Clinton abandons pivot to positive campaign
Email probe torpedoes plan to give people 'something to vote for,' as she escalates attacks on Trump.
By Annie Karni
Scaring voters to the polls was not how Hillary Clinton planned to begin the final week before Election Day.
After establishing a durable lead over an opponent beset by allegations of sexual assault, Clinton thought she could close out a grueling, 18-month campaign on a rare positive note about her history-making candidacy, and her vision for better future for the country.
But then FBI Director James Comey ripped that plan apart. Friday’s shocking revelation that the FBI was reviewing new evidence in the old probe of Clinton’s private State Department email server — and that the evidence involved messages on the laptop of Clinton aide Huma Abedin’s husband, disgraced former Rep. Anthony Weiner — has blocked Clinton’s final attempted pivot to the positive, which she has struggled with throughout the campaign.
Instead of giving the country "something to vote for," as she has promised, Clinton went back to the well of what has served her best during tough moments: whacking Donald Trump hard on whether he is responsible enough to control the nuclear codes; highlighting his erratic personality; and stirring anxiety about the threat he would pose to the entire world order if elected president.
“I am running against a man who says he doesn’t understand why we can’t use nuclear weapons,” Clinton said Monday, addressing a crowd of about 3,000 supporters at Kent State University. “Even the prospect of an actual nuclear war doesn’t seem to bother Donald Trump ... Let’s not get distracted from the real choice in this election.”
Fear was the letter of the day on an unseasonably warm Halloween day in Ohio. Introducing Clinton at her first rally of the day, Bruce Blair, a former U.S. Air Force Minuteman intercontinental ballistic missile launch control officer, said he “would live in constant fear of his making a bad call” if Trump was elected president.
On Monday, the campaign underscored that point with the release of a new television ad, which it billed as a 2016 version of the famous 1964 “Daisy Ad” warning of the dangers of nuclear weapons landing in the wrong hands.
Clinton’s speech was reminiscent of what her advisers consider one of her most memorable addresses of her career: her evisceration of Trump’s foreign policy bonafides in San Diego last summer, where she first called Trump “temperamentally unfit” to serve as president.
Back in June, Clinton’s blistering speech was met with cheers from Democrats worried she wasn’t taking on Trump in strong enough terms. But this time, those same allies were crouched in fear on Monday. “Do I need to start looking for an apartment in Toronto?” one DNC delegate supporting Clinton emailed POLITICO on Monday afternoon, after her first rally in Kent.
Over the weekend, Clinton allies bemoaned the timing of Comey’s announcement -- not only because it could have a significant impact on the election, but also because the majority of their pushback against the FBI director occur over the weekend.
“Middle of the week would have been much better,” grumbled one Clinton ally. They also admitted they felt like they were groping in the dark, with no idea what the investigation of Abedin’s computer would turn up.
Abedin, who typically travels with Clinton, was absent from the trail for the third day straight on Monday. A source close to Abedin said she had been spending the majority of her time holed up with lawyers while the extended Clinton world wondered what the probe meant for her role in a potential future Clinton White House.
With eight days left in the race, many Democrats also questioned whether there was enough time to litigate a case against an FBI director, who has the support of the White House.
“They have a legitimate beef,” said Democratic strategist David Axelrod, a former adviser to President Obama. “It has put them in a tough position eight days out, to defend against the broad inference his letter left. They probably don’t have a choice.”
But Axelrod warned, “Where they cannot and should not go is to imply that Comey’s mission was to sink her campaign.”
On Monday, Clinton appeared to give a cue for campaign surrogates to make that implication on her behalf. “Why in the world the FBI would jump into an election without any evidence of wrongdoing?” she asked the crowd. “There is no case here.”
Clinton’s top campaign advisers in Brooklyn kept the heat on Comey while Clinton turned her heat on Trump — campaign manager Robby Mook accusing him of a “blatant double standard” when it came to not naming Russia in meddling in the U.S. election.
Clinton allies and advisers on Monday said they still felt cautiously optimistic about her chances on Nov. 8, but worried that the latest email flap would leave her further damaged entering the White House with an investigation hanging over her head and potentially giving up Democratic control of the Senate.
It also means she is more likely to come into office, if she wins, with historically low favorability ratings.
It’s the piece of the puzzle Clinton’s campaign has struggled with since 2014, when she first began contemplating what would motivate her second presidential run -- highlighting what people look up to in the former secretary of state.
“There are powerful qualities that people admire in you, aspire to in their own lives, and wish for our country, as was the case for Obama in 2008 with ‘hope’ and ‘change,’’ her speechwriter Dan Schwerin wrote to Clinton in a memo from August, 2014, which was made public in the hack of campaign chairman John Podesta’s personal email. He offered the idea that “resilience” could be Clinton’s answer to Obama’s 2008 mandate about “change.” In the memo, entitled “Searching for Hillary Clinton’s Big Idea,” Schwerin also noted to the former secretary of state that “your passions and commitments have to be at the heart of this process.”
But instead, the heart of the process has been a comparison on some basics. “You have to ask yourself,” Clinton said, “in a crisis, who would you trust?" Her closing argument was, in the end, laying out what voters need to vote against.
"Donald Trump has a dark and divisive vision for America," she said, "that could tear our country apart."
A place were I can write...
My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.
November 01, 2016
FBI's Clinton probe
Justice Department seeks to speed up FBI's Clinton probe
After registering disagreement with Comey, Lynch is now trying to help him wrap up the case as quickly as possible.
By Josh Gerstein
Top Justice Department officials have a new strategy for dealing with their high-wattage clash with FBI Director James Comey over disclosures about the Hillary Clinton email probe: Downplay their disagreement and concentrate instead on pushing the FBI to move quickly to analyze the newly found messages.
Attorney General Loretta Lynch and Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates are now seeking a kind of detente with the beleaguered FBI chief after the extraordinary rift between Comey and the Justice Department last week over his plans to tell Congress that unexpected new evidence was under review in the Clinton email inquiry, officials familiar with the episode said.
While Justice officials disclaimed any political motivations in their shift in strategy, the effort to put the investigation on a fast track would be a step toward meeting the demands of top Democrats and the Clinton campaign for more answers in advance of the election.
Lynch and Yates "felt they needed to make clear that they disagreed with Comey's decision," one top Justice official said. "But no one is dragging their feet here. The Justice Department is committed to working with the FBI to move the case forward."
Top prosecutors have echoed that view, telling colleagues that it's time to put their disputes with Comey in the rear-view mirror and get on with an expeditious review of thousands of emails found on a laptop belonging to Anthony Weiner, the estranged husband of longtime Clinton aide Huma Abedin.
Letters the Justice Department sent to angry Democratic lawmakers Monday underscored that approach. Justice Department legislative liaison Peter Kadzik told the senators and House members that the agency "appreciates the concerns" they expressed about the impact of the disclosure on the election, but he never said explicitly that Comey had defied Lynch's strong advice to follow the usual DOJ practice of avoiding any disclosures close to elections.
Kadzik did say that Justice is working "closely with the FBI" to pursue the inquiry "as expeditiously as possible.
Evidence of that approach, officials said, could be seen in Justice's joint effort with the FBI to obtain a warrant over the weekend to access emails on the Weiner laptop that might be relevant to the Clinton email investigation. The warrant was granted Sunday, removing an important legal obstacle to the investigation.
In a letter to Comey Friday, top Senate Democrats said investigators should be "working around the clock to determine the basic facts about the emails in question."
Still, it's far from clear that the renewed investigation will reach any meaningful conclusions in the next eight days.
FBI officials said that if all of Abedin's relevant messages turn out to be copies of ones her lawyers already turned over, the matter might be brought to a close within a few days. But given the frequency with which Clinton aides and other State Department officials used personal accounts to facilitate printing of documents, it seems more likely that at least some will fall into a gray area that requires a deeper level of review.
"You have to meticulously go through each one. You can't just arbitrarily cut it off," said one former FBI top official who has worked on similar investigations and asked not to be named. "Every document you think may have classified information in it, you have to give it to what we call the 'victim agency.' Each one of those agencies then has to sign off on whether it was classified and whether it is still classified. ... There's going to be maybe 16 different agencies that need to take a look at that stuff."
Nonetheless, Lynch and Yates felt the fairest approach to all parties would be to push the investigation ahead as quickly as possible, given the expectations raised by Comey's dramatic announcement on Friday.
Still, current and former FBI officials insisted Comey wasn't looking to buck Justice Department policy, but believed he needed to fulfill promises he made to keep Congress posted of any significant developments in the case.
"He felt like he had to set the record straight. He found himself in a pickle," the ex-FBI leader said. "I don’t think he thought this through, though."
Comey is also facing dissent from his traditionally conservative rank-and-file agents over the decision in July not to recommend charges in the Clinton email case. It's unclear whether that played any role in his decision to essentially announce last week's development.
"The stuff about a rebellion going on inside the bureau is absolutely true, but that's not going to influence his decision," the ex-FBI official said."He loves his troops, but it's not a fair judgment that that's why he did it."
The FBI chief does seem to be aware that some in his agent ranks have doubts about how the politically charged, Clinton-related inquiry has been handled. In recent months, he has twice issued defensive memos to his workforce explaining his actions.
"Of course, we don’t ordinarily tell Congress about ongoing investigations, but here I feel an obligation to do so given that I testified repeatedly in recent months that our investigation was completed. ... At the same time, however, given that we don’t know the significance of this newly discovered collection of emails, I don’t want to create a misleading impression," Comey wrote Friday. "In trying to strike that balance, in a brief letter and in the middle of an election season, there is significant risk of being misunderstood, but I wanted you to hear directly from me about it."
Some former FBI officials said it's too early to say whether the highly public dust-up between Comey and Justice officials will poison the relationship or whether it can be put back on track.
"I hope some of the undercurrent of what is potentially playing out, the passive-aggressive part of it, isn’t a problem for the future," former FBI agent Ron Hosko said, noting that the officials are typically together almost every workday for briefings on threats and ongoing operations.
"You hope the rhythm of the bureaucracy puts everybody back together," he added.
After registering disagreement with Comey, Lynch is now trying to help him wrap up the case as quickly as possible.
By Josh Gerstein
Top Justice Department officials have a new strategy for dealing with their high-wattage clash with FBI Director James Comey over disclosures about the Hillary Clinton email probe: Downplay their disagreement and concentrate instead on pushing the FBI to move quickly to analyze the newly found messages.
Attorney General Loretta Lynch and Deputy Attorney General Sally Yates are now seeking a kind of detente with the beleaguered FBI chief after the extraordinary rift between Comey and the Justice Department last week over his plans to tell Congress that unexpected new evidence was under review in the Clinton email inquiry, officials familiar with the episode said.
While Justice officials disclaimed any political motivations in their shift in strategy, the effort to put the investigation on a fast track would be a step toward meeting the demands of top Democrats and the Clinton campaign for more answers in advance of the election.
Lynch and Yates "felt they needed to make clear that they disagreed with Comey's decision," one top Justice official said. "But no one is dragging their feet here. The Justice Department is committed to working with the FBI to move the case forward."
Top prosecutors have echoed that view, telling colleagues that it's time to put their disputes with Comey in the rear-view mirror and get on with an expeditious review of thousands of emails found on a laptop belonging to Anthony Weiner, the estranged husband of longtime Clinton aide Huma Abedin.
Letters the Justice Department sent to angry Democratic lawmakers Monday underscored that approach. Justice Department legislative liaison Peter Kadzik told the senators and House members that the agency "appreciates the concerns" they expressed about the impact of the disclosure on the election, but he never said explicitly that Comey had defied Lynch's strong advice to follow the usual DOJ practice of avoiding any disclosures close to elections.
Kadzik did say that Justice is working "closely with the FBI" to pursue the inquiry "as expeditiously as possible.
Evidence of that approach, officials said, could be seen in Justice's joint effort with the FBI to obtain a warrant over the weekend to access emails on the Weiner laptop that might be relevant to the Clinton email investigation. The warrant was granted Sunday, removing an important legal obstacle to the investigation.
In a letter to Comey Friday, top Senate Democrats said investigators should be "working around the clock to determine the basic facts about the emails in question."
Still, it's far from clear that the renewed investigation will reach any meaningful conclusions in the next eight days.
FBI officials said that if all of Abedin's relevant messages turn out to be copies of ones her lawyers already turned over, the matter might be brought to a close within a few days. But given the frequency with which Clinton aides and other State Department officials used personal accounts to facilitate printing of documents, it seems more likely that at least some will fall into a gray area that requires a deeper level of review.
"You have to meticulously go through each one. You can't just arbitrarily cut it off," said one former FBI top official who has worked on similar investigations and asked not to be named. "Every document you think may have classified information in it, you have to give it to what we call the 'victim agency.' Each one of those agencies then has to sign off on whether it was classified and whether it is still classified. ... There's going to be maybe 16 different agencies that need to take a look at that stuff."
Nonetheless, Lynch and Yates felt the fairest approach to all parties would be to push the investigation ahead as quickly as possible, given the expectations raised by Comey's dramatic announcement on Friday.
Still, current and former FBI officials insisted Comey wasn't looking to buck Justice Department policy, but believed he needed to fulfill promises he made to keep Congress posted of any significant developments in the case.
"He felt like he had to set the record straight. He found himself in a pickle," the ex-FBI leader said. "I don’t think he thought this through, though."
Comey is also facing dissent from his traditionally conservative rank-and-file agents over the decision in July not to recommend charges in the Clinton email case. It's unclear whether that played any role in his decision to essentially announce last week's development.
"The stuff about a rebellion going on inside the bureau is absolutely true, but that's not going to influence his decision," the ex-FBI official said."He loves his troops, but it's not a fair judgment that that's why he did it."
The FBI chief does seem to be aware that some in his agent ranks have doubts about how the politically charged, Clinton-related inquiry has been handled. In recent months, he has twice issued defensive memos to his workforce explaining his actions.
"Of course, we don’t ordinarily tell Congress about ongoing investigations, but here I feel an obligation to do so given that I testified repeatedly in recent months that our investigation was completed. ... At the same time, however, given that we don’t know the significance of this newly discovered collection of emails, I don’t want to create a misleading impression," Comey wrote Friday. "In trying to strike that balance, in a brief letter and in the middle of an election season, there is significant risk of being misunderstood, but I wanted you to hear directly from me about it."
Some former FBI officials said it's too early to say whether the highly public dust-up between Comey and Justice officials will poison the relationship or whether it can be put back on track.
"I hope some of the undercurrent of what is potentially playing out, the passive-aggressive part of it, isn’t a problem for the future," former FBI agent Ron Hosko said, noting that the officials are typically together almost every workday for briefings on threats and ongoing operations.
"You hope the rhythm of the bureaucracy puts everybody back together," he added.
Leads Trump
Poll: Clinton leads Trump by 6 in Virginia
By Louis Nelson
The resurfacing of Hillary Clinton’s email scandal and the FBI’s examination of new evidence pertaining to it do not appear to have hurt the Democratic nominee in the swing state of Virginia, where she holds a 6 percentage point advantage over Donald Trump.
The former secretary of state leads the Manhattan billionaire, 48 percent to 42 percent, among Virginia’s likely voters in a four-way race that also includes the Green Party’s Jill Stein and Libertarian Gary Johnson.
