After I Lived in Norway, America Felt Backward. Here’s Why.
A crash course in social democracy.
By Ann Jones
Some years ago, I faced up to the futility of reporting truths about America’s disastrous wars, and so I left Afghanistan for another mountainous country far away. It was the polar opposite of Afghanistan: a peaceful, prosperous land where nearly everybody seemed to enjoy a good life, on the job and in the family.
It’s true that they didn’t work much–not by American standards, anyway. In the United States, full-time salaried workers supposedly laboring 40 hours a week actually average 49, with almost 20 percent clocking more than 60. These people, on the other hand, worked only about 37 hours a week, when they weren’t away on long paid vacations. At the end of the workday, about four in the afternoon (perhaps three during the summer), they had time to enjoy a hike in the forest, a swim with the kids, or a beer with friends—which helps explain why, unlike so many Americans, they are pleased with their jobs.
Often I was invited to go along. I found it refreshing to hike and ski in a country with no land mines, and to hang out in cafés unlikely to be bombed. Gradually, my war-zone jitters subsided and I settled into the slow, calm, pleasantly uneventful stream of life there.
Four years on, thinking I should settle down, I returned to the United States. It felt quite a lot like stepping back into that other violent, impoverished world, where anxiety runs high and people are quarrelsome. I had, in fact, come back to the flip side of Afghanistan and Iraq: to what America’s wars have done to America. Where I live now, in the homeland, there are not enough shelters for the homeless. Most people are either overworked or hurting for jobs; the housing is overpriced, the hospitals crowded and understaffed, the schools largely segregated and not so good. Opioid or heroin overdose is a popular form of death, and men in the street threaten women wearing hijabs. Did the American soldiers I covered in Afghanistan know they were fighting for this?
Ducking the Subject
One night I tuned in to the Democrats’ presidential debate to see if they had any plans to restore the America I used to know. To my amazement, I heard the name of my peaceful mountain hideaway: Norway. Bernie Sanders was denouncing America’s crooked version of “casino capitalism” that floats the already-rich ever higher and flushes the working class. He said that we ought to “look to countries like Denmark, like Sweden and Norway, and learn from what they have accomplished for their working people.”
He believes, he added, in “a society where all people do well. Not just a handful of billionaires.” That certainly sounds like Norway. For ages, they’ve worked at producing things for the use of everyone—not the profit of a few—so I was all ears, waiting for Sanders to spell it out for Americans.
But Hillary Clinton quickly countered, “We are not Denmark.” Smiling, she said, “I love Denmark,” and then delivered a patriotic punch line: “We are the United States of America.” (Well, there’s no denying that.) She also praised capitalism and “all the small businesses that were started because we have the opportunity and the freedom in our country for people to do that and to make a good living for themselves and their families.” She didn’t seem to know that Danes, Swedes, and Norwegians do that too, and with much higher rates of success.
The truth is that almost a quarter of American start-ups are not founded on brilliant new ideas, but on the desperation of men or women who can’t get a decent job. The majority of all American enterprises are solo ventures having zero payrolls, employing no one but the entrepreneur, and often quickly wasting away. Sanders said that he was all for small business too, but that meant nothing “if all of the new income and wealth is going to the top 1 percent.” (As George Carlin said, “The reason they call it the American Dream is because you have to be asleep to believe it.”)
In that debate, no more was heard of Denmark, Sweden, or Norway. The audience was left in the dark. Later, in a speech at Georgetown University in Washington, DC, Sanders tried to clarify his identity as a democratic socialist. He said he’s not the kind of socialist (with a capital S) who favors state ownership of the means of production. The Norwegian government, on the other hand, owns the means of producing lots of public assets and is the major stockholder in many a vital private enterprise.
I was dumbfounded. Norway, Denmark, and Sweden practice variations of a system that works much better than ours. Yet even the Democratic presidential candidates, who say they love or want to learn from those countries, don’t seem know how they actually work.
Why We’re Not Denmark
Proof that they do work is delivered every year in data-rich evaluations by the United Nations and other international bodies. The Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development’s annual report on international well-being, for example, measures 11 factors, ranging from material conditions such as affordable housing and employment to quality-of-life matters like education, health, life expectancy, voter participation, and overall citizen satisfaction. Year after year, all the Nordic countries cluster at the top, while the United States lags far behind. In addition, Norway has ranked first on the UN Development Program’s Human Development Index for 12 of the last 15 years, and it consistently tops international comparisons in such areas as democracy, civil and political rights, and freedom of expression and the press.
What is it, though, that makes the Scandinavians so different? Since the Democrats can’t tell you and the Republicans wouldn’t want you to know, let me offer you a quick introduction. What Scandinavians call the Nordic model is a smart and simple system that starts with a deep commitment to equality and democracy. That’s two concepts combined in a single goal because, as far as they’re concerned, you can’t have one without the other.
Right there, they part company with capitalist America, now the most unequal of all the developed nations, and consequently a democracy no more. Political scientists say it has become an oligarchy, run at the expense of its citizenry by and for the superrich. Perhaps you’ve noticed that.
In the last century, Scandinavians, aiming for their egalitarian goal, refused to settle solely for any of the ideologies competing for power—not capitalism or fascism, not Marxist socialism or communism. Geographically stuck between powerful nations waging hot and cold wars for such doctrines, Scandinavians set out to find a middle path. That path was contested—by socialist-inspired workers on the one hand, and by capitalist owners and their elite cronies on the other—but in the end, it led to a mixed economy. Thanks largely to the solidarity and savvy of organized labor and the political parties it backed, the long struggle produced a system that makes capitalism more or less cooperative, and then redistributes equitably the wealth it helps to produce. Struggles like this took place around the world in the 20th century, but the Scandinavians alone managed to combine the best ideas of both camps while chucking out the worst.
In 1936, the popular US journalist Marquis Childs first described the result to Americans in the book Sweden: The Middle Way. Since then, all the Scandinavian countries, and their Nordic neighbors Finland and Iceland, have been improving upon that hybrid system. Today in Norway, negotiations between the Norwegian Confederation of Trade Unions and the Confederation of Norwegian Enterprise determine the wages and working conditions of most capitalist enterprises, public and private, that create wealth, while high but fair progressive income taxes fund the state’s universal welfare system, benefiting everyone. In addition, those confederations work together to minimize the disparity between high-wage and lower-wage jobs. As a result, Norway ranks with Sweden, Denmark, and Finland as among the most income-equal countries in the world, and its standard of living tops the charts.
So here’s the big difference: In Norway, capitalism serves the people. The government, elected by the people, sees to that. All eight of the parties that won parliamentary seats in the last national election—including the conservative Høyre party now leading the government—are committed to maintaining the welfare state. In the United States, however, neoliberal politics puts the foxes in charge of the henhouse, and capitalists have used the wealth generated by their enterprises (as well as financial and political manipulations) to capture the state and pluck the chickens.
They’ve done a masterful job of chewing up organized labor. Today, only 11 percent of American workers belong to a union. In Norway, that number is 52 percent; in Denmark, 67 percent; in Sweden, 70 percent. Thus, in the United States, oligarchs maximize their wealth and keep it, using the “democratically elected” government to shape policies and laws favorable to the interests of their foxy class. They bamboozle the people by insisting, as Hillary Clinton did at that debate, that all of us have the “freedom” to create a business in the “free” marketplace, which implies that being hard up is our own fault.
In the Nordic countries, on the other hand, democratically elected governments give their populations freedom from the market by using capitalism as a tool to benefit everyone. That liberates their people from the tyranny of the mighty profit motive that warps so many American lives, leaving them freer to follow their own dreams—to become poets or philosophers, bartenders or business owners, as they please.
Family Matters
Maybe our politicians don’t want to talk about the Nordic model because it shows so clearly that capitalism can be put to work for the many, not just the few.
Consider the Norwegian welfare state. It’s universal. In other words, aid to the sick or the elderly is not charity, grudgingly donated by elites to those in need. It is the right of every individual citizen. That includes every woman, whether or not she is somebody’s wife, and every child, no matter its parentage. Treating every person as a citizen frees each one from being legally possessed by another—a husband, for example, or a tyrannical father.
Which brings us to the heart of Scandinavian democracy: the equality of women and men. In the 1970s, Norwegian feminists marched into politics and picked up the pace of democratic change. Norway needed a larger labor force, and women were the answer. Housewives moved into paid work on equal footing with men, nearly doubling the tax base. That has, in fact, meant more to Norwegian prosperity than the coincidental discovery of North Atlantic oil reserves. The Ministry of Finance recently calculated that those additional working mothers add to Norway’s net national wealth a value equivalent to its “total petroleum wealth”—currently held in the world’s largest sovereign-wealth fund, worth over $873 billion. By 1981, women were sitting in parliament, in the prime minister’s chair, and in her cabinet.
