A place were I can write...

My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.



March 01, 2016

Ban Planned Parenthood

Now the GOP Wants to Ban Planned Parenthood From Teaching Sex Ed in Schools

A senator in Alaska says the health care organization is indoctrinating children.

By Samantha Michaels

The Alaska Senate passed a bill on Friday that prohibits abortion providers like Planned Parenthood from teaching sex education in public schools.

Republican state Sen. Mike Dunleavy, who sponsored the bill, described it as a way to protect children from the "indoctrination" of abortion providers. "Let's be straight," he told lawmakers before the vote. "The abortion providers are a business, they're in our schools to recruit our kids as agents of their business, and they're in our schools to recruit kids for potential clients later on down the road…This is a process of indoctrination, and it's getting worse."

The bill, SB 89, passed last week in an 11-7 vote. On Monday, the Senate passed it a second time, after its lone Democratic supporter asked that it be heard again.

The proposal does not name Planned Parenthood specifically. But the health care organization is the only abortion provider that teaches sex ed in the state's public schools, according to a spokeswoman for the organization. Planned Parenthood is also the largest nonprofit provider of sex ed in Alaska, teaching more than 2,000 students there each year, according to the Associated Press.

Planned Parenthood has said the measure will deprive students of access to information about STDs and contraception in a state that has the country's highest rate of chlamydia infections, the fifth-highest rate of gonorrhea, an above-average teen pregnancy rate, and a child sexual-assault rate that's six times the national average.

"In the face of these statistics, the state should really be focused on improving access to sexual-health education, instead of restricting it," says Planned Parenthood spokeswoman Jessica Cler.

Advocates of the proposal say it promotes parental involvement in education by allowing parents to withdraw their kids from school lessons over concerns about lessons on sexuality. But Democratic state Sen. Berta Gardner, who opposes the bill, says the law is unnecessary because parents in Alaska can already take their kids out of class if they don't approve of a lesson. The measure would do more harm than good, she says, because it would deprive children whose parents want them in sex ed from learning about sexuality and STDs.

"In this law, we're banning the one agency that is there and available with fact-based materials for children," she said, referring to Planned Parenthood. Dunleavy, the bill's sponsor, said parents and teachers should be in charge of sex education, "not abortion providers."

Dunleavy has also introduced a piece of companion legislation that would punish teachers and school board members who allow abortion providers to teach in Alaska schools. Under that bill, SB 191, school board members could risk funding for their district and teachers could lose their teaching certificates if any sex ed material comes from a person who's associated with an abortion provider.

Thirty-seven states and Washington, DC, require school districts to allow parental involvement in sex education, according to the Associated Press.

"We've certainly seen attacks on our sexual health education programs in other states, but never this extreme," Cler of Planned Parenthood says of the bill passed on Friday. She says lawmakers in Missouri and Montana introduced similar legislation in 2005 and 2013, respectively, but that those measures failed to pass.

The Alaska bill must still move through the state House, where a Republican representative introduced similar legislation last week. But at least one state legal expert has questioned whether the proposal could withstand a court challenge. In mid-February, a legislative attorney for the state Senate warned that the bill raised issues under the First Amendment—as well as other protections for free speech and association in the US and Alaska constitutions—by preventing schools from contracting with abortion providers. "It is likely that, if enacted," the attorney wrote, the bill "will be challenged in court, but it is difficult to predict the outcome."

Trump’s Budget Plan

Donald Trump’s Budget Plan Is Pure Fantasy. And It's a Nightmare for the Environment.

Fuzzy math.

By Ben Adler

Donald Trump has won the last three Republican presidential nominating contests and he holds a big lead in national polls. On Friday, Chris Christie shook the political world by endorsing him. Christie is considered a business-friendly establishment Republican and his ilk have generally lined up behind Marco Rubio. Christie's endorsement signals that he thinks Trump is going to be his party's nominee and he wants to get on the winner's good side.

Aside from his being an aggressively stupid climate science denier, Trump's agenda would have alarming implications for the environment, public health, and all other forms of regulation and investment in the public interest. On Thursday, Trump called for abolishing the EPA—and all of its work protecting land, air, and water from pollution and combatting climate change—but that's just the beginning. Trump's budget plan is so mathematically illiterate and extremely right-wing that it would require eliminating all spending on nearly everything the government does.

Trump has proposed an enormous tax cut heavily tilted toward the wealthy. He would reduce federal tax revenue by $9.5 trillion over the next 10 years. That's a 45 percent reduction in projected revenues. To be clear, this is only slightly more outrageous than the tax cuts proposed by his two major opponents, Rubio and Ted Cruz. Rubio proposed $6.8 billion in tax cuts over 10 years, and Cruz wants $8.6 trillion.

But that's only where Trump's budget-balancing problems begin. He also has promised not to cut spending on the major entitlement programs such as Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid, and to increase military spending.

Look at breakdowns of the federal budget from Politifact and the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities and a few salient facts emerge:

–Roughly half of the federal budget goes to paying for entitlements, which Trump says he won't cut.

–18 percent or so is for the military, including overseas operations. Trump wants to increase both general defense spending and our military actions in the Middle East.

–7 percent is mandatory interest payment on existing debt.

Taken together these categories account for about 73 percent of the federal budget.

Trump would need to find around $1.4 trillion in savings per year—$1 trillion to pay for his tax cuts and $400 billion to close the current deficit hole.

We already have a projected budget deficit of $426 billion in 2016 and Trump has pledged to balance the budget. So he would need to make spending cuts that not only equal but exceed his 45 percent reduction in revenue. But he can't do that when he can't touch 73 percent of the budget.

Trump says he will pay for his tax cuts by getting rid of tax deductions and "waste, fraud, and abuse" in government programs. He claims voters won't be "losing anything" in terms of actual government services.

This is impossible. His entire tax and budget plan—if the word "plan" can even be applied here—is absolutely mathematically impossible.

There aren't enough tax deductions and loopholes to come anywhere near compensating for the lost revenue even if Trump closed all of them, and Trump has already said he won't remove the two biggest income tax deductions, for charitable giving and home mortgage interest. (The latter is something we actually should gradually get rid of as it induces suburban sprawl.)