The Washington Post/Schar School poll was conducted from last Thursday to Sunday and did not show any dip in support for Clinton in the wake of FBI Director James Comey’s announcement on Friday that the bureau is examining a cache of potentially-new emails related to the private server she maintained as secretary of state. Clinton’s support was actually stronger among respondents reached on Saturday and Sunday, the Post noted, although it’s possible that that was a result of a more diverse sample being reached on those days.
The bulk of Clinton’s support comes from the Northern Virginia counties that surround Washington, where Trump is especially unpopular. The former secretary of state holds a 43 point edge in the close-in counties around Washington, much stronger than the 26 point advantage President Barack Obama had there in 2012, and a 7 point lead in Loudoun and Fauquier counties, where 2012 Republican nominee Mitt Romney nearly matched Obama.
But neither candidate is viewed favorably statewide: 60 percent of voters view Trump unfavorably while 57 percent have an unfavorable opinion of Clinton. Almost 75 percent of respondents said Clinton is too willing to bend the rules, while nearly 60 percent said Trump holds biases against women and minorities.
The Washington Post/Schar School poll was conducted from Oct. 27-30, reaching 1,024 likely voters via landlines and cell phones. The poll’s margin of error was plus-or-minus 3.5 points.
By Louis Nelson
The resurfacing of Hillary Clinton’s email scandal and the FBI’s examination of new evidence pertaining to it do not appear to have hurt the Democratic nominee in the swing state of Virginia, where she holds a 6 percentage point advantage over Donald Trump.
The former secretary of state leads the Manhattan billionaire, 48 percent to 42 percent, among Virginia’s likely voters in a four-way race that also includes the Green Party’s Jill Stein and Libertarian Gary Johnson.
The Washington Post/Schar School poll was conducted from last Thursday to Sunday and did not show any dip in support for Clinton in the wake of FBI Director James Comey’s announcement on Friday that the bureau is examining a cache of potentially-new emails related to the private server she maintained as secretary of state. Clinton’s support was actually stronger among respondents reached on Saturday and Sunday, the Post noted, although it’s possible that that was a result of a more diverse sample being reached on those days.
The bulk of Clinton’s support comes from the Northern Virginia counties that surround Washington, where Trump is especially unpopular. The former secretary of state holds a 43 point edge in the close-in counties around Washington, much stronger than the 26 point advantage President Barack Obama had there in 2012, and a 7 point lead in Loudoun and Fauquier counties, where 2012 Republican nominee Mitt Romney nearly matched Obama.
But neither candidate is viewed favorably statewide: 60 percent of voters view Trump unfavorably while 57 percent have an unfavorable opinion of Clinton. Almost 75 percent of respondents said Clinton is too willing to bend the rules, while nearly 60 percent said Trump holds biases against women and minorities.
The Washington Post/Schar School poll was conducted from Oct. 27-30, reaching 1,024 likely voters via landlines and cell phones. The poll’s margin of error was plus-or-minus 3.5 points.
Pedal-to-the-metal
Democrats go pedal-to-the-metal on early voting
In North Carolina, black turnout is key to the party's hopes of swamping Trump.
By Katie Glueck
Democrats are in the midst of an all-out blitz to turn out the early vote, hoping to bank enough votes to overwhelm Donald Trump even before the polls open on Election Day.
Nowhere is the urgency more apparent than in North Carolina where, thanks in part to restrictions on early voting enacted by the Republican legislature, Democrats hold a lead in ballots cast so far but are running behind their 2012 pace.
In places that are home to significant African-American populations, like Greensboro’s Guilford County and Winston-Salem’s Forsyth County, Democrats are still smarting from legislative changes that significantly restricted the number of polling sites available for the duration of in-person early voting — a method frequently utilized by minority voters.
Guilford County alone went from 16 polling sites available for the entire early vote period in 2012 to only one location open for the first week of 2016 — and even that site was not open on the first weekend of early voting.
Bill Clinton rallied here Sunday with local Democrats like state Sen. Gladys Robinson to sound the alarm about the importance of casting early ballots in a state that is essential to Trump's path to victory.
“I get upset when I don’t see that as many of you have turned to the polls as we did a couple years ago,” admonished Robinson, an African-American Democrat from the area, as she warmed up for the former president. “We have to get to the polls. We have to take everybody with us.”
Her urgent plea — amplified minutes later by the former president — is a recognition of the headwinds North Carolina Democrats are facing, four years after Mitt Romney narrowly carried the state and after the number of early voting locations was reduced. As of Saturday, only 37 percent of the total number of Democrats who voted early in Guilford County in 2012 had done so in 2016, though that number was expected to tick up some as Sunday’s full numbers trickled in, and as the state holds more expanded early-voting hours this week.
“For Guilford and Forsyth, particularly with Guilford, the issue is, can they get at least some make-up of where they’ve been behind that’s due to the early voting changes?” asked Michael Bitzer, an expert on the early vote at North Carolina’s Catawba College, who provided those comparisons to 2012.
That’s why Democrats are feeling the pressure this week to at least close the gap with their 2012 performance before in-person early voting, which tends to benefit their party, ends on Saturday and Republicans move to run up the score on Election Day.
“This is a critical time because this is the preferred method of voting for Democrats,” said Michael McDonald, an expert on the early vote who runs the U.S. Elections Project. “They are certainly mounting up a lead in the early vote. It’s just, is that lead going to be good enough?”
According to McDonald’s analysis, Democrats are steadily closing on their 2012 performance, and “on the trajectory they’re on, if they keep gaining ground as they are, they should meet or exceed their 2012 levels by the end of the week.”
But a significant piece of that effort hinges on African-American turnout in the final days of early voting.
On Sunday — a day on which African-Americans tend to vote in big numbers as a result of “souls to the polls” efforts that encourage church-goers to head to the ballot box after services — Democrats made a major push to close the deficit, and there are signs they made some progress.
“It was a big day for the Democrats,” McDonald said. “Without a doubt. 48.7 percent of people who voted were Democrats, 31.9 percent were African Americans…and they did make up some ground. There were 1,136 Democrats over their 2012 number.”
Democrats are now ahead of Republicans by 13.5 percent in the early vote, he said, but it may not be enough: Republicans are overperforming their own 2012 early vote numbers.
"Until they actually exceed 2012 numbers," McDonald said of Democrats, "I think they're going to be very nervous about where they're sitting with early voting in North Carolina."
"Republicans tend to win on Election Day," said Dallas Woodhouse, the executive director of the North Carolina Republican Party, in a recent interview.
Still, the Clinton campaign stresses that turnout is on the upswing for Democrats now that more polling sites have opened. They cite data from the North Carolina Board of Elections showing that Democratic turnout, and particularly black turnout, has expanded at a rapid clip since more polling sites were added last Thursday, noting that in Guilford, 549 African-Americans voted last Wednesday, but 7,496 did on Thursday.
One North Carolina Democratic operative working on several races in the state expressed confidence that the Clinton campaign would close the gap with 2012 African American turnout, saying that on Sunday, about 32 percent of votes cast were from African Americans, but the total share of the African American vote is only expected to be around 22 percent.
"I think the numbers are really catching up," the operative said. "Obviously a lot of that started Thursday, Friday, Sunday voting, we're continuing to see a huge push in a lot more traditional African American communities for folks continuing voting this week."
Over the next week, both President Barack Obama and Vice President Joe Biden are expected to campaign in North Carolina, building on visits from Bill Clinton, Michelle Obama, and Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine, who have all been in the state in the last week or so. The Clinton campaign has also launched aggressive advertising campaigns on African-American radio stations and in black newspapers, in addition to their extensive outreach efforts at churches and historically black colleges.
A Clinton adviser stressed that a robust surrogate operation would continue in the state’s African American communities through Election Day, even though there is no early voting allowed next Sunday.
“While early voting does conclude on [Nov.] 5, on the final Sunday we do plan to have some major events geared toward the African American community in order to drum up enthusiasm for [Election Day voting],” said the Clinton adviser.
Added Bitzer, “It is critical to get black votes out for Democrats to remain competitive this year, but the number of days to target on this population is growing smaller, and that will mean much more energy and attention for Election Day.”
This past Sunday set the tone for the final push in the African American community, and it’s clear that early voting is still the emphasis.
Bill Clinton started his Sunday with a visit to a black church, where he talked up the importance of “souls to the polls” — the last Sunday, according to state rules, on which voting would be allowed. He reiterated that message in front of the Greensboro crowd later in the day.
“No state has been a battleground for how to define the future of this country more than North Carolina,” he said. “This is the last Sunday of early voting. A lot of people fought for that.”
The sense that voting opportunities were under threat in North Carolina permeated several polling stations in heavily African American neighborhoods across the state, with a number of voters pointing to restrictions on early voting times as a motivator for turning out.
“That’s one of the driving forces for me,” said Derrick Holland, a minister, who had participated in a “souls to the polls” march to a Greensboro polling station from his church — where he said the Rev. Jesse Jackson, a Democratic civil rights activist, had made a get-out-the-vote speech earlier in the day. “It’s something that was fought for for so long. Now people are trying to take that away from us. I don’t think that’s fair.”
He and his wife voted for Hillary Clinton.
An hour away, in Raleigh, a steady stream of voters flowed into the Chavis Community Center, which served as a recreational haven for African-Americans during segregation, and remains a pillar of the community. Some Republicans wanted to eliminate the site as an early voting station, a decision that was ultimately blocked in a bipartisan fashion. Now, it has become so central to Democratic early voting efforts that Hillary Clinton stopped by two Sundays ago.
Efforts to remove Chavis from early voting options “was part of the suppression, more than anything else,” said Rep. Rosa Gill, a Democrat who represents the area and was in attendance on Sunday. “It’s heavily African-American. I think it was part of the voter suppression.”
Wake County, home to Raleigh, has been a brighter spot for Democratic early vote performance -- in part due to nine early voting locations that opened two weeks ago and another 11 that opened Thursday. The county is crucial to Democratic prospects — it is the second-biggest county in the state, and Democrats must run up big numbers there in order to compensate for the redder rural areas. As of Saturday night, 54 percent of Wake County’s 2012 early total was already in, according to Bitzer’s calculations, and that number was expected to climb. Heavily Democratic Mecklenburg County, the biggest in the state, he said, was also showing signs of strength for Democrats.
Back in Greensboro Sunday afternoon, as another Clinton organizer warmed up the crowd for Clinton, he spelled out the stakes of the next five days.
“If we ensure every single registered Democrat in Guilford County gets out to vote,” the organizer said, “we can win this election this week.”
In North Carolina, black turnout is key to the party's hopes of swamping Trump.
By Katie Glueck
Democrats are in the midst of an all-out blitz to turn out the early vote, hoping to bank enough votes to overwhelm Donald Trump even before the polls open on Election Day.
Nowhere is the urgency more apparent than in North Carolina where, thanks in part to restrictions on early voting enacted by the Republican legislature, Democrats hold a lead in ballots cast so far but are running behind their 2012 pace.
In places that are home to significant African-American populations, like Greensboro’s Guilford County and Winston-Salem’s Forsyth County, Democrats are still smarting from legislative changes that significantly restricted the number of polling sites available for the duration of in-person early voting — a method frequently utilized by minority voters.
Guilford County alone went from 16 polling sites available for the entire early vote period in 2012 to only one location open for the first week of 2016 — and even that site was not open on the first weekend of early voting.
Bill Clinton rallied here Sunday with local Democrats like state Sen. Gladys Robinson to sound the alarm about the importance of casting early ballots in a state that is essential to Trump's path to victory.
“I get upset when I don’t see that as many of you have turned to the polls as we did a couple years ago,” admonished Robinson, an African-American Democrat from the area, as she warmed up for the former president. “We have to get to the polls. We have to take everybody with us.”
Her urgent plea — amplified minutes later by the former president — is a recognition of the headwinds North Carolina Democrats are facing, four years after Mitt Romney narrowly carried the state and after the number of early voting locations was reduced. As of Saturday, only 37 percent of the total number of Democrats who voted early in Guilford County in 2012 had done so in 2016, though that number was expected to tick up some as Sunday’s full numbers trickled in, and as the state holds more expanded early-voting hours this week.
“For Guilford and Forsyth, particularly with Guilford, the issue is, can they get at least some make-up of where they’ve been behind that’s due to the early voting changes?” asked Michael Bitzer, an expert on the early vote at North Carolina’s Catawba College, who provided those comparisons to 2012.
That’s why Democrats are feeling the pressure this week to at least close the gap with their 2012 performance before in-person early voting, which tends to benefit their party, ends on Saturday and Republicans move to run up the score on Election Day.
“This is a critical time because this is the preferred method of voting for Democrats,” said Michael McDonald, an expert on the early vote who runs the U.S. Elections Project. “They are certainly mounting up a lead in the early vote. It’s just, is that lead going to be good enough?”
According to McDonald’s analysis, Democrats are steadily closing on their 2012 performance, and “on the trajectory they’re on, if they keep gaining ground as they are, they should meet or exceed their 2012 levels by the end of the week.”
But a significant piece of that effort hinges on African-American turnout in the final days of early voting.
On Sunday — a day on which African-Americans tend to vote in big numbers as a result of “souls to the polls” efforts that encourage church-goers to head to the ballot box after services — Democrats made a major push to close the deficit, and there are signs they made some progress.
“It was a big day for the Democrats,” McDonald said. “Without a doubt. 48.7 percent of people who voted were Democrats, 31.9 percent were African Americans…and they did make up some ground. There were 1,136 Democrats over their 2012 number.”
Democrats are now ahead of Republicans by 13.5 percent in the early vote, he said, but it may not be enough: Republicans are overperforming their own 2012 early vote numbers.
"Until they actually exceed 2012 numbers," McDonald said of Democrats, "I think they're going to be very nervous about where they're sitting with early voting in North Carolina."
"Republicans tend to win on Election Day," said Dallas Woodhouse, the executive director of the North Carolina Republican Party, in a recent interview.
Still, the Clinton campaign stresses that turnout is on the upswing for Democrats now that more polling sites have opened. They cite data from the North Carolina Board of Elections showing that Democratic turnout, and particularly black turnout, has expanded at a rapid clip since more polling sites were added last Thursday, noting that in Guilford, 549 African-Americans voted last Wednesday, but 7,496 did on Thursday.
One North Carolina Democratic operative working on several races in the state expressed confidence that the Clinton campaign would close the gap with 2012 African American turnout, saying that on Sunday, about 32 percent of votes cast were from African Americans, but the total share of the African American vote is only expected to be around 22 percent.
"I think the numbers are really catching up," the operative said. "Obviously a lot of that started Thursday, Friday, Sunday voting, we're continuing to see a huge push in a lot more traditional African American communities for folks continuing voting this week."
Over the next week, both President Barack Obama and Vice President Joe Biden are expected to campaign in North Carolina, building on visits from Bill Clinton, Michelle Obama, and Hillary Clinton and Tim Kaine, who have all been in the state in the last week or so. The Clinton campaign has also launched aggressive advertising campaigns on African-American radio stations and in black newspapers, in addition to their extensive outreach efforts at churches and historically black colleges.
A Clinton adviser stressed that a robust surrogate operation would continue in the state’s African American communities through Election Day, even though there is no early voting allowed next Sunday.
“While early voting does conclude on [Nov.] 5, on the final Sunday we do plan to have some major events geared toward the African American community in order to drum up enthusiasm for [Election Day voting],” said the Clinton adviser.