American feminists also marched for such goals in the 1970s, but the big boys, busy with their own White House intrigues, initiated a war on women that set the country back and still rages today in brutal attacks on women’s basic civil rights, healthcare, and reproductive freedom. In 1971, thanks to the hard work of organized feminists, Congress passed the bipartisan Comprehensive Child Development Bill to establish a multibillion-dollar national daycare system for the children of working parents. In 1972, President Richard Nixon vetoed it, and that was that. In 1972, Congress also passed a bill (first proposed in 1923) to amend the Constitution to grant equal rights of citizenship to women. Ratified by only 35 states—three short of the required 38—that Equal Rights Amendment was declared dead in 1982, leaving American women in legal limbo. In 1996, President Bill Clinton signed the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act, obliterating six decades of US social-welfare policy “as we know it,” ending federal cash payments to the nation’s poor, and consigning millions of female heads of household and their children to poverty, where many still dwell 20 years later. Today, even privileged women, torn between their underpaid work and their kids, are overwhelmed.
Things happened very differently in Norway. There, feminists and sociologists pushed hard against the biggest obstacle still standing in the path to full democracy: the nuclear family. In the 1950s, the world-famous American sociologist Talcott Parsons had pronounced that arrangement—with the hubby at work and the little wife at home—the ideal setup in which to socialize children. But in the 1970s, the Norwegian state began to deconstruct that undemocratic ideal by taking upon itself the traditional, unpaid household duties of women. Caring for children, the elderly, the sick, and the disabled became the basic responsibilities of the universal welfare state, freeing women in the workforce to enjoy both their jobs and their families.
Paradoxically, setting women free made family life more genuine. Many in Norway say it has made both men and women more themselves and more alike: more understanding and happier. It also helped kids slip from the shadow of helicopter parents. In Norway, both mother and father in turn take paid parental leave from work during the child’s first year or longer. At age 1, however, children start attending a neighborhood barnehage (kindergarten) for schooling spent largely outdoors. By the time kids enter free primary school at age 6, they are remarkably self-sufficient, confident, and good-natured. They know their way around town, and if caught in a snowstorm in the forest, how to build a fire and find the makings of a meal. (One kindergarten teacher explained, “We teach them early to use an ax so they understand it’s a tool, not a weapon.”)
To Americans, the notion of a school “taking away” your child to make her an ax wielder is monstrous. Yet though it’s hard to measure, it’s likely that Scandinavian children actually spend more quality time with their non-work-obsessed parents than does a typical middle-class American child being driven by a stressed-out mother from music lessons to karate. For all these reasons and more, the international organization Save the Children cites Norway as the best country on earth in which to raise kids, while the United States finishes far down the list, in 33rd place.
Don’t Take My Word for It
This little summary just scratches the surface of Scandinavia, so I urge curious readers to Google away. But be forewarned: You’ll find much criticism of all the Nordic-model countries. Worse, neoliberal pundits, especially the Brits, are always beating up on the Scandinavians, predicting the imminent demise of their social democracies. Self-styled experts still in thrall to Margaret Thatcher tell Norwegians they must liberalize their economy and privatize everything short of the royal palace. Mostly, the Norwegian government does the opposite—or nothing at all—and social democracy keeps on ticking.
It’s not perfect, of course. It has always been a carefully considered work in progress. Governance by consensus takes time and effort. You might think of it as slow democracy. Even so, it’s light-years ahead of us.
A place were I can write...
My simple blog of pictures of travel, friends, activities and the Universe we live in as we go slowly around the Sun.
January 29, 2016
Plays It Smart
Trump Plays It Smart, While the Rest of the GOP Field Rips Itself Apart
By avoiding a debate, Trump wins the night—and perhaps a lot more.
By John Nichols
Donald Trump does a lot of things that are unacceptable, unimaginable, and unexplainable. But his decision to skip the Fox News debate was entirely understandable.
Trump, the supposed outsider in the Republican race, was playing politics in a very predictable and potentially very smart way—as Thursday night’s events in Des Moines illustrated. What this tells us is something important: Trump often seems as if he’s on some bizarrely egocentric political joyride. Perhaps that was the case at the start of this race. But now, he’s making sly moves—and that’s something Republicans and Democrats (who ought not dismiss the billionaire casually) should note.
Trump skipped Thursday night’s Fox News debate in Des Moines, a move that at the start of the 2016 Republican race would, indeed, have been considered unacceptable, unimaginable, and unexplainable.
But anyone who watched the debate without Trump quickly understood why he decided that he was better off across town.
It wasn’t just that Trump’s counter-rally in Des Moines drew an overflow crowd and wall-to-wall coverage on the other cable news networks. It wasn’t just that Trump got to brag about raising millions of dollars for veterans. It wasn’t just that Trump invited excluded GOP contenders Mike Huckabee (the winner of the 2008 Iowa GOP caucuses) and Rick Santorum (the winner of the 2012 Iowa GOP caucuses) onstage at his event, thus linking himself to two old favorites of evangelical voters.
Trump was not just grabbing an opportunity to help himself. He was encouraging the other candidates to hurt one another.
The billionaire is a narrow front-runner in polls of likely Iowa caucus participants and a wide front-runner among New Hampshire primary voters. Trump faces genuine competition in both states from Texas Senator Ted Cruz and Florida Senator Marco Rubio. In New Hampshire he faces additional competition from Ohio Governor John Kasich and former Florida governor Jeb Bush. (Yes, Bush’s Granite State poll numbers have been on a notable upswing in recent days.)
Had he taken the stage with the rest of the candidates, Trump would have taken hits directly from them. He also would have had to stand by while they took shots at one another. They did just that: Cruz took shots at Rubio, Rubio took shots at Cruz, Bush took shots at Rubio, and Rand Paul took shots at everyone.
By skipping the debate, and letting the rest of the candidates argue among themselves, Trump avoided any potential damage—and he made it harder for the other contenders, especially Cruz, Rubio, and Kasich, to build on whatever momentum they might be accumulating as the key tests approach.
Why does this matter?
Consider the latest polling out of Iowa: The Real Clear Politics‘s averaging of recent polls has Trump at 33 percent and Cruz at 26 percent. Anything could happen on caucus night, and, yes, Cruz could still win it, with what is widely viewed as a superior organization. But the polls seem to suggest that Cruz is stalled, or potentially slipping. Several recent polls have Rubio, who got the Des Moines Register endorsement last weekend, catching up with Cruz. So Cruz was ready to rip Rubio, and Rubio was ready to rip Cruz.
That’s perfect for Trump. If Cruz and Rubio are fighting for second place in Iowa, rather than seeking to displace the front-runner, Trump’s under-organized Iowa campaign might just score a narrow caucus win.
If Cruz stumbles and Rubio surges in Iowa, all the better for Trump. Rubio is running poorly in New Hampshire (where his campaign lacks the energy, focus, and numbers of the Kasich and Bush efforts), which means he would have a hard time translating Iowa progress into New Hampshire progress.
Trump expects a win in New Hampshire, and the polls suggest he’ll get it. The only thing that could make that win better is rest-of-the-race chaos—with Bush, Kasich, Cruz, and Rubio all fighting for scraps.
Trump is no fool. He recognizes all of these dynamics. That’s why he skipped a debate on a network that, when all is said and done, will still be friendly to him if his strategies succeed.
No one should be happy with this circumstance. A healthy politics requires a lot of debates and a lot of participation, especially by high-profile contenders.
But, of course, Trump is not practicing a healthy politics.
He’s playing it rough, and ugly, from the start.
Now, he’s also playing it smart.
And if he plays it rough and ugly and smart in the primaries, it would be absurd (and dangerous) to presume—should Trump secure the Republican nod—that he will not play it rough and ugly and smart in the fall. •
By avoiding a debate, Trump wins the night—and perhaps a lot more.
By John Nichols
Donald Trump does a lot of things that are unacceptable, unimaginable, and unexplainable. But his decision to skip the Fox News debate was entirely understandable.
Trump, the supposed outsider in the Republican race, was playing politics in a very predictable and potentially very smart way—as Thursday night’s events in Des Moines illustrated. What this tells us is something important: Trump often seems as if he’s on some bizarrely egocentric political joyride. Perhaps that was the case at the start of this race. But now, he’s making sly moves—and that’s something Republicans and Democrats (who ought not dismiss the billionaire casually) should note.
