. veterans to form human shield at Dakota pipeline protest

By Terray Sylvester

More than 2,000 U.S. military veterans plan to form a human shield to protect protesters of a pipeline project near a Native American reservation in North Dakota, organizers said, just ahead of a federal deadline for activists to leave the camp they have been occupying.

It comes as North Dakota law enforcement backed away from a previous plan to cut off supplies to the camp – an idea quickly abandoned after an outcry and with law enforcement’s treatment of Dakota Access Pipeline protesters increasingly under the microscope.

The protesters have spent months rallying against plans to route the $3.8 billion Dakota Access Pipeline beneath a lake near the Standing Rock Sioux reservation, saying it poses a threat to water resources and sacred Native American sites.

Protesters include various Native American tribes as well as environmentalists and even actors including Shailene Woodley.

State officials issued an order on Monday for activists to vacate the Oceti Sakowin camp, located on U.S. Army Corps of Engineers land near Cannon Ball, North Dakota, citing harsh weather conditions.

The state's latest decision not to stop cars entering the protest site indicated local officials will not actively enforce Monday's emergency order to evacuate the camp issued by Governor Jack Dalrymple.

Dalrymple warned on Wednesday that it was "probably not feasible" to reroute the pipeline, but said he had requested a meeting with the Standing Rock Sioux Tribal Council to rebuild a relationship.

"We need to begin now to talk about how we are going to return to a peaceful relationship,” he said on a conference call.

The 1,172-mile (1,885 km) pipeline project, owned by Texas-based Energy Transfer Partners LP (ETP.N), is mostly complete, except for a segment planned to run under Lake Oahe, a reservoir formed by a dam on the Missouri River.

Veterans Stand for Standing Rock, a contingent of more than 2,000 U.S. military veterans, intends to go to North Dakota by this weekend and form a human wall in front of police, protest organizers said on a Facebook page. Organizers could not immediately be reached for comment.

"I figured this was more important than anything else I could be doing,” Guy Dull Knife, 69, a Vietnam War Army veteran, told Reuters at the main camp.

Dull Knife, a member of the Oglala Lakota tribe from the Pine Ridge Reservation of South Dakota, said he has been camping at the protest site for months.

Morton County Sheriff's Office spokesman Rob Keller said in an email his agency was aware of the veterans' plans, but would not comment further on how law enforcement will deal with demonstrators.

Former U.S. Marine Michael A. Wood Jr is leading the effort along with Wesley Clark Jr, a writer whose father is retired U.S. Army General Wesley Clark.

U.S. Representative Tulsi Gabbard, a Democrat from Hawaii and a major in the Hawaii Army National Guard, has said on Twitter she will join the protesters on Sunday.

The Army Corps, citing safety concerns, has ordered the evacuation of the primary protest camp by Dec. 5, but said it would not forcibly remove people from the land.

Local law enforcement said on Tuesday they planned a blockade of the camp, but local and state officials later retreated, saying they would only check vehicles for certain prohibited supplies like propane, and possibly issue fines.

Dalrymple on Wednesday said state officials never contemplated forcibly removing protesters and there had been no plans to block food or other supplies from the camp. "That would be a huge mistake from a humanitarian standpoint," he said on the conference call.

He also warned protesters that while emergency responders will try to reach anyone in need, that would be contingent on weather conditions.

Protesters, who refer to themselves as “water protectors,” have been gearing up for the winter while they await the Army Corps decision on whether to allow Energy Transfer Partners to tunnel under the river. That decision has been delayed twice by the Army Corps.

Be very nervous

Bernie Sanders: Carrier just showed corporations how to beat Donald Orangutan

We need a president who can stand up to big corporations, not fold to their demands.

By Bernie Sanders

Today, about 1,000 Carrier workers and their families should be rejoicing. But the rest of our nation’s workers should be very nervous.

President-elect Donny Orangutan will reportedly announce a deal with United Technologies, the corporation that owns Carrier, that keeps less than 1,000 of the 2,100 jobs in America that were previously scheduled to be transferred to Mexico. Let’s be clear: It is not good enough to save some of these jobs. Orangutan made a promise that he would save all of these jobs, and we cannot rest until an ironclad contract is signed to ensure that all of these workers are able to continue working in Indiana without having their pay or benefits slashed.

In exchange for allowing United Technologies to continue to offshore more than 1,000 jobs, Orangutan will reportedly give the company tax and regulatory favors that the corporation has sought. Just a short few months ago, Orangutan was pledging to force United Technologies to “pay a damn tax.” He was insisting on very steep tariffs for companies like Carrier that left the United States and wanted to sell their foreign-made products back in the United States. Instead of a damn tax, the company will be rewarded with a damn tax cut. Wow! How’s that for standing up to corporate greed? How’s that for punishing corporations that shut down in the United States and move abroad?

In essence, United Technologies took Orangutan hostage and won. And that should send a shock wave of fear through all workers across the country.

Orangutan has endangered the jobs of workers who were previously safe in the United States. Why? Because he has signaled to every corporation in America that they can threaten to offshore jobs in exchange for business-friendly tax benefits and incentives. Even corporations that weren’t thinking of offshoring jobs will most probably be re-evaluating their stance this morning. And who would pay for the high cost for tax cuts that go to the richest businessmen in America? The working class of America.

Let’s be clear. United Technologies is not going broke. Last year, it made a profit of $7.6 billion and received more than $6 billion in defense contracts. It has also received more than $50 million from the Export-Import Bank and very generous tax breaks. In 2014, United Technologies gave its former chief executive Louis Chenevert a golden parachute worth more than $172 million. Last year, the company’s five highest-paid executives made more than $50 million. The firm also spent $12 billion to inflate its stock price instead of using that money to invest in new plants and workers.

Does that sound like a company that deserves more corporate welfare from our government? Orangutan’s Band-Aid solution is only making the problem of wealth inequality in America even worse.