Added Bitzer, “It is critical to get black votes out for Democrats to remain competitive this year, but the number of days to target on this population is growing smaller, and that will mean much more energy and attention for Election Day.”
This past Sunday set the tone for the final push in the African American community, and it’s clear that early voting is still the emphasis.
Bill Clinton started his Sunday with a visit to a black church, where he talked up the importance of “souls to the polls” — the last Sunday, according to state rules, on which voting would be allowed. He reiterated that message in front of the Greensboro crowd later in the day.
“No state has been a battleground for how to define the future of this country more than North Carolina,” he said. “This is the last Sunday of early voting. A lot of people fought for that.”
The sense that voting opportunities were under threat in North Carolina permeated several polling stations in heavily African American neighborhoods across the state, with a number of voters pointing to restrictions on early voting times as a motivator for turning out.
“That’s one of the driving forces for me,” said Derrick Holland, a minister, who had participated in a “souls to the polls” march to a Greensboro polling station from his church — where he said the Rev. Jesse Jackson, a Democratic civil rights activist, had made a get-out-the-vote speech earlier in the day. “It’s something that was fought for for so long. Now people are trying to take that away from us. I don’t think that’s fair.”
He and his wife voted for Hillary Clinton.
An hour away, in Raleigh, a steady stream of voters flowed into the Chavis Community Center, which served as a recreational haven for African-Americans during segregation, and remains a pillar of the community. Some Republicans wanted to eliminate the site as an early voting station, a decision that was ultimately blocked in a bipartisan fashion. Now, it has become so central to Democratic early voting efforts that Hillary Clinton stopped by two Sundays ago.
Efforts to remove Chavis from early voting options “was part of the suppression, more than anything else,” said Rep. Rosa Gill, a Democrat who represents the area and was in attendance on Sunday. “It’s heavily African-American. I think it was part of the voter suppression.”
Wake County, home to Raleigh, has been a brighter spot for Democratic early vote performance -- in part due to nine early voting locations that opened two weeks ago and another 11 that opened Thursday. The county is crucial to Democratic prospects — it is the second-biggest county in the state, and Democrats must run up big numbers there in order to compensate for the redder rural areas. As of Saturday night, 54 percent of Wake County’s 2012 early total was already in, according to Bitzer’s calculations, and that number was expected to climb. Heavily Democratic Mecklenburg County, the biggest in the state, he said, was also showing signs of strength for Democrats.
Back in Greensboro Sunday afternoon, as another Clinton organizer warmed up the crowd for Clinton, he spelled out the stakes of the next five days.
“If we ensure every single registered Democrat in Guilford County gets out to vote,” the organizer said, “we can win this election this week.”
Decide the Senate...
5 keys that will decide control of the Senate
Hillary Clinton's renewed email troubles inject a huge dose of uncertainty into the final days of the volatile fight for the chamber.
By Burgess Everett and Kevin Robillard
Democrats had all the momentum in the brutal battle for the Senate as Donald Trump’s presidential prospects took a nosedive last month. But the sudden relitigation of Hillary Clinton’s email practices has them on defense in the last week of the election, injecting even more uncertainty into the half-dozen races that could go either way and will determine which party controls the Senate.
Simultaneously, Trump has pulled back within striking distance. That makes Democrats nervous not because they think Trump can win, but because many Republican candidates are running ahead of Trump and a small swing in the presidential contest could make the difference in key Senate races.
“Republicans have done a great job of keeping it very close in a bad environment,” said David McIntosh, president of the fiscally conservative Club for Growth, which plowed millions into competitive races. “They’re consistently running anywhere from 5 to 6 points ahead of Trump. If Trump gets within a point or two,” Republicans can hold the chamber.
Democrats are still in the driver’s seat thanks to simple math: Republicans essentially have to run the table in the most competitive races to keep the Senate. Democrats are on offense in North Carolina, Missouri, Indiana, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Florida, Wisconsin and Illinois — and are only on defense in Nevada. That gives them lots of ways to take back the minimum four seats they need, though Democrats are hoping for much greater gains to give them some cushion heading into a brutal 2018 map.
“In terms of Hillary being president. I feel good about where she is. I think people have made their decision,” said Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.). “In terms of the Senate, I think it’s tighter. I feel that the odds are we take back the Senate. But the question is, is it taking back the Senate by barely enough seats or [winning] seven or eight seats?”
Here’s POLITICO’s guide to five dynamics to watch in Senate races during what's sure to be a wild final seven days of the campaign.
A November surprise
In interviews on Monday, key strategists from both parties agreed that the “new investigative steps” into Clinton’s email practices announced by FBI Director James Comey are unlikely to seismically shift Senate battlegrounds. But the story is dominating the national news and finally puts the GOP on offense.
Indeed, Republicans spent most of the post-Labor Day period having to respond to the latest Trump outrage — to the point that several GOP candidates unendorsed him. No Democrats are abandoning Clinton after Comey’s bombshell, but at least Republicans have a new message to press.
“These kind of political disturbances, disruptions can have an effect. How much, I think is the question. But in a tight race, it could be significant,” said Sen. Steve Daines (R-Mont.).
Democrats said that internal polls over the weekend suggest Comey has not hurt them yet but added that his action was still unwelcome.
“It’s not a good development,” said a Democrat working on Senate races. “Does that affect our races? Maybe.”
Trump pulling closer to Clinton
The presidential campaign plays an undeniable role in Senate races and Trump is steadily gaining on Clinton since his October swoon sent Republicans fleeing from him. Clinton’s lead has dropped from about 7 points two weeks ago to roughly 3 points now, a trend that began before the FBI news.
Clinton still appears to be the overwhelming favorite to win. But Trump looks competitive in Florida and is within striking distance in Nevada, shifts that Republicans hope pay big dividends for them in an uphill battle to keep the Senate.
Still, Republicans fear that the landscape could shift yet again, perhaps with yet another bad story about Trump just before the election.
The Trump effect has been “tremendously damaging,” said Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.). “With just about any other candidate, we’d have been much better off.”
Shaky Senate polls
Then there's the possibility that we don't know what we think we know about all these competitive Senate races.
Remember Greg Orman? The Kansas independent went into Election Day in 2014 a slight favorite in the polls to win the Kansas Senate race that year. Incumbent GOP Sen. Pat Roberts ended up crushing him by double digits.
That year, pre-election polls favored Democrats by 4 points more than the actual results, according to FiveThirtyEight, which strategists attribute to public polls not reflecting what campaigns were seeing internally. Indeed, Republicans shifted some money from Joni Ernst’s successful run in Iowa that year to other races, even though public polls showed it a toss-up. She won comfortably by 8 points.
This year, public polls largely jibe with internal assessments of competitive Senate races: There are six toss-up races and poll averages show all of them within 4 points. Democrats and Republicans say New Hampshire, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Indiana and Nevada are all toss-ups.
But on the margins, there is disagreement. Florida Democrats say Rep. Patrick Murphy (D-Fla.) is trailing by just a point or 2, not 5 points like in the polls. And Wisconsin Republicans and the Club for Growth insist that Sen. Ron Johnson’s race will be far closer than public polls that sometimes show him down by double-digits. Those surveys have kept Washington GOP money away until a late-game infusion Monday from the Senate Leadership Fund.
“If it’s close and Johnson loses, they’ll look back and say they should have done something more,” McIntosh said.
Ticket-splitting
Republicans are relying on a return to ticket-splitting to save their majority. Voters may pick Democrat Hillary Clinton in the presidential race, but GOP Sens. Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania and Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire believe they positioned themselves to persuade suburban women to back them for reelection.
But with a week to go, ticket-splitters may actually provide a path for Democrats to seize the majority. While both Ayotte and Toomey are running ahead of Trump, they are doing so by much smaller margins than Democrats Evan Bayh and Jason Kander, who are running ahead of Trump in Indiana and Missouri. Polling averages indicate Bayh, in particular, is running a staggering 11 points ahead of Trump.
And while Republicans have a variety of attacks to deploy against Bayh because of his long record in Washington and the private sector over the past six years, their options are significantly limited when it comes to bringing Kander, an Afghanistan war veteran, down to Clinton’s popularity level. Republicans are worried that the Missouri race has become a referendum on incumbent GOP Sen. Roy Blunt's long history in D.C. and connections to lobbyists.
"Blunt's race is about him," said a Republican working on Senate races. "And he's getting crushed."
Ground game
Senate Republican operatives’ most consistent complaint this cycle has been the Republican National Committee’s failure to build a ground game on the same level as Democrats and Hillary Clinton. While individual campaigns and outside groups — including Americans for Prosperity and Susan B. Anthony List — have tried to make up the gap, some GOP operatives fear Democrats’ get-out-the-vote edge might be worth 3 percentage points or more in the final margin in some states.
Early vote numbers in some states bear this out: Democrats are outperforming their 2008 levels in Florida, and doing better than they did in 2012 in Nevada. But there are some blemishes on the Democratic record: Black turnout in North Carolina is down compared with past years.
Still, GOP operatives are more worried about a drop-off in their own vote than a Democratic surge.
“It’s not that Democrats are so good at this,” one operative said. “It’s that the RNC is so bad.”
Committe spokeswoman Lindsay Walters responded that the RNC "has built a permanent ground game operation that serves as the infrastructure for the entire GOP ticket."
"Both our data operation and field program are being utilized by Senate campaigns in multiple battleground states," she added.
Hillary Clinton's renewed email troubles inject a huge dose of uncertainty into the final days of the volatile fight for the chamber.
By Burgess Everett and Kevin Robillard
Democrats had all the momentum in the brutal battle for the Senate as Donald Trump’s presidential prospects took a nosedive last month. But the sudden relitigation of Hillary Clinton’s email practices has them on defense in the last week of the election, injecting even more uncertainty into the half-dozen races that could go either way and will determine which party controls the Senate.
Simultaneously, Trump has pulled back within striking distance. That makes Democrats nervous not because they think Trump can win, but because many Republican candidates are running ahead of Trump and a small swing in the presidential contest could make the difference in key Senate races.
“Republicans have done a great job of keeping it very close in a bad environment,” said David McIntosh, president of the fiscally conservative Club for Growth, which plowed millions into competitive races. “They’re consistently running anywhere from 5 to 6 points ahead of Trump. If Trump gets within a point or two,” Republicans can hold the chamber.
Democrats are still in the driver’s seat thanks to simple math: Republicans essentially have to run the table in the most competitive races to keep the Senate. Democrats are on offense in North Carolina, Missouri, Indiana, New Hampshire, North Carolina, Florida, Wisconsin and Illinois — and are only on defense in Nevada. That gives them lots of ways to take back the minimum four seats they need, though Democrats are hoping for much greater gains to give them some cushion heading into a brutal 2018 map.
“In terms of Hillary being president. I feel good about where she is. I think people have made their decision,” said Sen. Debbie Stabenow (D-Mich.). “In terms of the Senate, I think it’s tighter. I feel that the odds are we take back the Senate. But the question is, is it taking back the Senate by barely enough seats or [winning] seven or eight seats?”
Here’s POLITICO’s guide to five dynamics to watch in Senate races during what's sure to be a wild final seven days of the campaign.
A November surprise
In interviews on Monday, key strategists from both parties agreed that the “new investigative steps” into Clinton’s email practices announced by FBI Director James Comey are unlikely to seismically shift Senate battlegrounds. But the story is dominating the national news and finally puts the GOP on offense.
Indeed, Republicans spent most of the post-Labor Day period having to respond to the latest Trump outrage — to the point that several GOP candidates unendorsed him. No Democrats are abandoning Clinton after Comey’s bombshell, but at least Republicans have a new message to press.
“These kind of political disturbances, disruptions can have an effect. How much, I think is the question. But in a tight race, it could be significant,” said Sen. Steve Daines (R-Mont.).
Democrats said that internal polls over the weekend suggest Comey has not hurt them yet but added that his action was still unwelcome.
“It’s not a good development,” said a Democrat working on Senate races. “Does that affect our races? Maybe.”
Trump pulling closer to Clinton
The presidential campaign plays an undeniable role in Senate races and Trump is steadily gaining on Clinton since his October swoon sent Republicans fleeing from him. Clinton’s lead has dropped from about 7 points two weeks ago to roughly 3 points now, a trend that began before the FBI news.
Clinton still appears to be the overwhelming favorite to win. But Trump looks competitive in Florida and is within striking distance in Nevada, shifts that Republicans hope pay big dividends for them in an uphill battle to keep the Senate.
Still, Republicans fear that the landscape could shift yet again, perhaps with yet another bad story about Trump just before the election.
The Trump effect has been “tremendously damaging,” said Sen. Jeff Flake (R-Ariz.). “With just about any other candidate, we’d have been much better off.”
Shaky Senate polls
Then there's the possibility that we don't know what we think we know about all these competitive Senate races.
Remember Greg Orman? The Kansas independent went into Election Day in 2014 a slight favorite in the polls to win the Kansas Senate race that year. Incumbent GOP Sen. Pat Roberts ended up crushing him by double digits.
That year, pre-election polls favored Democrats by 4 points more than the actual results, according to FiveThirtyEight, which strategists attribute to public polls not reflecting what campaigns were seeing internally. Indeed, Republicans shifted some money from Joni Ernst’s successful run in Iowa that year to other races, even though public polls showed it a toss-up. She won comfortably by 8 points.
This year, public polls largely jibe with internal assessments of competitive Senate races: There are six toss-up races and poll averages show all of them within 4 points. Democrats and Republicans say New Hampshire, North Carolina, Pennsylvania, Missouri, Indiana and Nevada are all toss-ups.
But on the margins, there is disagreement. Florida Democrats say Rep. Patrick Murphy (D-Fla.) is trailing by just a point or 2, not 5 points like in the polls. And Wisconsin Republicans and the Club for Growth insist that Sen. Ron Johnson’s race will be far closer than public polls that sometimes show him down by double-digits. Those surveys have kept Washington GOP money away until a late-game infusion Monday from the Senate Leadership Fund.
“If it’s close and Johnson loses, they’ll look back and say they should have done something more,” McIntosh said.
Ticket-splitting
Republicans are relying on a return to ticket-splitting to save their majority. Voters may pick Democrat Hillary Clinton in the presidential race, but GOP Sens. Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania and Kelly Ayotte of New Hampshire believe they positioned themselves to persuade suburban women to back them for reelection.
But with a week to go, ticket-splitters may actually provide a path for Democrats to seize the majority. While both Ayotte and Toomey are running ahead of Trump, they are doing so by much smaller margins than Democrats Evan Bayh and Jason Kander, who are running ahead of Trump in Indiana and Missouri. Polling averages indicate Bayh, in particular, is running a staggering 11 points ahead of Trump.
And while Republicans have a variety of attacks to deploy against Bayh because of his long record in Washington and the private sector over the past six years, their options are significantly limited when it comes to bringing Kander, an Afghanistan war veteran, down to Clinton’s popularity level. Republicans are worried that the Missouri race has become a referendum on incumbent GOP Sen. Roy Blunt's long history in D.C. and connections to lobbyists.
"Blunt's race is about him," said a Republican working on Senate races. "And he's getting crushed."