Trump skipped Thursday night’s Fox News debate in Des Moines, a move that at the start of the 2016 Republican race would, indeed, have been considered unacceptable, unimaginable, and unexplainable.
But anyone who watched the debate without Trump quickly understood why he decided that he was better off across town.
It wasn’t just that Trump’s counter-rally in Des Moines drew an overflow crowd and wall-to-wall coverage on the other cable news networks. It wasn’t just that Trump got to brag about raising millions of dollars for veterans. It wasn’t just that Trump invited excluded GOP contenders Mike Huckabee (the winner of the 2008 Iowa GOP caucuses) and Rick Santorum (the winner of the 2012 Iowa GOP caucuses) onstage at his event, thus linking himself to two old favorites of evangelical voters.
Trump was not just grabbing an opportunity to help himself. He was encouraging the other candidates to hurt one another.
The billionaire is a narrow front-runner in polls of likely Iowa caucus participants and a wide front-runner among New Hampshire primary voters. Trump faces genuine competition in both states from Texas Senator Ted Cruz and Florida Senator Marco Rubio. In New Hampshire he faces additional competition from Ohio Governor John Kasich and former Florida governor Jeb Bush. (Yes, Bush’s Granite State poll numbers have been on a notable upswing in recent days.)
Had he taken the stage with the rest of the candidates, Trump would have taken hits directly from them. He also would have had to stand by while they took shots at one another. They did just that: Cruz took shots at Rubio, Rubio took shots at Cruz, Bush took shots at Rubio, and Rand Paul took shots at everyone.
By skipping the debate, and letting the rest of the candidates argue among themselves, Trump avoided any potential damage—and he made it harder for the other contenders, especially Cruz, Rubio, and Kasich, to build on whatever momentum they might be accumulating as the key tests approach.
Why does this matter?
Consider the latest polling out of Iowa: The Real Clear Politics‘s averaging of recent polls has Trump at 33 percent and Cruz at 26 percent. Anything could happen on caucus night, and, yes, Cruz could still win it, with what is widely viewed as a superior organization. But the polls seem to suggest that Cruz is stalled, or potentially slipping. Several recent polls have Rubio, who got the Des Moines Register endorsement last weekend, catching up with Cruz. So Cruz was ready to rip Rubio, and Rubio was ready to rip Cruz.
That’s perfect for Trump. If Cruz and Rubio are fighting for second place in Iowa, rather than seeking to displace the front-runner, Trump’s under-organized Iowa campaign might just score a narrow caucus win.
If Cruz stumbles and Rubio surges in Iowa, all the better for Trump. Rubio is running poorly in New Hampshire (where his campaign lacks the energy, focus, and numbers of the Kasich and Bush efforts), which means he would have a hard time translating Iowa progress into New Hampshire progress.
Trump expects a win in New Hampshire, and the polls suggest he’ll get it. The only thing that could make that win better is rest-of-the-race chaos—with Bush, Kasich, Cruz, and Rubio all fighting for scraps.
Trump is no fool. He recognizes all of these dynamics. That’s why he skipped a debate on a network that, when all is said and done, will still be friendly to him if his strategies succeed.
No one should be happy with this circumstance. A healthy politics requires a lot of debates and a lot of participation, especially by high-profile contenders.
But, of course, Trump is not practicing a healthy politics.
He’s playing it rough, and ugly, from the start.
Now, he’s also playing it smart.
And if he plays it rough and ugly and smart in the primaries, it would be absurd (and dangerous) to presume—should Trump secure the Republican nod—that he will not play it rough and ugly and smart in the fall. •
Crash and Burned...
Ted Cruz Can’t Take the Heat
Thrust into the limelight by Donald Trump's absence, Cruz gave his worst performance of the cycle at Thursday night's debate.
By Brian Beutler
Donald Trump’s last-minute decision to withdraw from the seventh Republican presidential primary debate Thursday night thrust his closest rival, Senator Ted Cruz, where he’s seemingly always wanted to be: at center stage.
Cruz is the most seasoned debater of all the Republican candidates, and Trump’s absence created a vacuum that Cruz could have filled with his typical brio. Instead, at a moment that presented Cruz as much opportunity and peril as any in his political career, he offered up his worst performance of the cycle.
Some of the blows Cruz suffered were self-inflicted, but there was more working against him than nerves and an unflattering limelight. Like so many elected Republicans and GOP operatives who have aligned with Trump to abate Cruz’s rise, the moderators and other candidates teamed up to damage him. To some small extent, this vindicated Trump’s decision to bow out in advance. But to a greater degree, the debate was a microcosm of the Republican establishment’s peculiar commitment to making Cruz, rather than Trump, their main target.
Cruz began the debate with characteristically unctuous panache. Asked what message Trump’s withdrawal sent to Iowa voters, Cruz delivered a pithy spoof of the absentee frontrunner. “[L]et me say I’m a maniac and everyone on this stage is stupid, fat, and ugly. And Ben, you’re a terrible surgeon. Now that we’ve gotten the Donald Trump portion out of the way, I want to thank everyone here for showing the men and women of Iowa the respect to show up and make the case to the people of this state and the people of the country why each of us believe we would make the best commander-in-chief.”
But for the rest of the debate’s first half, Cruz seemed lost. After moderators invoked Cruz in a series of questions (to Rand Paul, Marco Rubio, Chris Christie, and Jeb Bush) designed either to draw him into maximal conflict or sully his name, Cruz interjected angrily.
“I would note that that the last four questions have been, ‘Rand, please attack Ted. Marco, please attack Ted. Chris, please attack Ted. Jeb, please attack Ted.’”
Cruz was attempting to reprise his breakout moment from late October, when he excoriated CNBC moderators for provoking other candidates to attack each other. The difference is that this time he was whining on his own behalf, not on behalf of his fellow debaters, and it went over much, much worse.
“It is a debate, sir,” Fox’s Chris Wallace reminded him.
“A debate actually is a policy issue,” Cruz responded, betraying an impressive unfamiliarity with the timbre of the race he’s participating in. As if to contradict his own objection, Cruz sought to regain footing by defending his opposition to the Affordable Care Act with five provably false claims. “We have seen now in six years of Obamacare that it has been a disaster. It is the biggest job-killer in this country. Millions of Americans have lost their jobs, have been forced into part-time work, have lost their health insurance, have lost their doctors, have seen their premiums skyrocket.” (In fact, the economy has added jobs every month since Obamacare passed and at a remarkably steady pace. Millions of Americans have gained employment in that stretch, overwhelmingly full time employment. Millions more have gained health insurance, and premiums are lower now than they were projected to be if Obamacare had never passed).
Cruz entered the debate in the midst of a dangerous slide in the Iowa polls, battered both by Trump to his right and everyone else to his left. In an effort to repossess himself, Cruz has been simultaneously attacking and mimicking Trump all week. He called Trump fragile, then offered to participate in an unsanctioned one-on-one debate with him; he offered to give money to charity should Trump accept his challenge, just as Trump did five years ago when he challenged President Obama to produce his birth certificate. None of it has worked. And yet tonight, despite this strategy’s obvious shortcomings—as if to admit he’s running out of options—he tried one more time.
“I will say this,” Cruz sighed. “Gosh, if you guys ask one more mean question I may have to leave the stage.”
If Thursday’s debate was any indication, he will be doing so in much more consequential fashion very soon.
Thrust into the limelight by Donald Trump's absence, Cruz gave his worst performance of the cycle at Thursday night's debate.
By Brian Beutler
Donald Trump’s last-minute decision to withdraw from the seventh Republican presidential primary debate Thursday night thrust his closest rival, Senator Ted Cruz, where he’s seemingly always wanted to be: at center stage.
Cruz is the most seasoned debater of all the Republican candidates, and Trump’s absence created a vacuum that Cruz could have filled with his typical brio. Instead, at a moment that presented Cruz as much opportunity and peril as any in his political career, he offered up his worst performance of the cycle.
Some of the blows Cruz suffered were self-inflicted, but there was more working against him than nerves and an unflattering limelight. Like so many elected Republicans and GOP operatives who have aligned with Trump to abate Cruz’s rise, the moderators and other candidates teamed up to damage him. To some small extent, this vindicated Trump’s decision to bow out in advance. But to a greater degree, the debate was a microcosm of the Republican establishment’s peculiar commitment to making Cruz, rather than Trump, their main target.