Trump would need to find around $1.4 trillion in savings per year—$1 trillion to pay for his tax cuts and $400 billion to close the current deficit hole. Eliminating every penny of "waste, fraud, and abuse" from non-military discretionary spending won't result in anywhere near that kind of savings because all of that spending, wasteful or otherwise, accounts for only about $650 billion a year.

So what would happen if Trump's tax cuts were passed? There would be an explosion in the federal budget deficit. Presumably the Republican Congress, as they often have in the past, would seize on the deficits they'd created as an excuse to squeeze discretionary spending down to as little as possible. In fact, there is a school of thought on the right, known as "starve the beast," that calls for passing deficit-inducing tax cuts in order to force spending cuts. But they could cut discretionary spending down to absolute zero and there would still be a deficit.

Discretionary non-military spending includes almost all of the cabinet agencies, so Trump is essentially proposing to get rid of them. When asked how he would pay for his tax cuts in Thursday night's CNN/Telemundo debate, Trump said, "We're getting rid of—we're going to get rid of so many different things. Department of Education—Common Core is out … Environmental protection—we waste all of this money. We're going to bring that back to the states … We are going to cut many of the agencies, we will balance our budget, and we will be dynamic again." As debate moderator Wolf Blitzer pointed out, the Department of Education's entire budget is $68 billion per year and the Environmental Protection Agency's is only $8 billion. Combined, they account for less than one-tenth of what Trump would need to cut.

So besides EPA and education, the departments of state, transportation, energy, commerce, treasury, justice, housing and urban development, and interior would all be on the chopping block. Cut them all entirely and Trump would still fall short. (There are some departments, like homeland security and health and human services, that Trump couldn't eliminate without violating other promises, like enhanced border security and replacing Obamacare.)

Without those departments, the US would no longer print money, maintain embassies abroad, negotiate with foreign nations, investigate and prosecute federal crimes, or maintain highway and transit systems, to name just a few things. Enormous segments of the federal government would cease to function or even exist. The US would verge on becoming a failed state. It's almost too absurd to contemplate — except that the man proposing it stands a very good chance of becoming the next Republican nominee for president.

So then let's contemplate the implications for environmental protection. The government's entire policy arsenal for combatting climate change, promoting clean energy, and protecting air, water, species, and ecosystems would be completely disabled. Here are just a few examples:

–No EPA means no Clean Power Plan and no further enforcement of existing regulations, or new regulations, on any related carbon or conventional air pollution. There would be no methane leakage rules, no new auto efficiency standards, no mercury or ozone regulations. Also no clean water programs. We'd have more Flints: more sick kids, especially in poor neighborhoods, from dirty air and poisoned water. Trump has been fantasizing for months about gutting the EPA, having told Fox News in October, "What they do is a disgrace. Every week they come out with new regulations. They're making it impossible."

–No State Department means no one to negotiate international climate agreements like the one recently struck in Paris. Trump, naturally, has already attacked the Paris Agreement.

–No HUD means no federal affordable housing programs and no funding for transit-oriented development. Support for urban rental housing would be axed, while we could continue to subsidize suburban home-buying through the tax code.

–No Department of Interior means no national parks management, no one to oversee and protect other federal lands, and no one enforcing federal endangered species protections.

–No Department of Justice means no federal prosecutors to bring charges when, say, a coal mining company violates federal safety laws. That recent conviction of Don Blankenship, CEO of Massey Energy? It wouldn't have happened in Donald Trump's America.

To be fair, Trump hasn't actually called for eliminating all of these departments and he could just decide to be even more wildly fiscally irresponsible and not cut them. More likely is that he would both cut them to the bone and still run up a huge deficit.

Regulatory policy experts and public interest lobbyists who I reached out to for this article say that they are at a loss as to what Trump's agenda would actually mean for environmental or public health regulation. What happens, for example, if you don't repeal the Clean Air Act and Clean Water Act, but you completely disable or eliminate the agency responsible for their implementation and enforcement? No one is entirely sure.

The nicest thing that can be said about Trump's budget vision is that it's only marginally less cogent than his rivals'. Cruz and Rubio have also backed gigantic tax cuts and promised to increase military spending.

And in some ways, Cruz and Rubio's stronger policy chops make them more overtly threatening to the planet and the people who call it home. Both have explicitly called for undoing the Clean Power Plan and withdrawing from the Paris Agreement. Trump probably doesn't even know what the Clean Power Plan is. But what his right-wing extremism lacks in precision it makes up for in grandiosity. For Trump to keep his other promises, a lot of other goods would have to fall by the wayside, environmental quality and climate protection among them.

Battle Over Reagan

The Battle Over Reagan’s Economic Plan

The spirited debate about the merits of Bernie Sanders's economic plan reminds two prominent economists of one that they were on opposite sides of 35 years ago.

By Bruce Bartlett and James Galbraith

Lately, a number of economists associated with the Democratic Party have been engaging in a spirited back-and-forth about the economic impact of Senator Bernie Sanders’ economic program. Those we will call establishment economists are mostly former members of the Council of Economic Advisers (CEA) under Democratic presidents, while those we will call the insurgents tend to be less well known but are, nevertheless, well-credentialed economists. In many respects, the establishment economists are on the right side of the Democratic Party’s political spectrum, while the insurgents are on the left.

The essence of the debate is whether Sanders’ economic plan, which involves a substantial increase in government spending for infrastructure and other programs, is capable of significantly raising the rate of economic growth in the near-term. The establishment economists say that is unlikely if not impossible because it implies an implausibly large increase in the labor force and productivity. The insurgents argue that there is still a great deal of unused capacity in the economy that could come on line quickly if the right policies were followed.

One of us (Galbraith) has already taken sides in that debate, but our purpose today is not to discuss the pros and cons of the Sanders plan. Rather, what struck both of us is the similarity to a debate that took place exactly 35 years ago about the economic impact of Ronald Reagan’s economic plan. One of us (Bartlett) was intimately involved in that debate while the other was a close observer. We viewed the debate from a perch on Capitol Hill where we both worked for the Joint Economic Committee, the congressional counterpart to the CEA.