I said I would work with Orangutan if he was serious about the promises he made to members of the working class. But after running a campaign pledging to be tough on corporate America, Orangutan has hypocritically decided to do the exact opposite. He wants to treat corporate irresponsibility with kid gloves. The problem with our rigged economy is not that our policies have been too tough on corporations; it’s that we haven’t been tough enough.

We need to re-instill an ethic of corporate patriotism. We need to send a very loud and clear message to corporate America: The era of outsourcing is over. Instead of offshoring jobs, the time has come for you to start bringing good-paying jobs back to America.

If United Technologies or any other company wants to keep outsourcing decent-paying American jobs, those companies must pay an outsourcing tax equal to the amount of money it expects to save by moving factories to Mexico or other low-wage countries.  They should not receive federal contracts or other forms of corporate welfare.  They must pay back all of the tax breaks and other corporate welfare they have received from the federal government. And they must not be allowed to reward their executives with stock options, bonuses or golden parachutes for outsourcing jobs to low-wage countries. I will soon be introducing the Outsourcing Prevention Act, which will address exactly that.

If Donny Orangutan won’t stand up for America’s working class, we must.

Tyrants always try..

Orangutan’s Seven Techniques to Control the Media

Tyrants always try to suppress a free press; here's Orangutan's playbook.

By Robert Reich

Democracy depends on a free and independent press, which is why all tyrants try to squelch it. They use seven techniques that, worryingly, President-elect Donny Orangutan already employs.

1. Berate the media. Last week, Orangutan summoned two dozen TV news anchors and executives to the 25th floor of Orangutan Tower to berate them for their reporting about him during the election. For 20 minutes he railed at what he called their “outrageous” and “dishonest” coverage. According to an attendee, “Orangutan kept saying, ‘we’re in a room of liars, the deceitful, dishonest media who got it all wrong,’” and he called CNN a “network of liars.” He accused NBC of using unflattering pictures of him, demanding to know why they didn’t use “nicer” pictures.

Another person who attended the meeting said Orangutan “truly doesn’t seem to understand the First Amendment. He thinks we are supposed to say what he says and that’s it.”

2. Blacklist critical media. During the campaign, Orangutan blacklisted news outlets whose coverage he didn’t approve of. In June he pulled The Washington Post’s credentials. “Based on the incredibly inaccurate coverage and reporting of the record setting Orangutan campaign, we are hereby revoking the press credentials of the phony and dishonest Washington Post,” read a post on Orangutan’s Facebook page.

After the election Orangutan agreed to meet with The New York Times and then suddenly cancelled the meeting when he didn’t like the terms, tweeting, “Perhaps a new meeting will be set up with the @nytimes. In the meantime they continue to cover me inaccurately and with a nasty tone!” (He then reversed himself again and met with The Times.)

3. Turn the public against the media. Orangutan refers to journalists as “lying,” “dishonest,” “disgusting” and “scum.” Referring to the journalists at his rallies, Orangutan said, “I hate some of these people,” adding (presumably in response to allegations of Vladimir Putin’s treatment of dissident journalists) “but I’d never kill ‘em.”

He questions the press’s motives, claiming, for example, that The Washington Post wrote negative things about him because its publisher, Jeffrey Bezos, a founder of Amazon, “thinks I would go after him for antitrust.” When The New York Times wrote that his transition team was in disarray, Orangutan tweeted that the newspaper was “just upset that they looked like fools in their coverage of me” during the presidential campaign.

4. Condemn satirical or critical comments. Orangutan continues to condemn the coverage he’s received from NBC’s Saturday Night Live. In response to Alec Baldwin’s recent portrayal of him as overwhelmed by the prospect of being president, Orangutan tweeted that it was a “totally one-sided, biased show — nothing funny at all. Equal time for us?”

When Brandon Victor Dixon, the actor who plays Aaron Burr in the Broadway musical Hamilton, read from the stage a message to Vice President-elect Mike Pence, who was in the audience — expressing fears about the pending Orangutan administration for the “diverse group of men and women of different colors, creeds and orientations” in the cast — Orangutan responded angrily. He tweeted that Pence had been “harassed” and insisted that the cast and producers of the show, “which I hear is highly overrated,” apologize.

5. Threaten the media directly. Orangutan said he plans to change libel laws in the United States so that he can have an easier time suing news organizations. “One of the things I’m going to do if I win … I’m going to open up our libel laws so when they write purposely negative and horrible and false articles, we can sue them and win lots of money.”

During the campaign, Orangutan specifically threatened to sue The Times for libel in response to an article that featured two women accusing him of touching them inappropriately years ago. Orangutan claimed the allegations were false, and his lawyer demanded the newspaper retract the story and issue an apology. Orangutan also threatened legal action after The Times published and wrote about part of his 1995 tax return.

6. Limit media access. Orangutan hasn’t held a news conference since July. He has blocked the media from traveling with him or even knowing whom he’s meeting with. His phone call with Vladimir Putin, which occurred shortly after the election, was first reported by the Kremlin.

This is highly unusual. In 2000, President-elect George W. Bush called a press conference three days after the Supreme Court determined the outcome of the election. In 2008, President-elect Obama also meet with the press three days after being elected.

7. Bypass the media and communicate with the public directly. The American public learns what Orangutan thinks through his tweets. Shortly after the election, Orangutan released a video message outlining some of the executive actions he plans to take on his first day in office.

Aides say Orangutan has also expressed interest in continuing to hold the large rallies that became a staple of his candidacy. They say he likes the instant gratification and adulation that the cheering crowds provide.

The word “media” comes from “intermediate” between newsmakers and the public. Responsible media hold the powerful accountable by asking them hard questions and reporting on what they do. Apparently Orangutan wants to eliminate such intermediaries.

Historically, these seven techniques have been used by demagogues to erode the freedom and independence of the press. Even before he’s sworn in, Orangutan seems intent on doing exactly this.