Cruz began the debate with characteristically unctuous panache. Asked what message Trump’s withdrawal sent to Iowa voters, Cruz delivered a pithy spoof of the absentee frontrunner. “[L]et me say I’m a maniac and everyone on this stage is stupid, fat, and ugly. And Ben, you’re a terrible surgeon. Now that we’ve gotten the Donald Trump portion out of the way, I want to thank everyone here for showing the men and women of Iowa the respect to show up and make the case to the people of this state and the people of the country why each of us believe we would make the best commander-in-chief.”
But for the rest of the debate’s first half, Cruz seemed lost. After moderators invoked Cruz in a series of questions (to Rand Paul, Marco Rubio, Chris Christie, and Jeb Bush) designed either to draw him into maximal conflict or sully his name, Cruz interjected angrily.
“I would note that that the last four questions have been, ‘Rand, please attack Ted. Marco, please attack Ted. Chris, please attack Ted. Jeb, please attack Ted.’”
Cruz was attempting to reprise his breakout moment from late October, when he excoriated CNBC moderators for provoking other candidates to attack each other. The difference is that this time he was whining on his own behalf, not on behalf of his fellow debaters, and it went over much, much worse.
“It is a debate, sir,” Fox’s Chris Wallace reminded him.
“A debate actually is a policy issue,” Cruz responded, betraying an impressive unfamiliarity with the timbre of the race he’s participating in. As if to contradict his own objection, Cruz sought to regain footing by defending his opposition to the Affordable Care Act with five provably false claims. “We have seen now in six years of Obamacare that it has been a disaster. It is the biggest job-killer in this country. Millions of Americans have lost their jobs, have been forced into part-time work, have lost their health insurance, have lost their doctors, have seen their premiums skyrocket.” (In fact, the economy has added jobs every month since Obamacare passed and at a remarkably steady pace. Millions of Americans have gained employment in that stretch, overwhelmingly full time employment. Millions more have gained health insurance, and premiums are lower now than they were projected to be if Obamacare had never passed).
Cruz entered the debate in the midst of a dangerous slide in the Iowa polls, battered both by Trump to his right and everyone else to his left. In an effort to repossess himself, Cruz has been simultaneously attacking and mimicking Trump all week. He called Trump fragile, then offered to participate in an unsanctioned one-on-one debate with him; he offered to give money to charity should Trump accept his challenge, just as Trump did five years ago when he challenged President Obama to produce his birth certificate. None of it has worked. And yet tonight, despite this strategy’s obvious shortcomings—as if to admit he’s running out of options—he tried one more time.
“I will say this,” Cruz sighed. “Gosh, if you guys ask one more mean question I may have to leave the stage.”
If Thursday’s debate was any indication, he will be doing so in much more consequential fashion very soon.
Trump gloats
Trump gloats about skipping debate, knocks Cruz
By Daniel Strauss
A day after the latest Republican primary presidential debate, real estate mogul Donald Trump did two things: he gave himself a pat on the back for skipping the debate and also gloated at the pile-on on Sen. Ted Cruz.
"I think we're going to do really well in Iowa. We're leading in the Iowa polls. And Cruz is in the second place. He got really pummeled last night. I'm glad I wasn't there. And they didn't even mention that he was born in Canada," Trump said at a speech at the Radisson Hotel here in Nashua on Friday morning. "So he got beaten pretty badly last night. And I don't know what's going to happen to him."
At the debate Cruz was a popular focus of attacks from his Republican rivals, who repeatedly used their time to ding the Texas senator and presidential candidate who's been polling either in front or just behind Trump in Iowa.
"Our poll numbers probably went up," Trump said before predicting that Cruz's would probably go down as a result of the debate.
Later in his speech Trump mixed immigration with his attacks on on Cruz, noting that the Texas senator was born in Canada. Trump has repeatedly called into question Cruz's eligibility to be president.
"Ted Cruz is an anchor baby in Canada. But Canada doesn't accept anchor babies," Trump said, adding "he's a citizen of Canada and a senator of Texas." Cruz renounced his dual citizenship in 2014.
Cruz, Trump said, has tried to paint himself as an opponent of big banks but he's actually beholden to banks like Goldman Sachs and Citibank. Cruz took out loans from those banks during his successful run for Senate, failing to report two of them on campaign disclosure forms in 2012.
"He didn't want to put Goldman Sachs, he didn't want to put Citibank down because he wants you to think he's Robin Hood," Trump said.
Trump also knocked former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, who made sure to jab at Trump during the debate.
"How do you spend $125 million and you're at the bottom of the pack?" Trump said referring to the large amount the pro-Bush Right to Rise super PAC has spent.
He later pivoted to Democrats and in particular, former Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley, who has struggled to gain traction in the Democratic primary.
"Why is O'Malley running? What's that about? You know what his claim to fame was, he was the mayor of Baltimore," Trump said "What do you think his chances of getting the nomination are?"
Trump also argued that he is the reason Republican candidates are debating immigration policy. He noted that anti-immigration hardliner Maricopa County, Arizona, Sheriff Joe Arpaio recently endorsed him.
"Sheriff Joe endorsed me," Trump said.
Trump devoted a not-insignificant chunk of his speech to panning Joe McQuaid, the publisher of the New Hampshire Union-Leader, whose editorial page endorsed New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie.
"By the way Chris Christie's a friend of mine. He's got no chance. Zero. He's gone down since he got the endorsement," Trump said before predicting repeatedly that the Union-Leader would soon go bankrupt. Then he went back to hitting McQuaid.
"Here's a guy who's truly a dishonest guy," Trump continued. "Why wouldn't you give me the endorsement? I mean, who's better than me?"
By Daniel Strauss
A day after the latest Republican primary presidential debate, real estate mogul Donald Trump did two things: he gave himself a pat on the back for skipping the debate and also gloated at the pile-on on Sen. Ted Cruz.
"I think we're going to do really well in Iowa. We're leading in the Iowa polls. And Cruz is in the second place. He got really pummeled last night. I'm glad I wasn't there. And they didn't even mention that he was born in Canada," Trump said at a speech at the Radisson Hotel here in Nashua on Friday morning. "So he got beaten pretty badly last night. And I don't know what's going to happen to him."
At the debate Cruz was a popular focus of attacks from his Republican rivals, who repeatedly used their time to ding the Texas senator and presidential candidate who's been polling either in front or just behind Trump in Iowa.
"Our poll numbers probably went up," Trump said before predicting that Cruz's would probably go down as a result of the debate.
Later in his speech Trump mixed immigration with his attacks on on Cruz, noting that the Texas senator was born in Canada. Trump has repeatedly called into question Cruz's eligibility to be president.
"Ted Cruz is an anchor baby in Canada. But Canada doesn't accept anchor babies," Trump said, adding "he's a citizen of Canada and a senator of Texas." Cruz renounced his dual citizenship in 2014.
Cruz, Trump said, has tried to paint himself as an opponent of big banks but he's actually beholden to banks like Goldman Sachs and Citibank. Cruz took out loans from those banks during his successful run for Senate, failing to report two of them on campaign disclosure forms in 2012.
"He didn't want to put Goldman Sachs, he didn't want to put Citibank down because he wants you to think he's Robin Hood," Trump said.
Trump also knocked former Florida Gov. Jeb Bush, who made sure to jab at Trump during the debate.
"How do you spend $125 million and you're at the bottom of the pack?" Trump said referring to the large amount the pro-Bush Right to Rise super PAC has spent.
He later pivoted to Democrats and in particular, former Maryland Gov. Martin O'Malley, who has struggled to gain traction in the Democratic primary.
"Why is O'Malley running? What's that about? You know what his claim to fame was, he was the mayor of Baltimore," Trump said "What do you think his chances of getting the nomination are?"
Trump also argued that he is the reason Republican candidates are debating immigration policy. He noted that anti-immigration hardliner Maricopa County, Arizona, Sheriff Joe Arpaio recently endorsed him.
"Sheriff Joe endorsed me," Trump said.
Trump devoted a not-insignificant chunk of his speech to panning Joe McQuaid, the publisher of the New Hampshire Union-Leader, whose editorial page endorsed New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie.
"By the way Chris Christie's a friend of mine. He's got no chance. Zero. He's gone down since he got the endorsement," Trump said before predicting repeatedly that the Union-Leader would soon go bankrupt. Then he went back to hitting McQuaid.
"Here's a guy who's truly a dishonest guy," Trump continued. "Why wouldn't you give me the endorsement? I mean, who's better than me?"