The establishment in those days, like today, were mostly affiliated with the CEA under Republican presidents. Many identified themselves as “monetarists” associated with Milton Friedman at the University of Chicago who thought that the money supply was the central driver of the macroeconomy. Prominent monetarists in the administration included Jerry Jordan, a member of the 3-person CEA, and Beryl Sprinkel, Under Secretary of the Treasury for Monetary Affairs.

The insurgents were the supply-siders, who had sold Reagan on the idea of a big tax rate reduction modeled on legislation proposed by Rep. Jack Kemp and Senator Bill Roth in 1977. Inside the Reagan administration, they were represented by Larry Kudlow, chief economist for the Office of Management and Budget; Norman Ture, Under Secretary of the Treasury for Tax and Economic Affairs; and Paul Craig Roberts, Assistant Secretary of the Treasury for Economic Policy.

Like now, much of the debate between the two sides involved how much economic growth was capable of rising under Reagan’s proposed policies, and the administration’s economic forecast was the turf upon which the battle was fought. The supply-siders were very optimistic about faster growth and that inflation would fall rapidly. The monetarists thought large growth effects were implausible, given that the Federal Reserve had raised interest rates sharply and was tightening the money supply to squeeze inflation out of the economy. They also thought the fight against inflation would be long and painful.

Standing on the sidelines were mainstream economists, most of whom could probably be called Keynesian. In some ways they agreed with the monetarists, in other ways with the supply-siders. They were not especially enamored with a tax cut, but agreed that it would provide some fiscal stimulus to output and also raise inflation. They thought that Reagan’s proposed increase in defense spending was economically important, something mostly ignored by both the monetarists and the supply-siders. The Keynesians also thought faster growth was implausible as long as Fed policy remained tight.

Arbitrating the monetarist/supply-sider debate were Murray Weidenbaum, chairman of the CEA, who leaned toward the monetarists; David Stockman, director of the Office of Management and Budget, who had been a supply-sider but came to believe that reducing the deficit was paramount; and Treasury Secretary Don Regan, whose main interest was in pleasing the president and tended to side with the supply-siders. Treasury, OMB and the CEA made up the so-called “troika” that established the forecast used for budgetary purposes and Weidenbaum basically had the last word.

The forecast of inflation was the key battleground because it was the most politically important economic statistic, given that the consumer price index rose 13.3 percent in 1979 and 12.5 percent in 1980. The Carter administration’s last forecast, which probably reflected the conventional wisdom among economists, predicted double-digit inflation in 1981 and 1982, tapering down slowly to 6.3 percent by 1986.

According to reporting by John Berry in the Washington Post on February 7, 1981, the preliminary Reagan forecast saw inflation falling in half to 6.5 percent in 1982, 4.5 percent in 1983 and 3 percent in 1983. “The enormous reduction of inflation included in the Reagan forecast is sharply at odds with virtually all predictions made by other economists recently,” Berry said.

Additionally, the preliminary Reagan forecast saw rising output along with falling inflation. According to Berry, real gross national product would rise 7 percent in 1982 and 4.5 percent in 1983. But most economists thought that a rapid fall in inflation would cause real output to tank. Arthur Okun of the Brookings Institution had calculated in 1978 that a one percent reduction in the basic inflation rate would cost 10 percent of GNP, which would sharply raise the unemployment rate.

The magnitude of the recession implied by the initial Reagan inflation forecast was too frightening to contemplate. This led to much negotiating among the troika members, with supply-siders arguing that scaling back the growth forecast could be politically crippling since that was the big payoff to a large tax rate reduction.

Something had to give with either the growth forecast or the inflation forecast, since they were viewed as being fundamentally at odds with each other. In the end, the growth forecast was lowered and the inflation rate was raised to be less in conflict. This split-the-difference approach satisfied neither the monetarists nor the supply-siders, but it did have one virtue – it reduced the budget deficit in Reagan’s budget projections. That is because real growth has little impact on the budget, but higher inflation was helpful because the tax code was not indexed for inflation in 1981. Hence, higher inflation would lead to bracket-creep as people were pushed into higher tax brackets, thus increasing Treasury’s revenues.

As one can see in the table, the supply-siders were more right than wrong. Inflation came down much more rapidly than expected. This caused the economy to crash, as the monetarists and Keynesians predicted, but the bounce back was very strong.

Economic Forecasts: Carter, Reagan and CBO, 1981 (percent)

                                                      1981   1982   1983   1984   1985   1986 
Real GNP Growth    
          Carter                                     1.7      3.5      3.7      3.7      3.7      3.7
          Reagan                                   1.1      4.2      5.0      4.5      4.2      4.2 
          CBO                                       1.4      2.9      2.9      3.3      3.4      3.4 
          Actual (GDP)                          2.6     -1.9      4.6      7.3      4.2      3.5 

Inflation (CPI)    
          Carter                                    12.5    10.3     8.7      7.7      7.0      6.3
          Reagan                                  11.1     8.3      6.2      5.5      4.7      4.2
          CBO                                      11.3     9.5      9.0      8.3      7.7      7.2 
          Actual                                     8.9     3.8      3.8      3.9       3.8      1.1 

Unemployment Rate    
         Carter                                      7.8     7.5      7.1       6.7      6.3      6.0
         Reagan                                    7.8     7.2      6.6      6.4       6.0      5.6
         CBO                                        7.7     7.6      7.5      7.4       7.2      7.0 
         Actual                                     7.6     9.7       9.6     7.5        7.2      7.0 

According to Carter’s last budget, each one percentage point higher than expected inflation raised federal revenues by $11 billion – quite a lot when total revenues were around $600 billion. But this number is symmetrical, leading to lower revenues if inflation came in below forecast. This suggests that lower inflation added about $50 billion to the deficit in 1982 alone, about 40 percent.

A key reason for the rapid bounce back was from sharply rising defense expenditures, which rose from $134 billion in 1982 to $273 billion in 1986. According to Keynesian theory, increased government purchases of goods and services is the most effective countercyclical policy. So, unwittingly, Reagan’s policies provided a strong Keynesian kick to the economy just when it was needed.

The two of us were at loggerheads on these issues back in 1981, but with the passage of time it’s clear that we were both right to a certain extent. Inflation came down much faster than anyone thought at a much lower economic cost than imaginable. The tax cut deserves credit for this, as does the Keynesian medicine delivered by higher defense spending. The establishment was mostly wrong.