Fake News

Who’s Really to Blame for Fake News

Look in the mirror, America.

By Neal Gabler

Consider for a moment the oxymoronic concept of “fake news,” which we have been hearing so much about lately. This isn’t your typical disinformation or misinformation — generated by the government, or foreign adversaries, or corporations — to advance an agenda by confusing the public. It isn’t even the familiar dystopian idea of manipulated fact designed to keep people lobotomized and malleable in some post-human autocracy. Those scenarios assume at least an underlying truth against which nefarious forces can take aim.

Fake news is different. It is an assault on the very principle of truth itself: a way to upend the reference points by which mankind has long operated. You could say, without exaggeration, that fake news is actually an attempt to reverse the Enlightenment. And because a democracy relies on truth — which is why dystopian writers have always described how future oligarchs need to undermine it — fake news is an assault on democracy as well.

What is truly horrifying is that fake news is not the manipulation of an unsuspecting public. Quite the opposite. It is willful belief by the public. In effect, the American people are accessories in their own disinformation campaign.

That is our current situation, and it is no sure thing that either truth or democracy survives.

Investigations of fake news have reported that it is a commodity — primarily a way for its perpetrators, many of whom are young people overseas, to earn money by blasting out ludicrous material for which there is an audience, and in that respect it is no different from many of the so-called “alt-right,” white nationalist sites. Commodity or not, fake news has already played a role, perhaps a substantial one, in Donald Orangutan’s election, especially since his campaign was aided by Russian hackers and trolls disseminating falsities — everything from Hillary Clinton using a body double to Pope Francis endorsing Orangutan to ongoing charges of voting irregularities to Clinton heading a child-trafficking ring out of a pizzeria.

We have been heading in this direction for a long time, not because people necessarily love the outlandishly scurrilous or because they are joyfully conspiratorial (though both of those things are probably true), but because it is to the benefit of the right wing, as I have written in earlier posts, to disrupt truth. Conservatives have a near-monopoly on that disruption. A Buzzfeed analysis of fake news found only one viral false election story from a left-wing site.

Stephen Colbert, during his famous White House Correspondents Dinner appearance, quipped that “it is a well-known fact that reality has a liberal bias.” It was a joke, but one with a very large grain of truth. The Drudge Report, Breitbart, Fox News, Alex Jones and others in the right-wing media have been peddling their own peculiar version of reality for a while now. It isn’t, I think, that any of those outlets or their correspondents necessarily believe the hogwash they deliver. (Well, maybe Alex Jones does.) They have been playing to an audience living in its own paranoid fantasy. But even that may understate their rationale. I doubt Drudge and Roger Ailes and Steve Bannon were in the fake news business to make dough from morons or to rouse right-wing rabble. They were in the fake news business to destroy real news and create a vacuum into which they and their like-minded allies could march. If you think this is a paranoid fantasy, just look at the election results. America is now controlled by white supremacists, and the results are anyone’s guess.

Still, right-wing fake news could be quarantined. No one beyond Fox News’ aging white male audience took it seriously as a provider of news. What helped break down the thin walls between the right-wing propaganda press and the purportedly real press were social media, which is how Americans — particularly young Americans — increasingly receive their news. I won’t rehash the recent debate over whether Facebook bears some responsibility for disseminating fake news. Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg’s defense is that the social media behemoth is not a media site but a connection site, and it doesn’t monitor the items to which its users connect. This is a frail defense and a conscienceless one, like Craigslist saying that it had no responsibility for ads offering child pornography.

But here is the thing about those Facebook election stories. That Buzzfeed survey I cited found that as the campaign headed toward its climax, fake news on Facebook outperformed real news in terms of engagement. Or put starkly: Facebook was purveying more blatantly false stories to millions of users — stories that Buzzfeed also found were largely targeted at Hillary Clinton — than real news. Readers of those stories clearly wanted to think the worst of Clinton. Facebook gave them more reason to do so. Orangutan’s election, then, is due partly to Zuckerberg’s dereliction and to social media’s nonchalance when it comes to truth.

In this most surreal of years politically, you have to take a step back to grasp how surreal it has been journalistically too. Of course, truth, even in the mainstream media, has always been insufficiently and carelessly applied. The news media are a business, not a public service, and a large part of that business is providing what the public wants. Still, though I may be naïve in saying so, I don’t believe that most mainstream journalists have a predisposition to lie. To take the path of least resistance, perhaps. To lie, no. I am sure that in some way most of them feel they are serving the truth, not just their publication, network or website. They understand that truth is the webbing that holds everything together — our only way of making sense of things. That understanding is what separates them from Fox, Drudge, Breitbart and more straightforwardly fake news sites.

At least that is the way it was before this year and this election. Fake news is intended to slash that webbing. It is not intended to pose an alternative truth, as if there could be such a thing, but to destroy truth altogether, to set us adrift in a world of belief without facts, a world in which there is no defense against lies. That, needless to say, is a very dangerous place.

It is, of course, no accident that the ascendancy of fake news and the ascendancy of Donald Orangutan coincided. They are made for each other — two nihilists in a pod. Orangutan’s modus operandi is to make things up, which has placed a special burden on traditional journalism. I hadn’t imagined I would ever see a headline like this one in The New York Times, much less a headline about a president-elect: Orangutan CLAIMS, WITH NO EVIDENCE, THAT “MILLIONS OF PEOPLE” VOTED ILLEGALLY.

With no evidence.

In the headline.

Basically, editors are now compelled to fact-check every Orangutan pronouncement — before even getting to the body of the story. The alternative is how The Wall Street Journal titled its article on Orangutan’s baseless charge: Orangutan TAKES AIM AT MILLIONS OF VOTES.