Ground game
Senate Republican operatives’ most consistent complaint this cycle has been the Republican National Committee’s failure to build a ground game on the same level as Democrats and Hillary Clinton. While individual campaigns and outside groups — including Americans for Prosperity and Susan B. Anthony List — have tried to make up the gap, some GOP operatives fear Democrats’ get-out-the-vote edge might be worth 3 percentage points or more in the final margin in some states.
Early vote numbers in some states bear this out: Democrats are outperforming their 2008 levels in Florida, and doing better than they did in 2012 in Nevada. But there are some blemishes on the Democratic record: Black turnout in North Carolina is down compared with past years.
Still, GOP operatives are more worried about a drop-off in their own vote than a Democratic surge.
“It’s not that Democrats are so good at this,” one operative said. “It’s that the RNC is so bad.”
Committe spokeswoman Lindsay Walters responded that the RNC "has built a permanent ground game operation that serves as the infrastructure for the entire GOP ticket."
"Both our data operation and field program are being utilized by Senate campaigns in multiple battleground states," she added.
Avoided Paying....
How Donald Trump Avoided Paying Taxes
Using Other People’s Money...
By GABRIEL J.X. DANCE and AARON BYRD
The story of how Mr. Trump sidestepped a potentially ruinous tax bill emerged from documents recently discovered by The Times during a search of casino bankruptcy filings.
Mr. Trump structured his companies to allow him to have lucrative personal tax advantages, while limiting his personal liability should business go bad.
For each of his Atlantic City casinos, Mr. Trump formed a partnership between himself and a corporation that he wholly owned and created for this specific purpose.
At the time, many businesses, particularly real estate ventures, were structured similarly, with the goal of protecting owners from losing personal money should their businesses go bust. But Mr. Trump was playing on a vastly different scale than most; his leverage was the stuff of legend.
“There’s nothing like doing things with other people’s money, because it takes the risk,” Mr. Trump said at a campaign rally in September.
With the partnerships in place, Mr. Trump went looking for financing.
To purchase and finish construction on the Trump Taj Mahal, for instance, Mr. Trump’s company sold over a half-billion dollars in bonds – essentially i.o.u.s with interest – to individuals, companies and banks.
Within the first year, Mr. Trump began missing interest payments, a bad sign for investors. The Taj, though, was far from the only Trump business that was hemorrhaging money.
In the late 1980s and early 1990s, several of his casinos and other properties suffered significant losses, the majority of which ultimately ended up on Mr. Trump’s personal taxes.
Mr. Trump managed to turn these business losses to his personal gain — in the form of something called a net operating loss (N.O.L.).
But there was a threat to Mr. Trump’s N.O.L.: the debt forgiven by many of his creditors who were trying to salvage what was left of their investments.
Mr. Trump’s forgiven debt – which included the renegotiated bonds used to finance the Trump Taj Mahal – was viewed by the government as taxable income, and as such could be deducted from Mr. Trump’s personal N.O.L.
Mr. Trump needed a way to protect his advantage. He found a valuable one.
In a tax avoidance maneuver his own lawyers told him was legally dubious, Mr. Trump managed to avoid paying taxes on the forgiven debt by swapping partnership equity for debt. It didn’t matter if the actual market value of the equity was less than the forgiven debt. (Equity in an insolvent partnership could easily be next to worthless). This type of swap was made illegal for partnerships in 2004.
Mr. Trump also was part of a determined and successful lobbying campaign in 1991 to change several tax rules, including one that would allow him use his N.O.L. to offset all personal income, and not just real estate income. This cleared the way for him to avoid paying federal income taxes on ventures including “The Apprentice” (and “The Celebrity Apprentice”), for which Mr. Trump claims he was paid over $200 million.
Using Other People’s Money...
By GABRIEL J.X. DANCE and AARON BYRD
The story of how Mr. Trump sidestepped a potentially ruinous tax bill emerged from documents recently discovered by The Times during a search of casino bankruptcy filings.
Mr. Trump structured his companies to allow him to have lucrative personal tax advantages, while limiting his personal liability should business go bad.
For each of his Atlantic City casinos, Mr. Trump formed a partnership between himself and a corporation that he wholly owned and created for this specific purpose.
At the time, many businesses, particularly real estate ventures, were structured similarly, with the goal of protecting owners from losing personal money should their businesses go bust. But Mr. Trump was playing on a vastly different scale than most; his leverage was the stuff of legend.
“There’s nothing like doing things with other people’s money, because it takes the risk,” Mr. Trump said at a campaign rally in September.
With the partnerships in place, Mr. Trump went looking for financing.
To purchase and finish construction on the Trump Taj Mahal, for instance, Mr. Trump’s company sold over a half-billion dollars in bonds – essentially i.o.u.s with interest – to individuals, companies and banks.
Within the first year, Mr. Trump began missing interest payments, a bad sign for investors. The Taj, though, was far from the only Trump business that was hemorrhaging money.
In the late 1980s and early 1990s, several of his casinos and other properties suffered significant losses, the majority of which ultimately ended up on Mr. Trump’s personal taxes.
Mr. Trump managed to turn these business losses to his personal gain — in the form of something called a net operating loss (N.O.L.).
But there was a threat to Mr. Trump’s N.O.L.: the debt forgiven by many of his creditors who were trying to salvage what was left of their investments.
Mr. Trump’s forgiven debt – which included the renegotiated bonds used to finance the Trump Taj Mahal – was viewed by the government as taxable income, and as such could be deducted from Mr. Trump’s personal N.O.L.
Mr. Trump needed a way to protect his advantage. He found a valuable one.
In a tax avoidance maneuver his own lawyers told him was legally dubious, Mr. Trump managed to avoid paying taxes on the forgiven debt by swapping partnership equity for debt. It didn’t matter if the actual market value of the equity was less than the forgiven debt. (Equity in an insolvent partnership could easily be next to worthless). This type of swap was made illegal for partnerships in 2004.
Mr. Trump also was part of a determined and successful lobbying campaign in 1991 to change several tax rules, including one that would allow him use his N.O.L. to offset all personal income, and not just real estate income. This cleared the way for him to avoid paying federal income taxes on ventures including “The Apprentice” (and “The Celebrity Apprentice”), for which Mr. Trump claims he was paid over $200 million.
October 31, 2016
Trump’s companies have systematically destroyed emails
Trump's Missing Emails
By Kurt Eichenwald
Over the course of decades, Donald Trump’s companies have systematically destroyed or hidden thousands of emails, digital records and paper documents demanded in official proceedings, often in defiance of court orders. These tactics—exposed by a Newsweek review of thousands of pages of court filings, judicial orders and affidavits from an array of court cases—have enraged judges, prosecutors, opposing lawyers and the many ordinary citizens entangled in litigation with Trump. In each instance, Trump and entities he controlled also erected numerous hurdles that made lawsuits drag on for years, forcing courtroom opponents to spend huge sums of money in legal fees as they struggled—sometimes in vain—to obtain records.
This behavior is of particular import given Trump’s frequent condemnations of Hillary Clinton, his Democratic opponent, for having deleted more than 30,000 emails from a server she used during her time as secretary of state. While Clinton and her lawyers have said all of those emails were personal, Trump has suggested repeatedly on the campaign trail that they were government documents Clinton was trying to hide and that destroying them constituted a crime. The allegation—which the FBI concluded was not supported by any evidence—is a crowd-pleaser at Trump rallies, often greeted by supporters chanting, “Lock her up!”
Trump’s use of deception and untruthful affidavits, as well as the hiding or improper destruction of documents, dates back to at least 1973, when the Republican nominee, his father and their real estate company battled the federal government over civil charges that they refused to rent apartments to African-Americans. The Trump strategy was simple: deny, impede and delay, while destroying documents the court had ordered them to hand over.
Shortly after the government filed its case in October, Trump attacked: He falsely declared to reporters that the feds had no evidence he and his father discriminated against minorities, but instead were attempting to force them to lease to welfare recipients who couldn’t pay their rent.
The family’s attempts to slow down the federal case were at times nonsensical. Trump submitted an affidavit contending that the government had engaged in some unspecified wrongdoing by releasing statements to the press on the day it brought the case without first having any “formal communications” with him; he contended that he’d learned of the complaint only while listening to his car radio that morning. But Trump’s sworn statement was a lie. Court records show that the government had filed its complaint at 10 a.m. and phoned him almost immediately afterward. The government later notified the media with a press release.
Prosecutors responded to Trump’s affidavit by showing he had fudged his claim by using the term “formal communication”—an acknowledgment, they said, that he had received what only he would characterize as an informal notification—which they described as an intentional effort to mislead the court and the public. But the allegation slowed the case; it required government lawyers to appear in court to shoot down Trump’s false charge.
The Trumps had more delaying tactics. Trump announced in a press conference that his family and their company were bringing a $100 million countersuit against the government for libel; anonymous tenants and community leaders, he said, had been calling and writing letters expressing shock at the government’s “outrageous lies.” Once again, motions, replies and hearings followed. Once again, the court threw out the Trump allegations.
For months, the Trumps ignored the government’s discovery demands, even though court procedure in a civil or criminal case requires each side to produce relevant documents in a timely manner. This allows for the plaintiffs or prosecutors to develop more evidence in support of their claims, as well as for the defense to gather proof to fight the case against them. When litigation is filed or even contemplated, scrupulous lawyers and corporations immediately impose document-retention programs or require that any shredding or disposing of records be halted. Courts have handed down severe sanctions or even criminal charges of obstruction of justice against executives and companies that destroyed records because they knew they were going to be sued.
Yet when the government filed its standard discovery requests, the Trumps reacted as though seeking that information was outrageous. They argued in court that prosecutors had no case and wanted to riffle through corporate files on a fishing expedition. Once again, this led to more delays, more replies, more hearings...and another specious argument thrown out of court.
Six months after the original filing, the case was nowhere because the Trumps had repeatedly ignored the deadlines to produce records and answers to questions, known as interrogatories. When a government attorney finally telephoned a Trump lawyer to find out why, he was told the Trumps had not even begun preparing their answers and had no plans to do so. The Trumps also postponed and blocked depositions, refused to provide a description of their records, as required, and would not turn over any documents.
Finally, under subpoena, Trump appeared for a short deposition. When asked about the missing documents, he made a shocking admission: The Trumps had been destroying their corporate records for the previous six months and had no document-retention program. They had conducted no inspections to determine which files might have been sought in the discovery requests or might otherwise be related to the case. Instead, in order to “save space,” Trump testified, officials with his company had been tossing documents into the shredder and garbage.
The government dashed to court, seeking sanctions against the Trumps. Prosecutors asked the judge to allow them to search through the corporate files or simply declare the Trumps in default and enter a judgment against them. The judge opted to allow the government access to the company offices so they could find the records themselves.
In three letters and three phone calls, the government notified the Trumps that this inspection would take place on June 12, 1974. When they arrived at the Trump offices, Trump was there, but he and everyone else were “surprised” that prosecutors had come and refused to allow them access to documents without their defense lawyers present. A prosecutor called those lawyers, but they were not in their offices. The frustrated prosecutors then gave up and headed back to court.
The Trump strategy was simple: deny, impede and delay, while destroying documents the court had ordered them to hand over.
They were then hit with a new delaying tactic. The Trumps submitted a filing based on statements by Trump that radically misrepresented what had occurred that day. He claimed a prosecutor, Donna Goldstein, had arrived at the company without notifying the Trumps’ counsel, refused to telephone their lawyer and demanded access to Trump’s office. The prosecutor—accompanied, the Trumps claimed, by five “stormtroopers”—then banged on doors throughout the office, insisting she and her team be allowed to “swarm haphazardly through all the Trump files and to totally disrupt their daily business routine.”
At the same time, in a move that caused another huge delay, the Trumps claimed that Goldstein had been threatening Trump employees who were potential witnesses. In several instances, the employees signed affidavits stating they had been subjected to abuse by Goldstein, then denied it when they were forced to testify. Even one of the government’s key witnesses, Thomas Miranda—who told the government the Trumps instructed managers to flag applications from minorities and that he was afraid the family would physically harm him—suddenly announced that prosecutors had threatened him and that he had never provided any evidence against the Trumps.
These allegations of misconduct, which demanded sanctions against the government for abusing its power, required more hearings. Once again, the Trump claims went nowhere.
In June 1975, more than 18 months after the government filed the case and with the Trumps still withholding potentially relevant records, the two sides struck a settlement. The agreement—which, like all civil settlements, did not contain an admission of guilt—compelled the Trumps to comply with federal housing regulations against discrimination, adopt specific policies to advance that goal, to notify the community that apartments would be rented to anyone, regardless of race, and meet other requirements.
The Trumps ignored these requirements and still refused to rent apartments to minorities, something the government proved by sending African-Americans and non-Hispanic Caucasians to pose as applicants. The government brought another complaint against the Trumps in 1978, who then agreed to a new settlement.
In that case, the government had the financial wherewithal to fight back against abuses of the courts and the discovery process by the Trump family. But many private litigants, who have to spend their own money and hire their own lawyers, have been ground down by Trump’s litigation-as-warfare-without-rules approach.
Courts are loath to impose sanctions when litigants fail to comply with discovery demands; in order to hurry cases along, judges frequently issue new orders setting deadlines and requirements on parties that fail to produce documents. But Trump and his companies did get sanctioned for lying about the existence of a crucial document to avoid losing a suit.
In 2009, a group of plaintiffs claimed Trump duped them into buying apartments in a Fort Lauderdale, Florida, development by portraying it as one of his projects. The fine print of the dense and legalistic purchase contracts, however, revealed that Trump had agreed only to license his name to the developers, and when the project hit financial snags, he walked away from it.
In their initial disclosures in 2011, Trump and his company said they had no insurance to cover any of their liability in this case. That was important because an insurance policy lets the plaintiffs calculate how much money a defendant can pay in a settlement without suffering any direct financial consequences. In other words, that insurance lets the plaintiff know how aggressively to pursue a settlement, knowing the defendant will have some losses covered by the policy.
At the time, a settlement in the then-prominent case could have been disastrous for Trump; he faced an array of similar lawsuits because he had licensed his name to developers around the world for projects that later collapsed. In each case, Trump had marketed the developments as his own, a claim contradicted by the sales contracts. A settlement in any of these cases might have encouraged other people who had lost deposits in a Trump-marketed development to file lawsuits against him.
Trump testified that officials with his company had been tossing records into the shredder and garbage.
Two years after denying that Trump had insurance that could have been used to settle the Fort Lauderdale litigation, one of his lawyers made a startling admission: Trump and his company had been insured all along for up to $5 million. But no more—the policy had recently “dried up,” the lawyer said. Stunned, the apartment buyers filed a motion seeking sanctions against Trump and his company, arguing that the case “may very well have settled long ago had the plaintiffs been provided with the policy in a timely manner,” according to a court filing.
Alan Garten, General Counsel at the Trump Organization for the past decade, said that at the time of the original disclosure, the company’s lawyers did not believe that the policy covered any potential liability in the lawsuit, which he said was an error on his part. “This solely fell on me, and if anyone is to blame for that, it’s me,’’ he said. “It was completely an innocent oversight. And it was my innocent oversight.’’ Garten said the other cases in this article preceded his time at the company and he did not know the facts surrounding them. In the Ft. Lauderdale case, Federal Judge Kathleen Williams ruled in favor of the plaintiffs and ordered Trump to pay limited legal fees for failing to disclose the policy, then held in reserve the possibility of imposing additional sanctions. The case subsequently settled.