The lesson for today is that we shouldn’t be imprisoned by the conventional wisdom of establishment economists. When the magnitude of our economic problems is great, as it was with inflation in the early 1980s and stagnant growth now, bold policies must be enacted.

More Likely

Having Kids Makes You More Likely to Be Evicted

And five other takeaways from sociologist Matthew Desmond's new book, "Evicted."

By Edwin Rios

On the North Side of Milwaukee, Arleen's struggle to raise her two boys as a single mom on $628 a month ends in an eviction notice. On the South Side, a grandmother named Lorraine can't pay to heat her trailer, falls behind on the rent, and is eventually kicked out. The mark of eviction remains with both women long after they've been forced from their homes, their possessions hauled out on the street.

In his new book, Evicted: Poverty and Profit in the American City (out March 1), Harvard sociologist Matthew Desmond introduces us to Arleen, Lorraine, and others struggling with the consequences of getting tossed from their houses—a situation that disproportionately affects urban women. "If incarceration had come to define the lives of men from impoverished black neighborhoods, eviction was shaping the lives of women," Desmond writes. "Poor black men were locked up. Poor black women were locked out."

Desmond conducted his immersive, ethnographic fieldwork in Milwaukee for a little more than a year, living in a trailer park in the city's South Side and a rooming house in the North Side. He went on eviction ride-alongs with landlords and saw tenants and their possessions kicked to the curb. He sat with tenants in eviction court, where they wondered why they were getting kicked out. And with a crew of researchers, the 36-year-old researcher spearheaded the Milwaukee Area Renters Study, an extensive examination of the city's residential history that also offers a detailed look at urban poverty and evictions.

As a result, Evicted is a rich, empathetic feat of storytelling and fieldwork, one that Barbara Ehrenreich hails as "a new standard for reporting on poverty." I caught up with Desmond last week to discuss the costs of getting evicted, why kids don't protect parents from eviction, and what we can learn from the families on the margins. Here are six takeaways:

The face of the eviction epidemic are moms and families: "It's incredible that 1 in 8 renters in Milwaukee experience some sort of eviction in the course of two years," Desmond told me. "It's amazing that 1 in 5 African American women renting in the city report being evicted some time in their lifetime. So, the face of the eviction epidemic belongs to moms and kids, and it has a disproportionate effect on low-income African American women and low-income Latino women. It mirrors incarceration in certain ways. Eviction comes with a record, too, and just as a criminal record can bar you from receiving certain benefits or getting a foothold in the labor market, the record of eviction comes with consequences as well. It can bar you from getting good housing in a good neighborhood. Ironically, it can prevent you from receiving housing assistance. Arguably, the families most at need of housing assistance are systematically denied it because they're stamped with an eviction record. Moms and kids are bearing the brunt of those consequences."

Landlords consider kids to be a liability: "When I started this research, I thought kids would be a shield from eviction, that there would be some protections built in to help parents resist or protect them from displacement and homelessness. But it's really the opposite. Kids increase people's risk of eviction. We talked to about 250 people in eviction court in Milwaukee because we wanted to know: What explains why you get evicted and I don't, when we both show up to court? And the big answer is kids. Kids! If I lived with kids and you didn't and we owed the landlord the same thing and we had the same income and our racial and ethnic identity are the same, I would have a three times more likely chance of getting evicted than you. What you're seeing there is not the judges discretion or the commissioner, but the landlord. So kids can cost landlords money. They can get lead poisoning. They can draw the ear of the police if they are teenagers. Child Protection Services can get all up in your business if you have kids. Just strictly from a business standpoint, kids are a liability to landlords, and they actually provoke evictions."

The consequences of evictions go far beyond having shelter: "Families not only lose their home, but their possessions, too. Often, they are taken by movers, locked up, and lost, or put on the curb. People's stuff just get lost. People obviously lose their communities and schools. Then there's these consequences that I just didn't anticipate, like job loss. I thought going into it, 'You lose your job, you're getting evicted.' That's certainly true. But we have strong evidence that you get evicted, you're much more likely to lose your job. It can kind of take over your life. And if you're working in a sector of the labor market where you don't have a lot of security and a lot of protections, an eviction can cause you to get fired. And then there's the effect on your health—your mental health, your spirit. Moms that get evicted are depressed and have higher rates of depressive symptoms two years later. That has to affect their interactions with their kids and their sense of happiness. You add all that together, and it's just really obvious to me that eviction is a cause, not just a condition of poverty. It has to be part of the larger narrative that we are having today about inequality in America."

Displacement doesn't only happen in gentrifying areas: "Many times when we are talking about displacement, we talk about it within the frame of gentrification, which focuses on transitioning neighborhoods. But man, every city I've looked at, Milwaukee included, most evictions are right there, smack dab in ungentrifying, poor, segregated communities. So that's a big part of the story. But you know, this is a problem that's not just focused on the inner city or communities of color. This is a very broad story. If you go to eviction court, you are going to see a lot of moms and kids. You're going to see older people, too. You're going to see young, white families. You're going to see folks from immigrant communities. The problem of affordability and housing has stretched into a lot of regions in the country. One in five renters are estimated to be paying at least 50 percent of their income to housing now. It was important to write about a trailer park and things that folks in those communities are going through, because poverty and eviction lives there too."

A universal voucher program could give people in extreme poverty a chance: "The book argues for universal voucher program. It's basically taking our current voucher program, which allows folks to pay only 30 percent of their income to housing and the voucher covers the rest, and they can live wherever they want as long as their housing isn't too expensive or too shoddy—taking that program and expanding it would be a huge game-changer in the face of poverty in America. It would reduce family homelessness. It would make evictions rare again. It would allow families to use their freed-up income to take night classes or invest in their homes, invest in their kids. One very common thing families do when they finally get the housing voucher after years on the waiting list is just go buy more food. Their kids get enough to eat. They become better nourished and strong. But kids like Arleen's kids don't get that opportunity because their rent eats first. We do not have to reinvent the wheel on this one. There are countries in the developed world that have a universal affordable housing program, and they usually execute that through vouchers—Denmark, UK. There's groundwork for this that's already laid. There's a reason that vouchers are used instead of building public housing. It's way more efficient and would allow us to avoid the mistakes of our past about shoring up racial segregation, for example, or economic concentration of poverty by building these huge towers."