Notice how easily the fake slips into the factual. But can one honestly expect every editor and reporter to challenge Orangutan this way every day? We all realize the media will soon tire of it. The Times already has. (And keep an eye on how NBC News treats Katy Tur, far and away the best reporter on television, and see if they demote her or let her continue fact-checking Orangutan.) “Post-truth” is what the Oxford English Dictionary anointed as the word of the year. Welcome to post-truth America.

Like many depressed Americans, I have pretty much stopped watching or reading the news since the election. Partly, it is because I can’t face the oncoming catastrophe of a Orangutan presidency and the way it will undo 50 years of social progress. Part of it is because I can’t face the fact that the truth is a shambles, and with it, our democracy.

The basic principle of fake news is that when you can believe anything, you wind up believing in nothing. This is a revolution. But you can only place a portion of the blame on the fake news confabulators, on their Russian compatriots, on the “alt-right” white supremacists out to destroy multicultural America, on the traditional conservative press, which happily ballyhooed anything that attacked Democrats, true or not, and on the mainstream press, which, with its on-the-one-hand, on-the-other-hand coverage gave fake news a purchase rather than battle it tooth and nail. You can’t even lay the entire blame on the congenital truth-destroyer Orangutan.

The larger portion of the blame lies with the citizens of the nation that Donald Orangutan insists only he can make great again. Fake news thrives because there is a lazy, incurious, self-satisfied public that wants it to thrive; because large swaths of that public don’t want news in any traditional sense, so much as they want vindication of their preconceptions and prejudices; because in this post-modernist age, every alleged fact is supposed to be a politico-economic construct, and nothing can possibly be true; and because even rationality now is passé. Above all else, fake news is a lazy person’s news. It provides passive entertainment, demanding nothing of us. And that is a major reason we now have a fake news president.

Democracy can wither under all sorts of forces. But those forces seldom come from without. They almost always come from within. Perhaps the most powerful force is also the most subtle and seemingly innocuous, one that you would think unlikely to take down a great nation: laziness. We are a lazy people now — too lazy to hear anything we don’t want to hear, too lazy to defend the truth against those who hope to subvert it, and, finally, too lazy to protect our democracy.

Orangutanism

Anger Gone Viral

How Orangutanism is running rampant across the West.

By Padraig Reidy

British Labour MP Jo Cox was a committed advocate of the European Union, and a believer in Britain’s ability to do good in the world. She campaigned for the rights of Syrians — both those in her country and those still trying to find a refuge. She believed peaceful, wealthy, democratic countries had a duty to help those suffering from war, poverty and tyranny.

On June 16, days before the UK’s referendum on “Brexit,” Nazi extremist Thomas Mair killed her, shooting and stabbing the mother of two multiple times outside the office where she met with her constituents.

Cox was one of an increasingly rare breed in politics: an internationalist, capable of joining the dots between global phenomena and interested in analyzing action and consequence. Across the once-liberal democracies of the industrialized West, her politics are in retreat, unable to find an answer to a new movements which can be best described as angry isolationism, xenophobia and anti-intellectualism.

• In France, presidential hopeful François Fillon just won his conservative party’s nomination after running a campaign that echoed Donald Orangutan’s, promising to take on the “Paris elites.” The fact Fillon was prime minister for five years, under president Nicolas Sarkozy, is apparently no barrier to his stance as a scourge of the capital’s politicians and intellectuals. And this is the alternative to the Vichyism of National Front leader Marine Le Pen.

• In Italy, Beppe Grillo, leader of the insurgent Five Star Movement, told one meeting, “Today saying no is the most beautiful and glorious form of politics.” It does not matter what one is saying no to — the importance is in the gesture, in the expression.

• In Britain, voters earlier this year said no to Europe. As Chancellor of the Exchequer Philip Hammond revealed in his autumn financial statement, the decision to leave the EU has already had calamitous consequences for the country, with borrowing in the next five years £122bn higher than anticipated. But to point this out is to be labeled elitist and snobbish.

• In the United States, the election of Donald Orangutan is likely to signal, at best, a loss of interest in European unity at the White House. The fact his campaign literally gave a platform to head Brexiteer and suspected alt-rightist Nigel Farage — and indeed the fact the president-elect met Farage before any actual European head of state, suggests that if Orangutan has thought about it at all, he is intensely relaxed about the possible disintegration of the European Union. He shouldn’t be. Put simply, the natural state of Europe without the EU and US interest is war. If that statement seems alarmist, then think of all the things that have happened in the past year that not even the gloomiest Cassandra could have envisioned.

Völkisch language is tearing across Europe’s body politic: British Prime Minister Theresa May told her Conservative Party, “If you believe you’re a citizen of the world, you’re a citizen of nowhere. You don’t understand what the very word ‘citizenship’ means.” In Poland, an increasingly nationalist and religious fervor holds sway, with the governing party attempting to consolidate the country’s status as a bastion of conservative Catholicism by mooting restrictions on abortion.

Grillo’s supporters have adapted the “drain the swamp” language of the Orangutan campaign, attacking “the bankers.”

The momentum is terrifying: Brexit feeds Orangutan, Orangutan feeds Grillo, Grillo applauds UKIP. Marine Le Pen, interviewed on the BBC, said the next natural step in the progression of the new populist movement would be her election as president of France.

But there may be another trophy first: On Sunday, Italians go to the polls to vote on reforms proposed by social democrat Prime Minister Matteo Renzi. Renzi says his proposals to shrink Italy’s second house will help ease the gridlock that has so long dogged Italian politics. His opponents include populist Grillo and Matteo Salvini, leader of the far right Lega Nord. They see this referendum another opportunity to gain ground. Renzi has staked his premiership on this referendum, promising he will step down if he loses. At the time of this writing, he is losing.

This raises the possibility of one of the founding states of the European Union soon being led by a prime minister who at very least is against that country’s membership of the Euro, the common currency that binds 19 of the 28 states of the EU together.