Perhaps the worst legal case involving Trump and his companies hiding and destroying emails and other records involved real estate developer Cordish Cos., which, through an affiliate called Power Plant Entertainment LLC, built two American Indian casinos in Florida. In January 2005, Trump Hotels and Casino Resorts sued in a state court almost immediately after the opening of the casinos, which both operate under the Hard Rock brand. In his lawsuit, Trump claimed that the companies had unlawfully conspired with one of his former associates to cheat him out of the deal; he argued that the projects should be turned over to him.
Negotiations with the tribe and construction of the casinos had taken many years, raising the possibility that the state’s four-year statute of limitations had passed before Trump finally got around to filing his lawsuit. If Power Plant could prove Trump knew in early 2000 that his former associate was working on the Hard Rock deal, the case would be thrown out of court. The clock here for the statute of limitations starts ticking down when plaintiffs learn they have been swindled.
Trump claimed he learned about the deal in January 2001, about the time of the groundbreaking and more than three years before he filed suit. However, the defendants contended he had been informed of the projects in 1999. Trump offered no evidence in support of his contention except his word, so the opposing lawyers filed extensive discovery demands, seeking emails, computer files, calendars and other records that might prove he knew about the casino deal before 2000.
A full year into the case, Trump and his company, Trump Hotels, had produced only a single box of documents, many of which were not relevant—and no emails, digital files, phone records, calendars or even documents Trump lawyers had promised to turn over. Interrogatories were still unanswered. Lawyers for Power Plant obtained a court order compelling Trump and his company to comply with the discovery demands and hand over the relevant information and documents.
In a March 2006 response, Trump’s lawyers argued that the emails and other electronic documents had not been produced because the company didn’t have them. They claimed it had no servers until 2001—the year Trump claimed he had learned of the Power Plant project. They also claimed Trump Hotels had no policy regarding retaining documents until 2003. In other words, they hadn’t turned over any emails because no emails had been saved on a Trump server.
Judge Jeffrey Streitfeld reacted with near disbelief. "I don't have the patience for this," he said. "This has been going on too long to have to listen—and I don't mean to be disrespectful—to this double-talk. There has to be an attitude adjustment from the plaintiff."
Streitfeld ordered Trump executives to file sworn statements attesting to how their email systems had worked from 1996 onward. In response, Trump Hotels filed an affidavit from one of its information technology managers stating that it had had no servers prior to 2001.
That was false and by deposing numerous IT specialists with two Trump companies—the Trump Organization and Trump Hotels—lawyers for Power Plant gradually chipped away at it. Finally, during a deposition nine months after he had signed the deceptive affidavit, the same Trump executive admitted his assertions in it were untrue. In fact, an IBM Domino server for emails and other files had been installed in 1999, the same year witnesses for Power Plant contended that Trump had learned of the casino deal. Prior to that, as early as 1997, the Trump corporations used servers off-site operated by a company called Jersey Cape, according to sworn testimony by one of the Trump IT experts; the following year, the Trump Organization and Trump Hotels moved to another email provider, Technology 21.
These startling revelations changed nothing, however, because there was no trove of documents. The Trump records had been destroyed. Despite knowing back in 2001 that Trump might want to file a lawsuit, his companies had deleted emails and other records without checking if they might be evidence in his case. Beginning around 2003, the company wiped clear the data from everyone’s computers every year. Lawyers for Trump Hotels had never sent out the usual communication issued during litigation instructing employees to stop destroying records that might be related to this case. The deletions continued, and backup tapes were reused—thus erasing the data they held. Power Plant lawyers also discovered that after the lawsuit was filed, Trump Hotels disposed of a key witness’s computer without preserving the data on it.
Data from everyone’s computers at Trump’s company was wiped clear every year.
In subsequent filings, Power Plant maintained that Trump Hotels had intentionally deceived the court in its March 2006 filing when it claimed it had located no emails relevant to the case because, at that point, it had not yet conducted any searches of its computer system. Trump Hotels executives did not instruct their IT department to examine backup computer tapes until 2007, and even then the job wasn’t done, depositions show. And when computer specialists finally attempted to electronically locate any relevant documents that had survived the flurry of deletions, the procedures were absurdly inadequate. While looking for relevant documents, the technology team was told to use only two search terms—the name of the tribe and the last name of the former Trump associate. So even if there was an email that stated, “Donald Trump learned the full details of the Hard Rock casino deal in Florida in 1999,” it would not have been found by this search.
With all this proof that Trump Hotels had ignored every court order and filed false documents, Power Plant asked the judge either to impose sanctions or allow its own expert to search for relevant digital records. Trump Hotels argued it had done nothing improper, although its lawyers acknowledged having made some mistakes. Still, Streitfeld ordered Trump Hotels to make its servers and computer systems available for inspection by a computer forensics consulting firm. That review showed there was no digital data in the computers, servers or backup tapes prior to January 2001—the very month Trump claimed to have learned of the Florida casino deal.
With the likelihood of sanctions growing, Trump Hotels dropped the suit a few months later, in part because of the company’s financial troubles. A company involved in the Power Plant case agreed to purchase one of Trump’s struggling casinos in Atlantic City, New Jersey, and included as part of the deal a requirement that the litigation be ended.
This review of Trump’s many decades of abusing the judicial system, ignoring judges, disregarding rules, destroying documents and lying about it is not simply a sordid history lesson. Rather, it helps explain his behavior since he declared his candidacy. He promised to turn over his tax returns and his health records—just as he promised to comply with document discovery requirements in so many lawsuits—then reneged. As a result, he has left a sparse evidentiary trail that can be used to assess his wealth, his qualifications for the presidency or even his fitness. Should voters choose him to be the next U.S. president, he will enter the Oval Office as a mystery, a man who has repeatedly flouted the rules. He has solemnly told the country to trust him while refusing to produce any records to prove whether he speaks the truth or has utter contempt for it.
By Kurt Eichenwald
Over the course of decades, Donald Trump’s companies have systematically destroyed or hidden thousands of emails, digital records and paper documents demanded in official proceedings, often in defiance of court orders. These tactics—exposed by a Newsweek review of thousands of pages of court filings, judicial orders and affidavits from an array of court cases—have enraged judges, prosecutors, opposing lawyers and the many ordinary citizens entangled in litigation with Trump. In each instance, Trump and entities he controlled also erected numerous hurdles that made lawsuits drag on for years, forcing courtroom opponents to spend huge sums of money in legal fees as they struggled—sometimes in vain—to obtain records.
This behavior is of particular import given Trump’s frequent condemnations of Hillary Clinton, his Democratic opponent, for having deleted more than 30,000 emails from a server she used during her time as secretary of state. While Clinton and her lawyers have said all of those emails were personal, Trump has suggested repeatedly on the campaign trail that they were government documents Clinton was trying to hide and that destroying them constituted a crime. The allegation—which the FBI concluded was not supported by any evidence—is a crowd-pleaser at Trump rallies, often greeted by supporters chanting, “Lock her up!”
Trump’s use of deception and untruthful affidavits, as well as the hiding or improper destruction of documents, dates back to at least 1973, when the Republican nominee, his father and their real estate company battled the federal government over civil charges that they refused to rent apartments to African-Americans. The Trump strategy was simple: deny, impede and delay, while destroying documents the court had ordered them to hand over.
Shortly after the government filed its case in October, Trump attacked: He falsely declared to reporters that the feds had no evidence he and his father discriminated against minorities, but instead were attempting to force them to lease to welfare recipients who couldn’t pay their rent.
The family’s attempts to slow down the federal case were at times nonsensical. Trump submitted an affidavit contending that the government had engaged in some unspecified wrongdoing by releasing statements to the press on the day it brought the case without first having any “formal communications” with him; he contended that he’d learned of the complaint only while listening to his car radio that morning. But Trump’s sworn statement was a lie. Court records show that the government had filed its complaint at 10 a.m. and phoned him almost immediately afterward. The government later notified the media with a press release.
Prosecutors responded to Trump’s affidavit by showing he had fudged his claim by using the term “formal communication”—an acknowledgment, they said, that he had received what only he would characterize as an informal notification—which they described as an intentional effort to mislead the court and the public. But the allegation slowed the case; it required government lawyers to appear in court to shoot down Trump’s false charge.
The Trumps had more delaying tactics. Trump announced in a press conference that his family and their company were bringing a $100 million countersuit against the government for libel; anonymous tenants and community leaders, he said, had been calling and writing letters expressing shock at the government’s “outrageous lies.” Once again, motions, replies and hearings followed. Once again, the court threw out the Trump allegations.
For months, the Trumps ignored the government’s discovery demands, even though court procedure in a civil or criminal case requires each side to produce relevant documents in a timely manner. This allows for the plaintiffs or prosecutors to develop more evidence in support of their claims, as well as for the defense to gather proof to fight the case against them. When litigation is filed or even contemplated, scrupulous lawyers and corporations immediately impose document-retention programs or require that any shredding or disposing of records be halted. Courts have handed down severe sanctions or even criminal charges of obstruction of justice against executives and companies that destroyed records because they knew they were going to be sued.
Yet when the government filed its standard discovery requests, the Trumps reacted as though seeking that information was outrageous. They argued in court that prosecutors had no case and wanted to riffle through corporate files on a fishing expedition. Once again, this led to more delays, more replies, more hearings...and another specious argument thrown out of court.
Six months after the original filing, the case was nowhere because the Trumps had repeatedly ignored the deadlines to produce records and answers to questions, known as interrogatories. When a government attorney finally telephoned a Trump lawyer to find out why, he was told the Trumps had not even begun preparing their answers and had no plans to do so. The Trumps also postponed and blocked depositions, refused to provide a description of their records, as required, and would not turn over any documents.
Finally, under subpoena, Trump appeared for a short deposition. When asked about the missing documents, he made a shocking admission: The Trumps had been destroying their corporate records for the previous six months and had no document-retention program. They had conducted no inspections to determine which files might have been sought in the discovery requests or might otherwise be related to the case. Instead, in order to “save space,” Trump testified, officials with his company had been tossing documents into the shredder and garbage.
The government dashed to court, seeking sanctions against the Trumps. Prosecutors asked the judge to allow them to search through the corporate files or simply declare the Trumps in default and enter a judgment against them. The judge opted to allow the government access to the company offices so they could find the records themselves.
In three letters and three phone calls, the government notified the Trumps that this inspection would take place on June 12, 1974. When they arrived at the Trump offices, Trump was there, but he and everyone else were “surprised” that prosecutors had come and refused to allow them access to documents without their defense lawyers present. A prosecutor called those lawyers, but they were not in their offices. The frustrated prosecutors then gave up and headed back to court.
The Trump strategy was simple: deny, impede and delay, while destroying documents the court had ordered them to hand over.
They were then hit with a new delaying tactic. The Trumps submitted a filing based on statements by Trump that radically misrepresented what had occurred that day. He claimed a prosecutor, Donna Goldstein, had arrived at the company without notifying the Trumps’ counsel, refused to telephone their lawyer and demanded access to Trump’s office. The prosecutor—accompanied, the Trumps claimed, by five “stormtroopers”—then banged on doors throughout the office, insisting she and her team be allowed to “swarm haphazardly through all the Trump files and to totally disrupt their daily business routine.”
At the same time, in a move that caused another huge delay, the Trumps claimed that Goldstein had been threatening Trump employees who were potential witnesses. In several instances, the employees signed affidavits stating they had been subjected to abuse by Goldstein, then denied it when they were forced to testify. Even one of the government’s key witnesses, Thomas Miranda—who told the government the Trumps instructed managers to flag applications from minorities and that he was afraid the family would physically harm him—suddenly announced that prosecutors had threatened him and that he had never provided any evidence against the Trumps.
These allegations of misconduct, which demanded sanctions against the government for abusing its power, required more hearings. Once again, the Trump claims went nowhere.
In June 1975, more than 18 months after the government filed the case and with the Trumps still withholding potentially relevant records, the two sides struck a settlement. The agreement—which, like all civil settlements, did not contain an admission of guilt—compelled the Trumps to comply with federal housing regulations against discrimination, adopt specific policies to advance that goal, to notify the community that apartments would be rented to anyone, regardless of race, and meet other requirements.
The Trumps ignored these requirements and still refused to rent apartments to minorities, something the government proved by sending African-Americans and non-Hispanic Caucasians to pose as applicants. The government brought another complaint against the Trumps in 1978, who then agreed to a new settlement.
In that case, the government had the financial wherewithal to fight back against abuses of the courts and the discovery process by the Trump family. But many private litigants, who have to spend their own money and hire their own lawyers, have been ground down by Trump’s litigation-as-warfare-without-rules approach.
Courts are loath to impose sanctions when litigants fail to comply with discovery demands; in order to hurry cases along, judges frequently issue new orders setting deadlines and requirements on parties that fail to produce documents. But Trump and his companies did get sanctioned for lying about the existence of a crucial document to avoid losing a suit.
In 2009, a group of plaintiffs claimed Trump duped them into buying apartments in a Fort Lauderdale, Florida, development by portraying it as one of his projects. The fine print of the dense and legalistic purchase contracts, however, revealed that Trump had agreed only to license his name to the developers, and when the project hit financial snags, he walked away from it.
In their initial disclosures in 2011, Trump and his company said they had no insurance to cover any of their liability in this case. That was important because an insurance policy lets the plaintiffs calculate how much money a defendant can pay in a settlement without suffering any direct financial consequences. In other words, that insurance lets the plaintiff know how aggressively to pursue a settlement, knowing the defendant will have some losses covered by the policy.
At the time, a settlement in the then-prominent case could have been disastrous for Trump; he faced an array of similar lawsuits because he had licensed his name to developers around the world for projects that later collapsed. In each case, Trump had marketed the developments as his own, a claim contradicted by the sales contracts. A settlement in any of these cases might have encouraged other people who had lost deposits in a Trump-marketed development to file lawsuits against him.
Trump testified that officials with his company had been tossing records into the shredder and garbage.
Two years after denying that Trump had insurance that could have been used to settle the Fort Lauderdale litigation, one of his lawyers made a startling admission: Trump and his company had been insured all along for up to $5 million. But no more—the policy had recently “dried up,” the lawyer said. Stunned, the apartment buyers filed a motion seeking sanctions against Trump and his company, arguing that the case “may very well have settled long ago had the plaintiffs been provided with the policy in a timely manner,” according to a court filing.
Alan Garten, General Counsel at the Trump Organization for the past decade, said that at the time of the original disclosure, the company’s lawyers did not believe that the policy covered any potential liability in the lawsuit, which he said was an error on his part. “This solely fell on me, and if anyone is to blame for that, it’s me,’’ he said. “It was completely an innocent oversight. And it was my innocent oversight.’’ Garten said the other cases in this article preceded his time at the company and he did not know the facts surrounding them. In the Ft. Lauderdale case, Federal Judge Kathleen Williams ruled in favor of the plaintiffs and ordered Trump to pay limited legal fees for failing to disclose the policy, then held in reserve the possibility of imposing additional sanctions. The case subsequently settled.
Perhaps the worst legal case involving Trump and his companies hiding and destroying emails and other records involved real estate developer Cordish Cos., which, through an affiliate called Power Plant Entertainment LLC, built two American Indian casinos in Florida. In January 2005, Trump Hotels and Casino Resorts sued in a state court almost immediately after the opening of the casinos, which both operate under the Hard Rock brand. In his lawsuit, Trump claimed that the companies had unlawfully conspired with one of his former associates to cheat him out of the deal; he argued that the projects should be turned over to him.