We should focus more on housing policy: "I want readers to take away Arleen. Here's this mom who's just trying to do right by her kids, but has to choose between paying the rent or buying them school supplies. I want them to take away Lorraine, this grandmother living in a trailer park that sees her breath inside her trailer because she can't pay rent and pay the heat bill. I want them to remember folks like Vanetta who are pushed into this desperate situation and commit a crime to keep her kids from living out in the streets. I want them to carry those stories, and to remember that somewhere in their city, a family has been thrown out of their home and their stuff has been piled on the sidewalk. I think that those stories and the statistical analysis point to one firm conclusion: Housing is deeply implicated in causing poverty in America today, and we have to do something."

Skewers Lazy Democrats

Samantha Bee Skewers Lazy Democrats Who "Built" Donald Trump

Wow.

By Grace Wilson

On Monday night, late night host Samantha Bee said Democrats should shoulder some of the blame for Donald Trump, the billionaire reality show star who is likely to become the Republican Party's presidential nominee.

"If you didn't vote in 2010, you built that," Bee said on her show, Full Frontal, while pointing at a photo of Trump.

Bee argued that 2008—the year the first black president was elected—was not the most important election in modern times for Democrats. It was the midterm election that was held two years later.

"The year was 2010. Kesha's brave cry for help was at the top of dance charts. The man made disaster spewing toxic foulness wasn't Donald Trump, but Deepwater Horizon. And, oh yeah, there was an election. Just one of those boring midterm ones that will.i.am. does not make videos about. And just like with our college midterms, most of America thought it was fine to sleep through this one."

She added: "You know who didn't sit 2010 out? People who were old, and white, and super cranky about something."

Those conservative voters helped elect more Republicans to Congress, which led to the current gridlock in Washington, she said.

Now, Americans are "so frustrated, they’re willing to vote for the first two bit wall salesman who says he’ll stop Mexicans from raping their jobs."

And there you have it. Because we dropped the ball in 2010, we have to pay for it with this "tangerine-tinted trash can fire," Bee said.

Ben? Who???

Ben Carson: Politics 'is a slimy thing'

By Eugene Scott

Ben Carson said Tuesday -- the day Republicans go to the polls in 11 states -- that while some Republican politicians were encouraging him to drop out of the Republican presidential race, his "social media fans" are begging him to remain in.

He declined to name who had asked him to leave the race due to his low support so far in the early nominating contests.

"I don't think it's useful to divulge that because they would be certainly unhappy if I did," Carson told MSNBC's Mika Brzezinski Tuesday on "Morning Joe." "But of course. It's politics as usual in Washington, D.C. It's a slimy thing."

The latest CNN/ORC poll has Carson at 10% support among Republican voters. Donald Trump is leading with 49%, followed by Florida Sen. Marco Rubio at 16%, Texas Sen. Ted Cruz at 15%, and Ohio Gov. John Kasich with 6%.

Carson said he hopes voters recognize that he is everything they say they want in a candidate.

"A lot of times, it's sitting under your nose and they don't recognize it," he said. "There's always a possibility that people will awaken and recognize that just what they were asking for, I have presented for them -- someone who is honest. They can't find any scandals. All the lies that have been told have been debunked."

Carson, who has had one of the larger social media followings among the candidates, said his supporters are keeping him in the race.

"Many of my social media fans are begging me not to get out, continue to support us tremendously and economically," he said. "There's really no reason to disregard what they have to say."

Carson said on Fox News' "Fox and Friends" that voters must remember that he was once the candidate that could beat Trump and Democratic front-runner Hillary Clinton.

"Before the barrage of attacks on me occurred, I was beating Trump head-to-head, Hillary head-to-head and there are those who didn't like that very much. And the people are the only ones who can rectify the situation," he said Tuesday.

Big mistake

Obama's big mistake on cyber

Applying the Wassenaar export control agreement to cyber technologies puts the country at risk.

By John Ratcliffe and Will Hurd

Cyber criminals, hacktivists, and foreign adversaries conduct millions of cyberattacks against U.S. interests daily, looking to steal state secrets and valuable information and undermine critical infrastructure. Attacks on the Office of Personnel Management and big-name private sector companies have shown that no one is immune.

To defend their networks and fix breaches, companies that harbor valuable information must rapidly communicate about vulnerabilities and issue necessary patches. But in 2013, the Obama administration made that significantly harder when it agreed to join other countries in applying export controls to critical cybersecurity tools and techniques. This decision will force companies to endure the burdensome process of obtaining export licenses before sharing time-sensitive information on security vulnerabilities, causing them to sit on critical threat information while their license application is processed.

In the coming weeks, the State Department is expected to begin setting its agenda on this issue for key international meetings in December. We implore the administration to undo its previous decision and renegotiate this agreement. America’s ability to protect itself in cyberspace is at stake.

Established in the 1990s, the little-known Wassenaar Arrangement, named after the city in the Netherlands where it was negotiated, is composed of 41 countries that agree upon export controls on conventional arms and dual-use goods and technologies. Each country has discretion in implementing these controls under its own national laws.

In 2013, the Wassenaar member countries agreed to add fundamental cybersecurity technologies to their list of export controls. The goal was to prevent intrusion and surveillance technologies from falling into the hands of authoritarian regimes that have used these technologies to spy on their populations and identify political dissidents. But negotiators failed to consult with experts in the cybersecurity industry, and agreed to expansive and vague additions to the Wassenaar export control regime.

Last May, the Commerce Department issued a proposed rule for implementing these export controls in the United States, prompting nearly unanimous opposition from the technology and cybersecurity industries, academics and security researchers. The significant pushback prompted Commerce to rescind its proposed rule. A new proposal has not been issued, and we hope one never emerges.

Export controls are most effectively used for dual-use weapons and goods that require physical space to manufacture, store and transport. In other words, goods that can be tracked. Export controls are applied in those contexts because there are a finite amount of such goods and there are ways to identify them entering or exiting a country. But the same cannot be said of cybersecurity tools and techniques, which could simply be code written on a sheet of paper that can be photocopied or scanned and sent electronically.