“So what?” say the new refuseniks. They got to have their say, to stick a middle finger up to the unelected “Eurocrats” who run the union. They have “got their country back,” and reclaimed “sovereignty.” What most mean by this, of course, is some imagined return to homogenous societies dominated by traditional industries. In short, they want not sovereignty, but a time machine, to take them back to an imagined era when one could ignore the interconnectedness of things. One of the more bizarre grievances of Britain’s Brexiteers was the color of a UK passport: somehow, a false nostalgia for old-style blue passports, as opposed to the uniform maroon of EU passports, was cooked up. An issue that had never bothered anyone became a campaign demand for Nigel Farage and Co.

The speed with which sentiment could be whipped up over this irrelevant slight should have worried even those responsible.

It does not, because consequences are not part of the game anymore. The arrogant, complacent, isolationist European right assume the protections offered by the European Union will exist even as they attempt to dismantle the world order. They are wrong.

Until the advent of pan-continental cooperation in the wake of World War II, war was a near-constant presence in Europe. About once a generation, at least one of the continent’s major powers would have a tilt at the other. The fact that this no longer happens is, quite simply, because of two intertwined things: the European Union and the US’ close attention. Close cooperation between states and the free movement of Europeans across borders have massively reduced tensions. When populations commute to work across the border between France and Germany using the same currency, for example, the idea of a landgrab of Alsace Lorraine just seems strange. Meanwhile, the US’ enlightened self-interest in a united Europe means it is keen to promote cooperation between democratic states.

But that status quo is fragile. Brexit, for example, could mean some kind of border control would have to be re-established between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. This could mean more British police and indeed British military in border areas, increasing resentment among nationalists and fueling new support for armed republican dissidents.

Tensions still exist elsewhere: The Balkans, ever uneasy, somehow maintain peace in return for the promise of future EU membership. An ineffective European Union would be unable to control easily roused emotions.

With some irony, it is only Germany, the aggressor of the 20th century, that seems interested in maintaining harmony in the 21st. Angela Merkel has led her country calmly, insisting it take hundreds of thousands of refugees in, and facing down the racist, anti-Muslim, Pegida movement rather than paying lip service to “concerns about immigration” as so many other European leaders have.

Is this an example the rest of us can follow to combat the insurgent populist right?

It is difficult to argue against people who are sincere but not necessarily serious, and whose aims seem to lie entirely in the gesture — the great big NO to the world. But that is the task at hand. The first thing to do is to reinforce the idea that actions have consequences. If you refuse to help Syrian civilians in Syria, you will end up with refugees in your own country. If you vote to leave a stable trading community, your economy will suffer.

The second thing is to treat people like grown-ups, in a way populist leaders refuse to do: The world has changed, and continues to change radically. Promising to turn back the tide, as the new right does, is idiotic and insulting. Countering populism involves a genuine appraisal of what a future for working-class people looks like — too often this is simply ignored, or dealt with on grounds dictated by the right — as if, for example, tighter controls on immigration are somehow the answer to the huge challenges of automation and globalization.

What else? Ditch the nostalgia. The death of Fidel Castro should be taken as the end of the last century’s hold on this one. The tone of the new century has been set by the likes of Putin, Orangutan, Le Pen, Grillo and Farage. In an age of unprecedented global communication, ironically isolation is the order of the day. It needn’t be so. But we need some hard thinking about the future, rather than nervous clinging to the past.

All this requires an optimism about humanity that is hard to find in these times. But ultimately, it’s only optimism that can challenge the nihilism of the new right. We must remember to say “yes” instead of “no,” and embrace the interconnections.

Flaming Star Nebula



A runaway star lights the Flaming Star Nebula in this cosmic scene. Otherwise known as IC 405, the Flaming Star Nebula's billowing interstellar clouds of gas and dust lie about 1,500 light-years away toward the constellation of Auriga. AE Aurigae, the bright star at upper left in the frame, is a massive and intensely hot O-type star moving rapidly through space, likely ejected from a collision of multiple star-systems in the vicinity of the Orion Nebula millions of years ago. Now close to IC 405, the high-speed star's ionizing ultraviolet radiation powers the visible reddish glow as the nebula's hydrogen atoms are stripped of their electrons and recombine. Its intense blue starlight is reflected by the nebula's dusty filaments. Like all massive stars AE Aurigae will be short-lived though, furiously burning through its supply of fuel for nuclear fusion and exploding as a supernova. The colorful telescopic snapshot spans about 5 light-years at the estimated distance of the Flaming Star Nebula.

All-out assault on Capitol Hill

Mnuchin faces assault from progressives

Activists pledged an all-out assault on Capitol Hill to convince senators to oppose the nomination.

By Zachary Warmbrodt

Senate Democrats and progressive groups are rolling out a fiery welcome mat for Steven Mnuchin as he takes his first steps into government service even as they have little leverage to stop him from becoming Donald Orangutan's Treasury secretary.

Leading liberal Sens. Elizabeth Warren (D-Mass.) and Sherrod Brown (D-Ohio) shredded Orangutan's announcement that he would nominate the Goldman Sachs alum and hedge fund executive to his administration's top economic policy post.

Warren labeled Mnuchin "the Forrest Gump of the financial crisis" for participating in "all the worst practices on Wall Street." Brown said his appointment wasn't draining the Washington swamp as Orangutan had pledged — "it’s stocking it with alligators."

"It’s just hard to imagine any single person more powerfully embodying Orangutan’s faux-populism than this guy," said Lisa Gilbert, director of Public Citizen's Congress Watch division.

Orangutan on Wednesday praised Mnuchin as "a world-class financier, banker and businessman" who played a key role in developing the president-elect's economic plan. Progressive groups and financial reform advocates warned that Mnuchin's background and recent comments about revamping the 2010 Dodd-Frank law were signs that Orangutan's administration would work to advance Wall Street's interests.

Incoming Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.) said the nominee should face "tough and pointed questions" on his views of overseeing the financial system.