Negotiations with the tribe and construction of the casinos had taken many years, raising the possibility that the state’s four-year statute of limitations had passed before Trump finally got around to filing his lawsuit. If Power Plant could prove Trump knew in early 2000 that his former associate was working on the Hard Rock deal, the case would be thrown out of court. The clock here for the statute of limitations starts ticking down when plaintiffs learn they have been swindled.
Trump claimed he learned about the deal in January 2001, about the time of the groundbreaking and more than three years before he filed suit. However, the defendants contended he had been informed of the projects in 1999. Trump offered no evidence in support of his contention except his word, so the opposing lawyers filed extensive discovery demands, seeking emails, computer files, calendars and other records that might prove he knew about the casino deal before 2000.
A full year into the case, Trump and his company, Trump Hotels, had produced only a single box of documents, many of which were not relevant—and no emails, digital files, phone records, calendars or even documents Trump lawyers had promised to turn over. Interrogatories were still unanswered. Lawyers for Power Plant obtained a court order compelling Trump and his company to comply with the discovery demands and hand over the relevant information and documents.
In a March 2006 response, Trump’s lawyers argued that the emails and other electronic documents had not been produced because the company didn’t have them. They claimed it had no servers until 2001—the year Trump claimed he had learned of the Power Plant project. They also claimed Trump Hotels had no policy regarding retaining documents until 2003. In other words, they hadn’t turned over any emails because no emails had been saved on a Trump server.
Judge Jeffrey Streitfeld reacted with near disbelief. "I don't have the patience for this," he said. "This has been going on too long to have to listen—and I don't mean to be disrespectful—to this double-talk. There has to be an attitude adjustment from the plaintiff."
Streitfeld ordered Trump executives to file sworn statements attesting to how their email systems had worked from 1996 onward. In response, Trump Hotels filed an affidavit from one of its information technology managers stating that it had had no servers prior to 2001.
That was false and by deposing numerous IT specialists with two Trump companies—the Trump Organization and Trump Hotels—lawyers for Power Plant gradually chipped away at it. Finally, during a deposition nine months after he had signed the deceptive affidavit, the same Trump executive admitted his assertions in it were untrue. In fact, an IBM Domino server for emails and other files had been installed in 1999, the same year witnesses for Power Plant contended that Trump had learned of the casino deal. Prior to that, as early as 1997, the Trump corporations used servers off-site operated by a company called Jersey Cape, according to sworn testimony by one of the Trump IT experts; the following year, the Trump Organization and Trump Hotels moved to another email provider, Technology 21.
These startling revelations changed nothing, however, because there was no trove of documents. The Trump records had been destroyed. Despite knowing back in 2001 that Trump might want to file a lawsuit, his companies had deleted emails and other records without checking if they might be evidence in his case. Beginning around 2003, the company wiped clear the data from everyone’s computers every year. Lawyers for Trump Hotels had never sent out the usual communication issued during litigation instructing employees to stop destroying records that might be related to this case. The deletions continued, and backup tapes were reused—thus erasing the data they held. Power Plant lawyers also discovered that after the lawsuit was filed, Trump Hotels disposed of a key witness’s computer without preserving the data on it.
Data from everyone’s computers at Trump’s company was wiped clear every year.
In subsequent filings, Power Plant maintained that Trump Hotels had intentionally deceived the court in its March 2006 filing when it claimed it had located no emails relevant to the case because, at that point, it had not yet conducted any searches of its computer system. Trump Hotels executives did not instruct their IT department to examine backup computer tapes until 2007, and even then the job wasn’t done, depositions show. And when computer specialists finally attempted to electronically locate any relevant documents that had survived the flurry of deletions, the procedures were absurdly inadequate. While looking for relevant documents, the technology team was told to use only two search terms—the name of the tribe and the last name of the former Trump associate. So even if there was an email that stated, “Donald Trump learned the full details of the Hard Rock casino deal in Florida in 1999,” it would not have been found by this search.
With all this proof that Trump Hotels had ignored every court order and filed false documents, Power Plant asked the judge either to impose sanctions or allow its own expert to search for relevant digital records. Trump Hotels argued it had done nothing improper, although its lawyers acknowledged having made some mistakes. Still, Streitfeld ordered Trump Hotels to make its servers and computer systems available for inspection by a computer forensics consulting firm. That review showed there was no digital data in the computers, servers or backup tapes prior to January 2001—the very month Trump claimed to have learned of the Florida casino deal.
With the likelihood of sanctions growing, Trump Hotels dropped the suit a few months later, in part because of the company’s financial troubles. A company involved in the Power Plant case agreed to purchase one of Trump’s struggling casinos in Atlantic City, New Jersey, and included as part of the deal a requirement that the litigation be ended.
This review of Trump’s many decades of abusing the judicial system, ignoring judges, disregarding rules, destroying documents and lying about it is not simply a sordid history lesson. Rather, it helps explain his behavior since he declared his candidacy. He promised to turn over his tax returns and his health records—just as he promised to comply with document discovery requirements in so many lawsuits—then reneged. As a result, he has left a sparse evidentiary trail that can be used to assess his wealth, his qualifications for the presidency or even his fitness. Should voters choose him to be the next U.S. president, he will enter the Oval Office as a mystery, a man who has repeatedly flouted the rules. He has solemnly told the country to trust him while refusing to produce any records to prove whether he speaks the truth or has utter contempt for it.
Hype on GMOs
The New York Times Cuts Through the Hype on GMOs
They're likely safe to eat, but they sure haven't lived up to their high-yield, low-pesticide promise.
By TOM PHILPOTT
Genetically modified seeds emerged in the mid-1990s and have since conquered million of acres of US farmland. Today, upward of 80 percent of corn, soybean, and cotton acreage is planted with crops engineered to withstand herbicides or insects, as have large portions of our sugar beet and alfalfa crops. Beyond the massive marketing triumph and financial success of companies like Monsanto and Syngenta—which sell both the seeds and the related herbicides—what has the industry achieved in terms of public benefits?
Have they helped farmers churn out more food per acre and reduce pesticides, as the industry has long claimed? Or, as some of their more extreme critics suggest, are they subtly poisoning the food supply?
In Sunday's New York Times, investigative journalist Danny Hakim has an elegant, in-depth piece digging beneath considerable industry hype to examine that question. His conclusion: While "fears that they are unsafe to eat" are "largely unsubstantiated," "genetic modification in the United States and Canada has not accelerated increases in crop yields or led to an overall reduction in the use of chemical pesticides."
To reach that conclusion, Hakim compared US yields of crops like corn and sugar beets with the same crops grown in Europe (charts here), where GMOs aren't widely used. He also compared pesticide-use rates. The result: "The United States and Canada have gained no discernible advantage in yields—food per acre—when measured against Western Europe, a region with comparably modernized agricultural producers like France and Germany." The result, he notes, is consistent with a recent National Academy of Sciences report that found that "there was little evidence that the introduction of genetically modified crops in the United States had led to yield gains beyond those seen in conventional crops."
Shorter: Europe essentially rejected GMOs and paid no price for it.
For pesticides, the performance has been mixed, but not exactly an affirmation of GMO crops' 20-year run.
One measure, contained in data from the United States Geological Survey, shows the stark difference in the use of pesticides. Since genetically modified crops were introduced in the United States two decades ago for crops like corn, cotton and soybeans, the use of toxins that kill insects and fungi has fallen by a third, but the spraying of herbicides, which are used in much higher volumes, has risen by 21 percent.By contrast, in France, use of insecticides and fungicides has fallen by a far greater percentage—65 percent—and herbicide use has decreased as well, by 36 percent.
The article has predictably generated a storm of criticism from industry enthusiasts. Hakim answered some of them in a tweetstorm Sunday morning (start here). I'll have more to say about it later this week. In the meantime, as someone who has been teasing out this story for a decade, it's refreshing to see the topic covered with such precision and clarity in the paper of record.
They're likely safe to eat, but they sure haven't lived up to their high-yield, low-pesticide promise.
By TOM PHILPOTT
Genetically modified seeds emerged in the mid-1990s and have since conquered million of acres of US farmland. Today, upward of 80 percent of corn, soybean, and cotton acreage is planted with crops engineered to withstand herbicides or insects, as have large portions of our sugar beet and alfalfa crops. Beyond the massive marketing triumph and financial success of companies like Monsanto and Syngenta—which sell both the seeds and the related herbicides—what has the industry achieved in terms of public benefits?
Have they helped farmers churn out more food per acre and reduce pesticides, as the industry has long claimed? Or, as some of their more extreme critics suggest, are they subtly poisoning the food supply?
In Sunday's New York Times, investigative journalist Danny Hakim has an elegant, in-depth piece digging beneath considerable industry hype to examine that question. His conclusion: While "fears that they are unsafe to eat" are "largely unsubstantiated," "genetic modification in the United States and Canada has not accelerated increases in crop yields or led to an overall reduction in the use of chemical pesticides."
To reach that conclusion, Hakim compared US yields of crops like corn and sugar beets with the same crops grown in Europe (charts here), where GMOs aren't widely used. He also compared pesticide-use rates. The result: "The United States and Canada have gained no discernible advantage in yields—food per acre—when measured against Western Europe, a region with comparably modernized agricultural producers like France and Germany." The result, he notes, is consistent with a recent National Academy of Sciences report that found that "there was little evidence that the introduction of genetically modified crops in the United States had led to yield gains beyond those seen in conventional crops."
Shorter: Europe essentially rejected GMOs and paid no price for it.
For pesticides, the performance has been mixed, but not exactly an affirmation of GMO crops' 20-year run.
One measure, contained in data from the United States Geological Survey, shows the stark difference in the use of pesticides. Since genetically modified crops were introduced in the United States two decades ago for crops like corn, cotton and soybeans, the use of toxins that kill insects and fungi has fallen by a third, but the spraying of herbicides, which are used in much higher volumes, has risen by 21 percent.By contrast, in France, use of insecticides and fungicides has fallen by a far greater percentage—65 percent—and herbicide use has decreased as well, by 36 percent.
The article has predictably generated a storm of criticism from industry enthusiasts. Hakim answered some of them in a tweetstorm Sunday morning (start here). I'll have more to say about it later this week. In the meantime, as someone who has been teasing out this story for a decade, it's refreshing to see the topic covered with such precision and clarity in the paper of record.
Ridiculous Military Spending
Why Can't We Rein In This Ridiculous Military Spending?
William Hartung on fear, greed, and the cash cow Congress won't touch.
By WILLIAM D. HARTUNG
Through good times and bad, regardless of what's actually happening in the world, one thing is certain: In the long run, the Pentagon budget won't go down.
It's not that the budget has never been reduced. At pivotal moments, like the end of World War II as well as the war's end in Korea and Vietnam, there were indeed temporary downturns, as there was after the Cold War. More recently, the Budget Control Act of 2011 threw a monkey wrench into the Pentagon's plans for funding that would go ever onward and upward by putting a cap on the money Congress could pony up for it. The remarkable thing, though, is not that such moments have occurred, but how modest and short-lived they've proved to be.
Take the current budget. It's down slightly from its peak in 2011, when it reached the highest level since World War II, but this year's budget for the Pentagon and related agencies is nothing to sneeze at. It comes in at roughly $600 billion—more than the peak year of the massive arms buildup initiated by President Ronald Reagan back in the 1980s. To put this figure in perspective: Despite troop levels in Iraq and Afghanistan dropping sharply over the past eight years, the Obama administration has still managed to spend more on the Pentagon than the Bush administration did during its two terms in office.
What accounts for the Department of Defense's ability to keep a stranglehold on our tax dollars year after endless year?
Pillar one supporting that edifice: ideology. As long as most Americans accept the notion that it is the God-given mission and right of the United States to go anywhere on the planet and do more or less anything it cares to do with its military, you won't see Pentagon spending brought under real control. Think of this as the military corollary to American exceptionalism—or just call it the doctrine of armed exceptionalism, if you will.
The second pillar supporting lavish military budgets (and this will hardly surprise you): the entrenched power of the arms lobby and its allies in the Pentagon and on Capitol Hill. The strategic placement of arms production facilities and military bases in key states and congressional districts has created an economic dependency that has saved many a flawed weapons system from being unceremoniously dumped in the trash bin of history.
Lockheed Martin, for instance, has put together a handy map of how its troubled F-35 fighter jet has created 125,000 jobs in 46 states. The actual figures are, in fact, considerably lower, but the principle holds: Having subcontractors in dozens of states makes it harder for members of Congress to consider cutting or slowing down even a failed or failing program. Take as an example the M-1 tank, which the Army actually wanted to stop buying. Its plans were thwarted by the Ohio congressional delegation, which led a fight to add more M-1s to the budget in order to keep the General Dynamics production line in Lima, Ohio, up and running. In a similar fashion, prodded by the Missouri delegation, Congress added two different versions of Boeing's F-18 aircraft to the budget to keep funds flowing to that company's St. Louis area plant.
The one-two punch of an environment in which the military can do no wrong while being outfitted for every global task imaginable, and what former Pentagon analyst Franklin "Chuck" Spinney has called "political engineering," has been a tough combination to beat.
The overwhelming consensus in favor of a "cover the globe" military strategy has been broken from time to time by popular resistance to the idea of using war as a central tool of foreign policy. In such periods, getting Americans behind a program of feeding the military machine massive sums of money has generally required a heavy dose of fear.
For example, the last thing most Americans wanted after the devastation and hardship unleashed by World War II was to immediately put the country back on a war footing. The demobilization of millions of soldiers and a sharp cutback in weapons spending in the immediate postwar years rocked what President Dwight Eisenhower would later dub the "military-industrial complex."
As Wayne Biddle has noted in his seminal book Barons of the Sky, the US aerospace industry produced an astonishing 300,000-plus military aircraft during World War II. Not surprisingly, major weapons producers struggled to survive in a peacetime environment in which government demand for their products threatened to be a tiny fraction of wartime levels.
Lockheed President Robert Gross was terrified by the potential impact of war's end on his company's business, as were many of his industry cohorts. "As long as I live," he said, "I will never forget those short, appalling weeks" of the immediate postwar period. To be clear, Gross was appalled not by the war itself, but by the drop off in orders occasioned by its end. He elaborated in a 1947 letter to a friend: "We had one underlying element of comfort and reassurance during the war. We knew we'd get paid for anything we built. Now we are almost entirely on our own."
The postwar doldrums in military spending that worried Gross so were reversed only after the American public had been fed a steady, fear-filled diet of anti-communism. NSC-68, a secret memorandum the National Security Council prepared for President Harry Truman in April 1950, created the template for a policy based on the global "containment" of communism and grounded in a plan to encircle the Soviet Union with US military forces, bases, and alliances. This would, of course, prove to be a strikingly expensive proposition. The concluding paragraphs of that memorandum underscored exactly that point, calling for a "sustained buildup of US political, economic, and military strength…[to] frustrate the Kremlin design of a world dominated by its will."
Sen. Arthur Vandenberg put the thrust of this new Cold War policy in far simpler terms when he bluntly advised President Truman to "scare the hell out of the American people" to win support for a $400 million aid plan for Greece and Turkey. His suggestion would be put into effect not just for those two countries but to generate support for what President Eisenhower would later describe as "a permanent arms establishment of vast proportions."