Applying export controls to the digital world could force a security professional to apply for a license before sharing an email that contains the code for a critical security vulnerability with an overseas colleague, or even with a colleague who works down the hall if he or she isn’t a U.S. citizen. The license could take months to process, while the company watches its adversaries change tactics daily — or hourly. This will leave American businesses insecure while a government office works at the slow pace of bureaucracy to grind out the necessary paperwork.

As these examples make clear, attempting to regulate cybersecurity technologies through export controls is a fundamentally flawed approach that will cripple the cybersecurity industry, putting us all at risk. Even worse, it will not achieve the goal of curbing human rights violations.

Instead of protecting against cyberthreats, Wassenaar will only give our cyber enemies more opportunity to attack U.S. companies. Real-time collaboration is an indispensable component of providing cybersecurity. Threat information must be shared around the globe at breathtaking speed to keep up with adversaries who are working 24/7 to undermine our networks, systems and critical infrastructure. But adding export controls to fundamental cybersecurity technologies will take us in the opposite direction.

In addition, export controls will not hamper the ability of bad actors and oppressive regimes to obtain so-called spyware. Countries with sizable information technology sectors such as India and Brazil are not members of the Wassenaar Arrangement, nor is cyber giant China or growing cyberthreat Iran. Therefore, nothing would preclude these countries from producing and selling the very technologies the Wassenaar countries are seeking to control.

This is not a partisan issue. When the Commerce Department released its proposed rule last May, a coalition of industry, academic and civil society groups pushed back. In December, a bipartisan group of 125 members of Congress wrote a letter to the administration expressing deep concern. In January, we held a joint hearing with representatives from the private sector and the departments of State, Commerce and Homeland Security to examine Wassenaar, with respect to cybersecurity and export controls. The hearing resulted in a clear consensus among both Democrats and Republicans that the administration must reconsider its decision.

The United States must not compromise its national security in exchange for implementation of an arrangement that is negligent bargaining at best, and a blatant security compromise at worst. Given the resounding outcry by stakeholders, the administration must go back to the drawing board on this issue. A new proposed rule from the Commerce Department will not fix the fundamental flaw that cybersecurity tools and technologies should not be regulated through export controls.

We urge the administration to admit it made a mistake and return to Wassenaar to renegotiate the agreement. The protection of the private sector depends on it.

Push for encrypted data

Experts: iPhone unlikely to hold many clues

The FBI's push for encrypted data from a San Bernardino shooter's phone is mainly about setting a precedent, one ex-DHS official says.

By David Perera

The legal and political noise surrounding Apple’s legal battle with the FBI conceals one undramatic reality, security and law enforcement experts say: Investigators probably won’t find much useful new information even if they unlock Syed Farook’s iPhone.

That’s because they already have access to a teeming trail of digital breadcrumbs that the terror suspect inevitably left behind before he and his wife killed 14 people in the Dec. 2 shooting rampage in San Bernardino, California, according to experts familiar with the technology involved. Those include data about the websites he visited using the county-issued work phone, calls he made, apps he downloaded and the people with whom he exchanged text messages — possibly including the content of some messages, up to about a week before the attacks.

And it’s unlikely that Farook had been communicating with terrorist sleeper cells or foreign handlers that authorities wouldn’t otherwise know about, one former Department of Homeland Security counterterrorism official told POLITICO.

All told, if the phone really contains valuable anti-terror data, investigators probably already have it.

So why are Justice Department prosecutors waging such a loud, public court fight to demand that Apple help it unlock the encrypted phone’s security protections — a fight that has alarmed the tech industry, stoked the debate about privacy versus national security, and even intruded into the presidential race?

The FBI is “hoping to set a precedent,” the ex-DHS official told POLITICO. And it chose its ground well: a terrorism case, where “the public opinion aspect is stronger.”

FBI Director James Comey and Apple's top lawyer are set to square off on the debate Tuesday afternoon in separate appearances before the House Judiciary Committee.

Critics say the FBI is picking a fight with Apple over long-standing tensions about the increasing impenetrability of the iPhone’s encryption, rather than acting from an immediate, pressing need to extract evidence. Before this month, its most-publicized encryption dispute with Apple involved an obscure meth dealer prosecution in Brooklyn.

No former national security official contacted by POLITICO was willing to totally write off the chance that Farook’s phone contained relevant information. He “could have taken a picture of something. … He could have written notes on the phone, he could have cut and pasted material,” said a former Justice Department official, speaking on condition of anonymity. “You can extract a lot of information from a photograph.”

But Farook's iPhone appears to be a relatively weak target. "There is a reasonably good chance that there is nothing of any value on the phone," San Bernardino city police Chief Jarrod Burguan told NPR on Friday, although he defended the FBI’s request as “an effort to leave no stone unturned.”

Comey has vigorously insisted that it’s critical that investigators unlock the iPhone to get a full picture of its contents in the last six weeks before the rampage. "Maybe the phone holds the clue to finding more terrorists," he wrote in a blog post this month. "Maybe it doesn't. But we can't look the survivors in the eye, or ourselves in the mirror, if we don't follow this lead."

Even if the phone contains just a sliver of information, that sliver could prove useful, former FBI Associate Deputy Director Buck Revell said. “It could be absolutely nothing or it could be the key to the next terrorist event and the wrap-up to this one,” he said.

But based on the Justice Department’s own documents, plus interviews with a half-dozen security experts, a wealth of information from Farook’s phone is already available to the FBI, even without having Apple break into it.

Experts say it’s nearly impossible for Farook not to have left digital traces up to the minute he died in a gun battle with police — data obtainable from sources such as Verizon’s cellular network, the advertising program of Verizon’s AOL subsidiary and even Apple itself.

That includes any phone numbers that Farook contacted if he made a regular voice call in the past year or longer. If he exchanged SMS text messages, the FBI most likely knows not just whom he sent them to, but the messages’ contents going back about a week before the shooting. Apple can disclose which apps he downloaded — including any encrypted text messaging apps. And Apple can probably identify whoever used the phone’s default iMessage text client to exchange messages with Farook, although not the content of those messages.

In addition, the FBI says it has obtained a full digital backup from Farook’s iCloud account, which was last synced with the phone on Oct. 19, offering an even more complete treasure lode for his activities until six weeks before the shootings.