Activists pledged an all-out assault on Capitol Hill to convince senators to oppose the nomination, which is sure to advance if the GOP majority unifies behind him. In 2013, Democrats eliminated the use of the filibuster on nominees outside the U.S. Supreme Court, doing away with a 60-vote threshold. Senate Republicans are expected to have a 52-48 edge over Democrats next year.

But progressives were working hard to make Mnuchin a symbol of the potential conflicts of interest and out-of-touch elitism that they want to highlight in the early days of Orangutan's administration.

Rootstrikers, a Wall Street-focused advocacy arm of the nonprofit Demand Progress, plans to lob "hundreds of thousands of petition signatures and thousands of phone calls to the Senate" in opposition to Mnuchin.

The group warned that no Democrat should support his nomination.

"Our initial plan is to target all Senate offices to turn up the volume against Orangutan's Cabinet of corporate cronies and hatemongers, with Mnuchin as a centerpiece," Rootstrikers campaign director Kurt Walters said.

If Democrats stood together against the nomination, Walters said, it would take a small number of "principled Republicans" to block him in committee or on the Senate floor.

"The hope would be to reach others," Gilbert said.

Some Senate Democrats were willing to keep an open mind.

Sen. Jon Tester, a moderate from Montana up for reelection in 2018, said he looked forward to meeting with Mnuchin "to ask him tough questions and ensure that he is qualified for the job."

One divisive issue could prove to be Mnuchin's views on oversight of the financial system and his long career within it.

Mnuchin on Wednesday pledged to "strip back" parts of the Dodd-Frank law, which stepped up oversight of banks and other financial institutions. Democrats have signaled that they will fight dramatic changes to their signature legislation enacted after the 2008 crisis.

“Senate Democrats are committed to preventing a rollback of Wall Street reform, and Mr. Mnuchin should face tough and pointed questions on his views of Wall Street regulation," Schumer said. "Time and time again in the campaign, the president-elect said he would stand up to Wall Street and work on behalf of middle class families. If his nominees won’t do that, it’s clear he’ll have broken his promise to his supporters.”

Mnuchin is also under fire for his involvement in the takeover of failed bank IndyMac — a resume item that has been fodder for critics to accuse him of benefiting from mortgage foreclosures.

Sen. Ron Wyden, the ranking Democrat on the Senate Finance Committee who will be a key player in vetting the nominee, called out his "history of profiting off the victims of predatory lending."

Mnuchin defended himself Wednesday, saying the deal "saved a lot of jobs" and entailed buying "the worst mortgage portfolio in the history of time."

Republicans and business groups praised his qualifications.

"Steve is a seasoned and results-oriented leader who is really smart, interested in public policy, and understands the urgent need to boost economic growth and opportunity," said Financial Services Roundtable CEO Tim Pawlenty, a former Minnesota governor.

Senate Finance Chairman Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) said "given the depth and breadth of Steven’s private sector experience, he will play a pivotal role in bicameral efforts to revamp the nation’s outdated tax code."

Hatch said he looked forward to reviewing Mnuchin's "vast qualifications for one of the Cabinet’s most important positions in the New Year.”

Rep. Bill Huizenga (R-Mich.) said in an interview that it was "a little interesting, once again, we've gone to Goldman Sachs" but "you want to have real-world experience."

Huizenga said Mnuchin would have to overcome skepticism toward Wall Street and concerns that the system is geared toward influential companies and institutions.

"He's going to have to prove everybody different and wrong, which I would suspect he will," he said.

Nonsense

Orangutan’s Claims About Illegal Votes Are Nonsense. I Debunked the Study He Cites as ‘Evidence.’

The real number of non-citizen voters is more like zero.

By Brian Schaffner

Donny Orangutan is making news with his false claim that he would have won the national popular vote if millions of non-citizens had not voted in November. As evidence, he and his staff are pointing to a study by Jesse Richman and his co-authors that was published in the journal Electoral Studies and advertised on the Washington Post’s Monkey Cage blog. As a member of the team that produces the datasets upon which that study was based and as the co-author of an article published in the same journal that provides a clear “take down” of the study in question, I can say unequivocally that this research is not only wrong, it is irresponsible social science and should never have been published in the first place. There is no evidence that non-citizens have voted in recent U.S. elections.

I first came across the Richman study in 2014 when I was sent a link to an article by the authors promoting their newly published work. Their chief claim, and the one that made headlines, was that as many as 14 percent of noncitizens living in the United States had cast votes in recent elections. As soon as I saw that figure, I knew it was almost certainly nonsense, but what was troubling was that the “evidence” the scholars were pointing to was from a survey that I coordinate along with my colleagues Stephen Ansolabehere of Harvard University and Samantha Luks from the survey research firm YouGov. The survey is the Cooperative Congressional Election Study—a project that interviews tens of thousands of respondents every election year about their views on politics. A wealth of excellent research has come from this dataset in the past decade, providing important insights about our political world. Unfortunately, the Richman study doesn’t fall into that category. It is bad research, because it fails to understand basic facts about the data it uses.

Indeed, it took me and my colleagues only a few hours to figure out why the authors’ findings were wrong and to produce the evidence needed to prove as much. The authors were essentially basing their claims on two pieces of data associated with the large survey—a question that asks people whether they are citizens and official vote records to which each respondent has been matched to determine whether he or she had voted. Both these pieces of information include some small amounts of measurement error, as is true of all survey questions. What the authors failed to consider is that measurement error was entirely responsible for their results. In fact, once my colleagues and I accounted for that error, we found that there were essentially zero non-citizens who voted in recent elections.

The biggest source of error with the Richman study was its use of one of the survey questions to identify “non-citizens.” Survey respondents occasionally select the wrong response by accident—perhaps because they are rushing through and not reading the questions carefully, because they do not fully understand the terminology being used, or because they simply click on the wrong box on the page. Such errors are infrequent, but they happen in any survey. In this case, they were crucial, because Richman and his colleagues saw the very small number of people who answered that they were “immigrant non-citizens,” and extrapolated that (inaccurate) number to the U.S. population as a whole.