Rallies Democrats
Obama rallies House Democrats with fiery partisan speech
By Lauren French
President Barack Obama took a victory lap Thursday evening.
During a short speech to House Democrats at their policy retreat here, Obama counted off his biggest policy achievements as president while predicting that Democrats would win the White House next November.
The partisan speech was designed to excite Democrats already squarely behind Obama. He bragged that he exceeded expectations set by Mitt Romney, the Republican presidential nominee in 2012, on driving down the unemployment rate to 5 percent and said he achieved a historic agreement with Iran.
"Our policies rescued the economy from the worst crisis in generations," Obama said. "We have now seen the longest streak of private sector job creation in our history. Sometimes I get a little frustrated that we don't run back the tape to what the Republicans said back then. Every single of the steps we took...they wanted to go in a different direction, claimed that our policies would crush jobs and destroy the economy. Do people remember that?"
Looking ahead to 2016, Obama said he would be succeeded by a Democrat but didn’t name the two top contenders, Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders, who are both fiercely looking secure wins in Iowa’s early primary.
Obama made waves last week when he gave an interview to POLITICO suggesting Clinton was the most qualified for the job. But on Thursday, Obama didn’t tilt his remarks toward either candidate.
“I’m not worried about this party staying united. The other side may have some stuff to work but our trajectory is clear. Everyone is scouring my every word to find some deeper meaning to see if I’m trying to put my fingers on the scales,” Obama said. “Let me simplify things: Tonight I have an announcement about the presidential race. Democrats will win in November. The reason I can say that with confidence is because we focus on the things that matter in the lives of the American people.”
Obama spent most of the address attacking Republicans for a narrow focus center on opposing his agenda. He slammed congressional Republicans for opposing the Iran nonproliferation deal, voting-rights reform and measure to combat climate change.
Democrats, he argued, will see political success in 2016 because the party is focused on issues favored by the vast majority of Americans.
“We believe that our politics should reflect what’s best in us. I’m not going to claim that Democrats are perfect. I’m not going to claim that we are right on every single issue,” Obama said. “We hold ourselves to a higher standard. That we can do better.”
Echoing his State of the Union address, parts of which were widely interpreted as a broadside against Donald Trump, Obama added, “We're not going to strengthen our leadership … by allowing politicians to insult Muslims or pit groups … against each other.”
In a private question-and-answer session, lawmakers asked Obama about his administration's stepped-up deportations of immigrants in the United States illegally. Congressional Democrats have been highly critical of the move, while the White House has argued that it is constricted by the law and a broken immigration system while trying to downplay the number of individuals who have been deported.
Vice President Joe Biden was similarly questioned when he spoke to the Democratic lawmakers Thursday afternoon.
By Lauren French
President Barack Obama took a victory lap Thursday evening.
During a short speech to House Democrats at their policy retreat here, Obama counted off his biggest policy achievements as president while predicting that Democrats would win the White House next November.
The partisan speech was designed to excite Democrats already squarely behind Obama. He bragged that he exceeded expectations set by Mitt Romney, the Republican presidential nominee in 2012, on driving down the unemployment rate to 5 percent and said he achieved a historic agreement with Iran.
"Our policies rescued the economy from the worst crisis in generations," Obama said. "We have now seen the longest streak of private sector job creation in our history. Sometimes I get a little frustrated that we don't run back the tape to what the Republicans said back then. Every single of the steps we took...they wanted to go in a different direction, claimed that our policies would crush jobs and destroy the economy. Do people remember that?"
Looking ahead to 2016, Obama said he would be succeeded by a Democrat but didn’t name the two top contenders, Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders, who are both fiercely looking secure wins in Iowa’s early primary.
Obama made waves last week when he gave an interview to POLITICO suggesting Clinton was the most qualified for the job. But on Thursday, Obama didn’t tilt his remarks toward either candidate.
“I’m not worried about this party staying united. The other side may have some stuff to work but our trajectory is clear. Everyone is scouring my every word to find some deeper meaning to see if I’m trying to put my fingers on the scales,” Obama said. “Let me simplify things: Tonight I have an announcement about the presidential race. Democrats will win in November. The reason I can say that with confidence is because we focus on the things that matter in the lives of the American people.”
Obama spent most of the address attacking Republicans for a narrow focus center on opposing his agenda. He slammed congressional Republicans for opposing the Iran nonproliferation deal, voting-rights reform and measure to combat climate change.
Democrats, he argued, will see political success in 2016 because the party is focused on issues favored by the vast majority of Americans.
“We believe that our politics should reflect what’s best in us. I’m not going to claim that Democrats are perfect. I’m not going to claim that we are right on every single issue,” Obama said. “We hold ourselves to a higher standard. That we can do better.”
Echoing his State of the Union address, parts of which were widely interpreted as a broadside against Donald Trump, Obama added, “We're not going to strengthen our leadership … by allowing politicians to insult Muslims or pit groups … against each other.”
In a private question-and-answer session, lawmakers asked Obama about his administration's stepped-up deportations of immigrants in the United States illegally. Congressional Democrats have been highly critical of the move, while the White House has argued that it is constricted by the law and a broken immigration system while trying to downplay the number of individuals who have been deported.
Vice President Joe Biden was similarly questioned when he spoke to the Democratic lawmakers Thursday afternoon.
GOP debates interest
Poll: Democrats showing outsize interest in GOP debates
By Nolan D. McCaskill
Donald Trump is must-see TV, and not just for Republicans.
A recently released Pew survey found that large numbers of Democrats have been tuning in to the GOP prime-time debates, while Republicans have not shown as much interest in the showdowns between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders. No word, yet, on whether that held true for Thursday night's debate, which Trump boycotted after feuding with Fox News.
Among those who have watched at least one debate, 70 percent of Democrats said they have watched a Republican debate, the survey released Thursday found. But less than half of all Republican debate watchers have tuned into a Democratic contest — most of which have come on weekends, including the Saturday before Christmas and the Sunday before Martin Luther King Jr. Day.
Republicans overall, though, were found to have increased interest in the debates compared to Democrats and Independents. Sixty-four percent of Republicans have watched a debate, while just 53 percent of Democrats and 56 percent of independents have done the same.
Among those who have watched at least one debate, however, an overwhelming 94 percent of Republicans have seen a GOP debate; 86 percent have seen a Democratic debate.
Nearly nine in 10 Democrats who have watched multiple debates watched contests on both sides; 59 percent of Republicans who have seen multiple debates watched both a Republican and Democratic debate. Among the same group, 41 percent have only watched the Republicans spar — a drastic contrast to the 8 percent of Democrats who have only seen Democratic debates.
By Nolan D. McCaskill
Donald Trump is must-see TV, and not just for Republicans.
A recently released Pew survey found that large numbers of Democrats have been tuning in to the GOP prime-time debates, while Republicans have not shown as much interest in the showdowns between Hillary Clinton and Bernie Sanders. No word, yet, on whether that held true for Thursday night's debate, which Trump boycotted after feuding with Fox News.
Among those who have watched at least one debate, 70 percent of Democrats said they have watched a Republican debate, the survey released Thursday found. But less than half of all Republican debate watchers have tuned into a Democratic contest — most of which have come on weekends, including the Saturday before Christmas and the Sunday before Martin Luther King Jr. Day.
Republicans overall, though, were found to have increased interest in the debates compared to Democrats and Independents. Sixty-four percent of Republicans have watched a debate, while just 53 percent of Democrats and 56 percent of independents have done the same.
Among those who have watched at least one debate, however, an overwhelming 94 percent of Republicans have seen a GOP debate; 86 percent have seen a Democratic debate.
Nearly nine in 10 Democrats who have watched multiple debates watched contests on both sides; 59 percent of Republicans who have seen multiple debates watched both a Republican and Democratic debate. Among the same group, 41 percent have only watched the Republicans spar — a drastic contrast to the 8 percent of Democrats who have only seen Democratic debates.
Predator and prey
Fox was both predator and prey
GOP candidates feel free to pick fights with a network famed for its conservatism.
By Hadas Gold
Fox News was both the host of Thursday night’s Republican presidential debate and one of its subjects, as Donald Trump repeatedly goaded the network at his own competing event while Ted Cruz took his lectern and his place as the one to take shots at Fox, a once-unthinkable move for a conservative Republican.
"If you guys ask one more mean question, I may have to leave the stage," Cruz said, after a spat with co-moderator Chris Wallace over how many of Fox’s questions were designed to provoke attacks on the Texas senator.