Industry leaders like Lockheed's Gross were poised to take advantage of such planning. In a draft of a 1950 speech, Gross noted, giddily enough, that "for the first time in recorded history, one country has assumed global responsibility." Meeting that responsibility would naturally mean using air transport to deliver "huge quantities of men, food, ammunition, tanks, gasoline, oil and thousands of other articles of war to a number of widely separated places on the face of the earth." Lockheed, of course, stood ready to heed the call.
The next major challenge to armed exceptionalism, and to the further militarization of foreign policy, came after the disastrous Vietnam War, which drove many Americans to question the wisdom of a policy of permanent global interventionism. That phenomenon would be dubbed the "Vietnam syndrome" by interventionists, as if opposition to such a military policy were a disease, not a position. Still, that "syndrome" carried considerable, if ever decreasing, weight for a decade and a half, despite the Pentagon's Reagan-inspired arms buildup of the 1980s.
With the 1991 Persian Gulf War, Washington decisively renewed its practice of responding to perceived foreign threats with large-scale military interventions. That quick victory over Iraqi autocrat Saddam Hussein's forces in Kuwait was celebrated by many hawks as the end of the Vietnam-induced malaise. Amid victory parades and celebrations, President George H.W. Bush would enthusiastically exclaim, "And, by God, we've kicked the Vietnam syndrome once and for all."
However, perhaps the biggest threat since World War II to an "arms establishment of vast proportions" came with the dissolution of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War, also in 1991. How to mainline fear into the American public and justify Cold War levels of spending when that other superpower, the Soviet Union, the primary threat of the previous nearly half-century, had just evaporated and there was next to nothing threatening on the horizon? General Colin Powell, then chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, summed up the fears of that moment within the military and the arms complex when he said, "I'm running out of demons. I'm running out of villains. I'm down to Castro and Kim Il-sung."
In reality, he underestimated the Pentagon's ability to conjure up new threats. Military spending did indeed drop at the end of the Cold War, but the Pentagon helped staunch the bleeding relatively quickly before a "peace dividend" could be delivered to the American people. Instead, it put a firm floor under the fall by announcing what came to be known as the "rogue state" doctrine. Resources formerly aimed at the Soviet Union would now be focused on "regional hegemons" like Iraq and North Korea.
After the 9/11 attacks, the rogue-state doctrine morphed into the Global War on Terror (GWOT), which neoconservative pundits soon labeled "World War IV." The heightened fear campaign that went with it, in turn, helped sow the seeds for the 2003 invasion of Iraq, which was promoted by visions of mushroom clouds rising over American cities and a drumbeat of Bush administration claims (all false) that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction and ties to Al Qaeda. Some administration officials including Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld even suggested that Saddam was like Hitler, as if a modest-sized Middle Eastern state could somehow muster the resources to conquer the globe.
The administration's propaganda campaign would be supplemented by the work of right-wing corporate-funded think tanks like the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute. And no one should be surprised to learn that the military-industrial complex and its money, its lobbyists, and its interests were in the middle of it all. Take Lockheed Martin Vice President Bruce Jackson. In 1997, he became a director of the Project for the New American Century and so part of a gaggle of hawks including future Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz, his future boss Donald Rumsfeld, and future Vice President Dick Cheney. In those years, PNAC would advocate the overthrow of Saddam Hussein as part of its project to turn the planet into an American military protectorate. Many of its members would, of course, enter the Bush administration in crucial roles and become architects of the GWOT and the invasion of Iraq.
The Afghan and Iraq wars would prove an absolute bonanza for contractors as the Pentagon budget soared. Traditional weapons suppliers like Lockheed Martin and Boeing prospered, as did private contractors like Dick Cheney's former employer, Halliburton, which made billions providing logistical support to US troops in the field. Other major beneficiaries included firms like Blackwater and DynCorp, whose employees guarded US facilities and oil pipelines while training Afghan and Iraqi security forces. As much as $60 billion of the funds funneled to such contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan would be "wasted," but not from the point of view of companies for which waste could generate as much profit as a job well done. So Halliburton and its cohorts weren't complaining.
On entering the Oval Office, President Barack Obama would ditch the term "global war on terror" in favor of "countering violent extremism"—and then essentially settle for a no-name global war. He would shift gears from a strategy focused on large numbers of "boots on the ground" to an emphasis on drone strikes, the use of Special Operations forces, and massive transfers of arms to allies like Saudi Arabia. In the context of an increasingly militarized foreign policy, one might call Obama's approach "politically sustainable warfare," since it involved fewer (American) casualties and lower costs than Bush-style warfare, which peaked in Iraq at more than 160,000 troops and a comparable number of private contractors.
Recent terror attacks against Western targets—Brussels, Paris, Nice, San Bernardino, Orlando—have offered the national security state and the Obama administration the necessary fear factor that makes the case for higher Pentagon spending so palatable. This has been true despite the fact that more tanks, bombers, aircraft carriers, and nuclear weapons will be useless in preventing such attacks.
The majority of what the Pentagon spends, of course, has nothing to do with fighting terrorism. But whatever it has or hasn't been called, the war against terror has proven to be a cash cow for the Pentagon and contractors like Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Northrop Grumman, and Raytheon.
The "war budget"—money meant for the Pentagon but not included in its regular budget—has been used to add on tens of billions of dollars more. It has proven to be an effective "slush fund" for weapons and activities that have nothing to do with immediate war fighting and has been the Pentagon's preferred method for evading the caps on its budget imposed by the Budget Control Act. A Pentagon spokesman admitted as much recently by acknowledging that more than half the $58.8 billion war budget is being used to pay for nonwar costs.
The abuse of the war budget leaves ample room in the Pentagon's main budget for items like the overpriced, underperforming F-35 combat aircraft, a plane that, at a price tag of $1.4 trillion over its lifetime, is on track to be the most expensive weapons program ever undertaken. That slush fund is also enabling the Pentagon to spend billions of dollars in seed money as a down payment on the department's proposed $1 trillion plan to buy a new generation of nuclear-armed bombers, missiles, and submarines. Shutting it down could force the Pentagon to do what it likes least: live within an actual budget rather than continuing to push its top line ever upward.
Although rarely discussed because of the focus on Donald Trump's abominable behavior and racist rhetoric, both candidates for president are in favor of increasing Pentagon spending. Trump's "plan" (if one can call it that) hews closely to a blueprint developed by the Heritage Foundation that, if implemented, could increase Pentagon spending by a cumulative $900 billion over the next decade. The size of a possible buildup under Hillary Clinton is less clear, but she has also pledged to work toward lifting the caps on the Pentagon's regular budget. If that were done, and the war fund continued to be stuffed with non-war-related items, the Pentagon and its contractors will be sitting pretty.
As long as fear, greed, and hubris are the dominant factors driving Pentagon spending (no matter who is in the White House), substantial and enduring budget reductions are essentially inconceivable. A wasteful practice may be eliminated here or an unnecessary weapons system cut there, but more fundamental change would require taking on the fear factor, the doctrine of armed exceptionalism, and the way the military-industrial complex is embedded in Washington.
Only such a culture shift would allow for a clear-eyed assessment of what constitutes "defense" and how much money would be needed to provide it. Unfortunately, the military-industrial complex that Eisenhower warned Americans about more than 50 years ago is alive and well, and gobbling up your tax dollars at an alarming rate.
William Hartung on fear, greed, and the cash cow Congress won't touch.
By WILLIAM D. HARTUNG
Through good times and bad, regardless of what's actually happening in the world, one thing is certain: In the long run, the Pentagon budget won't go down.
It's not that the budget has never been reduced. At pivotal moments, like the end of World War II as well as the war's end in Korea and Vietnam, there were indeed temporary downturns, as there was after the Cold War. More recently, the Budget Control Act of 2011 threw a monkey wrench into the Pentagon's plans for funding that would go ever onward and upward by putting a cap on the money Congress could pony up for it. The remarkable thing, though, is not that such moments have occurred, but how modest and short-lived they've proved to be.
Take the current budget. It's down slightly from its peak in 2011, when it reached the highest level since World War II, but this year's budget for the Pentagon and related agencies is nothing to sneeze at. It comes in at roughly $600 billion—more than the peak year of the massive arms buildup initiated by President Ronald Reagan back in the 1980s. To put this figure in perspective: Despite troop levels in Iraq and Afghanistan dropping sharply over the past eight years, the Obama administration has still managed to spend more on the Pentagon than the Bush administration did during its two terms in office.
What accounts for the Department of Defense's ability to keep a stranglehold on our tax dollars year after endless year?
Pillar one supporting that edifice: ideology. As long as most Americans accept the notion that it is the God-given mission and right of the United States to go anywhere on the planet and do more or less anything it cares to do with its military, you won't see Pentagon spending brought under real control. Think of this as the military corollary to American exceptionalism—or just call it the doctrine of armed exceptionalism, if you will.
The second pillar supporting lavish military budgets (and this will hardly surprise you): the entrenched power of the arms lobby and its allies in the Pentagon and on Capitol Hill. The strategic placement of arms production facilities and military bases in key states and congressional districts has created an economic dependency that has saved many a flawed weapons system from being unceremoniously dumped in the trash bin of history.
Lockheed Martin, for instance, has put together a handy map of how its troubled F-35 fighter jet has created 125,000 jobs in 46 states. The actual figures are, in fact, considerably lower, but the principle holds: Having subcontractors in dozens of states makes it harder for members of Congress to consider cutting or slowing down even a failed or failing program. Take as an example the M-1 tank, which the Army actually wanted to stop buying. Its plans were thwarted by the Ohio congressional delegation, which led a fight to add more M-1s to the budget in order to keep the General Dynamics production line in Lima, Ohio, up and running. In a similar fashion, prodded by the Missouri delegation, Congress added two different versions of Boeing's F-18 aircraft to the budget to keep funds flowing to that company's St. Louis area plant.
The one-two punch of an environment in which the military can do no wrong while being outfitted for every global task imaginable, and what former Pentagon analyst Franklin "Chuck" Spinney has called "political engineering," has been a tough combination to beat.
The overwhelming consensus in favor of a "cover the globe" military strategy has been broken from time to time by popular resistance to the idea of using war as a central tool of foreign policy. In such periods, getting Americans behind a program of feeding the military machine massive sums of money has generally required a heavy dose of fear.
For example, the last thing most Americans wanted after the devastation and hardship unleashed by World War II was to immediately put the country back on a war footing. The demobilization of millions of soldiers and a sharp cutback in weapons spending in the immediate postwar years rocked what President Dwight Eisenhower would later dub the "military-industrial complex."
As Wayne Biddle has noted in his seminal book Barons of the Sky, the US aerospace industry produced an astonishing 300,000-plus military aircraft during World War II. Not surprisingly, major weapons producers struggled to survive in a peacetime environment in which government demand for their products threatened to be a tiny fraction of wartime levels.
Lockheed President Robert Gross was terrified by the potential impact of war's end on his company's business, as were many of his industry cohorts. "As long as I live," he said, "I will never forget those short, appalling weeks" of the immediate postwar period. To be clear, Gross was appalled not by the war itself, but by the drop off in orders occasioned by its end. He elaborated in a 1947 letter to a friend: "We had one underlying element of comfort and reassurance during the war. We knew we'd get paid for anything we built. Now we are almost entirely on our own."
The postwar doldrums in military spending that worried Gross so were reversed only after the American public had been fed a steady, fear-filled diet of anti-communism. NSC-68, a secret memorandum the National Security Council prepared for President Harry Truman in April 1950, created the template for a policy based on the global "containment" of communism and grounded in a plan to encircle the Soviet Union with US military forces, bases, and alliances. This would, of course, prove to be a strikingly expensive proposition. The concluding paragraphs of that memorandum underscored exactly that point, calling for a "sustained buildup of US political, economic, and military strength…[to] frustrate the Kremlin design of a world dominated by its will."
Sen. Arthur Vandenberg put the thrust of this new Cold War policy in far simpler terms when he bluntly advised President Truman to "scare the hell out of the American people" to win support for a $400 million aid plan for Greece and Turkey. His suggestion would be put into effect not just for those two countries but to generate support for what President Eisenhower would later describe as "a permanent arms establishment of vast proportions."
Industry leaders like Lockheed's Gross were poised to take advantage of such planning. In a draft of a 1950 speech, Gross noted, giddily enough, that "for the first time in recorded history, one country has assumed global responsibility." Meeting that responsibility would naturally mean using air transport to deliver "huge quantities of men, food, ammunition, tanks, gasoline, oil and thousands of other articles of war to a number of widely separated places on the face of the earth." Lockheed, of course, stood ready to heed the call.
The next major challenge to armed exceptionalism, and to the further militarization of foreign policy, came after the disastrous Vietnam War, which drove many Americans to question the wisdom of a policy of permanent global interventionism. That phenomenon would be dubbed the "Vietnam syndrome" by interventionists, as if opposition to such a military policy were a disease, not a position. Still, that "syndrome" carried considerable, if ever decreasing, weight for a decade and a half, despite the Pentagon's Reagan-inspired arms buildup of the 1980s.
With the 1991 Persian Gulf War, Washington decisively renewed its practice of responding to perceived foreign threats with large-scale military interventions. That quick victory over Iraqi autocrat Saddam Hussein's forces in Kuwait was celebrated by many hawks as the end of the Vietnam-induced malaise. Amid victory parades and celebrations, President George H.W. Bush would enthusiastically exclaim, "And, by God, we've kicked the Vietnam syndrome once and for all."
However, perhaps the biggest threat since World War II to an "arms establishment of vast proportions" came with the dissolution of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War, also in 1991. How to mainline fear into the American public and justify Cold War levels of spending when that other superpower, the Soviet Union, the primary threat of the previous nearly half-century, had just evaporated and there was next to nothing threatening on the horizon? General Colin Powell, then chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, summed up the fears of that moment within the military and the arms complex when he said, "I'm running out of demons. I'm running out of villains. I'm down to Castro and Kim Il-sung."
In reality, he underestimated the Pentagon's ability to conjure up new threats. Military spending did indeed drop at the end of the Cold War, but the Pentagon helped staunch the bleeding relatively quickly before a "peace dividend" could be delivered to the American people. Instead, it put a firm floor under the fall by announcing what came to be known as the "rogue state" doctrine. Resources formerly aimed at the Soviet Union would now be focused on "regional hegemons" like Iraq and North Korea.
After the 9/11 attacks, the rogue-state doctrine morphed into the Global War on Terror (GWOT), which neoconservative pundits soon labeled "World War IV." The heightened fear campaign that went with it, in turn, helped sow the seeds for the 2003 invasion of Iraq, which was promoted by visions of mushroom clouds rising over American cities and a drumbeat of Bush administration claims (all false) that Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction and ties to Al Qaeda. Some administration officials including Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld even suggested that Saddam was like Hitler, as if a modest-sized Middle Eastern state could somehow muster the resources to conquer the globe.