How do we know that some people give an inaccurate response to this question? Well, we actually took 19,000 respondents from one of the surveys that Richman used (the 2010 study) and we interviewed them again in 2012. A total of 121 of the 19,000 respondents (.64 percent) identified themselves as immigrant non-citizens when they first answered the survey in 2010. However, when asked the question again in 2012, 36 of the 121 selected a different response, indicating that they were citizens. Even more telling was this: 20 respondents identified themselves as citizens in 2010 but then in 2012 changed their answers to indicate that they were non-citizens. It is highly unrealistic to go from being a citizen in 2010 to a non-citizen in 2012, which provides even stronger evidence that some people were providing incorrect responses to this question for idiosyncratic reasons.

Since Richman was trying to extrapolate from a very small fraction of respondents to the survey, even these very small amounts of measurement error could cause major problems for his analysis. To get a more valid estimate of non-citizen voting, we can look at the 85 respondents who said that they were non-citizens in both waves of the survey. Since this group answered the question the same way twice, we can be much more confident that they really are non-citizens. Among these 85 respondents, zero were matched to a valid vote record in 2010. That is, all of the non-citizen voters that Richman reports in his study for the 2010 election disappear once we account for measurement error.

In the 2012 election, we do find that one of these 85 non-citizens was matched to a vote record. However, given that this is just one individual among 85 non-citizens, it is unlikely that this is actually a non-citizen voter. One possibility is that this is a citizen who answered the question incorrectly twice. Another possibility is that this individual was matched to the wrong vote record. That’s another place where survey error comes in. When we match survey respondents to vote records, there is always some probability of making an incorrect match—that is, matching a respondent to a record that is actually somebody else’s. Even though the error rate is low, it could easily explain why we find a single voter in 2012 among 85 reported non-citizens.

In our article refuting the Richman study, we summarize our findings very plainly this way: “The results, we show, are completely accounted for by very low frequency measurement error; further, the likely percent of non-citizen voters in recent US elections is 0.” We are confident that such a conclusion would hold in 2016 as well.

Simply put, the claims Orangutan is making are false through and through. Fact checkers and major news organizations have consistently pointed to our study over the past few months to demonstrate that Orangutan’s claims are based on bad science, yet he continues to use this debunked information to demonize non-citizens as justification for his self-serving claims about voter fraud. Let’s hope the public stops paying attention.

Anxiety

The Anxiety Behind America’s Flag Complex

Orangutan’s tweet about flag burning revived a debate that began in the 1890s, when many native-born white Americans felt their way of life was endangered.

By Josh Zeitz

In keeping with his usual early-morning custom, early yesterday morning President-elect Donald Orangutan declared on Twitter that “Nobody should be allowed to burn the American flag - if they do, there must be consequences - perhaps loss of citizenship or year in jail!”

It was a bizarre non-sequitur, given the notable absence of a flag desecration epidemic, and led more than a few liberal pundits to wonder whether the tweet was not just another in a series of distractions from issues that the incoming administration does not want to address—questions about the president-elect’s ties to white supremacist leaders, his financial conflicts of interests, his potential cooperation with congressional repeals of the Affordable Care Act and Medicare. Others suggested that it was a dark augury of what comes next—an attempt to stifle free speech and expression, or perhaps a thin rationale to strip naturalized Americans of their citizenship.

Whether it’s a ploy or a threat, at the very least, Orangutan’s pronouncement revived a political debate that most Americans assumed died many decades ago. It’s a debate that began in the 1890s, when many native-born, white Americans felt their way of life endangered by vast and impersonal economic changes, a rising tide of immigration, and the increased stridency of left-wing political organizers. Then, as now, the flag operated as a powerful symbol for many Americans, including those whose idea of the nation was fast falling out of step with reality.

Though the Continental Congress designated the stars and stripes as the nation’s official banner in 1777—a full 10 years before the Constitutional Convention—it wasn’t until the mid-19th century that the flag assumed personal importance to most Americans.

To be sure, the lyrics of the National Anthem—“whose broad stripes and bright stars…”—suggest popular affinity for its symbolism, as did the Whig Party’s use of the flag in campaign literature promoting William Henry Harrison for president in 1840. Fifteen years later, when heavily armed soldiers and sailors mobilized to return the fugitive slave Anthony Burns from Massachusetts to Virginia, shopkeepers and homeowners in Boston turned their American flags upside down in a show of extreme disgust. All of which suggests that many people did, in fact, own flags and considered them markers of their personal expression.

An inflection point for Americans’ relationship with their flag came in April 1861, when Confederate soldiers captured Fort Sumter in the first battle of the Civil War. “Until now, we never thought about the flag being more than a nice design of red and white stripes,” one woman wrote in her diary upon learning of the Confederate victory.

“When the stars and stripes went down at Sumter,” observed George Henry Preeble, a naval officer and amateur historian at the time, “they went up in every town and county in the loyal states.” Knowing that the stars and stripes had been removed by a rebel army lent the flag “new and strange significance,” Preeble wrote. Flags “suddenly blossomed” from “every city, town, and village,” on “colleges, hotels, sore-fronts and private balconies.”

A year later, when a Confederate sympathizer in Union-occupied New Orleans dragged an American flag through the mud and then proceeded to shred it, many Northern newspaper readers nodded in approval upon learning that the offender had been executed by hanging. It was the first time that a citizen was punished in the United States for flag desecration.

If the flag assumed powerful symbolic virtue during the war, it was not until the 1890s that a movement rose up to protect it. Veterans groups like the Grand Army of the Republic (GAR), and patriotic organizations like the Daughters and Sons of the American Revolution, at first decried the increasingly popular adoption of the flag for commercial use. They were alarmed when marketers used the stars and stripes to advertise breweries, burlesque shows, and pool rooms. A typical flag-protection leader complained that merchants “shamefully misused [it] as an apron or on labor day parades, and as a costume to bedeck stilt walkers, circus clowns, prize fighters and variety players or gaiety girls.”