Wallace didn’t let it stand.
“It is a debate, sir,” he said.
Beltway Twitter crowed.
"Chris Wallace throwing shade at Ted Cruz is everything,” tweeted Meghan McCain.
"Chris Wallace is 1000% right. Debates are about sussing out policy disagreements. Which is what the moderators are doing,” The Washington Post’s Chris Cillizza added.
It’s common for Republican politicians to attack the media for asking loaded questions — but less common when aimed at Fox, whose ability to draw attention to red-meat conservative issues was long viewed by Republicans as a corrective to the biases or omissions of the mainstream media.
On Thursday, however, Fox was not only the target of disdain by Trump and Cruz, but also chose to defend itself on traditional journalistic grounds — asserting its independence by refusing to negotiate with Trump over its choice of Megyn Kelly as co-moderator, while also insisting it was a fair and neutral forum where all candidates would get an equal shake.
The network says there’s a stark difference between its news reporters — a category in which the moderators fall — and its opinionated hosts like Bill O’Reilly and Sean Hannity. But the network is still seen by many on the political right as the very voice of heartland conservatism.
But in this campaign, in which Cruz and Trump have largely defined their candidacies against the Washington-based Republican “establishment,” Fox has gotten lumped in with the D.C. crowd.
In the first GOP debate last August, Trump became agitated over a question from Kelly about his past statements about women, and he took to the airwaves and Twitter to condemn the anchor. That feud, which Trump fanned for five months, culminated in the candidate’s decision to skip Thursday’s debate, after Fox not only refused to replace Kelly as moderator but also mocked his unwillingness to face her questioning.
Thus, on Thursday, many viewers found themselves flipping channels between the official GOP debate in Des Moines, Iowa, and Trump’s event across town. While Kelly, Wallace and co-moderator Bret Baier were busy questioning the seven candidates on the main stage, Trump was declaring victory in his fight with the network by saying Fox News CEO Roger Ailes had apologized to him for the mocking statement. The network immediately demurred.
Ailes had had three short conversations with Trump, acknowledging his objections to a teasing statement that questioned how he would deal with Iran’s ayatollah and Russian President Vladimir Putin, the network said. But it refused to negotiate with the mogul.
"In the last 48 hours, we've kept two issues at the forefront — we would never compromise our journalistic standards and we would always stand by our journalist, Megyn Kelly," the statement said. "We have accomplished those two goals and we are pleased with the outcome. We're very proud to have her on stage as a debate moderator alongside Bret Baier & Chris Wallace."
Even before taking the stage, the moderators made it clear they were expecting some attacks on the media. All three knew they were likely to be in the cross hairs. In fact, in an interview last week, Baier noted that at the CNBC debate, Cruz had one of his best debate moments by going on a tear about the media and the moderators’ questions.
“Frankly, from a political standpoint, Cruz couldn’t have benefited more from that moment,” Baier said.
But after Cruz reprised his attack on Thursday night, this time against Fox, the debate calmed down and, by the second hour, the moderators were able to provoke some truly illuminating moments between the candidates.
Bush, Rubio and Cruz all got grillings on immigration.
Questions were posed in ways that called attention to the ways in which candidates had shifted their positions. Old videos of the candidates themselves were even played to make the point.
Kelly, showing she wasn’t intimidated by Trump, was praised for her tough questions and follow-ups.
“Megyn Kelly is throwing fastballs tonight,” wrote New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman.
"This is a brilliant part of the debate. Megyn Kelly’s accountability project,” wrote radio host Erick Erickson.
"Just gonna say it: Megyn Kelly's a badass,” Time Magazine’s Dan Hirschhorn wrote.
But while Kelly was being complimented by the media, Trump — competing for attention — was sounding off against the network. The Trump event was carried live by Fox’s two top competitors, CNN and MSNBC.
GOP candidates feel free to pick fights with a network famed for its conservatism.
By Hadas Gold
Fox News was both the host of Thursday night’s Republican presidential debate and one of its subjects, as Donald Trump repeatedly goaded the network at his own competing event while Ted Cruz took his lectern and his place as the one to take shots at Fox, a once-unthinkable move for a conservative Republican.
"If you guys ask one more mean question, I may have to leave the stage," Cruz said, after a spat with co-moderator Chris Wallace over how many of Fox’s questions were designed to provoke attacks on the Texas senator.
Wallace didn’t let it stand.
“It is a debate, sir,” he said.
Beltway Twitter crowed.
"Chris Wallace throwing shade at Ted Cruz is everything,” tweeted Meghan McCain.
"Chris Wallace is 1000% right. Debates are about sussing out policy disagreements. Which is what the moderators are doing,” The Washington Post’s Chris Cillizza added.
It’s common for Republican politicians to attack the media for asking loaded questions — but less common when aimed at Fox, whose ability to draw attention to red-meat conservative issues was long viewed by Republicans as a corrective to the biases or omissions of the mainstream media.
On Thursday, however, Fox was not only the target of disdain by Trump and Cruz, but also chose to defend itself on traditional journalistic grounds — asserting its independence by refusing to negotiate with Trump over its choice of Megyn Kelly as co-moderator, while also insisting it was a fair and neutral forum where all candidates would get an equal shake.
The network says there’s a stark difference between its news reporters — a category in which the moderators fall — and its opinionated hosts like Bill O’Reilly and Sean Hannity. But the network is still seen by many on the political right as the very voice of heartland conservatism.
But in this campaign, in which Cruz and Trump have largely defined their candidacies against the Washington-based Republican “establishment,” Fox has gotten lumped in with the D.C. crowd.
In the first GOP debate last August, Trump became agitated over a question from Kelly about his past statements about women, and he took to the airwaves and Twitter to condemn the anchor. That feud, which Trump fanned for five months, culminated in the candidate’s decision to skip Thursday’s debate, after Fox not only refused to replace Kelly as moderator but also mocked his unwillingness to face her questioning.
Thus, on Thursday, many viewers found themselves flipping channels between the official GOP debate in Des Moines, Iowa, and Trump’s event across town. While Kelly, Wallace and co-moderator Bret Baier were busy questioning the seven candidates on the main stage, Trump was declaring victory in his fight with the network by saying Fox News CEO Roger Ailes had apologized to him for the mocking statement. The network immediately demurred.
Ailes had had three short conversations with Trump, acknowledging his objections to a teasing statement that questioned how he would deal with Iran’s ayatollah and Russian President Vladimir Putin, the network said. But it refused to negotiate with the mogul.
"In the last 48 hours, we've kept two issues at the forefront — we would never compromise our journalistic standards and we would always stand by our journalist, Megyn Kelly," the statement said. "We have accomplished those two goals and we are pleased with the outcome. We're very proud to have her on stage as a debate moderator alongside Bret Baier & Chris Wallace."
Even before taking the stage, the moderators made it clear they were expecting some attacks on the media. All three knew they were likely to be in the cross hairs. In fact, in an interview last week, Baier noted that at the CNBC debate, Cruz had one of his best debate moments by going on a tear about the media and the moderators’ questions.
“Frankly, from a political standpoint, Cruz couldn’t have benefited more from that moment,” Baier said.
But after Cruz reprised his attack on Thursday night, this time against Fox, the debate calmed down and, by the second hour, the moderators were able to provoke some truly illuminating moments between the candidates.
Bush, Rubio and Cruz all got grillings on immigration.
Questions were posed in ways that called attention to the ways in which candidates had shifted their positions. Old videos of the candidates themselves were even played to make the point.
Kelly, showing she wasn’t intimidated by Trump, was praised for her tough questions and follow-ups.
“Megyn Kelly is throwing fastballs tonight,” wrote New York Times reporter Maggie Haberman.
"This is a brilliant part of the debate. Megyn Kelly’s accountability project,” wrote radio host Erick Erickson.
"Just gonna say it: Megyn Kelly's a badass,” Time Magazine’s Dan Hirschhorn wrote.
But while Kelly was being complimented by the media, Trump — competing for attention — was sounding off against the network. The Trump event was carried live by Fox’s two top competitors, CNN and MSNBC.
GDP
GDP up 0.7 percent in fourth quarter of 2015
By Marianne LeVine
Gross Domestic Product grew 0.7 percent in the last quarter of 2015, the Commerce Department reported Friday, continuing a slide in the economic growth rate since July.
The 0.7 percent growth figure was lower than the third quarter’s 2 percent GDP growth, which in turn was lower than the second quarter’s 3.9 percent GDP growth. During the first quarter of 2015 GDP declined by 0.2 percent.