The administration's propaganda campaign would be supplemented by the work of right-wing corporate-funded think tanks like the Heritage Foundation and the American Enterprise Institute. And no one should be surprised to learn that the military-industrial complex and its money, its lobbyists, and its interests were in the middle of it all. Take Lockheed Martin Vice President Bruce Jackson. In 1997, he became a director of the Project for the New American Century and so part of a gaggle of hawks including future Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz, his future boss Donald Rumsfeld, and future Vice President Dick Cheney. In those years, PNAC would advocate the overthrow of Saddam Hussein as part of its project to turn the planet into an American military protectorate. Many of its members would, of course, enter the Bush administration in crucial roles and become architects of the GWOT and the invasion of Iraq.
The Afghan and Iraq wars would prove an absolute bonanza for contractors as the Pentagon budget soared. Traditional weapons suppliers like Lockheed Martin and Boeing prospered, as did private contractors like Dick Cheney's former employer, Halliburton, which made billions providing logistical support to US troops in the field. Other major beneficiaries included firms like Blackwater and DynCorp, whose employees guarded US facilities and oil pipelines while training Afghan and Iraqi security forces. As much as $60 billion of the funds funneled to such contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan would be "wasted," but not from the point of view of companies for which waste could generate as much profit as a job well done. So Halliburton and its cohorts weren't complaining.
On entering the Oval Office, President Barack Obama would ditch the term "global war on terror" in favor of "countering violent extremism"—and then essentially settle for a no-name global war. He would shift gears from a strategy focused on large numbers of "boots on the ground" to an emphasis on drone strikes, the use of Special Operations forces, and massive transfers of arms to allies like Saudi Arabia. In the context of an increasingly militarized foreign policy, one might call Obama's approach "politically sustainable warfare," since it involved fewer (American) casualties and lower costs than Bush-style warfare, which peaked in Iraq at more than 160,000 troops and a comparable number of private contractors.
Recent terror attacks against Western targets—Brussels, Paris, Nice, San Bernardino, Orlando—have offered the national security state and the Obama administration the necessary fear factor that makes the case for higher Pentagon spending so palatable. This has been true despite the fact that more tanks, bombers, aircraft carriers, and nuclear weapons will be useless in preventing such attacks.
The majority of what the Pentagon spends, of course, has nothing to do with fighting terrorism. But whatever it has or hasn't been called, the war against terror has proven to be a cash cow for the Pentagon and contractors like Lockheed Martin, Boeing, Northrop Grumman, and Raytheon.
The "war budget"—money meant for the Pentagon but not included in its regular budget—has been used to add on tens of billions of dollars more. It has proven to be an effective "slush fund" for weapons and activities that have nothing to do with immediate war fighting and has been the Pentagon's preferred method for evading the caps on its budget imposed by the Budget Control Act. A Pentagon spokesman admitted as much recently by acknowledging that more than half the $58.8 billion war budget is being used to pay for nonwar costs.
The abuse of the war budget leaves ample room in the Pentagon's main budget for items like the overpriced, underperforming F-35 combat aircraft, a plane that, at a price tag of $1.4 trillion over its lifetime, is on track to be the most expensive weapons program ever undertaken. That slush fund is also enabling the Pentagon to spend billions of dollars in seed money as a down payment on the department's proposed $1 trillion plan to buy a new generation of nuclear-armed bombers, missiles, and submarines. Shutting it down could force the Pentagon to do what it likes least: live within an actual budget rather than continuing to push its top line ever upward.
Although rarely discussed because of the focus on Donald Trump's abominable behavior and racist rhetoric, both candidates for president are in favor of increasing Pentagon spending. Trump's "plan" (if one can call it that) hews closely to a blueprint developed by the Heritage Foundation that, if implemented, could increase Pentagon spending by a cumulative $900 billion over the next decade. The size of a possible buildup under Hillary Clinton is less clear, but she has also pledged to work toward lifting the caps on the Pentagon's regular budget. If that were done, and the war fund continued to be stuffed with non-war-related items, the Pentagon and its contractors will be sitting pretty.
As long as fear, greed, and hubris are the dominant factors driving Pentagon spending (no matter who is in the White House), substantial and enduring budget reductions are essentially inconceivable. A wasteful practice may be eliminated here or an unnecessary weapons system cut there, but more fundamental change would require taking on the fear factor, the doctrine of armed exceptionalism, and the way the military-industrial complex is embedded in Washington.
Only such a culture shift would allow for a clear-eyed assessment of what constitutes "defense" and how much money would be needed to provide it. Unfortunately, the military-industrial complex that Eisenhower warned Americans about more than 50 years ago is alive and well, and gobbling up your tax dollars at an alarming rate.
Trump's loyal army
Who are Trump's loyal army?
By Michael Goldfarb
America is so divided in 2016 that one half of the electorate can barely understand the other. Comprehending the Donald Trump phenomenon has become the dominant theme of US election coverage, crowding out the usual questions a presidential campaign might raise about economic and foreign policy.
The question is not about the candidate himself. Trump hasn't hidden who he is - he hasn't concealed his attitudes to women and racial minorities behind sly innuendo, and his views on how he will deal with global problems are out there for all to see.
What has puzzled people who won't be voting for him, is how tens of millions of their fellow citizens could still be willing to support him. Who are they?
The answer is to be found in understanding what I call "The Bloc".
The Bloc, roughly 40% of the electorate, doesn't represent a majority in the US but it is the country's largest unified group of voters. It has lost four of the last six presidential elections but has mostly remained in control of one or both houses of Congress, and many state legislatures, making it almost impossible for Democratic administrations to govern the country.
The Bloc wasn't created by the Great Recession of 2008 or by the attacks of 9/11 or the bursting of the Dotcom Bubble in 2000. It wasn't even created by the economic bogeyman of this election, Nafta - the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement.
Instead The Bloc was created by a series of events that, in an almost geological process, added sedimentary layer after layer of voters to the Republican Party.
A new layer is laid down whenever there is "another round of economic displacement", says Todd Gitlin, professor of sociology and journalism at Columbia University, the new voters being overwhelmingly whites who had previously been Democrats.
Gitlin traces its origins to the Dust Bowl of the 1930s, when many farmers and their families were driven from Oklahoma and Kansas by drought. Most ended up in southern California and their children were among the early supporters of the ultra-right-wing John Birch Society and the 1964 Republican presidential candidate, Barry Goldwater.
In the late 1960s many southern whites also joined The Bloc following the enactment of the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act, which finally delivered - 100 years after the end of slavery - on the promise of equality for African Americans.
Then in the late 70s and early 80s, as factories in the North-east and along the Great Lakes shut down, communities like Johnstown in western Pennsylvania were devastated. Steelworkers in the town, even with their strong trade unions, were thrown out of work. People were forced to leave the region in vast numbers to find jobs elsewhere. Those jobs are nowhere near as secure as the factory jobs that sustained generations and allowed stable communities to grow. It was a displacement every bit as wrenching as that of the 1930s.
"The Rust Belt is the Dust Bowl of our times," says Gitlin.
Others, for whom the Supreme Court's 1973 decision in Roe v Wade (which gave women abortion rights) became the single issue on which they vote, joined The Bloc as well.
But both of America's major parties are grand coalitions.
Over the last 50 years, while disaffected Democrats were making common cause with the traditionally wealthy Republicans, a new Democratic Party was taking shape as well.
Its make-up is diverse, its policies dedicated to using civil rights law to undo centuries of job discrimination against minorities and women through preferential hiring, as well as pushing for socially liberal legislation on sexuality.
An overwhelming majority of African-Americans, and significant majorities of Hispanics and Asians vote Democrat, while university-educated whites dominate the party and give it its worldview and voice.
Identity and gender politics are a regular feature of life and discussion on university campuses and in the mainstream news media. Much of the debate, from the Democratic side this year, has been about white male identity. The New York Times has run dozens of articles about "angry white men".
A recent article was titled Men Need Help. Is Hillary Clinton the Answer? It was written by the paper's recently appointed gender editor, Susan Chira. Interestingly, in the late 1960s and 70s, when The Bloc began its rapid growth, it had a full-time labour correspondent. It doesn't any more.
This difference in thinking about the world provides a glimpse into America's terrible division.
When Donald Trump, speaking in his unique way, attacks Nafta for taking away American jobs, The Bloc cheers. When he attacks Democrats and their preference for gender and identity politics with its "politically correct" speech codes, the men and women of The Bloc nod in agreement.
Most Democrats shake their heads in disbelief and simply can't understand how anyone could vote for the Republican candidate.
One Clinton supporter I met while making my radio documentary, The Unswayables, did understand. Bonnie Cordova, a retired schoolteacher, and I were both watching the second presidential debate at the Bohemian Beer Garden in the New York borough of Queens. I asked her afterwards if she understood why people might vote for Trump.
She did. "I taught in inner city schools for 30 years," Cordova explained. "I was passed over a few times for promotion for a really good job because I wasn't a minority and I was working at a school where the kids got free dental and optical treatment because they were immigrant children and I was having trouble affording it for my kids." She acknowledged that made her resentful. "That's a flame that can be fanned into hatred. You have to rise above it."
Not everyone can rise above it.
And so American society and government is split. Dangerously.
But The Bloc isn't permanently moored to the Republican Party.
The Democrats would find governing easier if they brought some of its voters back. The best way to do that is directly related to employment. Economic displacement created The Bloc. Stable employment might whittle it away.
But Todd Gitlin, who has been a leader of left-liberal political movements in the US since the 1960s, doesn't hold out hope of this happening soon.
"What's the social democratic vision? There are fragmented visions, there are sectoral visions, little visions. There are no passionate centres. There is no luminous idea of what the world would look like if it were better," he says.
"People don't have a conception of the work of being a citizen and actually governing yourselves as a people. It's not just a problem on the right. It's that we don't have on the left a sustainable idea about political work."
The Bloc has been formed over a period of at least half a century. It will take more than one presidential election - dominated by the most unpresidential candidate in American history - to chip away at it.
It's not clear who on the Democratic side has the patience to give up the years that will be necessary to persuade these voters if not back to the Democratic fold at least to a position where compromise - and functioning government - is possible.
By Michael Goldfarb
America is so divided in 2016 that one half of the electorate can barely understand the other. Comprehending the Donald Trump phenomenon has become the dominant theme of US election coverage, crowding out the usual questions a presidential campaign might raise about economic and foreign policy.
The question is not about the candidate himself. Trump hasn't hidden who he is - he hasn't concealed his attitudes to women and racial minorities behind sly innuendo, and his views on how he will deal with global problems are out there for all to see.
What has puzzled people who won't be voting for him, is how tens of millions of their fellow citizens could still be willing to support him. Who are they?
The answer is to be found in understanding what I call "The Bloc".
The Bloc, roughly 40% of the electorate, doesn't represent a majority in the US but it is the country's largest unified group of voters. It has lost four of the last six presidential elections but has mostly remained in control of one or both houses of Congress, and many state legislatures, making it almost impossible for Democratic administrations to govern the country.
The Bloc wasn't created by the Great Recession of 2008 or by the attacks of 9/11 or the bursting of the Dotcom Bubble in 2000. It wasn't even created by the economic bogeyman of this election, Nafta - the 1994 North American Free Trade Agreement.
Instead The Bloc was created by a series of events that, in an almost geological process, added sedimentary layer after layer of voters to the Republican Party.
A new layer is laid down whenever there is "another round of economic displacement", says Todd Gitlin, professor of sociology and journalism at Columbia University, the new voters being overwhelmingly whites who had previously been Democrats.
Gitlin traces its origins to the Dust Bowl of the 1930s, when many farmers and their families were driven from Oklahoma and Kansas by drought. Most ended up in southern California and their children were among the early supporters of the ultra-right-wing John Birch Society and the 1964 Republican presidential candidate, Barry Goldwater.
In the late 1960s many southern whites also joined The Bloc following the enactment of the Civil Rights Act and Voting Rights Act, which finally delivered - 100 years after the end of slavery - on the promise of equality for African Americans.
Then in the late 70s and early 80s, as factories in the North-east and along the Great Lakes shut down, communities like Johnstown in western Pennsylvania were devastated. Steelworkers in the town, even with their strong trade unions, were thrown out of work. People were forced to leave the region in vast numbers to find jobs elsewhere. Those jobs are nowhere near as secure as the factory jobs that sustained generations and allowed stable communities to grow. It was a displacement every bit as wrenching as that of the 1930s.
"The Rust Belt is the Dust Bowl of our times," says Gitlin.
Others, for whom the Supreme Court's 1973 decision in Roe v Wade (which gave women abortion rights) became the single issue on which they vote, joined The Bloc as well.
But both of America's major parties are grand coalitions.
Over the last 50 years, while disaffected Democrats were making common cause with the traditionally wealthy Republicans, a new Democratic Party was taking shape as well.
Its make-up is diverse, its policies dedicated to using civil rights law to undo centuries of job discrimination against minorities and women through preferential hiring, as well as pushing for socially liberal legislation on sexuality.
An overwhelming majority of African-Americans, and significant majorities of Hispanics and Asians vote Democrat, while university-educated whites dominate the party and give it its worldview and voice.
Identity and gender politics are a regular feature of life and discussion on university campuses and in the mainstream news media. Much of the debate, from the Democratic side this year, has been about white male identity. The New York Times has run dozens of articles about "angry white men".
A recent article was titled Men Need Help. Is Hillary Clinton the Answer? It was written by the paper's recently appointed gender editor, Susan Chira. Interestingly, in the late 1960s and 70s, when The Bloc began its rapid growth, it had a full-time labour correspondent. It doesn't any more.
This difference in thinking about the world provides a glimpse into America's terrible division.
When Donald Trump, speaking in his unique way, attacks Nafta for taking away American jobs, The Bloc cheers. When he attacks Democrats and their preference for gender and identity politics with its "politically correct" speech codes, the men and women of The Bloc nod in agreement.
Most Democrats shake their heads in disbelief and simply can't understand how anyone could vote for the Republican candidate.
One Clinton supporter I met while making my radio documentary, The Unswayables, did understand. Bonnie Cordova, a retired schoolteacher, and I were both watching the second presidential debate at the Bohemian Beer Garden in the New York borough of Queens. I asked her afterwards if she understood why people might vote for Trump.
She did. "I taught in inner city schools for 30 years," Cordova explained. "I was passed over a few times for promotion for a really good job because I wasn't a minority and I was working at a school where the kids got free dental and optical treatment because they were immigrant children and I was having trouble affording it for my kids." She acknowledged that made her resentful. "That's a flame that can be fanned into hatred. You have to rise above it."
Not everyone can rise above it.
And so American society and government is split. Dangerously.
But The Bloc isn't permanently moored to the Republican Party.
The Democrats would find governing easier if they brought some of its voters back. The best way to do that is directly related to employment. Economic displacement created The Bloc. Stable employment might whittle it away.
But Todd Gitlin, who has been a leader of left-liberal political movements in the US since the 1960s, doesn't hold out hope of this happening soon.
"What's the social democratic vision? There are fragmented visions, there are sectoral visions, little visions. There are no passionate centres. There is no luminous idea of what the world would look like if it were better," he says.
"People don't have a conception of the work of being a citizen and actually governing yourselves as a people. It's not just a problem on the right. It's that we don't have on the left a sustainable idea about political work."
The Bloc has been formed over a period of at least half a century. It will take more than one presidential election - dominated by the most unpresidential candidate in American history - to chip away at it.
It's not clear who on the Democratic side has the patience to give up the years that will be necessary to persuade these voters if not back to the Democratic fold at least to a position where compromise - and functioning government - is possible.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)