“It gives you basically everything that’s on the phone,” said Jonathan Zdziarski, a forensic scientist who specializes in Apple devices. Examining that backup, agents can retrieve data such as the content of the iMessages and which Wi-Fi networks Farook used — yielding a record of his travels.

“You could even get third-party app data,” Zdziarski said, depending on how developers coded the software.

Apple spokesman Fred Sainz refused to clarify whether the company retains iMessage transaction information, and for how long. But the company said in a court filing Thursday that it had provided the FBI with “account information, emails and messages” associated with three Apple accounts in response to a search warrant.

"When the FBI came to us in the immediate aftermath of the San Bernardino attacks, we gave all the information we had related to their investigation," Apple general counsel Bruce Sewell is set to tell lawmakers at Tuesday's House Judiciary hearing, according to his prepared testimony. "And we went beyond that by making Apple engineers available to advise them on a number of additional investigative options."

Even so, he maintains, abiding by the government's latest request "would set a dangerous precedent for government intrusion on the privacy and safety of its citizens."

Security experts also have non-technical reasons for doubting that the phone contained much useful information — such as the fact that Farook and his wife, Tashfeen Malik, didn’t show much concern about what happened to it. Authorities have said the couple smashed their personal cellphones, along with their computer hard drives, before embarking on their shooting spree. But the phone was found in a black Lexus belonging to his family.

In addition, Farook didn’t bother to erase his iCloud backups. (There’s been speculation over whether he deliberately disabled new backups after Oct. 19, but they could have stopped on their own, perhaps because his account reached its storage limit.) He even left the device’s location-tracking Find My iPhone feature turned on, Zdziarski noted.

Plus, the former DHS counterterrorism official said, the relative amateurism of the shootings is one argument against the idea that Farook had been in contact with other terrorists or ISIL coordinators, further lessening the iPhone’s evidentiary value.

Running a sleeper cell inside the United States isn’t easy, requiring handlers and members to observe operational security practices that are easy to mess up. Had ISIL been able to coordinate the husband-and-wife team, the official said, it wouldn’t have told them to hit a nonprofit providing services to the developmentally disabled.

“The likelihood is that this is self-radicalization, followed by self-initiation,” the former official said of the shootings. “As horrible as it was on a personal level, it was not a geopolitical impactful activity.”

Nor do the government’s court filings mention sleeper cells and other terrorists. Instead, prosecutors discuss Farook’s iPhone communications with the shooting victims and his wife.

And if the government wants to read encrypted text message sent through an app such as Telegram — reported to be popular with ISIL — the FBI’s silence suggests there’s nothing to look at, said Nate Cardozo, a staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation. “I’m guessing if the phone did have Telegram installed, they would be shouting that from the rooftops,” he said.

Finally, former NSA official Ron Gula speculated, maybe the FBI and other agencies actually have the technology to get into the phone themselves, but are seizing on this case to publicize their push for “backdoors” to encryption.

“Obviously, the NSA, the CIA, whoever, is not going to come out and say, ‘We’ve got it, we can do this,’” said Gula, who’s now CEO of Tenable Network Security.

“I’d like to believe my government has the resources, including in the FBI, to do this,” he added. “So they’re making [the fight] public for a reason.”

Sailing

The will of allah

From Sailing Anarchy

Allah frowned on the Sultanate of Oman this past weekend after the beautiful town of Muscat provided yet another dismal showing for the beleaguered ACWS.  Fortunately, only a few gullible AC junkies paid to watch The World’s Fastest Boats drift around at 7 knots in another mind-numbingly bad pay-per-view production of The World’s Best Everything, and local spectators were nonexistent.

ISAF kindly waited for Russell Coutts’ Drifting Circus to end before releasing the news that proved ACEA is just as incompetent as ISAF at picking venues; after learning that they were required to guarantee equal treatment of all member nations’ sailors – even the Jews – Oman has officially withdrawn from their hosting of the 2016 ISAF Youth Worlds.

This is the same Oman that’s already spent tens of millions of dollars on the Oman Sail initiative to help transform the Sultanate into an international yachting destination while reintroducing Oman’s sailing heritage into the national culture.  Apparently, the Sultan just isn’t that into sailing any more – at least not if it means his kingdom needs to play by the same rules as everyone else.

Oman Sail CEO David Graham seemed to miss the news.  According to him, “The feedback…from the Louis Vuitton America’s Cup World Series Oman has been extremely positive. Let’s do it again!”  At least so long as the Jews stay home?

Several hig-ranking Israelis have  told us that without Sailing Anarchy’s highlighting of a little story on a little Tel Aviv news network back in November, this disturbing trend of anti-Israeli discrimination in international yachting may have continued unnoticed, and without thousands of you guys calling, writing, social media shaming, and otherwise holding ISAF and your national authorities’ feet to the fire; it’s a great example of the people taking their organization back from power-hungry bureaucrats and the vendors who curry their favor.

We also encourage you not to let up, and to continue to push back against the man who has presided over the most embarrassing period in ISAF/World Sailing history: President Carlo Croce.  While our sources have told us he is a passionate sailor who joined the ExComm to do good things, we’ve also seen how quickly power can corrupt at the top level of any sport.  Croce is currently caught in a massive and blatant conflict of interest that never should have been allowed — he continues to sit as both President of the Italian Sailing Federation AND President of Italy’s most prestigious yacht club — it’s time for a major change, starting with the man responsible for much of the opacity and intransigence of sailing’s governing federation.

Those who care about the governance of the sport and about sailing’s international reputation, we encourage you to get educated, and a good place to start is a deep look into the summarily inadequate Minutes of ISAF’s Executive Committee meeting from February 12th in Rio.  What’s the next big drama?  We think there are more than a few clues in here

Warren's ghost

Warren's ghost hovers over Massachusetts primary

As Clinton and Sanders slug it out, the state's most prominent politician is watching and waiting.

By Annie Karni and Gabriel Debenedetti

Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders are battling it out in Massachusetts ahead of the March 1 primary here — and the state’s most important endorsement, Sen. Elizabeth Warren, is still sitting on the sidelines of the debate, watching and waiting for her moment of maximum leverage.