The declining growth rate is a potential setback for Democrats in the presidential race, who will be running in part on President Barack Obama’s economic record. But they can still point to an unemployment rate that’s been cut in half since Obama entered office.
House Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady (R-Tx.) said "0.7 percent growth is not good enough and Washington should not pretend that it is"
Josh Bivens, research and policy director at the left-leaning Economic Policy Institute, appeared to agree, and said "continuing economic weakness" was likely causing slow productivity growth. He recommended that the Federal Reserve refrain from making further interest rate hikes.
The Commerce Department attributed fourth quarter deceleration to a decline in personal consumption expenditures that in turn reflected weak growth in wages and salaries. The Labor Department Friday reported that compensation costs for civilian workers rose 0.6 percent for fourth quarter and 2 percent from December 2014 to December 2015.
Deceleration in exports and imports and acceleration in federal government spending also contributed to the slowdown in growth.
For the year, GDP increased 2.4 percent in 2015, the Commerce Department said, in an estimate it will recalculate twice in coming months. That’s roughly consistent with 2014’s 2.4 percent and 2013’s 2.3 percent.
A Bloomberg survey of economists predicted real GDP growth at 0.8 percent for the fourth quarter of 2015. This is the first of three GDP estimates Commerce will make for the fourth quarter.
By Marianne LeVine
Gross Domestic Product grew 0.7 percent in the last quarter of 2015, the Commerce Department reported Friday, continuing a slide in the economic growth rate since July.
The 0.7 percent growth figure was lower than the third quarter’s 2 percent GDP growth, which in turn was lower than the second quarter’s 3.9 percent GDP growth. During the first quarter of 2015 GDP declined by 0.2 percent.
The declining growth rate is a potential setback for Democrats in the presidential race, who will be running in part on President Barack Obama’s economic record. But they can still point to an unemployment rate that’s been cut in half since Obama entered office.
House Ways and Means Chairman Kevin Brady (R-Tx.) said "0.7 percent growth is not good enough and Washington should not pretend that it is"
Josh Bivens, research and policy director at the left-leaning Economic Policy Institute, appeared to agree, and said "continuing economic weakness" was likely causing slow productivity growth. He recommended that the Federal Reserve refrain from making further interest rate hikes.
The Commerce Department attributed fourth quarter deceleration to a decline in personal consumption expenditures that in turn reflected weak growth in wages and salaries. The Labor Department Friday reported that compensation costs for civilian workers rose 0.6 percent for fourth quarter and 2 percent from December 2014 to December 2015.
Deceleration in exports and imports and acceleration in federal government spending also contributed to the slowdown in growth.
For the year, GDP increased 2.4 percent in 2015, the Commerce Department said, in an estimate it will recalculate twice in coming months. That’s roughly consistent with 2014’s 2.4 percent and 2013’s 2.3 percent.
A Bloomberg survey of economists predicted real GDP growth at 0.8 percent for the fourth quarter of 2015. This is the first of three GDP estimates Commerce will make for the fourth quarter.
Debate ratings
Early debate ratings give ammo to Trump, but Fox News still sees strong result
By Hadas Gold
Fox Entertainmnet News' Trump-less debate Thursday night drew an 8.4 household rating, according to preliminary Nielsen ratings first posted by CNN.
That means 8.4 percent of rated households with TVs were tuned in — a large number for a typical night, but not among the highest when it comes to debate nights.
The debate scored a higher household rating than the previous debate, on Fox Business Network. It had a household rating of 7.4, which translated into 11 million viewers. Thursday night's debate will have a higher audience than the FBN debate, but its ratings won't be anywhere near the astronomical ratings the first Fox News debate brought in, a stunning 24 million viewers. FBN's first debate had an overnight rating of 8.9 and averaged 13.5 million viewers. Thursday night's debate will probably slot in between the two FBN debates when the finals come in.
To be sure, even an audience in the 12- to 15-million range would be a big night for any network, and is incredible, historically, for a primary debate night. This entire cycle has seen debate ratings smash primary debate viewership records from prior cycles.
As for the other event of the night, Trump's rally, which was carried in part by CNN and MSNBC (neither outlet carried the entire event uninterrupted), the outlets' combined ratings were about a quarter of those for the debate, according to CNN. The rally also ran online, on smaller unrated cable channels like One America News, and on C-SPAN, which is not rated by Nielsen.
Full ratings will be available later today.
By Hadas Gold
Fox Entertainmnet News' Trump-less debate Thursday night drew an 8.4 household rating, according to preliminary Nielsen ratings first posted by CNN.
That means 8.4 percent of rated households with TVs were tuned in — a large number for a typical night, but not among the highest when it comes to debate nights.
The debate scored a higher household rating than the previous debate, on Fox Business Network. It had a household rating of 7.4, which translated into 11 million viewers. Thursday night's debate will have a higher audience than the FBN debate, but its ratings won't be anywhere near the astronomical ratings the first Fox News debate brought in, a stunning 24 million viewers. FBN's first debate had an overnight rating of 8.9 and averaged 13.5 million viewers. Thursday night's debate will probably slot in between the two FBN debates when the finals come in.
To be sure, even an audience in the 12- to 15-million range would be a big night for any network, and is incredible, historically, for a primary debate night. This entire cycle has seen debate ratings smash primary debate viewership records from prior cycles.
As for the other event of the night, Trump's rally, which was carried in part by CNN and MSNBC (neither outlet carried the entire event uninterrupted), the outlets' combined ratings were about a quarter of those for the debate, according to CNN. The rally also ran online, on smaller unrated cable channels like One America News, and on C-SPAN, which is not rated by Nielsen.
Full ratings will be available later today.
I'm Great! I'm the winner!
Donald Trump declares victory over Fox and GOP debate
‘We have more cameras than they do,’ Trump says.
By Ben Schreckinger and Anna Palmer
Donald Trump took the stage at his veterans fundraiser on Thursday night and declared victory in his war with Fox News.
Strolling out to Adele’s “Rolling in the Deep” – a mainstay of his campaign trail soundtrack — the businessman announced that Fox News had changed its tone and been “very nice to me” in recent hours and that his event was drawing more interest than the cable network's debate.
“We’re actually told we have more cameras than they do by quite a bit,” he said, comparing the media presence at his event to the Academy Awards.
Trump’s gambit split the political press corps between his own much-hyped event and the debate they would otherwise be covering across town, where seven of his rivals shared the spotlight instead. It also guaranteed that Trump’s name would once again dominate the headlines on the eve of the Iowa caucuses.
In fact, two of Trump's cellar-dwelling rivals traveled to his turf to bask in the media attention — and, they said, join him in honoring America's veterans. After brief introductory remarks, Trump summoned the pair, Mike Huckabee and Rick Santorum, to the stage.
"I’ll stand a little bit over here so that I'm not photographed with the Trump sign," said Santorum, stepping to the side of the Trump-branded podium. Speaking next, Huckabee did not bother trying to avoid the visual. “I figure you’re going to get the photo anyway," he said, speaking from the podium. The former Arkansas governor acknowledged that unlike his higher-polling rivals who made Fox's main stage debate, his schedule was wide open. “I have nothing to do at 8 o’clock tonight. This worked great for me.”
After the event, Huckabee told reporters that he would make an unspecified personal donation to veterans causes — "lt may not be a million bucks" — and defended his own lagging performance in polls. "How many people have voted yet?" he said. "Nobody."
Trump chose a humble venue for his bold spectacle, a cozy 775-seat auditorium on the campus of Drake University. The legions of press who could not squeeze into the auditorium watched the proceedings on a television in an overflow room, which itself overflowed, with reporters lining the walls and sitting on the floor.
The event was hastily thrown together after Trump announced he was boycotting the Fox News presidential debate in response to a taunting statement issued by the network that questioned Trump’s toughness. The network’s statement followed Trump’s griping about Fox co-moderator Megyn Kelly, whom the businessman wanted removed from the debate over her alleged anti-Trump bias.
The national anthem was backed by a lively instrumental accompaniment. Trump’s Iowa co-chair Tana Goertz, a former contestant on “the Apprentice”, and two North Carolina video bloggers -- Lynette “Diamond” Hardaway and Rochelle “Silk” Richardson, who have become prominent surrogates -- offered introductory remarks.
Before the event, Trump summoned a group of print reporters to his private jet, where he told them he had made a $1 million personal donation to veterans groups and that financier Carl Icahn had kicked in another $500,000. Following the event, Trump tweeted that a total of $6 million had been raised.