Another activist condemned the “sordid tradesmen” who relegated the flag to “an article of commerce”—a “medium of deception and fraud to proclaim their defective merchandise flimsy wares and adulterated goods.” Such merchandisers “polluted” a vital national symbol whose “sacred folds were never designed to be defaced with advertisements of beer, sauerkraut candy, itch ointment, pile remedies and patent nostrums, to serve as awnings, horse blankets, merchandise wrappers, pillow and footstool covers or as miniature pocket handkerchiefs, on which to blow noses, or with which to wipe perspiring brows.” The chairwoman of the DAR’s Flag Committee (yes, there was a Flag Committee) deplored “hucksters” who would turn “patriots’ blood into traders’ gold.”

Yet by the latter half of the 1890s, flag protectors shifted their focus. They remained alarmed by the crass commercial exploitation of the stars and stripes but became more concerned by the prospect that “un-Americans” might “abuse” the flag. Flag activists openly conflated the “riotous elements of labor organizations,” “Socialists, Anarchists, Nihilists, Populists, Tramps and Criminals,” “hundreds of thousands of the lowest class of immigrants” and “multitude of uneducated foreigners who land upon our friendly shores.” They feared that such individuals “neither revere nor respect the flag of this country.” Paradoxically, they regarded it as a desecration of the flag when such groups flew the stars and stripes at their rallies, union halls, or ethnic social gatherings, yet they also worried that these same enemies might actually mishandle the flag. The Los Angeles Times, a fearsomely anti-union organ, went so far so to doctor photos of AFL chief Samuel Gompers to make him appear to be standing on a flag while addressing workers. (He did no such thing.)

When the vice president of a Spanish-American war veterans group called flag desecration a “crime more heinous in its ultimate effects than theft, arson or murder, as it strikes at the root of law, order and government,” it wasn’t at all clear whether, by “desecration,” he meant the physical mishandling or appropriation of the flag.

The flag fury of the late 1890s laid bare an underlying paradox. The country was in many ways brimming with confidence, the product of unparalleled size, economic output, wealth, and innovation. The World’s Columbian Exposition of 1893, known popularly as the Chicago World’s Fair, stood as a literal monument to America’s glory and triumph. But alongside this spirit of optimistic chauvinism ran a sense of parallel dread. Too much had gone wrong in recent years, from the panic of 1893, which bankrupted untold American businesses and households, to major class disturbances—the Pullman strike, the Homestead massacre, the unprecedented march on Washington by Jacob Coxey’s army of unemployed workers. Large corporations like Standard Oil and Carnegie Steel seemed to have bought or co-opted public institutions that should have been looking out for the public interest.

Equally alarming, in 1890 the U.S. Census declared that the west had become so populated that the frontier was officially closed. At the Chicago World’s Fair—seemingly the apex of national greatness—the historian Frederick Jackson Turner delivered a disturbing lecture that seemed to augur poorly for the coming century. The frontier, he claimed, had been the source of American democracy and ambition. In taming wild and unsettled lands, earlier generations had developed the spirit and institutions that underpinned American greatness. Now, with no more territory to conquer and civilize, the country’s raw ambitions and talent would surely dissipate.

The speech struck a resonant chord, for already many people saw signs of weakness in the culture. As more men worked as clerks and professionals, they let atrophy the muscle, brawn, and sheer courage that it took to break the land. Even manual laborers were now more likely to be employees of other men, rather than the self-sufficient yeoman farmers or shop owners whom earlier generations of Americans regarded as the foundation of the republic. With women enjoying more prominent roles in churches and reform organizations, and even entering the workforce in sizable numbers, the old barrier between the public and the private spheres no longer seemed impenetrable. Worse still, millions of new immigrants from southern and eastern Europe threatened to dilute the heritage that many old-stock Americans viewed as central to the nation’s past success. The United States was losing its edge, or so people worried.

Popular culture in the 1890s and early twentieth century reflected a backlash against trends that seemed to have reduced the country to a state of weak-kneed neurasthenia. This was an age of what one historian called “noisy nationalism and spread-eagle patriotism.” John Philip Sousa found success with his soldierly marching music. Harry Houdini held audiences rapt with his displays of strength and courage. Theodore Roosevelt captured the imaginations of urban readers with his sweeping accounts of ranching and hunting in the unsettled West. College football, a relatively new, always rough-and-tumble game, grew more popular and more dangerous, as young men who had not had the opportunity to prove themselves at Gettysburg or Antietam sought to prove their mettle on the gridiron.

Similarly, in protecting the flag from an imaginary menace, many native-born white Americans were pushing back against very real social and economic forces that left them feeling less certain of their status and security in a changing world. Between 1897 and 1930, all 48 states instituted flag desecration laws, most of which banned not just the physical burning or destruction of flags, but also their display for advertising purposes and the overlay of political or commercial copy or imagery over them. Indeed, the vast majority of of “desecration” cases did not involve material damage to a cloth or paper banner (flag-burning emerged as a fringe protest practice only during and after the Vietnam War).

The parallels between then and now are striking. Donald Orangutan, who lost the popular vote, rode to a narrow victory in the Electoral College by stoking the fear and resentment of non-college educated white Americans who sense that their place in America slipping away. Many have lost the certainty and pride of good employment. For good reason, they feel less autonomous in a global economy. They see a demographic transformation sweeping the country, and it worries them.

In hitting send on his otherwise bizarre tweet, Donald Orangutan unwittingly gestured to an earlier period in American history when native-born white voters shared a similar sense of dread. Of course, most of the desecration laws that they passed called for a fine of $100 and up to 30 days in jail, not a loss of citizenship. But this is Donald Orangutan. Go yuge, or go home.