Even as Clinton turns Massachusetts — a predominantly white, progressive New England state that should be tailor-made for Sanders — into a battleground Super Tuesday state, the campaign has been quietly respectful of Warren’s desire to remain neutral.

In part, that’s because the progressive standard-bearer — and the only member of the state’s congressional delegation who has not endorsed Clinton — is expected to play the role of peacemaker in the Democratic Party at some point in the months leading up to the convention, sources familiar with Warren’s thinking said.

If Clinton wins enough delegates by the end of March to become the presumptive Democratic nominee, Warren is expected to negotiate hard before giving her support to Clinton. In doing so, she could play a critical role helping to bring young, enthusiastic Sanders supporters into her fold.

Warren’s endorsement has grown in importance for Clinton over the past 10 months, as Sanders transformed before the Democratic front-runner's eyes from a little-known senator from a small state into a serious presidential contender energizing millennial voters across the country with his message of economic inequality.

The Clinton campaign has tried to give Warren the space she wants to make her decision on an endorsement, while at the same time elevating her top issues of Wall Street regulation, college debt and tax fairness. Clinton’s ability to gain Warren’s endorsement any time soon, sources said, depends on whether Clinton is able to establish enough of a delegate lead over the next month to make it virtually impossible for Sanders to clinch the nomination.

But even in that case, Warren has no firm timetable for making a decision, said a source familiar with her thinking.

As it waits for Warren, the Clinton campaign has remained in constant contact with her office and her allies. Clinton’s policy team in Brooklyn has assiduously courted financial reformers in Warren’s circles, like former Consumer Financial Protection Bureau official Rohit Chopra, while it has crafted its proposals on student loan reform and Wall Street regulation. Clinton's policy team in Brooklyn often turns to Warren's shop for consultation on regulatory issues.

There are other, more direct, chains of communication as well. Campaign CFO and former top federal financial regulator Gary Gensler is a close Warren ally. And longtime Clinton consultant Mandy Grunwald remains an important go-between — Grunwald worked a Warren’s top paid media consultant for her 2012 Senate campaign and is a longtime adviser to both politicians.

On Monday, Clinton made two stops in Massachusetts — in Springfield and in Boston — a significant investment of the candidate’s time the day before Super Tuesday, when 11 states across the country will cast their ballots.

There, she was already previewing a general election message targeting Donald Trump. “I don’t think America ever stopped being great,” she said. “What we need to do now is make America whole. Sanders also held a Massachusetts rally, in Milton, on Monday night.

But at least in Massachusetts, the primary battle is still going full steam. A victory here would be symbolically important for Clinton — after a landslide 48-point victory in South Carolina, it would demonstrate there is little room for Sanders if she is able to win both African-American voters in the South and progressive white New Englanders who should be the Vermont Senator’s bread and butter.

Clinton’s campaign decided to play hard in Massachusetts after the crushing 22-point loss in New Hampshire that rattled both Hillary and Bill Clinton and caused them to question their own campaign strategy.

Veteran Boston-based political operative Charlie Baker, who serves as the campaign’s chief administrative officer, took a break from his work from Brooklyn headquarters to organize the state. “After New Hampshire, we decided I should stay here,” Baker, who served as a senior adviser to John Kerry’s 2004 presidential campaign, told POLITICO. “I’ve been doing campaigns here since the 1970s.”

Public polls in recent days have shown Clinton leading by 5 to 8 points. “There’s a great base of support here,” Baker said. “We’re pleasantly surprised — Vermont is on the border.”

Clinton has a better shot of winning Massachusetts than she did in New Hampshire, Baker said, because more Democrats than independents vote in the primary. The population of independents is also slightly more educated and older — making them more likely to be in Clinton’s camp.

“It matters because it’s a historically progressive state — my first election, Massachusetts and Washington, D.C. voted for George McGovern,” said Baker of 1972. “I would challenge anyone to find a more progressive place.”

The Clinton campaign now has five paid staffers on the ground here, and seven campaign offices. Baker said 984 volunteers worked for Clinton over the weekend, and the campaign logged 130,000 calls. The campaign has also invested in television ads in the Boston and Springfield markets that include an emotional gun-control-focused spot starring former Arizona Rep. Gabby Giffords.

“We’re doing well among Democrats, and we’re doing better among independents than we did in New Hampshire,” Baker said. “These elected officials in Massachusetts actually do real campaign work. Every single one of these people has actually canvassed, twice, three times.”

Still, Sanders’ team has been focused on Massachusetts — a state where he remains strong in the west and the Boston suburbs, according to local Democrats — even longer. His campaign has long recognized it as an important pickup opportunity to kick off March. His local team, led by former union official Paul Feeney, has five offices in the state and has brought in hundreds of volunteers from its successful New Hampshire campaign.

“I’ve been reminding our staff in state, our volunteers, our supporters to try not to ride the poll-er-coaster,” Feeney said. “When I came on in November, the polling had us down 25 points.” Feeney said the campaign has been building a hyper-local organization, spearheaded by more than 200 town captains, since Jan. 1.

“We knew that the entire congressional delegation and the electeds would be against us,” Feeney said. “We built an organization, we didn’t borrow one.”

Sanders has also been courting Warren by praising her on the trail as he campaigns across her state. “What our campaign has been talking about is … that we have a rigged economy, something that your Sen. Elizabeth Warren has talked about,” Sanders said at a rally in Amherst last week. “Thank you all for sending Elizabeth to the Senate.”

Even so, Sanders’ staffers who were once confident that Massachusetts would be one of the five winnable states on Super Tuesday — along with Oklahoma, Minnesota, Vermont and Colorado — now think it will be a neck-and-neck race and are growing increasingly nervous about Clinton’s scaled-up operation.

Sanders’ campaign used its months of New Hampshire advertising in the Boston media market as a way to build up his presence in Massachusetts, according to senior aides. That makes the stakes even higher.

“If she wins in Massachusetts it’s likely to be a long night for Bernie Sanders,” explained Steve Koczela, president of the MassINC polling group, alluding to the pair of recent polls — including his own — that show Clinton with an unexpected lead here. “This forces the Sanders campaign to play a bit of defense in a state where they were hoping to win by quite a bit."