Trump also told CNN before the event that he had received an apology from “top people” at Fox but would not specify whom. He added that he might have attended the debate after all if his plan to hold the rival event had not “taken on a life of its own."
But Fox shot back, accusing Trump of wanting a "quid pro quo" in order to attend the debate — in the form of a $5 million donation to charity. A source close to the situation said there was an acquiescence to Trump, and Fox's statement notes they "acknowledged his concerns."
The crowd ranged from college kids to seniors and their politics were just as varied. Several attendees said that they were still undecided about who to support for the caucus.
"Right now, I'm in between a few people, but I'm really looking forward to a Trump rally because it might sway my decision," said Jared Turner, a student at Drake who was seeing Trump for the first time. "There's a thing that I really respect about him. He's about bringing back the old values."
Others like Michael Duff, of Boone, Iowa, were already sold on Trump.
"I think he's sticking by his principles. I think he is doing what needs to get done," said Duff of Trump's decision to skip the Republican debate and hold his own event. "I didn't know if I really supported Trump the first time I went and listened to him because I heard all the media garbage of all the cut and pasting of what he really said."
Duff, who has seen Trump three times already, said the real estate mogul is the right candidate to help change the country's trajectory.
"There's a lot more excitement behind Trump and not just because he was on TV or because he had a reality TV show," Duff said. "It's because of the person that he stands for and he wants to make America great again. That's his underlying message and how can you argue that."
Before the event, the line of attendees wrapped around the block as attendees waited to be cleared by Secret Service.
Jordan Mix, a senior at Drake, was one of just a handful of protesters braving the cold.
"I believe that Donald Trump's rhetoric is poisonous and it validates the xenophobic attitudes of a lot of Americans," said Mix, who was holding a "Dump Trump" sign. "It's important to me that anyone looking at Drake right now does not represent the views of Drake University."
Mix said she was caucusing for the Democrats and she is likely to support Bernie Sanders.
"I just think it was really hard for us to be bystanders and not do something when you see something so poisonous and hateful in your home. It's easy to make Donald Trump a joke when he's away from you, but when he comes in your space it's a little scary," Mix said.
Trump, taking an emcee role, then returned to the stage to introduce John Wayne Walding, a green beret born on the 4th of July. Explaining that he would wander the stage as he spoke, Walding said, “In the military, a moving target’s a lot harder to hit.” It’s a lesson Trump — who avoided Vietnam era military service with a medical deferment — seems to have internalized. Thursday’s fundraiser was only the latest surprise move in a campaign that has kept Trump in motion while the rest of the field is forced to react. Walding brought on two more veterans, and the trio presented Trump with an award.
The mogul then brought "Diamond" and "Silk" back onstage for an encore. He took to the podium once more to wind down the event and announce that he had asked his pregnant daughter, Ivanka, to give birth in Iowa. “It would be so great,” he said. “I would definitely win! I want that to happen so badly!"
‘We have more cameras than they do,’ Trump says.
By Ben Schreckinger and Anna Palmer
Donald Trump took the stage at his veterans fundraiser on Thursday night and declared victory in his war with Fox News.
Strolling out to Adele’s “Rolling in the Deep” – a mainstay of his campaign trail soundtrack — the businessman announced that Fox News had changed its tone and been “very nice to me” in recent hours and that his event was drawing more interest than the cable network's debate.
“We’re actually told we have more cameras than they do by quite a bit,” he said, comparing the media presence at his event to the Academy Awards.
Trump’s gambit split the political press corps between his own much-hyped event and the debate they would otherwise be covering across town, where seven of his rivals shared the spotlight instead. It also guaranteed that Trump’s name would once again dominate the headlines on the eve of the Iowa caucuses.
In fact, two of Trump's cellar-dwelling rivals traveled to his turf to bask in the media attention — and, they said, join him in honoring America's veterans. After brief introductory remarks, Trump summoned the pair, Mike Huckabee and Rick Santorum, to the stage.
"I’ll stand a little bit over here so that I'm not photographed with the Trump sign," said Santorum, stepping to the side of the Trump-branded podium. Speaking next, Huckabee did not bother trying to avoid the visual. “I figure you’re going to get the photo anyway," he said, speaking from the podium. The former Arkansas governor acknowledged that unlike his higher-polling rivals who made Fox's main stage debate, his schedule was wide open. “I have nothing to do at 8 o’clock tonight. This worked great for me.”
After the event, Huckabee told reporters that he would make an unspecified personal donation to veterans causes — "lt may not be a million bucks" — and defended his own lagging performance in polls. "How many people have voted yet?" he said. "Nobody."
Trump chose a humble venue for his bold spectacle, a cozy 775-seat auditorium on the campus of Drake University. The legions of press who could not squeeze into the auditorium watched the proceedings on a television in an overflow room, which itself overflowed, with reporters lining the walls and sitting on the floor.
The event was hastily thrown together after Trump announced he was boycotting the Fox News presidential debate in response to a taunting statement issued by the network that questioned Trump’s toughness. The network’s statement followed Trump’s griping about Fox co-moderator Megyn Kelly, whom the businessman wanted removed from the debate over her alleged anti-Trump bias.
The national anthem was backed by a lively instrumental accompaniment. Trump’s Iowa co-chair Tana Goertz, a former contestant on “the Apprentice”, and two North Carolina video bloggers -- Lynette “Diamond” Hardaway and Rochelle “Silk” Richardson, who have become prominent surrogates -- offered introductory remarks.
Before the event, Trump summoned a group of print reporters to his private jet, where he told them he had made a $1 million personal donation to veterans groups and that financier Carl Icahn had kicked in another $500,000. Following the event, Trump tweeted that a total of $6 million had been raised.
Trump also told CNN before the event that he had received an apology from “top people” at Fox but would not specify whom. He added that he might have attended the debate after all if his plan to hold the rival event had not “taken on a life of its own."
But Fox shot back, accusing Trump of wanting a "quid pro quo" in order to attend the debate — in the form of a $5 million donation to charity. A source close to the situation said there was an acquiescence to Trump, and Fox's statement notes they "acknowledged his concerns."
The crowd ranged from college kids to seniors and their politics were just as varied. Several attendees said that they were still undecided about who to support for the caucus.
"Right now, I'm in between a few people, but I'm really looking forward to a Trump rally because it might sway my decision," said Jared Turner, a student at Drake who was seeing Trump for the first time. "There's a thing that I really respect about him. He's about bringing back the old values."
Others like Michael Duff, of Boone, Iowa, were already sold on Trump.
"I think he's sticking by his principles. I think he is doing what needs to get done," said Duff of Trump's decision to skip the Republican debate and hold his own event. "I didn't know if I really supported Trump the first time I went and listened to him because I heard all the media garbage of all the cut and pasting of what he really said."
Duff, who has seen Trump three times already, said the real estate mogul is the right candidate to help change the country's trajectory.
"There's a lot more excitement behind Trump and not just because he was on TV or because he had a reality TV show," Duff said. "It's because of the person that he stands for and he wants to make America great again. That's his underlying message and how can you argue that."
Before the event, the line of attendees wrapped around the block as attendees waited to be cleared by Secret Service.
Jordan Mix, a senior at Drake, was one of just a handful of protesters braving the cold.
"I believe that Donald Trump's rhetoric is poisonous and it validates the xenophobic attitudes of a lot of Americans," said Mix, who was holding a "Dump Trump" sign. "It's important to me that anyone looking at Drake right now does not represent the views of Drake University."
Mix said she was caucusing for the Democrats and she is likely to support Bernie Sanders.
"I just think it was really hard for us to be bystanders and not do something when you see something so poisonous and hateful in your home. It's easy to make Donald Trump a joke when he's away from you, but when he comes in your space it's a little scary," Mix said.
Trump, taking an emcee role, then returned to the stage to introduce John Wayne Walding, a green beret born on the 4th of July. Explaining that he would wander the stage as he spoke, Walding said, “In the military, a moving target’s a lot harder to hit.” It’s a lesson Trump — who avoided Vietnam era military service with a medical deferment — seems to have internalized. Thursday’s fundraiser was only the latest surprise move in a campaign that has kept Trump in motion while the rest of the field is forced to react. Walding brought on two more veterans, and the trio presented Trump with an award.
The mogul then brought "Diamond" and "Silk" back onstage for an encore. He took to the podium once more to wind down the event and announce that he had asked his pregnant daughter, Ivanka, to give birth in Iowa. “It would be so great,” he said. “I would definitely win! I want that to happen so badly!"
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)